Bonus Plan Hypothesis

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 2

BONUS PLAN HYPOTHESIS DEBT AGREEMENT HYPOTHESIS POLITICAL COST HYPOTHESIS

All else equal, managers of firms with bonus For companies that would violate the debt agreement, Companies that have high profitability tend to shift
plans are more likely to choose accounting the manager would have the possibility to choose their income from this period to the coming periods to
policies that shift reported earnings from accounting procedures that shift future income to the avoid political cost.
future periods to the current periods current period as to increase net income and avoid
technical errors.
Manager of firms: use accounting method that • Sweeney (1994) found that agreements were most • Jones (1991) found that the company reduced the
increase current period income often violated had to do with maintaining working net income it reported during investigation of
capital and shareholder equity, while debt to equity import relief/exemption
ratios and interest coverage ratios were not
violated too often
METHODS OF REWARD: • Debt agreement contain. Covenants • Some firms are expose to media due to their size,
• Fixed basis : salary independent of • Failing to meet covenants lead to technical default, fame , industry
performance which is costly • Other firm may attract attention irregularly due to
• Salary plus remuneration (bonus scheme) • Thus, manager will. Adopt accounting policies which sudden report huge profits
increase current income to reduce the risk of • Such firms are subject to risk that regulators will
technical default impose windfall tax upon them , or investigate if the
market is truly competitive
• These firms try to hide /avoid from reporting their
high profits
REMUNERATION: Managers with high debt to equity ratio will: Managers will :
• EPS (profit) • Choose less conservative accounting policies • Choose more conservative accounting policies
• Sales of firm • Oppose new standards which restrict their ability to • Less likely to oppose income-reducing accounting
• Return on asset do this standards
• If their pay depends upon reported
earnings then they will report the highest
earnings possible.
• Do it by adopting accounting policies which
increase current earnings
• Eventhough accruals reverse, leading to
reduced future earnings and bonus, PV of
future bonus stream is increased by
shifting income forwards
• Managers of firm with bonus plans:
- choose less conservative and less volatile
accounting policies
-oppose new accounting standards that
reduce net income
- object to volatily- increasing accounting
standards
• Healy research (1985) found that company
managers who have bonus plans will
systematically adopt accrual policies to
maximise their bonus.

EBIT
- Important in stock market
- If use profit after tax and interest, it may not really comparable as different company has different capital structure

Covenant Ratio
- Need to be positive? Use to figure out the capability of firm to pay its debt

If the remuneration committee had used Operating Profit instead of underlying EBIT , the CEO would not meet the minimum performance

You might also like

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy