Fishing Technology
Fishing Technology
& Practices
K K Verma
Fishing Operation
Fishing is any operation or
procedure:
• To release, remove or
recover.
• Tubulars or other
material in the hole
• That adversely affects
drilling, casing or
completion operations.
Fishing Operation
• Most of the times fishing
jobs are:
• Unpredictable.
• Unwanted.
• Very costly affair.
• Oil and gas well fishing is
not a typical practice for
drilling, work-over and
completion operations
except some.
• Roughly one in every five
wells experience the need
for fishing operation
Fishing Operation
• The origin of term fishing are attributed to the early days
of cable tool drilling.
• In cable tool drilling a cable attached to a spring pole
repeatedly lifted and dropped a bit that chiseled away
the rock at the bottom.
• When the cable parted, drillers attempted to retrieve the
cable and bit from the bottom of the hole using an
improvised hook – fishing out the cable and bit.
• Over the years fishing has become highly sought after job
and the art of fishing has grown up as specialized job
within the oil well services industry.
• The trial-and-error methods of industry’s early days built
the foundation for many of the catch tool used currently.
Cable Tool Drilling Setup
• The cable tool drilling is done
by raising and dropping a
string of tools on the end of a
cable.
• The up and down motion is
imparted by the walking
beam.
• The tools are pulled from or
lowered into the hole by
winding or unwinding the
drilling cable on the bull
wheel.
• Casing is raised or lowered by
the casing line or calf wheel.
• The cuttings are removed
from the hole by the bailer,
which is raised and lowered by
the sand line and wheel.
Fishing Operation
• Fishing can be thought of as a Risk Management
strategy. When used successfully, it can save a well.
• Fishing is basically more of an applied skill supported by
experience than an exact science, there may be more
than one possible solution for a given problem.
• A clear understanding of the problem, the equipment
used to solve the problem, and the best fitting solution
will lead to a successful operation.
• Although no fishing job technique can be guaranteed,
the combination of experienced personnel and
continuing advances in fishing tool technology offers an
option with good probability of success.
Why Fishing??
• When any junk or any hardware blocks the path to
continued operations, these items must be
removed from the hole as quickly as possible.
• The longer the fish or junk remains in a borehole,
the more difficult these parts will be to retrieve.
• If the fish or junk is in an open hole section of the
well, it may create serious borehole stability
issues.
• Often it is very important to consider tradeoff
between well cost and the cost of fishing
operations.
Need of Fishing Operation
Fishing Operations may be needed at any point during the life
cycle of a well – from drilling through abandonment.
Item
2
Evaluate and Communicate
• What is the reason for fishing operation?
• Operation which lead to fishing.
• Economics of the fishing operation.
• Whether the proper tools are available or the tools are
to be designed according to the fish?
• Careful evaluations and measurements.
• When to quit the fishing operation?
• Formulate the fishing plan in agreement with all
concerned.
• Since each fishing job is different from earlier ones,
communicate all details to all concerned.
Cardinal Rules of Fishing
In Fishing job, regardless of the type of job, there are
some basic rules of fishing which apply to all jobs.
Rule-1 Obtain the important details:
Cost = Lost
tool cost,
cement cost,
sidetrack & Cost of Not
Re-Drill cost Fishing CK
The Economics of Fishing
• The lower branch leads to certain costs if fishing is not attempted. Those
Costs corresponds to CK .
• The upper branch leads to expected costs if fishing is attempted.
• This cost is the expected cost C*, the sum of two expected costs :
• Expected cost associated with a successful fishing operation (C*p )
• Expected cost associated with an unsuccessful fishing operation (C*1-p )
• Therefore, C* = C*p + C*1-p
• Let the probability of successful fishing operation be p and that of an
unsuccessful fishing operation be 1-p .
• p is to be estimated based on historical data
The Economics of Fishing
• If the decision is made not to fish, the costs (B) that will be incurred
will include the cost of the lost fish, the cost of cementing it in, the
cost of side-track and re-drilling back to the previous depth, plus rig
time.
• The worst case (C) occurs when the fishing operation is abandoned
without retrieving the fish, thereby incurring fishing costs per day
(A) and the cost associated with not fishing (B). C= A + B
• C* = (Cr x t) + (1-p)B
The Economics of Fishing
Illustrated example: In a particular drilling field, on the basis of
historic data , 10 out of 23 times the fish was recovered within
100 hours.
• This means somewhat less than 100 hours may be spent on the
fishing job before expected costs exceeds potential return.
The Economics of Fishing
• Case II: Given Cost of Not Fishing CK = Rs 150,000 and Day
rate Cr = Rs 1000/hr
Sidetracking includes:
• Cost of Whip stock and services
• Cost of cementing and rig time while WOC
• Cost of directional drilling services and rig time to re-drill hole back to current
depth.
The Economics of Fishing
• Suppose a fish worth $150,000 is stuck in a well being drilled at a
cost of $5,000 per day.
• The methods have merits, but so many factors affect the decision
that converting them into a standard formula or pattern is almost
impossible.
• Plug Back, Run Casing & then Side Track below the shoe.
• Plug Back, Abandon the Hole and Re-drill from nearby location.
• Differential Sticking.
• Hole Pack-off / Bridging.
• Stuck up due to well bore geometry.
Parted Drill String
• Sometimes the Drill string gets parted while drilling and
other operations due to many causes.
• Usually the drill string parting is caused by metal fatigue
failure.
• Drill string fatigue failure is the most common and costly
type of failure in oil and gas drilling operations.
• There are several types of fatigue failure and they may
occur simultaneously.
• Twist off.
• Wash out.
• Cyclic stress failure.
Twist Off
• Twist-Off occurs when applied torque exceeds a pipe body
or tool joint’s torsional strength limits.
• This failure usually causes a sudden loss of hook load, as
well as a sharp drop in pump pressure.
• It may also occur when trying to rotate stuck pipe.
Washout
• Washout is when a hole is worn in the pipe, and becomes
increasingly larger due to circulating drilling fluid.
• This can eventually sever or twist off the pipe entirely.
• Washout usually occur at rotary connections, due to improper
make-up, cracks or defective materials.
• From the surface, a washout may be indicated by a gradual
decrease in pump pressure at constant pump rate.
Cyclic Stress Failure
• Cyclic stresses are induced by dynamic loads caused by
drill string vibrations and bending load reversals in curved
sections of hole and doglegs caused by rotation.
• Drill pipe can experience cyclic stress if they wear out after
a great deal of continuous and rigorous use.
• Drill pipe corrosion occurs during the presence of O2, CO2,
chlorides, and/or H2S (H2S being severely corrosive to
steel pipe and very deadly to humans).
• Furthermore, mishandling of drill string on ground may
lead to fatigue failure.
• The string fatigue failure is still least understood even after
lot of research work in this area.
Junk in Hole
• Junk can consist of all manner of things, from bit cones
and tong dies, to hard tools or other objects that have
been accidently dropped into the hole.
• Junk can cause irregular torque, or prevent drilling ahead
after a new bit is run.
• Sometimes it might nor even be necessary to recover junk,
if it is small enough or in the right location, or depending
on the formation hardness.
• In all such cases the junk could be ground with the bit, or
pushed to the side on a soft formation where it will not get
in the way of drilling operations.
Logging Tool Sticking
• While performing open hole logging operations when the
logging cuts through mud cake, differential pressure
sticking may occur.
• This may occur due to significant difference in formation
pressure and the mud hydrostatic pressure, due to which
the cable will be pressed harshly into the formation, and
friction against the formation stops the cable from moving
any longer.
• Other reasons why sticking may occur include ledges,
particularly severe doglegs, borehole caving or the
borehole becoming corkscrewed.
• As the length of the tool increases, and there has been a
long amount of time since last conditioning trip, the
chances of sticking may go up.
Cable and Wire Line Tools
• Logging cable and other wire line tools may become stuck in
the hole at any time.
• The recovery of parted wire line and the tool or instrument run
with it is one of the most challenging fishing jobs.
• Situations must be separated between those where the line is
still intact and situation where the line is parted.
• Parted wire line is very difficult to fish, as it has a natural
tendency to ball up, only relatively short sections of wire line
can be recovered per fish run.
• Differentiation shall also be made between slick line, electric or
conductor lines and sand lines.
• If a conductor line has not parted, good practice usually
dictates that we should not pull out of the rope socket, this
causes us to lose contact with the tool or instrument and it may
become permanently lost.
Cable and Wire Line Tools
• If the instrument contains a radioactive source, the situation
becomes even more critical.
• Fishing in these situations can be attempted by either cut and
thread method (cable guide method) or side door overshot
method.
• Normally cut and thread method is attempted for deep hole
situations or when a radioactive source is stuck in the hole,
since it is the safest method and assures a very high success
ratio.
• The only disadvantages are that the cable must be cut and the
stripping over procedure is slow and time consuming.
Casing Repair
• Casing failure can be caused by erosion, corrosion, a poor casing
program where high pressures are encountered.
• The most common indication of this type of problem is the
presence of sand or shale inside the well when the tubing is
pulled.
• Partial or complete collapse of casing causes dent marks on the
tubing. These marks ensure the exact determination of the depth
of the problem.
• A RTTS packer tool run on tubing can be used to locate the hole or
leakage point in the casing.
• If the packer is set at intervals and pressure is applied between
the tubing and casing, the packer will cause a pressure shut off as
long as it is above the hole.
• When the packer is set below the hole, the pressure in the
annulus will bleed off.
Casing Repair
Casing can be repaired using the following methods:
• Squeeze cementation.
• Using a stressed steel liner patch.
• Replacing the upper part of the string if the casing can be
pulled with an external casing patch.
• Running a liner to cover the bad place in the casing string.
• Using a casing roller or swage.
• Mill out with a string mill and run the casing alignment
tool.
Objects Lost
• Any tubular or any other tool which has been dropped in
the hole while drilling operations, while making or
breaking up the tool at the rig floor, that has been
accidently dropped into the hole.
• These types of fish certainly prevent further drilling
operations.
• The fish top of the tubulars or tool dropped in the hole can
either be in cased hole or in open hole.
• These types of fish dropped in the hole, can be fished out
either by the positive catch mechanism, or by the specific
fishing tools depending on the dimensions of the fish.
Happy Fishing