Defining and Developing An Effective Code of Conduct For Organizations
Defining and Developing An Effective Code of Conduct For Organizations
Defining and Developing An Effective Code of Conduct For Organizations
June 2007
Accountants in
Business
Committee
The mission of the International Federation of Accountants (IFAC) is to serve the public interest,
strengthen the worldwide accountancy profession and contribute to the development of strong
international economies by establishing and promoting adherence to high-quality professional
standards, furthering the international convergence of such standards and speaking out on public
interest issues where the profession’s expertise is most relevant.
This publication may be downloaded free-of-charge from the IFAC website http://www.ifac.org.
The approved text is published in the English language.
Copyright © June 2007 by the International Federation of Accountants (IFAC). All rights
reserved. Permission is granted to make copies of this work provided that such copies are for use
in academic classrooms or for personal use and are not sold or disseminated and provided further
that each copy bears the following credit line: “Copyright © June 2007 by the International
Federation of Accountants. All rights reserved. Used by permission.” Otherwise, written
permission from IFAC is required to reproduce, store or transmit this document, except as
permitted by law. Contact permissions@ifac.org.
ISBN: 1-931949-81-6
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL
GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
1. General Overview of Why the Topic is Important ............................................................... 2
Establishing a Business Case for Developing a Code of Conduct ........................................ 3
The Role of the Professional Accountant in Business .......................................................... 3
2. Key Principles That are Widely Accepted Features of Good Practice ................................. 5
The Nature of Codes of Conduct in Organizations ............................................................... 5
The Key Principles in Defining and Developing a Code of Conduct ................................... 6
3. Application Guidance on Implementing the Principles ........................................................ 8
Appendix A: Illustration of a Code of Conduct for the ABC Organization ............................... 21
Appendix B: Values-Based Principles in Public Life – An Example ......................................... 26
Appendix C: External Conduct Guidelines and Legal Standards ............................................... 27
Appendix D: A Graphic Representation of Key Stakeholders and
Their Primary Areas of Concern ................................................................................................. 28
Appendix E: Resources ............................................................................................................... 29
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
1.2 The concern over failure to establish or to adhere to standards of proper conduct has been
heightened by corporate scandals and their impact on the capital markets and investors.
Many individuals and groups demand more from their organizational leaders than profit
maximization and transparency, and many organizational leaders now emphasize ethics
and integrity as a primary feature of their business conduct. This increased focus on
ethics, corporate governance and corporate responsibility has encouraged many
organizations to establish codes of conduct. In some countries, laws and regulations have
required such codes; in others, their establishment has been prompted by market
mechanisms such as movements in share price, or a combination of market forces and
regulation. From a wider economic perspective, implementing codes of conduct
effectively and consistently could improve organizational performance and control,
leading to fewer irregularities and corporate scandals and a gradual build-up of trust
between organizations and its stakeholders.
1.3 Many organizations realize that good conduct and integrity contribute to marketplace
success. Management theorists and business leaders frequently assert that clear core
values are essential to high-performing organizations, and that “good conduct is good
business.” Ethical dilemmas can impair an organization’s reputation, and ultimately its
financial performance. Facilitating ethical behavior in organizations can help both to
safeguard reputation and to convey a commitment to responsible practice to both society
and regulators. Furthermore, multinational corporations influence standards of conduct
and business practice when they apply their codes of conduct to all their operational
facilities.
1.4 Questionable business practices, and even individual incidents of improper conduct,
reflect to some degree the values, attitudes, beliefs, and systems of the organization in
which they occur. Senior managers can be accused of failing to provide leadership if they
don’t institute systems that encourage and facilitate appropriate standards of conduct and
behavior.
2
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
and those wishing to review their existing approach whether in developing markets or
established economies.
1.6 Recognizing that this is an evolving area of practice, the PAIB Committee welcomes
feedback and additional comment on this Guidance over time. Additional comments can
be sent to edcomments@ifac.org. The PAIB Committee also encourages professional
accountants in practice to refer to this Guidance.
1.8 A well-designed code of conduct can provide the context for programs designed to
improve organizational performance. Organizations that fail to establish and implement a
code of conduct and to embed their organizational values could experience lower
productivity, higher turnover, increased transaction and agency costs, and increased
exposure to legal action. This failure will ultimately increase the cost of capital. Thus,
successfully implementing a code of conduct within a values-based organization is
increasingly perceived as a competitive asset and advantage.
1.10 Organizational leaders such as CEOs, CFOs and other directors and senior managers
1
Paragraph 300.5 of the IFAC Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants.
3
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
1.11 An accountant working in internal audit may be involved in (a) assessing whether the
code is an effective tool in minimizing the risk of improper conduct, including whether
non-adherence is being reported, and (b) reporting to the audit committee. Accountants in
the internal audit or finance function could also be involved in implementing and
reinforcing the code in that function.
1.12 More generally, codes of conduct play a vital role in strengthening the control
environment, within which professional accountants in business can feature significantly
by monitoring, reviewing, and reporting on performance. Because an effective code of
conduct is a critical component of an organization’s control systems, most professional
accountants in business should be able to:
• Recognize potential ethical and compliance problems within the organizations they
support;
• Apply a framework or a decision-making process for resolving conflicts;
• Articulate the reasons for making particular decisions based on a code of conduct;
• Identify, monitor, and communicate the expectations of stakeholders, as well as the
costs, benefits and risks of meeting those expectations;
• Monitor and report on adherence to their organizations’ codes of conduct; and
• Assess whether proposed action on current and future initiatives effectively manages
the risks faced by the organization.
1.13 Although organizations may have their own codes of conduct, accountants are also
required to comply with the code of ethics of their professional body. Professional bodies
that are members of IFAC are required to comply with the ethical requirements of the
IFAC Code, which establishes ethical requirements for professional accountants. A
member body may not apply less stringent standards than those stated in this Code.
However, if a member body is prohibited from complying with certain parts of this Code
by law or regulation, they should comply with all other parts. The requirements and
guidance of some jurisdictions may differ from the IFAC Code. Professional accountants
should be aware of those differences and comply with the more stringent requirements and
guidance, unless prohibited by law or regulation. Therefore, an accountant who is a
member of a professional body that is an IFAC member will be required to comply with
the principles of the IFAC Code, as well as the professional body’s code of conduct.
Professional accountants in business should support an organization’s code by behaving in
compliance with it. Where appropriate, professional accountants in business should also
4
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
be aware of other relevant codes such as the Group of 100 Code of Conduct for the Chief
Financial Officers of Australia’s major enterprises. Complying with all relevant codes
contributes to the integrity of reporting, and to responsible and ethical decision-making.
1.14 The 2005 PAIB Committee paper, The Roles and Domains of Professional Accountants
in Business, outlines the varied roles that professional accountants in business perform,
for example in implementing and maintaining operational and fiduciary controls,
providing analytical support for strategic planning and decision making, ensuring that
effective risk management processes are in place, and assisting management in setting the
tone for ethical practices.
2.2 Although codes of conduct are drafted in many different ways, programs in organizations
with a relatively developed approach to managing ethics and values usually include:
• An organization’s mission;
• A statement from the CEO and/or board of directors;
• Organizational values and principles;
• A statement(s) on how the entity relates to its community, the environment, and
society;
• Ethical and conduct guidelines and guidance on practices;
• Examples of ethical and unethical behavior;
• Specific rules of conduct; and
• Commitment to and information on performance evaluation.
2.3 The term “code of conduct” does not have an authorized definition. In its 1999 report
Code of Corporate Conduct: An inventory, the OECD Working Party of the Trade
Committee defined codes of corporate conduct for the purpose of its survey as
“commitments voluntarily made by companies, associations or other entities, which put
forth standards and principles for the conduct of business activities in the marketplace.”
2.4 Most other definitions emphasize that a code of conduct is a formal statement of the
values and business practices of a corporation. A comprehensive definition of “code of
5
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
2.7 The key principles underlying widely accepted good practice are:
B. A code of conduct reflects organizational context. The nature, title and content
of an effective code will vary between organizations, as will the approach to its
development.
6
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
G. Continuous awareness and promotion of the code and the wider approach to
ethics and compliance is an important part of conveying management’s
commitment to their underlying principles. A continuous awareness program
should sustain interest in and commitment to the code. Employees and others
should be made aware of the consequences of not adhering to the code.
7
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
PRINCIPLE A
3.1 A values-based code is best suited to a rapidly changing business environment, because it
allows for a multitude of circumstances that may arise in practice. A values-based code
provides a framework for analyzing threats and safeguards and determining appropriate
action. It allows all employees to make responsible decisions and avoid a “tick-box”
approach that could encourage loophole-based avoidance.
3.2 Managing for compliance2 is a starting point to developing a code. Organizations see the
tremendous damage that can be done to an organization’s reputation and momentum by
illegal or otherwise improper conduct. To prevent this, an organization can establish a
code of conduct requiring compliance with both the law and the standards of conduct the
public demands. A code based solely on managing compliance will typically focus on
prohibitions such as against conflicts of interest, theft of company property and revealing
trade secrets, and could be titled a compliance code.
3.3 A compliance program can address only a limited set of organizational situations and
behaviors, namely those that can be reduced to simple standards of right and wrong. The
most difficult issues faced by employees often involve dilemmas brought on by new
technologies, new business arrangements, or cases where two or more obligations conflict.
3.4 A compliance program based on a code of conduct that sets minimum standards for
organizational behavior does little to define expected or encouraged types of behavior. It
can expect employees to avoid mistreating customers, but it cannot help them see how to
treat customers well. It may:
• Indicate to employees that the program is designed to control their behavior because
they are not trusted. This directly counters efforts to empower employees to use their
personal judgment in appropriately handling the many situations they face; and
• Inadvertently give the impression that the organization wants only a minimum
standard of behavior, and that employees will not be rewarded for substantial
attention to ethical and conduct issues.
3.5 OECD research published in 2000, An Expanded Review of their Contents, illustrates the
most-cited motivations mentioned by codes beyond mere expressions of responsibilities
to the public or specific stakeholders. Cited objectives include: (a) protection or
enhancement of reputation and the building or retention of industry leadership in certain
areas of corporate social responsibility, (b) more customer loyalty, (c) improved operation
2
Managing for compliance refers to avoiding any legal or other behavior that violates an
organization’s policy and/or negatively affects its interests.
8
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
of the business, (d) stronger staff loyalty, and (e) control of legal risks.
3.6 Organizations usually affect employee behaviors in only a limited way if they manage
compliance without creating a genuine change in organizational culture. Without that
change, important situations raising conduct issues bring out instinctive rather than
strategic responses. Those who do create that change foster a values-driven organization
that identifies values and invests considerable resources to make those values permeate
all aspects of operations. They find it productive to make decisions consistent with those
values, even when short-term payoffs are not apparent.
3.7 A purely compliance-based approach that tells employees about the law as a means of
preventing violations has limited effectiveness. Recognition of this has steered many
organizations to manage by a set of positive values that help to guide employees’
decisions and actions, and promote individual responsibility. Organizational values may
be shaped by (a) an organization’s founders who continue to dominate leadership and
management beliefs, (b) the expectations and demands of stakeholders, or (c) a set of
long-standing values established by professional managers whether it is the board of
directors or others charged with leadership and governance.
3.8 Preparing a values-based code requires defining fundamental principles and providing
guidance, particularly on what is ethical conduct and what is not. A values-based code
defines values at a relatively high level, because it is impossible to address all situations
employees might face. A code should clearly identify activities or behaviors for which
there is no tolerance.
3.9 Appendix A is an example code of conduct that although not comprehensive acts as a
guide on how a fictional organization describes the values that govern how it does
9
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
business, sets out some example responsibilities of the organization towards its
stakeholders and specifies how employees are expected to act in relation to the
organization’s values as well as the laws and regulations that control operations.
Appendix B provides an example of values-based principles that public sector
organizations can appropriately include in their codes of conduct.
PRINCIPLE B
A code of conduct reflects organizational context. The nature, title and content of an
effective code will vary between organizations, as will the approach to its development.
3.10 Codes of conduct vary in design and content as well as how they are developed, and will
be affected by the following factors:
• Organizational size, type and complexity;
• Geography;
• Industry; and
• Cultural considerations.
3.11 Smaller organizations could take a simpler approach that leads to a shorter document
covering a narrower range of issues. The process of development and implementation
will likely be less formal, focusing on actions rather than formal policy statements. If the
behavior of the owner-manager(s) is to be seen as a model for employees’ behavior, they
should understand the owner-manager(s)’ approach to ethical issues. Ideally, new partners
and senior managers would share the same values. Smaller organizations should establish
clear lines of responsibility and accountability for ethical conduct, and regularly review
code and ethical performance, especially where the organization is changing rapidly.
3.12 Codes of conduct are important tools for state-owned and not-for-profit enterprises. The
codes of these organizations usually cover a range of public commitments, because a loss
of public confidence due to unethical behavior can irreversibly damage reputation.
Developing and implementing codes can help manage specific ethical issues that can
arise in these organizational types, and are challenging to manage. For example, these
organizations can also use codes of conduct for board members to good effect. This helps
to prevent conflicts of interest, especially by directing board members not to put their
personal objectives above the organization’s welfare. Diligent decision-making in these
organizations requires the same level of application and consideration of ethical issues as
for profit-driven organizations.
3.13 For larger and more complex organizations in both private and public sectors, more
substantial codes should include a set of specific ethical rules and guidance covering a
range of ethical issues. They should, for example, deal with bribery and corruption,
conflict of interest, improper accounting practices, and labor and environmental issues,
and include corporate goals, responsibilities and values. They should also include
10
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
guidelines for suppliers and business partners, and make public commitments where
appropriate.
3.14 While organizations in different sectors will have some issues in common, organizations
in heavy or resource-based industries are likely to focus on a different range of issues
than would service-based organizations or technology companies. Programs in heavily
regulated industries often initially respond to violation of the law, although many have
moved beyond this to establishing a values-based culture. Furthermore, very few codes
deal only with single issues. Most cover a wide spectrum of issues, in one or more
documents. Codes developed by organizations working with the public sector should also
refer to specific laws and regulations governing sales to the public sector. In most
countries, procurements by the public sector are subject to restrictions and guidelines.
PRINCIPLE C
Commitment from board of directors: Ultimately, ethical responsibility lies with the
board of directors (or its equivalent), the body that has power to influence an
organization’s culture and behavior. Boards should specifically oversee the development
of the code of conduct (and a wider initiative to achieve a values-based organization), and
formally appoint a senior manager to supervise that development.
3.15 Some organizations make a senior executive responsible for leading the development of a
code of conduct; some appoint full-time ethics officers; and some do both. Regardless of
where the responsibility lies, a champion, preferably at board level, is required and they
should also sponsor the wider initiative to achieve a values-based organization.
3.17 Some national laws and regulations require a senior officer to be in charge of ethics and
compliance. The board should require this person to report regularly through an
appropriate channel, such as the Audit Committee or Ethics Committee/group where
there is one.
3.18 Developing a values-based organization should start at the top of the organization, with
senior executive support. The CEO should be willing to commit the required time and
personal effort to the initiative, as well as to visibly demonstrate commitment. Companies
known for ethical conduct and social responsibility are typically led by such CEOs. A
values-driven program is likely to fail if employees sense that senior managers do not
believe in and are not committed to the program.
3.19 The importance of an introductory letter from the CEO unambiguously endorsing the
code and conveying top-management support cannot be underestimated. Such a letter
11
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
should emphasize the organization’s values, include an overview of the code, and state
the organization’s commitment to the proper conduct of its managers and employees.
This message from the CEO will play a critical role in determining how well the code
will be received and followed. It can also place the code within the context of a wider
ethics and values-driven program. The code of conduct could also begin with an
introduction from the CEO and/or board of directors explaining the importance of ethics
and integrity, how the code supports and guides ethical behavior, and how the code
reflects the organization’s context, values, and principles.
3.20 Through their everyday actions, senior managers can encourage others to meet higher
standards. The board itself needs to be ethical and committed to fostering and supporting
an ethical culture. Ethically acting boards can be facilitated and supported by having their
own code of conduct, and through sound corporate governance that deals with (a)
appointing directors, (b) board agendas and meetings, (c) remuneration, (d) internal
control, and (e) evaluating board performance. The existence of a board code and sound
corporate governance will help the corporation deal with issues such as existing
management and employee attitudes, the difficulty of communicating values and
standards, possible conflicts with other organization objectives, pressures to meet other
corporate goals, and the real cost of resources and management time to develop,
implement and enforce the code.
3.21 Where a board does not have its own code, the organization-wide code could be used to
raise the level of governance and board performance by providing guidance on a range of
issues, such as independence, nominations, tenure and remuneration, board structure, the
process for managing meetings and agendas, and evaluation of board members and their
performance. This should help prevent conflicts resulting from a lack of objectivity,
divided loyalty, favoritism and self-interest.
PRINCIPLE D
3.22 Using multi-departmental groups or committees to develop a code will foster ownership
across all areas of an organization. The composition of such groups will vary and could
include external representation, such as from suppliers or employee unions. Their work might
also be facilitated by the involvement of consultants, especially at the beginning when the
group determines its purpose, structure and process. Developing a code through cross-
functional groups or committees helps to foster agreement on difficult and pertinent issues.
3.23 Larger organizations can establish a working group with representatives from various
functions, including human resources, marketing, procurement, finance, internal audit,
12
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
and legal and compliance. This working group would be responsible for ensuring that the
code of conduct is made part of the organizational culture. Smaller organizations may
delegate these responsibilities to a sufficiently senior individual who commands respect
and support.
PRINCIPLE E
Clearly identifying the established process for defining, developing and reviewing a code
will promote understanding of, and agreement on, the key stages and activities.
3.26 In addition to gaining the commitment of senior management, defining and developing a
code includes at least the following activities:
• Agreeing on the purpose of the code and how it will be used, and including this in a
statement of intent in the code;
• Identifying stakeholders, what is important to them, and who should be involved in
code development and implementation;
• Reviewing widely recognized external and multi-sector conduct guidelines;
• Drafting the content, perhaps by a working group comprising representatives from
various functions in an organization;
• Testing/piloting and approving;
• Publishing and publicizing;
• Post-implementation reviewing of code content and its impact;
• Training and communicating as a means to embed the code (and organizational
values); and
13
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
• Connecting the code to the organization’s (a) performance management policies and
systems, and (b) internal controls.
Agreeing on the purpose of the code and how it will be used, and including this in a statement of
intent in the code
3.27 Organizations should be clear on the code’s purpose and use. Codes typically fulfill the
following objectives:
• Stipulating the values and principles that govern how the organization does business;
• Establishing the responsibilities of the company towards its stakeholders;
• Explaining how employees are expected to apply an organization’s values and laws
and regulations that affect its operations; and
• Providing guidance on resolving ethical issues and dilemmas, and how they can
receive further advice.
Identifying stakeholders, what is important to them, and who should be involved in code
development and implementation
3.28 Codes can be overly centered on responsibilities owed to the organization, rather than
responsibilities to stakeholders. This typically occurs where management leads and
manages the drafting process without stakeholder input. Such codes typically fail to
address important themes and issues.
3.29 Organizations that involve their stakeholders, at least by seeking their views and
requirements, should identify their stakeholders, evaluate their attitudes and opinions,
design programs to address their concerns, and audit the effectiveness of policies
affecting stakeholders.
3.30 A graphic representation of key stakeholders and their primary areas of concern is at
Appendix D. Key stakeholders include customers, employees, investors and creditors,
competitors, suppliers/partners, and the public. Where employee unions or councils exist,
the organization should consult with the employees’ representative. Most codes deal with
behavior at least in relation to customers and suppliers. Guidelines targeted at other
stakeholder groups are less commonly found, but should be considered for inclusion.
Code guidelines typically cover areas such as:
Employees: Protecting workers from injury and meeting health and safety requirements,
avoiding discrimination, providing equal employment opportunity, fair and appropriate
remuneration, respect of human rights, right to collective bargaining and support in
developing skills and capabilities, and approach to gifts, entertainment, favors and bribes.
14
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
Investors and creditors: Insider trading, financial returns to investors, accurate and timely
information, financial disclosure and reporting, accounting and audits, and respecting
shareholders’ legal rights. Directors’ responsibilities can be supported by guidelines on
integrity, duties of diligence, conflicts of interest, and unauthorized self-dealing.
Public: Promotion of free trade, open markets, and democratic institutions, avoiding
inappropriate involvement in politics, and environmental stewardship.
This list is not intended to be exhaustive. A number of surveys are available that indicate
a range of typical code guidelines – see resources in Appendix E.
3.31 The effectiveness of guidelines generally depends on the approach guidelines take on an
issue and what specific guidance is included. Credibility and commitment can be
enhanced when a code precisely defines key concepts and clearly and adequately
specifies required behavior. For example, if environmental concerns pose significant risks
to an organization, the code should provide detailed guidance that defines and supports
specific environmental initiatives.
3.32 Another example relates to bribery and corruption. Here, codes typically vary widely in
their definitions and required commitments. Rather than simply prohibiting bribery and
corrupt behavior, codes could include guidance on offering, giving, soliciting and receiving
“gifts,” and include references to authoritative guidance, such as the OECD Bribery
Convention. Rules and guidelines can be included for both public officials and business
partners, although they may vary in their treatment of these groups. In some circumstances,
gifts from business partners could be accepted, but should be subject to disclosure.
3.34 Although industry codes can be used to elevate standards, following them can be difficult
where an organization is raising standards above those of competitors, and employees
feel constrained in their ability to compete. However, raising ethical standards and
embedding organizational values should not be viewed negatively, as it can provide a
competitive advantage.
15
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
Drafting the content, perhaps by a working group comprising representatives from various
functions in an organization
3.35 One person needs to be primarily responsible for writing the code, but should be
supported by a group. This group should decide how to structure the code. The writing
and implementation of a code has many legal aspects that could be reviewed by legal
counsel. Where only a small amount of information is to be included, as could be the case
in small organizations, a formal structure might not be required. In this case, a prioritized
short list of issues and statements could form the basis of the written code.
3.36 Codes need to be easily understood by all employees. Negative phrasing should be
avoided. For example, individual rights can be addressed in such statements as, “We do
not tolerate discrimination in A, B or C”. Instead, the principle can be stated positively
and discrimination addressed more effectively through corporate and individual direction
to “treat people fairly”. Effective codes that promote proper conduct write guiding
principles and explanations in plain, positive language, rather than merely making
demands. Codes can also usefully include practical examples.
3.41 Where an individual is responsible for the code, and perhaps wider values and
compliance initiatives, that individual could be usefully supported by a group of senior
staff responsible for monitoring the adoption, promotion and effectiveness of the code.
This group could also investigate potential breaches and regularly review wording and
16
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
content. Feedback on compliance with the code should also help it to become an integral
part of an organization’s culture.
3.42 In the case of existing codes, the organization should undertake a gap analysis that
considers the existing policy and approach and related communications and training
programs, to identify what more or different is needed to encourage and support the
expected behavior and compliance.
3.43 An outcome-based evaluation should document the current situation by (a) identifying
organizational risks and uncertainties, (b) listing and describing the resources dedicated
to the program, (c) describing the program’s structures and systems, activities and
processes (both planned and undertaken), and (d) assessing the outputs of the program,
such as the number of people trained.
Training and communicating as a means to embed the code (and organizational values)
3.44 A well-drafted effective code simplifies adherence. Communication programs and
educational sessions are effective means of guiding employees, monitoring behavior, and
embedding the code’s provisions.
3.45 Training in the practical application of the code can include workshops, hard copy
materials, online resources and e-learning modules. More innovative approaches to
training such as mentoring and the use of ethical dilemma case studies can enhance its
effectiveness by allowing dialogue and discussion so that employees can develop their
level of awareness of ethical issues and ability to consider choices and possible
responses. New employees should participate in training and related awareness programs.
Without these, they may not realize the expectations and standards of their new
organization.
3.46 To move beyond mere legal compliance, training and awareness programs could help
workers and managers at operational sites to assume more control over issues such as
workplace conditions. Specific training could improve safety and enhance productivity.
Training could also help employees apply principles to local circumstances, and
encourage employees to disclose and discuss particularly challenging ethical dilemmas.
For example, these programs should define conflicts of interest with precision, apply the
principles to specific examples, and support the results with reasons. These programs
should first focus on educating employees about how conflicts can develop. In addition,
employees should be helped to (a) recognize situations having the potential to create
conflicts of interest, and (b) determine whether they are material and need to be managed
and reported.
17
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
Connecting the code to the organization’s (a) performance management policies and systems,
and (b) internal controls
3.48 Implementing the code requires reviewing existing performance management policies and
systems, and monitoring how expected behavior and compliance will be achieved and
supported.
3.49 Mechanisms to embed the code and measure performance include annual compliance
sign-offs, periodic internal audits, and regular performance reviews. Adherence to the
letter and spirit of the code could also be made a condition of continued employment, as
well as a consideration in pay and a condition of further promotion.
3.50 Measures used in monitoring adherence with a code of conduct should be developed, a
task particularly suited to professional accountants in business. In doing so, questions of
deviation should be addressed. For example, when does behavior so deviate from the
standards that it should be reported to management? And how should the organization
identify, consider and report on activities and behavior that poses risks to the organization?
3.51 Whistle-blowing (speaking up): the Code, or referenced documentation, should discuss
whistle-blowing, informing employees of what process to follow. Whistle-blowing should
be defined to include reporting of lapses in honesty and integrity. Those who witness such
behavior should be encouraged to report it and organizations should monitor the
prevalence of whistle-blowing to be satisfied that people are not deterred from speaking
up. In some jurisdictions, there is regulation that seeks to protect those speaking up and
this should be considered in establishing a policy on whistle-blowing. Organizations
should respond positively to those who speak up.
PRINCIPLE F
3.52 Codes and policies should apply to all global business operations/production facilities. A
code of conduct is a reference for decision-making for employees from diverse
backgrounds working across geographical and cultural boundaries. Without a fundamental
code of conduct on which to base decisions, managers in different countries may have
difficulty resolving conflicts. Local organizations should designate a senior person to be
responsible for ensuring that the code is adhered to in that location.
3.53 Development of local, or country-specific, guidance should follow the same process as
that used to develop the organization’s global code and policies. This ensures that the
over-arching values and principles flow through to country-specific guidance. A global
code supported by country-specific guidance is a way of dealing with local standards of
conduct that differ from those in the country of its head office. It can also ensure
compliance with domestic laws and regulations.
18
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
3.54 Although some organizations allow its stakeholders to define what constitutes appropriate
behavior in local jurisdictions, a compromise between a global and a domestic approach
to standards of conduct should be avoided. An organization that operates internationally
and seeks to respond to all stakeholders can be caught between the conflicting demands
of diverse cultural environments.
3.55 More mature organizations seek to establish a single set of values and behavior standards
for its worldwide operations. Although some minor variations are accepted to meet local
conditions and conflicting local laws, these organizations believe that their interests are
best served by a single, worldwide code of conduct that fosters a single, worldwide
standard of acceptable behavior. They consider this a matter of principle and good
management. They also believe that most, if not all, requirements in a code of conduct,
particularly those relating to key issues of human rights, labor standards and the
environment, have universal importance for the organization.
3.56 To facilitate local implementation, the code should be translated into the appropriate local
language(s). A high-quality translation helps to ensure that the spirit and the intent of the
text has been captured.
3.57 Training in local operational units can also facilitate implementation. An organization
could focus training primarily on its own culture and values rather than the local national
culture. For example, an organization could state as an organizational principle that all
employees will be given equal opportunity and will be treated fairly at work, despite any
different local pre-existing traditions. In addition, the organization should look for
commonalities and similarities between organizational values and local characteristics,
and consider these in training.
PRINCIPLE G
Continuous awareness and promotion of the code and the wider approach to ethics and
compliance is an important part of conveying management’s commitment to their
underlying principles. A continuous awareness program should sustain interest in and
commitment to the code. Employees and others should be made aware of the consequences
of not adhering to the code.
3.58 Apathetic adherence to a code can be avoided with regular communications, especially
feedback on adherence and case studies dealing with ethical dilemmas. Awareness of the
code’s existence is only a first step. Success depends on employees’ awareness of the
code’s content and how its key features relate to their work. Publicizing positive behavior
and contributions of employees in developing the code, setting and acting in accordance
with the code and organizational values can facilitate continuing awareness and
adherence.
3.59 A procedure for disciplining employees who do not adhere to any part of the code should
be simple and involve an appropriate range of stakeholders, for example human
19
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
resources, legal, and trade union representatives. Employees should be told the facts that
support allegations of non-adherence, and how it will be dealt with. Prescribing fixed
actions for particular offences is not necessary, but the process for investigating alleged
non-adherence should be clearly described and action should be proportional to the
seriousness of confirmed non-adherence. Disciplinary and remedial measures should be
applied with consistency, particularly across management levels, and reviewed so to
prevent recurrences of inconsistent discipline.
3.60 The Code of Conduct should apply at all times to all employees, including Directors,
especially during periods when challenging issues and ethical dilemmas arise. A Board of
Directors should not countenance the suspension of a Code for difficult decisions
particularly where there are, or could be, conflicts of interest.
20
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
The first page of the code of conduct would contain a letter from the President/CEO of The ABC
Organization.
Code of Conduct
This document clarifies the responsibilities that The ABC Organization and its employees have
to each other, to our partners, and to our communities. It helps us understand the responsibilities
we share, and alerts us to important legal and conduct issues that may arise. You will not find
every organizational rule, policy or standard here. You may also not find every answer you seek.
You will, however, find the basic values and principles by which The ABC Organization has
chosen to govern itself.
The Ethics and Conduct Committee produced this code in consultation with the organization’s
main stakeholder groups. The company is committed to regular and meaningful engagement with
its stakeholders regarding its activities.
Employee are encouraged to raise any questions or concerns about workplace behavior. If doubts
exist – ask. Many improper actions are taken, not because of poor character or dishonest
intentions, but because someone did not have the proper information, did not understand the
information they had, or acted prompted by a desire to “just get things done.”
Any employee, who in good faith seeks advice, raises a concern or reports improper behavior, is
doing the right thing. The ABC Organization prohibits all personnel from taking any action
against an employee who reports a concern.
The Ethics and Conduct Committee is responsible for initiating and supervising the investigation
of all reports of non-adherence of this code and ensuring appropriate disciplinary action is taken
when required.
21
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
Integrity
The foundation of The ABC Organization is our integrity. We are open, honest and trustworthy in
dealing with customers, suppliers, contractors, representatives, co-workers, shareholders and the
communities we affect.
22
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
Customer
We support our customers’ success by creating exceptional value through innovative product and
service solutions.
Excellence
We relentlessly pursue excellence in everything we do.
People
We work in an inclusive environment that embraces change, new ideas, respect for the
individual, and equal opportunity to succeed.
Profitability
We strive for sustainable financial results that enable profitable growth and superior shareholder
value.
Accountability
We are accountable – individually and collectively – for our behaviors, actions, and results.
Management Responsibility
All organizational leaders must show a commitment to the organization’s values through their
actions. They must also promote an environment where compliance is expected and valued. All
employees must comply with the organization’s values and principles. No one may ask any ABC
Organization employee to break the law or go against organizational policy and values.
23
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
Harassment
The ABC Organization does not tolerate any form of harassment whether it be sexual, physical
or mental harassment. This includes bullying of employees. Employees are expected to be open,
honest, and courteous with each other.
Human Rights
The ABC Organization honors and respects all who choose to work for the organization. The
ABC Organization does not use child labor or forced labor. The ABC Organization respects the
freedom of individual employees to join or refrain from joining legally authorized associations or
organizations.
The company supports human rights consistent with the UN Declaration of Human Rights and
will consider carefully before trading with, or investing in, countries which are governed by
regimes that do not adhere to the UN Declaration.
Personal Relationships
The ABC Organization recognizes that all individuals have the right to work for the organization.
In some cases, family members or close personal friends of employees may also work for The
ABC Organization. In these situations, ABC Organization will avoid, where possible, work
situations that create a direct reporting relationship between family members or individuals with
a close personal relationship.
Other issues
Employees are not allowed to work under the influence of drugs or alcohol. Employees may not
act violently or threaten violence while at work, and are prohibited from bringing weapons and
illegal drugs onto the work site.
24
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
No employees may be involved with an activity that is in conflict with ABC Organization’s
business interests. Any personal interests in relation to the organization’s business must be
disclosed. A conflict of interest could include directorships, significant shareholdings and
employment of family members.
The ABC Organization will aim to develop relationships with its suppliers based on honesty,
fairness and mutual trust.
The ABC Organization will consider ways of supporting communities in which it operates
through charitable and educational activities and contributions (made within policies set by the
board of directors).
The ABC Organization will minimize any harmful effects of our operations on the natural
environment and finite resources. In doing so, we will set out environmental quality standards
which are desirable and attainable and comply fully with all relevant environmental legislation.
If you have questions about this code of conduct or concern about a co-worker’s conduct,
first contact your manager. If you do not feel comfortable doing that, contact one of these
other organizational resources:
• Human Resources Department
• Compliance Department
• Legal Department
• Audit Committee.
25
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
The Committee has set out “Seven Principles of Public Life” that it believes should apply to all
in the public service. These are:
Selflessness
Holders of public office should act solely in terms of the public interest. They should not do so in
order to gain financial or other benefits for themselves, their family or their friends.
Integrity
Holders of public office should not place themselves under any financial or other obligation to
outside individuals or organizations that might seek to influence them in the performance of their
official duties.
Objectivity
In carrying out public business, including making public appointments, awarding contracts, or
recommending individuals for rewards and benefits, holders of public office should make
choices on merit.
Accountability
Holders of public office are accountable for their decisions and actions, to the public and must
submit themselves to whatever scrutiny is appropriate to their office.
Openness
Holders of public office should be as open as possible about all the decisions and actions that
they take. They should give reasons for their decisions, and restrict information only when the
wider public interest clearly demands.
Honesty
Holders of public office have a duty to declare any private interests relating to their public duties,
and to take steps to resolve any conflicts arising in a way that protects the public interest.
Leadership
Holders of public office should promote and support these principles by leadership and example.
26
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act: First passed in 1977 and amended in 1988 and 1998, this Act
applies to US citizens and organizations around the world, and to non-US companies listed on
the New York Stock Exchange. It makes it a federal offense to give anything of value to foreign
officials, political parties, or candidates for public office to obtain a contract.
27
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
Customers
General Business Activity
Quality, Performance,
Trustworthiness
Community
Investors/creditors
An Economic and Overall
Personal/ ROI
Organization’s Social Impact Community Life
Institutional Finances
Basic Activities Government Taxpayers
28
IFAC PAIB COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL GOOD PRACTICE GUIDANCE
Appendix E: Resources
This list of resources is a brief selection of many available resources on this topic and
is not intended to be exhaustive. Use the IFAC KnowledgeNet at www.ifacnet.com to
search IFAC and many of its member body websites.
• Center for the Study of Ethics in the Professions, Illinois Institute of Technology, Codes of
Ethics online: http://ethics.iit.edu/codes/
• Center for Business Ethics at Bentley College http://www.bentley.edu/cbe/
• The Conference Board: www.conference-board.org
• Ethics Resource Center: www.ethics.org
• Group of 100: www.group100.com.au
• International Labour Organisation:
www.itcilo.it/english/actrav/telearn/global/ilo/code/main.htm
• Institute of Business Ethics: www.ibe.org.uk
Publications
• International Federation of Accountants Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants (2005):
www.ifac.org/Store/Details.tmpl?SID=9560085 866929
• CMA Canada (Management Accounting Practices publication), Ethics Control Systems:
http://www.cma-canada.org/
• OECD (2001), Codes of Corporate Conduct, An Expanded Review of their Contents:
http://www.oecd.org/
• World Bank (2003 and 2004), Company Codes of Conduct and international standards: an
analytical comparison, Part I: Apparel, Footwear and Light Manufacturing, Agribusiness and
Tourism; Part II: Oil and Gas, Mining: http://worldbank.org/
• Dando N & Raven W (2006), Living up to our Values, Developing Ethical Assurance, The
Institute of Business Ethics, ISBN 09539517 8 2
• Gebler D (2006), Creating an ethical culture, Values-based ethics programs can help
employees judge right from wrong, Strategic Finance
• Paine L & Margolis JD (2005), Up to the Code: Does Your Company’s Conduct Meet World-
Class Standards?, Harvard Business Review
• Webley S (2003), Developing a Code of Business Ethics, The Institute of Business Ethics
ISBN 0 9539517 4 – includes references to codes available on company websites
• Driscoll D & Hoffman W M (2000), Ethics Matters, How to Implement Values-Driven
Management, Center for Business Ethics, Bentley ISBN 0-9675514-0-4
29
International Federation of Accountants
545 Fifth Avenue, 14th Floor, New York, NY 10017 USA
Tel +1 (212) 286-9344 Fax +1 (212) 286-9570 www.ifac.org