20th Century Education

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 3

Evolution of Pedagogical Ideas and Practices in the 20th Century

1. Introduction

The end of the 19th and beginning of the 20th Century are characterized by the
passage from traditional pedagogy to modern pedagogy. Traditional pedagogy is
defined as a conservative, prescriptive and ritualized 'know-how' practices and as a
formula that perpetuated the 17th Century teaching methods. This tradition which was
based on order was strictly respected until the 19th Century. Traditional pedagogy is
characterized by a concern with developing public education due to the appearance of
large groups of pupils that required an extremely detailed and global organization.

However, by the beginning of the 20th Century, this pedagogy started to be


criticized by the New School. This was due to the development of science and to the
desire to meet the needs of children. Pedagogy started to be seen as a field of practice
(no more a theoretical knowledge) based on science in general and on child
psychology in particular. Pedagogues called for objective observation and
experimentation in order to establish the basis of a science of education. New
pedagogy places the child at the center of its preoccupations and is opposed to
traditional pedagogy which is centered on the teacher and the content to be
transmitted. This movement is the starting point of numerous streams of thought that
still exist nowadays and which still influence contemporary pedagogical practices.

2. Scientific criticism of traditional pedagogy

The pedagogical knowledge produced in the 17th Century and transmitted to the
following generations was a traditional one. It was acquired by imitation through
contact with more experimented pedagogues. This tradition implied a set of ritualized
actions, executed in a mechanical way and which enabled a teacher to teach the way
he had been taught without even thinking.

That pedagogical tradition was denounced by the proponents of the new


pedagogy in the first half of the 20th Century. They held that that knowledge which
was acquired by imitation and which was constituted of ready–made answers to
pedagogical problems and pedagogical actions to be repeated evidently contained
errors. Therefore, this knowledge had to be questioned and the 3 centuries old
pedagogical practices had to be criticized.

One of the main functions of science, which acquired a great importance at the
end of the 19th Century, is to test hypotheses, to verify the truth of certain statements
and to correct errors. Therefore, by the end of the 19th century a lot of authors called
for the necessity of going beyond tradition and basing pedagogy on science. Around
1880, there appeared a movement in France that aimed at making pedagogy the
science of education. Binet, the founder of experimental pedagogy, stated in 1898 that
pedagogy had to be based on observation and experimentation (contrary to old
pedagogy which was based on preconceived ideas). Claparède also expressed in 1912
the double objective of eliminating the aspects of traditional pedagogy that existed
before, and of elaborating a new scientific pedagogical spirit.
In short, pedagogues did not want pedagogy to be simply a naïve expression of
educational tradition as it had been for three centuries. They rather wanted it to
correspond to a knowledge which is based on science and which clarifies its practice.
Therefore, it was not surprising to find among the first great proponents of new
pedagogy people like Montessori and Decroly and their predecessors Itard and Seguin
who were doctors familiar with scientific observation.

If tradition does not constitute the basis of teachers’ activity anymore, and if
science can take over this task, then which science exactly can perform this action?
Claparède suggested that the science that should give pedagogy a firm basis is
psychology. He maintained that a pedagogue must possess a knowledge about the
child. This illustrates the idea that for the authors of the 20th Century, pedagogy is an
applied science. Compayré (1883) stated that without a precise knowledge of the laws
of mental organization, it is impossible to set the appropriate order of studies, to
appreciate the pedagogical value of the teaching objects and to set different activities
according to the learners’ age, level and natural dispositions. Therefore, pedagogy and
psychology became inseparable terms. The future of education depended on the
progress of psychology.

2. The beginnings of new pedagogy

According to Claparède, it was Rousseau who inspired new pedagogy. In fact,


Rousseau can be considered as the founder of a scientific pedagogy based on
experimental psychology. He claimed in his work called ‘Emile’, that before
educating a child, you should first know him. This idea implied the necessity of
observing the child/learner, and having knowledge about child psychology. However,
his ideas had not been put into practice in the classrooms until the end of the 19th
Century. So, apart from Rousseau, we can not find any other inspiring figure for the
new pedagogy prior to the 19th century. However, by the end of that century and
beginning of the 20th Century, a series of authors contributed by their different
initiatives to the creation of the movement of new pedagogy. We can distinguish two
main streams:

a. The first trend


At the end of the 19th Century, a first trend of pedagogical innovations took place:
• The expression ‘New School’ appeared in England by 1889 when Reddie
created the new school of Abbotshome.
• In 1894, Dewey was named professor of psychology and pedagogy at the
University of Chicago and created his famous elementary school annexed to
the university.
• In the same year, Kerschensteiner started his first experiments in the schools
of Munich in Germany (Arbeitsschule: active school).
• In 1898, Binet published his book entitled Intellectual Fatigue in which he
‘declared war’ against traditional pedagogy.
• In 1899, Ferrière created the International Bureau of New School.
• In 1900, Montessori created in Rome the first Casa del Bambini (the house of
children).
• In 1907, Decroly founded in Brussels the Hermitage School and introduced a
new method of global reading called the Natural Method.
b. The second trend

The second important trend followed the First World War. A lot of Europeans
felt the necessity of reforming education for the sake of salvation of humanity. They
wanted, by means of education, to create a new type of man in order to get rid
definitely of the causes of war. Therefore, a series of pedagogical attempts took place.
For example:
• The Community of New Children was founded in Hamburg. It claimed that
children had to organize their school life, choose their leaders and put forward
their rules.
• In 1921, the Association for the New Education was created and the First
International Congress for the New Pedagogy was organized.
• In 1922, Neill created his famous Summerhill School in England.
• In 1923, the review New Era was founded.
• In the same year, Piaget begun the publication of a series of works on child
psychology which greatly influenced the development of the new education.
• In 1925, Freinet invented the printing system at school.

The preceding examples show that the period extending from the 19th to the
th
20 Century was extremely significant in the history of pedagogy in general and new
pedagogy in particular. The decades that followed this period were a continuation of
the efforts and their effects are still perceived till nowadays. All the streams and
approaches that were created throughout the 20th Century shared in common their
opposition to traditional education and the idea of centering their action around the
child (the learner).

You might also like

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy