Driveshaft Vibration Analysis
Driveshaft Vibration Analysis
Driveshaft Vibration Analysis
of each other. You can get a little electronic angle finder at Harbor Freight that has a
magnetic base on it. Set the driveshaft so that the ujoint cups are pointed straight up and
down, and set the angle finder on the driveshaft yoke. Then rotate the driveshaft 90
degrees ans perform the same check on the transmission yoke. The difference between the
two is the front U joint angle. Repeat the process at the rear end to get the rear U joint
angle. The angle on the two U joints should be exactly opposite. If the front U joint has a 2
degree downward angle, the rear end should have a 2 degree upward angle. On most cars,
the angles are constantly changing, but on a IRS car like a Corvette, the angle never
changes as the suspension moves. I have run angles as high as 3.5 degrees and never had
a problem with vibration, but 1/2 degree mismatch between the front and rear can cause
vibration.
My guess is that Wayne is correct, and the vibration is coming from the halfshaft U joints
and not the driveshaft. Improper camber settings. or rear suspension too high, can both
cause vibration. The U joints can bind if the angle exceeds 5 degrees or so, and a mismatch
between the inner and outer U joint angle can cause the same cyclical vibration that
driveshafts experience, although the halfshaft spins at a substantially slower speed than the
driveshaft. Sometimes, it is just a bad U joint.
BY JOHN NIOLON
Engine, drive line or rear suspension changes sometimes move things around. Engines
must be offset to clear steering boxes, different rear ends have different driveshaft
centerlines. Everything in the drive train must operate in "phase" in order to minimize
vibration, noise and component wear.�
Think about a complete automotive drive train from the side -this includes engine,
transmission, driveshaft and rear axle assembly. Part of the "phasing" procedure
includes making sure that the center lines of the transmission and the rear axle drive
shaft are parallel. If the axis of the pinion gear is parallel with the ground, then tail shaft
of the transmission must also be parallel to the ground. It can be higher or lower but it
MUST be parallel.
�
Trying to determine this while laying upside down under a car with a bunch of two-by-
fours, baling wire and an leaky old hydraulic jack supporting eight hundred pounds of
engine and transmission can be taxing (and a little unnerving). It's not really all that hard
and while it does go easier with some dexterity it requires a minimum of math skills. �
All you need is a device like these pictured below . Some call them a protractor Some
call them angle indicators. Sears calls them a universal protractor and they are about
$10.00. Harbor Freight sells them for less than that. There are a lot of protractor tools
around but these are the easiest to use.
Whichever you use (especially the cheaper one), I'd check it against a known accurate
level. Set up a 4' or longer level or a good Starrett #98 millwrights level and shim to get
it level, set the protractor on top of it and check the bubble or dial for accuracy� when
the reference level "is", the protractor dial should read zero.. it wouldn't hurt to check it
on both planes.
First I would park the truck on as level a surface as possible, both front to back and side
to side.. It's best that the vehicle be 'loaded' or carrying its normal operating weight if
possible. Sometimes when your building your vehicle this isn't possible, the engine isn't
installed yet or the bed and bed wood haven't been installed. If this is the case, I'd
recommend checking these measurements again after the vehicle is complete. They
shouldn't be far off, but if you are using extreme u-joint angles (normally in jacked up 4
wheel drive trucks), it could make the difference in a work or no work situation.
So, suck in your gut�slide under the car ( a creeper certainly helps here ) and hold the
protractor base flush against the nose of the pinion gear shaft or rotate the pinion yoke
until it is vertical and lay the protractor base against it. You can now read the position of
the pinion gear axis relative to the ground. Let's say it was below the horizontal 90�
mark and sitting on 81�. That means the pinion gear axis is tilted slightly upward at the
nose. Now attach the protractor to the tail shaft of the transmission or on the oil pan if it
is flat and parallel with the tail shaft. Follow the same procedure of getting the bubble
level and take a reading. Lets say it is 90 degrees. If the engine is left in this position
and the rear axle assembly is not moved, the drive line will be out of phase since 90
degrees plus 81 degrees is 171 degrees. It's 9� out. The center lines are not parallel.
To be in phase, the tail shaft and the pinion gear must be parallel.
To be parallel the center line of the transmission and center line of the pinion gear must
be on the same plane� the angles must total 180 degrees. Now that you have your
angles calculated and know how much you have to move 'something', you can decide
whether to tilt your engine/transmission down a little or rotate the axle up slightly so the
axis of the pinion gear is on a more level line. Of course, this will mean moving engine
mounts or spring perches or adding shims if your engine and rear end are already
mounted. If you're still fabbing up the drive train.. it's much easier, add or subtract
shims, braces or tighten or loosen your baling wire till you get it where you want it.�
Very probably the height of the tail shaft will be different that the height of the pinion
flange (because the engine sits higher in the frame than the rear end) that's o.k. as long
as the horizontal axis of the tail shaft and pinion = 180 degrees added together.
PARALLEL.
When that PARALLEL thing occurs you are finished . . . on that plane ! Now you have to
work on the other plane. Ddealing with an engine offset. Most times when you do an
engine swap, the engine will be offset to the passenger side by some amount. . . the
amount depending on the size of the replacement engine. Most people don't realize that
many factory engines are also offset. Another thing people don't realize is that the
pinion center line in hardly ever on the center line of the frame. They, also are offset to
the passenger side.
Look at the Vertical View (from above)
Drawing A represents the wrong way to offset an engine. Done this way you are sure to
have driveshaft vibration, noise and U-joint wear.
It doesn't matter that the two U-joints are not on the same centerline from the front of
the frame to the back (my engine is set right 2" and the pinion is 1-1/2" right.) It only
matters that their individual centerlines are parallel..
Look at the centerline of the pinion and the centerline of the crank/transmission - they're
parallel. You don't want the arrangement in the upper example (except in old torque
tube setups) Again you want the U-joints to "work".
The U-joint angle I was referring to is just this. If you hold the U-joint parallel to the
ground, it has a range that it will travel in both the vertical and horizontal plane. You
want "some" angle in the joint so the bearing will "work" and not just be an extension of
the driveshaft with all the load on the same needles all the time. But, as the U-joint
reaches its limit of travel in either plane - you're working it too hard and it will wear
abnormally. Normally the pinion gear angle is a negative angle and the nose of the rear
end is pointed down. This allows for the upward movement of the rear end when torque
is applied. Those who follow racing will know the term spring wrap. Setting up a drive
line for racing situations or high torque off-roading is different and much more
complicated than for street vehicles, as many more variables enter into the formula. For
normal street operated cars and trucks the normal drive shaft angle is from one to three
degrees from horizontal. One degree being the minimum to allow the u-joint to work and
the bearing surfaces to rotate in the housing preventing all the load to remain on one
group of needle bearings all the time. And, ideally the operating angles on each end
should be within one degree of each other. There are tables that define the maximum
allowable operating angles and they are determined primarily by driveshaft rpm. The
range is 11.5� at 1500 rpms down to 3.25� up at 5000 rpms. By no means should you
operate toward the extreme range of angles. This will only lead to premature failure of
u-joints and components and possibly considerable damage to other components and
the vehicle in general if the failure happens at high speeds.
All of this so far is assuming that you are using single joint (or single Cardan) u-joints.
Because of the nature of these type joints, they do not turn at a constant velocity if they
are not at a zero operating angle. They actually turn in an elliptical path rather than a
true circle, so at two points in the revolution they are turning faster than at the opposite
two points. Later developed CV (constant velocity) joints have helped rectify this action
and smooth out the operation of u-joints considerably. The position of the u-joint yokes
on each end of the driveshaft can help smooth out this to some degree. The yokes
should be positioned so that their center lines are on the same plane.
If you're using a factory shaft, all this has been taken care of. If you're building one or
having one shortened or lengthened, the yokes should be positioned so that their center
lines are on the same axis. The action of the opposite yokes tends to cancel out the
speed variations of each other.
I would also recommend getting a reputable shop to build and balance a new shaft.
Unless your dealing with very high torque racing shafts or funky little short shafts on 4
wheel drive trucks with radical lift kits and transfer cases and stuff� the cost of a new
driveshaft will probably be less than $200.00. Cheap when you consider that long road
trip with the vibration and droning a poorly made or out of balance shaft can generate,
or the cost of damage a poorly made unit could do. Not to mention the embarrassment
Normally all you need to give them is the yoke center to yoke center lengths and your
transmission type and rear end type both with spline counts or flange types. I was
fortunate to use the engine, transmission and rear end from one car and only had to
shorten my driveshaft to fit the new installation in a truck frame. Some manufacturers
use a double tube shaft with rubber grommet type vibration dampeners inside the outer
tube holding the inner shaft to it. If you have this type shaft and want to maintain that
function� be sure and tell your driveshaft man and he can build your new shaft using
those ends.
There are several good street rod building books that cover this information and a
number of good sources on the internet that have excellent technical information. Some
of these guys have 20+ years of experience in driveshaft work and their writings and
drawings are probably easier to understand that my ramblings. Much of my information
originally came from one in particular. I used it as a tutorial for my work. It is called
"Practical Engine Swapping, by John Thawley. It's handled by Steve Smith Auto Sports,
P.O. Box 11631 Santa Ana Ca 92711 714-639-7681 and its $10.95 & 3.00 shipping.
You can probably find it at a good bookstore. Got mine at Barnes and Noble. I strongly
suggest that you talk to a competent builder. Ask around for references. I hope my
notes here will make your drive line phasing a little clearer...the pictures are a lot easier
than the words in explaining this. Good luck on the project.
�Copyright � 2001 John Niolon, All International Rights Reserved. This document may not be copied or
published without prior written consent of the author. �� jniolon@bham.rr.com