HeliOps Frontline 2020 Issue 32
HeliOps Frontline 2020 Issue 32
HeliOps Frontline 2020 Issue 32
airbus.com
tHe
team
PUBLISHER
Ned Dawson
EDITOR
Mark Ogden
DEPUTY EDITOR
Alan Norris
SUB EDITOR
Leigh Neil
EUROPE EDITOR
Alexander Mladenov
CONTRIBUTING EDITORS
Paul Kennard
Scott McKenzie
PROOFREADER
Barbara McIntosh
GRAPHIC DESIGN
Carolina De Armas
EMAIL
info@heliopsmag.com
NEWS DESK
news@heliopsmag.com
heliopsfrontline.com
ISSN 1179-710X
ISSUE 32
2020
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
contents
34 THE H160M -
THE WAY AHEAD FOR EUROPEAN MILITARIES?
Paul Kennard examines the Airbus H160 and how, even as a
civilian helicopter, it may serve the military.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
50 GOING DUTCH
THE APACHE IN ROYAL NETHERLANDS
AIR FORCE SERVICE
The AH-64D Longbow is the first combat
helicopter purchased by the Netherlands and
Jimmy van Drunen reviews the acquisition,
operation and future of the proven, versatile
American combat helicopter in RNLAF service.
74 EXERCISE SARACEN –
COUNTER TERRORISM IN AOTEAROA
Recently our Chief Photographer and
Publisher Ned Dawson spent a few days
with the RNZAF’s 3 Squadron as they
supported the Commandos of the NZ
Army’s SAS during Exercise Saracen during
operations at various locations around the
central North Island of New Zealand.
I
n this editorial, I am not referring specifically to
military helicopter operations but rather to an
issue that inevitably involve helicopters. Over
BY
MARK OGDEN the past few editorials, I have commented about
Chinese expansionism and basically, copying of
Western technology. They were really an observation of
what appeared to be a slowly developing environment.
I was wrong. It’s not slowly developing. COVID, Hong
Kong and the South China Sea territorial claims all point to
a China deaf to international concerns and totally focused
on challenging the USA military, diplomatic and industrial
dominance. It is becoming obvious that China has no
intention or desire to stay within its current borders.
Unfortunately, China has demonstrated that it is on
a path to expansionism and is indeed quite prepared to
play bully boy in the international theatre. As an example,
Australia has become a target of a Chinese trade war
primarily because it had pushed for an investigation into
the source of COVID. Australia also resisted China’s desire
to control the narrative in Australian tertiary institutions
when the subject of China was raised. So it would seem
China wants to hold Australia up as the poster-boy of what
happens if a country dare challenge China’s narrative on
world and domestic affairs.
So, what is happening? It seems to me that China has
quickly acquired Western technology over the past 30
years through theft and copying. It has also skewed the
markets to be an importer of raw materials and an exporter
of manufactured goods (at such a price that destroys the
manufacturing base of many Western countries). Such a
large market as China is attractive and managing to enter
that market means a company can become lazy and rely
on this sole market. The trouble is that China can and has
turned the tap off, seemingly breaking trade agreements
that do not suit it at the time, primarily for political
purposes. That is where Australia is right now.
In a joint report, the chiefs of the Navy, Marine Corps
and Coast Guard singled China out as the gravest threat.
The increase in its naval power, warship-building and
proliferation of long-range precision missiles meant that
the US could no longer presume, “unfettered access to
the world’s oceans in times of conflict”. Russia was also
identified as a serious, though lesser threat.
HELIOPS FRONTLINE / ISSUE 32 / 2020 7
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Mark
8
industry news
HELIOPS FRONTLINE / ISSUE 32 / 2020
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
USA
Aerial
Firefighting
Type 1
& Type 2/3
Helicopters
@HeliOpsMagazine
Connect with like minded people in the industry
& get in-the-moment updates, in real time, from every angle.
industry news
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
11
RAN completes
Operation ARGOS
HMAS Arunta is on her way home
after completing her deployment
on Operation ARGOS to track and
record vessels of interest and
suspicious transfers using the
ship’s MH-60R Seahawk.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
US ARMY HH-60L
US ARMY CH-47F
US ARMY UH-72A
USAF HH-60G - OPFOR
FORT POLK
US NAVY MH-60
S SAR
NAS FALLO N
USAF TH-1H US ARMY 160TH
SOAR
MH-60 M
US NAVY MH-60
S
US ARMY UH-72A
OPFOR -
JOINT MULTI NATION
AL
READI NESS CENTE
R
USMC VH-3
USMC AH-1Z
US ARMY UH-60M
USMC AH-1W
US ARMY KOREA
US ARMY FLIGHT
UH-60
DETAC HMENT
WEST
POINT UH-72
US ARMY 160TH
US ARMY 160TH USAF CV-22B SOAR
SOAR MH-6
MH-47 G
USMC CH-53E
USAF UH-1N
US NAVY TH-57C
USCG MH-60 T
US ARMY AH-64E
USMC VH-60N
US ARMY- UH-72A
- WHITE SANDS USMC UH-1Y
US ARMY- UH-72A
REAGA N TEST
MARSH ALL ISLAND SITE -
S
US NAVY HH-60H
www.heliopsmag
.com
www.heliopsmag
.com
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
82nd Airborne
First Osprey Air
Assault
Paratroopers from 3rd Brigade
Combat Team, 82nd Airborne
Division have conducted a joint air
assault operation using MV-22B
Osprey tilt rotor aircraft during
Panther Storm a 4-day Mission
Readiness Exercise.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Corps Command
change for 9
RAF 28 Squadron change Regiment AAC
of command
Lieutenant Colonel Jon Dufton has
Wing Commander Hannah Bishop has formally formally handed over command of 9
taken command of RAF 28 Squadron is the Regiment (AAC) to Lieutenant Colonel
Operational Conversion Unit, for the Puma Stewart Pearce, 9 Regiment is one of
and Chinook, from Wing Commander Mark two wings within No.1 Flying Training
Pickford RAF Benson, Oxfordshire. School.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
HSM 37 saves
lives in Honduras
HSM-37 Detachment 7 has
supported 10 missions aiding
in the rescue of citizens, and
delivered supplies in the areas
affected by Hurricane Eta.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Rheinmetall
to maintain
CH-53G
Rheinmetall has won a
contract from the German
Bundeswehr for inspection,
maintenance and repair of the
CH-53G starting in 2021 for
the 64th Helicopter Squadron
at Diepholz.
Picatinny Arsenal
acquires AH-1W
Picatinny Arsenal has received a retired USMC
AH-1W to be used for research and development
purposes at the US Army Combat Capabilities
Development Command Armaments Center.
AW101
operational
in Norway
The first six out of 16
Norwegian AW101
SAR aircraft are
officially operational
from their Sola base
with the Ørland and
Banak bases becoming
operational in 2021.
US Army selects
BAE for FVL
autonomy
BAE Systems has been
awarded contracts for three
of the US Army’s Future
Vertical Lift program’s four
focus areas.
28
28
industry news
HELIOPS FRONTLINE / ISSUE 32 / 2020
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
YOUR MISSION
SAVES LIVES
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Ka-52 delivered
N.I. Sazykina of the Russian
Helicopters has delivered all Ka-
52 Alligator combat reconnaissance
and attack aircraft to the Ministry of
Defense of the Russian Federation
within the terms of the contract.
W5
Solutions
wins GPU
contract
W5 Solutions has been
awarded a contract for
the delivery of Ground
Power Units from the
Swedish Armed Forces
for their Black Hawk
and NH90s.
industry news
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
33
Second NH90
Canadian Navy contract simulator for Spain
for Bluedrop
Indra has delivered a second Full
Bluedrop Training & Simulation has won a $6.7 Mission Simulator to the NH90
million two year End-to-End Learning Services Simulator Center at the Spanish Army’s
contract for Maritime Warfare and Seamanship Aviation Academy at the Agoncillo
training from the Canadian National Defense. military base in La Rioja.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
The H160M
The Way Ahead for
European Militaries? STORY BY PAUL KENNARD
38 HELIOPS FRONTLINE / ISSUE 32 / 2020
FIRST MEMBER
The span of roles that the French envisage for their H160Ms (named
the Guepard in service) is eye opening. The ‘Helicoptere Interarmees Leger’
(Lightweight Joint Service Helicopter), or ‘HIL’ Project, anticipates some 169
machines replacing several legacy types, providing significant economies
in terms of through life costs and in overall fleet size reductions. The
169 Guepards will need to cover the roles that currently over 400 legacy
machines are responsible. In the French Army and in the Air Force, the
Guepard will replace the Fennec and Gazelles (military AS550/555 Ecureuil /
Twin Squirrel) and in the French Navy the remaining Alouette IIIs and both
AS365 Panther and SA365 Dauphin.
It was the scale and scope of this challenge that I wanted to examine
in more detail. Following on from our successful discussion on the Airbus
RACER concept for Heli Ops magazine, Airbus Helicopters’ Head of External
Communications, Laurence Petiard, was able to find some time in the
busy diary of Vincent Chenot, Head of the H160M programme at Airbus, to
discuss the H160M’s offering to the military marketplace in more detail.
NOT A BRIDGE
DVE
One such area of enhancement, and one that is vital to both civil and
HELIOPS FRONTLINE / ISSUE 32 / 2020 41
managers to make the case for the expense of the Top Owl over the utility
of the Scorpion.
NAVAL NEEDS
Whilst the H160M has a basic configuration, it will be subtly tailored for
the required mission set for each service. Vincent explained that, perhaps,
the French navy version of the machine is the most different.
The requirement for safe operations and stowage from Escort vessels
has necessitated the need to fit the aircraft with a deck landing harpoon
(a mechanical device that deploys from the aircraft’s belly and locks into
a metal grid in the flight deck to prevent the helicopter from sliding on a
wet deck in turbulent seas before the deck hands can secure or stow it)
and full manual blade folding capability. It seems a fully hydraulic blade
folds system was not considered due to weight, complexity and cost.
Vincent continued to explain that the landing gear was also being ‘beefed
up’ for the naval version. I asked him if there had been lessons identified
from some of the corrosion issues that the NH90 has suffered from in the
maritime environment, and he agreed that NH90 experience was important.
Vincent also confirmed that a NH90 had been used to test some of the new
H160M materials in maritime conditions, and that Airbus Helicopters had
worked very closely with the Navy in identifying appropriate anti-corrosion
methods and products. Finally, as befitting its role, the Navy Guepard will
be fitted with different sensor and weapon packages. The former will likely
include a Thales AirMaster-C compact AESA (Active Electronically Scanned
Array) radar for detecting surface vessels and airborne targets (potentially
including drones), integration of which into the H160M is currently
underway. The Guepard will also need dedicated Naval data links to enable
it to ‘talk’ to both its ‘mother’ (the ship) and, more globally,
to be integrated into the wider battlespace, in effect becoming a node in
the Battlefield ‘Internet of Things’ or ‘Combat Cloud’. Airbus Helicopters is
also developing the VSR700 VTOL UAV (based on the Guimbal Cabri G2) as
part of a French navy de-risking study to look at the utility of UAVs in the
maritime environment, so it is only natural to assume that they see the
H160M/VSR700 as a likely deployed combination on French vessels towards
the end of the decade.
Finally, the Navy’s weapon requirements will see the new MDBA Anti
44 HELIOPS FRONTLINE / ISSUE 32 / 2020
program. With a 30Kg warhead and high subsonic speed, the missile is
designed to provide an ‘Over the Horizon’ (OTH) engagement capability
against warships up to Corvette size. It will be interesting to see if the
French Navy follow a similar path to the Royal Navy, who also plan to fit a
46 HELIOPS FRONTLINE / ISSUE 32 / 2020
lighter missile to the Wildcat, the ‘Martlet’, which is a fast flying (Mach 1.5)
Laser beam riding weapon designed to engage small manoeuvrable targets,
such as Fast Inshore Attack Craft (FIACs), Unmanned Surface Vessels (USVs)
and Jet Skis, all often employed by terrorist and unfriendly state actors as
an asymmetric threat. Martlet also has a useful overland precision strike
capability with very low Collateral Damage Estimate
(CDE) considerations thanks to its small 3Kg warhead.
Not unexpectedly, the French Navy will also equip the aircraft with a gun
system, probably a pintle mounted 7.62/12.7 initially, but with options to dip
into the Army’s ‘toybox’ if needed.
ARMY APPETITES
Mistral. Naturally, The Guépard will also retain the capability to fit side-
mounted 7.62mm door guns.
The Guepard will also come with a comprehensive Defensive Aids
Suite (DAS), cockpit and vital system armour protection and an Infra-
Red Suppression System (IRSS) for the engines. Speaking of the engines,
another lesson identified from operations in Africa and Afghanistan is
the need to protect engines from dust ingestion. Vincent explained that
after considering both Inlet Barrier Filters (IBFs) and Vortex Generators,
they elected to fit IBFs. His rationale was that IBFs were more effective in
screening the engines, especially against the properties of the sand/dust
encountered in sub-Saharan Africa, and they were lighter and less complex
than vortex generator separation systems. The downside is that they
inevitably become clogged over time, and a ‘bypass’ facility is required to
ensure that the engine still receives enough airflow to prevent a flame out
if they become saturated in flight (albeit, with the consequence exposing
the engine to the full force of the sand/dirt for a short time). They also,
typically, require more inspection, maintenance, cleaning and replacement
than the vortex generator systems such as the Engine Air Particle
Separation System (EAPS) that I used to operate on the CH-47 Chinook.
world as responsible for such interceptions, but the huge speed differential
and small radar/visual/thermal signatures of such ‘threats’ often make it
impossible for a fighter to successfully locate and intercept them. There’s
then also the matter of Collateral Damage; over an urban area such a
Paris, even a short burst of 30mm cannon can endanger civilians on the
ground. The H160M will be faster and more responsive than the Fennec,
whilst the smooth ride, in Vincent’s opinion, should make for a superior
platform to conduct accurate air-air sniping, if required. There is also
some consideration being given to fitting a pilot-cued machine gun for
use against those targets that attempt to manoeuvre during the intercept.
Vincent noted that the Air Force are keen to exploit the potential Air-Air
modes of the AESA radar as an alternate method to detecting and tracking
low signature targets, such as UAVs, which the AWACS and other primary
radars may struggle to acquire
SUMMING UP
Paul “Foo” Kennard is a former Royal Air Force CH-47 Chinook pilot, who specialised in Tactical Instruction,
Electronic Warfare and Operational Test & Evaluation during a 23 year career, during which he flew
operationally in Northern Ireland, Bosnia, Kosovo, Iraq and Afghanistan. Since leaving the RAF, he has
established his own consultancy company where he continues to provide input into high technology
rotorcraft and aerospace projects for governments and Industry. He is a key member of the NATO Next
Generation Rotorcraft study team, specialising in Defensive Aids Suites, Degraded Visual Environment
technology, Head Mounted Displays and teaming with unmanned aircraft.
DYNAMIC COMPONENT
INSPECTION • REPAIR • OVERHAUL
AS350
AS355
EC130
BK117
T
he Royal Netherlands Air Force (RNLAF)
has been flying the AH-64 Apache since
November 1996. Although an agreement was
made in 1995 with Boeing Defense & Space
Industries to purchase thirty examples of the
AH-64D, the first delivery would not occur for three years,
so the RNLAF leased twelve AH-46A Apaches from the US
Army and the last of their own AH-64Ds was delivered to the
Netherlands in 2002. The Netherlands’ Apaches are serially
registered from Q-01 to Q-30 and all remain in service except
Q-15 and Q-20.
The Apache was in fierce competition with the French
/ German Eurocopter Tigre in the mid-nineties, after the
Mangusta and Super Cobra helicopters were ruled out of
HELIOPS FRONTLINE / ISSUE 32 / 2020 53
54 HELIOPS FRONTLINE / ISSUE 32 / 2020
SARACEN
Counter
Terrorism
in Aotearoa
HELIOPS FRONTLINE / ISSUE 32 / 2020 79
Bright
Star
THE ITALIAN ARMY’S 7TH
AVIATION REGIMENT ‘VEGA’
FRIULI
AIRMOBILE
Justice
rtment of
U.S. Depa
USA
pters
Capitol Helico
USA on
Kestrel Aviati
Australia
ng
BHH Leasi
USA
ie Royale
Gendarmer co
Moroc
autics
Ace Aeron
USA
Helicopters
Firehawk
USA
Service Corps
Airborne
National Taiwan
pter
Brown Helico
USA
ream
ic / Helist
Gas & Electr
San Diego USA
pter
Brown Helico
USA
Service
Billings Flying
USA
Academy
Training
Sikorsky
Protection USA
& Border
Customs e Operations
Air & Marin
USA
nal Police
Turkish Natio
Turkey
Police
National
Colombian
Colombia
UNICAL
COULSON
USA
nal Police
Polish Natio d
Polan
on
Helinet Aviati
USA
Aviation
Skycore
USA
Aviation
Haverfield
USA
Helicopters
Northwest
USA
or
of the Interi
Ministry
Limited Saudi Arabia
KAHU NZ d
New Zealan
Helicopters
Skydance
USA
Jalisco
State of
Mexico
al
Policia Feder
Mexico
Aviation
UNICAL
USA
pters
PJ Helico
USA
Helicopters
Blue Sky
65 USA
– Super
UNICAL
USA
Helicopters
Timberline
USA on
Edge Aviati
Leading
South Africa
EcoCopter
Chile
Aviati on
Withrotor
USA
sty
Roger Harde
USA
pter
Brown Helico
USA
pters
HP Helico
USA
Wing
State Air
rtment of
U.S. Depa USA
EH60
Helicopters
Northwest USA
Crisponi
ons by Ugo com
Illustrati graphic.
Aviation
pters
Carson Helico Company
USA & Electric
Pacific Gas USA
rtment
Fire Depa
rtment ra County
County Fire
Depa Santa Barba USA
Ventura USA
rtmen t
Fire Depa
San Diego USA
on
MP Aviati
USA
rtment
ty Fire Depa
les Coun
Los Ange USA
ters.com
ehelicop
timberlin
CAL FIRE
USA
om
licopter.c
brownhe
ag.com
heliopsm
firehawk
helic opters.co
m
apaero.c
om.au
sales@tracplus.com | www.tracplus.com
NZ +64 3 477 8656 AUS 1800 330 740 US 1 888 630 9404 LATAM +56 99 225 4823 ZA +02 87 550 9775
140 HELIOPS FRONTLINE / ISSUE 32 / 2020
WHERE
EVERYTHING
IS HAPPENING!
AH-129 MANGUSTA -
48TH SQUADRONS GROUP