Remanufacturing of Nodular Cast Iron Crankshaft With Plasma Cladding
Remanufacturing of Nodular Cast Iron Crankshaft With Plasma Cladding
Remanufacturing of Nodular Cast Iron Crankshaft With Plasma Cladding
Jinxia Liu , Chao Ma, Luda Yu, Yu Wang and Zhiyuan Jiao
Abstract
Remanufacturing technology has a wide range of applications in the repair of scrapped parts with a certain remaining ser-
vice life. In this work, a scrapped crankshaft fabricated from nodular cast iron that had failed from working surface wear
was remanufactured via a plasma cladding process. Taking into account the wear amount on the working surface and the
characteristics of nodular cast iron, in this article, cladding layer parameters were designed and two types cladding pow-
ders, Fe-based and Ni-based, were prepared, respectively, to perform the cladding experiment. After examining different
process parameters, relatively smooth cladding layers were obtained using four powders. The cladding experiment
results showed that the powder No. 3 exhibited superior qualities when combined with proper processing parameters.
When applying powder No. 3 to the main journal of crankshaft, a higher quality of cladding layer was achieved.
Keywords
Crankshaft, remanufacturing, nodular cast iron, plasma cladding, surface treatment
Creative Commons CC BY: This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License
(http://www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) which permits any use, reproduction and distribution of the work without
further permission provided the original work is attributed as specified on the SAGE and Open Access pages (https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/
open-access-at-sage).
2 Advances in Mechanical Engineering
Table 2. The diameters and errors of the main and connecting rod journal.
Powder C Cr Si Mn W V Mo Nb B Fe Ni
circumferential directions are shown in Table 3. From well, the Fe-based and Ni-based alloy powders were
Table 3, it can be seen that the hardness range for the made by water and nitrogen atomization, respectively,
main journal is 28.5–57 HRC. However, the difference according to the melting point. Finally, the powders
in hardness of a same crankshaft working surfaces is were obtained after drying and sieving, and the parti-
required no more than 6 HRC in accordance with the cles size is 53–198 mm. The components of four alloy
literature.32 powders are shown in Table 4.
According to the measurements of diameters and
hardness of main and connecting rod journals, it can The process of cladding experiment
be deduced that the main journals was more severely
Design of cladding layer parameters. The thickness of the
and unevenly worn.
cladding layer was determined to be 1–2 mm based on
the maximum wear thickness of the crankshaft, which
Cladding experiment would meet the repair requirements for the crankshaft’s
abrading section, and the width and length of the clad-
Preparation of the cladding powders ding layer were set to be 10 and 30 mm, respectively.
In line with the performance requirements for the clad- The path for the cladding processing is denoted via
ding layer, the physical and chemical properties of clad- arrows in Figure 2.
ding powders should be similar to the material of the
scrapped crankshaft, including melting point, thermal Determination of cladding parameters. The ideal micro-
expansion, and cold shrinkage, and should have high structure and properties of the cladding layer were
wear resistance, corrosion resistance, oxidation resis- determined not only by the alloy powder and the clad-
tance, wettability, and so on. In this article, two differ- ding processing route but also by the plasma processing
ent types of, Fe-based and Ni-based, alloy powders, parameters, which include the cladding power, scanning
which were numbered from 1 to 4, were prepared to speed, powder feeding rate, distance between the plasma
perform the cladding experiments. When melt with high torch and the substrate surface, gas flow, and so on.
temperature in electric melting furnace after the compo- The coating thickness is not very thick according the
nents of materials at a certain proportion ratio mixed plasma cladding technology (the thickness of single
4 Advances in Mechanical Engineering
Powder Current (A) Voltage (V) Powder feeding Cladding rate Distance between plasma Gas flow (m3/h)
rate (r/min) (mm/min) torch and substrate (mm)
Sample 1 2 3 4
number
Figure 2. The cladding processing path. layers of the four powders achieved high hardness,
and the Fe-based cladding layer had a higher hardness
than the Ni-based cladding layer. Also, the hardness
of all cladding layers was higher than the standard
hardness requirement for the nodular cast iron crank-
shaft surface.32
Figure 4. The microstructure from powder No. 1: (a) top region, (b) middle region, and (c) adjacent substrate bonding region.
Figure 5. The microstructure from powder No. 2: (a) top region, (b) middle region, and (c) adjacent substrate bonding region.
Figure 6. The microstructure from powder No. 3: (a) top region, (b) middle region, and (c) adjacent substrate bonding region.
of microcracks from the higher contents of C and B in middle region form a white reticular structure, and the
powder No. 2, which caused the higher hardness and carbide solid solution of M7(C, B)3 appears as strip-like
brittleness of the cladding layer. The structure near the structures in adjacent substrate bonding regions.22
bonding region consists of obvious lamellar eutectic Figure 7 shows the microstructure from the cladding
material from the melting of the iron substrate. layer for powder No. 4, which is also composed of a
Figure 6 shows the microstructure from the cladding Ni-based alloy and carbide. The distribution of car-
layer for powder No. 3, which mainly composed of a Ni- bides is relatively uniform and tiny in the middle region
based alloy and carbide according to literature.20 The and the carbide began to form into thick strips with
microstructure is dense, homogeneous with some tiny good wear resistance due to the diffusion of the C into
micropores and no obvious microcracks. The distribution the cast iron in adjacent substrate bonding region.
of carbides in the microstructure is different between the However, there are some micropores that act as the
top and adjacent substrate bonding regions. Due to the source of the microcracks, resulting in a cladding layer
diffusion of C in the cast iron, the carbides in adjacent with a lower toughness.
6 Advances in Mechanical Engineering
Figure 7. The microstructure from powder No. 4: (a) top region, (b) middle region, and (c) adjacent substrate bonding region.
Figure 8. The high magnification microstructure from powder No. 3: (a) top region, (b) middle region, and (c) adjacent substrate
bonding region.
High magnification microstructure of cladding layer decreases to about 2 mm in the middle region. Near the
adjacent substrate bonding region, the structure is more
formed by powder No. 3
compact and homogeneous without any micropores,
The high magnification microstructure of the cladding and the strip-like structures is nearly perpendicular to
layer formed by powder No. 3 is shown in Figure 8. the wear surface with high wear resistance.22 It implies
There are many micropores with diameters of 3–5 mm that in positions closer to the substrate bonding region,
in the top region. The diameter of the micropores the performance increases.
Liu et al. 7
Figure 12. The low magnification microstructure from cladding layer of main journal: (a) top region, (b) middle region, and (c)
adjacent substrate bonding region.
8 Advances in Mechanical Engineering
Figure 13. The high magnification microstructure from cladding layer of main journal: (a) top region, (b) middle region, and (c)
adjacent substrate bonding region.
in Figure 13. And, the micropores are so small that it Declaration of conflicting interests
hardly affects the practical performance of the The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with
crankshaft. respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this
article.
Conclusion Funding
1. For the scrapped crankshaft experiencing wear The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial sup-
failure, the original working surface dimensions port for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this
can be obtained by plasma cladding remanufac- article: This research was supported by the High Educational
turing, permitting the crankshaft to have a Institution of Shandong Science and Technology Project
(grant no. YB06).
higher performance than a new one.
2. The performance of cladding layer was deter-
ORCID iD
mined not only by the process parameters but
also by the degree of matching between the Jinxia Liu https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0889-0397
cladding powders and the substrate. In this arti-
References
cle, good quality of the cladding layer was
achieved using powder No. 3 cladding for a 1. Murtaza Q, Pandey SM and Niranjan MS. A novel man-
nodular cast iron crankshaft under proper clad- ufacturing route for automobile parts through two-wire-
ding parameters. arc thermal spray process. Mater Manuf Process 2016;
31: 1424–1432.
3. For the powder No. 3 cladding remanufacturing
2. Ganvir A, Kumara C, Gupta M, et al. Thermal conduc-
of nodular cast iron, the quality of the adjacent
tivity in suspension sprayed thermal barrier coatings:
bonding region and substrate bonding region in modeling and experiments. J Therm Spray Techn 2017;
the cladding layer is better than in the top and 26: 71–82.
adjacent top region. 3. Dai WS, Chen LH and Lui TS. SiO2 particle erosion of
4. To obtain better quality cladding layers, it is spheroidal graphite cast iron after surface remelting by
still necessary to adjust the cladding process the plasma transferred arc process. Wear 2001; 248:
parameters, powder composition, and cladding 201–210.
thickness according to the amount of wear on 4. Cao HT, Dong XP, Huang QW, et al. Effect of scanning
the working surface. It is possible that the rema- speed during PTA remelting treatment on the microstruc-
nufactured crankshaft will have better perfor- ture and wear resistance of nodular cast iron. Int J Min
mance than the original one. Met Mater 2014; 21: 363–370.
5. Cheng X, Hu SB, Song WL, et al. A comparative study
on gray and nodular cast irons surface melted by plasma
Acknowledgements beam. Vacuum 2014; 101: 177–183.
6. Glenny E and Restall JE. Evaluation of the properties of
The authors are indebted to Qingdao Haina Plasma Tec. Co.,
protected molybdenum and 0.45% titanium-
Ltd for supporting the test equipment and to their colleagues
molybdenum alloy. J Less: Common Met 1965; 09:
for assisting in the process of this study.
367–387.
Liu et al. 9
7. Zhuang W, Liu Q, Djugum R, et al. Deep surface rolling 20. Xu GJ, Kutsuna M, Liu ZJ, et al. Characteristics of Ni-
for fatigue life enhancement of laser clad aircraft alumi- based coating layer formed by laser and plasma cladding
nium alloy. Appl Surf Sci 2014; 320: 558–562. processes. Mater Sci Eng 2006; 417: 63–72.
8. Bykovskiy DP, Petrovskiy VN, Polskiy VI, et al. Devel- 21. Cai ZB, Wang YD, Cui XF, et al. Design and micro-
opment of the recovery technology for nickel superalloy structure characterization of FeCoNiAlCu high-entropy
blades of the aircraft engine by laser cladding. J Phys alloy coating by plasma cladding: in comparison with
2016; 747: 012056. thermodynamic calculation. Surf Coat Technol 2017; 330:
9. Liu HT, Wang LP, Ge SR, et al. Optimization of shearer 163–169.
sliding boots by plasma cladding with Cr4MnTi. Min Sci 22. Cheng JB, Sun B, Liu Q, et al. Synthesis of Fe-based
Technol 2011; 21: 877–880. coatings by low frequency electromagnetic stirring: evolu-
10. Kathuria YP. Some aspects of laser surface cladding in tion of microstructure and mechanical properties. Surf
the turbine industry. Surf Coat Technol 2000; 132: Coat Technol 2016; 307: 728–734.
262–269. 23. Cheng JB, Xu BS, Liang XB, et al. Microstructure and
11. Arias-González F, del Val J, Comesana R, et al. Fiber mechanical characteristics of iron-based coating prepared
laser cladding of nickel-based alloy on cast iron. Appl by plasma transferred arc cladding process. Mater Sci
Surf Sci 2016; 374: 197–205. Eng 2008; 492: 407–412.
12. Zhang PR and Liu ZQ. Effect of sequential turning and 24. Zhang LM, Liu BW, Yu HY, et al. Rapidly solidified
burnishing on the surface integrity of Cr–Ni-based stain- non-equilibrium microstructure and phase transforma-
less steel formed by laser cladding process. Surf Coat tion of plasma cladding Fe-based alloy coating. Surf Coat
Technol 2015; 276: 327–335. Technol 2007; 201: 5931–5936.
13. Guo J, Yang L, Cui HW, et al. Microstructure and tribo- 25. Liu YZ, Sun YF and Jing FY. On the microstructure and
logical properties of in situ synthesized TiN reinforced wear resistance of Fe-based composite coatings processed
Ni/Ti alloy clad layer prepared by plasma cladding tech- by plasma cladding with B4C injection. Ceramic Int 2015;
nique. J Mater Eng Perform 2016; 25: 2412–2419. 41: 10934–10939.
14. Ding Y, Zou ZH, Wang ZH, et al. Research status and 26. Xie GZ, Song XL, Zhang DJ, et al. Microstructure and
prospect of plasma cladding technology. J Ceramic 2012; corrosion properties of thick WC composite coating
33: 405–410. formed by plasma cladding. Appl Surf Sci 2010; 256:
15. Zhang LM, Sun DB, Yu HY, et al. Characteristics of Fe- 6354–6358.
based alloy coating produced by plasma cladding process. 27. Zhang DK, Liu Y and Yin Y. Preparation of plasma
Mater Sci Eng 2007; 457: 319–324. cladding gradient wear-resistant layer and study on its
16. Bi XQ, Hu XL and Wang J. Influence of processing para- impact fatigue properties. J Therm Spray Technol 2015;
meter on microstructure and forming characterizations of 25: 535–545.
Ni-Cr cladding formed by plasma surfacing processes. J 28. Zhu YZ, Yin ZM and Teng H. Plasma cladding of stellite
Aeronaut Mater 2009; 6: 45–49. 6 powder on Ni76Crl9AlTi exhausting valve. T Nonferr
17. Ulutan M, Kilic xay K and Cxelik ON. Microstructure and Metal Soc 2007; 17: 35–40.
wear behaviour of plasma transferred arc (PTA)-depos- 29. Xiang YH, Xu BS, Lv YH, et al. Technical study of
ited FeCrC composite coatings on AISI 5115 steel. J exhaust valve overlaying based on micro-plasma arc
Mater Process Technol 2016; 236: 26–34. welding. Key Eng Mater 2008; 373: 330–333.
18. Xu MS, Li JF, Jiang JB, et al. Influence of powders and 30. Harpreet S and Pramod KJ. A comparative study of pre-
process parameters on bonding shear strength and micro cision finishing of rebuild engine valve faces using micro-
hardness in laser cladding remanufacturing. Proc CIRP grinding and ECH. J Remanuf 2015; 5: 6.
2015; 29: 804–809. 31. Paolo C, Alessandro G and Ulisse M. Current challenges
19. Li Y, Cui XF, Jin G, et al. Interfacial bonding properties in material choice for high-performance engine crank-
between cobalt-based plasma cladding layer and sub- shaft. Proc Struct Integr 2018; 8: 486–500.
strate under tensile conditions. Mater Design 2017; 123: 32. GB/T 23339-2009:2009. Internal combustion engines—
54–63. crankshafts—specification.