Cargile Statement
Cargile Statement
voluntarily dismissed with prejudice all claims in the right of publicity lawsuit brought against
Serial Productions, LLC, Brian Reed, and the other creators of the podcast S-Town. The lawsuit,
which was filed in July 2018, was captioned Cargile v. Serial Productions, LLC, This American
Life Benefit Corporation, Brian Reed, Chicago Public Media, Inc., Shittown, LLC, Serial
Podcast, LLC, and American Whatever, LLC, case No. 7:18-cv-01667-LSC, in the Western
Division of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Alabama.
I have learned through the discovery and a review of other facts made available since this
suit was filed that Mr. McLemore was an avid listener and fan of This American Life and its
programming, and that over the course of two years, he invited and encouraged Mr. Reed, an
award-winning journalist, to create a program about his small town. He participated actively as a
documentary subject and source for the story that would become S-Town, partaking in many
interviews with Mr. Reed, and encouraging others to be interviewed as well. I have concluded
that Serial Productions, Mr. Reed, and the other creators of S-Town acted responsibly and
of Mr. McLemore’s family. I served as the Guardian ad Litem to John B. McLemore’s mother,
Mary Grace McLemore (who was not able to act on her own), a position I was selected for by
random appointment from the Probate Court. Then, one month after release of the S-Town
podcast and almost two years after Mr. McLemore’s death, I petitioned the Probate Court of
Bibb County, Alabama, to create an estate and appoint me as administrator. A member of the
1
McLemore family filed a competing petition in Probate Court to be appointed administrator, but
Pursuant to the appointment from the Probate Court of Bibb County, Alabama, but
without the prior knowledge or consent of Mr. McLemore’s family, I filed this right of publicity
lawsuit against Serial Productions, Brian Reed, and the other creators of the S-Town podcast on
As the administrator of the Estate of John B. McLemore, I declare that the estate has no
objection or claim to the podcast, nor does the estate have any objection or claim to any future
uses of the podcast or the journalistic and creative work relating to John B. McLemore by the