C1 Sampa Video
C1 Sampa Video
Sampa Video, Inc. was the second largest chain of videocassette rental stores in the
greater Boston area, operating 30 wholly owned outlets. Begun in 1988 as a small store in
Harvard Square catering mostly to students, the company grew rapidly, primarily due to its
reputation for customer service and an extensive selection of foreign and independent movies.
These differentiating factors allowed Sampa Video to compete directly with the leader in the
industry, Blockbuster Video. But unlike the larger rival, Sampa had no ambitions to grow
outside of its Boston territory. Exhibit 1 contains summary financial information on the
company as of their latest fiscal year-end.
In March 2001, Sampa Video was considering entering the business of home delivery of
movie rentals. The company would set up a web page where customers could choose movies
based on available in-store inventory and pick a time for delivery. This would put Sampa in
competition with new internet-based competitors, such a Netflix.com that rented DVDs through
the mail and Kramer.com and Cityretrieve.com that hand delivered DVDs and videocassettes.
While it was expected that the project would cannibalize the existing operations to some
extent, management believed that incremental sales would be substantial in the long run. The
project would provide customers the same convenience as internet-based DVD rentals for the
wider selection of movies available on videocassettes. Sampa also planned to hand deliver
DVDs. The company expected that the project would increase its annual revenue growth rate
from 5% to 10% a year over the following 5 years. After that, as the home delivery business
matured, the free cash flow would grow at the same 5% long-term rate as the videocassette
rental industry as a whole. Exhibit 2 contains management's projections for the expected
incremental revenues and cash flows achievable from the project.
Sampa management's major concern was the significant up-front investment required
to start the project. This consisted primarily of setting up a network of delivery vehicles and
staff, developing the website, and some initial advertising and promotional efforts to make
existing customers aware of the new service. Management estimated these costs at $1.5 million,
all of which would be incurred in December 2001, as the service would be launched in January
2002.1
Management was debating how to assess the project's debt capacity and the impact of
any financing decisions on value. In thinking about how much debt to raise for the project , two
options were being considered . The first was to fund a fixed amount of debt, which would
either be kept in perpetuity or paid down gradually. The second alternative was to adjust the
amount of debt so as to maintain a constant ratio of debt to firm value. Exhibit 3 contains
information on market conditions as well as management’s assumptions regarding the project’s
expected cost of debt
1
For the purposes of this exercise, it is assumed that all start-up costs would have been capitalized, and
depreciated over time. In reality, some of these costs would have been capitalized (e.g., investment in
delivery vehicles) while others would have been expensed immediately (e.g., advertising costs) .
Exhibit 1 Summary Financial Information on Sampa Video, Inc., 2000 (in thousands of dollars)
FY 2000
Sales 22,500
a 2,500
EBITDA
Depreciation 1,100
Operating Profit 1,400
Net Income 660