Stanag 4355
Stanag 4355
Stanag 4355
STANAG 4355 JAIS (EDITION 3) - THE MODIFIED POINT MASS AND FIVE DEGREES
OF FREEDOM TRAJECTORY MODELS
References:
a. MAS/24-LAND/4355 dated 20 January 1997 (Edition 2)
A. PFP(NAAG)D(2006)0005, dated 21 March 2006, (Edition 3) (Ratification Draft)
3. National staffs are requested to examine their ratification status of the STANAG
and, if they have not already done so, advise the Defence Investment Division through
their national delegation as appropriate of their intention regarding its ratification and
implementation.
J an . MORENO
Ice-Admiral, ESP(N)
irector, NATO Standardization Agency
Enclosure:
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
STANDARDISATION AGREEMENT
(STANAG)
Jua A. MORENO
Vi -Admiral, ESP(N)
Di ector, NATO Standardization Agency
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
RECORD OF AMENDMENTS
EXPLANATORY NOTES
AGREEMENT
2. No departure may be made from the agreement without informing the tasking
authority in the form of a reservation. Nations may propose changes at any time to the
tasking authority where they will be processed in the same manner as the original
agreement.
3. Ratifying nations have agreed that national orders, manuals and instructions
implementing this STANAG will include a reference to the STANAG number for
purposes of identification.
FEEDBACK
ii
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
Source: https://assist.dla.mil -- Downloaded: 2021-03-23T15:30Z
Check the source to verify that this is the current version before use.
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
STANAG 4355
(Edition 3)
THE MODIFIED POINT MASS AND FIVE DEGREES OF FREEDOM TRAJECTORY MODELS
ANNEXES:
Related Documents:
-1-
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
STANAG 4355
(Edition 3)
AIM
1. The principal aim of this agreement is to standardize the exterior ballistic trajectory
simulation methodology for NATO Naval and Army Forces. The Modified Point Mass
model will be used for spin-stabilized projectiles and the Five Degrees of Freedom model
will be used for fin-stabilized rockets. This will facilitate the exchange of exterior ballistic
data and fire control information.
AGREEMENT
2. Participating nations agree to use the Modified Point Mass Trajectory Model for
spin-stabilized projectiles and a Five Degrees of Freedom Model for exterior ballistic
trajectory simulation of fin-stabilized rockets.
GENERAL
DETAILS OF AGREEMENT
4. The details of the agreement are given hereunder and are divided into the
following four parts:
I - Equations of Motion
A. Equations of Motion For Spin-Stabilized Projectiles
B. Equations of Motion for Fin-Stabilized Rockets
C. Common Equations of Motion
II - List of Symbols
III - Comparison of Aerodynamic Coefficient Symbols
IV - List of Data Requirements
IMPLEMENTATION OF AGREEMENT
-2-
NATO/PfP UNCLASSIFIED
I. EQUATIONS OF MOTION
5. The following equations constitute mathematical models representing the flight of:
(1) spin-stabilized projectiles and
(2) fin-stabilized rockets,
that are dynamically stable and possess at least trigonal symmetry. The mathematical modeling is
accomplished mainly by: (a) including only the most essential forces and moments, (b) for spin-
stabilized projectiles, approximating the actual yaw by the yaw of repose neglecting transient yawing
motion, and (c) applying fitting factors to some of the above forces to compensate for the neglect of
or approximations for other forces and moments. All vectors have as a frame of reference a right-
& & &
handed, orthonormal, ground-fixed, Cartesian coordinate system with unit vectors ( 1, 2 and 3 ) as
shown in Figure I-1.
Assume that the body can be considered a solid of revolution, and assign to the axis of rotational
&
symmetry a unit vector x in the chosen coordinate system. Since the rigid body is to represent a
&
projectile or rocket, the direction of x from tail to nose is defined as positive. The total angular
momentum of the body can now be expressed as the sum of two vectors in the ground-fixed coordinate
system:
&
(1) The angular momentum about x , and
&
(2) the angular momentum about an axis perpendicular to x .
&
The angular momentum about x has the magnitude ( I X p ); where I X is the moment of inertia of
& &
the body about x , and p is the axial spin or angular velocity about x , in radians per second.
& &
Therefore, the total angular momentum about x can be represented by the vector ( I X p x ). In this
document, a positive p is defined as rotation, which would cause a right-hand screw to advance in
&
the direction of x . &
2 &
2 &
x
&
& 1
X
&
3
&
1
&
3
Figure I-1. Cartesian Coordinate System with Unit Vectors
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
3
In addition to these basic equations, two additional expressions are needed for use in the force-moment
system.
&
H u x& &
I Y x (c)
&
H x& IX p (d)
Equation (b) is the basic vector differential equations of angular motion in a fixed coordinate system.
The basic equation of motion for the center-of-mass is:
&
&
u
¦F (e)
m
& &
where ¦F denotes the sum of the vector applied forces, m is the mass of the body, and u is the vector
acceleration of the center-of-mass in the fixed coordinate system.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
4
where acceleration due to drag force, when i is used as a fitting factor, is:
DF §S Uid 2 · § &
¨¨ ¸ ¨ C D C D Q D D e 2 C D Q D D e 4 ·¸ v v (2)
¸
© 8m ¹ © ¹
2 4
m 0 D D
DF § S U mr ·§ &
¨¨ ¸¸ ¨ C D C D 2 Q D D e 2 C D 4 Q D D e 4 ·¸ v v (3)
m © 8C m ¹ © 0 D D ¹
DF §SU d 2 · § &
¨¨ ¸ ¨ f D C D C D 2 Q D D e 2 C D 4 Q D D e 4 ·¸ v v (4)
¸
m © 8m ¹ © 0 D D ¹
LF § S U d 2 fL ·§ 2 4· 2 &
¨ ¸
m ¨ 8 m ¸ ¨© C L D C LD 3 D e C LD 5 D e ¸¹ v D e (5)
© ¹
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
5
S U d 4 pv C spin
p (7)
8 Ix
where:
t
p p 0 ³ p dt (8)
0
is the magnitude of spin at time = t, and
2S u0
p0 (9)
tc d
is the magnitude of the initial spin of the projectile at the muzzle.
where:
ª0º
& «0»
D e0 (11)
« »
«¬0»¼
9. See section I-C for the velocity of the projectile with respect to the ground fixed axis at time = t.
See section I-C for the velocity of the projectile with respect to the air at time = t.
See section I-C for the position of the projectile with respect to the ground axis at time = t.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
6
10. Windage jump, the correction for wind shear between successive integration steps, is given as a
velocity correction:
§ C C D 2 C D 4 ·¸ f I p u& u 'w&
& ¨© LD L 3
D
e LD
5 e
¹ L X
'u (12)
(C MD C M 3 D e2 ) m d v 2
D
& & &
where: 'w wt wt 't (13)
& &
and at t = 0, wt w0 0 .
11. See section I-C for the position of the projectile with respect to the spherical earth’s surface.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
7
The equations of motion for fin-stabilized rockets are described during four phases of the flight,
namely, during launch, from launch to fin opening, from fin opening to the end of motion requiring five
degrees of freedom (5 DoF), and from the end of the 5 DoF segment to the end of the 3 DoF phase
which normally is the burst point of the warhead. Motor will normally be functioning from t0 until
before (near) the end of Phase 3, Time of End of Five Degrees of Freedom t0 d t t E 5 D . These phases
were chosen to represent those portions of the motion, which require significantly different force and
moment descriptions to properly simulate actual flight conditions.
The drag force DF , thrust force TF , acceleration due to gravity and the deceleration due to rocket-
launcher friction are considered during the rocket-launching phase. The equation of motion of the
center-of-mass during the rocket launch phase is given by:
&
F
&
m u DF TF m g& sin QE P f
&
cos QE x0 (14)
NOTE: In this phase the rocket does not move before t t FM and is restricted to forward
motion, i.e., for Eq. (14):
& & & &
F { 0 for t d t FM or whenever F 0
DF §S i U d 2 · &
¨¨ ¸¸ C D0 v 2 x 0 (15)
m © 8m ¹
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
8
at t L . Z y( t ) and Z z( t ) are used to match the observed angular performance of the rocket. The initial
L L
&
value of H ( tL ) is given by:
where:
& &
x(tL ) x0 (19)
DF
m
§ S Ui d 2 ·
¨¨
© 8m ¹
0 D
&
¸¸ C D C D 2 D 2 v v (21)
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
9
PDF
§ S U d 3 C N q C ND
¨
·¸ & &
v Hux (24)
m ¨ IY 8 m ¸
© ¹
15. The angular momentum of the body is the summation of the moments acting on the body and is given
by:
&
H OM PDM MM SDM FCM AJDM TJDM (26)
where:
Angular momentum due to Overturning Moment:
OM
§ U d3 S
¨
¨ 8
·
¸ D
& &
¸ C M D C M 3 D 2 v v u x (27)
© ¹
§ U d4 S · & &
MM ¨¨
¸¸ C mag m H x >v& x& x& v& @ (29)
© 8 IX ¹
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
10
§ U d3 S · &
FCM ¨ ¸ ClG H v 2 x (31)
¨ 8 ¸
© ¹
The angular momentum and unit vector along the longitudinal axis at time = t is:
t
& & &
x x (t L ) ³ x dt (35)
tL
&
where H ( t L ) is defined at Eq. (18), and
& &
x(t L ) x0 (36)
NOTE: While integrating the equations of motion during the 5 DoF phase, the magnitude of the
&
unit vector x should be normalized to the value 1.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
11
& &
The yaw of the symmetric rigid-body (D) is the included angle between x and v . The yaw is
defined as a positive quantity and the magnitude is given by:
ª v& x& º
D arccos « & » (38)
¬ v ¼
& &
The orientation of the yaw (\) is the angle of the plane containing v and x relative to the vertical
&
plane containing v measured in a clockwise direction. The orientation of the yaw is given by:
ª v1 x3 v3 x1 v º
\ arctan « » (39)
¬ v1 v1 x 2 v 2 x1 v3 v 2 x 3 v3 x 2 ¼
Phase 3: Time from Rocket Fins Opening to Time of End of Five Degrees of Freedom ( t FO d t d t E 5 D )
16. Same as equations in ( t L d t d t FO ) with aerodynamics for rocket with fins open. Define t E 5 D to
begin after a small time interval after motor burnout ( t BO ), to allow for aerodynamic settling.
DF §S Uid2 · &
¨¨ ¸ CD v v
¸ (41)
m © 8m ¹
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
12
ª 0 º
& « R »
R (45)
« »
«¬ 0 »¼
where:
ª ȍ cos lat cos AZ º
& « ȍ sin lat »,
Ȧ (47)
« »
«¬ ȍ cos lat sin AZ »¼
20. The velocity of the projectile or rocket with respect to the ground fixed axes at time = t is:
t
& & &
u u0 ³ u dt (48)
0
where:
ªu0 cos (QE ) cos ( 'AZ )º
& « »
u0 u0 sin (QE ) (49)
« »
«¬ u0 cos (QE ) sin ( 'AZ ) »¼
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
13
21. The velocity of the projectile or rocket with respect to the air is given by:
& & &
v uw (50)
M v a (51)
1/ 2
ªJ P º
a « » 20 .046796 (TV 273 .15)1 / 2 (52)
¬ U ¼
J ratio of specific heats for air
P = air pressure
0.003483678761P
U = air density = (53)
TV 273.15
TV = virtual temperature
NOTE: Values used in (52) and (53) referenced from STANAG 6022
22. The position of the projectile or rocket with respect to the ground axes is given by:
& & t &
X X 0 ³ u dt (54)
0
where:
ªlW cos (QE ) cos ( 'AZ )º
&
X 0 « X 2W lW sin (QE ) » (55)
« »
¬« lW cos (QE ) sin ( 'AZ ) ¼»
is the location of the muzzle, i.e., initial position of the center of mass
of the projectile or rocket. For a rocket, lW 0 .
23. The position of the projectile or rocket with respect to the spherical earth’s surface is given
by the approximation:
ª X1 º
&
E
«
«X 2
2
X1 X 3
2
»
» (56)
« 2R »
«¬ X 3 »¼
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
14
&
H Rate of change of the total angular momentum of the kg m 2 rad s 2
body
&
H ( tL ) Total angular momentum of the body at t L kg m 2 rad s
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
16
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
17
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
18
TV Virtual temperature qC
&
x Unit vector along longitudinal axis of the rigid body none
&
x0 Unit vector along longitudinal axis of the rigid body, none
Initially
&
x( t L ) Unit vector along longitudinal axis of the rigid body, none
at t L
&
x Rate of change of unit vector along longitudinal axis of rad/s
the body
&
X Position vector of the center of mass of the projectile or rocket m
in the ground-fixed coordinate system
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
19
Zy ( tL )
Transverse angular velocity of the body at ( t L ) about an axis rad/s
perpendicular to the quadrant elevation of the weapon
in the vertical plane.
Zz ( tL )
Transverse angular velocity of the body at ( t L ) in the vertical rad/s
plane containing the weapon.
: Angular speed of the earth rad/s
Three different conventions have been widely used to describe the aerodynamic coefficients
associated with the force and moment system used to describe the motion of the center of mass of a
projectile. Table III-1 provides a concise comparison of the symbols. The first column lists the
aerodynamic coefficient symbols used throughout this document. These symbols are associated with a
drag force and lift force whose directions are defined with respect to the velocity vector of the center of
mass of the shell and perpendicular to that vector (in the plane of yaw) respectively. The NACA
symbols are associated with axial drag and normal forces whose directions are defined with respect to
the axis of the shell and perpendicular to that axis (also in the plane of yaw) respectively. Consequently
a rotational transformation is necessary to completely relate these two sets of symbols:
CD Cx (57)
0 0
1
CD Cx C z C x0 (58)
D2 D2 D 2
C LD C zD C x0 (59)
1
CL C z 3 C zD C x 2 (60)
D3 D 2 D
The ballistic symbols shown have been slightly modernized to account for the fact that the
original set of symbols did not allow for some of the dependence of the aerodynamic forces on yaw
angle. The same logic as that used by the aeronautical community was applied to affix the subscripts 0,
D , D 2 and D 3 to the original symbols.
NOTE: Equations (58) and (60) use the small angle assumption cosD (1 sin 2 D )1 2
1
approximately equal to 1 2 D 2 . If instead one assumes cosD is approximately equal to 1, then
(58) and (60) become C D 2 C x 2 C zD and C L 3 C z 3 , respectively. If one uses higher order
D D D D
coefficients, such as C D 4 and C L 5 , (58) and (60) may still be used with a negilable effect on
D D
precision. The axial drag force and the drag force, DF , used in this STANAG are assumed to
act in the same direction.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
21
Other Symbols
Symbol C-to-K Relationship Definition
NACA Ballistic
C D0 C x0 K D0 S Drag force
K D0 C D0
8 coefficient
S Quadratic yaw
CD Cx KD KD CD drag force
D2 D2 D2 D2 D2
8 coefficient
S Quartic yaw
CD Cx KD KD CD drag force
D4 D4 D4 D4 D4
8 coefficient
C LD C zD K LD S Lift force
K LD C LD
8 coefficient
S Cubic
CL Cz KL KL CL lift force
D3 D3 D3 D3 D3
8 coefficient
S Quintic
CL Cz KL KL CL lift force
D5 D5 D5 D5 D5
8 coefficient
S Overturning
C MD C MD K MD K MD C MD moment
8 coefficient
S Cubic over-
CM 3 CM 3 KM 3 KM 3 CM Turning moment
D D D D3
D 8 coefficient
C mag f C y pD S Magnus force
KF KF C mag f
8 coefficient
(C M q C M D ) (C mq C mD ) S Damping
KH (C M q C M D )
KH 8 moment
coefficient
S Spin damping
C spin Cl p KA KA C spin moment
8 coefficient
ClG S Fin cant
none KE KE ClG
8 coefficient
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
22
NOTE: Special symbols Cmag-f and Cspin are defined in place of CNpD and Clp to avoid possible confusion
where these symbols have been used differently in published data (notably in the UK and US), where:
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
23
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
24
NOTE: Aerodynamic coefficients for fin-stabilized rockets are required for both the fin closed and fin
open configurations.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
25
24. This STANAG is implemented when a nation has issued instructions to the agencies concerned to
use the Modified Point Mass Trajectory Model for spin-stabilized projectiles and a Five Degrees of
Freedom Model for exterior ballistic trajectory simulation of fin-stabilized rockets as detailed in this
agreement.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
26
1. Aerodynamic coefficients
Aerodynamic coefficients are given as a function of Mach number. These functions are in
the form of polynomials of fourth degree or less. They are defined over regions of Mach
number, from MMAXi-1 up to and including MMAXi .
Ci a 0 a1 M a 2 M 2 a3 M 3 a 4 M 4 (A.1)
2. Fitting Factor:
a. Functions of Quadrant Elevation
Form factor (i) or ballistic coefficient (C) and lift factor (fL) are given for each charge as
follows:
where f = i, C, or fL
Yaw drag factor (QD) and Magnus force factor (QM) have been chosen as constants.
(See Table A-1)
Drag factor (fD) and lift factor (fL) are quartic polynomials of Mach number.
Yaw drag factor (QD = 1.2) has been chosen as a constant and Magnus force factor
(QM) = 1. (See Table A-1)
The modeling of time used in this document may require a correction to the computed
time of flight for each charge as follows:
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
A-1
Two fitting systems are used, quadrant elevation or Mach number as shown below:
Second Order
Range, high Yaw drag factor: QD Yaw drag factor: QD
angle
Vertex height
and time of Magnus force factor: QM Magnus force factor: QM
flight
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
A-2
Table A-2. Fitting factors for matching observed range firing data
Fitting Factors
Range Firing 5 DoF Modified Point Mass
Data Fin-Stabilized Rocket-Assisted Base-Burn
Projectiles
Rockets Projectiles Projectiles
i i i i
Range f (i BB,MT ) { 0 f (i BB , MT ) { 0 f (i BB , MT ) { 0 f (i BB ,MT )
*Optional
NOTE: See Annex C or D for further fitting factors for base-burn and rocket-assisted
projectiles
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
A-3
3. Fuze Setting
Fuze setting is given as a function of time of flight and initial spin as follows:
or,
T a 0 a 2 p0
FS (A.5)
b0 b1 p0
FS is fuze setting
T is time of flight
p0 is initial axial spin of projectile
Muzzle velocity correction for propellant temperature is given for each charge as follows:
a 0 a1PT 21 a 2 PT 21 a3 PT 21
2 3
'U pt (A.6)
The muzzle velocity correction for cannon (tube) wear for a specific
charge/projectile/cannon combination is given by
EFC is the current number of Equivalent Full Charge firings from the cannon.
a0,i, a1,i, a2,i are the coefficients required to calculate the ratio of the incremental change
in muzzle velocity for the reference change ('Ur) to the corresponding incremental
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
A-4
change in muzzle velocity for the ith charge at the specified EFC. This ratio is derived
from the interior ballistics models or actual firing trials.
Muzzle velocity correction for projectile mass is given for each charge as follows:
'U m ni U i m mr / mr (A.8)
T Time of flight s
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
A-5
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
A-6
The presence of nubs introduces terms in the expressions for certain of the aerodynamic forces
and moments, which are proportional to the nub setting angle and independent of the spin rate.
1. Equations of Motion
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
B-1
1. Introduction
This annex provides the equations required to simulate the flight of rocket-assisted projectiles
and the specific equations required to simulate the flight of base-burn projectiles and fin-
stabilized rockets.
a. Add the following thrust term to the equation of motion of the center of mass of the
projectile shown at Eq. (1):
&
TF T * § v cos D e & ·
¨ De ¸ (C.1)
m m © v ¹
b. Zero yaw drag coefficient during the burning phase (tDI d t d tB) is CDo . B
T
c. Thrust during the burning phase (tDI d t d tB) is as follows: B
T* f T TR Pr P Ae , (C.2)
where:
TR
TST t DI ST t BST / t DI t B , (C.3)
and
t* t t DI [t DI ST
t BST / t DI t B ] t DI ST (C.4)
mass at t = 0 is m = m0 (C.5)
for t < tDI
m m DI / t DI (C.6)
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
C-1
m TR / I SP (C.8)
for t t tB
m 0
(C.9)
m mB (C.10)
where:
mB m0 m DI m DOB m f (C.11)
a. The change in acceleration due to the base drag reduction of a base-burn motor, BB, during
burning (tDI d t and m t mB) is added to the equation of motion of the center of mass of
B
the projectile which follows from Equation (1) of the main body of this STANAG:
ª§ S · º
« ¨ 8 ¸ U d v C xBB f I f i BB , MT
2 2
» § v& cos D & ·
BB «© ¹ »¨ e
De ¸ (C.12)
« m »© v ¹
«¬ »¼
b. The coefficient C xBB is the drag reduction coefficient during the burning phase. As with
other aerodynamic coefficients, values of this coefficient are given by polynomial
functions of Mach number of fourth degree or less.
c. The characteristic flow rate function of the base-burn motor is given as follows:
f(I) = 1 If I t I0 (C.14)
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
C-2
NOTE: The function f(I) = I/I0 is principally used for emptying phase and
eventually at the start of the burning phase.
d. The coefficient iBB is a fitting factor which can be used, if necessary, to adjust the drag
reduction. iBB is expressed as a polynomial function of the quadrant elevation, QE, of
third degree or less. It is included for matching observed firing data during the base-burn
phase.
m = m0 – mCB0 (C.16)
m m f (C.17)
m f VC U p S C mCB (C.18)
where:
mB = m0 - mf
B (C.19)
mCB = m0 - m (C.20)
SC ai bi mCB ; (C.21)
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
C-3
ai and bi are defined over regions of mCB, from mCBi = 0 up to and including mCBi = n.
VC VC0 f MT gP K p (C.22)
where:
VC0 is the combustion rate obtained on the strand burner at standard pressure and
temperature
f MT e E MT 21 (C.23)
g P k Pn (C.24)
output.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
C-4
To compensate for the approximations in this annex, certain fitting factors are applied
in order to create correspondence between the computed and the observed range testing
results.
Table C-1. Fitting Factors for Rocket-Assisted and Base Burn Projectiles
Fitting Function
Fitting
Rocket-assisted Base-burn
Projectiles Projectiles
Change in
Radial Velocity
fT
During Motor
Burning
Base-burn,
tDI tDI
Motor-burn
tB - tDI K(p)
Time
B
i
Range i
f(iBB, MT)
5. The location of the center of mass for base burn and rocket-assisted projectiles is given by:
ª X CG0 X CGB m m0 º
X CG X CG0 « » (C.25)
¬ m0 m B ¼
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
C-5
6. Common Equations for base burn and rocket-assisted, spin-stabilized projectiles, and fin-
stabilized rockets.
C MD *
CM «
ª X CG X CG0 C D0 C LD º (C.26)
D »
¬ d ¼
*
where: CM D
is determined for the initial munition configuration and, when
tDI d t < tB, then CD0 equals CD0 for rocket-assisted projectiles
B
T
and fin-stabilized rockets.
*
ª X CG X CG0 C L 3 C D 2 1 / 2 C LD
D D
º»
CM CM « (C.27)
D3 D3 d
«¬ »¼
*
where: C M is determined for the initial munition configuration.
D3
Ix
ª I x I xB m m0 º
Ix0 « 0 » (C.28)
¬ m0 m B ¼
7. The location of the center of mass, motor nozzle exit, motor nozzle throat, and transverse
moment of inertia for fin-stabilized rockets.
X CG
ª X CG f 0 X CGB
X CGB «
m m B º
» (C.29)
«¬ m »¼
where:
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
C-6
b. The location of the motor nozzle exit from the center of the mass is given by:
re " X CG (C.30)
c. The location of the motor nozzle throat from the center of mass is given by:
rt re rt t (C.31)
IY
I Y0 m0 m r f2 m0 X CG f X CG0
0
m X
2
CG f
X CG
2
(C.32)
Figure C-1 illustrates the distances used for the determination of the transverse moment of inertia
of the rocket or projectile during motor burning.
X CG f X CG0 X CGB
+ +rf x + +
Figure C-1. Distances Used for the Determination of the Transverse Moment of Inertia
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
C-7
*
CM D
Overturning moment coefficient for initial projectile none
configuration
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
C-8
IxB B
Axial moment of inertia at burnout kg m2
P Air pressure Pa
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
C-9
rt-t Distance of the motor nozzle exit from the motor nozzle m
throat
T* Effective thrust N
XCGB B
Distance of center of mass from nose at burnout m
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
C-10
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
C-11
a. Rocket-Assisted Motor
Time of rocket ignition delay (tDI), time of rocket motor burn (tB – tDI) and thrust
B
factor (fT) are given as a function of rocket motor temperature for each charge as
follows:
f a 0 a1 MT 21 a 2 MT 212 a 3 MT 213 (C.33)
where:
f = tDI, tB – tDI, or fT
B (C.34)
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
C-12
b. Base-Burn Motor
The axial spin influence on burning rate factor K(p), is given as a linear function of
spin for each charge.
iBB MT 21 a0 a1 QE a2 QE 2 a3 QE 3 (C.36)
and
f (iBB, MT ) iBB MT 21 b1 MT 21 b2 MT 21 b3 MT 21 b4 MT 21
2 3 4
(C.37)
Time of base-burn ignition delay (tDI) is given as a function of motor temperature for
each charge.
t DI a 0 a1 MT 21 a 2 MT 212 a 3 MT 213 (C.38)
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
C-13
1. Introduction
This annex provides the equations required to simulate the flight of spin-stabilized rocket-assisted
projectiles, spin-stabilized base-burn projectiles, and fin-stabilized rockets
TF
The acceleration due to thrust force of the rocket motor, , during burning (tDI d t d tB) is B
m
added to the equation of motion of the center of mass of the unassisted projectile:
&
TF ª f T m f I SP Pr P Ae º § v cos D e & ·
« »¨ De ¸ (D.1)
m ¬ m ¼© v ¹
During rocket motor burning the aerodynamic zero-yaw coefficient is CDoT and if m f d m P then
(Pr – P) Ae = 0.
The base drag reduction due to a base-burn motor during burning (tDI d t d tB) is added to the B
§ DF ·
drag term ¨ ¸ of the projectile.
¨ m ¸
© ¹
ª º
DF
S Ud i2 «
^C Do f i BB , MT «
I
G BP
G I
» &
`
» C D 2 QDD e 2 C D 4 (QDD e ) 4 v v (D.2)
m 8m
« J M2 § d · 2»
«¬ 2 ¨ ¸
© b ¹ »¼
d
D D
where:
4 m f
I (D.3)
S U v db2
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
D-1
3. Common Equations for base-burn and rocket-assisted, spin-stabilized projectiles, and fin-
stabilized rockets.
a. The mass flow for spin-stabilized projectiles and fin-stabilized rockets is given by:
at t = 0
m m0 (D.4)
m 0 (D.5)
for 0 < t < tDI
m DI
m (D.6)
t DI
t DI § m DI ·
m ³ ¨¨ ¸¸ dt m0 (D.7)
0
© t DI ¹
m m f (D.8)
tB t DI § m DI ·
m ³ m f dt ³ ¨¨ ¸¸ dt m0 (D.9)
t DI 0
© t DI ¹
§ t B* t(*t ) · *
m f ¨ ¸ m (D.10)
¨ tB t ¸ f
© (t ) ¹
t B* t (*t )
t(*t ) (D.11)
t B( t ) t
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
D-2
ª § p · § P ·º
tB( t ) t B( t )
t « f BTp ¨¨ ¸¸ f BTP ¨¨ ¸¸» (D.12)
¬ © p¹ © P ¹¼
where:
'P 'P
P u2 (D.13)
't 'E 2
and at tDI
t (*tDI ) *
t DI (D.14)
f BT f BT
ª § p( tDI ) · p § P( tDI ) · P º
t B( t t DI «t B t DI ¨¨ ¸
¸
¨
¨ P ¸
¸ » (D.15)
DI ) p
« © r ¹ © r ¹ »
¬ ¼
for t t tBB
mB = m0 – mDI – mf
B (D.16)
m 0 (D.17)
X CG
ª X CG f 0 X CGB
X CGB «
m m B º
» (D.18)
¬« m ¼»
where:
( X CG0 X CG B )m0
X CG f0 X CG B (D.19)
(m0 mB )
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
D-3
c. The location of the motor nozzle exit from the center of the mass is given by:
re " X CG (D.20)
d. The location of the motor nozzle throat from the center of mass is given by:
rt re rt t (D.21)
C MD *
CM
ª X CG X CG0 C D0 C LD º (D.22)
D « »
¬ d ¼
*
where: CM D
is determined for the initial munition configuration and, when
tDI d t < tB , then CD0 equals CD0 for rocket-assisted projectiles and
T
fin-stabilized rockets. The aerodynamic coefficients are considered to
be dimensionless, with unit = 1, in this formulation.
*
ª X CG X CG0 C L 3 C D 2 1 / 2 C LD
D D
º»
CM CM «
D3 D3 d
«¬ »¼ (D.23)
*
where: C M is determined for the initial munition configuration. The
D3
Ix
ª I x I xB m m0 º
Ix0 « 0 » (D.24)
¬ m0 m B ¼
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
D-4
IY
I Y0 m0 m r f2 m0 X CG f X CG0
0
m X
2
CG f
X CG
2
(D.25)
Figure D-1 illustrates the distances used for the determination of the transverse moment of inertia of the
rocket during motor burning.
X CG f 0 X CG0 X CGB
+ rf x + +
Figure D-1. Distances Used for the Determination of the Transverse Moment of Inertia
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
D-5
CD0 Zero yaw drag coefficient during rocket motor burning none
T
*
CM 3 Cubic overturning moment coefficient for initial fuzed 1/rad2
D
munition
IxB B
Axial moment of inertia of the munition at motor burnout kg m2
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
D-6
m P Minimum mass flow rate of the motor fuel for air kg/s
pressure term
rt-t Distance of the motor nozzle exit from the motor nozzle m
throat
t* Pseudo-time-of-motor burning s
tB B Time-of-motor burnout s
*
t DI Reference time-of-motor ignition delay s
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
D-7
XCGB B
Distance of center of mass of the munition from nose m
at time tBB
Minimum mass flow rate of the fuel for air pressure term m p
Radius of gyration of motor fuel mass rf
Distance of the motor nozzle exit from the motor nozzle throat rt-t
Distance of center of mass of the munition from nose, initially XCG0
Distance of center of mass of the munition from nose at motor burnout XCGB B
*
Nonlinear overturning moment coefficient for initial fuzed munition CM
D3
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
D-8
G BP
is given, for up to five values of I, as a function of Mach number in the form of
GI
polynomials of fourth degree or less. They are defined over regions of Mach number, from
MMAXi = 1 up to and including MMAX.
§ G BP ·
¨¨ ¸¸ a 0 a1 M a 2 M 2 a 3 M 3 a 4 M 4 (D.26)
© G I ¹I
a. The time-of-motor ignition delay, tDI, and time-of-motor burn, (tB - tDI), for rocket-assisted and
base-burn projectiles are given as a function of motor temperature, MT, for each charge as
follows:
t DI a 0 a1 MT 21 a 2 MT 212 a 3 MT 213 (D.27)
t B t DI a 0 a1 MT 21 a 2 MT 212 a 3 MT 213 (D.28)
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
D-9
b. The thrust factor, fT, for a rocket-assisted projectile is given as a function of motor temperature,
MT, for each charge as follows:
fT a 0 a1 MT 21 a 2 MT 212 a 3 MT 213 (D.29)
c. The spin rate burning-time factor, fBTp, for a base-burn projectile is given as a constant for each
charge.
d. The atmospheric air pressure burning-time factor, fBTP, for a base-burn projectile is given as a
constant for each charge.
e. The factor, f(iBB,MT), for a base-burn projectile is given as a function of quadrant elevation, QE,
and motor temperature, MT, for each charge as follows:
i BB MT 21
a 0 a1 QE a 2 QE 2 a 3 QE 3 (D.30)
and
f i BB , MT i BB MT b1 MT 21 b2 MT 21 b3 MT 21 b4 MT 21
2 3 4
21
(D.31)
a. The mass of ignition delay element, mDI, time of motor ignition delay, tDI, spin rate burning-time
factor, fBTp, and the atmospheric air pressure burning-time factor, fBTP, are zero.
b. The time of first motion, tFM, time of launch, tL, time of rocket fin opening, tFO, time of motor
burn, (tB - tDI), is given by, tB, time of end of five degrees of freedom, tE5D, and thrust factor, fT,
B
a 0 a1 MT 21 a 2 MT 21 a3 MT 21
2 3
t FM (D.32)
a 0 a1 MT 21 a 2 MT 21 a3 MT 21
2 3
tL (D.33)
a 0 a1 MT 21 a 2 MT 21 a3 MT 21
2 3
t FO (D.34)
a 0 a1 MT 21 a 2 MT 21 a 3 MT 21
2 3
tB (D.35)
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
D-10
a 0 a1 MT 21 a 2 MT 21 a3 MT 21
2 3
t E5D (D.36)
a 0 a1 MT 21 a 2 MT 21 a3 MT 21
2 3
fT (D.37)
c. At time, tL, the initial angular velocity (spin) of the fin stabilized rocket is, p( t L ) , a constant and
the initial transverse angular velocities of the fin stabilized rocket, Z y( t and Z z( t ) , are given as
L) L
p(t L ) a0 (D.38)
Zy ( t L ( MT 21))
a 0 a1 QE a 2 QE 2 a 3 QE 3 (D.39)
and Zy ( tL )
= Z y( t L ( MT 21 ))
b1 ( MT 21) b2 ( MT 21) 2 b3 ( MT 21) 3
Zz ( t L ( MT 21 ))
a 0 a1 QE a 2 QE 2 a 3 QE 3 (D.40)
and Zz ( tL )
= Z z( t L ( MT 21 ))
b1 ( MT 21) b2 ( MT 21) 2 b3 ( MT 21) 3
d. The form factor, i , and adjustment to azimuth, '(' AZ ), are given as a function of quadrant
elevation, QE, as follows:
i a 0 a1 QE a 2 QE 2 a 3 QE 3 (D.41)
e. The modeling of time used for fin stabilized rockets may require a correction to time of flight
as follows:
T t 'ToF (D.43)
'ToF a 0 a1t a 2 t 2 a 3t 3 (D.44)
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
D-11
1. Introduction
Submunition trajectories are the trajectories for submunitions ejected from the carrier shell in
flight.
Figure E-1 defines the nomenclature for the different phases. A collective name for the
different phases is submunition trajectory. Note that terminal phase should always be used
for the phase in which the submunition hits the ground or functions.
The base separation point is the point where the fuze of the carrier shell activates the first
phase of the submunition trajectories. Calculation of the position of the base separation point
can be done using either of the following rules:
HOB a0 a1 QE AS a 2 QE AS 2 a3 QE AS 3
(E.1)
a 4 a5 QE AS a6 QE AS 2 a7 QE AS 3 Alt w
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
E-1
and
T fs b0 b1 QE AS b2 QE AS 2 b3 QE AS 3 (E.2)
Rule (a.) is designed to ensure that a specified fraction of all base separation points occur at a
certain height. Rule (b.) is designed to ensure that a specified fraction of submunitions hits
the ground before the self-destruct time.
The starting velocity of any phase, which includes point-mass and closed-form-biases:
& & &
u s1 u carrier 'u s1c (E.3)
*
& v &
where: c cosD e D e is the axis of the carrier shell at the end of the previous phase, and
v
&
the vector D e is the yaw of repose.
'u sn a 0,n a1,n p n 1 is the ejection speed of the submunition,
and p n 1 is the magnitude of the spin at the end of the previous phase
where: the subscripts s and n represent submunition and the phase number respectively. Ssn
is the effective presented cross sectional area of the submunition unit and msn is its mass.
They can both be given as linear functions of time.
&
The wind velocity, w , is accounted for through
& & &
v sn u sn w (E.5)
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
E-2
2U 2
p sn S sn p sn C spinsn v sn (E.6)
S I xsn
Drag coefficient can be formatted in two ways, one of which is dependent on Mach number only
and one of which is dependent on Mach number, velocity, and spin.
Drag coefficient is given as a function of the Mach number (Msn) of the submunition. The
function is in the form of a linear function. It is defined over regions of Mach number similar to
that of Annex A, paragraph 1. Thus in each interval
C Dsn value depends on the Mach number and the quotient of velocity and spin as follows.
1.0 § S ball _ sn S sn ·
C Dsn >a 0,n a1,n M sn @ ¨¨ ¸¸ (E.8)
i sn © S sn ¹
S 2
where: S ball _ sn d sn (E.9)
4
a1,sn
and d sn a 0,sn a3, sn
(E.10)
§ p sn ·
1 a 2,sn ¨ ¸
¨u ¸
© sn ¹
where: the coefficients ak,sn (k=0,1,2,3) are constant fitting factors for the submunition s in the
phase n.
psn The spin of the submunition s in the phase n ( rad/s )
usn The velocity of the submunition s in the phase n ( m/s )
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
E-3
Tsn t sn a t sn (E.14)
for each phase.
The end of the phase is determined either by height above the ground and/or the duration of
the phase and is calculated by one of the following equations:
H phase a (E.15)
or
b1
T f ,sn a 0 a1 QE AS a 2 QE AS 2 a 3 QE AS 3 (E.16)
u sn
a. Closed Form A
assuming a drag proportional to a velocity reference and constant meteorological
parameters throughout the phase using the vector equation
* & &
& & § v sn g · §& g· (E.17)
x n 1 x n ¨¨ 2 ¸¸ >1 exp Tsn k s @ Tsn ¨¨ w ¸¸
© ks ks ¹ © ks ¹
where:
S sn
ks C Dsn U v sn (E.18)
2m sn
ª 0 º
& « g »
g (E.19)
« 0»
«¬ 0 »¼
and
ª w1 º
& «w »
w (E.20)
« 2 »
or ¬« w3 ¼»
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
E-4
b. Closed Form B
assuming a constant velocity of fall and constant wind throughout the phase where
the heights of burst and time of fall are related by
If HOBn and HOBn+1 are in different met zones, a fall time is calculated for each zone
HOBn H Z 1
T f sn ( Z ) (E.22)
v sn ,2
H z H z 1
T f sn ( z ) (E.23)
v sn ,2
H Z0 HOBn 1
T f sn ( Z 0 ) (E.24)
v sn ,2
where Z is the met zone of HOBn, Z 0 is the met zone of HOBn+1 and z is any met zone
Z z Z 0 . Hz is the upper height of met zone z. When n is the last submunition
phase, equation (E.21) becomes zero.
The displacement due to horizontal wind is the sum of contributions from applicable met
zones.
& Z
&
d ¦ T f sn z wh z (E.25)
0 s Z
& &
where d is the displacement vector and wh ( z ) the horizontal wind vector of met zone z
(assumed constant throughout the zone).
The displacement due to wind may for certain types of submunition, e.g. illumination
canisters, be used to make an offset to the aim point. The offset is
where: Rill is the illumination radius (maximum absolute distance between illumination
canister and target). HOB is the height at which the illumination canister ignites.
or
c. Displacement
by fitting observed data (for phase 1) to the form
&
'X 1,1 a0 a1 vcarrier ,1 along the horizontal component of v (E.28)
&
'X 1, 2 b0 b1 vcarrier , 2 along the vertical component of v (E.29)
The separation phase is described by the following equations, where the index s
represents the submunition.
For a detailed description of the coefficients used, see chapter List of Symbols.
&
The change in position ǻX s is given as
ªcos ī 0 cos ȥ 0 º
& « sin ī »
ǻX s a0s (E.31)
« 0 »
«¬cos ī 0 sin ȥ 0 »¼
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
E-6
ǻp s a 0 a1 p0 a 2 u0 a 3 p0 u0 (E.34)
where p0 is the spin and u0 is the velocity at the start of the phase.
ǻt s a 0 a1 u0 a 2 u02 (E.35)
where u0 is the velocity at the start of the phase.
a. Concentric submunitions
The axis of the shell will not in general be parallel to the shell velocity vector due to a
non-zero yaw of repose. This effect may be accounted for as shown in the following
dispersion calculation.
&
The axis of the carrier shell is the vector c and the yaw of repose is defined by the
&
vector D e . Thus we have
*
& v &
c cos D e D e (E.36)
v
The ejection velocity of any central bomblet (a bomblet lying concentric with the axis of
the shell), we get
& & &
u s1 ucarrier ' u s1 c (E.37)
is the ejection speed of the submunition, and p is the magnitude of projectile’s spin at
time of fuze function.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
E-7
b. Eccentric submunitions
After combining (E.38-39) and adding the velocity for the central bomblets we get
& & & & &
us1
ucarrier 'us1c iD prs d sin I e cos I (E.43)
is the ejection speed of the submunition, and p is the magnitude of the projectile’s spin at
the time of fuze function.
& & & &
In the case when c u y = 0, both d and e are in the horizontal plane. In this case,
&
choose d to be the unit vector in the direction of the projection of the initial projectile
velocity onto the horizontal plane.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
E-8
c. Submunition trajectories
The ballistic trajectory of the submunitions can be determined by the same methods as
described in sections 3 and 4.
This pattern is defined by the impact point of four virtual submunitions defined relative to
the vertical plane of the trajectory of the carrier:
(1) the submunition ejected in the vertical plane above the shell trajectory,
(2) the submunition ejected in the vertical plane below the shell trajectory,
(3) the submunition whose tangential ejection velocity component is normal to the
vertical plane in the negative 3-direction,
(4) the submunition whose tangential ejection velocity component is normal to the
vertical plane in the positive 3-direction.
The initial velocities for these submunitions at the base separation point are respectively
& * & &
ulower u carrier ' u s1c i D prs e (I = 180º) (E.45)
& * & &
uupper u carrier ' u s1c i D prs e (I = 0º) (E.46)
& * & &
u right u carrier ' u s1c i D prs d (I = 90º) (E.47)
& * & &
uleft u carrier ' u s1c i D prs d (I = 270º) (E.48)
In cases (3) and (4) it is anticipated that the ejection takes place at such a height that the
descent is close to vertical at the end of the terminal phase.
The trajectory of the empty carrier left after the base separation point can be calculated
assuming that the carrier has the same aerodynamic properties as the original shell. The
empty carrier will at base separation get a velocity, a mass and a moment of inertia, which
are different to the original shell. The calculation of the trajectory could be done according
to the Modified Point Mass Model in the main text or the Point Mass Model in Annex F.
The sign of 'uec is opposite to 'us1. The mass of the empty carrier mec, its moment of inertia
Ixec, and 'uec must be entered separately.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
E-9
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
E-10
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
E-11
n (or a digit) property in terminal phase n (or phase number as given by digit)
s property of submunition
Symbols without vector indicator symbolize the scalar value of the vector
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
E-12
where:
DF §S U id 2 · & (F.2)
¨¨ ¸ CD v v
¸
m © 8m ¹
or when C is used as a fitting factor,
DF § S U mr · &
¨¨ ¸¸ C D v v (F.3)
m © 8 Cm ¹
or when fD is used as a fitting factor,
DF §SU d2 · &
m
¨¨
¸ f D CD v v
¸ (F.4)
© 8m ¹
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
F-1
ª 0º
& « R»
R
« » (F.8)
«¬ 0 »¼
where:
ª ȍ cos lat cos AZ º
& « ȍ sin lat »
Ȧ (F.10)
« »
«¬ ȍ cos lat sin AZ »¼
S U d 4 p v C spin
p (F.11)
8 Ix
where:
t
p p0 ³ p dt (F.12)
0
is the magnitude of spin at time = t and
2S u0
p0 (F.13)
tc d
is the magnitude of the initial spin of the projectile at the muzzle.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
F-2
4. The velocity of the projectile with respect to the ground fixed axes at time = t is:
& & t &
u u0 ³ u dt (F.14)
0
5. The velocity of the projectile with respect to the air is given by:
& & &
v uw (F.16)
6. The position of the projectile with respect to the ground axes is given by:
& & t &
X X 0 ³ u dt (F.18)
0
where:
ª º
& «lW cos (QE ) cos ( ' AZ )»
X0 « X lW sin (QE ) » (F.19)
« 2W »
« lW cos (QE ) sin ( ' AZ ) »
¬ ¼
is the location of the muzzle, i.e., initial position of the center of mass of the
projectile.
7. The position of the projectile with respect to the spherical earth’s surface is given by the
approximation:
ª X1 º
&
E
«
«X 2
2
X 1 X 32 »
» (F.20)
« 2R »
«¬ X 3 »¼
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
F-3
8. For some applications, especially where the flight path of the projectile is short, the model
described above may be simplified further:
the effects of height above the earth’s surface on gravity may be ignored, in which case
ª 0º
&
g g 0 1»
« (F.21)
« »
«¬0»¼
the effects of spin of the earth may be ignored, in which case
ȍ{0 (F.22)
p0 p { 0 (F.23)
9. The List of Symbols found at Sections II and III of the main document contain all the
symbols required for this annex with one exception, namely, CD is defined as the total drag
force coefficient (dimensionless).
10. The List of Data Requirements related to this annex are as follows:
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
F-4
Since the point mass equations do not explicitly model the effects of yaw of repose, the
fitting factors for the range estimation must be used to account for this fact. As a result,
the forms will vary from those forms used with the MPM equations. Following are some
typical forms used in fire control systems.
The equations are applicable over the QE intervals bounded by QEj-1 to and including
QEj. The functions must be continuous and smooth at each breakpoint. The minimum
and maximum values of QE are determined by the weapon and ammunition
characteristics but, typically, range from zero mils to the maximum trail angle. The
degree of the polynomial is dependent upon the desired quality of the range estimation.
b. Drift Correction
Since the point mass equations do not include the drift effects associated with spinning
projectiles, the drift (which is perpendicular to the vertical plane containing the line of
fire) is generally represented by a function based on the observed fall of shot results. The
following are typical expressions for drift expressed in mil:
or
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
F-5
or
or
In order to account for the difference between the actual time of flight (T) and the time of
flight predicted by the point mass model the following forms can be used:
T = a0 + a1 t + a2 t2 + a3 t3 (F.32)
T = t + 't (F.33)
Where the equation is applicable over the time (t) intervals bounded by tj-1 to and
including tj. The functions must be continuous and smooth at each breakpoint. The
minimum and maximum values of T are determined by the weapon and ammunition
characteristics but, typically, range from zero seconds to the maximum time of flight.
The degree of the polynomial is dependent upon the desired quality of the time
estimation.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
F-6
1. Introduction
This annex presents a method of extending the use of a modified point mass trajectory
model for mid-course guidance munitions utilizing Global Positioning System (GPS) and
Inertial Navigation System (INS), which incorporates an estimate of the vertical and
horizontal angles of yaw to simulate the flight of the guided munitions. The equations in
this annex are to be used during the guided and terminal phases of the trajectory, where
the munition departs from a ballistic trajectory t t t g .
The figure below shows the phases of a trajectory for guided munitions. This trajectory
shows one Aim Point after the start of guidance in the Mid-Course Guidance Phase with
a line of sight drawn between the two points. If more than one Aim Point is desired in
this phase, each Aim Point will have a line of sight vector drawn from the previous Aim
Point to the following Aim Point. The Proportional Navigation methods described in this
annex hold for each Aim Point in the Mid Course Guidance Phase.
If the canards are deployed at time tcd during the ballistic phase, the form factor and zero-
yaw drag force coefficient are ib and C D0 g respectively.
cd
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
G-1
2. Pointing of Munition
The pointing of the munition is assumed to be the same as the pointing of the velocity
vector. The projection of the velocity vector on the vertical (Jv) and horizontal (Jh) planes
is given by:
§v ·
Jv arcsin ¨ 2 ¸ (G.1)
© v ¹
§v ·
Jh arctan ¨¨ 3 ¸¸ (G.2)
© v1 ¹
Then define a unit vector along the longitudinal axis of the munition including an
estimate of the angles of yaw to simulate the guidance technologies during the guidance
phase.
2
Projectile
(v1,v2,v3)
v v12 v 22 v 32
1
Jh
Jv
3
Velocity
Vector (v)
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
G-2
where:
'RT
a0 a1 Ovtg a 2 Ovtg
2
(G.3)
a O a O
2
'H T a0 1 vtg 2 vtg (G.4)
The unit vector along the longitudinal axis of the munition to proportionally navigate to
an aim point beginning at the initiation of guidance (tg) is given by:
ª § f D ·º ½
°cos(J f D f D ) cos«J ¨ D h h pn ¸» °
v D v v pn gb v gb h ¨ cos J ¸ °
° « © »
v ¹¼
& ° ¬ °
x ®sin(J v fD v D v pn f gbD v gb ) ¾ (G.5)
° ª f D º °
°cos(J f D f D ) sin «J §¨ D h h pn ·¸» °
° v D v v pn gb v gb h ¨ cos J ¸ °
¯ «¬ © v ¹»
¼¿
where:
8 m N v Ov
D v pn (G.6)
2§ 2·
S U d ¨ C LD g C L 3 D g ¸v
© Dg ¹
8 m N h Oh
Dh (G.7)
S U d 2 §¨ C LD C L D g 2 ·¸v
pn
© D g g
3
¹
Nv and Nh are the vertical and horizontal plane navigation ratios, respectively. They are
linear polynomials of (t - tg) in the form a0 + a1(t - tg).
The pointing angle or angles of line-of-sight vector (from munition to aim point) in
inertial space are obtained from the known aim point position and the munition position
(for all aim points in the guidance phase) from GPS by:
§ X 2ap X 2 ·
¨ ¸
Ov arctan¨ ¸ (G.8)
¨
©
X 1ap X1 X
2
3ap X3
2
¸
¹
§ X 3ap X 3 ·
¨ ¸
Oh arctan¨ ¸ (G.9)
¨
©
X 1ap X1 X
2
2 ap X2 2
¸
¹
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
G-3
Projectile
(X1,X2,X3)
Ov
Oh Aim Point
(X1ap,X2ap,X3ap)
3
Then the rate of change of the pointing angles to the aim point are given by:
Ov
>X 1ap X X @ X X
X1
2
3ap 3
2
2 2 ap X2 >X X X X
1ap 1 1 3ap @
X 3 X 3
(G.10)
>X X X X X
1ap 1
2
2 ap 2
2
3ap X3 @ X X X
2
1ap 1
2
3ap X3
2
Oh
>X 1ap 2
X 1 X 2ap X 2 @ X X
2
3 3ap X3 >X X X X
1ap 1 1 2 ap @
X 2 X 2
(G.11)
>X X X
1ap 1
2
2 ap X X
2
2
3ap X3 @ X X X
2
1ap 1
2
2 ap X2
2
8 g 2 mcos J v
Dv (G.12)
S U d 2 §¨ C LD g C L 3 D 2 g ·¸v 2
gb
© Dg ¹
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
G-4
To compensate for the approximations in the equations of motion, the fitting factors fD v ,
fD h , and f gb are applied in order to match the computed and observed results. The factor
on gravity bias ( f gb ) is reduced linearly starting at a distance from the aim point to 0 at a
closer distance to the aim point. Fitting factors are defined in Table G-1.
&
The total angle of yaw during the guidance phase, D g , is given by:
&
& & & &§ v ·
Dg x x v ¨ 2 ¸ (G.13)
©v ¹
The total angle of yaw combining the horizontal and vertical directions will not be
allowed to exceed certain constraints. A vertical upward angle of attack
fD v D v pn f gbD v gb will increase the range by increasing lift and reduce the range by
increasing the drag. These opposing effects are balanced to avoid a decrease in
maximum range by defining a vertical upward angle of attack limit D vu max that yields the
maximum lift-to-drag ratio; and fD h D h pn must vanish as fD v D v pn f gbD v gb approaches
D vu max or the total drag will be increased beyond the maximum lift-to-drag ratio.
Therefore, for fD v D v pn f gbD v gb > 0: the limitation on the vertical upward angle of yaw
f D v D v pn f gbD v gb is D vu max . The limitation on f D h D h pn will be dependent on the
magnitude of f D v D v pn f gbD v gb . If D vu max is the limit on f D when
Dh h pn
f D v D v pn
f gbD v gb = 0, then when fD v D v pn f gbD v gb > 0, D vu max must be reduced to
prevent fD h D h pn from adding drag that would compromise the maximum lift-to-drag
criteria.
f Dh Dh 1
f Dv D v f gb D v
pn gb
2
(G.14)
hv 2
pn max max
D vu max
For fD v D v pn f gbD v gb d 0 : the maximum lift-to-drag ratio no longer applies, since the
downward lift and drag no longer oppose one another, so the primary limiter can be
fD h D h pn .
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
G-5
Therefore, for fD v D v pn f gbD v gb d 0 : the limitation on f
will be D D h D h pn hmax and the
limitation on fD v D v pn f gbD v gb will be dependent on the magnitude of f D h D h pn and
the maximum vertical downward angle of attack D vd max .
f D v pn f gb D v gb D vd max 1
f Dh D h pn
2
(G.15)
Dv max D h max 2
The maximum vertical upward ( D vu max ), vertical downward ( D vd max ), and horizontal
( D hmax ) angles of attack are quartic polynomials of Mach number.
D vu max
Dh max
Velocity
Vector of
Projectile
Dvdmax
Boundary of Dmax
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
G-6
To maintain munition pointing, the unit vector along the longitudinal axis of the munition
that existed at the initiation of glide (tg), that is a time interval (dtg) after a time setting
(tsg), is given by:
cos J cos J ½
vt g ht g
& °° °°
x ®sin J vt g ¾ (G.16)
°cos J sin J °
°¯ vt g ht g °¿
The unit vector remains fixed as above as long as D g , the total angle of yaw during the
guidance phase, is d D vu max . When D g ! D vu max due to the path of the trajectory falling
away from the pointing vector of the munition, the attitude must be allowed to drift
downward to prevent D g from becoming too large and causing the munition to stall.
°°
cos J D
vt g
vu max cos J ht g
½
°°
&
x
®sin J vt g D vumax ¾ (G.17)
°¯
°cos J D
vt g
vu max sin J ht g
°
°¿
6. Fitting Factors
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
G-7
Fitting factor for Horizontal angle of yaw ( fD h ) is given for each charge as follows:
fD h a 0 a1 (O h ) a 2 (O h ) 2 (G.18)
where: O h is evaluated at tg
Fitting factors for Vertical angle of yaw ( fD h ) and Gravity Bias angle of yaw ( f gb ) are
given for each charge as follows:
where: Ov is evaluated at tg
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
G-8
t cd Time-of-canards deployment s
tg Time-of-guidance or glide s
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
G-9
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
G-10
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
a. the origin is the point where the local vertical line, perpendicular to the surface of the
geoid, through the weapon trunnion, intersects the geoid.
&
b. the 1 axis is the intersection of the vertical plane of fire and the horizontal plane and
pointing along the gun to target line.
& &
c. the 2 axis is parallel to the gravity vector, g , and opposite in direction.
&
d. the 3 axis completes the right-handed coordinate system.
The geoid is the surface within or around the earth that is everywhere normal to the direction
of gravity and coincides with mean sea level.
2. Geophysical Approximations
a. The geoid is locally approximated by a sphere with a radius (R) of 6,356,766 metres.
&
b. The gravitational acceleration, g , has the scalar magnitude
at the surface of the above-mentioned sphere and is inversely proportional to the square
of the distance from the center of the sphere. The term “lat” is the latitude of the origin
of the coordinate system.
3. Coriolis
The origin of the& coordinate system is fixed to the rotating earth, therefore, a Coriolis
acceleration term, / , is included.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
H-1
4. Yaw of Repose
The Yaw of Repose is defined by an approximation to the particular solution of the classical
linearized equations of yawing motion for a dynamically stable projectile possessing at least
trigonal symmetry.
NOTE: Based on comparisons of test firings and modified point mass simulations, it has
been determined that quadrant elevations corresponding to a yaw of repose of 0.6 radians
provide a good approximation of a weapon system’s practical maximum quadrant elevation.
Quadrant elevations exceeding this limit can lead to erratic flight behavior reflected by
increased dispersion in the deflection plane. Details can be found in the reference, Collings,
W.Z. and Lieske, R.F., “A study of Artillery Shell Drift at High Angle of Fire Using Solar
Aspect Sensors,” BRL-MR-2244, U.S. Army Ballistic Research Laboratory, Aberdeen
Proving Ground, Maryland, November 1972.
5. Windage Jump
Windage Jump corrects for the effect of a transient yaw caused by a wind shear. This gives
the “Modified Point Mass Model” the ability to perform the correct second order response to
wind, range effect due to a cross wind, and the deflection effect due to a range wind.
6. Fitting
To compensate for the approximations in the “Modified Point Mass Model” and the
aerodynamic data, certain fitting factors are applied in order to create correspondence
between the computed and the observed values of range, deflection and the time of flight.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
H-2
Two fitting systems are used, quadrant elevation or Mach number as shown below:
Second
Order Yaw drag factor: QD Yaw drag factor: QD
Range, high
angle
Vertex height
and time of Magnus force factor: QM Magnus force factor: QM
flight
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
H-3
SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY
Title Topic
The Modified Point Mass Trajectory Specifications of Model for current use
Model, NATO D/161 (UK Source) by NATO countries
The Calibration of a Modified Point Mass Reports use of linearized MPM to aid
Model by Mach Number Fitting SCICON trials design and automated analysis
Jan 1982 techniques.
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
I-1
Title Topic
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
I-2
Title Topic
Modern Exterior Ballistics, The Launch Covers the free flight dynamics
and Flight Dynamics of Symmetric of symmetric projectiles. Provides
Projectiles. many examples of projectile motion
Robert L. McCoy, illustrating key flight behaviors.
Shiffer Publishing Ltd., 1999
ISBN: 0-7643-0720-7
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
I-3
NATO/PFP UNCLASSIFIED
I-4