Guidelines For Marinas and Boatyards
Guidelines For Marinas and Boatyards
Guidelines For Marinas and Boatyards
Guidebook
ON SUSTAINABLE ENVIRONMENTAL PRACTICES
FOR MARINAS
AND BOATYARDS
IN TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO
VERSION 1.0
2
Disclaimer
This document has been prepared to provide guidance on aspects of
the siting, design, operation and maintenance of Marinas and Boatyards
in Trinidad and Tobago. This guidebook does not apply to the operation
of vessels at sea. The coastal zone of Trinidad and Tobago is diverse in
its physical, ecological and socio-economic character. Therefore, the
applicability of the practices presented in this guidebook may not be
suitable for every site. Independent technical advice should be sought on
all matters covered by the document. This guidebook is meant to assist
developers/operators of marinas and boatyards in meeting, or exceeding,
their regulatory responsibilities, but is not a substitute for existing
regulations. Questions about specific regulations or regulatory compliance
responsibilities should be directed to the relevant competent authority.
3
List of Abbreviations
and Acronyms
CEC Certificate of Environmental Clearance
EMA Environmental Management Authority
IBWMC International Ballast Water Management Convention
IMA Institute of Marine Affairs
IMO International Maritime Organization
MARPOL International Convention for the Prevention of
73/78 Pollution from Ships
MSD Maritime Services Division
PRF Port Reception Facilities
SAV Submerged Aquatic Vegetation
TCPD Town and Country Planning Division
THA Tobago House of Assembly
UNCLOS United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea
4
Glossary
Bathymetric survey - The measurement of depth of water in oceans, seas, or
lakes.
Breakwater - A solid barrier constructed in the water to create a sheltered area
for boats.
Riparian buffer strip - An area of vegetation positioned between a water body or
watercourse and nearby development
Detention Pond – Also referred to as a “dry basin” is a natural or artificially
designed structure that temporarily holds storm water ( 6 – 8 hours) for the sole
purpose of attenuating flooding
Finger float- A floating structure connected to the walkway which provides
pedestrian access both to and from a berthed boat.
Porous pavement- A layer of porous top course covering an additional layer
of gravel. The runoff infiltrates through the porous asphalt layer and into the
underground recharge bed.
Rapid bio-assessment techniques - efficient, cost-effective methods of
evaluating the condition of a water body, using surveys and other direct
measurements of the biota in the water body.
Retention Pond – Also known as a ‘wet basin’ is a natural or artificial structure
designed to hold storm water runoff for prolonged periods of time to attenuate
flooding and remove contaminants (primarily sediments). Retention ponds may
also have shallow wetlands to aid the removal of chemical contaminants.
Revetment - A sloped facing of stone or concrete built to protect existing land or
newly created embankments (breakwaters, bund walls) against erosion by wave
action, currents, or weather.
Riparian - For the purposes of this report, riparian refers to areas adjoining
coastal water bodies, including rivers, streams, bays, estuaries, coves, etc.
Riprap - Larger facing, or protective mounds of rock placed on embankments and
breakwaters to prevent erosion, scour, or sloughing of structure or embankment.
Sand Filters – Also known as ‘filtration basins’ are engineered structures
consisting of layers of sand of varying grain sizes upon a bed of gravel to
promote infiltration into the soil, or perforated underdrains for the discharge of
treated water.
Shoaling - Deposition of sediment causing a water body or location within a
water body to become shallow
Swale - A low or hollow place, especially a marshy depression between ridges.
Wave Attenuator- area floating structure designed and engineered to
significantly reduce wave action entering a marina basin.
5
Table of Contents
Introduction 1
PART A - SITING AND DESIGN 2
Legislative and Regulatory Considerations 3
Water Quality Management 3
Marina Flushing 5
Storm Water Runoff Management 6
Sewage Facility Management 7
Fuel Station Design 8
Biodiversity Protection 9
Shoreline Stabilization 10
Consideration of Weather and Climate Change Risks 10
Chemical Storage / Handling 11
Social Amenities and Infrastructure Design 12
General Disturbance Management 13
Anchorage Design 13
BIBLIOGRAPHY 23
APPENDICES 24
Appendix A – Second Schedule of the Water Pollution Rules,
2001 (as amended) 24
1
Introduction
This document provides marinas and boatyards have adequate
port reception facilities (PRFs) to
guidance and best facilitate the efficient, environmentally
management practices for responsible disposal of MARPOL 73/78
the marina and boatyard residues/wastes. Thus, this guidebook
encourages marinas and boatyards to
industry to achieve achieve excellence in environmental
good environmental management, disaster risk reduction,
environmental education and safety.
stewardship.
The following environmental best
Marina and boatyard operators management practices for marinas and
intimately interact with, and benefit boatyards are described for common
from, Trinidad and Tobago’s marine and boatyard activities. The types of marina
coastal resources. As such, they have and boatyard operations that they
a special responsibility to uphold the apply to include:
highest environmental standards and • Recreational boat docking facilities
safeguard themselves against natural • Commercial boat docking facilities
disasters. • Boat storage facilities
• Boat building and maintenance
This guidebook contributes to facilities
Trinidad and Tobago’s sustainable
development agenda; providing This document is divided into two
measures to ensure that economic broad Parts: (A) Siting and Design and
growth in the Maritime Sector is (B) Operation and Maintenance. Part A
achieved in a manner that is socially is aimed at persons seeking to develop
and environmentally responsible. new marinas or expand existing
Its formulation is in accordance with marinas. It provides best management
the Yachting Policy of Trinidad and practices for issues that should be
Tobago (2017 – 2021), Integrated addressed prior to commencing
Coastal Zone Management Policy construction or operationalization. Part
Framework 2014, and the National B applies to marinas and boatyards
Environmental Policy 2006 which call that have already been established and
for the protection of environmental are operational. It provides guidance
and human health through pollution on preventing and minimizing
control and sustainable management environmental impact.
of natural assets. It is also aligned
with the United Nations Convention Users of this guidebook should select
on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) which measures appropriate to the nature,
obligates the State to protect and location and scale of their project. The
preserve the marine environment, use of this guidebook is not a substitute
and the International Convention for for adhering to regulations governing
the Prevention of Pollution from Ships marinas and boatyards in Trinidad and
(MARPOL 73/78), which requires that Tobago.
2
part A
1. Outline Permission from the Town and Country Planning Division (TCPD), if
establishing a new facility.
2. Full Planning Permission from the TCPD, if outline permission for
establishing a new facility is granted.
3. A Certificate of Environmental Clearance (CEC) from the Environmental
Management Authority (EMA), if the proposed activity is listed in the CEC
(Designated Activities) Order, 2001 (as amended).
For example: Designated Activity 13(a) – “The establishment, modification,
expansion, decommissioning or abandonment (inclusive of associated works)
of marinas, piers, slipways, jetties or other coastal features.”
4. A Source Registration Certificate for Water Pollution from the EMA, if a
facility within, or associated with, the marina/boatyard is anticipated to
discharge into the environment pollutants listed in the 1st Schedule of the
Water Pollution Rules, 2001 (as amended).
For example: Designated Activity 2(iii) - “Transport terminals (sea ports, air
ports, bus and rail terminals)”
5. A Source Registration Certificate as an Emitter Facility from the EMA, if a
facility within, or associated with, the marina/boatyard is anticipated to emit
air pollutants listed in the 2nd Schedule or undertake any of the designated
activities listed in the 3rd Schedule of the Air Pollution Rules, 2014.
6. A Facility Variation, if requested by the EMA in anticipation that facility
operations will cause sound in excess of the prescribed standards in the 1st
Schedule of the Noise Pollution Control Rules, 2001.
Good practice also dictates that developers consult with the competent authorities
when designing or developing programs of activities related to marinas and
boatyards to minimize environmental impact. Consultations should be held with
IMA, MSD, EMA or THA where appropriate.
1
This includes activities such as the subdivision of land, grading of hills, clearing of land, development of roads or establishment
of supporting facilities (e.g. waste water treatment, concrete batching, etc.)
4
The sampling programme must contain data from at least one wet-season and one dry season to capture seasonal changes. Numerical
2
modeling may be used in tandem with field sampling to predict rates of flushing, sedimentation or accretion/erosion.
Numerical modelling should not be used for monitoring the changes to parameters during construction. Sampling stations should be located
3
Marina Flushing
The movement of water through marinas and boatyards, referred to as ‘flushing’, is
important for the dilution and distribution of contaminants. The rates of flushing
depend on, among other things, the basin configuration, orientation to prevailing
winds, changes in tide, placement of hard structures, and depth of channels/
basins. The stagnation of water contributes to diminished water quality, aesthetic
appeal, loss of marine life, and increased sedimentation of the basin. Marinas and
boatyards should be located where the site’s characteristics naturally promote
flushing, and designed to further enable water renewal on a regular basis. Where
practicable, owners/developers of marinas and boatyards should:
These are organisms that live in, on, or near to the bottom of aquatic environments.
4
Flushing efficiency is inversely proportional to the number of segments. An open design has better flushing than a 1-segment
5
marina; 1-segement marina has better flushing than a 2-segment marina; and so on
6
6
Tarpaulins may be placed on permeable surfaces prior to the placement of boats for work.
7
Pond liners are required if underlying soil is permeable or if bedrock is fractured. Shallow wetlands
may be established in retention ponds to aid in contaminant removal.
8
A sump is a pit or reservoir serving as a drain or receptacle for liquids.
7
A flexible hose is connected to the wastewater fitting in the hull of the boat, and pumps or a vacuum system move the
9
wastewater to an onshore holding tank, a public sewer system, a private treatment facility, or another approved disposal facility.
10
Mobile units comprised of a pump and small storage tank is connected to the deck fitting of vessels and waste water is removed.
When filled, the mobile units discharge its contents into a municipal sewage system or a holding tank for removal by a septic
tank pump out service.
8
11. Restroom should be designed to cater for the physically disabled, and
outfitted using the following ratios11:
12. Ensure that all toilets have ultra-low flush fixtures with a maximum flow rate
of 1.6 gallons per flush.
Adapted from the Belize Department of Environment National Environmental Guideline for Marinas and Berthing Facilities.
11
12
Example: fuel nozzles with automatic back pressure shut-offs and no holding clip to keep the nozzle open.
9
1. Develop a Spill Contingency Plan for fuel storage and dispensation areas that
outlines, at a minimum:
a. Health and safety procedures;
b. Notification procedures to the competent authorities; and
c. Spill containment and control procedures.
2. Routinely conduct drills/simulations of the Spill Contingency Plan to ensure
all marina/ boatyard personnel are aware of appropriate procedures.
3. Appropriately label and make accessible spill containment equipment13 at
storage and dispensation areas.
Biodiversity Protection
The coastal zone of Trinidad and Tobago encompasses several diverse ecosystems
and habitats that contain plants and animals of commercial, aesthetic, ecological
and recreational value. Some critical biological resources found in the coastal
zone include, but are not limited to: i) submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV); ii) tidal
and non-tidal wetlands; iii) coral reefs; iv) rare, threatened, or endangered species;
v) fish spawning, nursery, or propagation areas; and vi) bird nesting sites and
existing riparian forests or mangrove forests with interior dwelling bird species.
Environmentally responsible siting and design of marinas and boatyards avoid the
destruction of ecologically significant habitats, and minimize disturbance to the
functioning and life cycles of species. Where practicable, owners/developers of
marinas and boatyards should:
1. Give preference for redeveloping coastal waterfront sites that have been
previously disturbed, or expanding exiting marinas and boatyards instead of
establishing new facilities in undisturbed areas.
2. Conduct a baseline assessment14 of the areas of concern within and around
the project site.
3. Assess the historical habitat function15 of the project site to avoid indirect
impacts to populations of species.
4. Ensure that only areas designed for construction are cleared.
5. Minimize the project footprint16 much as practicably possible.
6. Develop a Communication Plan to facilitate State Authorities in the monitoring
and assessment of vessels for compliance with the International Convention
for the Control and Management of Ships’ Ballast Water and Sediments (Ballast
Water Management Convention).
7. Establish systems for the treatment of ballast water and management of
sediments introduced by ballast waters to minimize the risk of invasive alien
species being introduced, unless the vessel has an International Maritime
Organization(IMO) approved Ballast Water Management Plan on-board
treatment system, and International Ballast Water Management Convention
(IBWMC) Certificate.
13
These include containment booms, absorbent pads and fire extinguishers.
14
This includes field surveys of the fauna and flora characterization and status present.
15
Habitat functions include: spawning grounds, nursery area, nesting area, and migration pathway.
16
Project footprint is the land or water area covered by a project. This includes direct physical coverage (i.e., the area on
which the project physically stands) and direct effects (i.e., the disturbances that may directly emanate from the project,
such as noise).
10
Shoreline Stabilization
The destabilization and erosion of the shoreline due to waves can have significant
environmental implications including, but not limited to: the compromising
of pollution mitigation measures and the introduction of debris to the marine
environment due to infrastructural damage. The type of technique used to
attenuate high-energy waves and stabilize shorelines is dependent on the
site’s specific characteristics and underpinning cause of erosion. Independent
technical advice should be sought for deciding the appropriate measure to use
so that unintended environmental impacts (E.g. increased shoreline erosion to
unprotected downstream areas) can be avoided. Where practicable, owners/
developers of marinas and boatyards should:
1. Establish vegetation17 along low-wave-energy areas where the underlying
soil type provides the stability required for plants and conditions are suitable
for plant growth.
2. Utilize appropriate, cost-effective structural methods and techniques18 to
minimize coastal erosion from long-shore drift, storm surge or high-energy
waves.
3. Utilize over-dredging, and possible future bypass dredging19, during
preliminary site assessments for the proposed design plan in order to
minimize the degree of sedimentation and to ensure that any sedimentation
which does occur can be efficiently removed.
17
Native species, particularly those historically associated with the area should be used where possible.
These may include, but are not limited to: bulkheads, jetties, breakwaters, gabions, riprap and sloping revetments. The selection of
18
21
A bilge is an area on the outer surface of a ship’s hull where the bottom curves to meet the vertical sides.
12
10. Prohibit chemical waste discharge into a storm sewer, sanitary sewer or onto
the open ground or surface waters.
11. Avoid, as far as practicably possible, the use of highly toxic materials such
as surfactant, anti-scaling agents, phosphoric, hydrochloric and sulphuric
acid, detergents containing more than 6% by weight of volatile compounds,
reactive chloro-compounds and formaldehyde and bioaccumlable
preservative classified as H410, H411, R50/53 or R51/53.
Anchorage Design
An anchorage is an area off the coast used for ship to anchor. Improper siting
and designation of anchorages in relation to other aspects of the marina, such
as the navigation channel, fairways and waiting berths, may result in increased
risk of collision hazards, damage to infrastructure, or adverse impacts to the
environment. Without limiting the power and authority of the Harbour Master as
prescribed in the Harbours Act 50:06, where practicable, owners/developers of
the marinas and boatyards should:
1. Install an anchorage system to provide mooring for all floating structures with
the consideration of water depth and exposure to wave and wind action. The
system should include dead man or ground stakes.
2. Mark and guard all anchorage systems.
3. Prohibit attaching anchor cables of securing devices to power poles, tree,
stumps or guardrail posts.
4. Ensure that anchor cables are fastened with a minimum of three U-bolts of
fist grip clamps.
5. Ensure that winches located on docks have cable guards.
14
part B
Operations
and Maintenance
15
22
Refer to Guidelines as outlined in the International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships, 1973 as modified by the Protocol of 1978
(MARPOL 73/78).
23
Materials that exhibit these characteristics can include explosives, compressed gases, including toxic or flammable gases, flammable liquids, flammable
solids, oxidising substances, toxic materials including carcinogens, pathogens, teratogens and mutagens, radioactive material and corrosive substances.
24
Non-hazardous solid waste includes scrap metal, aluminum, glass, paper, and cardboard
25
Disposal of non-hazardous waste shall take place at an appropriate facility operated by the relevant Regional/City/Borough Corporation or a waste
disposal firm with the appropriate licenses, permits, trained/certified personnel, facilities, equipment and insurance to handle such waste.
26
Proper disposal methods include employing filtration and separation techniques
27
Trash include sandings, paint chips etc.
16
14. Ensure that a service company/facility with the appropriate licenses, permits,
trained/certified personnel, facilities, equipment and insurance to collect and
handle solid waste and non-hazardous waste.
Catch-and-release is a method of fishing in which some or all of the fishes are released after capture, as a conservation measure.
28
29
Pollutant include suspended solids and organics (oil and grease)
30
Measures may include developing and adopting good housekeeping and spill prevention control.
17
31
Soak away system is a drainage system with a pit, typically filled with rubble, into which waste water is piped so that it drains slowly
out into the surrounding soil.
32
Measures include incinerate, remove or dispose of, to an appropriate land-fill
18
33
Absorbents include oil absorbent pads, booms, socks or pillows
34
Hot drain is defined as draining the oil filter at or near engine operating temperature but above 60 degrees Fahrenheit.
19
Repair and maintenance activities include painting, sand blasting, engine repairs and boat washing
35
16. Ensure the use of the proper personal protective equipment (PPE) always, if
engaged in the dismantling of yachts and other boats.
17. Follow good industrial hygiene practices, such as utilizing engineering
controls, reducing airborne exposures; and good housekeeping to keep dust
contained within work areas.
Print materials include maps of pump out facilities, booklets on boat pollution, pamphlets on plastic debris, and articles
37
38
Marina services include boat launching, fuelling and boat repairs and maintaining the premises in good condition
21
No-wake zone is where boats/ vessels must operate at the minimum speed that allows you to maintain steering and make headway.
39
22
Ecological Considerations
Marine activities can affect the ecological balance of the water body, if management
measures are not put in place there will be harmful effects on ecological health.
Where practicable, owners/developers of marinas and boatyards should:
1. Control vessel access and speed to protect banks and marine animals.
2. Consult with appropriate competent authorities prior to engaging in activities
that my impact the marine or coastal environment. These Authorities include,
but are not limited to: the EMA, IMA, THA, CDA, and MSD.
3. Establish ground maintenance guidelines which include:
a. Professional landscaping practices;
b. Conservative use of insecticides, herbicides and fertilizers;
c. Prevention and clean-up of petroleum spills from upland fuelling
stations; and
d. Maintenance of a regular rubbish/garbage collection schedule.
23
Bibliography
n.d. Blue Flag Marina Criteria and Explanatory Notes. Europe.
Bugler, Michael, and Sinclair Knight. 1994. Environmental Guidelines for
Marinas in the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park. Townsville, July.
n.d. Defined Term. https://definedterm.com/project_footprint.
Department of Environment. 2009. National Environmental Guideline for
Marinas and Berthing Facilities. Belize City, Haulover Creek Harbour, April.
Environmental Management Authority. 2010. Guidelines for the Trinidad & Tobago
Coast Guard for Pollution Prevention and Abatement during the Dismantling
of three derelict vessels.
2001. Good Mate Recreational Boating & Marina Manual. New York.
Kreuter, Endrick. n.d. Quora. https://www.quora.com/What-does-no-wake-zone-
mean.
Liebl, David S. 2002. Environmental Best Management Practices for Marinas and Boat
Yards. Wisconsin, September.
Maharaj, R. 1990. Tropical Storm Fran: A report on the passage of Tropical Storm Fran
through Trinidad on August 14, 1990. Trinidad and Tobago Meterological
Services Report.
n.d. Merrian Webster. Accessed 01 04, 2018. https://www.merriam-webster.com/
dictionary/bilge.
Oxford Univeristy Press. 2018. English Oxford Living Dictionaries. Accessed 01 04,
2018. https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/soakaway.
Rahmstorf, S. 2010. A new view on sea level rise. Nature Reports Climate Change.
2013. Recyling Oil Filters. Accessed 01 04, 2018. http://www.zendergroup.org/docs/
Used_oil_filter_crusher_print.pdf.
The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. 1993. “Management Measures for Marinas and
Recreational Boating.”
The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. n.d. Management Measures for Marinas and
Recreational Boating.
U.S. Agency for international Development. 1996. NRCA guidelines pertaining to
Marinas and Small Craft Harbours. July.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. 2003. Shipshape Shores and Waters A
Handbook for Marina Operators for Marina Operators and Recreational
Boaters. New York, January .
World Bank Group. 2017. Environmental. Health , and Safety Guidelines for Ports,
Harbors and Terminals. February 2.
24
Appendix
25
26
27