Chapter 2: Science, Technology, and Society in Human Condition Lesson 1: Human Flourishing
Chapter 2: Science, Technology, and Society in Human Condition Lesson 1: Human Flourishing
Chapter 2: Science, Technology, and Society in Human Condition Lesson 1: Human Flourishing
Verification Theory
The earliest criterion that distinguishes philosophy and science is verification theory. The idea proposes that a
discipline is science if it can be confirmed or interpreted in the event of an alternative hypothesis being
accepted. In that regard, said theory gives premium to empiricism and only takes into account those results
which are measurable and experiments which are movement repeatable. classic example is astrology, whose
followers are able to employ the verification method in ascertaining its reliability. The idea is that since one
already has some sort of expectations on what to find, they will interpret events in line with said expectations.
EXAMPLE OF VERIFICATION THEORY
She began by observing him and his interactions with her. Several gestures she noted include his always
exchanging pleasantries with her whenever they bump into each other, his big smile when he sees her, and
him going out of his way to greet her even when riding a jeepney. Through these observations, she was then
able to conclude that lan does like her because, she thought, why would anyone do something like that for a
person he does not like? As it tums out, however, lan is just generally happy to meet people he knew. He had
known Lea since they were in first year and regards her as a generally okay person. It is no Surprise then that
upon learning that lan basically does this to everyone, Lea was crushed. She vowed to herself that she would
never assume again.
Based from above story, is it justified for Lea to think that lan does not like her? Not quite. The next criterion
also warns us about the danger or this view.
Another example : The taste of apple is not sweet
FALSIFICATION THEORY
Falsification Theory Perhaps the current prevalent methodology in science, falsification theory asserts that as
long as an ideology is not proven to be false and can best explain á phenomenon over alternative theories, we
should accept the said ideology.
Karl Popper is the known proponent of this view.
Example of FALSIFICATION THEORY
To illustrate, previous story is restated:
around people and generally aspires to become everybody's friend. However, there is this one girl, Lea, who
seemed to not like him when he is around. Every time he waves at her, she turns away, and when they are in
the same room, she avoids his glances. Through this, he concluded that Lea does not like him and does his
best to show her that he is not a threat. He began greeting her whenever they pass by each other at the
corridor, even going so far as calling her attention when he was in the jeepney and saw her walking past.
When they are able to talk to each other, he found out that Lea is just really shy and is not accustomed to
people greeting her. He then was able to conclude that his initial impression of her not liking him (as a person)
is wrong and thus said proposition is rejected.
falsification method is prone to the same generalizations committed by the verification method. There is no
known rule as to the number of instance that a theory is rejected or falsified in order for it to be set aside.
Similarly, there is no assurance that observable event or evidences" are indeed manifestations of a cetain
concept or "theories”.
Another example: because the fruit he ate was not the good one
SCIENCE AS SOCIAL ENDEAVOR
Science as a Social Endeavor
Due to inconclusiveness of the methodologies previously cited, a new school of thought on the proper demarcation
criterion of science emerged. Several philosophers such as Paul Thagard, Imre Lakatos, Helen Longino, David
Bloor, and Richard Rorty, among others, presented an alternative demarcation that explores the social dimension of
science and effectively, technology. Sciences cease to belong solely to gown wearing, bespectacled scientists at
laboratories. The new view perpetuates a dimension which generally benefits the society. For instance, far-off 56
Science, Technology, and Society. places in South America where many of the tribes remain uncontacted, do
not regard western science as their science. Whatever their science is, it can be ascertainèd that it is in no way
inferior to that of globalized peoples' science. Thus, it presents an alternative notion that goes beyond the
boundaries of cold, hard facts of science and instead projects it in a different light, such as a manifestation of
shared experience forging solidarity over communities.
Science as a social endeavor means the application of science to figuring out how the world works/exists/originated
etc. Another dimension of Science as a social endeavor is to solve various problems, satisfy various needs and
sustainable development of society with the help of scientific knowledge.
Science and Results
For the most part, people who do not understand science are won over when the discipline is able to produce
results. Similar to when Jesus performed miracles and garnered followers, people are sold over the capacity of
science to do stuff they cannot fully comprehend. In this particular argument, however, science is not the only
discipline which is able to produce results--religion, luck, and human randomness are some of its
contemporaries in the field. For some communities without access to science, they can turn to divination and
superstition and still get the same results. Science is not entirely foolproof, such that it is correct 100% of the
time. Weather reports, for one, illustrate fallibility and limitations of their scope, as well as their inability to
predict disasters. The best that can be done during an upcoming disaster is to reinforce materials to be more
calamity proof and restore the area upon impact. It can be then concluded that science does not monopolize
the claim for definite results.