Scribd
Upload
47 views

Point Transformation Solution

Solution to classical mechanics problem inquiring about Lagrangian's invariance under point transformation.

Uploaded by

lantea1
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
47 views

Point Transformation Solution

Solution to classical mechanics problem inquiring about Lagrangian's invariance under point transformation.

Uploaded by

lantea1
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 4

Generalized Coordinates and Invariant Form for

Equations of Motion
Enrique Segura
September 27, 2019

Goldstein 1.15 | Symon 9.24. Show by direct calculation that for some L(q 1 , . . . , q f , q˙1 , . . . , q˙f ; t)
which satisfies Lagrange’s equation:

d ∂Lq ∂Lq
− k =0
dt ∂ q˙k ∂q

If we introduce new coordinates (s1 , . . . , sf ), where:

q k = fk (s1 , . . . , sf ; t), k = 1, . . . , f

then,
d ∂Ls ∂Ls
− j =0
dt ∂ s˙j ∂s
is obtained with:

L(q 1 , . . . , q f , q˙1 , . . . , q˙f ; t) = L(s1 , . . . , sf , s˙1 , . . . , s˙f ; t)

by substitution for fk (s1 , . . . , sf ; t) for q k where j = 1, . . . , f .


Solution. Let’s take the simplest case we can to be able to build this result; namely only use s, q
to build this system:
s = s(q, t), q = q(s, t) (1)
Our goal is show that in order for the L(s, ṡ, t) = L(q, q̇, t) then we must convert:

d ∂Lq ∂Lq d ∂Ls ∂Ls


− ←→ − (2)
dt ∂ q̇ ∂q dt ∂ ṡ ∂s
So let’s start with inspecting our Lq :

Lq = L(q, q̇, t) = L(q(s, t), q̇(s, t), t) (3)

1
According to the Euler-Lagrangian equation, this equation:

d ∂Lq ∂Lq
− (4)
dt ∂ q̇ ∂q

will change due to q = q(s, t).

By chain rule, we can find by inspection:

∂Lq ∂Lq ∂s
= (5)
∂q ∂s ∂q
∂Lq ∂Lq ∂ ṡ
= (6)
∂ q̇ ∂ ṡ ∂ q̇
From this inspection, we have to show:

∂ ṡ ∂s
= (7)
∂ q̇ ∂q
For that, let’s start with s and calculate its full derivative:
∂s ∂s
ds = dq + dt (8)
∂q ∂t
Dividing by dt yields
ds ∂s dq ∂s
= + (9)
dt ∂q dt ∂t
which can expressed as
∂x ∂x
ṡ = q̇ + (10)
∂q ∂t
By inspecting we can yield the following observation:

ṡ = ṡ(q̇, t) (11)

Having this form, we can then find the following:

∂ ṡ ∂x ∂ ∂x
= q̇ + (12)
∂ q̇ ∂q ∂ q̇ ∂t
Since the second partial is a function of t, this term vanishes leading to:

∂ ṡ ∂s
= (13)
∂ q̇ ∂q

2
Having arrived at this result, we go back and work with the lagrangian of interest:
d ∂Lq ∂Lq
− =0 (14)
dt ∂ q̇ ∂q
d ∂Lq ∂ ṡ ∂Lq ∂s
( )− =0 (15)
dt ∂ ṡ ∂ q̇ ∂s ∂q
∂Lq ∂ ṡ ∂Lq ∂s
( )= dt (16)
∂ ṡ ∂ q̇ ∂s ∂q
And by the substitution:
∂Lq ∂ ṡ ∂Lq ∂ ṡ
( )= dt (17)
∂ ṡ ∂ q̇ ∂s ∂ q̇

Just for reference:

Lq = L(q, q̇, t) = L(q(s, t), q̇(s, t), t)


Ls = L(s, ṡ, t) = L(s(q, t), ṡ(q, t), t)

Using our substitution we find:


∂Lq ∂Lq
= dt (18)
∂ ṡ ∂s
which brings:
d ∂Lq ∂Lq
( )− =0 (19)
dt ∂ ṡ ∂s
This means that Lq is a function s, which means Lq = L(s, ṡ, t), which means Lq is actually
Ls . Thus,
d ∂Ls ∂Ls
( )− =0 (20)
dt ∂ ṡ ∂s
Thus, we find that for the simplest case:
L(q, q̇, t) = L(s, ṡ, t) (21)
■
Solution. Now having shown this result for this case, we expand it for two coordinates systems
represented by:
q k = (q 1 , . . . , q f ; q˙1 , . . . , q̇ f ; t) (22)
sl = (s1 , . . . , sf ; s˙1 , . . . , ṡf ; t) (23)
(24)
If there is f k that maps q k ←→ sl such that:
q k = q k (s1 , . . . , sf ; t) (25)
sl = sl (q 1 , . . . , q f ; t) (26)

3
Then by finding:
∂ q˙k ∂q k
= (27)
∂ ṡl ∂sl
this can be use to yield:

d ∂Lq ∂Lq
( )− k =0 (28)
dt ∂ q˙k ∂q
d ∂Lq ∂ q˙k ∂Lq ∂q k
( )− k l =0 (29)
dt ∂ q˙k ∂ ṡl ∂q ∂s
d ∂Ls ∂Ls
( )− =0 (30)
dt ∂ ṡ l ∂sl
And thus showing that indeed:

L(q 1 , . . . , q f , q˙1 , . . . , q˙f ; t) = L(s1 , . . . , sf , s˙1 , . . . , s˙f ; t) (31)

Or, as Goldstein puts it : “...the form of Lagrange’s equations is invariant under a point
transformation.”
■

You might also like

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy