M 310106115
M 310106115
M 310106115
ABSTRACT: Mobile banking is one of the advances in information technology that banks use to provide
convenience and convenience to customers, which technology combines banking, internet and smartphone
transactions. This study aims to explain and analyze the influence of behavioral intentions and customer
perceptions of BPD Bali Klungkung Branch in Semarapura City, especially employees in the Klungkung
Regency Government on mobile banking intentions. The questionnaire method used in this study is to test
indicators of behavioral intention and risk perception with a total of 100 customers as respondents. The samples
were determined using purposive sampling method with the condition that they had never used BPD Bali mobile
banking. Hypotheses were analyzed using the Structural Equation Model (SEM) with SPSS and AMOS
programs. The results show: (a) Expectancy has a positive and significant effect on intention to adopt mobile
banking, (b) Expectancy has a positive and significant effect on intention to adopt mobile banking mediated by
performance expectations, (c) Performance expectation has a positive effect on intention to adopt mobile
banking. banking, (d) Social has a positive effect on the intention to adopt mobile banking, and (e) The
perceived risk has a negative and significant effect on the intention to adopt mobile banking. This research has
implications for the Bank BPD Bali that the district government employees. Klungkung wants mobile banking
that has a high level of security so that the risk of unwanted transactions and ending up using the BPD Bali
mobile banking application will reduce the management effort (energy and time) of employees in carrying out
their activities and the performance of the mobile banking application based on the level of effort of the effort.
the clerk itself. Therefore, Bank BPD Bali must improve the performance of BPD Bali mobile banking and be
aggressively socializing and promoting the mobile banking service.
I. INTRODUCTION
Information and communication technology (TIK) has developed very rapidly in the era of the
industrial revolution 4.0. The use of information and communication technology (ICT) in the banking world is
relatively more advanced than other sectors (Fadlan and Dewantara, 2018). One form of technology use in the
banking sector is the use of e-banking applications. E-banking service facilities are one of the most popular
services for bank consumers, this is in line with the lifestyle in the digital era that demands speed and ease of
transactions.
Maharsi and Fenny (2006) argue that the use of internet banking provides benefits for customers and
the bank itself. For customers, internet banking offers various transaction facilities as well as speed in banking
transactions, easy access that can be done anywhere and anytime. The advantage for banks is that internet
banking can be a cheap solution for infrastructure development compared to opening an ATM outlet. Internet
banking covers all banking services based on the use of the internet network, such as: mobile banking (M-
Banking), SMS banking, and so on. The modern lifestyle of today's society provides opportunities for the
banking sector to launch E-Banking service products. Figure 1. shows the composition of categories of internet
service usage in Indonesia in 2017.
Mobile Banking is an act of conducting financial transactions online with the help of mobile
telecommunications devices such as cell phones or tablets (Tan and Lau, 2016). The use of mobile banking in
Indonesia continues to increase. The results of a survey of 4 major banks in Indonesia showed that in 2015, m-
banking users were 23.65 million users, this number increased by 25% from the number of users in 2014 which
reached 18.8 million mobile banking users (Sharing Vision, 2015).
Mobile-banking offers the convenience of checking the last account balance (account in quiry),
opening a new account (account opening), sending money (transfer), paying bills (payment), information on
interest rates and currency exchange rates, changing PIN numbers and credit calculation simulation (Prihiyani
(2012) in Sulastini and Warmika, 2014). The use of m-banking is in line with economic growth and the use of
IT in the business world as well as in daily activities such as shopping activities, bill payment and so on. The use
of m-banking services is not only used by companies but also in the public sector (government). Currently, the
central and local governments have collaborated with banks regarding the use of mobile banking facilities.
Currently, commercial banks and regional development banks have collaborated with the government regarding
the use of m-banking facilities.
Bali as one of the regions with very fast economic growth is in line with the rapid development of
tourism. This opportunity supports the increased use of banking facilities in Bali, especially the use of m-
banking facilities. The opportunity for market share and mobile banking users is so high that BPD Bali will
further exploit it by marketing a mobile banking application product, namely BPD Bali mobile banking. The
majority of users of BPD Bali's m-banking facilities are public sector (government) consumers.
All government institutions in Bali Province collaborate with Bank BPD Bali. This cooperation
includes cooperation in receiving and disbursing regional cash, paying employee salaries to utilizing various
other banking services. One of them is that all employees in the Klungkung district government are now able to
enjoy BPD mobile services. However, the level of use of mobile banking applications among Klungkung
Regency Government employees is still low. The results of preliminary research (pre-research) through
incidental interviews with 47 Klungkung Regency Government employees, only 26 employees have adopted the
BPD mobile application. These results are supported by several reasons why Klungkung Regency Government
employees have not used BPD Bali mobile banking, namely fear of transferring money wrongly, having
difficulty understanding or understanding the mobile banking application, not requiring the BPD Bali mobile
banking application.
The use of a mobile banking application is a form of internet-based information system developed as a
banking service. In information systems research, there are several models used to predict the adoption of new
technologies, such as the TAM (Technology Acceptance Model), TPB (Theory of Planned Behavior) and
UTAUT (Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology). Based on the background description above,
the writer will re-examine the research entitled "Behavioral Intention to Adopt Mobile Banking Among The
Millennial Generation" which was researched by Evon Tan and Jasmine Leby Lau in 2016. This research is used
as the main reference for conducting research more specifically on PE, EE, SI, PR, and intention to adopt
mobile banking for customers of Bank BPD Bali Klungkung Branch in Semarapura City, especially Klungkung
Regency Government Employees in conducting online financial transactions.
Table 1
Goodness of Fit Test Results for Overall Contruction
Goodness of fit Cut-off Value Hasil Evaluasi Model
Measure Analisis
Chi Square 186,789
Probability ≥ 0,05 (Hair et al., 2010) 0,188 Qualified
CMIN/DF ≤ 2 (Byrne, 1998) 1,132 Qualified
GFI ≥ 0,85 (Schermelleh-Engel, Moosbrugger and 0,850 Qualified
Müller, 2003)
CFI ≥ 0,95 (Hu and Bentler, 1999) 0,984 Qualified
RMSEA ≤ 0,06 (Hu and Bentler, 1999) 0,037 Qualified
AGFI ≥ 0,80 (Hu and Bentler, 1999) 0,810 Qualified
Source: Appendix, Data processed in 2020
Table 1 shows that this research model has met the predetermined goodness of fit criteria. The results of
the path analysis in this study are as shown in Figure 3 below:
GOODNESS OF FIT
================
.78 Chi-Square=186.789
e21 Probability=.118
e14 y1.1 CMIN/DF=1.132
.65 .88
.14 GFI=.850
e15 y1.2 .81 TLI=.981
.69 Performance
.83 CFI=.984
y1.3 Exp RMSEA=.037
e16 .75
.56
AGFI=.810
e17 y1.4
.37
.85 .72
e1 x1.1 .92
.72
.85 e22
e2 x1.2 Effort
.72 .85 Expectancy .78
x1.3
.19 .71
e3 .89 y2.1 e18
.71
Intention .84
.65 to AMB y2.2 e19
.91 .83
e4 x2.1
.66 .81 .19 y2.3 e20
e5 x2.2 .81
.75 Social
.86
x2.3 Influence
e6 .90
.81
-.15
e7 x2.4
.68
e8 x3.1
.69
.83
e9 x3.2
.58 .83
e10 x3.3 .76
.61 Perceived
.78
x3.4 Risk
e11 .77
.60
.60
e12 x3.5
.37
e13 x3.6
Figure: 3
Results of the Analysis of the Performance Expectancy Path Diagram, Effort Expectancy,
Social Influence and Perceived Risk on Intention to Adopt Mobile Banking
Table 2 Estimation of Regression Weight Model of Structural Equation The Effect of Behavioral
Intention and Perceived Risk on Intention to Adopt Mobile Banking
Estimate S.E. C.R. P Keterangan
Standardized
Performance <--- Effort 0,333 0,100 3.344 0,000 Significant
Exp Expectancy
Intention to <--- Perceived -0,193 0,097 -1.983 0,047 Significant
AMB Risk
Intention to <--- Social 0,187 0,071 2.621 0,009 Significant
AMB Influence
Intention to <--- Effort 0,190 0,079 2.414 0,016 Significant
AMB Expectancy
Intention to <--- Performance 0,795 0,120 6.603 0,000 Significant
AMB Exp
Source: Appendix, Data processed in 2020
Based on table 5.11, the regression weight estimation output by looking at the p value can be explained
that:
1) Hypothesis 1a
Effort expectancy has a positive and significant effect on intention to adopt mobile banking. It can be
accepted with a probability value of 0.016 (<0.050) and a coefficient value of 0.190.
2) Hypothesis 1b
Effort expectancy has a positive and significant effect on intention to adopt mobile banking, which is
mediated by performance expectancy, which can be accepted with a probability value of 0.000
(<0.050) and a coefficient value of 0.333.
3) Hypothesis 2
Performance expectancy has a positive and significant effect on intention to adopt mobile banking. It
can be accepted with a probability value of 0.000 (<0.050) and a coefficient value of 0.795.
4) Hypothesis 3
Social influence has a positive and significant effect on the intention to adopt mobile banking which
can be accepted with a probability value of 0.009 (<0.050) and a coefficient value of 0.187.
5) Hypothesis 4
Perceived risk has a negative and significant effect on intention to adopt mobile banking. It can be
accepted with a probability value of 0.047 (<0.050) and a coefficient value of -0.193.
4.2 Discussions
4.2.1 Effect of Effort Expectancy on Intention to Adopt Mobile Banking and Performance Expectancy as
mediation.
Effort expectancy has a positive and significant effect on intention to adopt mobile banking with a
coefficient of 0.190 and a p value of 0.016. This shows that the higher the level of effort expectancy of users, the
greater the intention to adopt mobile banking users. These results also mean that the easier it is for users to
access the mobile banking application, the greater the desire of users to use the mobile banking application. So
that H1a is accepted.
Business expectations represent the level of ease of use of information systems (mobile banking) which
will reduce the effort (effort and time) in doing their jobs (Venkatesh et al., 2003). The results of this study are
in line with the results of preliminary interviews (pre-research) which show that Klungkung Regency
Government employees have high intentions in using the BPD mobile application, although the interviews show
they have not directly used the BPD mobile application. The convenience side is a strong factor affecting the
intention of Klungkung Regency Government employees to use the mobile banking application. The results in
this study are in line with research conducted by Ghalandari (2012); Yu (2012); and Alalwan et al. (2015) which
shows that the amount of effort spent can affect a person's intention to use m-banking. This also supports the
research results of Taiwo and Downe, (2013); Al-Qeisi et al., (2015); Tavares and Oliveira, (2016); and
*Corresponding Author: Chandra Mahardika1 www.aijbm.com 111 | Page
The Effect of Behavioral Intention and Perceived Risk to Adop Mobile Banking Using UTAUT…
Chinyamurindi, Chiwara and Mjoli (2017) found that the effort expectancy variable has a positive and
significant effect on intention to adopt mobile banking.
Effort expectancy has a positive and significant effect on intention to adopt mobile banking mediated
by performance expectancy with a coefficient of 0.333 and a p value of 0.000. H1b is accepted, Effort
expectancy has a positive and significant effect on intention to adopt mobile banking mediated by performance
expectancy. Performance Expectancy (PE) is rated as the strongest predictor that determines a person's interest
in technology (Venkatesh et al., 2003). Based on the results of this study, it can be concluded that the user
focuses on the performance of the BPD Bali mobile banking service, whether by using this service users get the
conveniences of using a system that can reduce the user's effort (effort and time) in carrying out activities or not.
4.3.2 Effect of Performance Expectancy on Intention to Adopt Mobile Banking
Performance expectancy has a positive effect on intention to adopt mobile banking with a coefficient of
0.795 and a p value of 0.000. H2 is accepted, performance expectancy affects the intention to adopt mobile
banking.
Based on the results of this study it can be concluded that the District Government Employees.
Klungkung has hopes for the performance of BPD Bali mobile banking, whether using mobile banking can
accelerate financial transactions or not. The results of this study are in line with the results of research by
Venkatesh et al. (2003); Al-Tarawneh (2016); Ammar and Ahmed (2016); and Dajani (2016). According to
Venkatesh et al. (2003) defined performance expectancy to what extent an individual believes that using the
system will help him to achieve gains in the performance of a job.
banking service, whether by using this service the user gets the convenience of using a system that can
reduce the user's effort (effort and time) in carrying out activities or vice versa.
3. Performance expectancy affects the intention to adopt mobile banking. This is due to district
government employees. Klungkung has hopes for the performance of BPD Bali mobile banking,
whether using mobile banking can accelerate financial transactions or not.
4. Social influence has a positive effect on intention to adopt mobile banking. This shows that the
influence or support from the surrounding environment as well as the experience that other people have
when using BPD mobile banking services can affect a person's interest in using the m-banking
application.
5. Perceived risk has a negative effect on intention to adopt mobile banking. This shows that the risk of
using mobile banking is still high, especially with regard to new users. New users will avoid using
mobile banking if they perceive the possibility of a criminal act in using mobile banking, especially
since mobile banking is directly related to financial issues, which is a sensitive issue for most people.
5.2 Suggestion
Based on the conclusions of the research, suggestions for the research results can be submitted as follows:
1. For further researchers, it is expected to develop or use the UTAUT Model (performance expectancy,
effort expectancy, social influence and facilitating conditions) and the perceived risk variable to
determine the effect of intention to adopt information technology, be it mobile banking technology or
other technologies with different types of population. .
2. Further research is expected to analyze the effect of the effort expectancy variable on the intention to
adopt information technology by mediating the variable performance expectancy
3. For Regional Development Banks (BPD Bank), it is hoped that it will be able to measure the
performance/performance of the deficiencies in the use of the mobile banking application so that it can
be used efficiently by customers and has a better level of security.
4. It is expected that there will be socialization and promos that can attract new customers, especially
district government employees. Klungkung to use BPD Bali mobile banking in its financial transaction
activities.
REFERENCES
Journal Papers:
[1]. Agbemabiese, G., Anim, P. and Nyanyofio, J. (2015) ‘Determinants of Mobile Banking Adoption in
the Ghanaian Banking Industry: A Case of Access Bank Ghana Limited’, Journal of Comupter and
Communications, 3(1), pp. 1–19. doi: 10.4236/jcc.2015.32001.
[2]. Al-Qeisi, K. et al. (2015) ‘How Viable Is The UTAUT Model in a Non-Western Context?’,
International Business Research, 8(2), pp. 204–215.
[3]. Al-Tarawneh, J. (2016) ‘Factors influencing the adoption of Mobile banking services in Jordan from
the perspective of customers: Overview and Pilot study .’, International Journal of Science and
Research Publications(IJSRP), 6(9), pp. 207–213.
[4]. Ammar, A. and Ahmed, E. M. (2016) ‘Factors influencing Sudanese microfinance intention to adopt
mobile banking’, Cogent Business & Management. Edited by D. McMillan, 3(1), pp. 1–20. doi:
10.1080/23311975.2016.1154257.
[5]. Ariyanti, K. and Iriani, S. S. (2014) ‘Pengaruh Persepsi Nilai Dan Persepsi Resiko Terhadap Niat Beli
Kosmetik Organik’, Jurnal Ilmu Manajamen, 2(4).
[6]. Bagadia, P. and Bansal, A. (2016) ‘Risk Perception and Adoption of Mobile Banking Services: A
Review’, The IUP Journal of Information Technology, 12(1), pp. 52–71.
[7]. Chinyamurindi, W., Chiwara, J. R. and Mjoli, T. (2017) ‘Factors That Influence The Use of The
Internet for Job-Seeking Purposes Amongst a Sample of Final-Year Students in the Eastern Cape
Province of South Africa’, SA Journal of Human Resource Management, 15. doi:
10.4102/sajhrm.v15i0.790.
[8]. Dajani, D. (2016) ‘Using the Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology to Explain E-
commerce Acceptance by Jordanian Travel Agencies’, Journal of Comparative International
Management, 19(1).
[9]. Fadare, O. A., Ibrahim, M. B. and Edogbanya, A. (2016) ‘A Survey on Perceived Risk and Intention of
Adopting Internet Banking’, Journal of Internet Banking and Commerce, 21(1), pp. 1–21.
[10]. Fadlan, A. and Dewantara, R. Y. (2018) ‘Pengaruh Persepsi Kemudahan dan Persepsi Kegunaan
terhadap Penggunaan Mobile Banking (Studi pada Mahasiswa Pengguna Mobile Banking Universitas
Brawijaya)’, Jurnal Administrasi Bisnis, 62(1).
[11]. Farzianpour, F. et al. (2014) ‘Consumers Perceived Risk and It’s Effect on Adoption of Online
Proceedings Papers:
[40]. Alalwan, A. et al. (2015) ‘Adoption of Mobile Banking in Jordan: Exploring Demographic Differences
on Customers’ Perceptions’, in Open and Big Data Management and Innovation. Netherlands:
Springer International Publishing, pp. 13–23. doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-25013-7_2.
Website:
[41]. Sharing Vision (2015) Pertumbuhan SMS/Mobile Banking di Indonesia, sharingvision.com. Available
at: https://sharingvision.com/pertumbuhan-smsmobile-banking-di-indonesia/.