Substation Asset Methodology Framework
Substation Asset Methodology Framework
Table of contents
1. Introduction ........................................................................................................................................................... 4
1.1 Purpose ................................................................................................................................................................... 4
1.2 Scope ....................................................................................................................................................................... 4
1.3 Objectives ................................................................................................................................................................ 4
1.4 Document Hierarchy .............................................................................................................................................. 6
1.5 References .............................................................................................................................................................. 6
1.6 Defined terms ......................................................................................................................................................... 7
1.7 Monitoring and compliance ................................................................................................................................... 7
1.8 Risk management .................................................................................................................................................. 7
2. Framework ........................................................................................................................................................... 10
2.1 Asset Profile .......................................................................................................................................................... 10
2.2 Stakeholder Requirements ................................................................................................................................. 10
2.2.1 Safety Compliance ....................................................................................................................................... 10
2.2.2 Environmental Compliance ......................................................................................................................... 11
2.2.3 Availability and Reliability of Supply .......................................................................................................... 12
2.2.4 Conformance with National Electricity Rules ........................................................................................... 12
2.2.5 Connection Agreements .............................................................................................................................. 12
1. Introduction
1.1 Purpose
The role of Powerlink’s asset management system is to ensure the organisation’s assets are managed to
optimise flexibility and cost-efficiency. The practices seek to acieve a balance between reliability, risk and
efficiency. In order to implement the organisation’s Asset Management Strategy specific asset management
methodologies must be developed for each major asset group within Powerlink.
This document sets out the whole of life management philosophy for Substation Plant covering all three stages
of an asset life cycle (as per ISO 55000) including planning, design, construction, acquisition, operation,
maintenance, renewal, life extension and disposal. It acts as a reference for the development of maintenance
and project budgets and forecasts.
1.2 Scope
This document covers the asset life cycle of the following high voltage substation plant and substation
infrastructure components:
• all high voltage substation equipment (including circuit breakers, disconnectors, instrument
transformers, earth switches, surge arrestors, power transformers, earthing transformers);
• all busbars and conductors (overhead) located inside substations fences and maintained by Powerlink;
• all reactive plant (including all capacitor banks, series and shunt reactors, earth reactors/resistors, static
VAr compensators, statcom devices);
• all substation site infrastructure including station supply transformers, direct and alternative substation
supply systems (station supply transformers, battery banks, chargers, controllers, standby supply
generators), oil separation systems, noise enclosures, and signage;
• all structures and foundations located within substations and maintained by Powerlink, excluding
communications structures;
• all substation land within the substation security fence and to a distance of five meters outside, earthing,
fences, and marshalling kiosks;
• all buildings, roadworks, cable trenches, switchyard lights and associated cabling located inside
substations; and
• compressed air systems, where applicable.
1.3 Objectives
Substation assets forms part of Powerlink’s asset management system documentation with the following key
elements shown in the diagram below:
The Substation Asset Methodology sets out how the following key performance areas are to be addressed:
• Levels of Service
• Lifecycle Management
• Asset Management Drivers
• Asset Management Activities (including maintenance, condition assessments, life extensions, technical
investigations, reporting, auditing and benchmarking)
• Environmental and Safety Compliance
1.5 References
Document Code
Document title
Document Code
Document title
Work Health and Safety Act Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld)
Work Health and Safety Regulation Work Health and Safety Regulation 2011 (Qld)
• Design Standards
Flood Moderate
• State Planning Guideline compliance
• Policies and Procedures
Acts of Theft and Vandalism Moderate • Policies and procedures
• Design Standards
• Site Radiation Folders
Exposure to EMF Moderate
• Policies and Procedures
• Monitoring of bare hand work levels
Working at Heights Moderate • Policies and Procedures
• Pre work risk assessment
• Design Standards for Substation
Unauthorised access to substations Moderate
Security
• Maintenance Policies and Procedures
• QEE Safe Access to High Voltage
Electric shock to personnel Low
Apparatus
• Policies and Procedures
• Training
• Switching sheets
• Live work procedures
• Design standards
2. Framework
Powerlink reviews the minimal number of insurance and maintenance spares in order to meet the requirements
of a dynamic and very diverse substation plant population. Where and when necessary Powerlink will also use
Network Support agreements and load curtailment measures . All planned outages are managed and co-
ordinated by Network Operations.
From 1 July 2018, a new rule will be implemented, to introduce more contestability for non-regulated
connections to the transmission network. This will change the traditional way of progressing connection
enquiries and requirements to provide additional public information around connections. This rule change
introduces two types of connection assets:
• A dedicated connection asset (DCA) services in which design, construction, ownership, operation and
maintenance can be provided by any party on commercial terms; and
• Contestable Identified User Shared Assets (IUSA) which can be designed, constructed and owned by a
third party but for which Powerlink will be responsible for operation and maintenance.
Powerlink will identify whether the proposed connection meets contestability criteria as per NER.
3. Lifecycle Management
Electricity transmission assets are high cost assets with a relatively long expected operating life. During the
Planning and Investment phase it is important to influence design, configuration and topology aspects of the
substation asset to provide a platform for achieving desired reliability, availability and maintainability at minimal
investment and life cycle cost. In order to achieve the best outcome for its stakeholders, Powerlink must
consider the asset’s whole of life cost. Minimising this cost is the basis of Powerlink’s asset management
approach and involves the following:
• optimisation of the standards, configurations and the design process.
• consideration of the asset’s expected operating life.
• the effective management of the asset’s lifecycle through targeted maintenance, refurbishment,
modifications, life extension, replacement and disposal activities.
This approach is often referred to as Lifecycle Management and includes three main stages:
required to bring them up to present day standards or to meet improved safety or operational requirements.
Examples of such activities are:
• installation of improved physical security measures
• installation of noise suppression systems to meet environmental standards, where appropriate
• upgrade of substation earthing systems
• replacement of plant items containing polychlorinated biphenyl (known as PCB) or asbestos to meet
WH&S requirements
• installation of improved oil separation systems to meet council or state environmental requirements
• replacement of power transformer bushings to reduce safety risk and extend life of power transformer
• replacement of circuit breaker operating mechanisms or their parts to achieve expected service life.
3.2.1 Maintenance
Maintenance strategy for substation plant is established using a Reliability-Centred Maintenance (RCM) model.
RCM provides a rigorous and verifiable analysis framework for identifying only those maintenance tasks that are
applicable and effective in managing possible failures. RCM analyses are undertaken by facilitated review
teams of technical experts and field personnel with the greatest knowledge of the Network Assets being
analysed. RCM also identifies those failures that cannot be dealt with effectively by maintenance alone, and
thus require other approaches to deal with them. This ensures that only practical, achievable and effective
maintenance tasks are adopted.
Prior to, or at the commissioning of a new type of substation plant item, a formalised Reliability-Centred
Maintenance analysis is organised to analyse potential failure modes and countermeasures resulting in the
development of the appropriate routine maintenance regime for that type of plant item.
Substation Plant consists of a mixture of static and moving plant of varying sophistication and complexity.
Typical substation plant failure modes relate to their inherent design characteristics, surrounding environment,
applied electrical load and stress and duty cycle.
Powerlink’s strategy for substation plant maintenance is based on an RCM applied philosophy of non-invasive
local and remote performance monitoring and condition assessment by condition monitoring and testing, with
invasive maintenance only being performed on a scheduled basis where there is no practical alternative.
Wherever it is cost effective to do so, remote performance and condition assessment of substation plant is
undertaken.
3.2.1.1 Routine scheduled
The nature of failure modes of substation plant means that the RCM developed maintenance strategy is
primarily based on the assessment of condition using visual inspection, condition monitoring, and testing. There
is a limited amount of time or duty based scheduled restoration or discard tasks. Various levels of routine
scheduled maintenance are applied as part of this strategy. They are:
3.2.1.1.1 Routine Substation Maintenance (RSM)
RSM is a non-invasive, visual inspection of all substation plant in a location, conducted on a regular basis as
specified by the maintenance policy. All equipment will remain live during an RSM.
3.2.1.1.2 Service Level Maintenance
Service Level Maintenance is conducted on specified plant in accordance with the appropriate maintenance
policy, and generally consists of more detailed and focused non-invasive condition monitoring and testing tasks,
such as contact resistance checks, or the collection of oil or gas samples for dissolved gas analysis (DGA)
testing. Where practical, service level maintenance is carried out on live equipment however planned outages
will be required on most equipment.
3.2.1.1.3 Overhaul
Overhauls are conducted on specified plant in accordance with the appropriate maintenance policy. Overhauls
are generally invasive requiring a planned outage.
3.2.1.2 Condition based
Continuous performance monitoring, routine scheduled maintenance, visual inspection, condition monitoring,
and testing are all used to detect deterioration of condition or degradation of performance of substation plant
that will, if allowed to continue, result in asset failure sometime in the future. Condition Based Maintenance
restores the condition or performance of the asset to an acceptable level before failure occurs. Reduction of
planned outage time and cost to carry out condition based maintenance is a major objective. This will be
achieved by:
• use of live maintenance techniques
• optimum work packaging and scheduling
• use of on-line, remote monitoring where practical.
3.2.1.3 Emergency Corrective
Emergency corrective maintenance is the immediate work that must be performed to minimise the danger to
personnel and equipment and to restore the system to service. The emergency work is typically initiated through
Network Operations requesting that staff be immediately called out to rectify a situation.
3.2.1.4 Deferred Corrective
Deferred corrective maintenance is all work associated with rectifying an unacceptable plant condition to an
acceptable condition, which is not emergency in nature. In addition to the actual “hands on” work to rectify a
fault, this category of maintenance also includes the subsequent investigations and reports relating to plant
failures.
3.2.1.5 Maintenance Support
Maintenance support tasks are those activities which are related to the ongoing maintenance and operation of
the plant, but which do not specifically involve the plant itself. Examples include carrying out risk assessments,
defect analysis and periodically reviewing the main substation plant item populations to consider changes in
reliability performance. Maintenance tasks resulting from these investigations and reviews are documented as
quality procedures and incorporated into the policies, procedures and secondary documentation for the different
plant groups. Typically for substation plant, the defects are analysed and the results are used to modify
maintenance and assist with selection of new plant.
The fault level and capacity of substation plant items are analysed annually and the recommendations are
submitted where potential encroachments are noted.
Table 3 - Asset Maintenance Types
3.2.2 Refurbishment
Refurbishment of substation plant is triggered where plant does not function in accordance with the original
design, identified through condition assessment, routine inspection, servicing or testing activities.
Refurbishment may also be required where plant, equipment or site infrastructure no longer complies with
relevant legislation and statutory requirements, or changed customer’s expectations and/or requirements.
Typical refurbishment activities involve the replacement of specific items of plant or equipment forming part of a
switching bay asset (e.g. instrument transformer due to poor physical condition or oil sampling results), work to
repair main tank corrosion, oil leaks and other defects on power transformers, or work to upgrade or repair
degraded infrastructure (e.g. erosion on roadways, poor drainage, corrosion on support structures), replacement
of battery banks if they fail routine test, etc.
workers or the public is assessed as compromised. A number of substation assets fail while in service typically
as a result of random or inherited design failures.
Powerlink’s’ asset management system aims to minimise the number of such failures. Typically, Powerlink
substation assets are expected to last for 40 years, however this can vary between items depending on design,
construction, installation, maintenance, duty and environmental conditions. For example most modern
transmission circuit breakers are expected to last up to 40 years although this is dependent on technology.
Circuit breakers that switch generators or reactive plant are operated more frequently and may require major
refurbishment or replacement after half the nominal life. They often reach the maximum rated number of
operations after 25-30 years of service.
Substation equipment condition is monitored using equipment health indices. These are updated on an annual
basis. Based on these and additional information provided by maintenance service providers and availability
and forced outages reports, desktop and detailed condition assessments are initiated. Condition assessment
provides an indication of defective and deteriorated items and may initiate further investigation and analysis of
the data to determine the level of deterioration. It provides estimated remaining service life for each asset,
equipment and/or component. Where possible the holistic condition of all assets at a substation is assessed
collectively to arrive at the optimum solution for refurbishment or reinvestment for the site.
4.1.1 Condition Assessment Process
For the purposes of condition assessment, substations can be viewed as a hierarchical construction of plant and
equipment items. The items combine into functional groups that make up individual assets and the assets
combine together to comprise a substation.
Powerlink applies condition assessments to assess the risks associated with substation plant from a range of
perspectives including impact on safety, network operations, business strategy, finance and contractual
obligations, impact on major stakeholders, project costs, and environmental and cultural heritage. Condition
assessments combined with planning reports are also used as a basis for the development of options for
refurbishment or reinvestment where this is considered necessary. Difficulties associated with obtaining access
to operational assets and associated costs may results in Powerlink carrying out replacement or major
refurbishment projects at the asset level or even at a substation level. The economic analysis indicates that the
replacement of the individual plant items in a piecemeal fashion may not always result in the optimum cost
savings. For this reason it is important to consider all options for replacement or major refurbishment.. The
substation plant methodology includes condition assessment activities at each level to enable this to occur.
These activities are initiated and managed by Powerlink’s Substation Asset Strategy team.
The replacement strategy always considers use of modern or improved technological solutions for substation
equipment which can reduce safety risks, improve availability and reliability or reduce environmental footprint.
These improvements are driven by Substation Asset Strategy team through development of specific equipment
strategies.
4.1.2 Condition Data
4.1.2.1 Plant Item Level
Plant items such as circuit breakers, instrument transformers, isolators, earth switches, power transformers,
reactive power plant (capacitors, reactors and SVCs), busbars and substation structures are the building blocks
from which the substation is constructed. In addition there are many elements that comprise substation
infrastructure such as substation buildings, roads, fences, switchyard lighting, oil separation systems, noise
enclosures, substation auxiliary supply, and direct current supply systems. The condition of these items is
monitored during routine inspection and servicing as applicable. Defects are reported and recorded in SAP and
the data is analysed annually using equipment health indices. This information is used to identify corrective and
condition based maintenance programs, as well as to initiate desktop and detailed condition assessments.
Where common defects are noted for a population of items, the information can be used to trigger operational
refurbishment projects.
Condition information for primary plant items can include details on:
• fluid containment and grades of metal corrosion from visual inspection
• contact and current carrying path resistances and localised hot spot temperatures
• insulation resistance, capacitance and dielectric information for graded insulation systems
• dissolved gas analysis and oil quality information from oil-insulated plant
• moisture and contaminant information from SF6 insulated plant
• operations counts and hour run meters from mechanical switching devices
• electrical partial discharge measurements to detect insulation breakdown
• performance tests undertaken during service such as circuit breaker travel and operating time
measurements
• details of failed and replaced components
• number of initiated alarms.
Determination of the complete condition of a plant item requires analysis of the appropriate parameters,
weighting each result in a manner determined by the importance of the parameter and then combining the
information to give a total result for each item. This provides a holistic representation of the condition or health
of the item and provides a means to rank the condition of each item within the population. Powerlink utilises a
health index methodology for this.
Health index is a consistent and logical means of combining relatively complex and diverse condition
information about a specific equipment item. It gives a total score between 1 and 10 representing the item’s
overall condition relative to that of the other items within the equipment population. Application of health index
requires engineering expertise, statistical data and judgement. To be of use in assessing future actions, the
health index profile for an equipment type needs to bear a relationship with the probability of failure or hazard
rate for equipment items, particularly those at the deteriorated end of the curve. This requires calibration with
real failure data. In addition the algorithm is designed to provide a predictive assessment of how the health
index profile will change in the future as an item’s condition goes through process of further deterioration. .
Health index provides a means to identify items that are performing satisfactorily as well as those that are
performing poorly enabling resources to focus on those items that should be targeted for detailed condition
assessment now, or in the near future to form basis to plan their repair, refurbishment or reinvestment. Health
index information is used to identify outliers for potential corrective and condition based maintenance activities.
4.1.3 Engineering Data
Engineering information relating to the designed performance of the asset is collated. This could include
information on structure, electrical ratings and capacity, and layout design. It also includes consideration of an
individual item’s performance in the service environment, design vulnerabilities and assumptions, historical
performance of similar assets and industry experience as well as any change in standards or legislation. This
activity is undertaken by strategies and standards groups.
4.1.4 Condition Assessment Report
The Condition Assessment Report for substation plant assets is the product of the Condition Assessment and
Engineering Data investigations. The Condition Assessment Report will take the engineering, loading and
condition data and apply analytical techniques, modelling, expected future performance criteria, based on
probability of failure curves and probabilistic evaluation to determine the decision criteria for the risk
assessment. This activity will be undertaken by Powerlink strategies engineers, planning engineers and
connection and development managers (regarding future performance requirements) and design groups in
consultation with the respective maintenance service provider for the asset.
The objectives of the Condition Assessment Report are to:
• determine and document the condition of the equipment or assets with respect to the decision criteria
• determine estimated remaining service life for each equipment
• provide an input for:
o life extension,
o corrective and condition based maintenance recommendations,
o high level scope of work for refurbishment, or
6. Supporting Activities
6.5 Documentation
The Substation Strategies Team conveys asset management requirements through the Substation Asset
Methodology framework and a number of asset management documents that are reviewed every two years and
promote the development of documentation and field guides to ensure substation plant strategies remain
relevant and are in accordance with good industry practice.
6.7 Benchmarking
Powerlink participate in benchmarking with other worldwide located electricity entities through bi-annual data
submission via ITOMS.
In addition RIN (Regulatory Information Notice) are analysed and benchmarked with other TNSPs in Australia.
8. Forward Planning
A ten year forward plan is prepared per regional area and network segments basis, outlining the projects by
type, location and expected completion date as well as scheduled condition assessments.
All routine maintenance plans are entered into SAP by outage group. These are combined with project outages
and assessed 12 months in advance to minimise requirements for outages and ensure network security is
maintained