Module 1
Module 1
Module 1
BSBA MM-21
3. What are the elements or requisites in order that a person may acquire a right of
action in court against another to enforce the performance of the latter’s obligation?
a. A legal right infavor of a person
b. Correlative legal obligation on the part of another; to respect or not violate the said right
c. An act or omission by the latter in violation of the said right with resulting damages to
the former
4. May a person incur obligations even without entering into any a contract or
voluntary agreement? Explain
Yes. Without entering into a contract, a person can incur responsibilities, such as
upholding the laws of the land or doing his duty as the father of the house. There are
responsibilities of this sort, although there are variations.
PROBLEMS
Explain or state briefly the rule of reason for your answers.
1. X saw at about one (1:00 p.m.) in the afternoon a child alone in a shopping mall.
The child who strayed from Y, his mother, was in tears and appeared very hungry.
Out of pity, X took him to a restaurant to eat for which he spent P 150. Y did not
give her consent to the good deed of X. Furthermore, they were on their way home
before the child got lost. Is X entitled to be reimbursed by Y for the amount of
P150?
Yes, even though she did not give her consent, Y is responsible to X. X fed the infant and
costs paid by Y and these should be reimbursed by X to discourage someone from being
wrongly rewarded or benefiting at the expense of others.
2. While the car of X was parked by the roadside, it was bumped at the rear by a jeep
belonging to Y. Only the car of X suffered damage. Under the circumstances, does it
follow that Y is liable to X for the damage?
Yes, but even though there is no pre-existing contractual arrangement between them,
because of Y's incompetence, X's car was impaired. If Y had not bumped X's car, it
would not have hurt X's car. Y is, thus, responsible to X for the damages.
3. In the same problem, has X the right to ask indemnity from R, employer of X, on
the ground that when the accident occurred X was then on his way to transact
business with a client of R?
X has the reason to petition R for compensation and there is no legislation requiring
4. D (debtor) borrowed P 10,000.00 from C (creditor). On the due date of the loan, D
could not pay C because he lost to a robber the P 10,000.00 intended for C. In
addition, he suffered financial reverses, and he was short of cash even for his
current family’s needs. Is D legally justified to refuse to pay C?
No, since he entered into a voluntary deal when D lent from C and D was willing and
therefore the arrangement is legitimate. D should also cooperate in good conscience with
their deal and have no legitimate reason for denying payment to C.