RM - Class - Notes - 2017
RM - Class - Notes - 2017
Yoga Research:
1. Revalidate empirically
2. Ancient literature
3. Subjective and objective
4. Multi disciplinary
1. Good observer
2. Unbiased
3. Curiosity
4. Perseverance
5. Good Communication
6. Scientific Temper
7. Knowledge of the domain
8. Ethics
9. Creative
10.Vigilance / Alertness
11.Planning ability
12.Discipline
HW. Write the above 12 points and what you are in these respects. How can you
improve yourself?
Research process: ( Process involves series of points and the way of doing)
1. Research Question
2. Literature survey
3. Planning ( 1,2 and 3 together is Phase 1)
4. Data ( Phase 2 )
5. Data Analysis and interpretation
6. Conclusion
7. Communication ( 5, 6 and 7 together is Part 3)
1. Knowledge of RM – Phase 1
2. Field work – Phase 2 ( There is no course. Go and help seniors. Learn by
observation. Involve in field )
3. Knowledge of Statistics – Phase 3.
Phase 1 :
Coming out with foolproof methods of doing your research.
You need to think in diverse way. If you know all the ways your project can go
down.
Research Question:
What exactly you want to know- You should know
Question that tells about research
A precise statement
A statement need to be constructed
Literature Review:
Google Scholar
Pubmed
Science direct
Sci_Hub (To open the full paper)
Library genesis
Li_Gen (To open the books)
21/8/17
Research Question:
HW Take three statements of research questions and evaluate each one of them.
Past 3 yrs
Past 5yrs
Past 15 yrs
OSF
22/8/17
Literature Review:
Why? ->
24/8/17
Thesis is advanced
PhD Thesis
MSc Dissertations
Thesis
TV
Online – Digital
Pubmed
Science direct – Science Engg
ERIC
Shodhganga
26/8/2017
Pranayama, Memory
After 4 wks
1yr
3yr
5yr
10yr
15yr
31/8/17
What is the plan/ Scheme/ Logic that we are going to check need to be
decided.
More time need to be given for planning
Something exists.
You can have of number of hypothesis for a Hypothesis. You can keep
negating them one by one.
1/9/2017
When we try to see hypothesis, then only we may see only one aspect of
truth and may lose to see all dimensions. All Null Hypothesis have to be
negated to say that Hypothesis is correct.
NULL HYPOTHESIS:
When researcher does not speak about the direction of change then
it is called non-directional hypothesis.
Steps in NHST:
1. State Alternative Hypothesis
2. State Null Hypothesis
3. Fix Alpha
4. Fix Power ( 1-Beta )
5. Estimate Effect Size.
6. Calculate required sample size
7. Collect data
8. Analyze and conclude ( If p < alpha, reject NH; if p > alpha Fail to
reject NH )
When researcher speaks about the direction of change then it is called directional
Hypothesis.
7/9/17
1. Ha
2. Ho
3. Fix α
4. Fix power (1-β)
5. Estimate Effect size
6. Calculate Sample Size
7. Collect data
8. Analyze and conclude - If p<0.05 => Ho rejected
- If p>= 0.05 => Fail to reject Ho
Understanding α,β, power, effect size, sample size
1. α error (Type 1)
2. β error (type 2)
Conditional probability
Decision:
H0 True H0 False
Reject H0 ×
Type 1 / α 1-β
Fail to reject ×
H0
1-α Type 2 / β
1 – β is known as POWER.
Suppose H0 is true
Suppose H0 is false
Reject H0 :
Researcher claims that Bh. Pr. Improves short term memory
Fail to reject H0 :
Researcher claims that Bh. Pr. Does not improve short-term memory.
α is traditionally fixed as
- 0.05 - *
- 0.01 - **
- 0.001 -***
Fixing power is the level at which you claim it is correct when it is correct.
- 0.80
- 0.95
- 0.99
- Paper is very difficult so students get 30% and seeing that, I assume
students are weak. This is underestimation that leads to β error.
- Paper is very easy so students get 90% and seeing that I assume students are
very smart. This is overestimation that leads to α error.
Before we start our research, we need to have required sample size known.
Cohen – D
Test1 announced
Fix α, Fix 1-β, Estimate ES are done to calculate the required Sample Size.
If you don’t have enough SS, sometimes you may end up with inconclusive results.
If power < 80% and p>0.05 then we can surely say intervention is not useful.
Apriori:
SS ->α
1-β
ES
Tail
Post hoc:
1-β -> α
SS
ES
Tail
22/9/17
P-Value(probability)
0 – Never
1 – always
Lower α more SS
Small ES more SS
P(D/Ho)
p value tells the experimental change assuming the Null Hypothesis to be True.
23/9/17
P value is the probability of finding the experimental change assuming the Null
Hypothesis to be True.
5/10/17
P = 0.082
1-β= 0.75
29/9/17
STUDY DESIGN:
Philosophy of design.
Noise – Unwanted ( which we don’t want ) we always try to enhance the signal and
reduce the noise.
Signal/Noise
If we are not able to enhance signal and try that the ratio do not increase
If we want to increase the signal, directly work on intervention.
Eg: 1 WK to 4WK
Variables are not constant. It changes from person to person. Variables are not
constant. It changes from person to person.
Types of Variables:
It is controlled by researcher.
It is dependent on researcher.
2. Give it a priority
High
Low
Moderate
3. Develops strategies
Experimental Method – Actually do to control it
Statistical method – We must have measured it to do this method.
Statistical method – directly connected with study design.
5/10/17
Population
Population
All people who are eligible to participate in your study.
1. Probability Sampling
2. Non-probability Sampling.
6/10/7
Stratified Sampling: This is applied when you know the characteristics of the
population well in advance, you must see that the ratio is represented in the sample.
Eg: For the disease of study women are more prone than the men, then you need to
take a sample with 75% women and 25% men.
When we need to cover large Geographic area, this is done. We make clusters in
geographical region and randomly select clusters from them.
Non-Probability Sampling:
You need not have to ensure that sample is a true representative of population.
Eg: Someone comes to Arogyadhama, gets well, he goes back and tells another –
another one will come etc
Quota Sampling:
Prepare a quota, as that no. of requirement is finished, you stop taking them.
Eg: I need 20 persons with HT with retinopathy
30 persons with HT and Head ach.
Purposive Sampling:
To experiment on Monks
Generalisation: the process after doing Randomized sample, can be applied for
whole population.
Research Designs:
1. Experimental Design: You try to manipulate Independent Variable and try to
see its exclusive effect on Dependent Variable. Randomization is there.
Random allocation of the participants in different experimental conditions.
Confounding variables are 100% controlled.
2. Non-Experimental Design: You are not interested in studying cause and
effect. Confounding Variables are not at all controlled.
3. Quasi Experimental Design: It is like an experimental design but differs in
some aspects. There is no randomization. Confounding Variables are partially
controlled.
Cross-sectional study:
Eg. Study the difference in memory of Gurukula students& normal students. We try to
compare key characteristics of distinct populations.
Quasi-Experimental designs
PRE POST
Control group:
The group which does not do intervention and continues their own trajectory of life is
called control group. Control group is supposed to control the confounding factors.
Control group controls confounding factors by equally distributing across both groups.
DESIGNS
NON- QUASI-
EXPERIMENTAL
EXPERIMENTAL EXPERIMENTAL
Y Survey
PRE POST PRE POST
C Observational/
PRE
POST PRE POST Y
field
Cross-sectional
PRE POST
C
Whenever there are more than 2 or more than 2 assessment points, that design is
called ANOVA.
e.g. Guna measured at every semester beginning. This is called repeated measure
ANOVA. It is a within group ANOVA because same subjects participate in differen
conditions.
Between Group ANOVA – different subjects – different conditions.
YOGA
AYURVEDA Between group ANOVA
CONTROL
MIXED DESIGN
Y Y Y
A A A
C C C
When there is more than two groups or more number of assessments it is ANOVA
or
C
C
or
C C C
C C C
It is ANOVA
Prospective ( For Future design )and Retrospective ( Look into records and carry
research ) Designs.
Like a crosssectional
12/10/17
Selection Bias: is more applicable to sampling. If you take a sample which is not
really representative.
Recall Bias:
Eg: Collecting your experiences of past one month and answer the questions.
Reporting may be influenced by our mood now.
We tend to distort the information while trying to recall information from the
memory.
Observer Bias:
In the process of observing, if we make any bias then it is called observer bias. It is
focused on the experimentor. Hence it is called experimentor bias.
Instrumental Bias:
Publication Bias:
Problem with randomization is that we can not ensure all factors to be randomized.
Yoga Control
Inferior
Matching
Restriction
Blocking
Age Matching:
Yoga Control
20-30Yrs - 15 20-30yrs - 15
30-40yrs - 25 30-40Yrs - 25
Restrict: Certain group of people to participate in your study. This is done by exclusion
criteria.
Statistical method of controlling confounding variables is called ANCOVA. Initially data is taken
on all and extremes which are unwanted are controlled by statistics.
13/10/17
If we want to see the effect of right nostril breathing and left nostril breathing possibly
Whenever we study short time effect , the subject variability may lead to more
confounding.
Clinical significance looks at the change in the value. Clinical significance means
wheather the range changed.
BP
Jump in range
Pre______RN_______Post_____Washout period____Pre________Post
Washout period: The main period required to wash out the effect of earlier
intervention.
RN 15
30
LN 15
Subjects don’t know wheather they are in control group or in experimental group. It is
called single blinding.
Placebo Effect: The psychological effect gets corrected. The participant takes pill
similar to the actual medicine and gets cured.
Double Blinding: Experimentor also doesn’t know which group they belong to.
Tripple blinding: Neither participant, nor experimentor, nor statistician know which
is control, which is experimental.
14/10/17
Measuring process:
Validity and Reliability:
Validity:
1. Internal Validity
2. External validity
3. Construct validity
4. Statistical Validity
Are all quality measures.
1. Internal validity deals with the cause and effect relationship is appropriately
and correctly got.
Cause Effect
1 2
100 100
Random sampling/ Probability sampling improves external validity. Sample size must
be large.
Crossectional / Multicentric style:
A consept which is difficult to see. Intangible ( not seen directly ) but want to
measure.
It is an abstract concept which is intangible but researcher still want to measure it.
Right test
Interpretation of number.
Analysis of data.
Reliability:
1. Test- Retest reliability
2. Split half Reliability
3. Internal Consistency
4. Inter Rater Reliability
1. Test- Retest reliability: We measure group of people now and we retest and
see the correlation between the two.
The correlation between test scores and Retest scores.
Correlation when = Reliability
No intervention Invalid
50Kg 55Kg
The duration of Test Retest Reliability is chosen is based on the stability of construct.
10
3.Internal Consistency:
All the possible ways to devide into two groups. One ultimate way is called
(Chrombacks’ alpha ) α
1 2 3 4 5
Chronback ALPHA
Method of deriving reliability index by splitting the questionnier into all possible ways
and deriving a common Index.
Population parameter
(The information which we get
from population)
Sample statistics
Generalisation (The information which we get from Sample)
Statistics
Descriptive Inferential
Directly see and conclude Making some assumption after seeing the
situation
Example: How many samples are there in my research? Eg: Seeing the smoke we
assume that there
is fire
Descriptive Sampling
Mean should not be used when there are out layers in the data.
2. Median : Middle value after arranging the data in descending or ascending
order.
Eg: 1,2,3,25,5,7,75
1,2,3,5,7,25,75
Median is 5
When we have outliers in the sample, Median gives best value for the result.
If we have two middle numbers, average of it has to be taken as median.
Eg: 1,2,3,100 ( 2+3)/2 =2.5 Median
3. Mode: Mode is the most frequently occurring number in sample.
Eg: 1,2,2,2,4,5,3,5,3
Unit no No of Times
1 1
2 3
3 2
4 1
5 2
More than two numbers can be there in sample then it is called Bimodes.
21/10/17
Measures of Dispersion:
1. Range
2. Standard Deviation
3. Coefficient of Variance
4. Variance
All these above four estimate the variability in the data.
1. RANGE: The difference between highest and the lowest score in the range.
One value
Eg: 1, 2, 3………75 75-1=74 range
X X bar (X-Xbar )2
1 -2 4
2 -1 1
3 0 0
4 1 1
5 2 4
Sigma 15 10 Sum of
squared deviations
Mean Xbar = 3
(X-Xbar) = Deviance Gives us information of variance through
central tendency
Sigma (X-Xbar)2 /n = Variance 10/5 = 2 Variable
Coefficient of Varience:
Math 45/75*100
Standard deviation is the process of making Raw Score into standard Score.
i) Percentage ( % )
Z Score = (X-Xbar)/SD
Z score is a standardized score.
Inferential statistics:
2. Internal Estimate
Eg: 95% CI ( CI is confidence interval )
100-95 time estimate mean value will be under interval
Eg: 30----50--- 70
95 times it will range between 30 and 70.
30 times it will range between 0—30/70—100
Narrow confidence interval is best.
Eg: 90-95% in exam.
95% CI – 95% we are sure that the true population mean would be within the
defined interval range.
Central limit theory:
1. When the size of the individual sample is 30 or more than 30, the sampling
distribution will be equal to true population mean.
Standard error of population is equal to standard deviation devided by square root of
n. ( Number of sample size ) SE =SD/SQRT(n)
2. Frequency distribution of all the sample means is called the sampling distribution.
Sampling distribution is for many means.
Mean
Variables
Continues variables are continuous which do not have break which can take
values continuously.
Discrete variables are without continuity with some error ( distance)
Eg: Gender – Male and Female
Person is live or dead.
Level of measurement:
R I O N
1. Continuous or categorical
1. Nominal variables: Where we can give names
Eg: Name : Ram Shyam
Name of the countries, state, types of vegetables
35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42
43 44
Eg: Time. It can never be zero. Ratio is not meaningful. Zero does not have
value.
4. Ratio Variables: Which have all the value of interval variables additional to
it zero value it has and ratio makes meaningful.
Eg: Money - 1000
Height
Weight
2/11/17
When you choose the design, the type of statistical test you are going to do is almost fixed.
Test for normality ( To check data is bell or not )
Normal distribution – Parametric
Non_parametric - Non_ Parametric
You must know the Null Hypothesis used for all statistical tests.
Equivalance of variance – Lavys Test
Principle of Measurement:
Each & every variable measure should be independent of other measurement.
If assumptions are satisfied parametric tests
If any assumptions are not satisfied non-paramatric tests.