LAARC Users Guide 508
LAARC Users Guide 508
LAARC Users Guide 508
CS320242-A
LAARC User’s Guide and Questionnaire
Version 2.0
August 2020
The Laboratory Assessment of Antibiotic Resistance Testing Capacity is a publication of the Division of
Healthcare Quality Promotion in the National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases within the
U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).
Suggested citation:
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Laboratory Assessment of Antibiotic Resistance Testing Capacity.
Atlanta, GA: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, CDC; 2020. Available at:
https://www.cdc.gov/drugresistance/intl-activities/laarc.html.
Antoine Pierson (Integrated Quality Laboratory Services, IQLS, Lyon, France) led the development of the Excel
scoring tool and provided expert subject matter input on the LAARC content to optimize the use of the scoring
tool. Additional support was provided by Abdoulaye Nikièma (IQLS).
The following experts participated in technical consultations to guide the development and provided technical
review of the tool: Rachel Smith, Ulzii Luvsansharav, Nora Chea, Michael Omondi, T.J. McKinney (Division of
Healthcare Quality Promotion, CDC), Michele Parsons (Division of Global Health Protection, CDC).
The following experts piloted the tool in resource-limited settings and provided technical expertise and
feedback: Nino Macharashvili, Lan Nguyen, Hien Bui, Valan Siromany, Wangeci Gatei, Molly Freeman, Pawan
Angra (Division of Global Health Protection, CDC). Lynee Galley, Emma Muir, Martin Evans, John TarBush, John
Aldom, Abdul Chagla, Vlademir Cantarelli, Victor Silva, American Society for Microbiology (ASM); Mona ElShokry,
Dana Itani, Walaa Khater, the World Health Organization (WHO); and Lindsey Shields, Rogers Kisame, Moctar
Mouiche, (FHI360).
Funding for the development of the Excel scoring tool was provided by the Division of Global Health Protection
in the Center for Global Health through a Cooperative Agreement.
DISCLAIMERS
All rights reserved. Publication of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is available on the U.S. CDC
website Lab Assessment of Antibiotic Resistance Testing Capacity (LAARC)
(https://www.cdc.gov/drugresistance/intl-activities/laarc.html) or can be obtained from Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention, 1600 Clifton Rd., Atlanta, GA, 30329, USA (email: IICP@cdc.gov).
The mention of specific companies or of certain manufacturers’ products does not imply that they are endorsed
or recommended by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in preference to others of a similar nature
who are not mentioned. Errors and omissions excepted, the names of proprietary products are distinguished by
initial capital letters.
The contents of the LAARC are solely the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official
views of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. All reasonable precautions have been taken to
verify the information contained in this publication. However, the published material is being distributed without
warranty of any kind, either expressed or implied. The responsibility for the interpretation and uses of the
material lies with the reader. In no event shall the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention or IQLS be liable for
damages arising from its use.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ..............................................................................................................................................2
DISCLAIMERS ..............................................................................................................................................................2
TABLES AND FIGURES .................................................................................................................................................4
ACRONYMS .................................................................................................................................................................5
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY................................................................................................................................................7
1. INTRODUCTION.................................................................................................................................................7
1.1. Rationale .................................................................................................................................................7
1.2. Purpose ...................................................................................................................................................7
1.3. Scope .......................................................................................................................................................8
2. ASSESSMENT PLANNING and PREPARATION ................................................................................................ 10
2.1. Assessment Team ................................................................................................................................ 10
2.2. Team Preparation ................................................................................................................................ 10
2.3. Laboratory Preparation........................................................................................................................ 11
2.4. Assessment Process ............................................................................................................................. 11
2.4.1. Take GPS Location ...................................................................................................................... 11
2.4.2. Meet with staff........................................................................................................................... 11
2.4.3. Tour the laboratory .................................................................................................................... 12
2.4.4. Review Documents and Fill the Questionnaire .......................................................................... 12
2.4.5. Professionalism .......................................................................................................................... 12
3. LAARC TOOL STRUCTURE............................................................................................................................... 13
3.1. Files ...................................................................................................................................................... 13
3.2. Excel File Organization ......................................................................................................................... 13
3.2.1. Yellow: ....................................................................................................................................... 13
3.2.2. Blue: Questionnaire (15 tabs) .................................................................................................... 13
3.2.3. Questionnaire Organization and Structure ................................................................................ 14
3.2.4. Red: ........................................................................................................................................... 15
4. ENTERING DATA INTO THE EXCEL TOOL ........................................................................................................ 16
4.1. Generate a Unique Filename ............................................................................................................... 16
4.2. Select Language ................................................................................................................................... 16
4.3. Answer Questions ................................................................................................................................ 16
4.3.1. Drop-down boxes ....................................................................................................................... 16
4.3.2. Free-text cells and Comment cells ............................................................................................. 17
4.3.3. Color Coding ............................................................................................................................... 17
5. SCORING SYSTEM........................................................................................................................................... 18
5.1. Questions ............................................................................................................................................. 18
The LAARC scoring tool is a Microsoft (MS) Excel® file. It does not contain macros, thus, it can be used on any
computer and works independently from operating system type and language. The tool is currently available in
English, French, Spanish, and Portuguese. Additional languages may be added to the translation table by the
end-user, including non-Latin alphabets.
1. INTRODUCTION
Control of antibiotic resistance (AR) is a global public health priority. Strong AR laboratory networks are
critical to inform policy and control efforts. Such networks often obtain AR data from clinical laboratories;
thus, the usefulness of the aggregate data largely depends on the ability of the laboratories to produce
accurate and reliable bacterial identification (ID) and antibiotic susceptibility testing (AST) results.
1.1 Rationale
Many existing laboratory assessment tools are designed to evaluate the quality management system
(QMS) requirements described by international laboratory standards organizations (e.g., ISO and
CLSI). These tools are inadequate to detect deficiencies in bench-level testing because they lack
technical depth and granularity. The LAARC assessment tool is designed to fill that technical gap and
is specifically adapted for laboratories in low- and middle- income countries which have not yet
established comprehensive laboratory regulations and/or accreditation requirements. The tool
contains extensive Quality Control (QC) and Quality Assurance (QA) questions, but it is primarily
technical in nature and does not provide a comprehensive QMS assessment.
1.2 Purpose
The purpose of the LAARC is to objectively evaluate technical proficiency in the bacteriologic
techniques and related quality processes that are required for accurate, reliable AR detection. Results
Other areas of importance to public health laboratories and institutions are not addressed by this
tool, such as:
• Molecular testing capacity and other advanced techniques (PCR, sequencing, MALDI)
• Packaging, shipping, transport, receiving, and storage following testing
• Participation in laboratory-based surveillance systems (e.g., STDs, TB, enterics, vaccine escape, AR)
• Funding and budget
• Non-laboratory personnel: epidemiologists, data managers and analysts, administrative support staff
• Public health roles: Notifiable Diseases, Outbreak response, provider of EQA/PT
A survey 1 addressing several of these topics was developed by WHO and is publicly available for use
in conjunction with the LAARC to comprehensively assess the AR capacity of NRLs. The LAARC does
not assess the readiness of the national health system to implement AR surveillance. Multiple WHO
tools 2,3,4,5 are available to assess national health systems.
1.3 Scope
The LAARC was built around the WHO priority AR specimen types, pathogens and antibiotics included in
their Global Antimicrobial Resistance Surveillance System (GLASS) initiative of 2015; see Tables 1 and 2.
*
Many labs are unable to definitively differentiate Acinetobacter calcoaceticus from A. baumannii, so in practice this refers to
Acinetobacter calcoaceticus-baumannii complex
†
N. gonorrhoeae was excluded from this tool due to the complexities involved with routine culture and recovery, identification and
AST, and the existence of other surveillance networks and STD clinics dedicated exclusively to this pathogen.
Staphylococcus aureus
Antibacterial class Antibacterial agents
Penicillinase-stable beta-lactams Cefoxitin
Streptococcus pneumoniae
Antibacterial class Antibacterial agents
Penicillins Oxacillin (as a screen for Penicillin resistance)
Penicillin G
Sulfonamides and Trimethoprim Co-trimoxazole
Third-generation cephalosporins Ceftriaxone or cefotaxime
Escherichia coli
Antibacterial class Antibacterial agents
Penicillins Ampicillin
Third-generation cephalosporins Ceftriaxone or Cefotaxime + Ceftazidime
Fourth-generation cephalosporin Cefepime
Carbapenems Imipenem, Meropenem, Ertapenem, Doripenem
Fluoroquinolones Ciprofloxacin or Levofloxacin
Sulfonamides and Trimethoprim Co-trimoxazole
Polymyxins Colistin
Klebsiella pneumoniae
Antibacterial class Antibacterial agents
Penicillins Ampicillin
Third-generation cephalosporins Ceftriaxone or Cefotaxime + Ceftazidime
Fourth-generation cephalosporin Cefepime
Carbapenems Imipenem, Meropenem, Ertapenem, Doripenem
Fluoroquinolones Ciprofloxacin or Levofloxacin
Sulfonamides and Trimethoprim Co-trimoxazole
Polymyxins Colistin
Acinetobacter baumannii
Antibacterial class Antibacterial agents
Aminoglycosides Gentamicin and Amikacin
Carbapenems Imipenem, Meropenem, Doripenem
Tetracyclines Tigecycline or Minocycline
Polymyxins Colistin
Shigella spp.
Antibacterial class Antibacterial agents
Third-generation cephalosporins Ceftriaxone or Cefotaxime + Ceftazidime
Fluoroquinolones Ciprofloxacin or Levofloxacin
Macrolides Azithromycin
Neisseria gonorrhoeae
Antibacterial class Antibacterial agents
Aminocyclitols Spectinomycin
Aminoglycosides Gentamicin
Fluoroquinolones Ciprofloxacin
Macrolide Azithromycin
Third-generation cephalosporins Cefixime and Ceftriaxone
Additional culture types, pathogens and antibiotics may be assessed pursuant to national priorities;
however, the current iteration of this tool focuses only those listed in Tables 1 and 2. Users cannot
edit or modify.
Ideally, all team members, including translators, would have a background in bacteriology laboratory
practices and the general operations of hospitals and clinical laboratories. Preferably, assessors will
also have previous experience with performing laboratory assessments. Persons with expertise that is
primarily research-based or that is grounded in other areas of microbiology (e.g., parasitology,
virology) are not ideal.
Allow two full days to complete each assessment. The assessment must be carried out during
laboratory operating hours to observe staff at work. A sample agenda follows:
Version 2 | August 2020 Page 10 of 90
LAARC User’s Guide and Questionnaire
Table 3: Sample agenda
Day 1 Day 2
8:00 – 8:30 am 7:30 – 09:30 am
• Introductions: Laboratory leadership, other • Observe laboratory staff at the bench
laboratory staff, and the assessment team • Continue filling assessment
• Review purpose of the evaluation and 9:30 – 10:00 am
expected timeline • Break for tea
8:30 – 9:30 am 10:00 am – Noon
• Tour laboratory • Continue filling assessment
• Begin review of pre-assembled documents, Noon – 1:00 pm
begin filling tool • Break for lunch
9:30 – 10:00 am 1:00 – 2:30 pm
• Break for tea • Complete assessment
10:00 am – Noon 2:30 – 3:30 pm
• Continue filling assessment • Summation/exit meeting with laboratory
Noon– 1:00 pm leadership, other relevant staff
• Break for lunch
1:00 – 4:30 pm
• Continue filling assessment
Partial credit. Some questions have “partial” responses available, but most are either “yes” or “no” for
simplicity of scoring. It may be tempting to mark a question as “yes” when a laboratory partially meets the
criteria, but if the criteria are not fully met and “partial” is not available, then the answer must be “no.”
Marking the response as “no” creates an opportunity for the laboratory to make the changes needed to
become fully compliant. Marking it as “yes” eliminates this opportunity to improve, which is a disservice
to the laboratory. Use the Comment boxes next to each question to add clarifying information.
Research specimens. Many laboratories have equipment, reagents and SOPs that are used for
research specimens but are not used for routine patient specimens. The questions in the LAARC
questionnaire refer only to the equipment, reagents and SOPs that are used with cultures submitted
for clinical patient management in the routine course of care.
2.4.5 Professionalism
Establishing a good relationship with laboratory personnel is vital if recommendations are to be
received well. Give recommendations and advice in a friendly and supportive manner. If there are
findings that may be embarrassing or upsetting for the laboratory, discuss them in private with the
laboratory manager and those in charge. Always obtain permission prior to taking photographs.
3.1 Files
The tool is a combination of three files:
• PDF file containing the User’s Guide and the LAARC questionnaire for printing (available in each
language: English, French, Spanish, Portuguese)
• Multilingual MS Excel tool for data entry and scoring
• (Optional) MS Excel “export reception” file to consolidate output from multiple assessments for
further analysis by statistical software; available in English only
The LAARC questionnaire is organized into 15 modules; each module contains 3 to 10 indicators. Each
indicator contains several closed questions.
• Summary: Summary of module and indicator scores, workload statistics, equipment summaries,
summary of biochemical identification reagents; four pages when printed
• Flags: Summary of all “Flagged” questions and answers; five pages when printed
• Conclusions: Includes an embedded Microsoft Word document where the assessor may insert their
conclusions in narrative form (recommended); number of pages depends on length of narrative
• Photos: Tab for inserting relevant photographs of the laboratory if desired (six positions); two pages
• Export: Compiles all scores and other select assessment data for optional export into GIS or
statistical analysis software. English only. Must be used in conjunction with Export Reception file
The entire tool will convert to your selected language, with two exceptions:
• The drop-down menus for responding to each question remain in English and cannot be translated
into other languages.
• The tab labels will remain in English.
Users may add new language translations to column F of the Language tab. The tool will accept Chinese,
Russian, or other left-to-right languages, but it is not well designed to accept Arabic or Persian
languages.
Click the response box, then click the small arrow at the right side of the cell to open a box containing
the authorized values. The answers to most questions are limited to “yes,” “no,” or “NA” (not
applicable). Select NA if the question doesn’t apply to the laboratory.
For example, if the laboratory does not perform stool cultures, select NA for questions pertaining to
stool cultures. Note: “NA” is not available for all questions, for some it is compulsory to select an
answer. In case of doubts about the appropriate answer, systematically select “no”.
Some questions have a numbered response system (see Figure 2). The corresponding response key is
located below the question; keys are translated into all languages.
Comment boxes are found next to each indicator and question on all 15 blue modules. Transcribe notes
taken during the assessment directly into a comment box, so they are not lost. See example below.
5 SCORING SYSTEM
Scoring occurs automatically as questions are answered, and Note: The overall score excludes the
scores display simultaneously on the Module tabs and on the LIS Module score, since the laboratory
Summary tab. Four levels of scores are generated: Questions -> is not directly responsible for
Indicators -> Modules -> Overall. Indicator scores are an deficiencies in the LIS.
average of the question scores comprising that indicator.
Module scores are calculated by averaging all questions in the
module, not by averaging the indicator scores making up the
module. The overall score is calculated by averaging the module
scores.
5.1 Questions
Most questions have three possible answers: Yes, No, or NA (not applicable); some offer partial
responses.
• “Correct” answers score 100%
• “Incorrect” answers score 0%
• Partial responses vary in value: 25%, 50%, 75%
• “NA” and unanswered questions have no value and are excluded from score calculations
The example in Figure 6, below, shows a portion of the Quality Assurance Module (blue lettering) and
two of the module’s indicators (black background).
The first indicator score is the average of questions 4.1 – 4.11, which is 68% (750/11). The second
indicator score is the average of questions 4.12 – 4.16, which is 100% (400/4). Note that the answer
to question 4.16 is NA, so the question is excluded from the denominator of the calculation. The
module score is not the average of the two indicator scores, which would be 84% (100+68/2). The
module score is the average of all questions, 4.1 – 4.16, excluding NA responses, which is 77%
(1150/15). The rationale for this method of calculation is that it gives equivalent weight to each
question and does not assign greater importance to any indicator.
5.3 Flags
Some questions generate “flags” that appear next to the score. Flags do not impact the score, but
they are useful for prioritizing corrective actions.
• Red Flags represent practices that may put patients or laboratory staff at risk. The laboratory should
correct these items immediately. There are 101 possible red flags
• Training Opportunity Flags highlight areas where sufficient training is commonly lacking. There are
10 possible training opportunities
• System Flags highlight problems for which the solution is often found at the level of the hospital or
national system. Laboratory leadership may need to reach out to hospital, regional, or national
leadership for assistance with correcting these issues. There are 24 possible System Flags
Scores for each Module and Indicator are summarized and displayed in a heat map, shown in Figure 8.
Figure 8: Color coded heat map for the Module: Safety Appendix and its four Indicators
8. EXPORTING DATA
In some cases, it may be useful to compile data from multiple laboratory assessments for comparison
purposes. For example, comparing assessment results from multiple laboratories to one another, or
comparing the results of one laboratory to itself over time. For this purpose, there is an Export tab
embedded in the file. This tab captures all data from the General, Summary and Flag tabs, as well as answers
to select questions from many of the Module tabs. Data from the Export tab may be copied and pasted into
another Microsoft Excel spreadsheet that has been developed for this purpose called the “Reception file.”
Data from the reception file may then be exported into analysis software.
Directions for copying and pasting into the Reception file are as follows:
1. Open both the LAARC Data file and the LAARC Data Reception file.
2. In the LAARC Data file, make sure all questions are answered. Unanswered questions will display as zeros
in the export.
3. Go to the Export tab.
• Select row 6 entirely by clicking on the number “6” at the left edge of the table
• Copy the selected data to the clipboard
• Go to the Export Reception file and select row number 8 entirely by clicking on the number “8” at the
left edge of the table. Row 8 should be blank
• Select “Paste Special,” then click “Values”
• NOTE: A “regular/simple” paste will not allow you to export the data correctly, you must “paste
special” as described above
4. Repeat steps 1-3 for each laboratory using the same Data Reception file. Each additional line of data will
be pasted on the next available blank line: 9, then 10, etc.
5. Once complete, save the Export Reception file
The .csv file can be opened by any database or GIS software. If you have shapefiles of the country or region,
you’ll be able to graphically represent indicators and data on maps. The figure below displays examples of GIS
mapping of equipment and sample volumes from another assessment tool (not LAARC).
Dear Sir/Madam,
The Ministry of Health of [COUNTRY] is developing a surveillance system for antimicrobial resistance (AR) of
priority bacterial pathogens. [LABORATORY NAME] may serve as a sentinel site for the surveillance system. As
such, an evaluation of the baseline capacity of the laboratory to perform basic bacteriology including isolation,
identification and antibiotic susceptibility testing (AST) has been proposed. The evaluation will be carried out
using the Laboratory Assessment of AR Testing Capacity (LAARC) developed by the International Infection
Control Program at the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The purpose of the evaluation is to
identify gaps in capacity and aid in development of plans for improvement prior to initiating surveillance.
The laboratory assessment may take up to two full days to complete. A proposed schedule is included below:
Day 1 Day 2
The assessment will be carried out by an experienced clinical bacteriologist, [NAME, TITLE, AND AFFILIATION OF
ASSESSOR if available], a representative from the Ministry of Health, and [ANY ADDITIONAL PERSONNEL].
We will perform the assessment during regular business hours, on days when staffing levels will be adequate to
permit the assessors to interact with the bacteriology technologists without disrupting their workflow. We
request that Bacteriology section heads, supervisors, and quality managers are present during the assessment
and that their schedules are clear of meetings or other obligations to the extent possible.
The following documents and information will require review by the assessors. To the extent these can be
assembled in advance into a single clean room for the team, the time required for the evaluation will be greatly
reduced:
• Names, job titles, and email addresses of relevant bacteriology laboratory leadership (e.g., Director,
Manager, Supervisor, Section Head, Quality Officer, etc.)
• Copies of any recent assessments by a third party
• Annual test volume for each specimen type
All findings and recommendations shall be discussed with the bacteriology supervisor in private prior to the final
summation. Please reach out to [Assessment Team Lead] with any questions.
The following dates have been proposed [dd/mm/yyyy – dd/mm/yyyy]. Please contact [Ministry Official] to
accept or reschedule your assessment dates.
Sincerely,
AST/AMR
• CLSI M02: Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Disk Susceptibility Tests
• CLSI M02QG: Disk Diffusion Reading Guide
• CLSI M07: Methods for Dilution Antimicrobial Susceptibility Tests for Bacteria That Grow Aerobically
• CLSI M39: Analysis and Presentation of Cumulative Antimicrobial Susceptibility Test Data
• CLSI M45: Methods for Antimicrobial Dilution and Disk Susceptibility Testing of Infrequently Isolated or
Fastidious Bacteria
• CLSI M100 Performance Standards for Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing
• ETEST Reading Guide [PDF - 2 pages] (http://www.ilexmedical.com/files/ETEST_RG.pdf)
• EUCAST Breakpoint Tables
• EUCAST Disk Test Reading Guide
• EUCAST reading guide for broth microdilution
• EUCAST Manual Disk Test
• EUCAST Preparation of agar plates and broth for EUCAST AST
• EUCAST Intrinsic Resistance and Unusual Phenotypes
• EUCAST Expert Rules for Enterobacterales, Staphylococcus, and other species
(http://www.eucast.org/expert_rules_and_intrinsic_resistance/)
• EUCAST guidelines for detection of resistance mechanisms and specific resistances of clinical and/or
epidemiological importance
Quality Control
• CLSI M22: Quality Control for Commercially Prepared Microbiological Culture Media
• CLSI M40: Quality Control of Microbiological Transport Systems
• CLSI M50: Quality Control for Commercial Microbial Identification Systems
• CLSI M52: Verification of Commercial Microbial ID and AST Systems
• EUCAST QC tables
Laboratory Biosafety
• WHO Laboratory Biosafety Manual
(https://www.who.int/csr/resources/publications/biosafety/WHO_CDS_CSR_LYO_2004_11/en/)
• CLSI M29: Protection of Laboratory Workers from Occupationally Acquired Infections
• CLSI GP05: Clinical Laboratory Waste Management
• CLSI GP17: Clinical Laboratory Safety
• CDC Biosafety in Microbiological and Biomedical Laboratories (BMBL)
(https://www.cdc.gov/labs/BMBL.html)
Table of Contents
Introduction ............................................................................................................................................................32
Assessor's Guide ......................................................................................................................................................33
0- GENERAL INFORMATION ......................................................................................................................................36
LABORATORY DEMOGRAPHICS ......................................................................................................................................... 36
TEST MENU and WORKLOAD ............................................................................................................................................ 37
AST/AMR METHODS AND WORKLOAD ............................................................................................................................. 38
LABORATORY STAFF EDUCATION/TRAINING .................................................................................................................... 38
QMS MENTORING PROGRAMS ......................................................................................................................................... 39
ACCREDITATION and CERTIFICATION ............................................................................................................................... 39
1- FACILITY...............................................................................................................................................................40
LABORATORY FACILITY ...................................................................................................................................................... 40
GENERAL EQUIPMENT AVAILABILITY ................................................................................................................................ 40
MEDIA PREPARATION EQUIPMENT AVAILABILITY ............................................................................................................ 41
EQUIPMENT CALIBRATION RECORDS ............................................................................................................................... 41
THERMOMETERS............................................................................................................................................................... 41
TEMPERATURE AND ATMOSPHERE MONITORING ........................................................................................................... 42
AUTOCLAVE MANAGEMENT ............................................................................................................................................. 43
INSTRUMENT AVAILABILITY AND MAINTENANCE ............................................................................................................ 43
INVENTORY & STOCK OUTS .............................................................................................................................................. 44
2 - LABORATORY INFORMATION SYSTEM (ELECTRONIC)............................................................................................46
DEMOGRAPHIC DATA FIELDS ............................................................................................................................................ 46
SPECIMEN DATA FIELDS .................................................................................................................................................... 46
CULTURE OBSERVATION DATA FIELDS.............................................................................................................................. 46
AST DATA FIELDS ............................................................................................................................................................... 47
REPORTS AND DATA TRANSFER CAPABILITIES.................................................................................................................. 47
INTERFACE CONNECTIVITY................................................................................................................................................ 47
3- DATA MANAGEMENT ...........................................................................................................................................49
PATIENT AND SPECIMEN IDENTIFICATION ....................................................................................................................... 49
SPECIMEN REQUISITION FORM ........................................................................................................................................ 49
ORDER ENTRY.................................................................................................................................................................... 49
CULTURE OBSERVATIONS ................................................................................................................................................. 50
AST RESULTS REPORTING.................................................................................................................................................. 50
DATA BACKUP & SECURITY ............................................................................................................................................... 51
AMR DATA SHARING ......................................................................................................................................................... 51
Many existing laboratory assessment tools are designed to evaluate the essential quality management system (QMS) requirements
described by international laboratory standards organizations such as ISO and CLSI. These tools are inadequate to detect deficiencies
in bench-level testing because they lack sufficient technical depth and granularity. The LAARC assessment tool is designed to fill that
technical gap and is specifically adapted for laboratories in low- and middle- income countries which have not yet established
comprehensive laboratory regulations and/or accreditation requirements. The tool contains extensive Quality Control (QC) and
Quality Assurance (QA) questions, but it is primarily technical in nature and does not provide a comprehensive QMS assessment.
The purpose of the LAARC is to objectively evaluate technical proficiency in the bacteriologic techniques and related quality
processes that are required for accurate, reliable AR detection. Results provide a clear pathway toward improvement. The LAARC
was designed for use in hospital-based laboratories that receive and process clinical specimens for the purposes of routine patient
care. National reference laboratories (NRLs) and other public health labs will benefit from the technical assessment, however, the
key gaps in assessing NRL capacity include the lack of questions about molecular testing, funding and budget, the non-laboratory
personnel required to administer an AMR surveillance program and much more. Other tools are available to assess these areas.
The LAARC was built around the WHO priority AR specimen types, pathogens and antibiotics included in their Global Antimicrobial
Resistance Surveillance System (GLASS) initiative of 2015. These are:
Additional culture types, pathogens and antibiotics may be evaluated pursuant to national priorities; however, the current iteration
of this tool focuses only on the above; users cannot edit or modify the tool.
* Most labs are unable to definitively differentiate Acinetobacter calcoaceticus from A. baumannii, so in practice this
refers to Acinetobacter calcoaceticus-baumannii complex.
† N. gonorrhoeae was excluded from this tool due to the complexities involved with routine culture and recovery,
identification and AST, and the existence of other surveillance networks and STD clinics dedicated exclusively to this
pathogen.
Version 2 | August 2020 Page 32 of 90
LAARC User’s Guide and Questionnaire Appendix 3: LAARC Questionnaire
Assessor's Guide
Figure for use with Facility Module, question 1.13
McFarland QC Standards in front of a Wickerham card
Figure 2 Abbreviations:
Tables for use with AST Expert Rules Module, questions 12.7 - 12.25
Current CLSI and EUCAST breakpoints for Salmonella spp, Enterobacteriaceae, Acinetobacter spp, and Pseudomonas
aeruginosa
0.6 Address
Enter answer
0.7 City
Enter answer
0.8 Province
Enter answer
0.9 District
Enter answer
0.10 Country
Enter answer
GPS position of the laboratory (used for GIS representation of indicators). PLEASE ONLY USE DIGITAL DEGREE WITH + OR - SIGN. DO
NOT USE DEGREES, MINUTES, SECONDS GPS position of the laboratory (used for GIS representation of indicators). PLEASE ONLY USE
DIGITAL DEGREE WITH + OR - SIGN. DO NOT USE DEGREES, MINUTES, SECONDS
Question Number
Question Answer Example
For altitude, enter meters without digits. Example: If altitude is 61.49 meters,
Enter answer
0.11
Altitude enter 61
For latitude, enter digital degrees with 5 digits after the comma. Example: 41,40338
Enter answer
0.12
Latitude
For longitude, enter digital degrees with 5 digits after the comma. Example: -2,17403
Enter answer
0.13
Longitude
0.14 Contact information of the relevant bacteriology laboratory leadership; e.g., Director, Manager, Supervisor, Section Head,
Quality Officer
Title/Position First Name Last name Email address
Enter answer Enter answer Enter answer Enter answer
3. NGO/Faith-based/Donors
4. Other
Primary Laboratory affiliation
1. Hospital: University Medical Center or Teaching Hospital
2. Hospital: Military
3. Hospital: (not academic or military)
1234
0.16 4. Clinic (primarily outpatient) place holder
567
5. Reference/referral lab within a Public Health Institute
6. Reference/referral lab not affiliated with a single healthcare facility or
public health institute
7. Other, e.g., Research Laboratory
3. Provincial 45
4. District
5. NA
Service level of the Hospital/Healthcare Facility
1. Primary
2. Secondary 123
0.18 place holder
3. Tertiary 45
4. Other
5. NA
Number of beds of the Hospital/Healthcare Facility
1: <100
2: 100 - 499 123
0.19 place holder
3: 500 - 1000 45
4: >1000
5: NA
Instructions for
the 5 items
Please indicate if the lab performs stool culture for the following place holder place holder place holder
below.
enteric pathogens. Do not enter the number of cultures.
0.23 Salmonella and/or Shigella Y N place holder place holder
0.36 MRSA screen for Infection Control purposes (e.g., nares, axilla, groin) Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.37 VRE screen for Infection Control purposes (e.g., rectal swab) Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.40 Y N
comments)
antibiotics tested
0.41 Disk diffusion Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.47 Phoenix Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.48 Microscan Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.51 CRE/Carbapenemases Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.52 MRSA Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.53 VRE Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.57 Carbapenemases Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.58 mecA Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.59 vanA/vanB Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.60 mcr-1 Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.62 Y N
Sciences (PhD, MD, equivalent)
0.63 Advanced degree, other concentration (PhD, MD, equivalent) Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.64 Y N
Sciences
0.65 Postgraduate Master's degree, other concentration Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.66 Y N
Sciences
0.67 Graduate Bachelor's degree, other concentration Y N
Enter number Enter comment
0.68 Y N
Laboratory Sciences
1: 1 star 5: 5 stars 4 5
2: 2 stars NA NA
3: 3 stars
Has the laboratory ever been enrolled in the WHO LQSI program?
Enter year Enter comment
0.76 Y N
What year?
If yes, what was the last overall % score for the 4 phases? What year?
Enter year Enter comment
1: >90% 4: <50% 1 2 3
0.77
2: 70%-89% NA 4 NA
3: 50-69%
Has the laboratory ever been enrolled in any other mentoring
Enter year Enter comment
1.8
computers, automated instruments) supported by a functioning generator? Partial
Are all critical pieces of equipment attached to uninterrupted power source
Enter comment
YN
1.9 (UPS) devices? (These provide temporary power until the generator can be
Partial
activated)
In the last 6 months, has prolonged power failure disrupted the ability to
Enter comment
1.10 Y N
provide routine bacteriology services?
Is there a contingency plan in place for continued testing in the event of
Enter comment
1.11 Y N
prolonged electricity disruption (e.g., power outage lasting several days)?
Standard: ISO 15189: 5.2.5 & 5.2.10 The laboratory space should be sufficient to
ensure that the quality of work, the safety of personnel, and the ability of staff to
carry out quality control procedures and documentation. The laboratory should
be clean and well organized, free of clutter, well-ventilated, adequately lit, and
Standard for item
above. within acceptable temperature ranges. Emergency power should be available for place holder place holder
1.16 Calibrated 1uL or 10uL loops (for plating urine cultures) Y N place Enter comment
holder
1.20 Microscope Y N
Enter Enter comment
number
1.21 Thermometers Y N
Enter Enter comment
number
strips)
der
1.39 Hot plate with magnetic stir bar (for mixing powdered media) Y N NA
Enter Enter comment
number
1.43 Centrifuge Y N NA
Enter comment
1.44 Thermometers Y N NA
Enter comment
1.45 pH meter Y N NA
Enter comment
THERMOMETERS
Indicate if manual (non-digital) thermometers are present inside each piece
Question Number of equipment. (Select NA if the lab does not have the equipment.) Answer Comment
1.53 CO2incubator Y N NA
Enter comment
1.60 Hot plate with magnetic stir bar (for mixing powdered media) Y N NA
Enter comment
1.63 Y N
defined on the record sheet?
Freezers, −20°C
Topic for 2 place holder place holder
questions below.
1.65 Y N NA
defined on the record sheet?
Freezers, −60°C
Topic for 2 place holder place holder
questions below.
1.67 Y N NA
defined on the record sheet?
Freezers, −80°C
Topic for 2 place holder place holder
questions below.
1.69 Y N NA
defined on the record sheet?
Refrigerators
Topic for 2 place holder place holder
questions below.
1.71 Y N
defined on the record sheet?
Incubators, ambient atmosphere
Topic for 2 place holder place holder
questions below.
1.73 Y N
defined on the record sheet?
Incubators, CO2
Topic for 3 place holder place holder
questions below.
1.75 Y N NA
defined on the record sheet?
Are CO2 incubators checked for adequate CO2 levels and documented daily
Enter comment
1.76 Y N NA
(or each day of use if not used daily)?
Water baths
Topic for 2 place holder place holder
questions below.
1.78 Y N NA
defined on the record sheet?
Standard for item Standard: Acceptable ranges should be defined for all temperature place holder place holder
dependent equipment
above.
temperatures?
1.79 1: Yes 1 2 3
2: No action is documented
3: Temperatures are not recorded
Standard for item Standard: Procedures should be available with instruction as to what place holder place holder
AUTOCLAVE MANAGEMENT
Question Number
Question Answer Comment
Instructions for 3 Do records demonstrate that the following mechanical indicators are recorded place holder place holder
1.80 Temperature Y N NA
Enter comment
1.81 Pressure Y N NA
Enter comment
Do records demonstrate that chemical indicators (e.g., heat sensitive tape) are
Enter comment
1.83 Y N NA
used each time the autoclave is run? (Review logs to confirm)
Do records demonstrate that biological indicators (e.g., Attest or other spore
Enter comment
1.89 Are routine (user) maintenance records present? Y N NA place Enter comment
holder
1.90 Are preventive (vendor) maintenance records present? Y N NA place Enter comment
holder
Does the laboratory have an automated instrument for bacterial ID and BRAND:
Enter
number
1.93 Y N
AST? (e.g., Vitek, Microscan, Phoenix)
1.94 Is the instrument functional today? Y N NA place Enter comment
holder
1.96 Are routine (user) maintenance records present? Y N NA place Enter comment
holder
1.97 Are preventive (vendor) maintenance records present? Y N NA place Enter comment
holder
Does the laboratory have an automated instrument for reading disk BRAND/ MODEL:
Enter
number
1.100 Y N
diffusion? (e.g., SIRSCAN, BIOMIC V3, ADAGIO, etc.)
1.101 Is the instrument functional today? Y N NA place Enter comment
holder
1.103 Are routine (user) maintenance records present? Y N NA place Enter comment
holder
1.104 Are preventive (vendor) maintenance records present? Y N NA place Enter comment
holder
1.110 Are routine (user) maintenance records present? Y N NA place Enter comment
holder
1.111 Are preventive (vendor) maintenance records present? Y N NA place Enter comment
holder
Does the lab have a PCR instrument used for detecting antibiotic BRAND/ MODEL:
Enter
number
1.114 Y N
resistance genes? (e.g., GeneXpert)
1.115 Is the instrument functional today? Y N NA place Enter comment
holder
1.117 Are routine (user) maintenance records present? Y N NA place Enter comment
holder
1.118 Are preventive (vendor) maintenance records present? Y N NA place Enter comment
holder
1.121 Y N place
1.122 Y N place
In the last 6 months, has the lab/hospital experienced stock outs of specimen
Enter comment
1.124 Y N
collection materials? (e.g., blood culture bottles, sterile cups, sterile swabs)
In the last 6 months, has the lab experienced stock outs of consumables? (e.g.,
Enter comment
1.125 petri dishes, tubes, sterile saline, pipettes, pipette tips, plastic inoculating Y N
loops, gloves, paper, gauze, disinfectant)
In the last 6 months, has the lab experienced stock outs of media? (e.g.,
Enter comment
1.126 Y N
powdered media, sheep blood, other additives, tubed media)
In the last 6 months, has the lab experienced stock outs of conventional
Enter comment
1.127 reagents? (e.g., oxidase reagent, indole reagent, catalase reagent, coagulase Y N
reagent, etc.)
In the last 6 months, has the lab experienced stock outs of antibiotic disks or
Enter comment
1.128 Y N
strips?
In the last 6 months, has the lab experienced stock outs of ID or AST
Enter comment
1.129 Y N NA
cards/trays for the automated instruments?
In the last 6 months, has the lab experienced stock outs of control materials or
Enter comment
1.130 Y N
reference strains?
1.131 In the last 6 months, has the lab experienced stock outs of other key materials? Y N
Enter comment
In the last 6 months, have any stock outs disrupted the lab's ability to provide
Enter comment
1.132 Y N
routine bacteriology services?
In the event of stock outs, is a contingency plan in place to provide
Enter comment
1.133 Y N
uninterrupted bacteriology services?
Standard: Testing services should not be subject to interruption due to stock
Standard for item outs. Laboratories should pursue all options for borrowing stock from another place holder place holder
laboratory or referring samples to another testing facility while the stock out
above.
is being addressed.
Are all currently in use media, reagents and test kits within the manufacturer-
Enter comment
1.134 Y N
assigned expiry dates? (Verify by random sampling)
Standard: All reagent and test kits in use, as well as those in stock, should be
Standard for item
above. within the manufacturer-assigned expiry dates. Expired stock should not be place holder place holder
following?
items below.
2.8 Patient Location (Ward or Unit at the time of specimen collection, e.g., "ICU") Y N
Enter comment
following?
items below.
2.22 Y N
"beta-hemolytic")
Description of colony quantities (e.g., "1+, 2+, 3+, 4+" or "few, moderate,
Enter comment
2.23 Y N
many")
2.24 Gram stain of bacterial colony Y N
Enter comment
2.25 Y N
methods
2.26 Organism name Y N
Enter comment
2.27 Y N
culture: isolate #1, isolate #2)
2.28 Y N
result (e.g., Etest vs. Vitek vs. disk)?
Instructions for Observe data entry into the LIS. Are individual data fields present for each of place holder place holder
the following?
items below.
2.33 Can the LIS record MIC values to three decimal places (e.g., 0.016)? Y N
Enter comment
Can the LIS suppress (hide) an individual antibiotic result from the patient
Enter comment
2.34 Y N
report without deleting it from the database (for cascade reporting)?
Does the LIS software automatically interpret zone sizes into Susceptible,
Enter comment
2.35 Y N
Intermediate, Resistant?
Does the LIS software automatically interpret MICs into Susceptible,
Enter comment
2.36 Y N
Intermediate, Resistant?
If the LIS software automatically interprets zone sizes or MICs, are the
Enter comment
2.37 Y N
breakpoints updated annually?
If the LIS software automatically interprets zone sizes or MICs, are the
Enter comment
2.38 Y N
breakpoints up to date today?
Can the LIS de-duplicate data based on select criteria (e.g., patient ID, organism,
Enter comment
2.39 Y N
specimen date)?
2.40 Can the LIS produce a cumulative antibiogram report? Y N
Enter comment
Can the LIS interface with automated AST instruments (e.g., Vitek, Phoenix,
Enter comment
2.41 Y N
SIRScan, BIOMIC)?
2.42 Can the LIS interface with the Hospital Information System (HIS)? Y N
Enter comment
2.43 Can the LIS export line lists of data to .txt or .csv files? Y N
Enter comment
INTERFACE CONNECTIVITY
Question Number
Question Answer Comment
Instructions for (An “interface” is an electronic connection that allows information to flow place holder place holder
If the lab uses an automated AST instrument, describe the data flow between
Enter comment
Y N
2.45 Record (EMR)?
NA
If yes, please record system name in comments
3.1 Y N
hospital?
Are outpatients assigned a unique patient ID number upon registration at the
Enter comment
3.2 Y N
clinic?
Are patient ID numbers assigned in such a way that no two patients are given
Enter comment
3.3 Y N
the same number in the course of one year?
Do patients retain the same patient ID number each time they are admitted to
Enter comment
3.4 Y N
the hospital?
Does the laboratory use the same patient ID numbers assigned by the hospital
Enter comment
3.5 Y N
and/or clinics?
Does the laboratory assign a unique specimen ID number to each specimen
Enter comment
3.6 Y N
received in the lab?
Are specimen numbers assigned in such a way that no two specimens are given
Enter comment
3.7 Y N
the same number during one year?
data fields?
items below.
3.11 Patient Location (Ward or unit at time of specimen collection, e.g., "ICU") Y N
Enter comment
ORDER ENTRY
Question Number
Question Answer Comment
Instructions for Review the process of specimen receiving/order entry. Are each of the following place holder place holder
3.22 Patient Location (Ward or unit at time of specimen collection, e.g., "ICU") Y N
Enter comment
3.36 Y N
"beta-hemolytic")
Description of colony quantities (e.g. "1+, 2+, 3+, 4+" or "few, moderate,
Enter comment
3.37 Y N
many")
Gram stain of bacterial growth colonies (gram-positive cocci, gram-negative
Enter comment
3.38 Y N
bacilli, etc.)
Biochemical test results (e.g., "catalase positive") for conventional test
Enter comment
3.39 Y N
methods
3.40 AST Method used for each antibiotic (e.g., Disk, Etest, Instrument) Y N
Enter comment
3.46 Y N
one year)?
physician/client
1: Fully electronic system – physician does not receive a paper report from
3.47 123
the lab
2: Combination of paper and electronic reporting
3: Fully paper-based system
If AST results are fully or partially issued to physicians on paper, please describe
Enter comment
that system.
1: Printout from the Laboratory Information System
3.48 1234
2: Printout from the ID/AST instrument (e.g., Vitek, Phoenix, etc.)
3: Printout from a non-LIS computer program (e.g., Word, Excel)
4: Primarily hand-written onto a paper form
3.49 Are AST reports retained for a defined time period (at least one year)? Y N
Enter comment
1: Daily/Continuously
3.51 2: Other frequency, specify in comments 1 2 3 NA
3: Never
NA: no electronic database
Does the lab or facility have a policy and/or SOP on data backup and
Enter comment
3.52 Y N NA
restoration?
Does the lab or facility have a policy and/or SOP on data security and
Enter comment
3.53 Y N NA
confidentiality?
3.54 Do laboratory computers have antivirus software? Y N NA
Enter comment
Which of the following methods are currently used to submit data to the AMR
Instructions for
items below. surveillance network(s)? More than one method may be selected. If the lab place holder place holder
Instructions for If the lab has ever tried to use BacLink to transfer data from the LIS into place holder place holder
3.64 The LIS export file was missing some of the required data fields Y N NA
Enter comment
The LIS export file merged/combined different data fields into a single
Enter comment
3.65 Y N NA
column
3.66 The LIS export file does not distinguish antibiotic results by AST method Y N NA
Enter comment
3.67 The LIS export file does not contain zone sizes or MIC values Y N NA
Enter comment
If the lab has ever tried to use BacLink to transfer data from the automated
Instructions for
items below. AST instrument into WHONET, were any of the following problems place holder place holder
encountered?
The instrument export file was missing some of the required data fields (like
Enter comment
3.69 Y N NA
patient demographics)
The instrument export file merged/combined different data fields into a
Enter comment
3.70 Y N NA
single column
3.71 The instrument export file was missing MIC values Y N NA
Enter comment
4.1 Y N
17025 or 9001)?
4.2 Does the lab have a formally designated Quality Officer or Manager? Y N
Enter comment
4.3 Y N
quality manager?
Is there documentation showing that the Quality Officers and Focal Points
Enter comment
AST QC results?
4.5 1234
1: Weekly 3: Sporadically
2: Monthly 4: Never
Is there evidence that QC review is performed at the stated frequency?
Enter comment
4.8 Y N
day?
Are there written guidelines stating who is permitted to modify erroneous lab
Enter comment
4.9 Y N
results after they have been reported?
Who is permitted to modify erroneous lab results?
Enter comment
erroneous result?
1: Erroneous results remain in place but are amended to reflect that
4.11 123
they are erroneous
2: Erroneous results are deleted from the record
3: Other (explain in comments)
4.12 Y N
microbiology or medical laboratory science?
Is the lab sufficiently staffed to provide high quality services? (Including
Enter comment
4.13 Y N
support staff)
4.14 Does the lab have a standardized process for training new employees? Y N
Enter comment
Does the lab have up-to-date documentation showing which benches & tests
Enter comment
4.15 each staff member has been trained on and approved to work Y N
independently? (Review such records)
Do records demonstrate that lab staff receive annual competency
Instructions for
items below. assessments for each of the following? (Review competency records, select place holder place holder
Standard: Newly hired lab staff should be assessed for competency before
performing independent duties and again within six months. All lab staff should
be regularly assessed for testing competency at least once a year. Staff
assigned to a new section should be assessed before fully assuming
independent duties. When deficiencies are noted, retraining and reassessment
Standard for item
above. should be planned and documented. If the employee’s competency remains place holder place holder
below standard, further action might include supervisory review of work, re-
assignment of duties, or other appropriate actions. Records of competency
assessments and resulting actions should be retained in personnel files and/or
quality records. Records should show which skills were assessed, how those
skills were measured, and who performed the assessment.
TOUBLESHOOTING, PROBLEM SOLVING, AND ROOT CAUSE ANALYSES
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
Is a root cause analysis performed when unacceptable QC results are
Enter comment
4.24 Y N
obtained? (Request to see a recent example)
Is corrective action based on the findings of the root cause analysis
Enter comment
4.25 Y N
documented?
Is there evidence the supervisor or Quality Officer has received adequate
Enter comment
4.27 Y N
not performed?
Are patient results reported if QC of media, ID method, or AST method failed
Enter comment
4.28 Y N
to produce acceptable results?
Is there evidence that the lab troubleshoots unacceptable QC results for
Enter comment
4.29 Y N
media, reagents, ID systems and AST methods?
If automated instruments are used for ID, (e.g., Vitek, Phoenix, Microscan) is
Enter comment
that include both bacterial identification & AST? (Please do not include
challenges designed to focus on a single organism, e.g., TB or N. gonorrhoeae)
4.31 1: One time per year 1234
2: Two times per year
3: Three times per year or more
4: Zero (if zero, please answer question 4.32, then skip to 5 – Media QC)
If the lab does not participate in an EQA program, what is the reason?
Enter comment
4.33 Y N
Please list provider in comments
Are the test methods used on EQA isolates the same as the test methods
Enter comment
4.34 Y N
used for routine patient isolates?
4.35 Y N
what would be performed on a typical patient isolate?
Does the lab ever send EQA isolates to another lab for confirmation before
Enter comment
4.36 Y N
submitting results?
Does the lab ever call another lab to ask what their EQA result was before
Enter comment
4.37 Y N
submitting results?
Are PT/EQA specimens tested by the same staff performing patient testing?
Enter comment
4.38 (Look for evidence that all staff participate in the challenges, not only Y N
supervisors or senior staff)
On average, how long does the lab have to wait before receiving the results of
Enter comment
123
4.40 many did the lab score ≥ 80%?
None
If scores are not made available to review, select "None"
Review the 3 most recent EQA challenges for AST. On how many did the lab
Enter comment
123
4.41 score ≥80%?
None
If scores are not made available to review, select "None"
Is a root cause analysis performed when unacceptable PT/EQA results are
Enter comment
4.42 Y N
obtained? (Request to see a recent example)
Is corrective action based on the findings of the root cause analysis
Enter comment
4.43 Y N
documented?
Is there evidence the supervisor or Quality Officer has received adequate
Enter comment
4.45 Y N
they are received?
5.1 Y N NA
house?
Instructions for
items below. Do all media preparation records including the following? place holder place holder
5.6 pH Y N NA
Enter comment
Instructions for Observe the media reconstituted in house, is each batch clearly labeled with place holder place holder
the following?
items below.
5.13 Y N
and cultures are processed?
5.14 Is media prepared in a clean room? Y N
Enter comment
5.15 Is deionized water (DI) or distilled water used to prepare all media? Y N
Enter comment
5.16 Are the media suspensions mixed with a magnetic stir bar while boiling? Y N
Enter comment
5.17 Y N
≥15 minutes?
Is the autoclaved suspension cooled to 45-50°C before adding additional
Enter comment
5.18 Y N
compounds (e.g. blood)?
What is the source of the blood used to make the blood agar, chocolate,
Enter comment
5.23 Conductimetry Y N NA
Enter comment
5.24 pH Y N NA
Enter comment
5.25 Sterility Y N NA
Enter comment
If the lab purchases distilled or deionized water, does it come with a Certificate
Enter comment
5.26 Y N NA
of Analysis demonstrating proper pH, sterility and conductimetry?
ROUTINE MEDIA QC
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
Are new batches of media checked for sterility by incubating a portion of un-
Enter comment
5.27 Y N
inoculated plates?
1: All
5.28 123
2: Some
3: None
Do records demonstrate that QC is performed on each newly reconstituted
Enter comment
5.29 Y N
batch or newly received lot number/shipment of media?
Do QC records for blood agar plates (BAP) demonstrate that they are checked
Enter comment
5.31 Y N
show alpha, beta, and gamma hemolysis?
Do QC records for chocolate agar plates demonstrate that they are checked for
Enter comment
5.32 their ability to support the growth of fastidious organisms, such as Neisseria Y N
gonorrhoeae or Haemophilus influenzae?
MacConkey (MAC) and Eosin methylene blue (EMB) agars contain bile salts
Enter comment
and/or dyes that are toxic for gram-positive bacteria when made properly.
5.33 Y N NA
Do QC records for MAC and/or EMB plates demonstrate that each batch/lot is
challenged using a gram-positive organism?
Dyes and pH indicators in MAC and EMB plates provide a color indicator to
Enter comment
5.35 that they are checked for their ability to suppress the growth of gram-positive Y N NA
organisms?
Do QC records for selective stool agar plates demonstrate that they are
Enter comment
5.36 checked for their ability to make hydrogen sulfide (H2S) production visible Y N NA
using an H2S producing organism, such as Salmonella spp or Proteus vulgaris?
Do QC records for selective stool agar plates demonstrate that they are
Enter comment
5.37 checked for their ability to make the acid byproducts of carbohydrate Y N NA
fermentation visible using both fermenters and non-fermenters?
Standard: CAP MIC.21300; SANAS TG 28-02: 6.1 The suitable performance of
culture media, diluents, and other suspensions prepared in-house should be
Standard for item checked, where relevant, with regard to recovery or survival maintenance of place holder place holder
Does the dehydrated Mueller Hinton Agar (dHMA) meet ISO 16782 (CLSI
Enter comment
5.40 Y N NA
bath?
Do plates have a uniform depth of approximately 4mm? Verify by examining
Enter comment
5.41 Y N
a recent batch.
5.42 Are plates poured on a level surface? Y N
Enter comment
Do records indicate that sterility is checked for each batch? (By incubating a
Enter comment
5.44 Y N
portion of un-inoculated plates, ideally 5%)
5.45 Are plates stored at 2-8°C until use? Y N
Enter comment
5.48 Y N
disk
Do QC records indicate that each batch of Mueller Hinton Blood (MHB) agar is
Enter comment
checked for its ability to produce expected zone sizes using Streptococcus
5.49 Y N NA
pneumoniae ATCC 49619 (or equivalent)?
Check NA if the lab does not use MHB
5.50 Y N
If no, answer NA to remaining questions
Which base broth is used? (Broth must support growth of a wide range of
Enter comment
bacterial species) 1
1: Brain Heart Infusion 2
2: Supplemented peptone 3
3: Soybean-casein digest (tryptic soy) 4
5.51 4: Thioglycolate 5
5: Thiol 6
6: Colombia 7
7: Brucella 8
8: Other NA
NA
Is sodium polyanethole sulfonate (SPS) added? (an anticoagulant and growth
Enter comment
5.52 Y N NA
stabilizer)
Are any growth-promoters added? (Such as: Gelatin, Yeast Extract, Hemin (X-
Enter comment
5.54 blood) Y N NA
If yes, please describe in comments
Is 50mL of broth dispensed into sterile bottles for adult patients? (1:5
Enter comment
5.55 Y N NA
blood:broth ratio)
Is 25mL of broth dispensed into sterile bottles for pediatric patients? (1:5
Enter comment
5.56 Y N NA
blood:broth ratio)
5.57 Are the bottles autoclaved at 121°C for ≥15 min? Y N NA
Enter comment
Instructions for
items below. Do QC records for blood culture bottles indicate the following: place holder place holder
5.59 Y N NA
5%)
5.60 Ability to support growth of Streptococcus pneumoniae Y N NA
Enter comment
Near the expiration date, is QC repeated on a few of the bottles to confirm the
Enter comment
5.62 Y N NA
long-term stability of the broth?
Are unused bottles labeled correctly (name, batch #, production date and
Enter comment
5.63 Y N NA
expiration date)?
6.2 Y N
organisms?
Observe the Gram stain, catalase, coagulase, oxidase and indole reagents in use
by the laboratory. Are they labeled with:
Instructions for
items below. 1: All place holder place holder
2: Some
3: None
6.3 Name of reagent 123
Enter comment
Are tubed media, reagents, and kits stored at the temperatures indicated by the
Enter comment
6.7 Y N
manufacturer?
Topic for 4
questions below. Coagulase plasma place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Staphylococcus latex agglutination place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Staphylococcus Chromagar place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. PYR place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Optochin ("P") disk place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Bile solubility (deoxycholate) place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Streptococcus pneumoniae latex agglutination place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Oxidase place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Indole reagents place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Methyl Red place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Voges-Proskauer place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Citrate place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Urease place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Motility place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Lysine Iron Agar (LIA) or Lysine decarboxylase (LDC) place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Glucose or Dextrose Oxidative-Fermentative (OF) test place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Nitrate reduction place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Gelatin hydrolysis place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Chloramphenicol resistance (disk) place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Growth at 42°C place holder place holder
Standard: CAP MIC.21624 Positive and negative controls must be tested and
Standard for item
above. recorded for all differential test procedures. Controls must be performed and place holder place holder
Topic for 4
questions below. Salmonella serotype place holder place holder
Check NA if the lab does not use any commercial test kits for organism ID
Is QC performed on every new lot number/shipment before kits are placed
Enter comment
6.108 Y N NA
into use, according to manufacturer recommendations?
6.109 Is QC performed using ATCC or ATCC-derivative strains? Y N NA
Enter comment
6.111 Y N NA
they are placed into use?
6.112 Is QC performed using ATCC or ATCC-derivative strains? Y N NA
Enter comment
7.1 Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923/CIP 76.25 (If CLSI standard used) Y N NA
Enter comment
7.2 Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 29213/CIP 103429 (If EUCAST standard used) Y N NA
Enter comment
7.3 Y N NA
Mueller Hinton Agar for trimethoprim-sulfonamide tests)
7.4 Streptococcus pneumoniae ATCC 49619 Y N
Enter comment
Instructions for
items below. Are reference strains stored as follows? place holder place holder
7.7 Y N NA
<−20°C
Reference stock cultures (broth preparations of reference cultures)
Enter comment
maintained at
7.8 Y N NA
<−20°C in a suitable stabilizer (10% -15% glycerol in tryptic soy broth, 50%
fetal calf serum in broth, defibrinated sheep blood, or skim milk)
Monthly working stock culture, or "F1", stored at 2-8°C for up to 4 weeks,
Enter comment
7.9 Y N NA
then discarded
Weekly working stock culture, or “F2”, stored at 2-8°C for up to 1 week, then
Enter comment
7.10 Y N NA
discarded
7.11 Daily subculture, or “F3”, discarded after one day of use. Y N NA
Enter comment
also shown)
items below.
7.19 Y N
test QC
Klebsiella pneumoniae ATCC BAA-1706 (Resistant to carbapenems by non-
Enter comment
7.20 Y N
carbapenemase method)
Instructions for 1 Some QC strains with plasmid-mediated resistance have been shown to lose the place holder place holder
7.21 Are these special AST reference strains maintained at <−60°C? Y N NA Enter comment
7.22 Y N
If No, answer NA until 7.31
Is antibiotic disk QC performed before placing newly received lot
Enter comment
7.23 Y N NA
numbers/shipments into use? (Review QC records to confirm)
IMPORTANT! Please read the information below before proceeding:
CLSI and EUCAST require that all antibiotic QC is performed each day of
patient testing, not only when a new lot number is received.
Instructions for
items below. Labs that wish to reduce the frequency of antibiotic QC from daily to weekly place holder place holder
7.24 the 20-30-day plan or the 15-replicate (3- x 5-day) plan for all antibiotic disks in Y N
use? (Request to see)
Not including new lot QC, how often is antibiotic disk QC performed? (Confirm
Enter comment
7.26 Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923/CIP 76.25 (If CLSI standard used) Y N NA
Enter comment
7.27 Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 29213/CIP 103429 (If EUCAST standard used) Y N NA
Enter comment
7.31 (ungraded) Y N
If no, answer NA until 7.40
Is gradient strip QC performed before placing new lot numbers/shipments into
Enter comment
7.32 Y N NA
use? (Review QC records to confirm)
Is there documentation showing that the lab has successfully completed either
Enter comment
7.33 the 20-30 day plan or the 15-replicate (3- x 5-day) plan for all antibiotic strips in Y N NA
use? (Request to see)
Not including new lot QC, how often is antibiotic strip QC performed? (Confirm
Enter comment
7.35 Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923/CIP 76.25 (If CLSI standard used) Y N NA
Enter comment
7.36 Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 29213/CIP 103429 (If EUCAST standard used) Y N NA
Enter comment
7.41 Y N NA
temperatures?
Is QC of the antibiotic cards/trays performed before placing new lot
Enter comment
7.42 Y N NA
numbers/shipments into use? (Review QC records to confirm)
Is there documentation showing that the lab has successfully completed either
Enter comment
7.43 the 20-30-day plan or the 15-replicate (3- x 5-day) plan for all antibiotic Y N NA
cards/trays in use? (Request to see)
Not including new lot QC, how often is antibiotic card/tray QC performed?
Enter comment
7.45 Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923/CIP 76.25 (If CLSI standard used) Y N NA
Enter comment
7.46 Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 29213/CIP 103429 (If EUCAST standard used) Y N NA
Enter comment
SPECIMEN MANAGEMENT
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
Does lab policy require that all specimens are accompanied by a laboratory-
Enter comment
8.1 Y N
approved test requisition form?
Does the lab enforce a two-identifier system? (e.g., both patient name and a
Enter comment
8.2 Y N
numeric identifier must be present on the requisition and on the specimen).
8.3 Are sensitive specimens processed within one hour of reaching the laboratory? Y N
Enter comment
8.4 process (culture) the specimens or ensure that they are stored at the proper Y N NA
temperatures? (Select NA if bacteriology lab does not close)
Instructions for
items below. Does the lab store specimens properly prior to and following testing? place holder place holder
Standard: ISO 15189: 5.4.1, 5.4.5, 5.4.7, 5.4.8, 5.4.10, 5.4.11, 5.4.13 Standard: ISO
Standard for item 15189: 5.2.9, 5.4.14, 5.7.3 Specimens should be stored under the appropriate place holder place holder
8.24 Are specimens rejected if not transported to the lab within established time limits? Y N
Enter comment
Are specimens rejected if there is evidence that they were not maintained in proper
Enter comment
8.25 Y N
conditions during and prior to transport?
8.26 Is there evidence that specimen rejection criteria are enforced (review rejection log)? Y N
Enter comment
Does the lab maintain quality indicators regarding the number of specimens
Enter comment
8.27 Y N
rejected?
When specimens are rejected, does the lab notify the ward or clinic
Enter comment
8.28 Y N
immediately so that a new specimen may be collected?
8.29 Y N
patient sample collection areas?
8.30 Y N
blood culture specimen collection?
Review the blood culture specimen collection instructions. Does it address the
Instructions for
11 items below. following items? (If specimen collection instructions do not exist or are not place holder place holder
8.37 Does laboratory policy require that two "sets" of blood cultures are drawn? Y N
Enter comment
Does the policy specify that each blood culture should be obtained from a
Enter comment
8.38 Y N
different venipuncture site?
8.39 Proper bottle labeling (patient name, ID, date, time, venipuncture site) Y N
Enter comment
8.41 Y N
temperature; store bottles for manual systems at 37°C.
8.42 Y N
patient sample collection areas?
Does the lab (or other department) provide annual refresher training to clinical
Enter comment
8.43 Y N
staff on urine culture specimen collection?
Instructions for 7 Review the urine culture specimen collection instructions. Does it address the place holder place holder
following items?
items below.
8.51 Y N
patient sample collection areas?
Does the lab (or other department) provide annual refresher training to clinical
Enter comment
8.52 Y N
staff on stool culture specimen collection?
Instructions for 7 Review the stool culture specimen collection instructions. Does it address the place holder place holder
following items?
items below.
8.58 Y N
medium (such as Cary-Blair) for up to 24 hours
If transport will be delayed, do not refrigerate stool since some pathogens,
Enter comment
8.59 Y N
especially Shigella spp, will die at low temperatures
Does the laboratory have an SOP describing how to process blood for bacterial
Enter comment
9.1 Y N NA
culture?
When a blood culture bottle shows signs of positivity, (turbidity, hemolysis, or
Enter comment
9.2 Y N NA
gas production), does the lab perform a Gram stain of the bottle broth?
If the Gram stain from the bottle is positive, does the lab call the result to the
Enter comment
9.3 Y N NA
physician immediately?
When a positive blood culture broth is sub-cultured, is a chocolate plate
Enter comment
9.4 Y N NA
included to ensure recovery of fastidious organisms?
9.5 Does the lab inoculate more than one patient sample on the same petri dish? Y N NA
Enter comment
Does the SOP for blood cultures appropriately define which organisms are
Enter comment
1: Automated only
9.8 1 2 3
2: Manual System only
3: Both automated and manual systems
answer NA)
On each day of incubation, visually examine all bottles for signs of positivity
Enter comment
9.9 Y N NA
(turbidity, hemolysis, gas production)
9.10 After 24 hours of incubation, subculture all bottles that appear negative Y N NA
Enter comment
9.11 Y N NA
again (if the first subculture was negative)
Subculture bottles that appear negative to a chocolate agar plate (incubated
Enter comment
9.12 Y N NA
in 5% CO2) to ensure recovery of fastidious organisms
Incubate all bottles between 5 and 7 days before issuing a final negative
Enter comment
9.13 Y N NA
report
On the final day of incubation, perform a terminal subculture before the
Enter comment
9.14 Y N NA
final negative report is issued
URINE CULTURE
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
Does the laboratory perform urine cultures? Y N
No question Enter comment
number
Does the laboratory have an SOP for how to process urine for bacterial
Enter comment
9.15 Y N NA
culture? (request to see)
According to the SOP, which media are used for primary culture of urine?
Enter comment
1: Yes, 1µL
9.18 123
2: Yes, 10uL
3: No, calibrated loops are not used to plate urines
9.19 Does the lab inoculate more than one patient sample on the same petri dish? Y N NA
Enter comment
9.20 determining which organisms to “work up” (ID and AST) based on relative Y N NA
quantities, pathogenicity, and method of specimen collection?
Have technologists been adequately trained to recognize a poorly collected
Enter comment
Does the laboratory have an SOP for how to process (plate) stool for bacterial
Enter comment
9.22 Y N NA
culture? (request to see)
Does the SOP describe how to identify potential pathogens on all primary
Enter comment
media?
9.23 The SOP should describe the colony appearance of potential pathogens on Y N NA
MAC other selective & differential media used and should define how to
proceed when a potential pathogen is encountered.
Topic for
questions below. Which media are used for primary culture of stool? place holder place holder
Selective and differential screening agar for Salmonella and Shigella (e.g.,
Enter comment
9.29 Does the lab inoculate more than one patient sample on the same petri dish? Y N NA
Enter comment
Question for 3 Are the following pathogens routinely targeted in every stool culture place holder place holder
submitted?
items below.
Shigella spp. Y N NA
No question Enter comment
number
CONVENTIONAL ID METHODS
Answer the questions below for each manual method/biochemical in use at the lab.
Definitions used in this section:
*"Fully implemented" means that the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) has been approved and signed by a lab supervisor or
designee, and that laboratory staff have been trained on the contents and utilize the SOP. A SOP that is complete but has not been
approved or is not in routine use is not considered fully implemented.
**"Readily available" means that technologists can easily access the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) at or near the bench,
either in electronic or paper form, and that the information sought is easily located within the SOP, not buried in a larger
document, and is written in a language that those using the SOP can read fluently.
STAPHYLOCOCCUS AUREUS, KEY ID METHODS
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
Topic for
questions below. Catalase (H2O2) place holder
place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.1 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.2 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.3 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.4 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for how to perform the test
Enter comment
10.5 Y N NA
correctly?
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for interpreting the test result
Enter comment
10.6 Y N NA
correctly?
Is catalase testing performed prior to coagulase testing on suspected
Enter comment
Staphylococcus isolates?
10.7 1 2 3 NA
1: Always 3: Never
2: Sometimes NA
Topic for
questions below. Coagulase plasma place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.8 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.9 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.10 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.11 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for how to perform the test
Enter comment
10.12 Y N NA
correctly?
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for interpreting the test result
Enter comment
10.13 Y N NA
correctly?
What is the source of the plasma used for coagulase testing?
Enter comment
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.16 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.17 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.18 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.19 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for how to perform the test
Enter comment
10.20 Y N NA
correctly?
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for interpreting the test result
Enter comment
10.21 Y N NA
correctly?
Are disposable reaction cards discarded after use (not reused)?
Enter comment
1: Always
10.22 2: Sometimes 1 2 3 NA
3: No
NA: lab does not use latex agglutination to identify Staphylococcus
Topic for
questions below. Staph chromagar place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.23 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.24 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.25 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.26 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for how to perform the test
Enter comment
10.27 Y N NA
correctly?
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for interpreting the test result
Enter comment
10.28 Y N NA
correctly?
Topic for
questions below. DNase place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.29 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.30 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.31 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.32 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for how to perform the test
Enter comment
10.33 Y N NA
correctly?
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for interpreting the test result
Enter comment
10.34 Y N NA
correctly?
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.35 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.36 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.37 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.38 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for how to perform the test
Enter comment
10.39 Y N NA
correctly?
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for interpreting the test result
Enter comment
10.40 Y N NA
correctly?
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.41 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.42 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.43 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.44 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for how to perform the test
Enter comment
10.45 Y N NA
correctly?
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for interpreting the test result
Enter comment
10.46 Y N NA
correctly?
Topic for
questions below. Optochin (“P”) disk place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.47 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.48 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.49 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.50 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for how to perform the test
Enter comment
10.51 Y N NA
correctly?
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for interpreting the test result
Enter comment
10.52 Y N NA
correctly?
If the Optochin result is equivocal (9-13mm), is bile solubility or other
Enter comment
10.53 Y N NA
additional testing performed to confirm the ID?
Topic for
questions below. Streptococcus pneumoniae latex agglutination place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.54 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.55 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.56 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.57 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for how to perform the test
Enter comment
10.58 Y N NA
correctly?
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for interpreting the test result
Enter comment
10.59 Y N NA
correctly?
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.60 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.61 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.62 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.63 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for how to perform the test
Enter comment
10.64 Y N NA
correctly?
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for interpreting the test result
Enter comment
10.65 Y N NA
correctly?
Topic for
questions below. Indole place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.66 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
10.67 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.68 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.69 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for how to perform the test
Enter comment
10.70 Y N NA
correctly?
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for interpreting the test result
Enter comment
10.71 Y N NA
correctly?
Topic for
questions below. Methyl Red place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.72 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.73 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.74 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.75 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.76 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for inoculation and incubation? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.77 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for reading and interpretation? Y N NA
Enter comment
Topic for
questions below. Voges-Proskauer place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.78 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.79 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.80 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.81 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.82 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for inoculation and incubation? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.83 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for reading and interpretation? Y N NA
Enter comment
Topic for
questions below. Citrate place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.84 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.85 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.86 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.87 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.88 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for inoculation and incubation? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.89 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for reading and interpretation? Y N NA
Enter comment
Topic for
questions below. Triple Sugar Iron (TSI) or Kligler Iron Agar (KIA) place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.90 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.91 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.92 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.93 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.94 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for inoculation and incubation? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.95 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for reading and interpretation? Y N NA
Enter comment
Topic for
questions below. Urease place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.96 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.97 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.98 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.99 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.100 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for inoculation and incubation? Y N NA
Enter comment
Topic for
questions below. Motility place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.102 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.103 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.104 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.105 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.106 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for inoculation and incubation? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.107 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for reading and interpretation? Y N NA
Enter comment
Topic for
questions below. Lysine Iron Agar (LIA) or Lysine Decarboxylase (LDC) place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.108 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.109 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.110 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.111 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.112 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for inoculation and incubation? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.113 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for reading and interpretation? Y N NA
Enter comment
SHIGELLA/SALMONELLA SEROLOGY
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
Topic for
questions below. Shigella serology place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the Enter comment
10.114 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but Enter comment
10.115 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.116 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA Enter comment
10.117 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA Enter comment
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for how to perform the test Enter comment
10.118 Y N NA
correctly?
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for interpreting the test result Enter comment
10.119 Y N NA
correctly?
Topic for
questions below. Salmonella serology place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the Enter comment
10.120 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but Enter comment
10.121 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.122 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA Enter comment
10.123 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA Enter comment
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for how to perform the test Enter comment
10.124 Y N NA
correctly?
Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for interpreting the test result Enter comment
10.125 Y N NA
correctly?
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.126 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.127 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.128 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.130 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for inoculation and incubation? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.131 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for reading and interpretation? Y N NA
Enter comment
Topic for
questions below. Nitrate reduction place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.132 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.133 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.134 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.135 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.136 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for inoculation and incubation? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.137 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for reading and interpretation? Y N NA
Enter comment
Topic for
questions below. Gelatin hydrolysis place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.138 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.139 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.140 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.141 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.142 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for inoculation and incubation? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.143 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for reading and interpretation? Y N NA
Enter comment
Topic for
questions below. Chloramphenicol resistance (disk) place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.144 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.145 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.146 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.147 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.148 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for inoculation and incubation? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.149 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for reading and interpretation? Y N NA
Enter comment
Topic for
questions below. Growth at 42°C place holder place holder
Is this reagent used to test patient isolates? (If No, select NA for the
Enter comment
10.150 Y N
remaining questions about this reagent)
Has an up-to-date SOP been fully implemented?* (If the reagent is in use but
Enter comment
10.151 Y N NA
there is no SOP, answer "no" to all remaining questions about this reagent)
10.152 Is the SOP readily available** to bench staff? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.153 Does the SOP define QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.154 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for inoculation and incubation? Y N NA
Enter comment
10.155 Does the SOP provide stepwise instructions for reading and interpretation? Y N NA
Enter comment
KIT-BASED ID METHODS
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
If the lab uses rapid biochemical kits for organism ID (e.g., API, Liofilchem, RapID),
does the SOP for each kit contain the following information?
Question and
Instructions for 5
items below.
(If kits are not used, select "NA"; if kits are used but there is no SOP, select "3: No") place holder place holder
1: Yes 3: No
2: Partial NA: The lab does not use rapid biochemical kits
10.156 Defined QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results 1 2 3 NA
Enter comment
10.157 1 2 3 NA
medium and at the correct density
10.158 Stepwise instructions on how to inoculate and incubate the device 1 2 3 NA
Enter comment
10.159 1 2 3 NA
reagents if necessary
Are the SOPs available in a language that the technologists can read
Enter comment
10.161 Y N NA
proficiently?
10.162 Is the lab using the inoculation media recommended by the manufacturer? Y N NA
Enter comment
Following device inoculation, does the lab use the remaining inoculum to make
Enter comment
a purity plate? (A purity plate is a light subculture of the inoculum that is made
10.163 to ensure the inoculum was not a mixed culture or contaminated; usually Y N NA
streaked like a urine to ensure visualization of individual colonies and checked
for purity when reading results)
Following incubation, are all supplemental reagents available and added
Enter comment
10.164 Y N NA
according to manufacturer instructions? (e.g., VP1 & 2 for API)
Y N NA
Enter comment
10.165 Are the databases used to interpret the kit results (bionumbers) up to date? Don’t
know
When an ID result (bionumber) does not reach the threshold for an acceptable
Enter comment
AUTOMATED ID METHODS
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
If the lab uses automated methods for organism ID (e.g., Vitek, Microscan,
Phoenix), do the SOPs contain the following information? (User manuals
Instructions for
items below. provided by the manufacturer are not considered SOPs) place holder place holder
1: Yes 3: No
2: Partial NA: automated methods are not used
10.167 Defined QC organisms, QC frequency, and expected QC results 1 2 3 NA
Enter comment
10.168 1 2 3 NA
medium and at the correct density
10.169 Stepwise instructions on how to inoculate and incubate the device 1 2 3 NA
Enter comment
10.170 1 2 3 NA
reagents if necessary
10.171 Clear guidance on interpreting results and recognizing unacceptable results 1 2 3 NA
Enter comment
Is the SOP available in a language that the technologists using the instrument
Enter comment
10.172 Y N NA
can read proficiently?
10.173 Is the lab using the inoculation medium recommended by the manufacturer? Y N NA
Enter comment
Following card/tray inoculation, does the lab use the remaining inoculum to
Enter comment
10.175 evidence that appropriate action is taken, such as repeating the test by Y N NA
another method or performing additional biochemical tests?
IDENTIFICATION FLOWCHARTS
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
For questions 10.176 to 10.184:
Instructions for 1: Always place holder place holder
2: Sometimes
items below.
3: Never
When the primary plate has mixed colony types, is it standard practice to
Enter comment
10.176 subculture each colony of interest to a fresh plate to ensure purity prior to 1 2 3
pursuing identification?
10.177 1 2 3
to performing any other testing?
For gram-negative bacilli, is it standard practice to perform an oxidase test
Enter comment
10.178 first, before proceeding with any other identification tests (including 1 2 3
automated ID)?
For gram-negative bacilli, is it standard practice to perform an indole test
Enter comment
10.179 second, before proceeding with other identification tests (including automated 1 2 3
ID)?
For oxidase-negative gram-negative bacilli that do not ferment lactose (clear
Enter comment
10.181 aeruginosa (lack the characteristic appearance and odor), are sufficient tests 1 2 3
available to achieve a definitive identification?
For gram-positive cocci, is it standard practice to perform a catalase test first,
Enter comment
10.182 before proceeding with any other identification tests (including automated 1 2 3
ID)?
For catalase positive gram-positive cocci, is it standard practice to perform a
Enter comment
10.183 coagulase test next, before proceeding with other identification tests 1 2 3
(including automated ID)?
For catalase negative gram-positive cocci, is it standard practice to evaluate
Enter comment
10.184 the type of hemolysis (alpha, beta, gamma), before proceeding with other 1 2 3
identification tests (including automated ID)?
11.1 manufacturer ensuring that they were tested and performed according to ISO Y N
quality standards?
Are the packages not currently in use stored unopened and in their original
Enter comment
11.2 Y N
packaging in order to prevent moisture ingress?
11.3 Are unopened antibiotic disks and strips stored in a non-defrosting freezer? Y N
Enter comment
If the antibiotic disk cartridge has a cap, is the cap replaced each time the
Enter comment
11.4 Y N
cartridge is opened?
Once opened, are in-use antibiotic disks stored in such a way that the lot
Enter comment
number and expiration date of each disk is always traceable? (When individual
11.5 Y N
disks are removed and transferred to secondary containers, lot numbers may
become mixed and expired disks may inadvertently be used.)
Are the in-use antibiotic disks and strips stored in a tightly sealed container
Enter comment
11.6 Y N
with active desiccants?
Do the desiccants change color as moisture levels increase (indicating the need
Enter comment
11.7 Y N NA
to replace or recharge)?
If desiccants do not have a color indicator, are colorless desiccants replaced at
Enter comment
11.8 Y N NA
least monthly?
Are the containers holding open antibiotic disks/strips stored in a refrigerator
Enter comment
11.9 Y N
or non-defrosting freezer when not in use?
Are the containers holding open antibiotic disks/strips allowed to equilibrate
Enter comment
INOCULUM PREPARATION
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
When preparing an inoculum using the colony suspension method, are
Enter comment
11.11 Y N
colonies less than 18 hours old ever used?
When preparing an inoculum using the colony suspension method, are
Enter comment
11.12 Y N
colonies more than 24 hours old ever used?
Observe an AST inoculum preparation. Do technologists use only individual,
Enter comment
11.13 Y N
well-isolated colonies of the same morphological type?
Are colonies taken only from non-selective media, such as blood agar
Enter comment
11.14 Y N
(MacConkey agar is acceptable)
Does the lab ever intentionally mix two different organisms in the same
Enter comment
11.15 Y N
inoculum for AST?
11.16 Is an appropriate, sterile inoculation medium (TSB or saline) used? Y N
Enter comment
Do records indicate that the saline solution is tested for sterility on a regular
Enter comment
11.17 Y N
basis? (Preferably at least weekly)
11.18 Is the inoculum brought to a density equivalent to 0.5 McFarland? Y N
Enter comment
11.20 Y N
organisms?
Does the lab ever use agar other than Mueller Hinton with Blood for AST of
Enter comment
11.21 Y N
Streptococcus pneumoniae?
Instructions for
items below. Observe a MH plate being inoculated. place holder place holder
To create an even lawn, streak a line from top to bottom, then spread left to
11.24 Y N
right across that line from top to bottom. Rotate plate 60° and repeat from
beginning; rotate plate another 60° and repeat again.
Before applying disks/strips, are inoculated MH plates allowed to sit, lid-ajar,
Enter comment
11.25 for 3 to no more than 15 minutes to allow for absorption of excess surface Y N
moisture?
11.26 Are disks/strips ever moved after being placed on the agar? Y N
Enter comment
11.27 Y N NA
between isolates?
11.28 Are AST plates incubated within 15 minutes of placing disks/strips? Y N
Enter comment
After AST inoculation, are “purity plates” made from the remaining
Enter comment
suspension?
A purity plate is a light subculture of the inoculum that is made to ensure the
11.29 Y N
inoculum was not mixed or contaminated; usually streaked like a urine to
ensure visualization of individual colonies and checked for purity when
reading AST results
11.30 Are AST plates for non-fastidious organisms ever incubated in CO2? Y N
Enter comment
Topic for Observe some currently incubating and/or recently read Mueller Hinton AST place holder Enter comment
plates.
questions below.
11.32 Are the lawns of growth confluent (no gaps or individual colonies showing)? Y N
Enter comment
Are disks spaced properly? (At least 24mm from center to center, no
Enter comment
11.35 Y N
overlapping zones, not too close to edge, uniformly circular zones)
11.37 Are AST results ever read after more than 24 hours of incubation? Y N
Enter comment
If individual colonies are apparent within the ellipsis or the zone of inhibition,
Enter comment
11.38 does the lab repeat the test with a fresh subculture of a single colony from the Y N
original plate?
Instructions for 4
items below. Observe a Mueller Hinton AST plate being read. place holder place holder
11.42 Is a ruler or a caliper with millimeter marks used to measure zone sizes? Y N
Enter comment
Does the lab possess a guidance document with photos describing how to
Enter comment
11.43 measure zone sizes, such as the CLSI M02 or the EUCAST disk diffusion reading Y N
guides?
Does the lab possess a guidance document with photos describing how to
Enter comment
11.45 co-trimoxazole (SXT) are measured at 80% inhibition of growth, rather than Y N
100%?
Does the SOP or bench aide instruct how to measure zones of inhibition and/or
Enter comment
11.46 Y N
MIC endpoints when Proteus spp. swarming is present?
Is the automated AST instrument software up to date?
Enter comment
11.47 Y N NA
Answer NA if the lab does not use automated AST instrument
INTERPRETING RESULTS
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
Is there evidence that appropriate actions are taken when the AST instrument
Enter comment
11.52 results? (Such as those found in CLSI M100 Appendix A or EUCAST Expert Rules Y N
V3.1)
Do the AST SOPs or bench aides describe what actions to take when unusual or
Enter comment
11.53 unexpected AST results are encountered (e.g., check purity, reconfirm Y N
organism ID, check relevant QC, repeat testing, notify supervisor)?
11.54 Is there evidence of such actions being taken? Y N
Enter comment
Is the microbiology lead or supervisor informed when unusual AST results are
Enter comment
11.55 Y N
identified?
Does a supervisor review all AST results for unusual findings before results are
Enter comment
11.56 Y N
given to physicians?
Is there evidence that the supervisor received appropriate training on how to
Enter comment
1: CLSI
11.58 2: EUCAST 1234
3: Other (please list in comments)
4: None/mixed
Ask to see the lab’s most current hard copy of the standard. Is it less than 3
Enter comment
11.59 Y N
years old?
11.60 Does the lab obtain updates of the standard in use at least every 3 years? Y N
Enter comment
Does the lab review important standards changes, e.g., breakpoint changes,
Enter comment
11.61 with the relevant hospital committees (e.g., pharmacy and therapeutics, Y N
stewardship)?
Is there internet in the lab to access free EUCAST PDFs or CLSI M100 online
Enter comment
version?
11.62 EUCAST Guidance Documents in Susceptibility Testing Y N
(http://www.eucast.org/ast_of_bacteria/guidance_documents/)
CLSI M100 and M60 (http://clsi-m100.com/)
Is there evidence that microbiology staff have received adequate training on
Enter comment
Look at the cefotaxime disks currently in use. Does the drug concentration
Enter comment
11.64 correspond correctly to the standard the lab uses? (CLSI breakpoints require Y N NA
30µg disks, EUCAST breakpoints require 5µg disks).
Look at the ceftazidime disks currently in use. Does the drug concentration
Enter comment
11.65 correspond correctly to the standard in use? (CLSI breakpoints require 30µg Y N NA
disks, EUCAST breakpoints require 10µg)
Look at the piperacillin-tazobactam disks currently in use. Does the drug
Enter comment
12.1 Y N NA
cephadrine)
12.2 2nd generation cephalosporins (cefuroxime, cefonicid, cefamandole) Y N NA
Enter comment
Does the lab use Nalidixic Acid to screen Salmonella isolates for ciprofloxacin
Enter comment
12.5 Y N NA
resistance?
Compare the lab’s AST bench aids and SOPs to the Salmonella table in the
Enter comment
Assessor’s Guide. Does the lab use the correct fluoroquinolone (FQ)
12.6 Y N NA
breakpoints for Salmonella spp?
(Enterobacteriaceae FQ breakpoints should not be used for Salmonella spp).
12.30 Y N NA
ceftriaxone) AND ceftazidime alone and in combination with clavulanic acid?
12.31 Does the lab perform any genotypic tests for ESBL production? (e.g., PCR) Y N
Enter comment
Do records indicate that quality control for ESBL testing is done either on a
Enter comment
12.32 Y N NA
weekly basis or each time the test is performed?
Do records indicate that lab uses both positive and negative control organisms
Enter comment
12.33 to QC the ESBL test in use? (A commonly used ESBL-positive strain is Klebsiella Y N NA
pneumoniae ATCC 700603)
12.34 When an ESBL-positive is confirmed, is infection control notified by the lab? Y N NA
Enter comment
production?
items below.
12.38 Other disk method, e.g., combination disk test or double disk synergy Y N
Enter comment
12.39 MIC Strip test, e.g., Etest KPC, MBL or Liofilchem MRP/MBO, ETP/EBO Y N
Enter comment
Does the lab perform any genotypic tests for carbapenemase production?
Enter comment
12.43 Y N
(e.g., PCR, GeneXpert, etc.)
Do records indicate that quality control is done each time carbapenemase
Enter comment
12.44 Y N NA
testing is performed?
Do records indicate that lab uses both positive and negative control organisms
Enter comment
12.46 Y N NA
the clinician?
When a carbapenemase producer is detected, is infection control notified by
Enter comment
12.47 Y N NA
the lab?
COLISTIN TESTING
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
Does the lab perform colistin AST? (Not scored. If No, skip to next section.) Y N
No question Enter comment
number
Question and
Instructions for 7
Which methods does the lab use for colistin AST? (Select Y for each method place holder place holder
items below.
used)
12.48 Disk diffusion Y N
Enter comment
Do records indicate that quality control for colistin AST is performed on either
Enter comment
12.55 Y N NA
a weekly basis or each time the test is performed?
Do records indicate that lab uses appropriate organisms to QC the colistin test
Enter comment
12.56 in use? (Pseudomonas aeruginosa 27853 AND E. coli NCTC 13846 or E. coli AR Y N NA
Bank #0349).
Question for 3
items below. When colistin resistance is detected, are any of the following notified? place holder place holder
When colistin resistance is detected, is the isolate sent to a reference lab for
Enter comment
12.60 Y N NA
molecular characterization (e.g., testing for mcr genes)?
If the lab uses broth microdilution for colistin AST, is colistin sulfate used, not
Enter comment
12.63 AST? (i.e., the risk of false susceptible results when using disk diffusion, Y N
gradient strip, or automated methods.)
12.64 Y N
associated with colistin AST?
12.65 Y N
If no, answer NA to next question
Are S. aureus isolates with penicillin zones sizes or MICs in the susceptible
Enter comment
12.66 range tested for β-lactamase production using the zone-edge test before being Y N NA
reported as penicillin susceptible?
12.67 Does the lab use oxacillin disks to test for MRSA? Y N
Enter comment
When oxacillin and cefoxitin results are discrepant for S. aureus (one is S and
Enter comment
12.69 Y N
penicillin, oxacillin, cefoxitin, or ceftaroline?
12.70 Does the lab use vancomycin disks to test for VISA/VRSA? Y N
Enter comment
12.71 aureus, is the test incubated for a full 24 hours before reading the result? Y N NA
Answer NA if manual MIC method not used
When a vancomycin MIC >8 is detected for S. aureus, is the isolate sent to a
Enter comment
12.73 Y N
intermediate to Clindamycin tested for inducible clindamycin resistance?
answers
12.74 Is the upper surface of the agar read with the cover removed? Y N NA
Enter comment
Are zones measured where growth is inhibited (as opposed to the zone of
Enter comment
12.76 Y N NA
hemolysis)?
Are there no more than 4 disks per 100mm plate or 9 disks per 150mm
Enter comment
12.77 Y N NA
plate?
If the lab uses an oxacillin disk (1ug) to screen for penicillin resistance in Strep.
Enter comment
pneumoniae, what does the lab’s SOP instruct when the zone size measures
<19? (Referring to penicillin G or Benzylpenicillin, the IV formulation)
12.78 1 2 NA
1: Report penicillin resistant
2: Perform additional testing using a penicillin MIC method
NA: lab does not perform oxacillin screen
section.)
number
Question for 10 Does the lab use the disk diffusion method to test any of the following place holder place holder
12.79 Penicillin Y N NA
Enter comment
12.81 Ampicillin Y N NA
Enter comment
12.82 Cefotaxime Y N NA
Enter comment
12.83 Ceftriaxone Y N NA
Enter comment
12.84 Cefuroxime Y N NA
Enter comment
12.85 Cefepime Y N NA
Enter comment
12.86 Ertapenem Y N NA
Enter comment
12.87 Meropenem Y N NA
Enter comment
12.88 Imipenem Y N NA
Enter comment
Question for 2 When S. pneumoniae is isolated from blood or cerebrospinal fluid, does the lab place holder place holder
12.89 Penicillin Y N NA
Enter comment
12.91 Y N NA
cefotaxime reported using the meningitis breakpoints only?
When S. pneumoniae is isolated from specimens other than CSF, are penicillin,
Enter comment
12.92 ceftriaxone, and/or cefotaxime reported using both meningitis and non- Y N NA
meningitis breakpoints?
Are S. pneumoniae that are resistant to Erythromycin and susceptible or
Enter comment
12.93 Y N NA
intermediate to Clindamycin tested for inducible clindamycin resistance?
12.95 Y N NA
disks must be placed 15-26 mm apart for Staphylococcus species?
Does the SOP for the ICR test specify that the erythromycin and clindamycin
Enter comment
12.96 Y N NA
disks must be placed 12 mm apart for Streptococcus species?
Do records indicate that quality control for ICR testing is done either on a
Enter comment
12.97 Y N NA
weekly basis or each time the test is performed?
Do records indicate that lab uses both positive and negative control organisms
Enter comment
12.98 to QC the ICR test in use? (Commonly used ICR positive strain is S. aureus ATCC Y N NA
BAA-977)
12.99 When the ICR test is positive, is the clindamycin result changed to resistant? Y N NA
Enter comment
12.100 Y N NA
cephadrine)
12.101 2nd generation cephalosporins (cefuroxime, cefonicid, cefamandole) Y N NA
Enter comment
12.103 Clindamycin Y N NA
Enter comment
12.107 Nitrofurantoin Y N NA
Enter comment
13.4 Enterobacteriaceae Y N
Enter comment
Review several patient AST reports for E. coli. Is the same combination of
Enter comment
13.8 Y N
antibiotics tested each time?
Does the SOP clearly define how to modify the standard antibiotic panels
Instructions for
items below. described above based upon the body site of infection? ONLY select NA if the place holder place holder
13.10 CSF Y N NA
Enter comment
13.11 Blood Y N NA
Enter comment
CUMULATIVE ANTIBIOGRAMS
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
13.12 Does the lab produce a cumulative antibiogram at least annually? Y N
Enter comment
13.13 Does the lab have a software program to produce the antibiogram? Y N NA
Enter comment
Question and
Instructions for
Review the most recent cumulative antibiogram. Does it adhere to the place holder place holder
items below.
following CLSI M39 recommendations?
13.14 Clearly displays the inclusive date range (e.g. Jan 1, YYYY – Dec 31, YYYY) Y N NA
Enter comment
13.18 Y N NA
isolates
Are isolates from environmental cultures and screening cultures (e.g., MRSA
Enter comment
13.19 Y N NA
screen, VRE screen) excluded from the analysis?
Is the lab able to de-duplicate the data, so that only the first isolate of a given
Enter comment
13.20 species per patient, per analysis period is included, irrespective of the body site Y N NA
of recovery?
13.21 Is the lab able to separate Inpatient data from outpatient data? Y N NA
Enter comment
If the lab serves multiple hospitals/facilities, are they able to separate the data
Enter comment
13.22 Y N NA
by Facility?
Is the cumulative antibiogram reviewed annually by either an Antibiotic
Enter comment
13.23 Y N NA
Stewardship or a Pharmacy & Therapeutics Committee?
13.24 Is the cumulative antibiogram distributed to all physicians? Y N NA
Enter comment
AST POLICY
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
Does lab policy primarily determine which isolates receive AST, or is AST
Enter comment
does the lab only test and report the antibiotics specifically requested by the
physician?
13.26 1 2 3
1: Lab policy primarily determines
2: Only the antibiotics requested by physician
3: Equal mix of both
"Cascade reporting” is a strategy of selective reporting of AST results in which
Instructions for secondary agents (e.g., broader spectrum, more costly) may be suppressed or place holder place holder
13.27 Y N
If no, answer NA to next question
With cascade reporting, there is a risk that the AST results excluded from the
Instructions for patient report may also be excluded from the main data repository or LIS. This place holder place holder
statistics.
If the lab practices cascade reporting, is it done in a way which ensures that
Enter comment
13.28 the AST results excluded from the patient report are NOT excluded from the Y N NA
LIS or other main data repository?
13.29 Does the hospital have an Antibiotic Stewardship Committee? Y N NA
Enter comment
13.30 Y N NA
member?
13.31 Does the hospital have a Pharmacy and Therapeutics Committee? Y N NA
Enter comment
13.32 Y N NA
a member?
Does the hospital's Antibiotic Stewardship or Pharmacy and Therapeutic
Enter comment
BIOSAFETY EQUIPMENT
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
Question for
items below. Is standard safety equipment available and in use in the laboratory? place holder place holder
SA7 Flame cabinet (for securely storing flammable liquids, e.g. ethanol) Y N
Enter comment
readiness.
Standard: ISO 15189: 5.2.10: All syringes, needles, lancets, or other
bloodletting devices capable of transmitting infection must be used only
once and discarded in puncture resistant containers that are not overfilled.
Sharps containers should be clearly marked to warn handlers of the potential
hazard and should be located in areas where sharps are commonly used.
SA10 Have all biosafety cabinets been recertified within a year of today’s date? Y N
Enter comment
serviced accordingly.
PERSONAL PROTECTIVE EQUIPMENT
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
Question for 4
items below. Is all necessary personal protective equipment (PPE) available for BSL2? place holder place holder
SA11 Gowns Y N
Enter comment
SA12 Gloves Y N
Enter comment
SA15 Does lab policy require microbiology staff to wear close-toed shoes? Y N
Enter comment
1: Yes
SA16 123
2: Partial
3: No
Standard: Management is responsible to provide appropriate personal
protective equipment — gloves, lab coats, eye protection, shields, etc. — in
Standard for item useable condition. Laboratory staff must utilize personal protective place holder place holder
Question for 4 Observe the refrigerators and freezers where media and reagents are stored. place holder place holder
Are they:
items below.
Are all hazardous chemicals stored appropriately (acids separate from alkaline;
Enter comment
SA22 Y N
flammables in a flame cabinet)?
SA23 Is work area (bench and hood) disinfection documented daily? Y N
Enter comment
Standard: ISO 15189: 5.2.10 The work area should be regularly inspected for
cleanliness and leakage. An appropriate disinfectant should be used. At a
Standard for item
above. minimum, all benchtops and working surfaces should be disinfected at the place holder place holder
beginning and end of every shift. All spills should be contained immediately,
and the work surfaces disinfected.
BIOSAFETY DOCUMENTATION AND TRAINING
Question Number
Question Answer Comments
Is a safety/biosafety manual available in the laboratory and easily accessible to
Enter comment
SA24 Y N
all staff?
SA25 Is a training module in safety/biosafety available in the laboratory? Y N
Enter comment
SA26 refresher course is conducted for all staff handling specimens, isolates, or Y N
chemicals?
Is there documentation demonstrating that accident/incident investigations
Enter comment
SA27 Y N
are systematically conducted?
Are risk assessments conducted annually and each time a new
Enter comment
SA28 Y N
analysis/technology/equipment is introduced?
NOTES: