BRM Book by Rabbani
BRM Book by Rabbani
BRM Book by Rabbani
DEFINITIONS OF RESEARCH
Research is the specific process of finding solutions to a problem thorough study and analysis of the
situation and data.
Research: In the broadest sense of the word, the definition of research includes any gathering of data,
information and facts for the advancement of knowledge.
Business Research can be described as systematic and organized effort to investigate a specific problem
encountered in the work setting, which needs a solution. (Uma Sekaran)
Business Research is the systematic process of gathering, recording and analyzing data for effective
decision making.
Business Research is the systematic investigative process employed to increase or revise current
knowledge by discovering new facts. It is divided into two general categories: 1) Basic research is inquiry
aimed at increasing scientific knowledge and 2) Applied research is effort aimed at using basic research
for solving problem or developing new processes, products or techniques. (Business Dictionary)
Research Methods: Research methods provide the knowledge and skills to solve the problems and meet
the challenges of a fast-paced decision- making environment.
Applied Research: Applied research undertaken to solve a current problem faced by the manager in the
work setting. Applied research done with the intention of applying the results of the findings to solve
specific problems being experienced in the organization.
Applied research can help make a decision about the following, including a variety of other business and
management decisions:
o Pricing a new product
2|Page Created by Rabbani
Applied research can be used to collect information about markets, competitors, and customers.
For example, research can help pinpoint the optimal business location and the size of markets. It can also
be used to monitor competitive actions. Customer research determines customer loyalty, customer
satisfaction, and customer preferences.
Basic Research: Basic research also known as fundamental or pure research. Basic research undertakes
mainly to increase the understanding of certain problems that commonly occur in organization. Most basic
research is conducted by professors in academic institutions (i.e. colleges and universities), by the
government, or by consulting firms. Few business organizations will engage in pure research related to
business problems.
For example: A university professor may be interested in investigating the factor that contributes the
absenteeism as a matter of mere academic interest. After gathering information on this topic from several
institutions and analyzing the data, the professor may identify factors such as inflexible work hours,
inadequate training of employees and low morale as primarily influencing absenteeism. Later on, a manager
who encounters absenteeism of employees in his organization may use this information to determine if
these factors are relevant to those particular work settings for problem solving.
The Manager Researcher Relationship: During their career, it often becomes necessary for manager to
deal with consultant. When the manager is knowledgeable about research then the interactions between the
manager and researcher become more meaningful, purposeful and beneficial both to the organization and
the researcher alike.
The manager has to inform the researchers what types of information could be provided
to them and more important, which of their records would not be made available to them. Such record
might include the personal files of the employees or the ones with certain trade secrets. Managers who are
very knowledgeable about research can more easily foresee what information the researchers might require
and if certain documents containing such information cannot be made available, they can inform the
research team about this at the outset. It is vexing for researchers to discover at a late stage that the company
will not let them have certain information. If they know the constraints right from the beginning, the
researchers might be able to identify alternate ways of tackling the problems and to design the research in
such a way as to provide the needed answers.
INTERNAL CONSULTANTS/RESEARCHERS
Some organizations have their own consulting or research departments, which might be called the
management services department, the organization and methods department, R & D, or by some other
name. Such a unit within the organization would be useful in several ways and enlisting its help might be
advantageous under some circumstances, but not in others. The manager often has to decide whether to use
internal or external researchers. To reach a decision, the manager should be aware of the strengths and
weaknesses of both and weight the advantages and disadvantages of using either, based on the needs
of the solution.
2) Cost Effective: The internal team might cost considerably less than an external team for the department
enlisting help in problem solving, because they will need less time to understand the system due to their
continuous involvement with various units of the organization. The internal team would be ideal for the
low complexity problems.
3) Availability after Research: They would be available for implementing their ideas and
recommendations after the research findings are accepted.
4) Understanding with Employees: The internal team would stand a better chance of being readily
acceptable by the employees in the organization.
1) Limited Ideas: Certain organizational biases of the internal research team might in some instances make
the findings less objective and consequently less scientific.
2) Less Involvement: There is scope for certain powerful coalitions in the organization to influence the
internal team to conceal, distort, or misrepresent certain facts. In other words, certain vested interests could
dominate, especially in securing a sizable portion of the available scant resources.
3) Not Perceived as Experts: There is also a possibility that even the most highly qualified internal
research teams are not perceived as “experts” by the staff and management, and hence their
recommendations do not get the considerations and attention they deserve.
4) Lack of up-to-date Knowledge: In view of their long tenure as internal consultants, the internal team
may quite possibly fall into a stereotyped way of looking at the organization and its problems. This would
inhibit any fresh ideas and perspectives that might be needed to correct the problems.
EXTERNAL CONSULTANT/RESEARCHERS
The disadvantages of the internal research teams turn out to be the advantages of the external teams, and
the former’s advantages work out to be the disadvantages of the latter.
1) Credibility: The external team may be perceived as having more credibility for people of the
organization. They possess certain evaluation research skills and knowledge that the internal evaluator may
not. They have exposure to a wider range of issues, methods and practices that would be useful to
incorporate
2) Adequate Experience: The external team can draw on a wealth of experience from having worked with
different types of organizations that have had the same or similar types of problems.
3) Up-to-date Knowledge: The external teams, especially those from established research and consulting
firms, might have more knowledge of current sophisticated problem-solving models through their periodic
training programs, which the teams within the organization may not have access to.
1) High Cost: The cost of hiring an external research team is usually high and is the main deterrent, unless
the problems are very critical.
4|Page Created by Rabbani
2) Additional Fees: The external team also charges additional fees for their assistance in the
implementation and evaluation phases.
3) Time Consuming: The external team takes considerable time to understand the organization to be
researched. They seldom get a warm welcome, nor are readily accepted by employees. Departments and
individuals likely to be affected by the research study may perceive the study team as a threat and resist
them.
SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH
Scientific research or investigation focuses on solving problems, pursues a step-by step logical, and
rigorous (careful) method to identify the problem, gather data, analyze them and draw valid conclusions
from them. Scientific research is not based on experience and intuitions. Scientific research also helps to
state their findings with accuracy and confidence. This helps various other organizations to apply those
solutions when they encounter similar problems. The terms scientific research applies to both applied
and basic research. Applies research may or may not be generalizable to other organization due to
differences in such factors as size, nature or work, characteristics of employees and structure of the
organization.
Purposiveness
Parsimony Rigor
Hallmarks of
Generalizability Scientific Research Testability
1) Purposiveness: The manager has started the research with definite aim or purpose. The purpose of the
research should be clearly mentioned in an understandable and unambiguous manner. Failure to mention
the purpose clearly will raise doubts in the minds of stakeholders of the research.
2) Rigor: Rigor means carefulness, scrupulousness (accuracy) and the degree of exactness in research
investigation. In order to make a meaningful and worthwhile contribution to the field of knowledge,
research must be carried out rigorously. Conducting a rigorous research requires a good theoretical
knowledge and a clearly laid out methodology. This will eliminate the bias; facilitate proper data collection
and analysis, which in turn would lead to sound and reliable research findings.
3) Testability: Research should be based on testable hypotheses developed after a careful study of the
problems involved. The scientific research should enable the testing of logically developed hypotheses to
see whether or not the data collected support the hypotheses developed. Several descriptive and inferential
statistical analysis will indicate whether the hypothesis is substantiated (verify) or not.
5|Page Created by Rabbani
4) Replicability: Research findings would command more faith and credence if the same results are
evolved on different set of data. The results of the test hypothesis should be supported again and again
when the same type of research is repeated in other similar circumstances. This will ensures the scientific
nature of the research conducted and more confidence could be placed in the research findings. It also
eliminates the doubt that the hypotheses are supported by chance and ensures that the findings reflect the
true state of affairs.
5) Precision and Confidence: Precision (accuracy) refers to the closeness of the findings to “reality” based
on a sample. It reflects the degree of accuracy or exactitude of the results on the basis of the sample to what
exactly is in the universe. The confidence interval in statistics is referred here as precision.
Confidence refers to the probability that our estimations are correct. It is also important that we can
confidently claim that 95% of the time our results would be true and there is only a 5% chance of our being
wrong. This is also known as confidence level. In research, it’s usually referred to as a significant level of
0.05 (p = 0.05)
If the precision and confidence levels of the research findings are higher, then the findings of the research
study would be more scientific and useful. Precision and confidence can be attained through appropriate
scientific sampling design.
6) Objectivity: Research finding should be factual, database and free from bias. The conclusion drawn
should be based on the facts of the findings derived from the actual data and not on the basis of subjective
or emotional values. Business organizations will suffer a greater extent of damage if a non-data-based or
misleading conclusion drawn from the research is implemented. Scientific approach ensures objectivity of
research. For instance, if we had a hypothesis that stated greater participation in decision making
will increase organizational commitment, and this was not supported by the results, it makes no sense.
7) Generalizability: Generalizability refers to the scope of applicability of the research findings in one
organizational setting to other settings. Obviously, the wider the range of applicability of the solutions
generated by research, the more useful the research is to users. For instance, if a researcher`s findings that
participation in decision making enhances organizational commitment are found to be true in a variety of
manufacturing, industrial, and service organizations, and not merely in the particular organization studied
by the researcher, then the generalizability of the findings to other organizational settings is enhanced. The
more generalizable the research, the greater its usefulness and value. However, not many research findings
can be generalized to all other settings, situations, or organizations.
8) Parsimony: Research needs to be conducted in a parsimonious i.e. simple and economical manner.
Simplicity in explaining the problems and generalizing solutions for the problems is preferred to a complex
research framework. Economy in research models can be achieved by way of considering less number of
variables leading to greater variance rather than considering more number of variables leading to less
variance. Clear understanding regarding the problem and the factors influencing the same will lead to
parsimony in research activities. The sound understanding can be achieved through structured
and unstructured interview with the concerned people and by undertaking a study of related literature in
the problem area.
1) Identify a Broad Problem Area: Identify a broad problem area is the first step of the hypothetico-
deductive method. In business research context, the manager is always sensitive to and aware of what is
happening in and around the workplace. Changes in attitudes, behaviors, communication patterns and
styles, and a score of other verbal and nonverbal cause can be readily picked up by managers who are
sensitive to the various nuances (shade). When there is indeed a problem in the situation, the manager may
not understand what exactly is happening, but can definitely sense that things are not what they should be.
For instance, a drop in sales, frequent production interruptions, incorrect accounting results, low morale
of employees in their work, customer switching, and the like, could easily attract the attention of the
manager and catalyze the research project.
2) Define the Problem Statement: Scientific research starts with a definite aim or purpose. Problem
statement describes the general objective of the research. Gathering initial information about the factors
that are possibly related to the problem will help us to narrow the broad problem area and to define the
problem statement.
3) Develop Hypothesis: In this step variables are examined as to their contribution or influence in
explaining why the problem occurs and it can be solved. A scientific hypothesis must meet two
requirements. First, hypothesis must be testable. A famous example of hypothesis that is testable is the
hypothesis that “GOD created the earth.” Second, hypothesis must also be falsifiable. It must be possible
to disprove the hypothesis. There is always a possibility that future research will show that it is false.
5) Data Collection: Data collection methods are an integral part of research design. There are several data
collection methods, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. The use of appropriate data collection
methods can greatly enhance the value of research. Data collection methods include interviews,
questionnaire, observation, and projective tests.
6) Data Analysis: Hypotheses are tested through appropriate statistics analysis according the nature and
requirements of data. Several descriptive (mean, median, mode, standard deviation) inferential (correlation,
regression) and others (ANNOVA) statistical tools can be applied for data analysis.
7) Interpretation of Data: In the last step, we must decide whether our hypotheses are supported or not
by interpreting the meaning of the result of the data analysis.
LITERATURE REVIEW
A literature review is a step-by-step process that involves the identification of published and unpublished
work from secondary sources on the topic of interest.
A good literature review provides the foundations for developing a comprehensive theoretical framework
from which hypothesis can be developed for testing.
7|Page Created by Rabbani
Data Sources: The quality of literature review depends on the cautions selection and reading of books,
academic and professional journals, reports conferencing proceeding, unpublished manuscripts, and the
like. Academic books and journals are the most important and useful sources of information.
However, other sources such as reports and even newspapers may also be valuable because they can provide
you with specific, real world information about markets, industries or companies.
Books
Unpublished Manuscripts Theses
1) Books: Textbooks are useful sources of theory in a specific area. An advantage of textbooks is that they
can cover a broad range of topic. Textbooks offer good starting points from which to find more detailed
sources. A downward of textbooks is that they tend to be less up to date than other sources such as journals
reports and newspapers.
2) Theses: PhD theses is one of the most reliable and useful sources of data. PhD theses often contain a
useful and reliable review of the literature in a specific area. Theses offer good starting points and provide
useful findings and insights for a specific topic.
3) Reports: Government departments and corporation carryout a large amount of research. Their published
findings provide useful sources of specific market, industry or company information.
4) Journals: Bothe academic and professional journals are important sources of up-to-date information.
Article in academic journals have generally been pre-reviewed. This means that the articles have subject to
the scrutiny of experts in the same field before being accepted for publications. Review article are very
useful because they provide an overview of all important search in a specific area.
The names of some reliable journals include the followings:
▪ The Journal of Marketing
▪ Journal of Marketing Research
▪ African Journal of Marketing Management
▪ Africans Journals of Business Management
8|Page Created by Rabbani
5) Newspapers: Newspapers provide up-to-date information. They are useful source of specific market,
industry or company information. Note that opinions in newspapers are not always unbiased.
6) The Internet: The interned is one of the most useful sources of data. You can search for the details of
books, journals articles and conference proceedings as well as the specialized data such as company
publications and reports. The number of newspapers, magazines and journals that is available electronically
is growing rapidly. Search engines such as Google, AOL and Yahoo can help you to find relevant
information. For instance, Google Scholar can help you to identify academic literature such as research
papers, theses, books, abstracts and articles from academic publishers and universities.
7) Conference Proceedings: Conference proceedings can be useful in providing the latest research.
Conference proceedings are very up-to-date and valuable sources especially in a new and unique area of
research.
8) Unpublished Manuscripts: Unpublished manuscripts may define as any information source that is not
officially released by an individual, publishing house or other company. Examples of unpublished
manuscripts may include papers accepted for publications but still “in press”. Unpublished manuscripts are
often very up-to-date.
To assess the quality of the recent research, you should concentrate on the following questions:
o Is the variable appropriate?
o Is the sample size appropriate?
o Is there a theory that guides the research?
o Will the study make a contribution to the field?
o Are the research designs appropriate for the study?
o Are the measures of the variables valid and reliable?
o Has the author presented the limitations of the study?
o Do the conclusions result from the findings of the study?
o Do the conclusions give a clear answer to the main research questions?
o Has the author used the appropriate quantitative or qualitative techniques?
Furthermore, the quality of the journal that published an article can also be used as an indicator of the
quality of an article. Important questions in this respect are:
Is the journal peer-reviewed?
What is the impact factor of the journal?
Impact Factor: The impact factor of a journal can be viewed as the average number of citation in a year
given to those papers in the journal that were published during a given period. (Usually the two proceedings
years)
1) APA Style (2001): APA citation style refers to the rules and conventions established by the American
Psychological Association for documenting sources used in a research paper. APA provides a disciplinary
standard to facilitate clear communication and easy reference in the field.
Last Name, N. (Year Published). Article Title. Journal name, Volume number, Page Numbers.
Rabbani, N. (2013). The Effect of Demographic Factors on Impulsive Buying Behavior. Asian Journals of
Business Management Studies, Vol. 30, No. 3, pp. 31- 40.
Rabbani, N. (2013). The Effect of Demographic Factors on Impulsive Buying Behavior. Asian Journals of
Business Management Studies, 30 (3), 31- 40.
2) Chicago Manual of Style (2003) (SMS or SMOS): The Chicago Manual of Style is used in some social
science publications and most historical journals. It remains the basis for the style guide of the American
Anthropological Association.
Last Name, First Name. "Article Title." Journal Name Volume Number (Year Published): Page Numbers.
URL or DOI
Rabbani, Naveed. “The Effect of Demographic Factors on Impulsive Buying Behavior.” Asian Journals
of Business Management Studies Vol. 30 No. 3 (2013): pp. 31- 40.
3) Turabian’s Style (2007: The journal article example of Turabian’s style is given below.
Last Name, First Name. "Article Title." Journal Name Volume Number (Year Published): Page Numbers.
Rabbani, Naveed. “The Effect of Demographic Factors on Impulsive Buying Behavior.” Asian Journals of
Business Management Studies Vol. 30 No. 3 (2013): pp. 31- 40.
4) MLA Style: The Modern Language Association (MLA) establishes values for acknowledging sources
used in a research paper. The journal article example of MLA style is given below.
Last Name, First Name. "Article Title." Journal Name Volume Number (Year Published): Page Numbers.
Medium.
Rabbani, Naveed. “The Effect of Demographic Factors on Impulsive Buying Behavior.” Asian Journals
of Business Management Studies Vol. 30 No. 3 (2013): pp. 31- 40. Print
PROBLEM STATEMENT
The problem statement introduces the key problem that is addressed in the research project. After the
interviews and the literature review, the researcher is in position to narrow down the problem from its
original broad base and define the issue of concern more clearly.
Problem Statement: A problem statement is a clear, precise (accurate) and succinct (brief) statement of
the specific issue that a researcher wishes to investigate. There are three key criteria to assess the quality
of the problem statement.
-- It should be relevant.
-- It should be feasible.
-- It should be interesting.
9) What are the specific factors to be considered in creating a data warehouse for a manufacturing
company?
10) Does consumer demographic factors influence the purchase of grocery item in the context of impulsive
buying behavior?
RESEARCH PROPOSAL
11 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
The research proposal is a written statement of the research design. It always includes an explanation of
the purpose of the study and detailed, systematic outline of a particular research methodology.
Developing a good Research proposal: Quality writing is critical in all good proposals. It should be clear,
concise, and free of jargon. There should be no spelling or grammatical errors, and the proposal should be
easy to read. Sloppy proposals and proposals laden with jargon do not provide a positive image. Proposals
that are well-written and attractive are a pleasure to read, and they make a good impression with reviewers.
The plan should be easy to read, complete and accurate. There should be no misspellings, improper
grammar, or mistakes in data.
Title Page
Bibliography Abstract
Budget Table of
Elements of Research Contents
Proposal
Time Frame Introduction
Literature
Research Design
Review
.
1) Title Page: On the title page, state your topic of interest and personal data, such as name, supervisor
name, roll number, university name etc. Title should be accurate, descriptive and comprehensive, clearly
indicating your research area.
2) Abstract: Abstract is the brief summary of the proposal. The abstract allows a busy executive to
understand quickly the essentials of a proposal without having to read the details. The abstract must be
written in single paragraph. This section must start with two or three sentences about the importance of the
study. It should be briefly explain the essential components of proposal such as purpose, methodology,
findings, limitations and key terms.
3) Table of Contents: A list of the parts of a proposal organized in the order in which the parts appear.
Very brief proposals with few sections ordinarily do not need a table of contents. Long and detailed
proposals require a table of contents. The table of contents should list all major parts of the research
proposal.
4) Introduction: Introduction generally includes the problem statement, purpose of the research, and
significance of the research. It should give enough background to enable an informed layman to place your
particular research problem in a context of common knowledge.
Problem Statement: A problem statement is a clear, precise and statement of the specific issue that a
researcher wishes to investigate. Under this heading, the main idea of research is discussed
comprehensively with all the possible and relevant issues added to it. This section is written in a very
critical manner.
Objective/Purpose of the Study: This section must be dedicated to identifying the main objectives of the
study through numbers or bullets. A study should have at least three to four objectives, set after reviewing
the previously carried out researches on a similar subject.
The objectives should be phrased in positive terms (e.g., to develop, to determine, to measure) rather than
broad generalities, such as, to investigate, to study.
12 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
Significance of the Study: This section make the proposed study different and unique from the previously
studies on a similar subject. In this regard, differences based on approaches, subject areas and methods can
be taken into consideration.
5) Literature Review: A literature review is a step-by-step process that involves the identification of
published and unpublished work from secondary sources on the topic of interest. This is the most critical
part of a proposal. The section critically represents the findings of previously carried out researches.
6) The Research Design: This is a very important part of research and should receive a lot of attention.
This component is designed to identify the exact road map of a research study. In simple words, a researcher
defines how he would conduct the proposed research study. The research design generally includes the
sampling design, data collection method and data analysis.
The Sampling Design: This section is designed to clearly discuss the sampling design (probability and
non-probability) will be used in research proposal. What is the appropriate sample size for this study?
Data Collection Method: Data collection methods are an integral part of research design. The use of
appropriate data collection methods can greatly enhance the value of research. In this section, the methods
of data collection (interviews, questionnaire, and observation) will be discussed in sophisticated manner.
Data Analysis: Under this heading, hypotheses are tested through appropriate statistics analysis according
the nature and requirements of data. Several descriptive statistics (mean, median, mode, standard deviation)
and inferential statistics (correlation, regression and SEM) can be applied for data analysis.
7) Time Frame-work: This section is designed to clearly discuss the consumption of time expected by
each and every action of the study. In this regard, a chapter-wise or action-wise schedule can be proposed
as per the convenience of the students and his/her supervisor. In addition, Gantt chart (a bar chart stating
the starting and finishing dates of proposed actions) can also be drawn for the sake of better representation
of project management within an applicable time frame.
8) Budget: Research work also needs money to be carried out. The estimation of the required budget is
essential to understand whether the expenses on the research project are affordable for the researcher or
not. The project budget should include clear and reasonable estimates of the costs of each element of the
project, and there should be enough supporting information to indicate how the estimates were developed.
Base salaries for all staff, standard charges for computer use, and allowable travel costs are a few examples
of useful background information.
9) Bibliography: A bibliography is a listing of work that is relevant to the main topic of research arranged
in alphabetical order of the last name of authors. Theses citations have the goals of crediting the authors
and enabling the readers to find the work cited. At least some of them should be recent publications,
indicating that you are aware of the current discourse in your area of research.
DEFINITIONS OF VARIABLES
Variable: A variable is anything that can take on differing or varying values. The values can differ at
various times for the same object or person, or at the same time for different objects or persons.
(Uma Sekaran)
Variable: A variable is anything that may assume different numerical values. (W. Zikmund)
Examples of variables are sales, commitment, buying behavior, production units, absenteeism, and
motivation.
Sales: One sales executives of the insurance company may sell 01 insurance policy per day, a second might
sell 02 per day, a third might sell 03 per day. In this case, the number of insurance policies sell has taken
on different values. So it’s variable.
Production Units: One worker in the manufacturing department may produce one unit per minute, a
second might produce two per minute, a third might produce five per minute. In this case, the number of
units produced has taken on different values. So it’s variable.
Absenteeism: Today, three members in sales department may be absent; tomorrow, six members may not
show up for work; the day after, there may be no one absent. In this case, the number of absent days has
taken on different values. So it’s variable.
TYPES OF VARIABLES
Four main types of variables are including the following:
TYPES OF VARIABLES
1) Dependent Variable (DV): A dependent variable is also known as a criterion variable, response
variable, measured variable, explained variable, outcome variable, experimental variable, and output
variable. It is called dependent because it "depends" on the independent variable. The dependent variable
is the variable of primary interest to the researcher. The researcher’s goal is to understand and explain its
variability.
For Instance: A manager is concerned that the sales of a new product, do not meet with his expectations.
The dependent variable (DV) here is sales. Since the sales of the product can vary-can be low, medium or
high. Sales are the main focus of interest to the manager. For Instance: Owner of the private organization
is concerned that the employees are not loyal to the organization and switch their loyalty to other
institutions. The dependent variable (DV) in this case would be organizational loyalty.
2) Independent Variable (IV): An independent variable is also known as a predictor variable, controlled
variable, manipulated variable, explanatory variable, and exposure variable. Independent variable is one
that influences the dependent variable in either a positive or negative way. When the independent variable
is present, the dependent variable is also present, and with each unit of increase in the independent variable,
there is an increase or decrease in the dependent variable also. For Instance: A production manager
strongly believes that adequate training will increase the production level of the workers.
Independent Variable Dependent Variable
Training Production
14 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
Diagram of the relationship between the independent variable (training) and dependent variable
(production)
3) Moderating Variable: The moderating variable is one that has a strong contingent (conditional) effect
on the independent and dependent variables relationship. The presence of a third variable (the moderating
variable) modifies the original relationship between the independent and the dependent variable.
In general terms, a moderator is a qualitative (e.g., gender, race, class) or quantitative (e.g., level of reward)
variable that affects the direction or strength of the relation between an independent and a dependent
variable. For Instance: A production manager strongly believes that four-day work-week will lead to
higher productivity, especially among younger workers.
Independent Variable (IV) Dependent Variable (DV)
Age
(Younger Worker)
Diagram of the relationship among the three variables: Independent variable (working hour), dependent
variable (productivity) and moderating variables (age).
4) Mediating Variable: A Mediating variable is also known as intervening variable. A mediating variable
is one that surfaces between the time the independent variables start operating to influence the dependent
variables and the time their impact is felt on it. The mediating variables surfaces as a function of
independent variable operating in any situations and help to conceptualize and explain the influence of the
independent variables on the dependent variables. For instance: The management of a bank wishes to
study the effect of promotion on savings. They predicting that promotion campaign will increase saving
activity, especially when free prizes are offered. The results come from enhancing the motivation to save.
Independent Variable Mediating Variable Dependent Variable
Moderating Variable
(MV)
Free Prizes
Diagram of the relationship among the four variables: IV (Promotion Campaign), DV (Saving Activity),
mediating variable (motivation to save), and moderating variables (Free Prizes).
RESEARCH HYPOTHESIS
Research hypotheses are the specific testable predictions made about the independent and dependent
variables in the study. Usually the literature review has given background material that justifies the
15 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
particular hypotheses that are to be tested. Hypotheses are described in terms of the particular independent
and dependent variables that are going to be used in the study.
Hypothesis is an unproven proposition or suppositions that tentatively explain certain facts or phenomena.
(W.G. Zikmund)
Hypothesis is a tentative statement about the relationship between two or more variables. A hypothesis is
a specific, testable prediction about what you expect to happen in your study.
The Role of Hypothesis: in research, a hypothesis serves several important functions. It guides the
direction of the study.
1) If-then Statements: These hypotheses can be set either as propositions or in the form of if-then
statements.
The two formats can be seen in the following examples.
o Employees who are more healthy will take sick leave less frequently.
o If employees are more healthy, then they will take sick leave less frequently.
2) Directional Hypotheses: Directional hypothesis predicts the nature of the effect of the independent
variable on the dependent variable. These hypotheses can be stating the relationship between two variables
or comparing two groups, terms such as positive, negative, more than, less than, and like are used. These
hypotheses are directional because the direction of the relationship between the variables
(positive/negative, less than/more than) is indicated.
3) Non-directional Hypotheses: Non-directional hypothesis predicts that the independent variable will
have an effect on the dependent variable, but the direction of the effect is not specified. Non-directional
hypotheses are those that do assume a relationship or difference, but offer no indication of direction of
these relationships or differences. It may be conjectured that there would be a significant relationship
between two variables. We may not be able to say whether the relationship would be positive or negative.
The two formats can be seen in the following examples.
o There is a relationship between compensation and job satisfaction.
o There is a difference between the satisfaction level of male and female.
Null Hypotheses: The null hypothesis (Ho) is used for testing. It is a statement that no difference exists
between the parameter and the statistic being compared to it. The null hypothesis in respect of group
differences stated in the example women is more motivated than men would be:
16 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
Ho: uM = uW OR Ho: uM – uW = 0
The Alternate Hypothesis: The alternate hypothesis (H1) which is the opposite of the null, is a statement
expressing a relationship between two variables or indicating differences between groups. The alternate
hypothesis in respect of group differences stated in the example women is more motivated than men would
be: HA: uM < uW OR HA: uW > uM = 0
Null hypothesis states that there is no relationship between the two variables being studied (one variable
does not affect the other). It states results are due to chance and are not significant in terms of supporting
the idea being investigated.
Alternative hypothesis states that there is a relationship between the two variables being studied (one
variable has an effect on the other). It states that results are not due to chance and that they are significant
in terms of supporting the theory being investigated.
5. A production manager finds that off-the-job classroom training has a great impact on the productivity
of the employees. However, he also observes that employees over 60 years of age do not seem to drive
many benefits and do not improve with such training.
6. A marketing manager finds the intensity of e-business adoption is positively associated with sales
performance. What’s more, when market uncertainty (the rate of change in the compositions of
customers and their preference) is high, this positive effect is strengthened.
7. Failure to follow accounting principles causes immense (huge) confusion, which in turn creates a
number of problems for the organization. Those with vast experience in bookkeeping are able to avert
17 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
the problems by taking timely corrective actions. List and label the variables in this situation, explain
the relationship among the variables and illustrate these by means of diagrams.
8. The manager observes that the morale of employees in company is low. He thinks that if working
conditions are improved, pay scales raised, and vacation benefits made attractive, the morale will be
boosted. He doubts, however, if an increase in pay scale would raise the morale of all employees. His
conjectures (guess) is that those that have supplemental incomes will just not be “turned on” by higher
pay, and only those without side incomes will be happy with increased pay with a resultant boost in
morale. List and label the variables in this situation, explain the relationship among the variables and
illustrate these by means of diagrams.
Descriptive Study: Descriptive study is more quantitative in nature. The objective of descriptive study is
to describe. Descriptive studies are often designed to collect data that describes the characteristics of
persons, events or situations. In this study the researcher exactly knows what has to be studied and where
to look for the solution. Secondary data and literature review are available in this study.
For Example: A bank manager wants to have a profile of the individual who have loans payment
outstanding for 6 months and more. The profile will include details of their average age, earning, nature of
occupation, full-time/part-time employment status. This might help him to elicit further information or
decide right away on the types of individual who should be made ineligible for loans in future.
Causal Study: Causal studies also known as hypothesis testing. Causal studies are at the heart of the
scientific approach to research. In a causal study, the researcher is interested in delineating (define, explain)
one or more factors are causing the problem. This is undertaken to find out whether any relationship exists
between two variables - one being the cause and the other being the result.
For Example: A marketing manager wants to know if the sales of the company will increase if he increases
the advertising budget. Here, the manager would like to know the nature of the relationship that may be
established between advertising and sales by testing the hypothesis. “If advertising is increased, then sales
will also go up.”
Case Study: Case Study involve in depth, contextual (background) analysis of matters relating to similar
situations in the organizations. Case Studies that are qualitative in nature are useful in applying solutions
to current problems based on past problem-solving experiences. They are also useful in understanding
certain phenomena, and generating further theories for empirical testing.
Correlation Study: In a correlation study, the researcher is interested to explaining the important variable
associated with the problem.
For example: A correlation study question: “Are smoking and cancer related”?
“Are smoking, drinking and chewing tobacco associated with cancer”?
Non-contrived: In non-contrived settings, the organizational research can done in the natural environment
where work proceeds normally. Correlation studies are invariably (always) conducted in non-contrived
settings. Correlation studies done in organizations are called field studies.
merely taken the balance in various types of account and correlated them to the changes in interest rates.
Research here is done in a non-contrived setting with no interference with the normal work routine.
Field Experiment: (Non-contrived settings but with researcher interference to moderate extent)
In a field experiment, the researcher makes changes in the independent variable to see how it affects the
dependent variable, but otherwise you leave everything in its natural state.
For instance: The bank manager now want to determine the cause and effect relationship between the
interest rate and the inducement (incentives) it offers to clients to save and deposit money in the bank. He
selects four branches within a 60 miles radius for the experiment. For one week only, he advertises the
annual rate for new certificates of deposit received during that week in the following manners. The interest
rate will be 9% in one branch, 8% in another, and 10% in the third. In the fourth branch, the interest rate
remains unchanged at 5%. Within the week, he will be able to determine the effects, if any, of interest rates
on deposits mobilizations. This is a field experiment. Just interest rate is manipulated, and other all activities
occurring in the normal and natural work environment.
Individuals: If researcher focuses on how to raise the motivational levels of employees in general. Here
the unit of analysis is the individual. He will be looking at the data gathered from each individual and
treating each employee’s response as an individual data source.
Dyads: If the researcher is interested in studying two-person interactions, then the unit of would be the
Dyads. Analyses of husband-wife interaction in families and supervisor-subordinates relationship in the
workplace are the examples of dyads.
Groups: If the researcher is interested in studying group effectiveness, then the unit of analysis would be
the group.
Organizations: If the researcher is interested in studying the proportion of the workforce employed by the
healthcare, transportation, telecom, and manufacturing industries. Then the unit of analysis would be the
organizations.
Culture: If the researcher is interested in studying organizational traditions, norms and values, then the
unit of analysis would be the Culture.
commitment of the employees before and after a promotion. Here the time horizon of study is the
Longitudinal.
EXERCISE 01
For each situation, decide whether the research should be exploratory, descriptive or causal:
1) Estimating prices for Dell stock 2 year in the future
2) Identifying target market demographics for a shopping center
3) Leaning the extent (level, scope) of job satisfaction in a company
4) Investigating customer reactions to the unique idea of new product
5) Establishing the functional relationship between advertising and sales
6) Learning how many organizations are actively involved in the just-in-time production
EXERCISE 02
A foreman of Textile Company thinks that the low efficiency of the machine tool operators is directly
linked to the high level of heat and fumes emitted in the workplace. He would like to prove this to his
supervisor through a research study.
Critically think about the above scenario and respond to the following questions:
EXERCISE 03
A marketing department of the pharmaceutical company has a high turnover rate. Employees of this
department have a shorter average tenure than those of other departments in the company. Skilled and
experienced marketing staffs are leaving and the employee population contains a high percentage of novice
(trainee) staff. The company has no idea what is going on and wants to know more about what is
happening.
Critically think about the above scenario and respond to the following questions:
WHAT IS MEASUREMENT?
In everyday usage, measurement occurs when an established yardstick is used to verify the height, weight,
or another feature of a physical object. How well you like a song, a painting, or the personality of a friend
is also a measurement.
In a dictionary sense, to measure is to discover the extent, dimension, quantity, or capacity of something,
especially by comparison with a standard. We measure casually in daily life, but in research, the
requirements are rigorous.
Concepts used in research may be classified as objects or as properties. Objects include the things of
ordinary experience, such as tables, people, books, and automobiles. Properties, on the other hand, are the
characteristics of the objects. A person’s physical properties may be stated in terms of weight and height.
Psychological properties include attitudes and intelligence. Social properties include leadership ability,
class affiliation, or status. These and many other properties of an individual can be measured in a research
study.
DEFINITIONS OF MEASUREMENT:
Measurement is the assignment of numbers or other symbols to characteristics or attributes of objects
according to the pre-specified set of rules. (Uma Sekaran)
Measurement is specific process used to discover the extent, dimension, quantity, or capacity of something
(objects or properties), especially by comparison with a standard. (Rabbani)
SCALES
A scale is a tool or mechanism by which individuals are distinguished as to how they differ from one
another on the variables of interest to our study. (Uma Sekaran)
1) Nominal Scale: Nominal scale is one that allows the researcher to assign subjects to certain categories
or groups. Nominal scale is always used for obtaining personal data such as gender, age, education, income,
occupation or department in which one work.
Understand the nominal scale with the help of following examples.
23 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
2) Ordinal Scale: Ordinal scale not only categories, it also rank-orders the categories in some meaningful
way. Ordinal scale is used to rank the preference or usage of various individuals, objects or events. The
preference would be ranked and numbered 1, 2, 3 and so on.
Rank the following personal computer with respect to their usage in your college. Assign the number 1 to
the most used system, 2 to the next most used, and so on. If a particular system is not used in your college,
put a 0 next to it.
------ HP ------ Dell
------ IBM ------ Sony
------ Apple ------ Compaq
3) Interval Scale: Interval scale not only ranks, but also provides information on the magnitude (level) of
the difference in the variables. It measure the distance between any two points on the scale. Interval scale
is used when responses to various items can be measured on three points, five-point or seven points scale.
Understand the interval scale with the help of following example.
INTERVAL SCALE
Please indicate your response to each of the following items by circling the number that best describe your feelings.
1 = Strongly Disagree, 2 = Disagree, 3 = Neither agree nor disagree, 4 = Agree, 5 = Strongly Agree
4) Ratio Scale: A ratio scale has all the properties of nominal, ordinal, and interval scale. The ratio scale
not only measures the magnitude of the differences between points on the scale but also taps the proportions
in the differences.
RATING SCALE
Rating scales have several response categories and are used to elicit (obtain) responses with regards to the
object, events or person studied.
Dichotomous
Consensus Scale Scale Category Scale
Semantic Differential
Graphic Rating Scale
Scale
RATING SCALES
Numerical Scale
Staple Scale
Constant Sum Rating
Scale Likert Scale Itemized Rating Scale
3) Semantic Differential Scale: (Semantic differential scale is the part of interval scale)
Semantic differential is a type of a rating scale designed to measure the meaning of objects, events, and
concepts. This is a seven point scale and the end points of the scale are associated with bipolar labels.
Bipolar means two opposite streams. Note: Although a 7-point scale is common, but acceptable fewer
choices, 5 or even 3. Understand the semantic differential scale with the help of following examples.
Rate the College on the following dimensions by putting a mark on one of the 7 dimension.
Quit ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ Noisy
Dirty ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ Clean
Good ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ Bad
Cheap ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ Expensive
Beautiful ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ ------ Ugly
NUMERICAL SCALE
Rate the job on the following dimensions by putting a mark on one of the 7 dimension
ITEMIZED SCALE
Respond to each item using the scale below, and indicate your response no. on the line by each item.
1 = Very Unlikely, 2 = Unlikely, 3 = Neither Unlikely nor Likely, 4 = Likely, 5 = Very Likely
LIKERT SCALE
Please indicate your response to each of the following items by circling the number that best
describe your feelings.
1 = Strongly Disagree, 2 = Disagree, 3 = Neither agree nor disagree, 4 = Agree, 5 = Strongly Agree
7) Fixed or Constant Sum Scale: (Fixed or constant sum scale is the part of ordinal scale) The respondents
are asked to distribute a given number of points across various items. Understand the fixed or constant
sum scale with the help of following example.
STAPEL SCALE
State how you would rate your manager’s ability with respect to each of the characteristics
mentioned below, by circling the appropriate number.
+3 +3 +3
+2 +2 +2
+1 +1 +1
Communication Skill Interpersonal Skill Technical Skill
-1 -1 -1
-2 -2 -2
-3 -3 -3
27 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
1) Paired Comparison: Suppose, rater evaluates the six employees. The names of these employees are
listed on the left side of a sheet of paper. The evaluator then compares the first employee with the second
employee on a chosen performance criterion, such as quality of work, If evaluator believes that the first
employees has produced more work than the second employee, a check mark is placed by the first employee
name. The rater then compares the first employee to the third fourth, fifth, and sixth employee on the same
performance criterion, placing a check mark by the name of the employees who produced the most work
in each paired comparison. The process is repeated until each employee has been compared to every other
employee. The employee with the most check marks is considered to be best performer.
2) Forced Choice: The forced choice enables respondents to rank objects relative to one another’s, among
the alternatives provided. This is easier for the respondents, particularly if the number of choices to be
ranked is limited in number. Understand the forced choice method with the help of following examples.
FORCED CHOICE
Rank the following newspapers that you would like to subscribe to in the order of preference. Assign
the number 1 to the most preferred choice, and 5 to the least preferred.
Daily Jang ----------
Daily Express ----------
Daily Pakistan ----------
Daily Khabrain ----------
Daily Nawa-i-Waqt ----------
3) Comparative Scale: The comparative scale provides a benchmark or a point of reference to assess
attitudes towards the current object, event, or situations under study. Understand the forced choice
method with the help of following examples.
COMPARATIVE SCALE
In a financial environment, compared to stocks, how useful is it to invest in bonds?
Please circle the appropriate response.
More Useful About the same Less useful
1 2 3 4 5
28 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
GOODNESS OF MEASURE
The use of better instruments will ensure more accuracy in results, which in turn, will enhance the
scientific quality of the research. Hence, in some way, we need to assess the “goodness” of the measures
developed. That is, we need to be reasonably sure that the instruments we use in our research do indeed
measure the variables they are supposed to, and that they measure them accurately.
Let us now examine how we can ensure that the measures developed are reasonably good. First an item
analysis of the responses to the questions tapping the variable is done, and then the reliability and validity
of the measures are established.
Goodness of Measure
Validity Reliability
Stability
Consistency
ITEM ANALYSIS
Item analysis is done to see if the items in the instrument belong there or not. Each item is examined for
its ability to discriminate between those subjects whose total scores are high, and those with low scores. In
item analysis, the means between the high-score group and the low-score group are tested to detect
significant differences through the t-values (t-test). The item with a high t-value are then included in the
instrument. Thereafter, tests for the reliability of the instrument are done and the validity of the measure is
established.
VALIDITY
Several types of validity test are used to test the goodness of measures. For the sake of clarity, we may
group validity tests under three broad headings: content, criterion-related validity and construct validity
1) Content Validity: Content validity ensures that the measure includes an adequate and representative set
of items that tap the concept.
Face Validity: Face validity refers to the subjective agreement among professionals that a scale logically
appears to reflect accurately what it purpose to measure. The contents of the scale appear to be adequate.
Clear, understandable questions such as “how many children do you have?” are generally agreed to have
face validity. (Some researcher don’t see fit to treat face validity as a valid component of content validity)
2) Criterion Validity: Criterion validity is established when the measure differentiates individuals on the
criterion it is expected to predict. This can be done by establishing concurrent or predictive validity
Concurrent Validity: Concurrent validity is established when the scale discriminates individuals who are
known to be different; that is, they should score differently on the instrument.
29 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
Predictive Validity: Predictive validity indicates the ability of a measuring instrument to differentiate
among individuals with reference to a future criterion. For instance, if an ability test administered to
employees at the time of recruitment is to differentiate individuals on the basis of their future job
performance, then those who score low on the test should be poor performers and those with high scores
good performers.
3) Construct Validity: Concurrent validity testifies to how well the results obtained from the use of the
measure fit the theories around which the test is designed. Construct validity may be classified as either
convergent validity and discriminant validity
Convergent Validity: Convergent validity is established when the scores obtained with two different
instruments measuring the same concepts are highly correlated.
Discriminant Validity: This validity is established when, based on theory, two variables are predicted to
be uncorrelated, and the scores obtained by measuring them are indeed empirically found to be so.
RELIABILITY
The reliability of a measure indicates the extent (degree, level) to which it is without bias (error free) and
ensures consistent measurement across time and across the various items in the instrument. In other word,
the reliability of a measure is an indication of the stability and consistency with which the instrument
measure the concept and helps to access the goodness of a measure. For instance, a tailor measuring fabric
with a tape measure obtains a true value of the fabric length. If the tailor takes repeated measures of the
fabric and each time comes up with the same length, it is assumed that the tape measure is reliable.
1) Stability: Stability refers to the ability of a measure to remain the same over time. Stability can be
measured through the test-retest reliability and parallel-form reliability tests.
Test-retest Reliability: Test-retest reliability obtained by repetition of the same scale or measure to the
same respondents at two separate times to test for stability. If the measure is stable over time, the test,
administrated under the same conditions each time, should obtain similar result. For instance, suppose a
researcher measure job satisfaction and finds that 65 %t of the population is satisfied with their job. If the
study is repeated a few weeks later under similar conditions and the researcher again find that 65 % of
the population is satisfied with their jobs. It means that the measure has test-retest reliability. The high
stability between the two measures at time 1 and time 2 indicate a high degree of reliability.
Parallel-form Reliability: Parallel-form reliability obtained when responses on two comparables sets of
measure tapping the same result. Both forms have similar items and the same response format, the only
changes being the wording and the order or sequences of the questions. If two such comparable forms are
highly correlated, we may be fairly certain that measure are reasonable reliable, with minimal error variance
caused by wording, ordering or sequences.
2) Consistency: Consistency can be measured through the interitem consistency reliability and split-half
reliability tests.
Interitem Consistency Reliability: The most popular test of the interitem consistency reliability is
Cronbach’s coefficient alpha (Cronbach’s alpha; Cronbach, 1946) which is used for multipoint-scaled
items and the Kuder-Richardson formulas (Kuder and Richardson, 1937) used for dichotomous items. The
higher the coefficients, the better the measuring instrument.
Split-half Reliability: Split-half reliability reflects the correlations between two halves (divide) of an
instrument. The technique of splitting halves is the most basic method for checking internal consistency
when a measure contains a large number of items. In this method, the researcher may take the result
obtained from one half of the scale items (e.g., odd-numbered items) and check them against the result
from the other half of the items (e.g., even-numbered items).
30 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
SOURCES OF DATA
A data source is simply the source of the data. The purpose of a data source is to gather all of the technical
information needed to access the data. Adequate test data are always preferred over predicted or estimated
data. The researcher can be obtained data from primary, secondary or both.
SECONDARY DATA
Secondary data were collected for another purpose and already exist somewhere. Secondary data includes
both internal and external data.
o Internal Secondary Data: Internal secondary data consists of such information as data generated in-
house for earlier studies as well as customer files, such as past customer transactions, letters from
customers, sales call reports and data collected via warranty cards.
o External Secondary Data: External secondary data consists of any data collected by an outside
organization. The quality of external secondary data depends on the selection of appropriate sources.
The major sources of external secondary data are books, academic and professional journals,
government or media reports, conferencing proceeding, unpublished manuscripts, and the like.
Company annual reports and government publication and are the most important and useful sources of
information.
Advantages of Secondary Data: Some key advantages of secondary data include the following:
- It may provide a solution to the research problems.
- It may provide ideas for the method to be used in research.
- It can be obtained more cheaply and quickly than primary data.
Limitations of Secondary Data: Some limitations of secondary data include the following:
- It may be support a limited point of view.
- It may not be fully focused on your needs.
- It won´t include the opinions of your prospects and clients
- It may not be accurate because of errors in gathering or analyzing the data.
PRIMARY DATA
When the needed data don’t exist, inaccurate, incomplete or unreliable, the researcher will have to collect
primary data. Primary data freshly gathered and collected by conducting individual’s interview, focus
groups, panels, and unobtrusive methods.
Primary data can be expensive and time consuming to collect but primary research is often the only way to
successfully answer specific research questions. Researchers usually start their investigation by examining
secondary data to see whether the problem can be partly or wholly solved without collecting costly primary
data.
Advantages of Primary Data: Some key advantages of primary data include the following:
- It is specific to your needs
- It gives you an edge over competitors due to fresh information.
- You can directly get opinions from your prospects and clients.
- It gives you accurate and reliable information than secondary data.
Limitations of Secondary Data: Some important limitations of primary data include the following:
- It can be very expensive
- It can require expertise to analyze
- It can be very time consuming to gather and analyze.
The four main primary sources of data are individuals, focus groups, panels, and unobtrusive methods.
PRIMARY SOURCE OF DATA
1) Individual: The individual interview is conducted one-on-one using open-ended questions that require
the respondents to generate their answers. The focus of individual interviewing is not to have people answer
lots of yes/no questions but to get them to open up and discuss their attitude and opinions. This technique
requires a great deal of skill on the interview in term of both conducting the interview and interpreting the
results.
2) Focus Groups: A focus group is a gathering of 06 to 10 people who are invited to spend a few hours
with a skilled moderator to discuss certain topic such as new product ideas, reactions to certain consumer
problems, and so forth. The moderator /interviewer generally have a list of specific points to discussed, and
these are used to prompt discussion. Participants are normally paid a small sum of attending or may be
voluntary. The meeting is typically held in pleasant surrounding and refreshments are served.
In sum, focus groups are used for:
o Exploratory studies
o Conducting sample surveys
o Making generalization based on the information gathered by them
Video-conferencing: If regional variations in response are expected, several focus groups could be formed
including trained moderators at different locations. This process easily facilitate through video-
conferencing.
3) Panels: Focus groups meet for a one-time group session; panels (of members) meet more than once.
In cases where the effects of certain changes are to be studied over a period of time, panel studies are very
useful. Individuals are randomly chosen to serve as panel members for a research study. For
instance, if the effects of a proposed advertisement for a certain brand of soft drinks are to be assessed
quickly, the panel members can be exposed to the advertisement and their intentions of purchasing the
brand assessed.
There are two types of panels: Static Panels and Dynamic Panels
▪ Static Panels: In static panels, the same panel members serve over extended periods of time. The main
advantage of the static panel is that it offers a good and sensitive measurement of the changes that take
place between two points in time-a much better alternative than using two different groups at two
different times.
▪ Dynamic Panels: In dynamic panels, the panels members change from time to time as various phases
of the study are in progress.
Data collection methods are an integral part of research design. There are several data collection methods,
each with its own advantages and disadvantages. The use of appropriate data collection methods can greatly
enhance the value of research. The choice of data collection method depends on the facilities available, the
degree of accuracy required, the expertise of the researcher, the time span of the study and other costs and
resources associated with and available for data gathering. Data collection methods include interviews,
questionnaire, observation, and projective tests.
DATA COLLECTION METHODS
01) Interviews: One method of collecting data is to interview respondents to obtain information on the
issue of interest. Interviewing is useful data collection method, especially during the exploratory stages of
research. Where a large number of interviews are conducted with a number of different interviewers, it is
important to train the interviewers with care in order to minimize interviewer bias manifested in such ways
as voice inflections, differences in wording, and interoperation. Good training decrease interviewer bias.
Interviews may be structured, unstructured or semi-structured and conducted face to face, by telephone or
online.
- Structured Interview: Structured interview also known as pattern interview. An interview conducted
according to a predetermined outline. A series of questions develop before interview and ask the same
questions from every candidate.
1) Face-to-face Interviews: The face-to-face interview also called an in-person interview. Face to face
interviewing remains the most frequently used business research. Interviews can be conducted in the
respondent’s home or workplace, in halls or even simply on the street. Face-to-face interviewing can offer
advantages over telephone or online interview because respondents are more likely to give their undivided
attention when an interviewer is present. A good interviewer will help build rapport with the respondent
and explaining the questions in his own words in case of any confusion.
2) Telephone Interviews: Telephone interview are best suited when information from a large number of
respondent spread over a wide geographic area is to be obtained quickly. Many market surveys are
conducted through structured telephone interviews.
3) Computer-assisted Interviews (CAI): With CAI, questions are flashed onto the computer screen and
interviewers can enter the answers of the respondents directly into the computer. CAI software also
prevents interviewers from asking the wrong questions or in the wrong sequences since the questions are
automatically flashed to respondent in an ordered sequence. For instance: Kaun Banega Crorepati quiz
show by Amitabh Bachan is the example of CAI interviews.
There are two types of computer-assisted interview (CAI): Computer-assisted telephone interview (CATI)
and computer-assisted personal interviews (CAPI).
Computer-assisted Telephone Interview (CATI): With CATI, information can be obtained from people
all over the world since the personal computer (PC) is networked into the telephone system. The PC monitor
prompts the questions with the help of software and the respondent provides the answer. The computer
selects the telephone number, dials and places the responses in the file. The data are analyzed later.
Computer-assisted Personal Interviews (CAPI): CAPI involves big investment in hardware and
software. CAPI has an advantage in that it can be self-administered. Respondent can use their own
computers to run the program by themselves once they receive the software and enter their response.
However, not everyone is comfortable using a personal computer and some may not have access to one.
TYPES OF QUESTIONNAIRE
1) Personally Administered Questionnaires: When the survey is confined to a local area, and the
organization is willing and able to assemble groups of employees to respond the questionnaires at the
workplace, a good way to collect data is to personally administered questionnaires. The main advantage of
this is that the researcher can collect all the completed responses within a short period of time.
Any doubts that the respondents might have on any questions can be clarified on the spot. The researcher
is also afforded the opportunity to introduce the research topic and motivate the respondents to offer their
frank answer.
2) Mail Questionnaires: A mail questionnaire sent to respondents through the mail. Mail questionnaire
requires simple and clearly worded questions. The main advantage of mail questionnaire is that a wide
geographical area can be covered in the survey. They are mailed to respondent, who can complete them
at their convenience, in their home, and at their own pace. However, the return rates of mail questionnaire
are typically low. A 30% rate is considered acceptable.
However, some effective techniques can be employed for improving the rates of response to mail
questionnaires. Sending follow-up letters, enclosing small monetary amounts as incentives with the
questionnaire, and keeping the questionnaires brief all help. The main disadvantages of questionnaire are
that any doubts the respondents might have cannot be clarified.
o literacy is must
o Nonverbal cues can’t be read.
o Response rate is almost always low.
o Follow-up procedures are necessary.
o Mail questionnaire can’t clarify the questions, and clear doubts.
03) Observation: Much of what we know comes from observation. In our daily life’s, we notice co-
workers reactions, the smell of perfume, the taste of food and much more.
“Observation is the systematic process of recording the behavioral pattern of people events or objects”.
Business researches can observe people, objects or events by assigning the task to human observers or by
using machines designed for specific observations tasks. For example, researcher may visit different
supermarkets and observe customers buying behavior toward purchasing their products. A Bank might
evaluate possible new branch location by checking traffic pattern, neighborhood conditions and the
locations of competing branches.
The researcher can play one of two roles while gathering observational data: participant observer and non-
participants observers.
-- Participant Observer: The researcher may act as a participant’s observer by collecting the necessary
data with becoming an integral part of the organizational system. The researchers enter the organizations
and become a part of the work team. For examples, if a researcher wants to study group dynamic in work
organizations, then he may join the organizations as an employee and observe the dynamics in groups.
-- Non-participants Observers: The researcher may act as a non-participants observer by collecting the
necessary data without becoming an integral part of the organizational system.
For example, the researcher might sit in the corner of an office and watch and record how the managers
spend their time in workplace. Observation of all the activities of managers, over a period of several days
will allow the researchers to make some generalization on how managers typically spend their time. By
merely observing the activities, recording them systematically and tabulating them, the researcher is able
to come up with some findings.
36 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
Structured Observational Studies: Structured observation works according to a plan and involves
specific information of the units that are to be observed. The operations that are to be observed and the
various features that are to be noted or recorded are decided well in advance.
Mechanical Observation: Mechanical observation uses a mechanical or electronic devise that provide
data by recording the events of interest as they occur without a researcher being physically present. In
mechanical observation, videotape, cameras, traffic counters and other machine record the events of
interest.
Understand the concept of mechanical observation with the help of following examples:
o Motor way police used speed-gun to determine the over speed of vehicle.
o Supermarket use barcode scanners to determine the brand sales information.
o Films & electronic recording devices such as video cameras can be used to record data.
o Org. uses the CCT Cameras to watch the activities of their employees during work place.
o A.C Nielsen’s system used for estimating national television audience. Nielson uses a sophisticated
monitoring device called a People Meter to obtain rating for television programs.
4) Projective Techniques: Projective techniques are indirect and unstructured methods of investigation
that give respondents the opportunity to recognize their feelings by projecting them into objects or other
people. Here are some examples of the projective techniques used in business research.
PROJECTIVE TECHNIQUES
1) Inkblot Test: Inkblots tests use colored inkblots that are interpreted by the respondents, who explain
what they see in the various pattern and colors. During the test you will be shown a series of ink blot
images. Look at each ink blot for a moment, then select the appropriate response(s). At the end of the test
your responses will be analyzed and scored, and a summary of the test evaluation will be presented to you.
37 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
2) Expression Techniques: In this method, the respondents are asked to express the feeling or attitude
about an organization or a brand. The answer of the respondent will reflect their state of mind regarding
specific products
3) Word Association Test: An individual is given a clue or hint and asked to respond to the first thing that
comes to mind. There can be many interpretations of the same thing. For instance, (“What come to mind
when I say work”. One respondent might say work is a lot of fun,” whereas another might say “work is
boring” these response may provide some insight into individual feelings and attitude towards work.
4) Sentence Completion Test: In this test, the respondents are asked to complete an incomplete sentence
or story. For instance, (“The Coke makes people feel ---------------.”) One respondent might say amazing”
whereas another might say “just coo” these response may provide some insight into individual feelings and
attitude towards Coke.
5) Thematic Apperception Tests (TAT): The TAT was developed by the American psychologist Henry
A. Murray and Christiana D. Morgan during the 1930s.
TAT call for the respondent to weave a story around the picture that is shown. Several need patterns and
personality characteristics of respondents can be traced through these tests.
Purpose of
Questions
Personal Language of Questionnaire
Information
GUIDELINE FOR
QUESTIONNAIRE
Sequence of Types of
Questions Questions
Length of
Questions
1) Contents and Purpose of the Questions: The nature of the variable tapped, subjective feelings or
objective facts will determine what kinds of questions are asked. Contents of the questions should be match
according the areas of interest. If contents of the questions don’t reflect the areas of interest, then the entire
process of research is just time wasting.
2) Language and Wording of the Questionnaire: The language of the questionnaire should approximate
the level of understanding of the respondents. The choice of words will depends on their educational level,
the usage of terms in the culture of the respondent. It is essential to word the questions in a way that can be
understood by the respondent. If some questions are not understood by the respondent, the researcher will
obtain wrong answer to the questions. In this way the findings of the research don’t reflect the real picture.
3) Types and Forms of Questions: The type of question refers to whether the question is open-ended or
closed. The form of the question refers to whether it is positively or negatively worded.
Open-ended Question: Open-ended question allow respondent to answer them in their own choice.
An example of open-ended question is asking the responded to state five things that are interesting and
challenging in the job. Another example is asking what the respondents like about their work environment.
Close-ended Question: Close-ended question allow respondent to answer the questions among a set of
alternatives given by the researcher. All items in a questionnaire using a nominal, ordinal interval or ratio
scale are considered close-ended questions. An example of open-ended question is asking the responded
“do you like job”. Choice is YES or No. Respondent can chose yes or no options as per their choice.
Positive and Negatively Worded Questions: Instead of phrasing all questions positively, it is advisable
to include some negatively worded questions as well, so the tendency in respondents mechanically circle
the points toward one end of the scale is minimized. For example, if the respondent has circle 5 for a
38 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
positively worded question such as “I feel I have been able to complete a number of different task in my
job”. He can’t circle number 5 again to the negatively worded questions “I don’t feel I am very effective in
my job”
Ambiguous Questions: Some questions might be ambiguously worded and the responded may not be sure
what exactly they mean. For example, “to what extent would you say you are happy”. Respondent might
find it difficult to decide whether the question refers to their state of feelings in the workplace, or at home.
Because it is an organizational survey, a respondent might presume that the question related to the
workplace. Yet the researcher might have intended to inquire about individual experience in personal life.
The result is mixed bag of ambiguous responses that don’t accurately provide the correct answer to the
question.
Recall-dependent Questions: Some questions might require respondents to recall experience from the
past that are hazy in their memory. Answer to such questions might have bias. For example, if an employee
who has had 30 years service in the organizations is asked to state “when he first started working in a
particular department and for how long”. He may not be able to give the correct answers and may be way
off in his response. A better source for obtaining that information would be the personnel records.
Leading Questions: Questions should not be phrased in such a way that they lead the respondents to give
the responses that the researcher would like them to give. For example, “Do you think that in these days
of increasing costs of living, employees should be given good pay rises?” By asking leading questions, we
are signaling and pressuring respondents to say “yes”. Tagging the questions to rising living costs makes it
difficult for most respondents to say “no”.
Social Responsibility Questions: Questions should not be worded such that they elicit socially desirable
responses. For instance, a question “Do you think that older people should be laid off?” would be elicit a
response of “no”. Because society would frown on a person who said that elderly people should be fired
even if they are capable of performing their job satisfactorily. This question asked in this way “To
what extent do you think companies should continue to keep the elderly on their payroll?
Funneling Question: Asking general questions before specific questions in order to obtain unbiased
response. It is advisable to ask open-ended questions to get a broad idea and form some impression about
the situations. For instance, a question that could be asked would be: “What are some of your feelings
about working for this organization?”
Unbiased Questions: It is important to ask questions in a way that ensures the least bias in the responses.
For example, “Tell me how your experience your job” is better question than,” “Boys, the work do must
be really boring; let me hear how you experience it.” The latter question is biased.
4) Length of Questions: Simple short questions are preferable than long questions. As a rule of thumb, a
question or statement in the questionnaire should not exceed 20 words. (Horst, 1968; Oppenheim, 1986)
39 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
5) Sequence of Questions: The sequence of questions in the questionnaire should be start from easy
questions to those that progressively more difficult. This approach facilitates the easy and smooth progress
of the respondent through the items in the questionnaires.
6) Personal Information: Personal information elicits such information as age, educational level, marital
status, religion, profession and income. Unless absolutely necessary, it is best not to ask for the name of
respondent. Questions seeking personal information should appear at the beginning or at the end of the
questionnaires a matter of choice for a researcher. Some researchers ask for personal data at the end rather
than the beginning of the questionnaire, their reasons may be that by the time respondent reaches the end
of the questionnaire he or she have been convinced of the genuineness of the questions framed by the
researcher.
CHAPTER: 8 SAMPLING
SAMPLING
Sampling is a method of studying from a few selected items, instead of the entire big number of units. The
small selection is called sample. The large number of items of units of particular characteristic is called
population. Example: We check a sample of rice to see whether the rice well boiled or not. We check a
small sample of solution to decide how much a given solution is concentrated. Thus with the sample we
infer about a population.
3) Sampling Frame: Sampling frame also known as working population. The sampling frame is the list of
elements from which the sample may be drawn. For example, the payroll of an organization would serve
as the sampling frame if its members are to be studied. Likewise, the university database containing a listing
of all students, facility, administrators and supporting staff serve as sampling frame. A roster of class
students could be sampling frame for the study of student in a class. The telephone directory is also
frequently used as a sampling frame for some types of study.
4) Sample: A sample is a subset or some part of the large population. Acceptable precise results can usually
be obtained by questioning only a part of population.
5) Sampling: Sampling is the process of selecting sufficient number of elements from the population to
make conclusions about the whole population. Researches measure the thoughts and attitudes of thousands
or even millions of people by asking only a few hundred and provide accurate results.
40 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
6) Subject: A subject is single member of the sample, just as an element is a single member of the
population. The people who participate as part of sample are usually referred to as subject or respondent.
Understand the concept of population with the help of following examples.
▪ If 100 employees from the total population of 1000 employees form the sample for the study, then each
employee in the sample is a subject.
▪ If a sample of 50 machines from a total of 500 machines is to be inspected, then every one of the 50
machine is a subject.
▪ If a sample of 50 hospitals from a total of 500 hospitals is to be studied, then each hospital in the sample
is a subject.
7) Census: An investigation of all the individual elements making up a population. If you were to ask
questions of every person in the research population, you would be conducting a census. Some examples
of census are agriculture census, live stock census, population study. However, researches rarely use the
entire population due to quite expensive and time consuming.
Parameters: The characters of the population such as μ (Population Mean) σ (Population Standard
Deviation), and σ2 (Population Variance) are referred to as its parameters.
NORMALITY OF DISTRIBUTIONS
Attributes or characteristics of the population are generally normally distributed. When the properties of
the population are not over-represented or under-represented in the sample, we will have a representative
sample. When a sample consists of elements in the population that have extremely high values on the
variable we are studying, the sample mean will be far higher than the population mean and vice versa.
SAMPLING PROCESS
The major steps in sampling process include the following:
Define the Population
SAMPLING DESIGN
There are two major types of sampling design: Probability and Non-probability Sampling.
SAMPLING DESIGN
41 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
Probability Sample: A sampling techniques in which every member of the population has equal chances
of being selection. The important types of probability sampling are simple random sampling, systematic
sampling, stratified random sampling, cluster sampling, area sampling and double sampling.
Non-probability Sample: A sampling techniques in which members of the population don’t have equal
chances of being selection because sample are selected on the bases of convenient or judgment.
The important types of non-probability sampling are convenient sampling, judgment sampling, quota
sampling and snowball sampling.
1) Unrestricted or Simple Random Sampling: In the simple random sampling, every element in the
population has a known and equal chance of being selected as a subject. For instance, Let us say there are
1000 elements in the population, and we need a sample of 100. Suppose we were to drop pieces of paper
in a basket, each bearing the name of one of the element, and draw 100 of those from the basket with our
eyes closed. We know that the first piece drawn will have a 1/1000 chance of being drawn, the next 1/999
chance of being drawn, and so on. In this case, each single element in the basket has a known and equal
chance of being selected as a subject.
Restricted or Complex probability Sampling: The five most common complex probability sampling
designs are systematic sampling, stratified random sampling, cluster sampling, area sampling, and double
sampling
2) Systematic Sampling: The systematic sampling design involves drawing every nth element in the
population staring with a randomly chosen element between 1 and n. For instance: Suppose a researcher
wants to take a sample of 35 households from a total population of 260 houses in a particular locality.
First, nth is calculated as the population size (260) divided by the sample size (35). (260/35=7.4 If n is not
whole number, then round down) With systematic sampling, every 7 th house from the list would be selected.
Let us say that the random number was 7, then houses numbered 07, 14, 21, 28 and so on, would be sampled
until the 35 houses were selected.
3) Stratified Random Sampling: Stratified random sampling as its name implies, involve a process of
stratification or segregation followed by random selection of subjects from each stratum. The population is
first divided into mutually exclusive groups that are relevant, appropriate and meaningful in the context of
the study. For example, if the CEO of a company is concerned about low motivational level among the
employees, it makes sense to stratify the population of organizational members according to their job level.
Proportionate and Disproportionate Stratified Random Sampling: Once the population has been
stratified in some meaningful way, a sample of members from each stratum can be drawn either a simple
random sampling or a systematic sampling procedure. The subject drawn from each stratum can be either
proportionate or disproportionate to the number of elements in the stratum. For instance, if an organization
employs 10 top managers, 30 middle managers, 50 first line managers, 100 supervisors, 50 clerks and 20
42 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
secretaries and stratified sample of about 140 people is needed for some specific survey. The researcher
might decide to include the sample 20% of members from each stratum. This would means that 2 from the
top, six from the middle, and 10 from the first line management. In addition, 20 supervisor, 100 clerks and
4 secretaries would be represented in the sample. This type of sampling is called a proportionate stratified
random sampling.
If researcher concerned that information from only 2 members at the top and 6 from the middle levels
would not truly reflect the sample size, then a researcher might decide to use a disproportionate stratified
random sampling. The number of subjects from each stratum would now be altered, while keeping the
sample size unchanged. Disproportionate stratified random sampling are made either when some stratum
are too small or too large
Proportionate Disproportionate
Job Level Number of Elements
Sampling (20%) Sampling
Top Mangers 10 2 7
Middle Managers 30 6 15
First-line Managers 50 10 20
Supervisors 100 20 30
Secretaries 20 4 10
4) Cluster Sampling: A population is divided into cluster using naturally occurring geographic or other
boundaries. Then, clusters are randomly selected and a sample is collected by randomly selecting from
each cluster.
For example: Suppose you divided the state into 12 primary regions. Then selected at random four regions
2, 7, 4 and 12 and concentrated your efforts in these primary units. You could take a random sample of the
residents in each of these regions and interview them. (Note that this is a combination of cluster sampling
and simple random sampling). A specific type of cluster sampling is area sampling
Area Sampling: Area sampling is less expensive than most other probability sampling design. It is not
dependent on a sampling frame. For instance: A city map showing the blocks of the city is adequate
information to allow a researcher to take a sample of the blocks and obtain information from the residents
therein.
5) Double Sampling: A sampling design where initially a sample is used in a study to collect some
preliminary information of interest and later a subsample of this primary sample is used to examine the
matter in more details. For instance, a structure interview might indicate that a subgroup of the respondents
has more insight into the problems of the organization. Theses respondents might be interviewed again and
asked additional questions. This research adopts a double sampling procedure.
Non-probability Sample: A sampling techniques in which members of the population don’t have equal
chances of being selection because sample are selected on the bases of convenient or judgment. The
important types of non-probability sampling are convenient sampling, judgment sampling, quota sampling
and snowball sampling.
1) Convenience Sampling: Convenience sampling also called haphazard or accidental sampling.
Convenience sampling refers to the collection of information from members of the population who are
conveniently available to provide it. For example, it may be convenient and economical to sample
employees in companies in a nearby area.
43 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
2) Snowball Sampling: Snowball sampling also known as chain referral sampling. Snowball sampling
refers to a variety of procedures in which initial respondent are selected by probability methods and
additional respondents are then obtained from information provided by initial respondents. This technique
is used to locate members of rare population by referrals. For example, a researcher is studying
environmental engineers but can find only two. He asks these engineers if they know any more. They give
him several further referrals, which in turn provide additional contacts. In this way, he manages to contact
sufficient engineers.
3) Purposive Sampling: The sampling here is confined to specific types of people who can provide the
desired information, either because they are the only ones who have it, or conform to some criteria set by
the researcher. This type of sampling called purposive sampling and this have two major types of Judgment
and quota sampling.
Judgment Sampling: Judgment sampling involves the choice of subjects who are most prominent placed
or in the best position to provide the information required. For instance, if a researcher wants to find out
what it takes for women managers to make it to top, the only people who can give sufficient information
are the women who have risen to the top positions of president, vice president and important top level
executives in work organization. They could reasonably be expected to have expert knowledge by virtue
and might be able to provide good information to the researcher.
Quota Sampling: Quota sampling ensures that certain groups are adequately represented in the study
through the assignment of quota. Generally, the quota fixed for each subgroup is based on the total numbers
of each group in the population. For example, a researcher might ask for a sample of 100 females, or 100
individuals between the ages of 20-30.
Quota sampling is useful when time is limited, a sampling frame is not available, the research budget is
very tight or when detailed accuracy is not important
Descriptive Statistics: Descriptive statistics are used by researchers to summarize and "describe" data
found during research. Typically researchers deal with lots of data and descriptive statistics provide a way
for the researchers to summarize the main properties of a large group of data into just a few numbers.
Some examples of descriptive statistics are frequency distributions, measures of center tendency (i.e.,
mean, median, and mode), measures of variability (standard deviation, variance) range, the minimum and
maximum values of the variables, kurtosis, skewness and graphs like pie charts and bar charts.
Inferential Statistics: Inferential statistics also known as inductive statistics. Examples of inferential
statistics include linear regression analyses, logistic regression analyses, ANOVA, correlation analyses,
structural equation modeling, and survival analysis.
Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): SEM is a statistical technique for testing and estimating causal
relations using a combination of statistical data and qualitative causal assumptions.
ANNOVA: Statistical technique for determining the degree of difference or similarity between two or more
groups of data. It is based on the comparison of the average value of a common component. There are
several varieties of ANOVA, such as one-factor (or one-way) ANOVA, two-factor (or two-way) ANOVA,
and so on, and also repeated measures ANOVA.
44 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
One-way between groups ANOVA. A one-way between groups ANOVA is used when you want to test
the difference between two or more groups.
One-way repeated measures ANOVA. A one-way repeated measures ANOVA is used when you have
a single group on which you have measured something more than one time. For example, if you wanted
to test students’ understanding of a subject, you could administer the same test at the beginning of the
course, in the middle of the course, and at the end of the course. You would then use one-way repeated
measures ANOVA to see if students’ performance on the test changed over time.
SPSS: Statistical Package for the Social Science is data management and analysis program designed to do
statistical data analysis, including descriptive statistics as well as inferential and multivariate statistical
procedures like analysis of variance (ANOVA), factor analysis, cluster analysis and category data analysis.
LISREL: LISREL is a statistical software package and an acronym for linear structural relations. It was
developed in 1970s by Karl Jöreskog. It is designed to estimate and test structural equation models. SEM
are complex, statistical models of linear relationship among laten (unobserved) variables and manifest
(observed) variables. You can use LISERL to carry out exploratory factor analysis and confirmatory factor
analysis.
45 | P a g e Created by Rabbani
Scientific Investigation
Q.2) The Hallmark of Scientific Investigation
Q.3) The Hypothetico-deductive Methods
Sampling
Q.14) Sampling Process - Reason for Sampling
Q.15) Types of Sampling: Probability Sampling and Non-probability Sampling