2 Utility Analysis

Let's recall : 2) Subjective concept : It is a psychological

concept. Utility differs from person to
1) Want denotes a feeling of lack of
person. This is due to differences in taste,
satisfaction.
preferences, likes, dislikes, nature, habits,
2) Wants are unlimited.
profession etc. For example, stethoscope
3) They are recurring in nature.
has utility to a doctor but not to a layman.
4) They differ with age, gender, seasons,
habits and culture. 3) Ethically neutral concept : The concept of
5) Utility is the capacity of a commodity utility has no ethical consideration. It is a
morally colourless concept. The commodity
to satisfy human wants. In other words,
should satisfy any want of a person without
utility is the want satisfying power of a
consideration of what is good or bad,
good.
desirable or undesirable. For example, a
Introduction : knife has utility to cut fruits and vegetables
You have been already introduced to the as well as it can be used to harm someone.
concept of utility in class XI. This unit gives a Both wants are of different nature but are
detailed explanation of consumer’s behaviour. satisfied by the same commodity. Thus,
In practice, every individual tries to utility is ethically neutral.
satisfy his wants with available resources. 4) Utility differs from usefulness : Utility
It is true that all human wants cannot be is the capacity of a commodity to satisfy
satisfied fully at a specific time. Utility analysis human wants, whereas usefulness indicates
explains a consumer’s behaviour in relation to value in use of the commodity. For example,
maximization of satisfaction. milk has both utility as well as usefulness to
a consumer, while liquor has utility only to
Try this : an addict, but has no usefulness.
1) Make a list of 10 commodities which
5) Utility differs from pleasure : A
  satisfy your wants. commodity may possess utility but it may
2) Make a list of 10 commodities which not give any pleasure to the consumer. For
satisfy the wants of particular individuals example, injection for a patient has utility
performing specific activities. For because it cures the ailment but it hardly
example, A chalk has utility for a teacher. gives any enjoyment or pleasure to him.
6) Utility differs from satisfaction : Utility
Features of Utility : is a cause of consumption, satisfaction is
Following are the features of utility : the end result of consumption. They are
1) Relative concept : Utility is related to interrelated but still different concepts. For
time and place. It varies from time to example, a thirsty person drinks a glass
time and place to place. For example, (i) of water since water has the capacity to
woollen clothes have a greater utility in the satisfy thirst. Utility of water is the cause of
winter. (ii) sand has greater utility at the consumption and the satisfaction derived is
construction site than at the sea shore. the end result of consumption.

8
 7) Measurement of utility is hypothetical : 2) Place utility : When utility of a commodity
Utility is an abstract concept. Cardinal or increases due to a change in its place, it is
numerical measurement of utility is not called place utilities. For example, woollen
possible. For example, a thirsty person clothes have more utility at cold places than
after drinking water, may derive higher or at warm places. Transport creates place
lower level of utility. Thus, utility can only utility.
be experienced and found either positive,
zero or negative. Negative utility is called
disutility.
8) Utility is multi-purpose : A commodity
can satisfy the want of more than one
person, it can also be put to several uses.
For example, electricity can be used to
serve many purposes and for many people   Fig. 2.2
at some point of time. 3) Service utility : Service utility arises when
9) Utility depends on the intensity of want : personal services are rendered by various
Utility depends on the intensity of a want. professionals. For example, services of
More intense the want, greater will be the doctors, teachers, lawyers etc.
utility. As and when the urgency of want
declines, utility diminishes. For example,
a hungry person finds more utility in food,
than a person who is not hungry.
10) Utility is the basis of demand : A person
will demand a commodity only if it gives
utility to him. For example, a sick person
has utility in medicines hence, he demands
medicines. Fig. 2.3

Types of Utility : 4) Knowledge utility : When a consumer

Following are some of the different types of utility acquires knowledge about a particular
1) Form utility : When utility is created due product, it is called knowled uitility. For
to a change in the shape or structure of an example, utility of a mobile phone or a
existing material, it is called form utility. computer increases when a person knows
For example, toys made of clay, furniture about its various functions.
from wood etc.

Fig. 2.1 Fig. 2.4

9
 5) Possession utility : Possession utility arises
Try this :
when the ownership of goods is transferred
Following are the various types of utility
from one person to another. For example,
and their respective examples. Arrange the
transfer of goods from the sellers to the
information in the form of pairs:
buyers.
Types of utility : Time utility, possession
utility, service utility and place utility.
Examples : 1) A dentist giving dental
treatment to a patient.
2) A mountaineer using oxygen cylinder at
a high altitude.
  3) A farmer selling rice stored in the
    Fig. 2.5 warehouse at the end of the season.
4) A retail trader purchasing 100 chairs
6) Time utility : When the utility of a
from the wholesale trader.
commodity increases with a change in its
time of utilization, it is called time utility. Concepts of Utility :
For example, a student has more utility for Following are the two main concepts of
text books during examinations than in the utility :
vacations. Time utility is also observed 1) Total Utility (TU) : Total utility refers
when goods are stored and used at the time to the aggregate of utility derived by the
of scarcity. For example, Blood bank. consumer from all units of a commodity
consumed. It is an aggregate of utilities
from all successive units of a commodity
consumed.
2) Marginal Utility (MU) : Marginal utility
refers to the additional utility derived by
  a consumer from an additional unit of a
commodity consumed. In other words, it
is the addition made by the last unit of a
Fig. 2.6 A commodity consumed.

Fig. 2.6 B Fig. 2.6 C Fig. 2.6 D

10
 TU Curve = Total Utility Curve
You should know :
Formulae explaining the relationship MU Curve = Marginal Utility Curve
between total utility and marginal utility : X axis measures the units of the commodity
TU = Σ MU or consumed while Y axis indicates the figures of
TU = MU1 + MU2 + MU3 ……….. + MUn
total and marginal utility.
MUn = TUn – TU(n–1)
Where TU = Total Utility Fig. 2.7 shows that total utility curve slopes
MU = Marginal Utility upwards whereas marginal utility curve slopes
MU1, MU2, MU3 = Marginal Utility of each unit. downwards. Marginal utility curve shows zero
MUn = Marginal Utility of nth unit. and negative levels of marginal utility whereas
TUn = Total Utility at nth level. total utility curve shows maximum and constant
TU(n–1) = Total Utility at previous level. total utility level.
Relationship between Total Utility and 1) Total utility and marginal utility of the very
Marginal Utility : first unit of x consumed, are the same.
Marginal utility derived from various
2) As the consumer consumes further
units of a commodity and its total utility are units of x, the total utility increases at a
interrelated. This can be easily followed from diminishing rate and marginal utility goes
the hypothetical example given in the table 2.1 on diminishing. (TU MU)
Table 2.1 Utility Schedule 3) At a particular stage, total utility reaches to
Units of x Total utility Marginal utility
1 10 10
its maximum and remains constant whereas
2 18 8 marginal utility becomes zero. This is called
3 24 6 the point of satiety. (TU highest, MU = 0)
4 28 4
4) After this point, any additional unit
5 30 2
6 30 0 consumed further results in a decline in the
7 28 –2 total utility, while marginal utility becomes
Table 2.1 explains the relationship between negative. (TU MU negative)
total utility and marginal utility. 5) After reaching the point of satiety, a rational
On the basis of Table 2.1 Total utility and consumer should stop his consumption
Marginal Utility curves (TU and MU) can be since the maximum limit of satisfaction is
derived with the following diagram. reached and there is no addition to total
Y Point of satiety
32 utility by any further increase in the stock
S
28
of a commodity.
TU
Curve 6) Consumption beyond the point of satiety
Total and Marginal utility

24
transforms satisfaction into dissatisfaction.
20
In other words, a consumer starts
16
experiencing ill effects of consumption.
12

8 Try this :
Complete the following chart with proper
4
statement and bring about the difference
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 X
MU
between the two concepts i.e total utility
-4 Disutility Curve and marginal utility.
Units of Commodity x    Fig. 2.7
11
 which a person derives from a given increase
Total Utility Marginal Utility in his stock of a thing, diminishes with every
1) Total utility is the 1) Marginal utility increase in the stock that he already has.”
sum total of the is the addition In other words, marginal utility that any
individual utilities made to the total
consumer derives from successive units of a
derived from the utility from every
consumption of a additional unit particular commodity goes on diminishing as
single unit of good. consumed. his or her total consumption of that commodity
2) Total utility 2) increases. In short, the more of a thing you have,
increases at a the less you want to have more of it.
diminishing rate.
Assumptions :
3) 3) At the point of Following are the assumptions of the law of
satiety MU = O
diminishing marginal utility :
4) Total utility 4) 1) Rationality : Consumer is assumed to
declines if be rational. It means that his behaviour
consumption is normal and he tries to maximize his
continues.
satisfaction.
5) Total utility deter- 5)
mines value in use 2) Cardinal measurement : The law assumes
of a commodity. that utility can be cardinally or numerically
6) 6) Marginal utility measured. Hence, mathematical operations
can be positive, are easily possible to know and compare
negative, zero. the utility derived from each unit of a
7) Diagram : 7) Diagram : commodity.
y
3) Homogeneity : All units of a commodity
4 consumed are exactly homogeneous or
TU

TU curve identical in size, shape, colour, taste etc.

2
4) Continuity : All units of commodity are
0 Units x consumed in quick succession without any
lapse of time.
Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility : 5) Reasonability : All the units of a commodity
Introduction : consumed are of reasonable size. They are
This law was first proposed by Prof. Gossen neither too big nor too small.
but was discussed in detail by Prof. Alfred 6) Constancy : All the related factors like
Marshall in his book ‘Principles of Economics’ income, tastes, habits, choices, likes,
published in 1890. dislikes of a consumer should remain
The law of diminishing marginal utility constant. Marginal utility of money is also
is universal in character. It is based on the assumed to be constant.
common consumer behaviour that utility derived 7) Divisibility : The law assumes that the
diminishes with the reduction in the intensity of commodity consumed by the consumer is
a want. divisible so that it can be acquired in small
Statement of the Law : quantities.
According to Prof. Alfred Marshall, “Other 8) Single want : A given commodity can
things remaining constant, the additional benefit satisfy a single want of a person. The law
12
 assumes an experience of a single want brings disutility (negative utility) which is shown
which is completely satiable at a given by the shaded portion in the diagram.
point of time. Exceptions to the Law of Diminishing
Table 2.2 explains the Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility :
Marginal Utility.
Following are the exceptions to the law of
Table : 2.2
diminishing marginal utility :
Units of x Marginal Utility (MU)
1 10 1) Hobbies : In certain hobbies like collection
2 8 of various stamps and coins, rare paintings,
3 6 music, reading etc., the law does not hold
4 4 true because every additional increase in the
5 2 stock gives more pleasure. This increases
6 0 marginal utility. However, this violates the
7 –2 assumption of homogeneity and continuity.
The table shows that marginal utility keeps 2) Miser : In the case of a miser, every
on diminishing with increase in consumption, additional rupee gives him more and more
further it becomes zero and then negative. satisfaction. Marginal utility of money
Y tends to increase with an increase in his
MU MU = Marginal Utility Curve
10 stock of money. However, this situation
ignores the assumption of rationality.
8
Marginal utility

3) Addictions : It is observed in case of a

6
drunkard that the level of intoxication
4 increases with every additional unit of
2 liquor consumed. So MU received by
drunkard may increase. Actually it is
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 X only an illusion. This condition is similar
MU
-2 Disutility to almost all addictions. However, this
Units of Commodity x violates the assumption of rationality.
Fig. 2.8 4) Power : This is an exception to the law
Explanation of the Diagram : because when a person acquires power, his
In the above diagram, units of commodity x lust for power increases. He desires to have
are measured on X axis and marginal utility is more and more of it. However, this again
measured on Y axis. Various points of MU are violates the rationality assumption.
plotted on the graph as per the given schedule. 5) Money : It is said that the MU of money
When the locus of all the points is joined, MU never becomes zero. It increases when the
curve is derived. stock of money increases. This is because
MU curve slopes downwards from left to money is a medium of exchange which is
right which shows that MU goes on diminishing used to satisfy various wants. However,
with every successive increase in the consumption according to some economists, this law
of a commodity. is applicable to money too. For example,
When MU becomes zero, MU curve intercepts marginal utility of money is more to a poor
the X axis. Further consumption of a commodity person than to a rich person.

13
 However, these, exceptions are only resources, it is necessary to ‘diversify’ the
apparent. Since they violate some or the consumption.
other assumptions of the law and hence, 2) Useful to the government : The law is
they are not real exceptions. useful to the government in framing various
Criticisms of the Law : policies such as progressive tax policy,
The law of diminishing marginal utility is trade policy, pricing policy etc.
criticised on the following grounds. 3) Basis of paradox of values : The law
1) Unrealistic assumptions : The law of of diminishing marginal utility helps us
diminishing marginal utility is based upon to understand the paradox of values. It
various assumptions like homogeneity, includes goods that have more value-in-use
continuity, constancy, rationality etc. but and zero or less value-in-exchange such as
in reality it is difficult to fulfil all these air, water, sunshine etc. as well as goods
conditions at a point of time. that have more value-in-exchange and less
value-in-use such as gold, diamonds etc.
2) Cardinal measurement : The law assumes
4) Basis of law of demand : The law of demand
that utility can be expressed cardinally so
is based on the law of diminishing marginal
it can be added, compared and presented
utility. According to the law of demand, the
through a schedule. In reality cardinal
quantity demanded of a good rises with a
measurement of utility is not possible
fall in price and falls with an increase in
because utility is a psychological concept.
price. When a consumer purchases more
3) Indivisible goods : The law is not and more units of a good, its marginal
applicable to indivisible and bulky goods utility steadily declines. Hence, he would
like refrigerator, car, TV sets etc. which are buy additional units of a commodity only
normally purchased in single unit at a time. at a lower price.
4) Constant marginal utility of money : The
law assumes that MU of each unit of money Try this :
remains constant. However, critics argue Write an informative note on paradox of
that MU of money differs from person to values along with examples.
person. It is influenced by changes in prices, Relationship between Marginal Utility and
stock of money etc. Price :
5) A single want : The law is restricted to Let us discuss the relationship between
the satisfaction of a single want at a point marginal utility and price in order to understand
of time. However, in reality, a man has to how the law of diminishing marginal utility
satisfy many wants at a point of time. forms the basis of law of demand. It is a perfect
Significance of the Law : example of practical application of the law of
In spite of the criticisms, the law of Diminishing Marginal Utility (DMU).
diminishing marginal utility is a very popular To understand the relation, it is essential
and an important law in Economics because of to convert marginal utility in terms of money so
its universal application. that it can be compared with market price.
1) Usefulness to the consumers : This law Let us assume : One unit of marginal utility =
creates awareness among the consumers. ` 10.
To obtain maximum utility from the limited Market price per unit of x = ` 50.
14
 Table 2.3 marginal utility and price :
No MU/ MU in terms Market Comparison 1) Units which a consumer willingly buys
of units of money price/unit between MU because MU is greater than price are called
units of x 1unit = ` 10 of x = ` 50 and price
“Intra-marginal units” (MUx>Px)
1 10 100 (10 × `10 ) ` 50 100 MU> `50

2) Unit at which MU becomes equal
2 8 80 (8 × ` 10 ) ` 50 80 MU> `50
with market price is “marginal unit”.
3 7 70 (7 × ` 10 ) ` 50 70 MU> `50 (MUx=Px) = Consumer’s equilibrium
4 5 50 (5 × ` 10 ) ` 50 50 MU = `50 3) Units which a rational consumer is not
5 3 30 (3 × ` 10 ) ` 50 30 MU< `50 willing to buy and consume where he has
6 1 10 (1 × ` 10 ) ` 50 10 MU< `50 to pay more than the MU are called “Extra-
marginal units.” (MUx<Px)
Table 2.3 explains the relationship between Thus, a rational consumer attains
marginal utility (MU) and price. equilibrium where MUx=Px. This relationship
The table shows that a consumer between marginal utility and price paved way
starts buying units of commodity x for his for law of demand.
consumption, one after the other. Marginal
utility which is added to his stock goes on Do you know?
diminishing with every further unit consumed. Two English Economists, J. R. Hicks
When MU is converted in terms of money, one and R. G. D. Allen were
can easily compare it with market price which is the main exponents of
shown in the column 5 of the table 2.3 ‘Indifference Method’. It
For the first three units consumed, it is was evolved to supersede
found that marginal utility in terms of money is cardinal utility analysis
greater than the price paid. A rational consumer given by Prof. Alfred
will willingly buy these units since the benefit J R Hicks Marshall. Indifference curve
derived is more than the price paid. At the 4th analysis adopts the concept
unit marginal utility and price become equal. of ordinal utility.
So the consumer can also think of buying the   An indifference curve is
4th unit. In the case of 5th and 6th units, marginal the locus of points indicating
utility derived is less than the market price paid. particular combinations of
A rational consumer will not buy further once two goods from which the
the equality between marginal utility and price consumer derives the same
R.G.D Allen
is established. level of satisfaction. As
From the given table 2.3, following a result, he is indifferent to the particular
inferences can be made with reference to combination that he consumes.

15
 EXERCISE

Q. 1. A) Complete the following statements by 2) Statments indicating consumer equilibrium :

choosing the correct alternatives. a) MU is greater than price
1) In the law of diminishing marginal utility, b) MU is equal to price
Alfred Marshall assumes that marginal utility c) MU is less than price
of money………. d) Price is less than one
a) increases b) remains constant Options :
c) decreases d) rises and then falls   i) a and b   ii) a, b, c and d
iii) a, b and c iv) only b
2) As per the law of diminishing marginal utility,
measurement of utility is assumed to be ………. Q. 3. Identify and explain the concepts from the
given illustration :
a) ordinal
1) Salma purchased sweater for her father in
b) cardinal
winter season.
c) both ordinal and cardinal
2) Nilesh purchased ornaments for his sister.
d) none of the above
3) Kavita consumed five units of oranges one after
3) MU of the commodity becomes negative when the other.
TU of a commodity is ……… 4) Bhushan refused to eat fifth chapati after eating
a) rising   b) constant   c) falling   d) zero four chapatis.
5) Lalita satisfied her want of writing on essay by
4) Point of Satiety means ……….
using pen and notebook.
a) TU is rising and MU is falling
Q. 4. Observe the given table and answer the
b) TU is falling and MU is negative
questions:
c) TU is maximum and MU is zero Unit of a commodity TU units MU units
d) MU is falling and TU is rising. 1 6 6
2 11 5
5) When MU is falling, TU is……….
3 15 4
a) rising b) falling 4 15 0
c) not changing d) maximum 5 14 –1
1) Draw total utility curve and marginal utility
Q. 2. Choose the correct option :
curve.
1) A    B
1) Time utility a) Transport 2) a) When total utility is maximum marginal
utility is
2) Place utility b) Blood Bank
3) Service utility c) Mobile phone b) When total utility falls, marginal utility
becomes
4) Knowledge utility d) Doctor
Options : Q. 5. Answer in detail :
 i) 1-d, 2-b, 3-a, 4-c   ii) 1-b, 2-a, 3-d, 4-c 1) State and explain the law of diminishing
iii) 1-a, 2-b, 3-c, 4-d   iv) 1-b, 2-c, 3-d, 4-a marginal utility with exceptions.



16