4.sir Syed Ahmed Khan

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 4

HOW IMPORTANT WAS THE WORK OF SIR SYED AHMAD KHAN IN

THE DEVELOPMENT OF PAKSITAN MOVEMENT IN 19TH CENTURY

Sir Syed Ahmed Khan (1817 – 1898)


INTRODUCTION:

• Respectable family, Delhi.


• Career in the legal system, 1838; by hard work, became a judge, 1846.
• Wrote “Athar – al – Sanadeed”, 1846.
• 1857, Chief Judge, Bijnaur; saved lives of some European families; refused to take reward
for that.
• Unpopular among some Muslims for loyalty towards British.
• Chief justice in Muradabad, Ghazipur.
• 1864, Aligarh, retired on 1876.
• Dedicated to Aligarh movement / Muslim ‘renaissance’, till his death, 1898.

HIS BELIEFS:

• Worried on poor condition of Muslims.


• Weakening since the days of Mughal decline; worsened with time
• Punished by the British after the 1857, as most blame was put on Muslims; were denied
respectable jobs, other tough measures also taken against Muslims.
• Muslims also distanced themselves from the Brit, considering them no more than
invaders.
• Sir Syed Believed that the Muslims:

1. Should befriend the Brit, as they were the established rulers of India.
2. Should acquire modern education in order to compete with Hindus, and improve
their socio-economic and political conditions by getting better jobs.
3. Should not join politics.

SERVICES / WORK OF SIR SYED:


Improving relations b/w Muslims and Brit:
Why:

• To improve socio-economic condition of Muslims; it was vital to make friends with Brit.
• British put all the blame of the war on Muslims; considered other Indian communities
loyal to them; British had replaced Muslims rulers and so, thought it justified to punish
Muslims.
• Muslims generally resented Brit; took them as invaders trying to replace Islam with
Christianity; many rejected the Western culture values considering them as un-Islamic;
showed hostile attitude towards the British.

Details: how Sir Syed did that.

1. Convinced the British by:

• Writing books, articles, pamphlets e.g., “the Loyal Muhammadens of India “(Defended
the loyalty of Muslims); “Essays on the cause of the Indian Revolt” (analyzed the munity;
insufficient Indian share in govt, forcible conversion of Indians, poor management of
army, British failure to understand Indians mindset); senior British circles read all this;
explained the meaning of “Nazareth” to clarify its use.
Muslims didn’t use it to insult the Brits; it was derived from the Arabic word “Nasir”
(helper); Muslims used the word in a positive, not an insulting way.

2. Convinced the Muslims:

• Improved his image as a sincere Muslim by correcting errors in the book of Sir William
Muir about the holy prophet.
• Highlighted similarities b/w Islam and Christianity to bridge the gap b/w Muslims and
Brits; wrote “Tabayin al Kalam” (commentary on the Bible); convinced that dining
together with Christians was not un-Islamic.
• Founded the “British Indian Association” to Improve Anglo-Muslim relations.

Results / Importance:

• Efforts of Sir Syed would bear fruits later


• Success of Simla delegation; Separate electorates for Muslims, 1909 Act.

EDUCATIONAL SERVICES:

Why / Reasons:

• Muslims were not interested in modern British education.


• Hindus began to excel by acquiring modern education; got better jobs, and improve their
image before the Brit, who started using them to counter Muslims; by 1871, 711 Hindus
against only 92 Muslims in the Govt service.
• Growth of Hindu revivalism (Hindu Movement) with increasing number of educated
Hindus; they showed little respect towards Muslims.

Details:
• Told Muslims about the Quranic commands to acquire knowledge.
• Issued “Tahzib-ul-Akhlaq” that publish articles of Sir Syed and other influential Muslims
to bring about the positive intellectual change among Muslims.
• 1863, Scientific Society, Ghazipur; translation of modern scientific writings in Urdu; 1866,
a school in Muradabad; 1864, another school in Ghazipur.
• 1869, visited England, observed Oxford and Cambridge – dreamed similar institutes for
Indian Muslims.
• On return started fund raising campaign: May 1875, MAO (Muhammad Anglo Oriental)
School, Aligarh; became MAO Collage, 1876, and University, 1920; offered modern and
Islamic education.
• MAO College acted as nursery for many important future leaders.
• 1886, Muhammaden Educational Conference (MEF), to improve educational standard of
Muslims.

Results / Importance:

• Gradual improvement of educational, social and economic status of Muslims.


• MAO collage becomes a breeding ground for Muslim leaders and MEF served as platform
for political activity of Muslims.
• AIML was founded in its 20th session, 1906.

3. POLITICAL SERVICES:

INC politics:

• 1885, Indian National Congress formed (INC) , aimed to convey views of Indians to Brit
• INC claimed to represent all Indians, regardless of religion; in reality it was Hindu-
dominated party working for raj in India
• Sir Syed’s advice to Muslims to stay away from politics of INC.
• It could engage Muslims in oppositional politics and damage their relation with Brit.

INC Demanded:
o Joint electorates for the council elections, along democratic pattern of England, Sir Syed
opposed this because of numerical majority and better political organization of Hindus.

o Competitive examinations for the civil services in India; Sir Syed opposed this because of
visible educational difference b/w Hindus and Muslims; Hindus might sweep all seats
causing further problems for Muslims.

o 1867, Hindus demanded Hindi to be the official language replacing Urdu; Sir Syed opposed
this because of Arabic / Persian script of Urdu and its association with Muslims; Hindi
reflected Hindu aim of ruling India in future. To counter the Indian National Congress
politics, he founded the United Patriotic Alliance – in 1893, it became the Muhammaden
Defence Alliance.

Importance / Results:

• Founder of the Two Nation Theory


• Predicted the separation of Hindus and Muslims in future, after the 1867 language
controversy and other demands of INC.
• Two Nation Theory would gradually become valid and lay basis of the struggle for
separate Muslims homeland – the Pakistan Movement.

Q: What is Two Nation Theory? 4 Marks

• In 1867, Hindi-Urdu controversy


• Hindus demanded Hindi to replace Urdu as the official language
• Sir Syed was shocked to know this because
• Sir Syed also Predicted the separation of India in future

Q: What was Aligarh Movement 4 Marks?

Aligarh Movement was started for Muslims, this movement gives a respectable position
to Muslims in society. This movement introduced a unique trend in Urdu literature.
... Aligarh movement was creating a new educational system for the Muslim community
during the late 19th century, main objective was to educate Muslims.

Q: Why did Sir Syed Ahmed khan write “the causes of Indian revolt” 7 Marks

Convinced the British by Writing books, articles, pamphlets e.g., “the Loyal
Muhammadens of India “(Defended the loyalty of Muslims); “Essays on the cause
of the Indian Revolt” (analyzed the munity; insufficient Indian share in govt so
Indians felt them excluded, forcible conversion of Indians towards Christianity
which threatened Indians that their religion was under threat , poor management
of army which was a cause of resentment among Indian soldiers, British failure to
understand Indians mindset which was a cause of hatred); senior British circles read
all this; explained the meaning of “Nazareth” to clarify its use by Muslims. Muslims
didn’t use it to insult the Brits; it was derived from the Arabic word “Nasir” (helper);
Muslims used the word in a positive, not an insulting way.

You might also like

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy