Development: Unit OF Scheduled Tribes
Development: Unit OF Scheduled Tribes
Development: Unit OF Scheduled Tribes
TRIBES
Structure
2.1 Introduction
2.2 Scheduled Tribes-Meaning and Concept
2.3 Process of Change Among the Scheduled Tribes
2.4 Social Discrimination and Disabilities of Scheduled Tribes
2.5 Major Problems of Scheduled Tribes
2.6 ' Government Measures
2.7 Development Policies and Programmes
2.8 Let Us Sum Up
2.9 References and Suggested Readings
2.10 Check Your Progress - Possible Answers
2.1 INTRODUCTION
The Tribes of India are one of the earliest populations in the land. India can
proudly be called the largest "tribal" population in the world. Today there are as
many as 698 Tribes across the country. The Tribals are considered the "sons of
the soil" and make for 8.2% of the total population of India according to 2001
census. This interprets into 84 million people. Tribes in India are derived from
four racial stocks: Negrito (Jarwa and Onge in Andamans), Proto-Autroloid
(Munda, Oraon, Gonds in Jharkhand and Madhya Pradesh), Mongoloid (most
Tribes in North-East) and Caucasoid (Toda, Rabari, Gujjar). There is another
method of division of Tribes. The NEFA and Eastern India belong to the
Mongoloid racial stock, Proto-Austroloid in Central India, Mediterranean-Nordic
in the West and Central Himalayas and the Austroloid, Negroid and Alpine stock
in South India. The largest tribe is the Gond followed by the Bhils, Meena,
Santals and Oraons according to 1981 census. The tribes of India lived across
states despite a common background of language. The Santals, Oraons, Mundas
and others lived in the original region of Jharkhand extending to the states Orissa,
Bengal, Madhya Pradesh. The Gond region extended across Andhra Pradesh,
Chhatisgarh, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashrtra, and Orissa. The Bhils inhabited a
region that stretched fiom Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra and Rajasthan.
The Nagas Lived in Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Manipur and Nagaland.
The Tribes of India, also referred as adivasis (original inhabitants), are spread
across the central, northeast, and southern regions of India. These various tribes
resided in India long before the Aryans had arrived here approximately 1500
BC. They were socially and geographically isolated, following the entry of the
Aryans and then subsequently the Muslims and the British. More than 650 tribes
that make up the Scheduled Tribes speak multitude of languages. They are also
religiously diverse, with some following animism, while others have adopted
Hinduism, Islam or Christianity. The social organization and traditions of most
of the tribals make them stand out from the country's mainstream Hindu
population also known as "state" or c'civilization".
Thrr Indian Tribes collectively owned property in keeping with their tradition. Develo~mentofSched~lled
The British regime introduced a new land tenure system against the traditional Tribes
cus1,om of the tribals. As a result others infringed into the lands of the tribals.
This led to many a land revolt amongst tribals. These tribal revolts may be referred
to hialpahariya uprising in 1772, the unrest in Kutch in 1815 and 1832, the Bhil
Revolt of 1818, the uprising of the Mers in Rajputana in 1820, the rebellion of
$ Hos in Chotanagpur in 1831, the Kol insurrection of 1832, the uprising of Khonds
in Orissa in 1846, the Santal Rrevolt of 1855 and Birsa Munda Rrevolt of 1895.
Today the Scheduled Tribes account for 55 % of the total displaced in India.
.
The study of this Unit should lead the students to know:
Explain Tribes in general and Scheduled Tribes in particular
Describe the overall conditions of Scheduled Tribes
13iscuss the changes taking place among the Scheduled Tribes
I3xplain the Constitutional provisions and other developmental scheme.^ for
them
I'ointout the problems related to development in order to plan better
The word "Tribe" is not known in the Indian society prior to the British
anthropologists or the colonial rule. In India there lived heterogeneous
communities better known by the more indigenous term "jana" and "jati". This
term jana is derived fiom Sanskrit and Prakrit meaning to give birth. We also
know that there are "communities of people like the Savars, the Kullutas, the
Kollas, the Bhi1las;the Khasas, the Kinnars, the Gujjars, the Gaddis, the Lepchas,
and countless others whom today we know as "Tribes7'(Dube ed. 1972:8). At
that stage the two communities seemed very much belonging to the same ethnic
categories altogether.
There is a di%culty in distinguishing the jana and the tribes in ancient times.
But not many would accept equating them on equal parlance. The social
organization of the janas was based on egalitarian principle while the jati's social
organization was based on the system of jati. Today we can understand better
the distinction between the Tribals and the castes system (Beteille 1986; Roy
Burman 1994). The term tribe was used by Colonial administration to describe
communities which were heterogeneous in physical and linguistic traits,
demographic size, ecological conditions of living, regions inhabited, stages of
social formation and levels of acculturation and development (Xaxa, 2008).
Tribes have also been studies in relation to peasant society. The two have different
types of societies. In Anthropological literature tribes have been defined as
communities that are more or less homogeneous, having a common government,
a common dialect, and a common culture. Tribes have characteristic of segmentary
social system, The Tribal society is small in scale are restricted in spatial and
temporal ranges of their social, legal and political relations and possess a morality,
religion and world view of a corresponding order. In short, tribal societies are
self-contained units whereas the peasant society is a part society and not a whole
society. The tribes do not suffer fiom any caste-like social stigma. They have
remained beyond the pale of caste society except for those who have interacted
closely with peasant castes in a few regions.
The so-called tribals of India are the indigenous people of the land, in the sense
that they have been long settlers in different parts of the country before the Aryan-
speaking people penetrated into India passing through Kabul and Tndus Valley.
Since then tribal communities have spread all over India including Bangladesh,
erstwhile East Bengal. There are four fold categories of tribals according to
economic type as given by D.N. Majumdar and T.N. Madan. The first are the
food gatherers, mainly depending on the forests. The second are the tribes having
an economy between food gathering and primitive agriculture. The third are the
tribes of North-East and Middle India that mainly depend on some form of
ab't-iculture with forest produce as a secondary support. The fourth are those
working in industries. Especially the Bihar, Bengal and Assam (Mehta, 1991).
They are found ethnically and culturally distinct from the non-tribal neighbours.
This is the reason why their demand for special treatment as socio-culturally
distinct group is valid and has to be looked sympathetically.
In general, the following are the characteristic features of a tribe:
Tribe should be a primitive and isolated community
(Generallybackward, illiterate, rustic and outside of state civilization Developmentof Schedub?d
'kibes
Primitive method of exploiting natural resources
'Territorial unity and a separate common language
Descendants from a common ancestor
Having its own belief system like animism, morality, governance
Cultural unity and governed by customary law
2.3.1 Education
Impact of development processes, particularly, education has brought about a
sea change in tribal society of India. According to 2001 Census, there are 47%
literate among the tribals at all India level; 59% among male and 35% among
female. The All India literacy rate is 65%; 75% among male and 54% among
female. In the following table a decennial growth of literacy rate among the
tribals is given:
Table 1: Educational Status of Scheduled Tribes
Year Male % Female % Total %
The main crops of tribals are rice, pulses, millets and other coarse grains grown
in the hilly terrains and rocky grounds. More than 90 per cent tribals eat rice and
millet forms the staple food for many tribals. Wheat is introduced recently. Now
they have taken to growing vegetables. Those engaged in agriculture are plain
dwellers and are influenced by modem agriculttue.There is a variety of cropping
like wheat, oilseeds, cash crops and marketable vegetables. The Tribals have
also taken to business but mostly as small entrepreneurs.
Today the tribals are found in almost all the occupations both white-collar jobs
and blue-collar jobs. Under professional jobs there are tribal doctors, lawyers,
engineers, university teachers, school teachers of various grades, nurses, skilled
technical workers etc. The tribals are also found in central and state government
ofices, executives and managerial ofices. The highest number of course is found
in the clerical grades of different levels. Semi-slulled, skilled and non-skilled
workers come in the blue-collar workers where tribals are the majority.
c
Since they were the rules of their areas the entire territory with all the resources Development of Scheduled
Ikibes
or1 the surface of the land and below belonged to them. Hence the tribals were
land owners from the very beginning who owned all resources and managed
them. The Mughals did not interfere into their ownership or social organization
and life style so long as they paid the maIgujari (land revenue) to the Mughal
Emperor. That is why the introduction of the zarnindars and rajas by the British
for their revenue was totally alien to the tribal system of self-rule and communal
ov~nershipof land and forest. Even the old rulers- tribals and others- began to
adopt new methods of administration through their zamindars and their agents.
The successive, almost continuous uprisings of the tribal communities living in
these regions against the imposition of new administration drew attention to the
sp1:cial problems. The British slowly realized the difference between the larger
Intlian masses and the inhabitants of forests and hills. Consequently certain
co~nmunities,for the first time, were recognized as separate ethnic groups and
classified as aborigines. The areas predominantly inhabited by the aborigines
were directly under the British administration and excluded hlly or partially
from the normal administration. Areas were, later on, called "scheduled areas"
anti the tribes included in the Schedules to the Presidential order of 1950 were
called "Scheduled Tribes".
Thl:re was no question of access to the land by tribes; rather they had inherently
possessed the land and forest of the territorial entity where they lived. It is their
binh right over the land and forest and all the natural resources of their territory.
2.4.2 Poverty
The main occupation of the tribals is agriculture and some of them still depend
on hunting and gathering and some on nomadic zoom agriculture which is also
known as "slash and burn" cultivation. Their agriculture is very much primitive
and traditional depending mainly on monsoon. In kharif season about 47% land
are under inigatioil and only 2% in the rabi season (1991 Census). Nearly 90 per
Social Development cent of the tribals live in villages, some in forests and hills. In 2004-2005 there
were 47 per cent tribals below poverty line in the rural area and 33 per cent in the
urban area compared to 16 per cent for others in both the areas (Planning
Commission). One can see the vast difference in poverty between the two social
groups. Recently the migration of tribals due to displacement has increased by
leaps and bounds.
2.4.3 Illiteracy
The literacy rate of tribals at the national level was 47.10 per cent as per 2001
Census, of which 59 per cent was male and 37 per cent was female. The literacy
rate for the general population was 65 per cent. The literacy rate among the
tribals comparatively is very low. We have discussed earlier that due to poverty
the tribals cannot take to education and much less to the higher level particularly,
among the rural tribal population. There is little awareness about the value of
education among the tribals and to add to it there are no sufficient number of
schools in the remote villages. The present status of the literacy rate goes higher
much due to the pioneering efforts of the Christian missionaries who opened
schools even in the remotest areas to impart education to tribals and backwards
classes. Now there are various projects, like National Literacy Mission
programmes, Non-formal Education, Adult Literacy, sarva shiksha abhiyan and
private schools that have boosted up the literacy rate.
2.4.4 Backwardness
Both the factors given above, namely, poverty and illiteracy sum up to give the
rationale for the relative backwardness of the tribals in general. The habitat of
the tribals is also partly responsible for their isolation, and minimum interaction
with the rest of the society.
In this sections you read about the tribals and their status now answer the questions
given in check your progress 1.
Check Your Progress 1
Note: a) Write your answer in about 50 words
b) Check your answer with possible answers given at the end of the unit
1) What are the two principal points that distinguish a tribe from a caste?
.......................................................................................................................
2) Identi@ at least three factors that have brought about changes in the socio
economic conditions of the tribals.
- - '3) 'What are the three main points of the social discrimination of Tribals? Development of Scheduled
Tribes
/ into utter poverty and misery. Out of the 40 million people displaced since
independence across India 40% are tribals This shows the magnitude of the
development-induced displacement. Land alienation is the major problem of
the trlbals today. The causes of land alienation are hydroelectricity and irrigation,
mega dams, power plants, mines, industries, military installations, weaponry
I testing, railways, roads, reserves, sanctuaries etc.
r
2.5.1: Losing Rights Over Community Forests
For a large number of tribal people, forest is home, a livelihood, yes the very
existc:nce. Forest is one of the mainstays of tribal economy. It gives them food -
fruits of all kinds- edible oils, honey, nourishment roots, herbs, wild game and
fish. Minor forest produce gives them supplementary income to their meager
produce. From time immemorial tribal people have enjoyed freedom to use the
foresr and hunt animals and this has given them a conviction that remains even
today deep in their hearts that the forests belong to them. Traditionally local
comniunities exercised their rights over the forests because it was the source of
livelihood, house construction and agricultural implements. The forests provide
Social Development fuel, food, fodder, fibre and timber for housing, ploughing and other materials.
While the community utilized the forest produce it was in the nature of the
tribals to conserve the forests for their sustainable economy and livelihood. The
tribals had free hand in exploiting the forest resources, and they also regulated it
continuously, like restrictions in cutting certain kinds of trees. But it did not
pose any problem as the population was small and the forest vast. After the
British came into the scene they realized the value of timber and started controlling
its use especially after 1855-56.
i) Post Independence:
a) National Forest Policy 1952 - Declared that the forests should be used strictly
for the national interests. "The accident of village being situated close to a
forest does not prejudice the right of the country as a whole to receive the
benefits of a National Asset" (Paty Kr Ed 2007). Logic was that the rural
people have not contributed much towards the maintenance and regeneration
of the forests (National Commission on Agriculture - 1976:25). This act
does not consider the needs of the adivasisl tribals for the use of even the
minor forest products. A study team of the Tribal Development Programme
of the Planning Commission presented a report that asserted, " that the tribals
have special claim over the forest and forest produces, they have the rights
to collect fuel, food, fodder and minor produces"
b) The Forest Policy 1988 with amendment - The Act stressed on the forest
conservation but did not blame the people statement as in earlier documents.
But it did not analyse the causes of destruction and solution.
c) The Conservation of Forests and Natural Eco-system Act 1995 - It was
proposed as a New Forest Bill to replace the Forest Act 1927. This bill was
not covering the people's right over forest for livelihood. But this bill stressed
the need of people to manage and conserve forests. orei its are national
assets to be protected and enhanced for the well-being of the people and me
nations. Management was decentralized by the 73rd-74th Amendment of the
Constitution implying people's participation.
2.5.4 Traditional Agriculture Development of Sched~ded
Tribes
By and large the tribals take to primitive technology for agriculture even to this
day. It depends on the mercy of monsoon entirely which of late is coming more
and more unpredicted and erratic due to climatic change. The animal power,
moilsoon rain, mono cropping, meager land holding, less fertile soil, land erosion,
depletion of forests are some of the main characteristic features of tribal
agriculture. The annual per acre yield remains to be low. There is a high level
dependency population on the agriculture and the labour surplus is the added
reas~onfor poor agriculture. For most of the tribal households the produce of the
land is hardly sufficient for six months, so for the remaining months they have
to depend on daily wages either locally available or outside. There is also undue
pressure on agriculture land because of the large population to be fed. The modern
technology has not touched primitive agriculture extensively and high yielding
varieties are limited in use. Cultivation remains the main occupation of the tribals
but with so many constrains.
2.5.5 Unemployment
The kharifcrop cultivation activities keeps the tribal farmers busy for about six
months and for the remaining six months they are largely idle and unemployed.
The rabi crop is taken up only by about 2 per cent of the tribals because of the
lack.of irrigation facilities. These are the non-productive days when the tribals
are imemployed. In the rural sectors there are go\~ernmentschemes now to give
then1employment but insufficient. Some of the schemes under rural employment
programmes are: National Rural Employment Programme (NREP), Jawahar
Rojgar Yojna (JRY), Food for Work Scheme, and now the latest is National
Rural Employment Guarantee Act (NREGA). The last one gives a guarantee of
100 days work by Act of the parliament. Most of the unemployed tribals and
other poor people are the beneficiaries. The youth have a very high rate of
uneinployment because there is also high degree of school dropouts. The result
is that they are migrating to the urban areas' in search of job and livelihood.
2.5.7 Migration
Migration by definition is the movement of population from one place to another
in search of livelihood or other necessities of life not available in the place of
birth. Such movement could be from less developed villages or cities to more
developed villages and cities. It could also be from a traditional agricultural
occupational area to modern industrial occupational areas. The desire is to gain
basic: necessities and amenities of life for a higher standard of life. Such a motive
to m~svementis called the bbpush"factor and the availability of goods and services
in another place is called the "pull" factor. The push and pull factors can be both
economic and non-economic. Need of higher income in the industrial sector
Social Development could be the pull economic factor whereas the aspiration of modern amenities
like films and TV and running water for household use could be the non-economic
factor. More concretely economic factors are poverty, search for livelihood, better
employment opportunities etc. Lack of proper education, social discrimination,
open war, media influence, and desire to be away fi-om social control are some
of the social and non-economic factors of migration. In this sense it is different
from the displacement which is by compulsion rather than voluntary. The tribals
in general have moved to towns and cities main in search of jobs and better
t
oppoi-tunities.
The main cause of their move is poverty and poverty is caused mainly by the
unviable agricultural yield in the traditional villages. The government has not
given enough attention to modernize agriculture or provide irrigation facilities.
The available job opportunities are
found only in towns and cities and industries. So because of this economic
development policy of the government the people migrate to towns and cities.
The consequences are:
loss of tribal population in the stateldistricts of birth
tribals are becoming minority in their own homelands
transferlalienation of tribal lands
identity of tribals in danger
increasing slums in cities and poverty as well
2.5.8 Problem of Maoist Extremism
This is very pernicious fallout of the poverty and exploitations of the tribal society
particularly in the central regions of India. The Maoist organization found fertile
ground to take roots and flourish in the poverty stricken regions of central regions
in India. They made their inroads in Bengal and Andhra Pradesh central Bihar.
Today they have got firm footing in all most all the tribal belts of India. Andhra
Pradesh, Orissa, Jharkhand, West Bengal, Chhattisgarh, Madhya Pradesh are
rigged with the menace of the Maoist terrorism. They induce the young
unemployed fi-om the tribal belts and recruit them to their regiment on a paltry
sum of money, uniform and a gun. The developments of these regions have been
sabotaged by the Maoists. These extremists groups are nearly running a parallel
government in the rural areas. The efforts of the government to squash these
groups have been very unsuccessful.
2.6.2 Reservations
Reservation in the Indian law is a form of aflirniative action. By this measure
certain percentage of seats are reserved for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled
Castes in public sector units, union and state civil services, union and state
governinent departments and in all public and private educational institutions. It
is meant for socially backward classes who are inadequately represented in these
senlice~sand institutions. Reservation is a concept not unique to India only; it
Social Development also exists in other nations like the USA where certain percentage of jobs are
served for African Americans or other "disadvantaged" groups. Scheduled Tribes
in India are under represented in the country's social structure because they have
been historically oppressed and discriminated. Reservation was an attempt to
abolish some social evils like untouchabilty and reduce social differences giving
the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes equal opportunities to better their
lives and integrate themselves into the country's social fabric. To this effect the
following are the provisions:
There have been periodical reviews and each time-due to above mentioned
considerations the period of reservations is extended by various amendments in
the parliament. Reservation for Lok Sabha and Vidhan Sabha is supposed to
expire in January 2010 as of now. Only the time will tell about its fate. It is to be
noted that political reservations in the Lok Sabha and the Vidhan Sabha are not
as stiff as it is in the educational and professional institutions, like the schools
and colleges, IIT/JEE, IIM, Medical and Engineering Colleges. Some points of
arguments are brought out here.
The President declared certain areas in the central belt of Madhya Pradesh
(Clthattisgarh), Rajasthan, Gujarat, Andhra Pradesh, Bihar (Jharkhand), Orissa,
Maharashtra, Himachal Pradesh as Scheduled areas. The characteristic features
are that the Governor has special legislative power, as to report to the President
and take the advice of the Tribal Advisory Council, however, not bound by it.
The Governor has the power to suspend any Act of the Parliament that may not
be c:onducive to the welfare of the Tribals.
.......................................................................................................................
2) What are the three main features of the Fifth Schedule?
.......................................................................................................................
3) I:n what four different ways has the Sixth Schedule helped the North-East Develo~mentofScheduled
'Tribals? Tribles
I
I
2.7 DEVELOPMENT POLICIES AND
PROGRAMMES
Somc: of the policy and programme measures undertaken for the upliftment of
ST population are described here under.
Taking this policy into account the post independent period has seen number of
programmes for the development of tribals. In order to achieve this objective a
special tribal development administrative setup was organized right from after
the independence. The broad framework of administration is given below:
1.
LJnder Article 338 of the Constitution, a special officer known as
C)ommissionerfor Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes has been working
! s lnce November 1950. The ministry of Home Affairs was initially in charge
of the work related to the welfare of Scheduled Tribes till 1964. It came
under the Department of Social Security, and in 1966 was recognized under
the Department of Social Welfare and is responsible for the welfare of
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and other backward classes.
C'ommissioner for SC and ST groups: It is the medium through which the
union government is kept informed of the programmes and implementation
of the safeguard and welfare schemes of ST and SC.
I\ational Commission for SC and ST: The commission shall consist of the
Chairperson the Vice Chairperson and five other members nominated by
the President. Their power and duties are to investigate and monitor matters
relating to the safeguards provided to the ST and SC, inquire into the
I
complaints regarding deprivation of rights, participate and advice the planning
for their socio economic development inform the President of the working
o F this Commission, that is put in the parliament.
There are State and district level setups for the tribal programmes that may
vary from one state to another. At lower level the District Magistrate and his
i
subordinate staff and officers of various departments are responsible for all
d1:velopment activities related to the Tribals.
L
Social Development Under the Fifth Scheduled and the Sixth Scheduled (described earlier) there
are elaborate provisions for the governance and development of the Scheduled
areas.
The 2ndFive year Plan emphasized on the economic development and set up
Special Multiple Tribal Blocks (SMPT). The Ministry and Home Affairs
and the State government through blocks jointly implemented the
programmes.
In 3rdFive Year Plan these blocks were named as Tribal Development Block
which primarily undertook with priority the economic, education and, health
and housing sectors. The blocks were initially consisting of one lakh
population later on reduced to 25 thousand with 213 tribal population.
The 4&Five Year Plan introduced the strategy of Tribal Development Agency
as additional programme focusing on specific target groups/areas especially
in Bihar Orissa and Andhra. The targets were individual families and small
farmers.
The 5&Five Year Plan is known as the landmark of tribal people. The concept
of Tribal Sub Plan (TSP) was introduced. The strategy under this concept
was that of Integrated Tribal Development Actions ( ITDA).
The 6" Five Year Plan adopted Modified Ares Area Development Approach
to cover smaller areas of 10,000 population. In this 50% or more were
supposed to be tribals. There are 268 MADA at present.
Under the 7" and 8&Five Year Plans the Tribal Sub-plans were consolidated
better. Other efforts were also initiated for the development of the Primitive
Tribal Groups (PTG).
Objectives
Narrowing the gaps at the levels of development between tribal and non-
tribal areas
Improving the standards of lives of tribal communities
Making up for deficiencies in infrastructures for development
- ---
In these sections you read about the policy and programme measures undertaken
for the uplifiment of STs and now answer the questions .given in check your
progress 3.
I .......................................................................................................................
1
What actions were taken in the lsc frdand 5thF Y Plans for the welfare of the
Scheduled Tribes?
Under Tribal Sub Plan what h e three most important activities for the
development of the Scheduled Tribes?
I
- Development of Sched~~led
2 LET US SUM UP lkibes
I Tribals are the important segment of the Indian population. They constitute 8.2
I
I 2) What actions were taken in the 1sc frdand 5"' Five Year Plans for the welfare
Ans.
of the Scheduled Tribes?
a) In the 1st Five Year Plan launching of Community Development
Programme for Scheduled Tribes in Blocks,
b) Under the 3rdFive Year Plan composition of Special Multiple Tribal
Blocks (SMPT),
I c) Under 5"' Five Year Plan introduction of Tribals Sub Plan (TSP).
3) Under Tribal Sub Plan what are three most important activities for the
I
development of the Scheduled Tribes?
Ans. The three most important activities for the development of the Scheduled
Tribes are:
a) Tribal cooperative Marketing Development Federation of India
(TrnED),
f-
b) Large Sized Multipurpose Cooperative Societies (LAMPS), fiee the
Tribals from money- lenders. I