Faith and Intimate Partner Violence: Handbook For Advocates
Faith and Intimate Partner Violence: Handbook For Advocates
Faith and Intimate Partner Violence: Handbook For Advocates
Partner Violence
Handbook for Advocates
A collaborative publication produced by the
Florida Coalition Against Domestic Violence
and FaithTrust Institute
None of us, as helpers, should ever put a
battered woman in the position of having to
choose between safety and the support of
her faith community. She needs both, and
it’s up to us to provide that.
~ Rev. Dr. Marie Fortune
Table of Contents
Introduction..........................................................................................................3
First Things First: Your Views................................................................................6
Assessment..........................................................................................................8
A Crisis of Faith is a Crisis.....................................................................................10
Honoring the Diversity of Faith-Based Beliefs amongst Survivors..........................12
Assessing Faith-Based Referral Sources...............................................................14
Engaging Faith Leaders........................................................................................15
Opportunities for Community Collaboration..........................................................17
Coordinated Response by Faith Communities......................................................18
FAQ......................................................................................................................20
1
An informed, compassionate advocate and
a knowledgeable religious leader can make
all the difference for a victim/survivor
who is experiencing domestic violence.
An adequate advocate’s response that
includes competent and sensitive religious
and cultural concerns, combined with the
resources of the wider community, can save
lives and bring healing where there has been
woundedness.
~ Rev. Thelma Burgonia-Watson, from “Walking Together: Working with Women from Diverse Religious and
Spiritual Traditions”
Introduction
In Florida, 7.36 million of 18.8
Why is faith an important consideration in advocacy? million residents are either
full members or are regular
Religion is a primary cultural and personal influence.
attendees of a religious
Nearly eight in ten Americans are religiously affiliated.1
congregation, including
For many people, including survivors, religious beliefs are Catholics, Protestants, Jews,
intrinsic and influence the way they see themselves, make Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists,
sense of their situations, weigh their options, and make and others2. These figures do
decisions. Advocates must recognize this influence and not include those who attend
respect survivors’ understanding of their identities and faith less regularly, or did not
traditions. report a specific faith tradition
yet may still practice privately.
Cultural Competence is essential. Cultural competency is
critical to providing sensitive, safe, and informed services Domestic violence advocates
to survivors of intimate partner violence. Spirituality, or the regularly serve survivors with
practice of faith, is an important aspect of culture. Just as you religious/spiritual beliefs.
honor and respect the language, diet, and other customs of
survivors, it is important to respect their spiritual beliefs. If you
don’t understand and value faith as part of a survivor’s story, you are missing out on possible options
for safety, encouragement and support for the survivor.
Survivors have spoken. Many survivors have shared that their spiritual beliefs and faith
communities have been critical resources in survival and healing. You should not minimize or ignore
those beliefs if you are going to effectively utilize every option and resource available.
Spiritual: of or relating to the spirit or soul, as distinguished from the physical nature
Spirituality: the state or quality of being dedicated to God, a higher power, religion, or spiritual
things or values, especially as contrasted with material or temporal ones
Faith Community: a body of persons adhering to a particular set of beliefs and practices
http://www.pewforum.org/religious-landscape-study/
1
http://www.thearda.com/rcms2010/r/s/12/rcms2010_12_state_rate_2010.asp.
2
3
Religion can be a resource
or a roadblock.
When intimate partner violence enters their A crisis of faith is a crisis. See page 10
lives, survivors who find meaning in their faith for more examples and discussion.
may experience a profound spiritual crisis.
4
Roadblocks are factors that contribute to the
perpetuation of violence and compromise
the safety of survivors and their children.
Roadblocks:
• Misuse sacred texts or teachings to justify,
minimize, or excuse intimate partner violence
• Fail to understand that violence in a
relationship/marriage breaks any covenantal
bonds
• Prioritize forgiveness and restoration over
safety of the survivor
• Perpetuate silence and shame
5
First Things First: Your Views
Your perception and experience impact your advocacy. Your interactions must be survivor-
focused and your approach should be guided by curiosity and unconditional positive regard. This
means you want to learn the survivor’s story, believing and accepting it despite your personal views.
You need to consider your personal experiences with faith, spirituality and/or religion,
both positive and negative. Here are some questions to ask yourself:
• What is my personal experience with religion and faith?
• If it has been negative, how will I find a way to be a resource to a survivor who discusses
her spirituality?
• If it has been positive, how do I experience it as a resource in my work as an advocate?
• How do I feel about people who do not share my particular faith experience or traditions?
• How do I feel about others who don’t believe as I do?
• What do I know about the survivor’s faith tradition, and how do I know it? Might I have a
bias?
• Have I ever been harmed by someone – especially a person in a position of authority–
from a faith community? If so, how has this experience affected my perceptions?
• How will I set aside my views in order to best serve those who are involved in a faith
tradition that I view as abusive, misogynistic, or otherwise oppressive?
• What steps can I take to ensure I don’t proselytize* or influence their decision around
spiritual beliefs and faith communities?
• If someone from my faith tradition wants to discuss faith issues, am I comfortable sharing
my perspective?
6
Each person brings their personal experiences to the advocate/survivor relationship. Your
experiences can profoundly affect how you perceive and engage with survivors. Being survivor-
focused requires being self-aware.
This self-examination process is the same you use in any situation when you find yourself over-
identifying with a survivor, or perhaps judging or being critical. For example, suppose you personally
know a survivor or her family, and you already have an opinion about her situation. How do you
overcome this challenge if you are the only available advocate? What do you do when you find
yourself over-identifying with a survivor and wanting to influence her decisions?
Whatever the issue, you owe it to survivors to be as prepared, nonjudgmental, and supportive as
possible, regardless of your personal views and experiences.
Appropriate Boundaries. You may have strong feelings or opinions about faith that you want to
share with a survivor. There is nothing wrong with those feelings, however, it is simply not your
place to influence the survivor in this area. Instead, you need to be prepared to understand and
incorporate the survivor’s own faith story and resources in your advocacy.
7
Assessment
How can you assess the religious/spiritual needs of survivors?
Indirect Approach
Your intake process or
general conversation Even if you are unsure or
can help you learn about uncomfortable talking about faith or
the religious/spiritual spirituality, survivors may be grateful
needs of survivors without that you recognize its significance to
directly asking faith-based them with a non-judgmental approach.
questions. In particular,
strength-based questions
can naturally generate good information about a survivor’s faith.
Listen for faith-based responses when addressing standard topics.
Support System:
• Do you have a support system, and what does it look like?
• Who in your life are your biggest supporters?
• What has helped you survive so far?
• What nourishes your spirit? What gives you courage and
strength?
Transportation: A survivor may request regular rides to a church, temple, mosque, or other
faith-based settings. This is a perfect opening for a conversation. A good question to ask in this
situation is, “It sounds like your faith community is a positive resource. Is there any other way we
can support you in this area of your life?”
Dietary Restrictions: Asking incoming shelter residents about their dietary restrictions is
considerate of those with faith-based food restrictions. For example, many observant Jews and
Muslims may avoid pork or shellfish for religious reasons. When making a shopping list for the
shelter pantry, include all residents in the decision making to help address any faith-based dietary
needs. Avoid questions like “Why can’t you eat _____?” which may make her feel she has to justify
her dietary habits. Instead, you could ask how it will impact her if other residents store and cook
foods on her list of dietary restrictions.
8
Power and Control Wheel:3 When discussing “isolation,” “using
children,” or “male privilege,” a survivor might talk about how her
abuser doesn’t allow her to attend her place of worship anymore,
mocks her faith in front of the children, or manipulates their faith leader
into advising her to “obey” or “submit more” to stop the abuse. She
may reveal other important faith-based information as well.
Direct Approach
Sometimes the answers to standard intake questions will not reveal
a survivor’s faith perspective. Her hesitation may be based in fear,
shame, mistrust of support services, or lack of a private place to
receive services (such as in a rural area). She may have heard
that shelters “cause” divorce, or “destroy the traditional family.”
She may believe her information or situation will not be confidential
particularly if her faith community, her friends, or her family
members support or volunteer for the organization.
If this is the case, you may need to ask direct questions to ensure
she has every opportunity to talk about her faith-based needs. The
more transparent and open you are, the more comfortable and
open survivors will be.
The best way to directly help a survivor talk about personal yet
important topics like faith is to normalize the conversation. Just as
many medical professionals have adopted asking all patients if
they feel safe at home as a standard question, faith questions can
be normalized with survivors. Such questions can include:
• Many of our residents have a faith or spiritual practice that is important to them. How about you?
• We have heard from many survivors that their faith is very important to their lives and survival.
Is this true for you?
• We have heard from many survivors that spirituality is a significant part of coping.
Is that true for you?
• We have learned from a lot of people that abuse has affected the most important aspects of their
lives, like their family, their friends, and their faith. What is your experience?
• What effect has the abuse had on your beliefs and values, such as relationships or family or faith?
• Do you participate in a faith community? If so, have you sought help there? What did you find?
How do you feel about the response you received?
A supportive demeanor and non-judgmental response to answers that reveal faith-based resources
(faith leaders, faith communities, personal spirituality) helps survivors know it is safe to talk about
their beliefs and traditions.
http://www.theduluthmodel.org/pdf/PowerandControl.pdf
3
9
A Crisis of Faith is a Crisis
Crisis of Faith: The spiritual beliefs of survivors and the
influence of their faith community can have a fundamental impact
on their safety, decision making and survival. The abuse or the
need to leave the abuser may cause a crisis of faith.
For many survivors, given the significant role of spirituality and religion, it is important
that this crisis is acknowledged and addressed in a non-judgmental manner.
10
To respond to these questions, it is important to ask the survivor what they think.
Here are some possible responses:
• What do you think about that?
• It sounds like this means a lot to you.
• How did you decide that?
• What does your pastor/rabbi/imam/faith
leader say about it? What does your faith tell you
about violence? Justice? Peace? Oppression?
Due to a lack of understanding of intimate partner violence, the faith community may
discourage a survivor from seeking safety by:
• Normalizing or minimizing abuse within relationships/marriage
• Advising couples counseling and restoration of the relationship over safety
• Encouraging submission as a solution to the abuse
• Using religion or sacred texts to impose reconciliation
• Shunning those who choose to end their relationship
Let survivors know that if their faith is important to them, it is important to you. If you
aren’t familiar with a topic, let the survivors know. In those cases, you might ask:
• Have you talked to anyone about these concerns before?
• Is there someone you trust who would be helpful with these questions?
• Would you like to talk to a faith leader about what you are going through?
This last question is only appropriate when a faith-based
referral is available.
11
Honoring the Diversity of Faith-Based Beliefs
amongst Survivors
How can you honor the diversity of faith-based beliefs of
survivors in practical ways? What does a welcoming
shelter space look like? Here is a checklist for
shelters regarding the faith-based needs of
survivors.
Spiritual Practice
• When possible, provide separate or
private space for individual and/
or group meditations, rituals,
prayers, and worship.
• Provide ritual items such as
candles, copies of Bibles
(both Christian and Jewish),
Qur’an, prayer books,
and other relevant items
for worship and holy day
observance.
• Encourage celebrations of
any holidays observed by
residents, such as Ramadan
and Rosh Hashanah. Be
sensitive, especially during
December, to the reality that
not all residents are Christian.
High visibility of the “Christmas
season” can feel very isolating
to women and children of other
faiths and traditions.
Respect
• Do not let cultural biases, myths, or
stereotypes get in the way of validating the
survivor, her experiences, and her decisions.
• Do not proselytize or otherwise attempt to lead
her away from her beliefs no matter how sincerely you
hold your own personal beliefs.
• If you think you might be unable to support the survivor
nonjudgmentally, talk to your supervisor, and, when appropriate, refer
the survivor to another advocate. This should only be communicated to
the survivor as a natural part of the intake process, such as a referral
to someone who is more familiar or knowledgeable about issues the
survivor is facing. For example, “I think I know a great advocate for you.”
12
Dietary Practice
• When possible, provide cooking equipment (e.g. pots
and pans) utensils, and space for food preparation
and eating in accordance with particular religious
traditions (Kosher, Halal, etc.).
• Maintain a supply of paper plates, utensils, cups, etc.
• Provide a vegetarian meal option at every meal.
• Include residents in the decision making when
creating shopping lists for the shelter.
• Explore the possibility of providing residents with
Kosher, Halal, etc. packaged meals.
• Provide or make accessible cooking ingredients
for meals from various religious, cultural, and ethnic
traditions.
Modesty
• Be aware that, for some women, modesty has
religious significance.
• Provide space where individual privacy is secured –
for bathing, dressing, and use of the toilet.
• Don’t walk into a resident’s room unless she has
expressly let you in. Don’t assume that residents are
comfortable talking to you in pajamas or any state other
than fully dressed.
• Always be cautious about the use of touch. Ask before
you reach out to hug someone, and ask in a way that
makes it clearly their choice, such as “Would you like
a hug?”
13
Assessing Faith-Based Referral Sources
It is very important to become familiar with community faith-based resources. You need to know
before you make a referral to a faith-based resource that it is safe, non-judgmental, welcoming and
competent. Survivors may perceive any referral you make as an endorsement and therefore safe.
Here are ways to assess faith-based referral sources:
Listen to survivors. Some will have stories about how faith communities have responded to them.
Just as you might alert your co-workers to how other individuals or systems treat survivors (police
officers, judges, child protection workers, etc.), you should communicate this knowledge about faith-
based resources, within the bounds of confidentiality, with the rest of the advocate team.
Recognize faith leaders/communities who have reached out to you. Which communities have
requested information about your services, and more importantly, training on intimate partner
violence and sexual assault? The groups who have been proactively engaged in your work may be
your safest and most trustworthy referrals.
Identify the faith leaders/communities already supporting your mission. Existing support for
your mission may indicate openness to assisting survivors. If you are involved in a faith community,
share with your peers as appropriate your observations of your own faith leaders as to whether or
not they are sensitive and safe referrals.
Listen to and observe local faith leaders in community events and in the media. They might
support your center financially or otherwise, but do they also speak out against domestic and sexual
violence? Do they promote the ideals of peace, social justice, and equality?
Follow up, follow up, follow up. Whenever possible, follow up with survivors when they have
accessed the resources of the local faith communities based on your referral, particularly if it is
a new referral. Were they treated respectfully? Was the staff and environment welcoming? Were
they pressured to make decisions before they were ready? Were they encouraged to reconcile the
relationship with the abuser when it was unsafe or pressured into couples counseling?
14
Engaging Faith Leaders
Faith-based organizations are often the bedrock of both urban and rural communities, particularly for
underserved populations. In addition to emotional and spiritual support, faith communities can be a
vital resource for food, clothing, transportation, employment, and other basic daily living needs. How
can you engage faith communities in addressing and preventing intimate partner violence?
Seek those leaders who are largely responsible for organizing local events and who are known in the
community for advising others wisely.
Make connections. Do any agencies you already partner with (food banks, charitable organizations,
law enforcement, etc.) also partner with faith communities? Use those connections/events to meet
and greet faith leaders, thank them for their service to the community, and express a desire to
collaborate.
Explore common ground. Remember that faith Faith communities may not think to
communities and DV service providers both care connect with a local domestic violence
about and work towards the well-being of families center unless they have a member
and the community. Find shared goals, such as who is in crisis. However, prevention
justice, peace, compassion, violence-free families, programming may also provide
etc. Communicate using this shared language. opportunities for collaboration. See
Opportunities for Collaboration on
page 17.
15
Openly address the topics of mandated reporting, confidentiality and liability with faith
leaders. These topics may not hold the same meaning for each of you. For example, clergy and
advocates may have different reporting requirements. It is important for everyone to know those
requirements when acting collaboratively. A helpful tool can be found here: www.childwelfare.gov.
Evaluate openness and willingness to work with survivors. What do they do when you approach
them about intimate partner violence?
• Do they step away from you?
• Do they change the subject quickly?
• Do they indicate interest by asking questions?
How do they respond when you ask if they have encountered intimate partner violence in their
organizations? If they say no, they may benefit from training. You might respond:
• “Have you ever talked about intimate partner violence with your congregation?”
• “We work with survivors from many faith backgrounds. Can we tell you about our services?”
• “We provide training to faith leaders on intimate partner violence. Would you be interested in
training opportunities for your faith community?”
If faith leaders indicate they know intimate partner violence has affected their communities, you can
respond:
• “How do you respond?”
• “Are you comfortable addressing it?”
• “We would love to help you have those conversations.”
• “What resources exist in the community to assist survivors?”
• “Are you familiar with the local certified domestic violence center?” If yes, how would you describe
your relationship?”
• “Wecan help survivors access safety, advocacy, and other resources.”
• “Wecan provide training on how to identify and address intimate partner violence.”
Recruit faith leaders to be trained on intimate partner violence. Does your center offer trainings
to the public? Invite faith leaders, particularly those who are already involved with your center. Keep
in touch with them and invite them to your events. Tell them about the Florida Coalition Against
Domestic Violence. Encourage them to sign up for the Florida Voice Newsletter - http://www.fcadv.
org/florida-voice-newsletter.
16
Opportunities for Community Collaboration
Local Cooperative Groups. Many local communities bring members and leaders together in
teams to prevent and address intimate partner violence. The names of these groups may vary by
city or county, but typically they are called coordinated community response teams, task forces, or
community action teams. Invite faith leaders to attend and participate in these important groups.
This is a great opportunity for cross-training; offer faith leaders the opportunity to talk about their
community outreach ministries while you educate them about the unique needs of survivors of
intimate partner violence.
Community Events. Take advantage of any and all community events to connect with those
leaders, particularly events sponsored by faith communities.
• What are the events in your area?
• Which organizations sponsor community-wide events?
• Do you have a county fair in which you might have a presence?
• Do you have back-to-school events, child safety events (such as car seat installations), or
community food drives in which you can participate?
• Does your local medical center sponsor health fairs at which you could have a booth?
• Are there culturally-specific events occurring in your area in which you can show your support?
17
Coordinated Response by Faith Communities
Faith leaders may ask how they can help. Here are some suggestions to offer:
• Become a Safe Place. Make your church, temple, mosque, or synagogue a safe place where
survivors of intimate partner violence can come for help. Establish a Safe Church Policy and
adopt procedures to protect vulnerable members. Display brochures and posters which include
the telephone number of the certified domestic violence center in your area. Publicize the Florida
Domestic Violence Hotline: 800-500-1119, 800-621-4202 (TTD) and local shelter information.
• Educate the Congregation. Provide ways for members of the congregation to learn about
domestic and sexual violence. Routinely include information in monthly newsletters, on bulletin
boards, and in marriage preparation classes. Create an environment of awareness. Sponsor
educational events in your congregation on violence against women.
• Speak Out. Speak out about intimate partner violence and sexual assault from the pulpit. As a faith
leader, you can have a powerful impact on people’s attitudes and beliefs. Intimate partner violence is
a traumatic life experience. Your congregation relies heavily on you for solace and guidance to cope.
• Lead by Example. Volunteer to serve on the board of directors at the local certified domestic
violence center or attend a training to become a crisis volunteer. Model non-violent behaviors and
healthy relationships in your home, congregation, and community.
• Offer Space. Offer safe, welcoming, and confidential meeting space for educational seminars or
weekly support groups.
18
• Partner with Existing Resources. Include your local certified domestic violence center in
donations and community service projects. Adopt a shelter for which your church, temple, mosque
or synagogue provides material support, or provide similar support to families as they rebuild their
lives following a shelter stay.
• Support Professional Training. Encourage and support training and education for clergy and
lay leaders, ministry leaders, hospital chaplains, paid staff, volunteers, and seminary students to
increase awareness about intimate partner violence and sexual assault. Read A Commentary on
Religion and Domestic Violence by Rev. Dr. Marie M. Fortune, Salma Abugidieri, and Rabbi Mark
Dratch.
• Address Internal Issues. Encourage continued efforts by religious institutions (your denomination)
to address allegations of abuse by clergy or lay leaders to insure that your leaders are a safe
resource for victims and their children.
www.fcadv.org
www.faithtrustinstitute.org
19
FAQ:
“We have federal funding. Can we even talk about religion?”
You cannot proselytize or favor one faith tradition over another. As part of cultural competency, you
can and should support the survivor’s effort to address her faith issues and connect with her faith
community in a helpful way.
“I grew up in the church but I have come to believe that religion is part of the problem for
domestic violence.”
It is part of the problem and it is also part of the solution for people whose faith is important in their
lives. Your job as an advocate is to help the survivor remove roadblocks and find the resources that
speak to her.
“I grew up in a predominantly Jewish community and went to Jewish schools. I just don’t
know very much about any other faith tradition.”
Educate yourself about the basic teachings of traditions other than your own. A good place to begin
is the FCADV and FaithTrust Institute websites.
“I just don’t feel comfortable really engaging around questions of faith. This is way outside my
expertise.”
Be confident in your ability to learn from survivors and the other resources you have available to you.
Take the time to develop the cultural competencies surrounding faith and spiritual beliefs.
“What about reading materials? Are there any good resources for particular faith groups that
address intimate partner violence?”
Yes. Have reading materials available in your shelter for survivors from various traditions. Contact
?
FCADV for more information at Info_fcadv@fcadv.org.
? ?
20
Sponsored by the Florida Coalition Against Domestic
Violence and the State of Florida, Department of Children
and Families.
21