NMCG
NMCG
NMCG
April 2020
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY……………………………………………………………………..……………….………………………………..1
1. INTRODUCTION………………………………………………………………………………………………………..…….……1-1
1.1. NAMAMI GANGE PROGRAMME……………………………………………………………………….……………………..…….……1-2
1.2. STRUCTURE OF THE REPORT………………………………………….……………………………………….………………..…….……1-3
2. PROJECT DESCRIPTION………………………………………………………………………………….…..…….……………2-1
2.1. ABOUT THE CITY…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..2-1
2.2. EXISTING SCENARIO OF SEWERAGE FACILITIES IN AGRA CITY……………………………………………………………….2-2
2.2.1. Overview of Sewerage Zones of Agra ............................................................................................................ 2-2
2.2.2. Zone Wise Population projections for Agra City ............................................................................................. 2-4
2.3. EXISTING SEWERAGE FACILITY IN THE PROJECT CITY……………………………………………….………………..…….……2-5
2.4. NECESSITY OF THIS PROJECT……………………………………………………………………..………….…………………..…….……2-7
2.5. PROPOSED PROJECT ACTIVITIES………………………………………………………………………………………………..…….……2-8
2.5.1. Agra Sewerage Scheme (I&D Works) ............................................................................................................. 2-8
2.6. DISPOSAL OF TREATED EFFLUENT……………….…………………………………………………………………..………………….2-11
2.7. DISPOSAL OF SLUDGE…………………………………………………………………………….………………………..…………..…….2-12
2.8. BIO ENERGY………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..……………….……..2-13
2.9. IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE…………………………………………………………………………………….……………….………2-13
2.10. AGENCY RESPONSIBLE FOR EXECUTION OF O&M WORK……………………………………………….…………………….2-13
2.11. TOTAL COST………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….…………….2-13
3. APPROACH AND METHODOLOGY………………………………………………………………………….……………….3-1
3.1. METHODOLOGY……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………3-1
3.1.1. Review of available documents and data collation..................................................................................... …3-1
3.1.2. Describing the sub-project activities ............................................................................................................ ..3-2
3.1.3. Field survey and discussion with the key stakeholders .................................................................................. 3-2
3.1.4. Discussions with Community People .............................................................................................................. 3-2
3.1.5. Describing baseline environmental and social profile of project area ........................................................... 3-2
3.1.6. Screening Activities ........................................................................................................................................ 3-2
3.1.7. Identification and assessment of impacts ...................................................................................................... 3-2
3.1.8. Developing Management Action Plan............................................................................................................ 3-3
3.2. SCOPE OF WORK……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..……………3-3
4. LEGAL POLICY & FRAMEWORK……………………………………………………………………………………….……..4-1
4.1. APPLICABLE ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS AND REGULATION………………………………………………………………….…..4-1
4.2. APPLICABLE SAFEGUARD POLICIES OF WORLD BANK……………………………………………………………………….…..4-3
4.3. APPLICABLE LAWS AND REGULATIONS – SOCIAL…………………………………………………………………………………..4-4
4.3.1. Uttar Pradesh Negotiation (Mutual Consent) Policy, 2015 ............................................................................ 4-4
rd
4.3.2. 73 Constitution Amendment Act, 1992 ........................................................................................................ 4-5
4.3.3. Other legislations applicable to construction activities ................................................................................. 4-5
5. ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL PROFILE OF PROJECT AREAS………………………………………………….5-1
5.1. ENVIRONMENTAL PROFILE…………………………………………………………………………………………………………..……….5-1
5.1.1. Physiography & Soil........................................................................................................................................ 5-1
5.1.2. Seismicity........................................................................................................................................................ 5-3
5.1.3. Air environment ............................................................................................................................................. 5-4
5.1.1 Noise Environment ......................................................................................................................................... 5-5
5.1.4. Water environment ........................................................................................................................................ 5-7
5.1.5. Biological environment ................................................................................................................................ 5-13
5.1.6. Other Eco-Sensitive area within 10 km boundary from projects site ........................................................... 5-15
5.1.7. Land use profile of the sub project locations ................................................................................................ 5-16
LIST OF TABLES
TABLE 2-1 SEWERAGE ZONE WISE ESTIMATED POPULATION OF AGRA ....................................................................................... 2-4
TABLE 2-2 OVERVIEW OF SEWAGE DISPOSAL SYSTEM OF AGRA ................................................................................................. 2-5
TABLE 2-3: PROPOSED DECENTRALIZED STPS OF TOTAL 11.6 MLD .............................................................................................. 2-9
TABLE 2-4: PROPOSED CENTRALIZED STPS OF TOTAL 166 MLD ................................................................................................... 2-9
TABLE 2-5 : CHARACTERISTICS OF TREATED EFFLUENT .............................................................................................................. 2-11
LIST OF FIGURES
FIGURE 2-1: LOCATION OF AGRA IN INDIA FIGURE 2-2: REGIONAL SETTING OF AGRA CITY .................................................... 2-1
FIGURE 2-3: AGRA MUNICIPAL: SEWERAGE ZONES ..................................................................................................................... 2-4
FIGURE 2-4: EXISTING SEWERAGE FACILITIES OF AGRA ............................................................................................................... 2-7
FIGURE 2-5: POPULATION GROWTH TREND OF AGRA ................................................................................................................. 2-8
FIGURE 2-6: PROPOSED LOCATIONS OF DECENTRALIZED AND CENTRALIZED SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANTS ............................ 2-10
FIGURE 2-7: PROPOSED DRAIN TO TAP FOR DSTP @ KK MANDIR ............................................................................................. 2-10
FIGURE 2-8: CHOKED DRAIN TO TAP FOR DSTP @ ARTONI ....................................................................................................... 2-10
FIGURE 2-9: CHOKED DRAIN TO TAP FOR DSTP @ KAMAYANI HOSPITAL ................................................................................. 2-10
FIGURE 2-10: PROPOSED DRAIN TO TAP FOR DSTP @ MAU NALA ............................................................................................ 2-10
FIGURE 2-11: PROPOSED DRAIN TO TAP FOR DSTP @ BAIPUR .................................................................................................. 2-10
FIGURE 2-12: PROPOSED AREA FOR MPS @ KHAIRATI TOLA ..................................................................................................... 2-10
FIGURE 3-1: FLOWCHART DESCRIBING STEPS ADOPTED FOR ESDDR PREPARATION .................................................................... 3-1
FIGURE 5-1: SOIL SAMPLE COLLECTION- S1 ................................................................................................................................. 5-2
FIGURE 5-2: SOIL SAMPLE COLLECTION- S2 ................................................................................................................................. 5-2
FIGURE 5-3: SEISMIC MAP OF STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH ........................................................................................................... 5-3
FIGURE 5-4: LAST FIVE YEAR RAINFALL RECORD OF AGRA........................................................................................................... 5-4
FIGURE 5-5: LEVEL OF AIR QUALITY IN AGRA CITY (SOURCE : SPCB 2019) .................................................................................... 5-4
FIGURE 5-6: SAMPLING AT DHANDUPURA CSTP LOCATION ........................................................................................................ 5-6
FIGURE 5-7: SAMPLING AT ARTONI DSTP LOCATION................................................................................................................... 5-6
FIGURE 5-8: SAMPLING LOCATION AT REPRESENTING UPSTREAM AND DOWNSTREAM OF THE CITY ......................................... 5-7
FIGURE 5-9- YAMUNA RIVER BASIN MAP.................................................................................................................................... 5-7
FIGURE 5-10: COMPARATIVE RECORD OF WATER QUALITY OF YEAR 2017 - 2018 ....................................................................... 5-8
FIGURE 5-11: COMPARATIVE RECORD OF WATER QUALITY OF YEAR 2019 .................................................................................. 5-8
FIGURE 5-12: WATER SAMPLE COLLECTION AT DHANDUPURA CSTP LOCATION ........................................................................ 5-13
FIGURE 5-13: WATER SAMPLE COLLECTION AT ARTONI DSTP LOCATION .................................................................................. 5-13
FIGURE 5-14: THE PHOTOGRAPHS OF SITE TAKEN DURING SITE VISIT ....................................................................................... 5-14
FIGURE 5-15: THE PHOTOGRAPHS OF SITE TAKEN DURING SITE VISIT AT DHANDUPURA STP.................................................... 5-14
FIGURE 5-16: ECO SENSITIVE BOUNDARY AND SUR SAROVAR BIRD SANCTUARY ...................................................................... 5-15
FIGURE 5-17: SENSITIVE PROJECT FEATURE WITHIN 10 KM BUFFER AREA OF THE PROJECT SITE ............................................... 5-19
FIGURE 5-18: POPULATION DISTRIBUTION AGRA CITY .............................................................................................................. 5-20
FIGURE 5-19:LITERACY RATE ..................................................................................................................................................... 5-21
FIGURE 5-20:WORKER DISTRIBUTION AND CATEGORY ............................................................................................................. 5-21
Project Description
3. Agra, a historic town is situated in the Indo-Gangetic plain of India. The town is geographically
located between latitude 27°11'18.40"N and longitude78° 0'31.05"E in State of Uttar Pradesh. The city of
ancient culture and empire of various historic events is located at distance of about 200 km from New
Delhi, the capital of India. The city of Agra is built along the river bank of Yamuna at an average elevation
of 171 meter above the mean sea level. The total area of the town is 4027 sq. km. having total population
of 15.85 lakhs.
4. River Yamuna forms the major drainage of the city and it flows from North to South-East of the
city. The river enters the city on its northern boundary and takes a U-shape while flowing through the heart
of the city.
5. As per the Environmental and Social Management Framework (NGRBA, 2020)1, the
implementation of such river pollution mitigation projects under the NGRBP is anticipated to encounter a
11
For the Environmental and Social Management Framework (ESMF) document please refer
https://nmcg.nic.in/writereaddata/fileupload/7_Environmental%20and%20Social%20Management%20Framework.pdf
1.1.
different sections of existing sewerage network are partially and/or fully chocked, carries reduced flow and
the STPs are not receiving designed flow. The untreated sewerage disposal is a critical area; most of the
waste water of town and from un-sewered areas is discharged directly into the drains creating unhygienic
environment.
10 1.5 MLD STP for Moti Mahal (I-VIII) & Indira Memorial Bridge Drains
10. The implementation of all new sewerage infrastructure work such as I&D of 23 Drain, SPS, MPS,
rising main, centralized and decentralized STPs are proposed under Namami Gange Progrmme. The
remaining provisions such as I&D work 37 Nala (6.38 MLD discharge) & O&M of existing STPs, MPS are
planned under State Fund Scheme and has been awarded to M/s VA Tech Wabag, Chennai for 10 years.
Project Screening
12. The project screening was carried out to understand the nature, scale and magnitude of
environmental and social impact associated with the project. The screening activity was conducted as per
the guidelines provided in Environmental and Social Management Framework of NGRBA (2011 revised in
March 2020) and on the secondary data analysis, field assessments and stakeholder
interactions/consultations. The E&S Screening was carried out based on ESMF guideline, which indicates
that the project falls in ‘high impact’ category. Please refer Annexure 1 of this report. Based on the initial
Environmental screening, Agra Sewerage Project has been rated under High risk zone because of following
reasons:
The project area falls in the Taj Trapezium which is Declared Ecologically Sensitive Areas (ESAs) under "The
Environment (Protection) Act (EPA), 1986";
it involve felling of 704 number of trees in notified ESAs area and also involve diversion of 0.97 ha of forest land
which are notified forest under " The India Forest Act-1927". Please refer Section 6.1.1 (Para No. 136) of the
Report.
2 For the Environmental and Social Management Framework (ESMF) document please refer
https://nmcg.nic.in/writereaddata/fileupload/7_Environmental%20and%20Social%20Management%20Framework.pdf
The proposed STP and DSTP under the project1.1. in Agra city is falling under TTZ zone. However, eco-
friendly projects (like STP etc.) are allowed with permission from State pollution control board as per
latest Supreme Court Order dated 6th December 2019 (Annexure 3).
About 0.97 hectare of forest land is required for 8 DSTPs in different area of the city (northern and
eastern zone of sewerage plan of Agra), for which prior permission under “The Forest (Conservation)
Act, 1980 are required for diversion of forest area for installation of DSTP from the Regional Office of
MoEF&CC, Lucknow.
The land identified for establishment of 100 MLD STP Dhandupura is available within existing STP.
This land has good canopy cover, which would involve felling of approximately 704 trees under TTZ
regulated area. Tree felling permission would be required from the TTZ regulatory authority to use
the existing land available within the existing STP.
As an option to avoid felling of 704 tree within the TTZ, YPCU has mulled over another private land
just adjacent to existing STP. In case of delay happens in the TTZ approval from Supreme Court for
tree felling, the private land purchase will be preferred, as per UP Negotiation (Mutual Consent)
Policy, 2015.
The screening checklist of project planning and sites reiterates that the project will not adversely
affect the livelihood, but prior permissions in case of forest land, TTZ, revenue department will be
required for the project STPs.
The project will not have any adverse impact on the tribal population.
The likely anticipated impacts on environment would be overcome by suggesting mitigation
measures and proposing project specific environmental & social management plan. Appropriate
Sludge Management Plan shall be prepared by the Concessionaire. Suitable site should also be
identified by the Concessionaire for the safe disposal of sludge generated at the STP. The
Concessionaire shall also need to identify specific site for intermittent storage of waste from SPS and
STP sites.
The project will not have any adverse impact on vulnerable and Scheduled Caste community for
laying mains. Since all the DSTPs are proposed in the forest land, no diversion structure is required.
Most of the project site is at a distance from the settlement. As per the consultations conducted, the
participants expressed their relief and satisfaction that the open drains will be channelized and
treated.
Cost Estimate
CANADA | INDIA| ASIA | AFRICA | MIDDLE EAST Page | E -6
Final Report
Environmental and Social Due Diligence Report (ESDDR) for Interception
& Diversion with Rehabilitation of sewerage scheme at Agra
Implementation Schedule
20. It is anticipated that entire work will be completed within 2 years from the date of commencement
of work.
1. River Ganga, along with her many tributaries, has been the source of physical and spiritual
sustenance of Indian civilization for millennia, and consequently, her well-being is of prime national
concern. It is the largest river basin in India in terms of catchment area and constitutes almost 26
percent of the country’s land mass, near about 30 percent of country’s water resources and supports
more than 40 percent of country’s population3. The delta of the Ganga basin is one of the largest in the
world, which is known by Sundarbans. It is the 20th longest river in Asia. Drainage of the River traverses
through 11 States of the country (Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Bihar, West Bengal,
Uttarakhand, Jharkhand, Haryana, Chhattisgarh, Himachal Pradesh and Delhi), where largely covered
States are Uttar Pradesh (28.02 %), Bihar (10.86%), West Bengal (8.3%), Uttarakhand (6.15%) and
Jharkhand (5.85%). In addition to the physical resource value, the economic, environmental and cultural
value of river Ganga is enormous in India. The Ganga also serves as one of India’s holiest rivers whose
cultural and spiritual significance is widely known.
2. Despite this iconic status and religious heritage, the Ganga River today is facing formidable
pollution pressures, along with the attendant threats to its biodiversity and environmental
sustainability. An ever-growing population, together with inadequately planned urbanization and
industrialization, has affected the quality of the river’s water. Today, the Ganga’s waters are sullied by
the incessant outpouring of sewage, as well as by the large volumes of solid and industrial waste that
are churned out by human and economic activity along the river’s banks. According to the reports, the
main causes of extreme pollution pressures in river Ganga includes (i) inadequacy of municipal waste
water infrastructure and services, (ii) inadequacy of industrial effluent management, (iii) solid waste and
non-point pollution sources, and (iv) inadequate in-stream flows.
3. The World Bank recognizes that the pollution in River Ganga is primarily a result of inadequate
infrastructure, the weak capacity of local water and wastewater utilities in the basin, and the poor state
of environmental monitoring and regulation. The Government of India (GoI) has received loan
assistance from the World Bank for the Mission Clean Ganga related activities under NGRBA Program
(later which is included as one of the component of the Namami Gange Programme) at the level of
institutional development, operational and implementation support and in four sectors, namely,
wastewater collection and treatment, industrial pollution control, solid waste management and
riverfront development.
4. At the Central level, the National Mission for Clean Ganga (NMCG) registered as a society on
th
12 August 2011 under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, was constituted as an authority to ensure
implementation of Namami Gange Programme. At State level, State Mission for Clean Ganga (SMCGs)
were set-up as registered societies in the respective states, namely Uttarakhand, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar
and West Bengal while Jharkhand has a dedicated nodal cell within the Department of Urban
Development was set up.
3
Source: Environmental and Social Management Framework (ESMF) for the Namami Ganga Programme, Ministry of Water
Resources, River Development & Ganga Rejuvenation, Government of India,2011 (revised in March 2020).
5. NMCG acted as implementation arm 1.1. of National Ganga River Basin Authority (NGRBA) which
was constituted under the provisions of the Environment (Protection) Act (EPA), 1986. NGRBA has since
been dissolved with effect from the 07th October 2016, consequent to the constitution of National
Council for Rejuvenation, Protection and Management of River Ganga (referred as National Ganga
Council) vide Notification No. S.O. 3187(E), dated 07th October 2016 under EPA 1986 and subsequent
amendments vide Notification No. S.O. 1793(E), dated the 21st May, 2019 and Notification No. S.O.
3163(E), dated 02nd September, 2019.
6. The current focus of World Bank funded National Ganga River Basin Projects (NGRBP) under
National Mission for Clean Ganga (NMCG) is on six participating States namely Uttarakhand, Uttar
Pradesh, Bihar, Jharkhand, West Bengal and Madhya Pradesh. The National Mission for Clean Ganga
(NMCG), the implementing wing of Namami Gange Programme has appointed LEA Associates South Asia
Private Limited, New Delhi, as a Consulting agency for the preparation of Environmental and Social Due
Diligence Report (ESDDR) for “Interception, Diversion & Sewerage System Work In Agra in the state of
Uttar Pradesh, under National Mission for Clean Ganga (NMCG), following the principles of ESMF of
NGRBA.
8. The Namami Gange Programme will be implemented in the Ganga Basin in India. The overall
technical assistance and program development under the proposed project will focus on the entire
Ganga Basin; however specific sub-project investments under this project will focus on critical stretches
of six basin states of Uttarakhand, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Jharkhand, West Bengal and Madhya Pradesh in
India.
9. A comprehensive, basin-level, and multi-sectoral approach has been adopted, with support for
investments in waste water, solid waste and river front management, industrial effluent management,
address non-point source of pollution and maintaining ecological flows and assessment of biodiversity
Figure 2-1: location of Agra in India Figure 2-2: Regional Setting of Agra City
1.1.
North Zone
17. This zone lies to the north of CIS area above NH-2 bypass. At present water from Burhi ka Nagla
nala is tapped & diverted by MPS to 2.25 MLD STP at Buri ka Nagla. Manoharpur , Anurag nagar, Amar
Vihar-I,II drains are tapped and diverted to 14 MLD STP at Jaganpur.
West Zone
18. This zone lies on the west of CIS area, surrounded by central railway line and Fatehpur Sikri
railway line. Almost all water comes to central zone by nala and existing Mantola trunk sewer. This zone
has two IPS, one MPS and two STP’s viz. 40 MLD at Bichpuri&36 MLD STP at Sadarban. 40 MLD STP is
maintained by U.P. Jal Nigam while 36 MLD STP is maintained by ADA.
Central Zone
19. This zone houses main city area of CIS Zone. It is highly dense & fully urbanized. Many areas are
saturated in development. This zone is sewered and includes catchments of IPS Rajwah, IPS Balkeshwar,
Cantonment Zone
23. This Zone has only one catchment and lies on the lower side of central zone with Tajganj Zone
on the Eastern side. At present no sewers or I&D works exist in this zone; zone drains to Mantolanala
and Dholikar sewer and finally to MPS at Khairati Tola and then to STP at Dhandupura.
Tajganj Zone
24. This area covers southeast part of CIS Zone surrounding the historical monuments Taj Mahal.
Many development works are under taken in this zone under Taj Trapezium Zone (TTZ) program.
Presently there is no sewerage system in this zone and flows of this zone are drained by Taj East nala
and Taj West nala to Yamuna River. Part of the flow reaches MPS at Khairati Tola. But under TTZ
scheme, sewers are being laid and wastewater flow is taken care of by four catchments, three IPSs and
one MPS. Whole of the flow is taken care of by the TTZ scheme and is proposed to be taken to 78 MLD
STP at Dhandupura.
South Zone I
25. This Zone covers the urban settlement to the south-west of CIS area surrounded by central
railway line & Fatehpur Sikri railway line and includes the area of Shahganj, airport, surrounding area of
airport etc. and substantial area of more recent development. This zone also includes two census towns
named Azizpur & Dhandauli having high density. At present no sewer system exists in this zone &
wastewater is disposed to nala, which mostly reach to Mantolanala. But water from villages reaches
Khari River.
South Zone II
26. This zone lies south of CIS area outside of Agra Nagar Nigam boundary. This zone comprises
mostly of villages coming in the projected horizons. At present no sewer system exists in this zone &
partly flow reaches central zone & partly Khari River.
27. This zone is divided by two catchments (Nainakijat &Fatehabad). The area is currently
undeveloped but is expected to develop steadily. There are no sewers in this zone.
SPS
3 Bhairon
BurhiNag Taal
Locations Waterworks Peelakhar Dhandhupura
la Semri
KhairatiTola
Nos. 3 7 4 4 - - 1 - 7 26
STPs 2 1 2 1 1 2 9
Peelakhar
Burhi
4 WSP Devri
Nagla& Dhandhupura Dhandhupura Sadarba
Locations & - - Road
Jaganpur old UASB+EAS New USAB n SBR
KalindiVihar USAB
WSP
USAB
MLD 16.25 78 14.5 24 12 76 220.75
Source: DPR Agra Sewerage Scheme (I&D Works)-Dec 2019
Drains: There are total 90 drains in Agra comprising of discharge of 286.85 MLD. Out of which
29 drains are partially intercepted and 61 drains are untapped.
4
Note: A project costing Rs. 353.56 Cr. has been approved under AMRUT Programme in Western Zone of sewer network of
length 251 Kms.Work is under progress and is likely to be completed by June 2021.
1.1.
There are total 90 surface drains having cumulative discharge of 286.64 MLD in Agra, which are
carrying the waste water load and falling in Yamuna River. Out of these 90 drains-
29 drains having cumulative discharge of 269 MLD have been tapped under previous
schemes.
Remaining 61 drains having cumulative discharge of approximately 18 MLD are untapped
and are falling into River Yamuna with flows ranging between 0.001 MLD to 1.91 MLD.
Of total 61 drains, 38 drains having total capacity of 6.40 work has been tendered out under
state fund.
Remaining 23 drains having total discharge of 11.6 are proposed to be tapped and treat
under the present project of I&D Sewerage scheme of Agra.
Sewer Network (Km): A total of 572.34 km Sewer lines are laid in different Sewerage Zone,
Cantonment and South Zone 1 is not have sewer line underlaid.
SPS: At present the existing wastewater system consists of 26 Sewage pumping Stations out of
which two sewage pumping station are constructed by UP Avas& Vikas Parishad for its colonies.
Out of total Sewerage zone, Cantonment area, South Zone 1 and South Zone III three has not
any SPS.
STPs: Except, cantonment Area, South Zone I & III, the other sewerage zones has STP. The Total
existing STP are 9 nos. having total capacity of 220.75 MLD. Presently functioning of all 9 STPs
are in good condition. The effluent discharge quality and the other efficiency are presented in
Annexure 2. O&M has been awarded to M/s VA Tech Wabag, Chennai for 10 years by SMCG
vide letter no. 067/358/SMCG-UP/(PC) dated 14.06.2019.
Water Supply: Surface water from river Yamuna is the only source of water supply for Agra city.
As per available information from UP Jal Nigam, two water treatment plants (WTPs) supplies
drinking water to the consumers of Agra city. Both the treatment plants are surface water
treatment plants. The source of water supply in Agra is met by surface water (280 MLD) and
tube wells (9MLD). The rate of water supply in Agra is taken 150 lpcd as per GOI guideline for
design of Sewerage facility Project. Recommended rate of water supply as per CPHEEO Manual
on water supply is 150 lpcd at consumer end + unaccounted for water (15%). There is an
extreme shortage of water in the river Yamuna during summer5.
5
Government of India requested Japan Bank for International Co-operation for an Official Development Assistance loan for the
Agra Water Supply (Ganga Jal) Project, which aims at improving living conditions by providing reliable water supply through
construction of water supply system from Palra fall of Upper Ganga Canal to Agra and Mathura/Vrindavan. Under this project it
is proposed to bring 350 MLD of water to Agra. Presently the work on the said project is in progress which is likely to be
completed by the mid of year 2020 , after the completion of Ganga Jalproject; demand of water for Agra town shall be fulfilled
1.1.
1.1.
32. Likewise, the effluents of industries, effluent of different slaughter houses are also discharged
directly into the drains without any treatment. In order to reduce pollution load of major drains of
Agra, the existing sewerage network necessities renovation and strengthening, so that the wastewater
would be treated before its discharge to River Yamuna, which finally joins with the Ganga River at
downstream near Prayagraj district of Uttar Pradesh.
10 1.5 MLD STP for Moti Mahal (I-VIII) & Indira Memorial Bridge Drains
38. CSTP of total 166 MLD are proposed to cater the overflow of the existing STPs. CSTPs are
considered the population projected till year 2035 and thereof discharge capacity of drain too,
therefore the capacity of CSTP has been upgraded , the details of STP capacity estimations has been
provided in Annexure 11.
Table 2-4: Proposed Centralized STPs of total 166 MLD
Sl.no. Centralised Treatment Plant Sewerage Zone
1 35 MLD Biological Nutrient Removal technology based STP at Peelakhar Eastern Zone
2 31 MLD Biological Nutrient Removal technology based STP at Jaganpur Northern Zone
3 100 MLD Biological Nutrient Removal technology based STP at Dhandupura Central Zone
1.1.
Figure 2-6: Proposed Locations of Decentralized and Centralized Sewage Treatment Plants under the Project
Figure 2-7: Proposed Drain to Tap for Figure 2-8: Choked Drain to Tap Figure 2-9: Choked Drain to Tap
DSTP @ KK Mandir for DSTP @ Artoni for DSTP @ Kamayani Hospital
Figure 2-10: Proposed Drain to Tap for Figure 2-11: Proposed Drain to Figure 2-12: Proposed area for
DSTP @ Mau Nala Tap for DSTP @ Baipur MPS @ Khairati Tola
39. The implementation of all new sewerage infrastructure work such as I&D of 23 Drain, SPS, MPS,
Rising main, Centralized and Decentralized STPs are proposed under Namami Gange Progrmme. The
remaining provisions such as I&D work 37 Nala (6.38 MLD discharge) & O&M of existing STPs, MPS are
planned under State Fund scheme and has been awarded to M/s VA Tech Wabag, Chennai for 10 years.
Refer Annexure 13 for drawing of MPS & I&D provisions.
Table1.1.
2-6: Project Cost
AGRA SEWERAGE SCHEME (I&D WORKS) Under NATIONAL MISSION FOR CLEAN GANGA (NMCG) REVISED
PROJECT COST ESTIMATE (Rates as per AA&ES)
Cost as per
S. N0. Items Quantity
Revised DPR
1 2 3 4
A Items on which centage is admissible
1 Interception of drains
Interception of new drains 22 nos. 730.48
2 Intercepting Sewers
By open trench method 1950 m 559.00
By trenchless method 600 m 800.00
Sub Total Sewers 1950 m 1359.00
3 Sewage Pumping Stations (SPS)
New MPS 3 nos. 4061.14
Lift Station (As per estimated cost) 01 no 58.8
Sub Total SPS/Lift Station 4119.94
4 Rising mains 9350 m 1585.00
5 Sewage Treatment Plants
Decentralized STPs 11.6 Mld, 10 nos. 2450.10
Centralized STPs 166 Mld, 3 nos. 20000.00
Online monitoring / Local Control Station
(LCS) / Master Control Station (MCS) of 5 nos. 644.91
STPs and D -STPs
Sub Total STPs 23095.01
Treated effluent disposal (As per
1560 m 882.32
estimated cost)
Sub Total (A) Basic Capital Cost 31771.75
B Centage
Cost of project preparation @ 4% as per
1270.87
NGRBA guidelines (maximum)
Cost of project supervision @ 4% as per
1270.87
NGRBA guidelines (maximum)
Sub Total B 2541.74
C GST @ 12% 3812.61
D Items on which no centage is admissible
st
O&M cost for 1 15 years 16079.21
(Excluding electricity & Fuel)
GST on O&M @12% 1929.51
Power connection 523.49
GST on power connection @18% 94.23
Land acquisition 0.00
Environmental Sanitation and
317.72
Management Plan (ESAMP)
Communication & Public Outreach 158.86
6For the Environmental and Social Management Framework (ESMF) document please refer
https://nmcg.nic.in/writereaddata/fileupload/7_Environmental%20and%20Social%20Management%20Framework.pdf
1.1.
Project Report (DPR), consultation with stake-holders and other secondary sources including the
water/air/noise monitoring data of UP Pollution Control Board, UP Jal Nigam and from the reports of tests
conducted at site.
3.1.2. Describing the sub-project activities
58. With the help of information and data received mainly from the Detailed Project Report (DPR) and
consultations with stakeholders, a brief description and analysis of the project activities has been
established. Based on initial understanding, the list of required information has been drafted before
conducting the field survey.
3.1.3. Field survey and discussion with the key stakeholders
59. The team conducted field surveys and transect walks of the project area to develop an
understanding of the proposed project. The key stakeholders including the UP Jal Nigam, Agra were
interacted (both formally and informally) during the field visits while preparing the ESDDR. Most of the
associated government departments were visited to collect the relevant data and their feedback on the
proposed project activities. Also they were asked about the mitigation plans they have adopted or are
planning to adopt, suggestions for improvement and any public grievances. Surveys were conducted along
the path of proposed project sites.
3.1.4. Discussions with Community People
60. With the help of structured questionnaires, local people were interviewed in groups. A wide range
of potentially project affected people and people from different sections of the local community (both men
and women) including residents of households, residents of temporary settlements, shop keepers, street
vendors, etc. were interviewed in and around the project area. The interviewees were asked about their
awareness of the project, their response to it and how the proposed project is affecting them (during
construction phase) and how it will affect them (after completion phase).
3.1.5. Describing baseline environmental and social profile of project area
61. With the help of secondary information/data received from the available documents and from the
discussions/interactions with key stakeholders and host population, a brief description of the baseline
environmental and social profile of the project area has been established.
3.1.6. Screening Activities
62. The project screening has also been carried out to understand the nature, scale and magnitude of
potential environmental and social impacts associated with the proposed project. The screening activities
have been conducted as per the guidelines provided in Environmental and Social Management Framework
of NGRBA (NGRBA, March 2020) and on the basis of secondary data analysis, field assessments and
stakeholder interactions/consultations.
3.1.7. Identification and assessment of impacts
63. Based on the analysis of the data collected from field surveys, stakeholder interactions/
consultations and secondary sources, issues related to the environmental and social sectors were
identified. The impacts so identified were compared with the existing baseline environmental and social
condition of the study region. The impacts of the activities are mostly positive with few adverse impacts.
1.1.
3.1.8. Developing Management Action Plan
64. Based on the identified and assessed potential environmental and social impacts, an appropriate
mitigation / management action plan has been developed recommending suitable measures needed to
prevent, minimize, mitigate, or compensate for adverse impacts (if any) and to improve the environmental
and social performance. The mitigation plans is suggested for different stages of the project, as applicable:
designing phase, construction phase and, operation and maintenance phase.
71. This section briefly describes the baseline environmental and social profile of the study area. Agra
city is situated on the western bank of river Yamuna in the State of Uttar Pradesh and can be accessed by
the National Highway (NH- 2) and is about 200 kms. from Delhi. Agra is geographically located at 27°12'
North latitude and 78°12' East longitude. It has an extremely strategic location at the confluence of three
distinct geo-physical regions namely the plains of Uttar Pradesh, the plateau of Madhya Pradesh and the
desert of Rajasthan. The city also falls within the centre of the four culture rich areas of Braj, Bundelkhand,
Rajputana and western UP.
Table 5-2 : Soil Quality Sampling Results of proposed DSTP, CSTP locations
S. No. Parameters Units Results Results Test Method
Physical Characteristics S1 S2
1 Colour Brown Brown STRL/STP/SOIL/01
2 Textural class Sandy Clay Sandy Clay IS27720 (P-4), 1985
3 Bulk Density gm/cm3 1.27
Loam 1.22
Loam IS 14765:
(Reaff: 2000,
2015) RA
4 Water Holding Capacity % 48.6 46.6 STRL/STP/SOIL/01
2010
Particle Size
7 Sand
Distribution % 46.5 49.8 IS27720 (P-4), 1985
8 Slit % 21.2 20.2 IS27720 (P-4),
(Reaff: 2015)1985
9 Clay % 32.3 30 IS27720 (P-4),
(Reaff: 2015)1985
Chemical Characteristics (Reaff: 2015)
10 pH (1:2 Suspension) - 7.98 8.14 IS: 2720 (part-26),1987
11 Electrical Conductivity µmhos/cm 640 122.6 IS: 14767(2000),
(Reaff:2011) RA
12 Organic Matter
(1:2) %W/W 1.45 1.12 STRL/STP/SOIL/01
2016
13 Exchangeable Calcium mg/kg 4343.4 2876.5 IS 2720 (Part 24): 1976,
14 Exchangeable mg/kg 1434.6 1434.2 IS 2720 RA
(Part 24): 1976,
2010
15 Copper
Magnesium mg/kg 5.4 6.1 IS 2720(Part-27):
RA 2010 1977,
16 Nickel mg/kg 3.6 5.6 IS 2720(Part-27): 1977,
17 Chromium mg/kg 21.2 23.2 IS 2720(Part-27): 1977,
18 Iron mg/kg 3454.6 2878.5 IS 2720(Part-27): 1977,
19 Lead mg/kg 7.2 7.6 IS 2720(Part-27): 1977,
20 Sulphate mg/kg 434.3 378.6 IS 2720(Part-27): 1977,
Figure 5-1: Soil Sample collection- S1 Figure 5-2: Soil Sample collection- S2
7
EPA & Oklahoma corporation commission common ranges of heavy metals in soil (Fe- 7,000- 550,000;Pb 2-200;Cu 2-200;Cr1-
3000 ;Ni 5-500 mg/l)
Agra
8
http://www.censusindia.gov.in/2011census/dchb/DCHB_A/09/0915_PART_A_DCHB_AGRA.pdf
1.1.
September). The concessionaire shall avoid construction works close to the streams or water bodies during
monsoon.
Rainfall data of Agra for the year (2014-2018)
400 360.6
350
300
RAINFALL IN MM
250 2014
187.5
200 2015
137.7
150 2016
100 2017
52.9 43.7
50 20.2 2018
1 1.3 0 1.8 0.1 1.5
0
JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC
Figure 5-5: Level of Air quality in Agra City (source : SPCB 2019)
1 Particulate Matter, µg/ 82.6 92.1 87.1 89.6 100 IS:5182 (P-
2 Particulate Matter, µg/ 53.2 52.8 54.4 54.3 60 SOP1/STRL/
PM 10 m3 23 ) : 2006
3 Sulphur
PM 2.5 Dioxide ( µg/
m3 13.6 21.9 17.8 14.1 80 IS:5182
Ambient(P-2
4 Carbon
as SO2) Monoxide µg/
m3 784.2 781.2 760.4 823.6 4000 IS:5182
) : 2006 (P-
(as CO)04(1hourly) Air/Gravime
10 ) :
m3
5 Oxide of Nitrogen ( µg/ 25.9 18.4 32.7 25.8 80 199,RA-
IS:5182
tric (P-6
Method
as NO2) 2003
m3 ) : 2006
Figure 5-6: Sampling at Dhandupura CSTP Location Figure 5-7: Sampling at Artoni DSTP Location
1.1.
Location at Atroni
DSTP for ambient
Air, Water Soil &
Noise
Agra City
Agra Municipal Corporation
Location at
Dhandupura CSTP for
ambient Air, Water
Soil & Noise
Figure 5-8: Sampling location at representing upstream and downstream of the city
1.1. below. As per data available from SPCB for year 2019,
year 2017 and 20189 has been shown in the figure
the water quality record has been shown for one station located in downstream of Tajmajhal.
85. The concentration complies with the standard of >4 mg/l almost at all stations, however Graphical
representation of BOD data for consecutive three years shows concentration much higher than what is
permissible for various uses, i.e., < 3mg/l. So also the Total coliform shows much higher values than the
permissible limit prescribed by CPCB as < 500 MPN/100ml for class B & C.
86. Each drain wise waste water quality in terms of BOD, DO, COD, TSS, VSS & pH has been presented
in DPR, however drains which will be tapped under the project has generally BOD ranges from 85-250 &
COD-200- 700 Mg/l.
9
Uttar Pradesh State pollution control board 2017-18
1.1.(IS-10500:2012)
Limit
S. Results- Results-
Parameters Unit Desirable Permissible Test method
No. GW1 GW2
Limit Limit
Anionic Detergents(as Annexure K of
23 mg/l 0.2 1 <0.1 <0.1
MBAS) IS-13428.
24 Boron(as B) mg/l 0.5 1 0.12 0.19 IS: 3025(Pt-57)
No IS 3025(Part-
25 Mineral Oil mg/l 0.5 <0.1 <0.1
Relaxation 39)
Phenolic Compound ( IS 3025(Part-
26 mg/l 0.001 0.002 <0.001 <0.001
as C6H5OH) 44)
No 3110- B, APHA
27 Cadmium ( as Cd) mg/l 0.003 <0.002 <0.002
Relaxation 23nd Ed2017
4500- CN-B,C
No
28 Cyanide( as CN) mg/l 0.05 <0.1 <0.1 &E, APHA 23nd
Relaxation
Ed2017
No 3110- B, APHA
29 Lead mg/l 0.01 <0.01 <0.01
Relaxation 23nd Ed2017
No 3110- B, APHA
30 Mercury( as Hg) mg/l 0.001 <0.001 <0.001
Relaxation 23nd Ed.2017
No 3110- B, APHA
31 Nickel (as Ni) mg/l 0.02 <0.02 <0.02
Relaxation 23nd Ed.2017
4500-Cl-B,
Residual Free
32 mg/l 0.2 1 <0.2 <0.2 APHA 23nd
Chlorine
Ed2017
No No 3110- B, APHA
33 Molybdenum (Mo) mg/l <0.05 0.07
Relaxation Relaxation 23nd Ed.2017
APHA
Polynuclear Aromatic No No
34 mg/l <0.0001 0.0001 6440,23nd
Hydro Carbons Relaxation Relaxation
Ed.2017
APHA
Poly chlorinated No No
35 mg/l <0.0001 0.0005 6430,23nd
biphenyl Relaxation Relaxation
Ed.2017
Shall not be detectable <1
36 Total Coli form MPN/100ml <1 IS : 1622-1981
in any 100 ml of sample
Shall not be detectable Absent
37 E.Coli E.coli/100ml Absent IS : 1622-1981
in any 100 ml of sample
Source: Primary Survey by Consultant
1.1.
Figure 5-12: Water Sample collection at Dhandupura Figure 5-13: Water Sample collection at Artoni DSTP
CSTP Location Location
5.1.5. Biological environment
92. Agra District Falls in Zone 7- Gangatic Plane Biogeographic Zone and 7A- Gangatic Plane; Upper
Gangatic Plane as per the Biogeographic Province Classification of India. The District covers an area of
4,041 sq.km (total Geographical Area) of which the area under forest cover i.e moderate dense forest is 63
sq.km and open forest is 272 sq.km; which is 6.73% of the geographical area.
93. Of the total available forest area in the district about 1.16 ha of forest area will be affected which
will be utilized for construction of STPs. During primary site visit of these affected forest area, the site
witness extensive growth of shrubs i.e Acacia Sp. followed by scatted growth of Acacia nilotica (Babul) and
Acacia catcehu (Kikar) which are dominant tree species. Other trees reports are neem, semal, Cassia sp,
Siris, Sissoo sp., Chitwan, Chilbil, etc.
94. The proposed project area, forest lands diverted for establishment of STP are having mostly Acacia
sp., which are naturally species reported in this climatic zone. Felling of trees will be minimized by
modifying the site layout, where service area a planned. To utilize the forest land , the UP Jal Nigam (YPCU)
need to apply for diversion of these forest area under The Forest (Conservation), 1980 to the Ministry of
Environmental Forests and Climate Change (MoEF&CC) online forest portal. After obtaining the forest
diversion approval, from the state forest department (regional office of Moef&CC), these land can be
utilized for establishment of DSTPs.
1.1.
Acacia sp. In the affected forest area Project site adjacent of settlements
Figure 5-14: The photographs of site taken during site visit
95. The area of 5 hectare has also been identified by YPCU for construction of 100 MLD STP which exist
within STPs at Dhandupra in Agra. This land belong to UP Jal Nigam – YPCU where the plantation of trees
reported at site has been done by the forest department under afforestation program. During primary site
visit, the proposed site witness growth of trees with growth of bushes, grasses as ground cover. Tree
numeration and identification has been done by the department, which are expected to be affected during
STP construction work. Based on the communication with the forest department and YPCU, 10 times of
trees plantation need to be done for each species cut. Based on the communication with YPCU the forest
department requested for compensation for tress loss and to carry out compensatory plantation in the TTZ
area.
96. There are approximately 704 trees affected within demarcated STP and services area, which would
involve felling and removal; this area is under Tajganj Zone & also falls under TTZ. Therefore for
construction of STP, prior permission from Supreme Court & TTZ authority is required to be obtained.
During primary site visit the species of the trees reported within the project site are Kikar, Karanj, Papdi,
Eucalyptus, Jamun, Siris, Neem, Semal, Cassia sp, Sissoo sp., Chitwan, Chilbil, Royal Palm, gulmohar,
Alistonia, etc. the photographs of trees species reported during site visit are shown in figure below:
Trees reported within the proposed site Chilbil trees reported with proposed site
Figure 5-15: The photographs of site taken during site visit at Dhandupura STP
Figure 5-16: Eco sensitive boundary and Sur Sarovar Bird Sanctuary
Figure 5-17: Sensitive Project Feature within 10 km Buffer area of the Project site
10
Other Workers: all those workers other than cultivators or agricultural labourers or household industry workers are 'Other
Workers'. The type of workers that come under this category of 'OW' include all government servants, municipal employees,
teachers, factory workers, plantation workers, those engaged in trade, commerce, business, transport banking, mining,
construction, political or social work, priests, entertainment artists, etc. In effect, all those workers other than cultivators or
agricultural labourers or household industry workers are 'Other Workers'.
1.1.Population
5.2.4. Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe
107. Analysis of social groups for the project city has been done on the basis of concentration of
Scheduled Caste (SC) and Scheduled Tribe (ST) population in Tehsil and project city. As per census 2011
108. , the total SC and ST population of taluka is 5.36 lakh, which shares 24.21 percent SC and only 0.30
percent ST to the total population.
109. As per Census 2011, SC and ST population for Agra city accounts for the figure of 3, 76,371. Of this
the share of ST community is only 0.38 percent to the total population.
5.2.5. Socio-cultural
110. Agra city is situated on the western bank of
river Yamuna on National Highway (NH-2) and
located at about 200km from Delhi capital of India.
Agra is of historic importance of city, which is amply
evident from the numerous historical monuments in
and around the city. The city is a center of
international fame with proud possession of ‘Taj
Mahal’. In addition to its historical importance; the
city is the main centre of political, economic,
Figure 5-21: SC&ST %
commercial and cultural activities.
111. Agra achieved fame as the capital of the Mughal emperors and remains a major tourist destination
because of its many splendid Mughal-era buildings, most notably the Taj Mahal, Agra Fort and Fatehpur
Sikri, all three of which are UNESCO Sites. Agra is ranked amongst the most outstanding historic cities in
the world and certainly best known tourist destinations in India.
112. Hindus are prominent in Agra city with 80.68 percent and followed by Muslim community second
most popular religion in the city with approximately 15.37 percent.
5.2.6. Slum areas in Project City
113. The city has approximately 252 slums (notified) with 30 percent of population to the total
population and 96 thousands households (approximately) located in Agra Municipal Corporation area with
electricity and tap water connection.
5.2.7. City’s planned activities
114. The city has divided into 90 wards and total over 2.67 lakhs of houses to which it supplies basic
amenities like water and sewerage. It also authorizes to build roads within Municipal Corporation limits
and impose taxes on properties coming under its jurisdiction.
5.2.8. Historical importance/ Archaeological Properties
115. Proposed sub-project is located within the Taj Trapezium Zone (TTZ) which is a trapezoid shaped,
10,400 Sq. Km area around the Taj Mahal and a buffer zone designed to protect this historic monument
from pollution. Within the TTZ, There are 3 ASI protected monuments- Mehtab Bagh, Humayun Mosque
and Gyarah Sidi.
116. The process of environmental and social due diligence was accomplished through the review of
available documents viz. Detailed Project Reports (DPR) and other literatures related to environmental and
social aspects of the project area. Site visits / field surveys, detailed interactions with key stakeholders and
consultations with host communities at site wherever feasible are also conducted to identify and assess
the anticipated environmental and social impacts associated with the proposed project, as well as to
develop an Environmental and Social Management Action Plan (ESMAP) recommending suitable mitigation
measures.
The project will not have any adverse 1.2. impact on vulnerable and Scheduled Caste community for
laying mains. Since all the DSTPs are proposed in the forest land, no diversion structure is required.
Most of the project site is at a distance from the settlement. As per the consultations conducted, the
participants expressed their relief and satisfaction that the open drains will be channelized and
treated.
6.1.2. Implementation Arrangement
118. State Mission for Clean Ganga-Uttar Pradesh (SMCG-UP) is an extended arm of National Mission
for Clean Ganga (NMCG) for the state of Uttar Pradesh and implementing the Namami Gange and other
programmes through various executing agencies. At state level it is implementing arm of State Ganga
Committee constituted vide S.O. 3187 E dated 7th October, 2016 under Environment protection act
1986.Under SMCG, Yamuna Pollution Control Unit (YPCU) is functioning as the Executing Agency in Agra or
some western part of UP under YAP region. The I&D Sewerage and STP Scheme at Agra will also be
implemented under the same structure.
119. One Environmental Safeguard Official, one wild life expert & one Social safeguard official is placed
at SMCG and functioning as a focal point for environment and social safeguards. The Contract for
implementing the Sewerage and STP Scheme at Agra is based on Hybrid Annuity Model.
120. The proposed interventions involve numerous construction activities. Accordingly, the available
Project Staffs of UP Jal Nigam/YPCU, Agra Division should be trained and assigned for monitoring as well as
ensure compliance of environmental and social safeguard measures associated with the day to day
construction activities of the proposed project.
6.1.3. Compliance to Regulatory Requirements
121. The project does not require any environmental clearance; however permission from Forest
department is required under Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 for proposed 0.97 ha of forest land &
another approval from Supreme Court will be required for tree felling of (704 no) under TTZ authority. As
per Provision of Air and Water Act, the project requires obtaining CTE & CTO from SPCB. The approval
required for project implementation by UP Jal Nigam is as follows:
Forest Approval for 0.97 ha of land under Forest (Conservation) Act 1980.
For establishment of 100 MLD STP near existing STP at Dhanupura two options are identified and
under consideration
a. Option1: Approval from Supreme Court will be required for tree felling of (704 no) at around 5
hectare land within premises of existing STP at Dhandupura under TTZ regulatory Zone.
b. Option 2: Purchase of 5.5 hectare of private land from adjacent area of existing STP as per UP
Negotiation (Mutual Consent) Policy, 2015.
Consent to Establish (CTE) & Consent to Operate (CTO) for the STP is mandatory to obtain under
Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act 1972 & Air (Prevention and control of Pollution) 1981
of Government of India.
Permission for use of water for construction purpose from irrigation department/CGWA (for Surface
or Ground Water).
1.2.
Labour license to be obtained by the Concessionaire prior to construction.
6.1.4. Land Requirements
122. The designated land identified for establishing various project components (Pumping Stations)
belongs to Yamuna Pollution control unit. There is no encroacher or squatter found in the designated land.
Land for proposed STPs/MPS is available within the vicinity of the existing facilities.
123. Proposed MPS/SPS as mentioned below are proposed in vicinity land within the premises for
development. Proposed Rising main work of total 9.35 km & Sewerage line of 2.5 km has been planned
along the Road within available ROW. The ROW width is varied from 15-30m. In case of non-availability of
enough ROW or constraints due to tree or any structure, the laying work has been planned in center of the
road. No private land or impact on tree is anticipated for laying work. Ensuing sections provides the
availability of land for proposed project work & additionally required necessary approval/No objection
certificate from Inter government department as well as Forest Departments.
11
Area has been worked out by YPCU, average of total area required under different tech. MOUD Manual
124. Brief for NOC/Permission required with regard to land are presented below:
NOC from Railway is required for laying Sewer line in area of MPS Peelakhar of 440 m length & DSTP
line of Indira memorial drain (request letter for NOC has been forwarded by YPCU to respective
Authority – refer annexure 4)
NOC from cantonment Board for rising main of Khairati Tola for 600 meter. (request letter for NOC
has been forwarded by YPCU to respective Authority – refer annexure 4)
Forest Approval for 0.97 ha of land under FC ACT 1980 for establishment of 8 DSTPs having total
capacity of 9.85 MLD.
NOC from Agra development Authority for establishment of two DSTPs i.e. 0.25 MLD Peeli Pokhar
Drain & 1.5 MLD STP at Indira Memorial. Both the proposed lands are vacant & no tree felling is
required.
For establishment of 100 MLD STP near to existing STP at Dhanupura two options are identified and
under consideration
a) Option-1: Approval from Supreme Court will be required for tree felling of (704 no) at around 5
hectare land within premises of existing STP at Dhandupura under TTZ authority.
b) Option-2: Purchase of 5.5 hectare of private land from adjacent area of existing STP.
1.2.
6.1.5. Construction & Occupational Health and Safety
125. The Concessionaire who will be procured for the project on Hybrid Annuity Model, is liable to
develop a project specific EMP. The Concessionaire should ensure that the following aspects are included
and implemented on site, complying with the provisions given in ESMF:
There are number of schools, colleges and hospitals situated in Agra. Due mitigation measures should
be taken to reduce the disturbances to the educational / medical institutions located alongside the
project locations at Agra, especially during the excavation works for laying of sewer pipes.
Local traffic disturbance is anticipated due to laying work of Sewerage line (2.5 km) and Rising main
line (9.35 km) along the road, therefore proper Traffic Management Plan should be prepared by
concessionaire for reducing traffic congestion and mitigating disturbances to public during the
excavation works.
Concessionaire should adopt appropriate implementation mechanism for restoration of topsoil (to
control soil disturbance), dust suppression, use of DG sets in acoustic enclosure with proper stack
height (for betterment of Air), restoration of construction sites, etc.
Appropriate training to construction labourers regarding health and safety aspects. Concessionaire
should provide the workers with PPEs and they should be encouraged to consistently use the PPEs
Proper civil work schedule should be in place and be included as part of EMP.
The STP site is located near banks of the River Yamuna; hence appropriate measures should be taken
to control the direct discharge of untreated effluent into the River Yamuna.
Properly insulated electrical works should be provided at respective STPs and in construction sites
elsewhere.
Integration of adequate safely aspects (Protection rails along walk ways at height) in STP.
Adhering to the monitoring and reporting of the environment Management Measure applicable to
the construction stage wise.
6.1.6. Discussion & Community Consultations with Key Stakeholder and local community
126. Local communities & Key stakeholder (UPJN) were consulted during the preparation stage of
ESDDR of Agra, which included consultations with various community groups (Framers, shop owners, local
residents, etc.). The brief of interaction, discussion is presented in table below, detail minutes of meeting is
presented in annexure 14 of this report.
Table 6-5: Brief of discussion with stakeholder and local communities, residents
No. of
Date of Site
No. Location Particip Issues Discussed Photographs
Visit
ants
th
1 11 and Yamuna 6 Total land required (Government &
th
12 Pollution Forest) under the project has been
December Control Unit discussed. The implications of
2019 (YPCU) office, necessary rules and regulation
Agra under the Forest act have been
discussed.
Options for land finalizations (TTZ
zone and forest area has been
No. of 1.2.
Date of Site
No. Location Particip Issues Discussed Photographs
Visit
ants
discussed). The current situation is
presented in the DDR section.
STP treated water and sludge from
Jaganpur is being used by farmers of
Dayalbagh Community.
Presently extra sludge is being
dumped in Kuberpur MC’s Dumping
ground.
The officials suggested to get an
MOU with the MC for proper sludge
dumping area.
th
2 27 Dhandupura 5 JE and Concessionaire / staff of STP
December & Jaganpur intimated that local farmer residing
2019 STP in outskirts of Agra city takes dry
sludge/manure from the STP
between March to May season every
year.
No farmers were available in the STP
area because of post monsoon
season and off season for crop
sowing.
th th
3 11 & 12 Proposed 21 Community residents have extended
December DSTP and all support for the proposed project.
2019 and Nala tapping Local community welcomed the
th
4 at Artoni and initiative of major Nala Tapping and
February Waipur & giving onsite treatment facility to
2020 rising main cater the pollution incoming in the
area River Yamuna.
Community people suggested to
provide continuous and regular
mechanism to create education and
awareness among the people,
particularly the younger generation
about the importance of keeping
river Ganga clean.
Community people were enthusiastic
about the project and expressed
their willingness to work in the
construction phase of the project.
th
4 4 Proposed 17 Community residents have extended
February DSTP at all support for the project.
2020 Transport Community people were enthusiastic
Nagar about the project and expressed
their willingness to work in the
construction phase.
Suggestion was provided by
community people to improve the
aesthetics of the area through
project establishment
No. of 1.2.
Date of Site
No. Location Particip Issues Discussed Photographs
Visit
ants
th
5 4 Proposed 15 Community people expressed the
February DSTP at Burhi problem of foul smell from the
2020 Ka Nagla existing STP and suggested
plantation of trees to reduce the foul
smell.
Community residents expressed
their willingness to work in the
construction phase of the project.
127. The project specific EMP to be prepared by the Concessionaire should address respective
suggestions provided by or feedback obtained from the local community during the preparatory stage
consultations:
Excavation works on roads for lying of rising main (9.3km) and MPS, STPs should be done with proper
planning in order to avoid or minimise the disturbance to local residents.
Restoration of excavated roads/sites should be carried out on priority basis.
Excessive amount of noise while during excavation works should be avoided.
Appropriate measures should be adopted for dust suppression during construction works.
Construction works should be regulated according to school timings, especially in adjacent areas of
educational institutions.
To avoid dispute with local residents, preferably local worker should be hired for various stage of
development/ construction of the project.
6.1.7. Grievance Redress Mechanism
128. Currently, NMCG has one GRM officer, who addresses all queries registered on the Centralized
Public Grievance Redress and Monitoring System (CP GRAM) portal of NMCG. The GRM officer is supported
by one social expert who helps to coordinate with all the state the SMCGs.
129. At SMCG level, reporting of grievances are being monitored by Environmental and Social experts.
All Executing Agencies have a GRM mechanism at each project site. The project manager and deputy
project managers are in-charge of these GRMs. To register grievances, a register has been kept at all
project site offices and in some sites sometime field team received grievances over mobile phones as well
as on whatsapp massages. The grievances should be resolved by conducting monthly review meetings and
if site team is unable to resolve the issue on its own, the complaint/matter is brought up to Senior
Management of EA.
130. ESDDR suggest establishing the similar grievance redressal mechanism in Agra site as well. Further,
it is also recommended to constitute a GRC in the PIU to record and redress public grievances. A dedicated
team under the supervision of the Project Manager could be appointed for recording the grievances. The
name and contact information of Grievance Redressal Officers (GROs) should be displayed at the
project/construction site, labour camps, in communities where construction work is taking place and in the
websites of ULB, EA and SMCG. Also, a toll free number should be generated and displayed in work sites
for registering grievances. A grievance reporting format is attached at Annexure 7.
1.2.
6.1.8. Gender Assessment and Development
131. According to ESMF, the objective of Gender Assessment and Development is to analyse gender
issues during the preparation stage of sub projects, design interventions and primary data collection. The
gender analysis shall be carried out based on findings from gender specific queries and requirements
during data collection and community consultation process. The quantitative and qualitative analysis shall
include sex disaggregated data, issues related to gender disparity, needs, constraints, priorities and
understanding of gender based inequitable risks, benefits and opportunities as well as gender relevant
indicators.
6.1.9. Gender Based Violence (GBV)
132. GBV is an umbrella term for any harmful act that is perpetrated against a person’s will and that is
based on socially ascribed gender differences. GBV includes acts that inflict physical, mental, sexual harm
or suffering; threats of such acts; and coercion and other deprivations of liberty, whether occurring in
public or in private life. The project site includes both the actual locations where civil works are conducted
and also the associated areas such as the locations of workers’ camps, quarries, etc. These GBV risks need
to be assessed throughout the project’s life by monitoring the situation, assessing the effectiveness of risk
mitigation measures, and adapting them.
133. Since a sub project involves construction work that will demand a constant supply of labourers, the
influx of migrant workforce can be a potential risk for the host population. The influx of labour force can
lead to the risk of Gender-Based Violence.
134. ESDDR in ESMAP suggests key actions and responsibilities of project partners. The interventions
will be at three levels, that of SPMG, EA and of the Contractor. According to guidelines of ESMAP on GBV
prevention has been prepared clearly defining the roles and responsibilities at all levels. Robust measures
shall be prepared and implemented to address the risk of gender based violence in the project and
adjoining communities.
6.1.10. Integration of ESMAP with Project
135. To ensure the implementation of safeguard measures by the Concessionaire, the ESMAP including
the suitable conditions for the preparation of project specific detailed ESAMP and necessary
recommendation of ESDDR will be included in the bid document. The ESMAP clearly outlines the
responsibility for various safeguard management actions associated with the project activities related to
Construction stage Labour Management, Assessment of Gender Based Violence and Grievance Redress
Mechanism as well as to ensure compliance of the same in accordance with the safeguard requirements of
the ESMF.
6.1.11. Requirements for preparation of ESHS Management Strategies and Implementation
Plans
(a) The Concessionaire shall submit comprehensive and concise Environmental, Social, Health
and Safety Management Strategies and Implementation Plans (ESHS-MSIP). These strategies
and plans shall describe in detail the actions, materials, equipment, management processes
etc. that will be implemented by the Concessionaire, and its subcontractors. In developing
these strategies and plans, the Concessionaire shall have regard to the ESHS provisions of the
Concession Agreement including 1.2. those as may be more fully described in the
following:Works Requirements described in Concession Agreement;
(b) Environmental and Social Assessment (ESA);
(c) Environmental and Social Management Plan (ESMP);
(d) Consent Conditions (regulatory authority conditions attached to any permits or approvals for
the project).
Interactions with community members1.2. (for example to convey an attitude of respect and
nondiscrimination)
Prohibition of child labour (for example employment of children below 14 years of age is prohibited in
Building and Construction Industry)
Sexual harassment (for example to prohibit use of language or behavior, in particular towards
women or children, that is inappropriate, harassing, abusive, sexually provocative, demeaning or
culturally inappropriate)
Violence or exploitation (for example the prohibition of the exchange of money, employment,
goods, or services for sex, including sexual favors or other forms of humiliating, degrading or
exploitative behavior)
Protection of children (including prohibitions against abuse, defilement, or otherwise unacceptable
behavior with children, limiting interactions with children, and ensuring their safety in project areas)
Sanitation requirements (for example, to ensure workers use specified sanitary facilities provided by
their employer and not open areas)
Avoidance of conflicts of interest (such that benefits, Concession Agreement, or employment, or any
sort of preferential treatment or favors, are not provided to any person with whom there is a financial,
family, or personal connection)
Respecting reasonable work instructions (including regarding environmental and social norms)
Protection and proper use of property (for example, to prohibit theft, carelessness or waste)
Duty to report violations of this Code
139. Non retaliation against workers who report violations of the Code, if that report is made in good
faith.The Code of Conduct should be written in plain language and signed by each worker to indicate that
they have:
received a copy of the code;
had the code explained to them;
acknowledged that adherence to this Code of Conduct is a condition of employment; and
understood that violations of the Code can result in serious consequences, up to and including
dismissal, or referral to legal authorities
140. As prescribed in the ESMF, a Gap Analysis with respect to major environment and social attributes
was done and the major observations are presented in Table 7-1:
141. Table 8-1 presents the implementation schedule, responsibilities and respective time frame.
142. YPCU has prepared detailed project report, on the basis of site specific information, visits,
Stakeholder Consultation and reviewed design criteria available in the DPR. Further, the environmental and
social screening has been carried out as per ESMF guideline. As per screening analysis of the project, I&D
Sewerage System project at Agra is categorized as having ‘High impact’.
143. The project does not trigger EIA notification 2006. The Duration of associated impact shall be
during construction phase. This can be mitigated through proper project specific Environmental
Management Plan (EMP) prepared and implemented by the Concessionaire under the supervision of YPCU.
144. Based on the findings of due diligence exercise, the following recommendations are provided with
an objective to ensure compliance with the ESMF:
1.2.
Independent Environment and Social/Compliance Monitoring Audit by the third party independent
inspection agency should be carried out annually, as per the ESMF requirements of Namami Gange
program.
A Gender Action Plan to be prepared to address the risk of gender based violence in the project and
adjoining communities.
Orientation and sensitization training needs to be provided for all project staff and contractors, in
particular, safety supervisors and engineers on GBV at all levels.
ICC committees addressing GBV need to be constituted at EA, SPMG and NMCG level.
GBV needs to be integrated with GRM with special provisions, so, confidentiality/personal
information can be controlled /maintained.
Project Components:
I&D Works of 23 drains
2.55 km Sewer Network & 9,35km of Rising Main
3 nos. Main Pumping Stations
10 decentralized STP of total 11.6 MLD capacity
3 Centralized STP of 35, 31, 100 MLD
O&M of sewerage system for 15yrs.
Sl. Screening Criteria Yes/No Assessment Remarks /Explanatory note for categorisation
No. of Category
(High/ low)
1 Is the project in an Yes High The proposed STP and DSTP under the project in Agra city
eco-sensitive area is falling under TTZ regulated zone. However, eco-friendly
or adjoining an eco-
projects (like STP etc) are allowed with permission from
sensitive area?
(Yes/No) If Yes, State pollution control board as per latest Supreme Court
which is the area? Order dated 6th December 2019 (Annexure attached).
Elaborate impact Around 1.16 hectare of forest land is required for 10
accordingly.
DSTPs in different area of the city (norther and eastern
zone of sewerage plan of Agra), and another land (vacant
part of existing STP @ Dhandupura) having 704 tree which
is under TTZ is required to be obtained for establishment
of 100 MLD STP at Dhandupura under Central Zone
catchment.
2 Will the project Yes High There is likely requirement of 5.5 hectare of private land from
create significant/ adjacent area of existing STP. This alternative land is identified
limited/ no social and the procurement of the same will be decided, if
impacts? permission for TTZ land is not obtained.
Project considers the land already available and owned by the
UP Jal Nigam, which is 5.11 hectare Within this, approximately
4.2 hectare is having trees planted by Forest Department in
2001. The proposed construction of 100 MLD STP requires
cutting of these trees. This area lies in the Taj Trapezium
Regulated Zone & the department has filed a petition in
Hon’ble Supreme Court seeking permission to cut 704 out of
1525 trees.
Land acquisition/ No Low In case of private land acquisition/ purchase, the impacted
purchase resulting area is agricultural land.
in loss of income
from agricultural
1.2.
Sl. Screening Criteria Yes/No Assessment Remarks /Explanatory note for categorisation
No. of Category
(High/ low)
land, plantation or
other existing land-
use.
Land acquisition/ No No Land selected for STP will not involve any relocation of
purchase resulting household. Agricultural land is impacted, no relocation is
in relocation of envisaged. ,
households.
Any reduction of No No Impact None of Proposed DSTP or STP is located far from nearby
access to agricultural farm land. The DSTPs are basically on forest land
traditional and which is presently having Mesquit and Keekar trees. The said
river dependent vegetation is of no use to domestic animal too. Thus the
communities (to proposed project will not cause any loss of access to
river and areas traditional and river dependent communities (to river and
where they earn areas where they earn for their primary or substantial
for their primary or livelihood). To support this further kindly refer the location
substantial map in Annexure C.
livelihood). The selected land is a vacant place at river bank. No
displacement of river dependent communities will be
required.
Any displacement No No There is no tribal settlement in or around project area.
or adverse impact Therefore, the proposed project will not displace any tribal
on tribal settlement(s).
settlement(s).
Any specific gender No No No gender specific issue directly related to the project is
issues. envisaged. However, better sanitation facility will improve
health status of women in the area.
3 Will the project No Low and The STP is going to be constructed on forest land at the river
create significant / short term bank. Therefore, there will be only short term/ limited
limited / no Impact environmental impact. The land selected for DSTPs is presently
environmental having scrub vegetation mainly Mesquit and Keekar tree. The
impacts during the said vegetation is of no use to domestic animal too.
construction stage? Further the loss of bushes shall be compensated by developing
(significant/limited/ green belt around STP.
no impacts) The proposed lifting stations & MPS will be constructed in
Govt. land authorized under YPCU, which are open areas.
Therefore, it will minimise the impact.
The proposed sewer line will be under the road with minimum
3m or more road width.
Clearance of Yes High The identified forest land is majorly scrub land having plants
vegetation/ tree- like Keekar and mesquite trees, or few other trees. As a part of
cover minimization of impact, compensatory afforestation cost shall
be submitted to forest department. In project perspective,
measures like provision of green belt shall be provided.
Except, around 704 trees felling would be required at
proposed 100 MLD STP at Dhandupura is alternative land is
not finalized.
Direct discharge of Yes Low and The DSTPs will be based on Conventional/SBR/MBBR/MBR
construction run- short term type prefabricated units with minimal civil works. The
off, improper impact centralized STP to be developed on fresh land will have
1.2.
Sl. Screening Criteria Yes/No Assessment Remarks /Explanatory note for categorisation
No. of Category
(High/ low)
storage and during construction specific impact during civil construction activity.
disposal of construction With due care and management direct discharge, improper
excavation spoils, phase storage of wastes shall be taken care of.
wastes and other The laying of sewer lines is not much in the project; however
construction laying will cause some traffic disruption of temporary nature.
materials adversely Sensitive locations like schools, hospitals will have special
affecting water problems which will be taken care of during construction.
quality and flow
regimes.
Flooding of Yes Low Impact Construction of project will not obstruct any of natural drain
adjacent areas short term /channel near the site. The level of STPs and SPS will be made
impact with due care of high flood level record, which is 145.5 m
during Dewatering for construction will not generate any significant
construction amount of water to flood adjacent areas
phase
Proposed STP and MPS will have garland drain to avoid further
flooding in premises and neighbourhood area in case of storm
water during monsoon.
Improper storage Yes Low and Civil Construction material like cement, sand, earth etc. will be
and handling of short term prevalent in use, while contaminated material such fuel , used
substances leading impact oil shall be taken care of properly for storage and handling
to contamination during properly at site. Further the EMP shall be framed with
of soil and water construction inclusion of site specific Environmental issues to address the
phase safety health related issues· for
Elevated noise and Yes Low and Proper measures should be taken during sewer lying to
dust emission short term minimise the noise and dust emissions. Contractor should
impact ensure the proper acoustic measure for noise generating unit
like DG set as per CPCB norm, etc.
The Concessionaire has to submit the method statement to
comply with Air Act, 1981 & Noise Rules as per EP Act, 1986
before construction.
Disruption to traffic Yes Low and No much Sewer laying work is envisaged, but around 10 km of
movements short term rising main work will need proper traffic management at the
Impact site.
during Proper diversion of traffic will ensure less disruption during
construction construction. Contractor shall ensure proper traffic
phase management in place prior to construction activities.
Damage to existing No Low and Utility mapping of the existing infrastructure and relocation of
infrastructure, short term the same if required will minimise the damage on existing
public utilities, Impact infrastructure.
amenities etc. during No much Sewer laying work is envisaged however shifting of
construction other utilities like telephone lines, electric poles or street lights
phase etc. if required shall be shifted temporarily or relocated (only if
needed) after taking due permission from the concerned
department.
Failure to restore No Low and The roads will be reinstated to its original conditions after lying
temporary short term of sewer line.
construction sites Impact Mitigation measures towards restoration of temporary
during construction sites will be part of ESMP of contractor’s bid
1.2.
Sl. Screening Criteria Yes/No Assessment Remarks /Explanatory note for categorisation
No. of Category
(High/ low)
construction document.
phase
Possible conflicts No No impact The local community will be made aware of the temporary
with and/or nature of disruption.
disruption to local All possible disputes during construction work shall be avoided
community by hiring of local labour as much as possible. In case of migrant
labour hiring, the fundamental facility in labour camp shall be
ensured by contractor to avoid further disputes.
Health risks due to Yes Low Impact Adequate sanitation facilities and safety arrangement will be
unhygienic provided to the workers in construction camp. A site specific
conditions at ESAMP shall be having Health and hygiene maintenance plan
workers‟ camps for project construction site, which will be part of BID
document for its completed implementation at sites.
Safety hazards Yes Low and Proper health and safety statement will be submitted by the
during construction short term Concessionaire and approved by The Engineer prior to the
Impact construction. This will be included in ESAMP and be part of Bid
during document.
construction
phase
4 Will the project Yes Limited STP will have minimal odour and noise pollution.
create significant / Moreover, provision of green belt, landscaping within the STP
limited / no and SPS premised will reduce the negative impact of odour.
environmental The proposed projects of establishment of STP are based on
impacts during the advance technologies of sewerage waste water treatment
operational stage? plan.
(Significant /
limited / no
impacts)
Flooding of Yes Low Impact Proposed STP and MPS will have garland drain to avoid further
adjacent areas flooding in premises and neighbourhood area in case of storm
water during monsoon. All the STPs are design above the
High Flood Level of Yamuna River.
Impacts to water Yes Low Impact The characteristics of the treated waste water from SBR
quality due to reactor will be within permissible limit set by latest NGT /CPCB
effluent discharge guideline 2019.
Gas emissions Yes Low Impact SBR or other Aerobic reactor is a compact system and the
possibility of the Gas emission is very less.
Safety hazards Yes Low Impact Mechanised system and trained people will be used to run the
Pumping stations and STPs will reduce the risk of safety
hazards.
Proper PPEs shall be ensured by the contractor for
Concessionaire and Staff of STP/ MPS. First Aid Measures shall
be adhered as part of safety management.
Emergency Site management plan shall be adhered to the
deputed STP area to avoid unsafe hazard like fire, electricity
etc.
5 Do projects of this No No The proposed STP Project is not listed under the Schedule to
nature / type clearance the 14th September 2006 EIA notification and its amendment
require prior required made thereafter. Hence it is exempted from environmental
1.2.
Sl. Screening Criteria Yes/No Assessment Remarks /Explanatory note for categorisation
No. of Category
(High/ low)
environmental clearance.
clearance either However, the proposed project needs Consent to Establish
from the MOEF or (CTE) prior to start of construction of STP and Consent to
from a relevant Operate (CTO) prior to start operation of STP. These
state Government permissions are required from State Pollution Control Board
department? (EPPCB) under Air and Water act.
(MOEF/ relevant
State Government
department/ No
clearance at all)
6 Does the project Yes Yes Around 0.97 ha of land is affected in selected sites of
involve any prior decentralized STPs, for this prior forest clearance shall be
clearance from the required to be obtained from Forest Department UP & MOEF
MOEF or State &CC.
Forest department Another option of acquiring 5 hectare of land identified within
for either the premises of existing Dhandupura STP, where around 704 nos.
conversion of of trees are impacted. Since this is under TTZ area, therefore
forest land or for prior approval from supreme court shall be required for the
tree-cutting? (Yes/ project.
No). If yes, which?
Overall Assessment High Based on the initial Environmental screening, Agra Sewerage
Project has been rated under High risk zone because of
following reasons:
The project area falls in the Taj Trapezium which is Declared
Ecologically Sensitive Areas (ESAs) under "The Environment
(Protection) Act (EPA), 1986";
it involve felling of 704 number of trees in notified ESAs area
and also involve diversion of 0.97 ha of forest land which are
notifed forest under " The India Forest Act-1927". Please refer
Section 6.1.1 (Para No. 136) of the Report.
Further, below table can be referred for the overall rating and assessment (high/low) of the project.
1 Is the treatment plant of the project is No Soor Sarovar Bird Sanctuary is located within 5.24 km
located within Eco Sensitive Zone as per the towards West of Project site. the Eco sensitive zone
Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 has been demarcated to be 1 km from boundary of
the sanctuary through Gazette of India no. 3319,
New Delhi, Thursday, October 10, 2019. Hence it is
exempted from obtaining NOC from State Board of
Wild Life and not falling within ECZ.
2 Is the treatment plant of the project is Yes The project area falls in the Taj Trapezium which is
located within Ecological Sensitive Area (ESA) Declared Ecologically Sensitive Areas (ESAs) under
as per the Environmental (Protection) Act, "The Environment (Protection) Act (EPA), 1986"; it
1986 involve felling of 704 number of trees in notified ESAs
1.2.
Sl.no. Categorization Criteria Applicability Remarks
(Yes/No)
area
3 Is treatment plant of the project is located Yes Project also involves diversion of 0.97 ha of forest
within notified Forest Area as per the Indian land which are notified forest under “The India Forest
Forest Act 1927 Act-1927".
4 Is the treatment plant of the project is Yes Agra city is one of 43 critically polluted Areas as per
located within Critically Polluted Area (CPIA) CPCB record, since proposed project components (STP
as per Environmental (Protection) Act, 1986 & I&D Provisions) does not fall under EIA notification
2006, so Environmental Clearance is exempted.
However, respective Consent for establishment &
Operation (CTE, CTO) shall be required from SPCB (as
per Om dated 24.10.2019 Annexure ) with stipulated
certain conditions from SPCB.
The proposed STP Project is not listed under the
5 Does the treatment plant of the project No Schedule to the 14th September 2006 EIA notification
th
attract the 14 September 2006 EIA and its amendment made thereafter. Hence it is
Notification & further amendments exempted from environmental clearance.
6 Is the treatment plant of the project is No The Project region is located in upper Gangetic plain,
located within the Notified zone Coastal does not fall under Notified Coastal Regulation Zone
Regulation Zone (CRZ) notification 2016 2019, of India.
7 Is the treatment plant of the project is No The project region does not falls under 27 notified
located within the area as notified under areas as specified under Wetlands (Conservation and
Wetlands (Conservation and Management) Management) Rules, 2016.
Rules, 2017
8 Is the treatment plant of the project is No None of the project related structure and I&D
located within the regulatory zone of area as provisions are coming within regulatory zone of ASI
per The Ancient Monuments and Monuments. Therefore, no prior permission is
Archaeological Sites and Remains Act 1958. required under this notification for project
implementation.
Note: If any of these indicators is answered yes, the project will be considered as high impact sub project.
O&M has been awarded to M/s VA Tech Wabag , Chennai for 10 years by SMCG vide letter no.
067/358/SMCG-UP/(PC) dt. 14.06.2019.
Conditional Assessment:
Table 4: Conditional Assessment of existing sewerage works have been done by UPJN
S.No Zone STP/SPS/MPS/Interception Present Conditional Status Remarks
1 14 MLD STP Jaganpur Good condition
2 2.25 MLD STP Burhi ka Nagla Good condition
3 MPS Burhi ka Nagla Good condition
4 SPS Burhi ka Nagla P-5 Good condition
5 SPS Manoharpur Good condition
6 Amar vihar-I Nala Tapping Good condition
7 Northern Zone Amar vihar-II Nala Tapping Good condition
8 Burhi ka Nagla Nala Tapping Good condition
9 Anurag Nagar Nala Tapping Good condition
10 ManoharpurNala tapping Good condition
11 78 MLD STP Dhandhupura Good condition Renovations required
12 MPS khairati Tola Good condition
13 SPS rajwah Good condition
14 SPS Balkeshwar Good condition
15 SPS Waterworks Good condition
16 SPS Subbalkeshwar Good condition
17 SPS Bhaironnala Good condition
18 SPS Khoja Nala Good condition
19 SPS Sanjay place Good condition
Central Zone
20 RajwahNala Tapping Good condition
21 BalkeshwarNala Tapping Good condition
22 Waterworks Nala Tapping Good condition
23 Krishna Colony Nala Tapping Good condition
24 Paliwal park Nala Tapping Good condition
25 BhaironNala Tapping Good condition
26 Khoja Nala Tapping Bad condition Renovation required
27 Peepal mandi Nala Tapping Bad condition Renovation required
28 MantolaNala Tapping Good condition
29 BaluganjNala Tapping Good condition
30 10 MLD STP Peelakhar Good condition
31 SPS Naraich Good condition
Supreme Court Order on TTZ Area regarding development of Eco-friendly, Sustainable projects.
1.2.
1.2.
Figure 1: Letter to Forest Department for required land for DSTPs (however presently 0.97 ha is required),
Peelipokhar & Indira Memorial DSTP is on AGRA development Authority land.
1.2.
Figure 2 request letter to Defense for approval for rising main work of khairati tola
1.2.
Figure 3: NOC requested from Railway Board for laying of rising main near to MPS Peelakhar
Figure 4: Proposed Artauni DSTP Figure 5: Proposed Jaganpur CSTP Figure 6: Proposed KK Mandir DSTP
Location Location Location
Figure 7: Proposed Location for DSTP Figure 8: Proposed Location for DSTP Figure 9: Proposed Location for MPS
@ Kamayani Hospital @ Mau nala I&II @ Nagla Budi
Figure 10: Proposed Location for Figure 11: Proposed Location for Figure 12: Proposed Location for
DSTP @ Baipur DSTP @ Pelipokhar DSTP @ Peelakhar
Figure 13: Proposed Location for CSTP @ Dhandupura (Option 1- TTZ tree Figure 14: Proposed Location for
area) CSTP @ Dhandupura- Option 2
(Private Land)
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
Consent to Operate construction work from the State Pollution Control of Pollution) work.
(CtO) Control Board Act, 1981.
The Water (Prevention
and Control of
Pollution) Act, 1974
As per information from UPJN, no utility
shifting is envisaged. However, in case of
urgent requirement occurs in the project
during execution stage, the following
measure shall be adopted by concessionaire:
Identify the common utilities to be affected
such as: telephone cables, electric cables,
electric poles, water pipelines, public tabs,
etc.
Identify and include list of affected utilities
and Concessionaires of these utilities in the
detailed design documents to prevent
Prospective Concessionaires in
unnecessary disruption of services during Concerned Pre-construction
collaboration and approval of
Utility Relocation construction phase. ESMF Guideline NMCG department / UP Jal & Construction
concerned department / UP Jal
Affected utilities shall be relocated with prior Nigam / SMCG phase
Nigam / SMCG
approval of the concerned agencies before
construction starts.
Provide advance notice (not less than 10
working days) to affected parties. The
advance notice shall be in the form of
written notice and a grievance redressal cell
shall be established for timely addressing of
grievances.
Bid document to include requirement for a
Contingency Plan for service interruptions
(For example provision of water if disruption
is more than 24 hours).
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
The identification of locations of labor camps
should be finalized prior to the start of
construction work. The raw material stacking
Pre-construction
Labor Camps/ area should be identified and get approved by SMCG/NMCG/Other
ESMF Guideline NMCG Contractor & Construction
Stacking yard the implementing agency prior to start of implementing agency
phase
construction work.
To avoid local dispute, preference should be
given to hire local Labour as much as possible.
Around 360mm rainfall recorded in year
2018 as maximum, which is quite good,
accordingly provision should be given for
adequate holding capacity for storage of ESMF Guideline NMCG
Provision of flood
sewage to prevent flow of untreated sewage Pre-construction
risk management, SMCG/NMCG/Other
into river. World Bank’s EHS Contractor & Construction
effective storm implementing agency
Suitable drainage provision should be made Guidelines for Water phase
water drainage
to divert the rain water likely to be and Sanitation
accumulated from peripheral catchment
area of STP, to natural drainage stream or
area.
The treated water quality shall comply with
the prescribed standards of the State
Pollution Control Board and NGT 2019
before let out into the ESMF Guideline NMCG Pre-construction,
stream/nallah/drain/open land/irrigation Construction and
Disposal of treated Prospective Concessionaires /
purposes. World Bank’s EHS YPCU / SMCG Post
waste water Contractors
Provision of effective separation and Guidelines for Water Construction
controlled disposal of digested sludge and Sanitation phase
Preference shall be given to reuse the
treated water in nearby agricultural field
available to DSTPs in Agra.
Safety measure for During COVID 19 Scenario, a Separate Safety Occupational Safety Prospective Concessionaires / Pre-construction,
YPCU / SMCG
COVID 19 Preparedness plan shall be prepared by and Health Contractors Construction
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
Pandemic issue Contractor before start of Work for COVID Administration (OSHA)
19. 2020
Criteria such as Initial health Screening w.r.t
COVID 19 Issue, vaccination (if available for
Migrant laborers) & avoid overage worker
deployment (above 60 yrs.) deployment at
site shall be added in the COVID 19 Safety
Plan.
Construction Stage
Concessionaire to prepare list of approved
quarry sites and sources of materials with
Vendor/Supplier
the approval of UP Jal Nigam / SMCG.
should have prior Prospective Concessionaires / Upon submission
Bid document to include requirement for
sources of approval for sand/ Contractors to finalize quarry of work plan by
verification of suitability of sources and
construction quarry material mining sites and sources of materials in YPCU / SMCG the
permit for additional quarry sites if
materials under Amended EIA consultation and approval of UP Concessionaire /
necessary. th
notification dated 15 Jal Nigam / SMCG Contractor.
The contractor has to procure aggregate
January, 2016.
from the identified authorized vendor who
has all the necessary approvals.
The construction materials shall be
stockpiled in designated areas only.
The contractor shall identify the site for
temporary use of land for construction sites /
Pre-construction,
storage of construction materials, etc. These
Storage of Construction and
sites shall be operated only after prior Prospective Concessionaires /
construction ESMF Guideline NMCG YPCU / SMCG Post
approval of the engineer. Contractors
materials Construction
Prioritize areas within or nearest possible
phase
vacant space in the project location.
Construction materials shall be stored on the
high laying areas and storing near to storm
water run-off channels or any low lying areas
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
to be avoided.
If it is deemed necessary to locate
elsewhere, consider sites that will not
promote instability and result in destruction
of property, vegetation, irrigation, and
drinking water supply systems.
The project sites shall be properly fenced
The World Bank Group
prior to the commencement of construction During
Fencing of project General EHS Guideline Prospective Concessionaires /
activities, to restrict public access. YPCU / SMCG Construction and
sites for Occupational Contractors
CSTPs areas are already fenced, new fencing Operation
Health and Safety.
will be required for DSTPs.
All work shall be done in feasible manner so
Site clearing and that minimal flora disturb.
grubbing and Lying Afforestation in 1:3 ratio in lieu of inevitable
of rising main, STP tree cutting shall be done by the contractor.
(Excavation, The plant species, suitable for local climate
cutting, back filling so native trees will be preferred in
and compaction afforestation. The concerned District Forest
)operations) Officer can be consulted for selection of
species and technical guidance, if required.
The Construction &
Excavated soil and construction debris shall
Demolition Waste
be suitably stored to filling back the
Management Rules,
excavated areas after placing the sewer lines.
2016.
Suitable site should be identified for safe
Disposal of
disposal of construction debris and
construction debris Prospective Concessionaires / During
excavated materials, in relatively low lying YPCU / SMCG
and excavated Contractors construction
areas, away from the water bodies,
materials
residential and agricultural fields, etc., and
got approved by the engineer.
Ensure the site shall be selected preferably
from barren, infertile lands. In case
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
agricultural land needs to be selected,
written consent from landowners (not
lessees) will be obtained for reuse of excess
spoils.
Care should be taken that dumped material
does not affect natural drainage system. The Plastic Waste
Top soil generated during various Management Rules,
construction activities shall be used for 2016.
agricultural purpose, planned land filling and
landscaping.
All the plastic/ cement bags should be stored
properly and should be disposed through
authorized vendor.
Care to be taken to store fuel and oil (if
required) at a place away from any drainage
Hazardous and
channel/nalla preferably to be stored in
Other Wastes
drums mounted on a concrete paved
(Management and
platform.
Transboundary
The contractor shall ensure that all
Movement) Rules,
constructions vehicle parking location, fuel /
2016
lubricants storage sites, vehicle machinery
During
Pollution from fuel and equipment. Maintenance and refueling Prospective Concessionaires /
The World Bank Group YPCU / SMCG Construction and
and lubricants sites will be located at least 500m from rivers Contractors
General EHS Guideline Operation
and irrigation canal/ponds.
for Occupational
Contractor will arrange for collection, storing
Health and Safety
and disposal of oily wastes to the pre-
identified disposal sites (list to be submitted
World Bank’s EHS
to Engineer) and approved by the engineer.
Guidelines for Water
All spills and collected petroleum products
and Sanitation
will be disposed off in accordance with
MoEF&CC and state PCB guidelines.
Air pollution for Although primary survey monitoring record The Environment Prospective Concessionaires / YPCU / SMCG During
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
emissions from the at Artoni and Dhandupura shows the Air (Protection) Act, 1986 Contractors Construction and
construction quality standard is falling within permissible The World Bank Group Operation
vehicles, limit, necessary safety precautionary General EHS Guideline
equipment and measures as mentioned below shall be taken for Occupational
machinery care of by concessionaire during construction Health and Safety
of the project.,
Water shall be sprinkled regularly to World Bank’s EHS
suppress airborne dusts from truck / dumper Guidelines for Water
movements particularly on unpaved and Sanitation
surfaces.
Damp down exposed soil and any stockpiled
material on site by water sprinkling
necessary during dry weather. Maintain of
log book too for the same.
Water Springing to be done on the excavated
area of STP, Sewer line as well SPS locations,
Tarpaulins shall be to cover sand and other
loose material when transported by trucks.
All heavy equipment and machinery shall be
fitted with air pollution control devices.
Maintain DG sets using at site should follow
enough Stack as per CPCB norms.
Maintain construction vehicles and obtain
“Pollution under Control” certificate from
concerned Authority.
Ambient Air Quality monitoring has to be
performed as per the Environmental
Monitoring Program.
The Concessionaire has to submit the
method statement to comply with Air Act,
1981 before construction.
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
Appropriate PPEs (Mask N-95) to be
provided to worker/labourer handling the
fine dust and construction material.
Transportation of materials to the site shall
be covered to avoid spillage of materials.
Ground water quality may get contaminated
due to leaching of waste water. So, the
The Environment
treated water quality shall comply with the
(Protection) Act, 1986
standards laid down by the CPCB for disposal During
Decline of ground Prospective Concessionaires /
onto land, water body or for irrigation use. YPCU / SMCG Construction and
water quality World Bank’s EHS Contractors
The extraction of ground water for Operation
Guidelines for Water
construction work should not be anticipated.
and Sanitation
If required, prior permission from the CGWB
is required
The Contractor shall avoid construction
works close to the streams or water bodies
during monsoon.
No construction camp shall be allowed near
to 100 m of River line, pond water bodies.
Proper barricading, bund protection shall be
done if work is closed to these regions.
The contractor shall take all precautionary World Bank’s EHS During
Water pollution Prospective Concessionaires /
measures to prevent the waste water Guidelines for Water YPCU / SMCG Construction and
from construction Contractors
generated during construction from entering and Sanitation Operation
into streams, water bodies or the irrigation
system. All waste arising from the project is
to be disposed off in the manner that is
acceptable by the Engineer.
STP operations shall take place only after
Consent to Operate (CTO) certificate is
accorded by the UPPCB and treated water
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
quality shall comply with the consent
conditions stipulated by UPPCB or at
minimum shall meet the discharge standards
depending on the type of receiving water
body (stream / nallah / drain / open land /
irrigation purpose, etc.).
Performance standards shall always be
maintained, ensuring efficient working
condition of treatment plant.
The contractor can utilize STP treated water,
if water quality meets the water quality
requirement for construction work.
The water Quality
should comply with
During
Sufficient supply of portable water at all the IS:10500(2012) norms MNCG/SMCG
Construction
Portable Water construction camp, active site, etc should be HAM Contractor /Implementing
phase/ Operation
provided and maintained. World Bank’s EHS agency
Phase
Guidelines for Water
and Sanitation
Garland drain shall be constructed within the ESMF Guideline
During
premises of proposed STP and MPS to avoid
Flooding of Prospective Concessionaires / Construction and
flooding in premises and neighborhood area World Bank’s EHS YPCU / SMCG
adjacent areas Contractors Operation
in case of storm water during monsoon. Guidelines for Water
phases
Stockpiled areas shall be bordered by berms. and Sanitation
Provide curtains or sound barriers (poly
sheets / GI sheets) all around the
Increased noise During
construction site.
level due to Prospective Concessionaires / Construction and
Proper maintenance of construction YPCU / SMCG
construction Contractors Operation
equipment and vehicles. THE NOISE POLLUTION
activities phases
The Concessionaire has to submit the (REGULATION AND
method statement to comply with Noise CONTROL) RULES, 2000
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
Rules as per EP Act, 1986 before
construction.
Construction activities to be carried out in day The World Bank Group
time with prior intimation to local residents. General EHS Guideline
Construction activities particularly near for Occupational
sensitive zones like schools and colleges to Health and Safety
be carried out during vacations and the
works near hospitals to be completed on
priority basis (in short time period with
alternate provision of traffic, accessibility of
exit / entry gates, etc.).
DG Sets to be used at site should have
acoustic enclosure.
Proper PPEs (ear muff) shall be provided to
worker having long time noise generated
heavy work etc.
All the construction activities should be
carried out during the day time i.e 10:00 A.M
to 6:00 P.M No nights time work should be
allowed.
DG sets will be provided with acoustic
enclosures.
The Stack height of the D.G set should be
maintained as per the CPCB guideline for
Noise pollution due The World Bank Group During
noise abatement.
to operation of General EHS Guideline Prospective Concessionaires / Construction and
The D.G set should be thickly padded as YPCU / SMCG
pumps and for Occupational Contractors Operation
abatement to vibration pollution.
machineries Health and Safety phases
No night time construction work should be
anticipated
Green belt / two rows tree plantation and
landscaping will be developed along the
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
periphery of the STP and SPS which will
attenuate noise.
Pump station in STP shall ensure minimum
noise generation by locating within a noise
reducing structure or in an enclosed space
(such as concrete/brick structure).
Equipment’s need to meet the noise
standards as prescribed by CPCB12.
Ambient Air Quality monitoring with respect
to Noise should be carried out at all the
construction site, stacking yard, loading and
unloading area, etc as per the general and
specific condition of CtE.
To avoid the problems of foul smell polluted ESMF Guideline
air, insects, noise pollution and other problems During
Prospective Concessionaires /
Odour buffer zones to be provided in the form of World Bank’s EHS YPCU / SMCG Construction and
Contractors
green belt around the STP site, this has to be Guidelines for Water Operation
strictly ensured. and Sanitation
The 15 cm top soil should be stored at
designated location within the site. It should be
Protection of soil
stabilized using seeding and mulching as Prospective Concessionaires / During
and Environmental ESMF Guideline YPCU / SMCG
preventive measures. Contractors construction
enhancing
it can be used for gardening purposes at STP
site as an environmental enhancing measure.
The backfilling material shall be free from
Settlement of During
petroleum products, slag, cinders, ash or Prospective Concessionaires /
backfilled area ESMF Guideline YPCU / SMCG Construction and
other material. Contractors
after construction Operation
Backfilling activity should strictly follow the
12 http://moef.gov.in/citizen/specinfo/noise.html
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
construction schedule.
Proper compaction as per the soil condition
and retain the original level/ alignment.
The contractor shall provide, erect and
maintain informatory /safety signs, hoardings During
Information signs Prospective Concessionaires /
written in English and local languages, YPCU / SMCG Construction and
and hoardings Contractors
whatever required or as suggested by the Operation
Engineer.
Appropriate Traffic Management Plan shall
be prepared and implemented by the
Concessionaire after necessary approval of
SMCG / NMCG.
Temporary diversion will be provided with
the approval of the engineer. Detailed traffic
control plans will be prepared and submitted
to the engineers for approval, at least two
weeks prior to commencement of works.
Pre-construction,
Construction activities at commercial /
Construction and
Planning business and market areas must be Prospective Concessionaires /
ESMF guideline YPCU / SMCG Post
temporary traffic completed on war footing basis to minimize Contractors
Construction
business loss.
phase
The traffic control and plans shall contain
details of temporary diversion, details of
traffic arrangements after cessation of work
each day, SIGNAGES, safety measures for
transport of hazardous materials and
arrangements of flagmen.
Any accidents and/or risk of inconveniences
caused to the community shall be borne by
the Contractor.
Disposal of treated The treated effluent Prospective Concessionaires / Pre-construction,
The treated water quality shall comply with YPCU / SMCG
waste water shall comply with Contractors Construction and
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
the prescribed standards of the State schedule –VI (General Operation phase
Pollution Control Board and NGT before let Standard for Discharge
out into the stream/nallah/drain/open of Environmental
land/irrigation purposes, and necessary pollutants Part –A :
permission to be obtained from the Effluents as per the
concerned department. CPCB Guidelines.
Ensure efficient working condition or
treatment plant. World Bank’s Group
Prevent the pollution of stream water and Environmental, Health,
other water bodies receiving STP discharge. and Safety Guidelines
for Water and
Sanitation.
& the World Bank
Group Environmental,
Health and Safety
(EHS) Guideline
General.
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
identify specific site for intermittent storage
of waste from SPS and STP sites.
Concessionaire shall sign a Memorandum of
Understanding (MoU) with the concerned
competent authority prior to the disposal of
sludge at available landfill site authorized by
MC/ULB.
Concessionaire shall be responsible to get
the Bio chemical quality check of dried
sludge before handling to farmer or using as
soil conditioner in nearby area. The sludge
disposal standard as per CPHEEO 2016.
Compensatory plantation of at least thrice
the number of trees felled should be done in
line with competent authority guidelines. Pre-construction,
Compensatory
The Contractor shall take reasonable Construction and
plantation of trees/ Prospective Concessionaires /
precautions to prevent his workmen or any YPCU / SMCG Post
protection of Flora Contractors
other persons from removing and damaging Construction
, Fauna
any flora (plant/vegetation) and fauna phase
(animal) including restriction of fishing in any
water body and hunting of any animal.
Concessionaire/Contractor shall follow all
relevant provisions of the Factories Act,
1948, the Building and the other
Construction Workers (Regulation of Building and the
Employment and Conditions of Service) Act, Construction Workers
Construction of Prospective Concessionaires / During the
1996 and World Bank’s Accommodation (Regulation of YPCU / SMCG
labour camps Contractors Construction
Processes and Standards for construction Employment and
and maintenance of labour camp. Conditions of Service)
Though the project is located in dense urban Act, 1996
area, so provision of construction camp near
to the site is not advisable and feasible. World Bank’s
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
While during construction phase, local labour Accommodation
shall be preferred for construction activities. Processes and
However, location of construction camp shall Standards
be finalized not close to 1 km vicinity of
dense habitation.
Concessionaire/Contractor shall follow all
relevant provisions of the Factories Act, 1948
and the other Construction Workers
(Regulation of Employment and Conditions
of Service) Act, 1996 for construction and
maintenance of labour camp.
The location, layout and basic facility
provision of each labour camp will be
submitted to Engineer prior to their
construction.
The construction will commence only upon
the written approval of the Engineer.
The contractor shall maintain necessary
living accommodation and ancillary facilities
in functional and hygienic manner and as
approved by the engineer.
All temporary accommodation must be
constructed and maintained in such a fashion
that uncontaminated water is available for
drinking, cooking and washing.
The sewage system for the camp must be
planned. Adequate health care is to be
provided for the work force. The layout of
the construction camp and details of the
facilities provided should be prepared shall
be approved by the engineer. The
construction camp shall not be located
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
within 1000m from the nearest water
stream, residential areas and / or any
sensitive land uses like schools, hospitals,
etc.
Labour Management Plan shall also be
prepared and implemented by the
Concessionaire after necessary approval of
SMCG / NMCG.
Settling up of labour camps needs to be done
as per all relevant provisions of the Factories
Act, 1948, the Building and the other
Construction Workers (Regulation of
Employment and Conditions of Service) Act,
1996 and World Bank’s Accommodation
Processes and Standards. Adequate potable
Building and the
water facilities, sanitation and drainage etc.,
Construction Workers
in conformity with the Indian labour laws
(Regulation of
shall be ensured. The contractor shall also
Employment and
guarantee the following: During Pre-
Conditions of Service)
Labour camp & The location, layout and basic facility Prospective Concessionaires / construction and
Act, 1996 YPCU / SMCG
facilities provision of each labour camp will be Contractors Construction
submitted to Engineer prior to their phase
World Bank’s
construction.
Accommodation
The construction will commence only upon
Processes and
the written approval of the Engineer.
Standards
The contractor shall construct and maintain
all labour accommodation in such a fashion
that uncontaminated water is available for
drinking, cooking and washing.
The provision of good drinking water and
sanitation facility shall be plan of
construction safety plan. It is the
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
responsibility of contractor for Sufficient
supply of potable water (as per IS: 10500) at
workplace.
Separate Washrooms for female labour must
be constructed at the labour camps and each
construction sites.
The sewage system for the camp are
designed, built and operated in such fashion
that no health hazards occurs and no
pollution to the air, ground water or adjacent
water courses take place. Ensure adequate
water supply is to be provided in all toilets
and urinals.
The contractor shall take all required
precautions to prevent danger from Building and the
electrical equipment and ensure that – Construction Workers
No material shall be stacked or placed as to (Regulation of
cause danger or inconvenience to any person Employment and
or the public. Conditions of Service)
All necessary fencing and lights will be Act, 1996
provided to protect the public in
construction zones. During
Risk from Electrical Prospective Concessionaires /
All machines to be used in the construction YPCU / SMCG Construction and
Equipment Contractors
will conform to the relevant Indian Standards Operation
(IS) codes, will be free from patent defect, The World Bank Group
will be kept in good working order, will be Environmental, Health
regularly inspected and properly maintained and Safety (EHS)
as per IS provision and to satisfaction of the Guideline General for
Engineer. Occupational Health
OHS Management Plan shall also be and Safety.
prepared and implemented by the
Concessionaire after necessary approval of
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
SMCG / NMCG
Adequate precautions shall be taken to
prevent the accidents and from the
machineries. All machines used shall confirm
to the relevant Indian standards code and
shall be regularly inspected.
The excavation and loose soil shall be
maintained with the provisions of shoring
trench sides by placing sheeting, timber
shores, trench jacks, bracing, piles, etc. to
avoid collapse of soil.
Exposed surface shall be resurfaced and
Building and the
stabilized on priority basis.
Construction Workers
Protective footwear and protective goggles
(Regulation of
to all workers employed on mixing of
Employment and
materials like cement, concrete etc.
Conditions of Service) Prospective Concessionaires / During
Safety aspects Welder’s protective eye shields shall be YPCU / SMCG
Act, 1996 Contractors construction
provided to workers who are engaged in
welding works.
World Bank’s EHS
Earplugs shall be provided to workers
Guidelines for Water
exposed to loud noise, and workers working
and Sanitation
in crushing, compaction, or concrete mixing
operation.
The contractor shall supply all necessary
safety appliances such as safety goggles,
helmets, safety belts, ear plugs, mask etc. to
workers and staffs.
The contractor will comply with all the
precautions as required for ensuring the
safety of the workmen as per the
International Labour Organization (ILO)
convention No. 62 as far as those are
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
applicable to this contract. The contractor
will make sure that during the construction
work all relevant provisions of the factories
act, 1948 and Building and other Conditions
of Services) Act, 1996 are adhered to.
The contractor will not employ any person
below the age 14 years.
Contractor shall be responsible to provide following
safety arrangement for COVID 19 issue
A basic Health screening of all new workers shall
be carried out before deployment (Risk of serious
illness rises with age wise).
Avoid over aged (more than 60 years old) workers
deployment in Project area during COVID-19.
If available, ensure vaccination to all workers
against COVID 19 pandemic.
Always ensure all workplaces are clean and
hygienic,
Promote regular and thorough hand-washing by Occupational Safety
Safety Alertness on all workers with any soap or Alcohol based hand During
and Health Prospective Concessionaires /
the site due to COVID rub YPCU / SMCG Construction and
19 pandemic Disease Regular Sanitization shall be carried out in all Administration (OSHA) Contractors
Operation phase
workplace, common areas, equipment, handle, 2020
railing etc..
Promote good respiratory hygiene in the
Workplace.
Wearing of a face mask is compulsory to all
workers during this period of COVID 19.
Always maintain sufficient gap between workers /
staff as per mentioned in the guidelines (Min 1m
interval)
All kinds of Social Gathering must be avoided.
There will be strict ban on the use of Gutka’,
‘Tambaku’, ‘Paan’ etc. at work sites and spitting
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
shall be strictly prohibited as well.
Entire construction site including site office,
labour camp, canteens, pathways, toilets, and
entry / exit gates must be disinfected on a basis.
Housekeeping team should be provided with all
necessary equipment/tools.
Encourage workers to stay home if they are sick.
Avoid large gatherings or meetings (Eg : TBT/ Site
/ Office committee meeting) . Maintain at least 1
metre (3 feet) distance from persons.
Especially with those having flu-like symptoms,
during interaction. Not more than 2/4 persons
(depending on size) should be allowed to travel in
lifts or hoists. Use of staircase (Height works) for
climbing should be encouraged for manual
concrete work.
Appropriate signage shall be installed at
construction sites, spelling out safety practices in
the language which is understood by all.
Organize regular awareness program on COVID
19.
Employers should inform and encourage
employees to self-monitor for signs and
symptoms of COVID-19 if they suspect possible
exposure.
Providing workers with up-to-date education and
training on COVID-19 risk factors and protective
behaviors (e.g., cough etiquette and care of PPE).
Rest area should be maintained in good hygienic
with regular cleaning and sanitization.
During the activity, meetings, events
Develop and agree a preparedness plan
to prevent infection at meeting or
event.
Provide information or a briefing, preferably
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
both orally and in writing, on COVID-19 and the
measures that organizers are taking to make this
event safe for workers
If anyone who starts to feel
unwell, follow your preparedness
plan.
Common Area/ Construction vehicle
& Activities
All vehicle need to be sanitized regularly and
advise workers / Staff need to maintain the gaps (
1m interval minimum) .
All vehicles and machinery entering the premise
should be disinfected by spray mandatorily.
Non-touch garbage bins with biodegradable
garbage bag should be installed for waste
collection at all common access areas. Proper
disposal of garbage bags along with daily cleaning
and sanitization of bins should be ensured.
Wipe down interiors and door handle of machines
or construction vehicles, the handles of
equipment and tools that are shared, with
disinfectant prior to using.
Maintaining the social distance during material
shifting
The contractor shall arrange for:
Readily available first aid units including an Building and the
adequate supply of sterilized dressing Construction Workers
materials and appliances as per the Factories (Regulation of Prospective Concessionaires / During
First Aid YPCU / SMCG
Rules I every work zone. Employment and Contractors Construction
Availability of suitable transport at all times Conditions of Service)
to take injured or sick persons to the nearest Act, 1996
hospital.
If any impacts on livelihood of any permanent UP Jal Nigam / SMCG / NMCG / YPCU / Pre-construction
Livelihood ESMF Guideline
shop owners, licensed kiosks noticed during Prospective Concessionaire SMCG & Construction
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
construction, then should be compensated phase
according to the Entitlement Matrix of ESMF.
No construction is envisaged near to
regulatory zone of ASI Monuments, however
contractor shall ensure that no disturbance
activity to be undertaken near to sensitive
zones. ESMF Guideline
Precautionary Signage to be provided. It should also comply
Protection near to Pre-construction
Sensitization among worker shall be with the World Banks NMCG / YPCU /
historical Concessionaire & Construction
undertaken for awareness about significance Operational Policy SMCG
Monuments phase
of monuments and penalties prescribed (O.P) 4.11 – Physical
under Ancient Monuments and Cultural Resources.
Archaeological Sites and Remains Rules 1959
and Ancient Monuments and Archaeological
Sites and Remains (Amendment and
Validation) Act 2010.
If any temporary/Permanent impact on
residential structures, Land and assets will be Pre-construction
Impact on UP Jal Nigam / SMCG / NMCG / YPCU /
occurred during construction, then should be ESMF Guideline & Construction
Community Prospective Concessionaire SMCG
compensated according to the Entitlement phase
Matrix of ESMF.
Community Consultations shall be conducted
at all the project locations, all the project
locations and in nearby residential and ESMF Guideline
Possible conflicts market area. prior to the initiation of
Pre-construction
with and/or construction activities. World Bank’s UP Jal Nigam / SMCG / NMCG / YPCU /
& Construction
disruption to local All possible disputes during construction Accommodation Prospective Concessionaire SMCG
phase
community work shall be avoided by hiring of local Processes and
labour as much as possible. Standards
In case of migrant labour hiring, the
fundamental facility in labour camp shall be
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
ensured by contractor to avoid further
disputes.
A grievance Register must be maintained and
monitored at each of the construction site. During
Grievance UP Jal Nigam / SMCG / NMCG / YPCU /
Contact details of designated Grievance ESMF Guideline Construction and
Redressal Prospective Concessionaire SMCG
Redressal Officer (GRO) must be displayed at Operation
the each construction site.
Employ female in construction and other
project related activities.
A gender disaggregated details of labourers
shall be maintained in register at all the
projects sites.
Female participation in O&M, Monitoring &
Evaluation processes
Training & Capacity Building of project staff
Gender focusing on Labour Standards
Assessment and Orientation of project staff, contractors and
Development other stakeholders regarding Gender
Sensitive issues and Gender development
indicators.
Subproject design should be Gender
responsive.
Preparation and development of IEC
(Information, Education and Communication)
material in the local language on gender
equality.
Mandatory and repeated training and ESMF Guideline
Pre-construction,
Gender Based awareness raising for the workforce about UP Jal Nigam / SMCG /
NMCG / YPCU / During
Violence refraining from unacceptable conduct Sexual Harassment of Prospective
SMCG Construction and
(GBV) toward local community members, Women at Work Place Concessionaire/Contractor
Operation phase
specifically women (Prevention,
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
Informing workers about national laws that Prohibition and
make sexual harassment and gender-based Redressal) Act, 2013
violence a punishable offence which is
prosecuted;
Introducing a Worker Code of Conduct as
part of the employment contract and
including sanctions for non-compliance (e.g.,
termination),
Contractors adopting a policy to cooperate
with law enforcement agencies in
investigating complaints about gender-based
violence.
A small transport allowance, ideally allowing
workers to regularly return for brief visits to
their families, spouses, and friends,
ICC committees addressing GBV and GRM
need to be constituted at EA, SPMG and
NMCG level.
Prepare IEC material in the local language for
policy against Sexual harassment at
workplace and display in strategic locations
Capacity Building of Social and Environment
Specialists and project officials and project
staff on GBV to be organized at regular
intervals.
Inclusion of consequences of GBV in safety
induction.
A Grievance Register must be maintained in
Project offices and at each Construction site
followed by the Status of GBV Complaints -
Total cases, Resolved, Pending, and Type of
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
action taken.
The Contractor shall prepare site restoration
plans that shall be approved by the Engineer.
The plan shall be implemented by the
Contractor prior to demobilization.
On completion of the works, all temporary During the
Construction guideline NMCG / YPCU /
Site Restoration structures shall be cleared away, all rubbish Prospective Concessionaire closure of
MOEF & CC SMCG
burnt, excreta or other disposal pits or Construction
trenches filled in and effectively sealed off
and the site left clean and tidy, at the
Contractor’s expense, to the entire
satisfaction of the Engineer.
Inclusion of Environmental & Social Monitoring Plan shall
During
Environmental & be included in the detailed ESAMP prepared ESMF Guideline NMCG Prospective Concessionaire /
UP Jal Nigam / SMCG Construction and
Social Monitoring and implemented by the Concessionaire Contractors
Operation phase
Plan after necessary approval of SMCG / NMCG.
Operation Stage
Comply with applicable condition of CTO, ESMF Guideline
Maintaining treated water shall meet the NGT standard of
treated waste treated waste water quality strictly. World Bank’s EHS
water quality Follow standard operating procedures for Guidelines for Water
operation and maintenance. and Sanitation
Bid document to include requirement for an
effective action plan to avoid and/or
immediate clearance of such leakages, ESMF Guideline
Leakages,
blockages and overflow.
blockages and Prospective Concessionaires /
Implementation of regular O&M schedules. World Bank’s EHS YPCU / SMCG During Operation
overflow issues in Contractors
Regular monitoring of sewer line manhole Guidelines for Water
sewers
leakages/ overflows should be done. and Sanitation
Proper emergency plan shall be in place in
STP area.
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
Adequate green belt / tree plantation and
landscaping will be developed along the
periphery of the STP and SPS will reduce the
ESMF Guideline
negative impact of odour.
Spraying of water will be done on the odour
Prospective Concessionaires /
Odour control creating units. YPCU / SMCG During Operation
World Bank’s EHS Contractors
Spraying of herbicides like Maple and Gtech
Guidelines for Water
on accumulated sludge/solid waste will
and Sanitation
reduce the negative impact of odour.
Monitoring will be done on Ambient Air
Quality around STP site.
Instead of disposing digested sludge it shall
be provided to the local farmers for
agriculture purpose, and/or to the local
authorities to use as manure for landscaping
purposes in city level / district level.
Suitable site should be identified for the safe
disposal of sludge generated at the STP and
CPHEEO; Manual on
got approved by the Engineer. Prepare a
Sewerage and Sewage
Sludge Disposal Plan and adheres to the
Treatment Systems - During
same. Prospective Concessionaires /
Disposal of sludge 2013 YPCU / SMCG Construction and
A logbook for sludge disposal shall be Contractors
Operation
maintained at STP sites.
World Bank’s EHS
Provision for regular clearance of sludge and
Guidelines for Water
solid waste to minimize odor nuisance
and Sanitation
pumping station areas
Periodic disposal of accumulated
sludge/solid waste to designated land fill
sites of the city (Kuberpur Dumping site of
MC Agra)
Concessionaire shall be responsible for
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
dumping of surplus sludge on authorized
dumping site of MC/ULB, the development &
Maintenance of sludge disposal site shall also
be done regularly by project concessionaire.
After having testing of heavy /toxic content
of the sludge, priority to be made by
contractor under supervision with YPCU for
handing over sludge/ manure to nearby local
farmer.
YPCU and Contractor to undertake
sensitization program about importance of
sludge and safe use of sludge in agricultural
practices with local farmer.
An MOU with authorized local body
(MC/ULB) shall be required by
concessionaire for developing suitably
dumping ground for sludge at identified area
(if not provided by UPJN).
DG sets will be provided with acoustic
enclosures.
Green belt / tree plantation and landscaping ESMF Guideline
Noise pollution due During
will be developed along the periphery of the
to operation of Prospective Concessionaires / Construction and
STP and SPS which will attenuate noise. World Bank’s EHS YPCU / SMCG
pumps and Contractors Operation
Pump station in STP shall ensure minimum Guidelines for Water
machineries phases
noise generation by locating within a noise and Sanitation
reducing structure or in an enclosed space
(such as concrete/brick structure).
For Chlorination System the following
World Bank’s EHS
Protective mitigation measures will be in place to arrest/ Prospective Concessionaires /
Guidelines for Water YPCU / SMCG During Operation
Equipment’s identify any leakage of chlorine Contractors
and Sanitation
Neutralization System.
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
Leak Detection System.
Ventilation System
Appropriate personal protection equipment
(PPE) including oxygen masks will be provided
for personnel working in plants where there is
a risk due to harmful gaseous emissions
[Hydrogen sulphide (H2S), Carbon Monoxide
(CO), Methane (CH4), etc.].
Mechanised system and trained people shall
be deployed to run the Pumping Stations and
STPs to reduce the risk of safety hazards.
Handrails on both sides of walkways close to
deeper tanks and STPs needs to be ensured.
Smaller on and off switches at STP units to
be installed with protection from rain water
to minimize electrical short circuit
All personnel engaged in plant will be
provided safety clothing and Personal ESMF Guideline
Protective Equipment’s (PPE) and also
Prospective Concessionaires /
Safety measures trained to implement Occupational Health World Bank’s EHS YPCU / SMCG During Operation
Contractors
and Safety (OHS). Guidelines for Water
OHS Management Plan shall also be and Sanitation
prepared and implemented by the
Concessionaire after necessary approval of
SMCG / NMCG
Chlorine will be stored in accordance with
safety standards and regulations in force.
Operating staff will be provided induction
training on safe handling, storage and
precautions in use of hazardous materials.
Also directions will be given regarding
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
Chlorine emergency repair kits, and other
emergency procedures.
Leak detecting arrangements will be properly
provided in the plant.
Storage of large quantity of Chlorine will be
avoided and only procured based on need
and accurate inventory will be maintained.
Only approved instruments should be used
for lifting and opening cylinders.
Appropriate personal protection equipment
(PPE) including oxygen masks will be
provided for personnel cleaning
underground sewers where there is a risk
due to oxygen deficiency and harmful
gaseous emissions [Hydrogen sulphide (H2S),
Carbon Monoxide (CO), Methane (CH4), etc.].
The contact details of police station,
ambulance services and fire stations nearby
to the site shall be displayed.
A basic Health screening of all new workers
shall be carried out before deployment (Risk
of serious illness rises with age wise).
Avoid over aged (more than 60 years old)
workers deployment in Project area during Occupational Safety
During
Safety Precautions COVID-19. and Health Prospective Concessionaires /
YPCU / SMCG Construction and
COVID 19 Scenario If available, ensure vaccination to all worker Administration (OSHA) Contractors
Operation phase
against COVID 19 pandemic. 2020
Always ensure all workplaces are clean and
hygienic,
Promote regular and thorough hand-washing
by all workers with any soap or Alcohol
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
based hand rub
Regular Sanitization shall be carried out in all
workplace, common areas, equipments,
handle, railing etc..
Promote good respiratory hygiene in the
Workplace.
Wearing of a face mask is compulsory to all
workers during this period of COVID 19.
Always maintain sufficient gap between
workers / staff as per mentioned in the
guidelines (Min 1m interval)
All kinds of Social Gathering must be
avoided.
Entire office, Lab, canteens, pathways,
toilets, and entry / exit gates must be
disinfected on a basis. Housekeeping team
should be provided with all necessary
equipment/tools.
Encourage workers to stay home if they are
sick.
Avoid large gatherings or meetings (Eg : TBT/
Site / Office committee meeting) . Maintain
at least 1 metre (3 feet) distance from
persons.
Appropriate signage shall be installed at
construction sites, spelling out safety
practices in the language which is
understood by all.
Develop and agree a preparedness
plan to prevent infection at meeting
or event.
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
.Organize regular awareness program on
COVID 19.
Employers should inform and encourage
employees to self-monitor for signs and
symptoms of COVID-19 if they suspect
possible exposure.
Providing workers with up-to-date education
and training on COVID-19 risk factors and
protective behaviors (e.g., cough etiquette
and care of PPE).
All vehicle need to be sanitized regularly and
advise workers / Staff need to maintain the
gaps ( 1m interval minimum) .
Non-touch garbage bins with biodegradable
garbage bag should be installed for waste
collection at all common access areas.
Proper disposal of garbage bags along with
daily cleaning and sanitization of bins should
be ensured.
Wipe down interiors and door handle of
machines or construction vehicles, the
handles of equipment and tools that are
shared, with disinfectant prior to using.
Maintaining the social distance during
material shifting
Inclusion of Environmental & Social Monitoring Plan shall
During
Environmental & be included in the detailed ESAMP prepared ESMF Guideline NMCG Prospective Concessionaire /
UP Jal Nigam / SMCG Construction and
Social Monitoring and implemented by the Concessionaire Contractors
Operation phase
Plan after necessary approval of SMCG / NMCG.
During
Grievance The name and contact information of UP Jal Nigam / SMCG / NMCG / UP Jal Nigam
ESMF Guideline NMCG Construction and
Redressal Grievance Redressal Officers (GROs) should Prospective Concessionaire / SMCG
Operation
Responsible for
Potential Impacts Mitigation Measures Reference Responsible for Implementation Time Frame
Monitoring
be displayed at the project/construction site,
labour camps, in communities where
construction work is taking place and in the
websites of ULB, EA and SMCG.
A grievance Register must be maintained and
monitored at each of the construction site.
Also, a toll free number should be generated
and displayed in work sites and websites of
ULB, EA and SMCG for registering grievances.
Mandatory training’s for the workforce on
the GBV grievance redressal mechanism for
reporting and response of GBV incidents
Training should be imparted to the
stakeholders, Implementing Agencies and
Contractor regarding identification,
reporting, recording and resolving the GBV
cases.
Revised Detailed Project Report for Agra Sewerage Scheme (I&D Works) has been prepared in compliance
with order of Project Director, SMCG, Lucknow vide letter No. 1343/SMCG/0394-T/07 & DG. NMCG, New
Delhi D.O. No. Pr.-110135/5/2018-O/o Dir. (T-III) NMCG, dated 18.09.2019.
Revised Detailed Project Report for Agra Sewerage Scheme (I&D Works) has been prepared in
compliance with order of Project Director, SMCG, Lucknow vide letter No. 1343/SMCG/0394-T/07
Figure 15: Ceiling concentration of heavy metals in treated sewage sludge for use in Agriculture
For dewatered septage/sludge agriculture application, it should satisfy the following criteria of Class A
Biosolids of US EPA either by lime stabilization, solar drying and or composting.
• A faecal coliform density of less than 1,000 MPN/g total dry solids
• Salmonella sp. density of less than 3 MPN per 4 g of total dry solids (3 MPN/4 g TS)
ANNEXURE 11: STP CAPACITY ESTIMATION (BASED ON PRESENT & PROJECTED POPULATION)
1.4.
ANNEXURE12: DRAIN DISCHARGE CAPACITY MEASUREMENT (AS PER DPR)
1.3.
1.3.
1.3.
Figure 17: Map showing Nala tapped and Untapped and total I&D provisions
Figure 18: map showing Existing & Proposed DSTPs & STPs
1.6.
ANNEXURE 14: MINUTES OF MEETINGS
Minutes of Meetings
1. Public Consultation held at Yamuna Pollution Control Unit (YPCU) office, Agra
Number of participants: 6
Attended by:
Project Manager (Civil),
Project Manager (Planning),
Asst. Engineer, Junior Engineer and
Other support staff
A detailed discussion was held on total scope of the projects, approvals/ permission required for
the project from different agencies under cantonment board and railway board. It also included
discussion on total impacted area of the forest, required process for online procedures.
The options for land finalizations (TTZ zone and forest area) was also discussed.
The officials of YPCU, Agra intimated that STP treated water and sludge from Jaganpur is being
used by farmers of Dayalbagh Community.
It was further informed by the officials that presently extra sludge is being dumped in Kuberpur
MC’s Dumping ground.
Suggestion was also provided by the officials to get an MOU with the MC for proper sludge
dumping area.
Number of participants: 5
Attended by:
Junior engineer (YPCU), Concessionaire and Staff of STP
The public consultation meeting was initiated by welcoming the participants and briefed them
about the agenda of the meeting. Consultation was conducted with community people of
Dhandupura & Jaganpur STP. Further the meeting was carried forward by presenting the details
about the proposed STP project, present status of river Ganga, stake-holder participation during
the project, etc. A brief summary of all the important points discussed during the meeting are
mentioned in the following points:
The laws, regulations and World Bank Safeguard policies applicable to the project were
discussed.
It was discussed to safeguard and minimize any possible negative impact on the socio-cultural
beliefs and traditions of the local communities regarding river Ganga, while implementing the
sub-projects
All safety and precautionary measures must be taken to avoid any accidents during the
construction phase of the projects.
It was intimated by the officials that farmers which are residing in outskirts of Agra city takes
dry sludge/manure from the STP between March to May season every year.
The farmers were not available in the STP for consultation because it was a post monsoon
season and off season for crop sowing.
Date: 11th December 2019 and 4th February 2020 Time: 12:00 noon; 1:25 pm
Number of participants: 20
Attended by:
UP Jal Nigam: Ms. Anuja Driwedi (Assistant Engineer) and Sh. Mohammad (Junior
Engineer)
21 Community people (list attached)-5 on 11th & 12th Dec 2019 and 17 on 4th Feb 2020
The public consultation meeting was initiated by welcoming the participants and briefed them
1.5.
about the agenda of the meeting. Consultation was conducted with community people of Artoni
and Waipur (nearby proposed STP). Further the meeting was carried forward by presenting the
details about the proposed STP project, present status of river Ganga, stake-holder participation
during the project, etc. A brief summary of all the important points discussed during the meeting
are mentioned in the following points:
Discussion was held in length about the purpose of the project and how it is beneficial for
the State as well as the nearby communities.
The laws, regulations and World Bank Safeguard policies applicable to the project were
discussed.
Safety and precautionary measures were discussed to avoid any accidents during the
construction phase of the projects.
Community people welcomed the initiative of major Nala Tapping and onsite treatment
facility to cater the pollution in the River Yamuna.
Community people suggested providing continuous and regular mechanism to create
education and awareness among the people, particularly the younger generation about
the importance of keeping river clean.
Further, ccommunity showed enthusiasm about the project and expressed their
willingness to work in the construction phase of the project.
The meeting was concluded with vote of thanks given by Sh. Mohammad
Number of participants: 20
Attended by:
UP Jal Nigam: Sh. Chanderhas (Project Engineer), Sh. P.K Yadav (Project Engineer) and Sh.
Mohammad (Junior Engineer)
Number of participants: 17 Community people (list attached)
The public consultation meeting commenced by welcoming the participants and briefed them
about the agenda of the meeting. Consultation was conducted with community people of
Transport Nagar (nearby proposed STP). Further the meeting was carried forward by presenting
the details about the proposed STP project, present status of river Ganga, stake-holder
participation during the project, etc. A brief summary of all the important points discussed during
the meeting are mentioned in the following points:
Discussion was held in length about the purpose of the project and how it is beneficial for the
State as well as the nearby communities.
The laws, regulations and World Bank Safeguard policies applicable to the project were
discussed.
Safety and precautionary measures were discussed to avoid any accidents during the
construction phase of the projects.
Community people were enthusiastic about the project and expressed their willingness to
work in the construction phase.
It was suggested by the community people to improve the aesthetics of the area through
project establishment
It was suggested by the community people to S improve the aesthetics of the area along with
the project establishment
The meeting was concluded with vote of thanks given by Sh. Mohammad.
1.5.
Attendance Sheet of the Consultation conducted with community people at Transport Nagar
1.5.
5. 1.5.
Public Consultation held at Burhi Ka Nagla
Number of participants: 15
Attended by:
UP Jal Nigam: Sh. Chanderhas (Project Engineer), Sh. P.K Yadav (Project Engineer) and Sh.
Mohammad (Junior Engineer)
Number of participants: 15 Community people (list attached)
The public consultation meeting was initiated by welcoming the participants and briefed them
about the agenda of the meeting. Consultation was conducted with community people of Burhi Ka
Nagla. Further the meeting was carried forward by presenting the details about the proposed DSTP
project, present status of river Ganga, stakeholder participation during the project, etc. A brief
summary of all the important points discussed during the meeting are mentioned in the following
points:
Discussion in length about the purpose of the project and how it is beneficial for the State as
well as the nearby communities.
The laws and regulations as well as World Bank Safeguard policies applicable to the project
were discussed.
Safety and precautionary measures were discussed to avoid any accidents during the
construction phase of the projects.
Community people expressed the problem of foul smell from the existing STP and suggested
plantation of trees to reduce the foul smell.
Community residents expressed their willingness to work in the construction phase of the
project.
1.5.
Attendance Sheet of the Consultation conducted with community people at Transport Nagar
1.5.
1.6.
Annexure 15: MOU between UP Jal Nigam & MC Agra for dumping of extra
sludge and garbage
MOU between UP Jal Nigam (implementing agency) & Municipal Corporation Agra for dumping of extra
sludge and garbage
1.6.
ANNEXURE 16: Office Memorandum 24.10.2019 Regarding CPA Management
1.5.
1.5.
1.5.
1.5.
1.5.