Notes of Elements
Notes of Elements
Anastasia Sakka
PhD candidate in Architecture at the University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, U.K.
Abstract
The Greek architect and urban planner Constantinos Doxiadis belonged to the group of
professionals and thinkers who challenged the quality of urban environment and living, as
it had been evolved up to the mid of the 20th century. Doxiadis identified the need for
revisiting policies in modern urban planning and he mobilized any available means –
theory, practice, education and communication- towards this end. Providing his services
as a government’s consultant in several countries of the under-development world during
the fifties and sixties, having established solid liaisons with distinguished Institutions in
the U.S.A., having a remarkable portfolio of materialized projects with global impact and
respectively a remarkable volume of written work, research and publications, having even
created an Institute for postgraduate studies on the field, he went further beyond. He
declared the necessity for a radical change in urban planning, by means of introducing a
new scientific domain in the service of human settlements, that of Ekistics.
The proposed paper aims to explore the idea of Ekistics, through its implementation at the
Master Plan of Islamabad, or otherwise the City of the Future. Doxiadis was assigned to
design the new Federal Capital of Pakistan and he seized the opportunity to launch Ekistics
with this project of global magnitude –both Islamabad and Ekistics could be benefited from
such a gesture. Ekistics transcended the strict boundaries of urban planning, as social,
political and economic factors were also involved. It constituted a holistic approach, which
aimed towards the balance of the five primal elements of human settlements, namely
Nature, Man, Society, Shells and Networks. And it is not the agenda pursued by means of
the modernist functional city that is abandoned, it is rather that changes in the processes
followed can be observed.
Challenging CIAM
A question that practically signified the advent of the Post-CIAM era. The ideals,
regarding the Functional City that for a first time have been concretely expressed
in Le Sarraz of Switzerland and through the works of CIAM 1, which found their
most mature expression on the deck of Steam Ship Patris II and while sailing from
Marseille to Athens, were now under questioning. This is to say that the Athens
Charter –the epitome of modern urban planning-, or otherwise the outcomes of
CIAM 41, were to be severely challenged by the CIAM 10 delegates, who have
been already oriented in defining the Charter of Habitat2. Le Corbusier was fully
aware3 that a first circle of CIAM’s contribution has been completed. Respectively,
he was aware that the ends towards which CIAM has been aiming were still to be
reached. Therefore, he could not do other than salute “Long live the SECOND-
CIAM!” (Mumford, 2002, p.248)
Maybe the answer to the Corbusian question should be crisis due to evolution, as
the inner criticism that terminated the idea of CIAM meetings signified the
comprehension that intellectual circles had to take steps, in order to better
respond to the emerging needs of a rapidly evolving society. If it is to be taken
under consideration, either the phenomenological approach of Team X (Frampton,
1981), or its respective sensitivity concerning historical and vernacular settings
(Goldhagen and Legault, 2000), both viewed in their wider context, it would seem
more likely to realise that the actual distance between them and the functional
city is not so immense. Anyhow, the functional city was not meant to be an end
per se; it was rather the means towards a new socio-economic order and
ultimately towards a new mode of living. Considering the initial threefold, namely
dwelling, producing and relaxation, as well as its subsequent, which further
included the function of circulation, an emerging portrait of life can be perceived.
The idea of challenging and revisiting the dogmatic rationality of the functional
city, which has been more than adequately serviced through the CIAM activities,
1
The Athens Charter might have been published ten years after the works of CIAM 4 took place, however it
constitutes the absolute basis of the meeting’s conclusions.
2
“’Habitat’ is a word used by the French to describe not only the home but also its environment and everything
appertaining to it.” (Goldhagen and Legault, 2000, p.56)
3
Le Corbusier prior the last meeting of CIAM takes place insisted in transferring leadership to the younger members
of the Congress. (Bullock, 2002, p.145)
272
REVISITING POST-CIAM GENERATION: debates, proposals and intellectual framework
Proceedings. Porto, April 11-13, 2019
Constantinos Doxiadis
The Greek architect and urban planner Constantinos Doxiadis belonged to the
group of professionals and thinkers who severely challenged the quality of the
urban environment, as it had been already evolved up to the mid of the 20th
century. Characteristically, he talked about “urban nightmares” (Doxiadis, 1963,
p.19), or otherwise “dystopias” (Doxiadis, 1968, p.4). Even though, he credited
the revolutionary spirit of the Modern Movement’s leading figures, such as Gropius
or Le Corbusier, for breaking the bonds with academism, yet he considered the
goal as a non-fully achieved. To some important extent, he identified as critical
factor for the experienced failures the reluctance of his colleagues to transcend
the conventional boundaries set by the role of a designer and instead to become
master builders (Doxiadis, 1963). Doxiadis did not hesitate4 to make this leap, as
per his own words; “Personally I often feel like an itinerant master builder of the
4
Doxiadis not only did not hesitate becoming a builder, but instead he considered it a duty and privilege, according
to his own words; “So as to be privileged of building even one step, instead of waiting for others to become builders
and keep for myself the role of a well-dressed man climbing up the stair, which was built by others.” (Filippidis,
2015, p.18-19)
273
Anastasia Sakka, Ekistics, or the science of human settlements, through the paradigm of the master plan of
Islamabad
past, travelling around the world and offering my services.” (Doxiadis, 1963,
p.21). Pakistan, one of the newly emerging countries of the 20th century
decolonization period, has been a benchmark concerning Doxiadis’ global activity5.
5
As per the memoirs of an architect who was member of the Capital Development Authority and worked closely
with Doxiadis, “Dr. Doxiadis, on the other hand, went from strength to strength and never looked back from the
time in 1954, when I first met him in New Delhi at the UN Conference on Low-Cost Housing as a Town-Planner
whose reputation had not yet travelled beyond the shores of Greece. Within a space of ten to fifteen years however,
he gathered around him a vast empire and had works extending from Vietnam to Iraq, Ghana, Saudi Arabia and
various other countries of South America as well as works even in the USA including the role of adviser on the
Washington master plan.” (Khwaja, 1998, p.111-112)
274
REVISITING POST-CIAM GENERATION: debates, proposals and intellectual framework
Proceedings. Porto, April 11-13, 2019
the country’s political leadership. All efforts and gazes were turned on the
Islamabad project, which if taken under consideration along with the fact that it
was implemented on a “tabula rasa” basis, or otherwise on a basis of minimizing
undesired commitments, it seems reasonable to conclude that Doxiadis has been
offered the perfect ground, in order to deploy and communicate his philosophy,
regarding modern urban planning.
Introducing Ekistics
Doxiadis identified in the weaknesses of modern urban planning the source for a
series of acute social problems and respectively he appraised as defining factors,
in regards to any potential solutions the emergence of three basic phenomena,
namely the unprecedented global population increase, the advent of machine’s
dominance, as well as the gradual shift of interest in masses (C.A.D.A., Pakistan
v.16, DOX-PA 29, 1959). In other words, after interrelating the existing social
malaises with poor urban planning, a reversed process seems to prevail, which
suggests the pursuit of social reformation on the basis of sound planning practices,
following a deep understanding both of current needs and future demands.
Otherwise and according to the terminology introduced by Doxiadis, Ekistics –the
science of human settlements- could drive humankind to a deserved prosperous
future.
Ekistics (from oikos, the Greek word for a house or dwelling) is the science
of human settlements. It coordinates economics, social sciences, political
and administrative sciences, technology and aesthetics into a coherent
whole and leads to the creation of a new type of human habitat. (Doxiadis,
1963, p.96)
In more detail, Ekistics constituted a holistic approach, which aimed towards the
balance of the five primal elements6 of human settlements, namely Nature, Man,
6 The five ekistic elements can be defined as follows “Nature: the total natural environment which provides the
basis for the creation of settlements and the context in which they function. Anthropos: the inhabitant, as an
individual. Society: the systems of interactions between Anthropoi. Shells: the structures which shelter Anthropos,
his functions and activities. Networks: the natural and man-made connective systems which serve and integrate
settlements, such as roads, water supply and sewerage systems, electrical generating and distribution facilities,
275
Anastasia Sakka, Ekistics, or the science of human settlements, through the paradigm of the master plan of
Islamabad
Society, Shells and Networks. Practically, these five elements constitute the
fragments of two broader divisions of human settlements – the content’s and the
container’s (Doxiadis and Papaioannou, 1974). This is to say that human beings,
either perceived as individuals or as social entities, shape the habitat’s content,
while all of the rest elements –both natural and man-made-, define the container.
Nevertheless, “The essential nature of settlements results from the fusion and
interactive balance between their container –or physical structure- and their
contents –or Anthropos.” (Doxiadis and Papaioannou, 1974, p.7) As a key factor,
in terms of defining the level and nature of achieved balance, can be highlighted
the nexus of potential correlations that are being created among the diverse
ekistic elements and the relevant scientific disciplines –economic, social, political,
technological and cultural. As per Doxiadis, if all the potential combinations are to
be calculated, then we come across with the amazing number of more than thirty-
three million alternatives (Kyrtsis, 2006). The ultra-dynamic character of human
settlements is depicted by means of the “Ekistic Grid”, which constitutes a valuable
working tool both at the levels of analysis and planning.
communications facilities, and economic, legal, educational and political systems.” (Doxiadis and Papaioannou,
1974, p.9)
276
REVISITING POST-CIAM GENERATION: debates, proposals and intellectual framework
Proceedings. Porto, April 11-13, 2019
According to him, ‘the analysis of settlements cannot be separated from the fourth
dimension, that of time.’ (Doxiadis and Papaioannou, 1974, p. 7)
Summarizing, Doxiadis had been offered the empty plains of Potwar Plateau in
Northern Pakistan, neighbouring the existing city of Rawalpindi, so as to
implement his ekistic theory and create Islamabad, the first fragment of the city
of the future7, or otherwise the first fragment of a universal system of life. In other
words, a capital city was about to be established, which would be consistent in
terms of economic, social, political, technical and cultural factors, while it would
maintain its functionality in the infinity8. Alternatively, Islamabad was about to
emerge, following two of the Ekistics’ principles, namely the “Unity of Purpose”
and the “Four Dimensions”. Equally respected were supposed to be the other two
principles, which complete the ekistic theory, suggesting the “Hierarchy of
Functions”, as well as “many Masters and many Scales”9. Therefore, Islamabad
was meant to be a coherent system of life, which could be perpetually growing
and evolving, while maintaining its initial virtues and functional competence,
through a series of hierarchically ordered and highly integrated sub-systems. The
basis for materializing the above mentioned ideal has been the introduction of
“Dynapolis”. Doxiadis again introduced this kind of urban development pattern,
which presupposed a linear and simultaneously parabolic model of expansion both
of the residential and the city’s central functions. The existence of a modular
human community, which could be perpetually reproduced, constituted the key
parameter for the materialization of the Dynapolis model. For Islamabad the Class
7
Islamabad was considered to be the first materialized fragment of “Ecumenopolis, the inevitable city of the future”.
Ecumenopolis, a term also introduced by Doxiadis, signified the unified global human settlement, the
implementation of which has already been initiated, while its completion was estimated to take place in the year
2100. (Doxiadis, 1968)
8
“The only way to envisage our goals in size is to relate size to time. Our goals, expressed in size, must be dynamic.
Our new city must become the Federal Capital not for today, not for tomorrow, but from now on and as long as the
government of Pakistan feels that it is the best place for a capital.” (Doxiadis Associates, 1960, p.416)
9
More information on the four principles of Ekistics –Unity of Purpose, Four Dimensions, Hierarchy of Functions,
many Masters and many Scales- can be found in page 317 of ‘The spirit of Islamabad’, in Ekistics; Abstracts on
the problems of science of human settlements, ed. by Doxiadis Associates (vol.12, No.73, 1961), p.p. 315-335.
277
Anastasia Sakka, Ekistics, or the science of human settlements, through the paradigm of the master plan of
Islamabad
V human community was defined as its modular and the southwest direction as
its only possible way towards expansion.
In more detail, the creation of Pakistan’s federal capital presupposed the formation
of a metropolitan area, which included the area of Islamabad with distinguished
national features, the area of Rawalpindi destined to maintain its regional
character and the National Park, corresponding and serving both Islamabad and
Rawalpindi, by means of retaining agricultural functions, as well as special
functions with either cultural or educational orientation. For the development of
Islamabad, a narrow triangular10 area had been reserved, strictly defined from the
one side by the Margalla Hills and from the other side by Rawalpindi and the
National Park, leaving only the southwest direction unbounded. Respectively
Rawalpindi had absolute boundaries from all three sides –Islamabad, National Park
and Soan river-, while again the southwest edge had been kept free to expansion.
Both urban schemes, namely the existing Rawalpindi and the created ex-novo
Islamabad, were designed so as to evolve in parallel and in a complementary
manner, following the Dynapolis model. It worth to be noted that this kind of
unlimited future development appears to be feasible, only by means of absolute
limitations at the stage of planning. According to the inspirer of this urban model:
The proper name for the city of the future is Dynapolis, the dynamic polis
or city, which in contrast to the static polis or city of the past will possess
the characteristics of dynamic development built in it. Thus this city will be
able to develop freely and naturally along a planned and predetermined
course. (C.A.D.A., DOX-PA 77, 1960, p.134)
Since human settlements are identified as systems of life, then it seems perfectly
reasonable the idea of human community to be the ideal of any urban planning
process. Anyhow, it was towards social reformation that urban planning aimed,
which was not irrelevant with architecture’s socialization11. One of the
10
Additionally, the selected triangular area secured the coherence of scale at all stages of urban development.
11
“This is because the architect must now build for the masses, creating architecture for everybody and not for a
certain leading class alone. At the same time, he has to build much larger numbers of houses and buildings.”
(C.A.D.A., DOX-PA 115, 1961, p.38)
278
REVISITING POST-CIAM GENERATION: debates, proposals and intellectual framework
Proceedings. Porto, April 11-13, 2019
Therefore, if the community was meant to be the unit of planning12, then it could
be assumed that a predefined social tissue was intended to be materialized
through a properly designed urban tissue. The master plan of Islamabad had been
utterly based on a series of autonomous human communities of various scales,
which were, nevertheless, in an absolute and hierarchical manner interrelated –
as specified by the ekistic principle, concerning the hierarchy of functions. This
sequence of hierarchically ordered communities resulted to the already mentioned
Class V human community, which presented the higher level of complexity and
constituted the most extended area under the dominance of the human scale. This
is to say that Class V human community, which was defined in spatial terms by
means of a 2x2km square terrain and which could be fully accessible on foot by
its inhabitants, without any real dependence on the machine, constituted a static,
however autonomous and of a highest order integrated system of life, which
became the modular for the development of Islamabad, or otherwise the city’s
sector.
12
Further, on the interrelation between the new capital city’s physical and social features, “The basic principle that
should be observed in the structure of a residential community is that its physical pattern should be in complete
accord with the social organization of the human group that is expected to settle in them.” (C.A.D.A., DOX-PAK-
LH38, 1966, p.3)
279
Anastasia Sakka, Ekistics, or the science of human settlements, through the paradigm of the master plan of
Islamabad
The following notes of Doxiadis, which correspond to one of his visits in India,
provide a clear aspect of his vision, regarding urban planning objectives and
instruments.
For hours we wander into these housing schemes. They have been built
during the last twelve years. They are all characteristic of the same spirit.
I could say that their defects are the following: a) there is no creation of
community spirit at all. There is no interconnection of the different
buildings. On the contrary they look as being thrown on a vast land with no
order. There is no formation of a social pyramid. No neighbourhoods, no
communities. (C.A.D.A., India Notes, 1955, p.35)
The urge for implementing master plans with the idea of social pyramid being well
kept in mind, signifies a lot. In fact, a strong commitment to social structuring is
unveiled, which expectedly will take place on a basis of the proper spatial
arrangements. Considering again the Islamabad case, as the ultimate criterion, in
order that the social pyramid to be portrayed, had been defined the one of income
–its objective features render it a highly efficient instrument. In more detail, all
280
REVISITING POST-CIAM GENERATION: debates, proposals and intellectual framework
Proceedings. Porto, April 11-13, 2019
The ideal of the functional city, which constituted the cornerstone of CIAM
manifesto, should not be appraised as an element completely detached from any
humanitarian context. On the contrary and despite any failures of modern urban
planning, as expressed through the CIAM rhetoric, the aim of social reformation
was on the top rank of the modernist agenda. The idea of social equality and
humankind’s well-being went along with the propagation of the functional city and
more precisely it was considered that the viability of the former depended on the
successful implementation of the latter. Both privileges and responsibilities
281
Anastasia Sakka, Ekistics, or the science of human settlements, through the paradigm of the master plan of
Islamabad
sourcing from the advent of the Machine Era concerned all members of the social
strata, or otherwise everyone who “have chanced to be touched by the sun” (Le
Corbusier, 1943, p.xix), as characteristically is referred in the introduction of the
Athens Charter edition of 1943. This is to say that solely the shift in interest from
spatial associations to human associations, as it was urged by the younger
members of CIAM, did not actually signify a reorientation, in terms of pursued
goals. Anyhow, the impact of the Machine Age could not be disregarded; mass
production activities in order to be viable required a competent audience –both in
terms of quantitative and qualitative features-, which at that moment did not
exist, but needed to become existent. The creation of a shared culture at a global
scale –where culture is comprehended as synonymous to mode of living- appeared
to be the key factor. And the vehicle in order to create the required social content
was considered to be the creation of the proper urban container both in the CIAM
and post-CIAM period.
282
REVISITING POST-CIAM GENERATION: debates, proposals and intellectual framework
Proceedings. Porto, April 11-13, 2019
simultaneously he was attentive with the very essentials that secured the system’s
function. That is why he urged that “Our primary duty is to understand that we
must start preparing programs instead of plans” (C.A.D.A., DOX-PA29, 1959, p.2)
283
Anastasia Sakka, Ekistics, or the science of human settlements, through the paradigm of the master plan of
Islamabad
284
REVISITING POST-CIAM GENERATION: debates, proposals and intellectual framework
Proceedings. Porto, April 11-13, 2019
References
Bullock, N. (2002). Building the Post-War World; Modern Architecture and Reconstruction
in Britain. London: Routledge.
Doxiadis, C. & Papaioannou, J. (1974). Ecumenopolis: The Inevitable City of the Future.
Athens: Athens Publishing Center.
Frampton, K. (1981). Modern Architecture: A Critical History. London: Thames and Hudson
Ltd.
285
Anastasia Sakka, Ekistics, or the science of human settlements, through the paradigm of the master plan of
Islamabad
C. A. Doxiadis Archives, Bulletin 64: Islamabad the New Capital of Pakistan, March 1964,
Doxiadis Associates (Ed.)
286