Pipe Routing Instructions
Pipe Routing Instructions
Pipe Routing Instructions
The objective of this guideline is to provide the Pipe Designer direction in applying recommended
engineering piping layout practices as applied to above grade piping. These recommendations apply to
both critical systems (with an operating temperature above 300° F) and non-critical systems (with an
operating temperature below 300° F). Refer to the Steam Pipe Routing Recommendations Section for
additional guidance for design above 300°F. Additional general design information has been included for
consideration by the Pipe Designer.
2.0 Responsibilities
The Mechanical/Chemical Project Lead Designer (PLD-M) is responsible for assigning pipe systems
appropriate to their staff’s capabilities, and provides direction for incorporating the following guidelines
into the design process.
Mechanical/Chemical Pipe Designers are responsible for developing logical pipe layouts using the design
data as determined by the Design Engineers. Note that close coordination is required by the Designer
with the System Engineer, Stress Analysis Engineer, and all disciplines in communicating design
information that impacts other project personnel design responsibilities.
3.0 Process
The following sections describe the responsibilities associated with pipe routing and the importance of
following a logical set of procedures that has been developed from proven engineering design. The
following design approaches are applicable to all B&V Energy projects, except for GOC projects.
Definitions:
Critical systems – steam, feedwater, and systems 300° F and above.
Non-critical Systems – low pressure systems and systems below 300° F.
Engineered components – pipe, valves, equipment, structural steel, cable tray and other
components designed or procured by B&V.
This section provides recommendations for general pipe routing layout that should be consistently applied
unless unique project requirements dictate a different approach.
Piping shall be routed as direct as possible from origin to destination and be arranged for efficient
operation and maintenance.
A preliminary pipe routing provides several benefits with space control and valve access being
two major factors that must be considered.
If a single pipe line is being routed in an open space locate the line closer to a column instead of
in the middle of a bay to allow for an efficient use of the space for pipes that are routed at a later
time in the design process.
Steam piping shall take precedence when establishing pipe space allocation.
It is recommended that small-bore pipe routing be given consideration at the early stages of a
project to allow for space control and support fabrication requirements. All small-bore piping
greater than 300° F should have a preliminary routing developed for thermal analysis reasons
and the space that it may occupy – a 2” (50mm) main steam drain for example can have a 12”
(300mm) or more diameter when the insulation is included.
When a modular construction of a pipe rack is considered all small-bore should be preliminarily
routed to account for space and pipe support requirements. Modularization generally requires
small-bore be designed and delivered at site at the same time as the large-bore piping to support
installation.
Consideration shall always be given to a pipe routing to account for pipe support requirements as
described in M/C Department Guidelines for “Pipe Support Guidelines for Cold Systems”. Avoid
running pipe across open areas that are not accessible from support steel or structure above or
below the pipe that can be used to support the pipe.
Pipe centerline spacing between pipes and from column rows should be rounded to the nearest
inch or 25mm for metric projects. Refer to Figure 3.1A.
As a general rule try and maintain the same centerline of pipes that run in the same direction
especially when the pipes are hung from above. Bottom-supported pipes should maintain the
same bottom of pipe O.D. unless the insulation thickness or support requires a specific elevation.
Refer to Figure 3.1B.
Setting the elevation of piping above a floor or grade is dependant on several different
considerations:
o What access is required below the piping – personnel walkway, maintenance equipment
(forklift, flatbed truck, cranes, etc.), or railcar access?
o How much space is available between floors – floor spacing of 20’ (6.09m) allows 2-level
piping runs at 9’-0” (2.74m) and 12’-0” (3.66m), where 10’ (3.05m) spacing may only
allow one-level of piping to be run at minimum headroom?
o What other engineered components are located in the same area and require sharing the
available space – electrical cable tray, HVAC ducts, etc?
All piping, including associated supports, insulation and attachments shall maintain a minimum
overhead clearance of 6’-9” (2.05m) above floor level and 7’-0” (2.13m) above the nearest tread
at stairways. OHSA Standards require a minimum of 6’-8” (2.03m) headroom clearance for
walkway access. Be aware of the governing codes and standards as required by the project
contract. Refer to Figure 3.1C.
FIGURE 3.1C
Minimum OSHA Head Clearance
Minimum personnel aisle access generally requires 3’-0” (.914m) clearance with surrounding
plant components. Refer to NFPA requirements that apply to the specific layout conditions as
required.
As a general rule a 2-level piping approach is used in the turbine areas and the lower floors of
coal plants to allow for an organized change of elevation of piping. As an example overhead
piping may maintain standard elevations of 9’-3” (2.82m) above floor level for east/west pipe runs
and 12’-3” (3.73m) above floor level for north/south pipe runs to allow for consistent vertical
clearances when changes in pipe direction are required. Refer to Figure 3.1D.
FIGURE 3.1D
A minimum distance of 3” (80mm) should be maintained from the outside diameter of non-critical
piping systems, including insulation, to allow for installation clearances and account for normal
miss-installation tolerances, which can range from ¼” (8mm) to several inches depending on the
quality of construction control. Refer to Figure 3.1A above.
A minimum distance of 6”-12” (150-300mm) from outside diameter of critical piping systems,
including insulation, for horizontal and vertical clearances with the following considerations taken
into account-
o Thermal movements of pipe from cold to hot position.
o Some systems may have several thermal positions dependant on the operating
sequence – for example which units are in operation on a 3-on-1 combined cycle
plant, or the operation of a bypass system that may impact the associated systems.
o In the extreme example of 28” (710mm) thermal expansion as designed on a
combined cycle a manual check of clearances is suggested and the space be
allocated to prevent the placement of other components in the path of expansion.
o Coal plants have long vertical runs where we may see up to 12”-18” (300-450mm) of
downward movement. Be aware of these cases and account for space allocation
accordingly.
o Contact and work closely with the Stress Analysis Specialist to identify thermal
movements and impacts on attached components or other components in close
proximity.
o A 3-D model of the thermal movements can be extracted from the CAESAR model
and then imported into the project 3-D model to visually and electronically check
clearances.
o Inform the other disciplines of pipes and valves that have large thermal movements
so they may base their design accordingly. Several examples of components that
may be impacted by thermal movements are: conduits to valves and instruments,
cable tray location, or platform steel for accessing valves or instruments.
Under certain circumstances (for example a long straight run associated with combined cycle
pipe rack routing) specific pipe movements must be obtained from the Stress Analysis Section
(SAS) to verify adequate clearance is maintained between piping and other engineered
components under all plant operating conditions. Refer to Figure 3.1E.
FIGURE 3.1E
Piping shall avoid areas designated as equipment and instrument maintenance space, vertical
access hatches, crane and monorail travel spaces and normal personnel access and egress
lanes.
When routing bottom-supported pipe it is a good practice to use eccentric reducers (flat on
bottom) keeping the bottom of the pipe run constant. The two main reasons for this are to simplify
the pipe support design by keeping the bottom of the pipe at the same elevation. Draining the
pipe, whether it is a cold system or a hot system that requires draining the condensate, requires
consideration in location of drain connections and can be achieved easier with the use of
eccentric reducers.
Avoid sudden expansion on the outlet of desuperheaters, a straight run distance is normally
required by the manufacturer to provide a proper mixing zone for the spraywater and the steam. If
reducers are required and allowed use several reducers to allow gradual expansion in lieu of one
large expansion (for example a 20”x30” reducer is too extreme of a sudden expansion).
Bottom supported piping with no insulation or with insulation for personnel protection shall be
routed with bottom of pipe (BOP) resting on top of steel (TOS) or top of concrete (TOC). When
required, personnel protection insulation should be notched at support points.
Bottom-supported pipe with insulation for anti-freezing or anti-sweating shall be routed with a
clearance between BOP and TOS or TOC to avoid damaging the insulation and lagging. Pipe
shoes will be used to elevate the pipe off the supporting surface to allow for thermal movements.
When locating instrument taps, vents and drains, take into consideration freeze protection, hydro
testing and flushing requirements. Locating these connections close together can save on heat
tracing costs.
Consider locating small-bore vertical runs behind the stairwells for easy installation access. The
pipe supports can be welded to the stair and platform support steel eliminating the need for
scaffolding and manlifts. Always be aware of the OHSA or local codes that define minimum
distances around stairs and ladders.
Freeze protection requirements shall be adhered to when routing pipe and should be discussed
during the “Released for Routing” meeting. Criteria for freeze protection changes from job to job
but should be identified by cross hatching on the affected lines on the P&ID. A unique line
number should be included in J48 (i.e. preceding the line size with the letter “F”)
Vent connections shall be provided at all high points on top of pipe and drain connections shall be
provided at all low points on bottom of pipe with the following exceptions: Low point drains are
generally not required on air or gas systems down stream of dryers. High point vents are not
required for systems using Initial Service Leak Test (ISLT) to prove system integrity.
Socket weld connections shall be used for Vent and Drain connections.
Continuous or high volume vents and drains should be routed to drain funnels or bell-ups.
Air Relief Valves / Vacuum Breaker Valves / Burp Valves / route discharge to drain.
Vents and drains are usually fabricated from the same material as the originating header or
equipment connection. Exceptions to this may occur when the main header is alloy material, in
which the material may change downstream of the first isolation valve. Always discuss this with
the Design Engineer and make sure any material change is reflected in the linecodes.
3.1.3 Insulation
Personnel protection insulation when required should extend 8’-0” (2.44m) vertically above
platform/floors, and 4’-0” (1.22m) horizontally past the handrail when accessible off a
platform/floor.
Carbon Steel
o Carbon steel material is usually used in non-corrosive water applications.
o Carbon steel pipe is generally shop fabricated.
o Butt weld fittings are typically used.
o Flanges or butt-weld end preps are typically used at equipment connections.
o Butt-welded valves are generally used in high pressure systems and either butt-welded or
flanged valves are generally used in low pressure systems. Flanged valves typically have
a lower installation cost.
o Most carbon steel pipe can be welded to alloy pipe, but a dissimilar weld must be
identified on fabrication drawings. It is preferred to have dissimilar welds made in the
shop by the pipe fabricator.
Alloy
o Alloy material is usually used in steam or flashing applications.
o Alloy pipe is generally shop fabricated.
o Butt-welded fittings are typically used.
o Flanges or butt-weld end preps are typically used at equipment connections.
o Butt-welded valves are typically used.
o Some alloy pipe can be welded to different alloy pipe material (P91 to P22), but a
dissimilar weld must be identified on fabrication drawings. It is preferred to have
dissimilar welds made in the shop by the pipe fabricator.
Stainless Steel
o Stainless steel material is usually used in low-corrosive water, chemical and control air
system applications.
o Butt-welded fittings are typically used for large-bore applications.
o Socket-welded fittings are typically used for small-bore water applications, and press-fit
fittings are typically used for small-bore air applications.
o Flanges or butt-weld end preps are typically used at equipment connections
o Seam-welded stainless steel pipe. 6” (150mm) and above, should be used in place of
seamless pipe to take advantage of the cost-savings.
Copper
o Copper material can be used in potable water applications.
o Fittings are typically socket type with braised (soldered) connections.
o Connections to valves and equipment are typically flanged.
Plastic
o Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) material can be used in general chemical applications, and
Chemical Polyvinyl Chloride (CPVC) can be used in harsher chemical applications.
o Fittings are typically socket type that uses a bonding solvent at fitting connections.
o Connections to valves and equipment are typically flanged or threaded.
FRP - Fiberglass Reinforced
o Fiberglass Reinforced Pipe (FRP) can be used for abrasive or non-abrasive water or
slurry applications. Material content is selected based on whether medium is abrasive or
non-abrasive.
o Fittings vary from butt-end, belled, socket, flanged or threaded depending on the pipe
size and application for the system.
o Valves are generally flanged.
o The use of FRP with concentrated sulfuric acid requires very specific operation
safeguards to be employed by the operators to avoid pipe failures. In the case you see
the use of FRP pipe in the application associated with sulfuric acid discuss and verify the
material selection with the Chemical Engineer.
The following provides general information a designer needs to be familiar with when understanding the
descriptions and applications of schedule/class information associated with pipe and pipe connections.
A pipe schedule represents the actual physical dimensions for the outside diameter (O.D.) of the
pipe and the wall thickness associated with carbon steel, alloy, and stainless steel material with a
numbered description – for example the nominal pipe size - 10” (250mm) Schedule 40 tells you
that the pipe O.D. is 10.75” (273mm) with a wall thickness of 0.365” (9.27mm) as established by
the ASTM Specification ASA 36.10.
The ASTM Specification defines these dimensions based on Pressure-Temperature Ratings for
seamless pipe of the same size, thickness (schedule) and material grade.
At B&V the J48 linecode dictates the pipe size and schedules as determined by an Engineer’s
calculations for a specific system.
Higher pressure/temperature systems such as Main Steam may require an alloy pipe with higher
schedules such as schedule 160, while a low pressure/temperature service water system typically
requires carbon steel material with a schedule 40.
It is common to see a reduction in the pipe schedule when transitioning from a larger pipe size to
a smaller pipe size, since the smaller line size can handle the higher design conditions that
dictated the schedule for the larger pipe. For example on a feedwater recirculation line a pipe size
may reduce from a 12” (300mm) schedule 80 (with a wall thickness of .594”[15.08mm]) to a 10”
(250mm) schedule XS (with a wall thickness of .500”). In this case the 12”x10” reducer would
require a schedule 80 with the 10” (250mm) outlet end prep bored out to match the 10” (250mm)
schedule XS dimensions.
Flanges, flanged valves, and flanged fittings are classified by a pressure/temperature rating
based on the appropriate Standard for a specified material, including cast steel, alloys, stainless
steels, bronze, FRP, and PVC material as some examples. The range of pressure and
temperature application is dependant on the material - for example a 10” (250mm) Class 150
carbon steel flange may be rated at a 150 lb. primary pressure class service rating with a test
pressure limit of 425 PSI and a service temperature high of 425° F, compared to a 10” (250mm)
Class 150 FRP flange that is rated at a 150 lb. primary pressure service rating with a test
pressure limit of 225 PSI and a service temperature high of 225° F.
At B&V the J48 linecode dictates the pipe size and class as determined by an Engineer’s
calculations for a specific system.
Flanges, flanged valves, and flanged fittings require that the same service rating be used at
flanged interfaces
Refer to Section 3.5 Flanges for additional detail on flanged connections.
Pipe fitting descriptions as in the wall schedule or pressure class, connection type, and fabrication
method are all dependant on the material selected based on the specific application. The following
sections provide some general information for the fitting types usually used by B&V.
B&V strongly urges the use of induction bending in place of large-bore butt-weld elbows fittings.
There is considerable cost savings that is realized from the fabricator when induction bending is
utilized. The following are requirements and/or considerations to be taken into account prior to
using induction bends:
o Confirm that the pipe fabricator has induction bending capabilities.
o Confirm any capability limitations the pipe fabricator has in the way of pipe size and wall
thickness.
o Confirm that the System Engineer has performed the proper wall thickness calculations
to account for the wall thinning that occurs during the induction bending process.
o Be familiar with the induction bending process and take into account the allowed radius
bend, the required tangent length at the ends of the bend for the clamps, and the impact
that using bends has on the overall layout of the routing.
o B&V does not currently allow the induction bending of stainless steel due to the
discoloration of the metal during the process.
When sloping a line it is preferred to use a bend over a fitting. Very little angle deflection is
allowed at the weld on fittings.
The use of short radius elbows is discouraged unless the piping configuration has such restrictive
space problems that a short radius elbow becomes the solution.
The suggested method for reducing a pipe line size is to use a butt-weld reducer especially for
high pressure systems and around small-bore control valves. Swages can be used to reduce
from a large-bore to small-bore pipe sizes, but they are generally more expensive than a butt-
welded reducer and availability can be a problem.
Piping weld spacing shall be maintained as defined in the Standard EEC-Std-3-03113-01304,
Standard for Minimum Distance Spacing for Welds. This Standard will provide the minimum space
requirements - for example when locating olet fittings from an adjacent fitting weld.
Butt welding elbows shall be long radius, unless short radius is required for clearance.
o Use straight tees for branches of same pipe size and weld-o-lets for branches reducing in
pipe size. Branch connections on steam, air, condensate gas and nitrogen piping should be
on top of the header.
Double wall containment – LATER
The insertion set-back of a pipe into a socket fitting occasionally comes into question as to what
the correct dimension of set-back is, or if it needs to be considered. A 1/16” (2mm) set-back is
typical and is what is required by code as a value that can be measured in the field. B&V fitting
tables are set to 1/16” (2mm) set-back and should accommodate any issue that should arise
whether that is weldability, proper engagement (insertion depth), fatigue issues due to thermal
changes the fitting sees, or from a fabrication accuracy point of view. Since a true zero gap is
nearly impossible to achieve and the fabrication tolerances of small-bore piping can vary
depending on the conditions, our current standard of 1/16” (2mm) is sufficient as a point of
reference. Refer to Figure 3.4.2A.
Figure 3.4.2A
Socket Welded Fitting Insertion Setback
For reduction of socket-welded small-bore pipe, use reducer inserts as a cost-effective method.
Swages can be used to reduce from a large-bore to small-bore pipe sizes, but they are generally
more expensive and availability can be a problem.
A union fitting may be required when a section of pipe needs to be removed at an equipment
interface that has a threaded connection. The union is usually socket-welded on both ends with a
threaded coupling connection in the middle that allows a separation of a line when the coupling is
unthreaded.
B&V guide specifications require that pre-engineered olets be used as a branch connection on
headers. The question arises occasionally if half or full couplings may be welded onto headers as
branch connections and the following must be considered in application of these fittings:
o B31.1 states that couplings may be used for a branch connection only if a full penetrating
weld is used at the header connection – a fillet weld is unacceptable.
o B&V guide specifications state that branch connections must be made with either a fitting
(tee) or a pre-engineered adaptor.
o Due to the challenges associated with quality control of the welding process (manual
beveling of the opening for a full penetrating weld and possible area replacement
calculation requirement) it is B&V practice to avoid the welding of half and full couplings
onto a header. There are a few exceptions associated with unique cases.
Consideration has been given to the most practical and acceptable Industry Standards for branch
connection types meeting B31.1 Design Code Criteria.
The following branch connection types have been evaluated,
Piping Stub in connections - Unreinforced, low pressure, low temperature branch connections
meeting ASME B31.1 section 104.3.1 (C) criteria. This option was eliminated because the
cost is comparable to the integrally reinforced branch outlet fittings and does not provide any
additional reinforcement to the connection.
Reinforced Stub-in connections - Stub-in branch connections with reinforcement pad meeting
ASME B31.1 section 104.3.1 (D) criteria. It is labor intensive and associated costs make it
more expensive than an integrally reinforced branch outlet fitting.
Tee connections - Both socket-welded and butt-welded tee fittings meet ASME B31.1 section
104.3.1 (B.1) and the Standards listed on ASME B31.1 Chapter IV, Table 126.1 criterion.
These fittings are more expensive than the integrally reinforced branch outlet fitting on all
sizes for full and reducing sizes on schedule 80 and under. Only the socket-weld tee comes
to a comparable cost on same size branch for pipe heavier than schedule 80. Same size tee
pipe sizes up to 10” (250mm) will be used on the branches for consistency.
Integrally reinforced branch outlet fittings - Fittings manufactured to MSS-SP-97 meet ASME
B31.1 section 104.3.1 (C.3) and it is listed on ASME B31.1 Chapter IV, Table 126.1
Standards. For Shop labor and material costs this is the most cost efficient connection.
Wyes, laterals and other specialty connections - These are not used very often and due to
their specialized application are usually engineered and priced independently. These fittings
have not been considered for the development of the branch charts.
The type of branch connection, based on the previously defined criteria, is shown on the following
Charts for the branch connection size and type on carbon steel piping.
The following Chart is for 2 ½” (65mm) and larger butt-welded schedule 80 and under carbon
steel piping, excluding 5” (125mm) pipe sizes.
All piping branches with pipe walls heavier than schedule 80 will have WOL branch connections.
WOL – Is for weld-o-lets or similar reinforced branch connection
Tee – Is for butt-welded piping tee branch connection
The following Chart is for 2” (50mm) and under socket-welded carbon steel piping branch connections on
all piping wall schedules.
3.5 Flanges
This section provides typical application and installation suggestions commonly used at B&V. Gasket
and bolting preferences have been included to provide a general guideline for Pipe Designer’s to
follow when selecting and detailing flange connections.
Refer to section 3.3.2 for description of flange classes.
When connecting to equipment, valves, and piping interfaces take into consideration the material,
flange class, flange facing furnished with these components before selecting the correct flange.
Verification of these features on vendor drawings is a must in order to provide the proper mating
flange.
Use weld neck flanges except for low pressure/low temperature system and for 30” (750mm) and
larger pipe - Raised face flanges should not be attached to flat face flanges except for unique
cases.
Slip-on flanges have limited applications at B&V such as:
o Unique piping arrangement problems force the use of a slip-on flange instead of a weld-
neck flange.
o A construction contractor or equipment manufacturer uses a slip-on flange in place of a
weld-neck flange due to a piping arrangement problem, costs savings, or for other
reasons.
In the case slip-on flanges are the only solution to a piping problem, the following are acceptable
design requirements:
o Slip-on flanges shall not be used at pressures above Class 300.
o Soft gaskets must be used – Do not use spiral wound gaskets or any type of gasket that
requires high compressive force requiring high strength alloy steel bolts.
o Normal strength carbon steel bolts must be used.
Calculating the length of the studs or bolts required for bolting two flanges together require
knowing the specific thickness of the following components and adding them together to arrive at
an overall length:
1. Thickness of the flange that B&V is furnishing – the thickness will vary from
material to material and the class of the flange. Be sure to include the raised face
dimension (usually .0625” or .25” [2 or 8mm]) if required.
2. Thickness of the vendor furnished component flange (pump, valve, strainer, etc.)
that is being mated up to – the thickness will vary from material to material and
the class of the flange.
3. The thickness of the gasket if one is required.
4. The depth of the nuts on both ends of the flanges – the depth varies depending
on the diameter of the bolt.
5. As a general rule two threads should be exposed outside of the nut, which as a
rule of thumb is .25” to .375” (8-10mm) on each side.
6. Add items 1 through 5 for a total, then round up to the nearest half inch (15mm)
for a total length.
A good reference for standard length of bolts for a standard flange to flange mating is the NAVCO
book. NAVCO has a table that provides the stud or bolt lengths for typical flange sizes and
classes.
Some valves or equipment connections have tapped bolt holes, or a combination of tapped and
through bolt holes. Refer to the vendor drawing to determine the correct bolting requirements.
Carbon steel flanges 24” and smaller shall be per ANSI B16.5 and sizes above 24” shall be per
AWWA C207.
Orifice flanges are used in conjunction with orifice plates that can be used to measure the flow
rate using the differential pressure across both sides of the orifice plate. Each orifice flange will
have a ½”-3/4” (15-20mm) pipe tap located on the outside diameter surface for the tubing to the
pressure indicator. See Figure 3.7.3A for the preferred location of the taps.
Orifice flanges required similar straight pipe-run up and downstream of the orifice to ensure
accuracy of the flow reading. A safe rule of thumb is 20 pipe diameters upstream and 10 pipe
diameters downstream. Refer to the Control Engineer for specific system requirements.
Threaded flanges should be used only in places where threaded fittings are permitted by the
piping material specification and on lines such as galvanized piping, where welding would be a
special problem.
The number of flanged joints in a high pressure process piping system should be minimized.
The use of flanges or Victaulic coupling in straight runs of pipe may provide an installation cost
savings over welded joints.
3.5.1 Gaskets
Spiral Wound Gaskets – are used on raised faced metallic flanges and are constructed of
continuous stainless steel ribbon wound into a spiral with non-asbestos filler between adjacent
coils. A spiral wound gasket O.D. fits inside of the flange bolt hole and compresses to 1/8” (6mm)
thickness (0.130” ±0.005” [3.3mm ±.127mm]) at installation. A common manufacturer is Flexitallic
Gasket Company.
Compressed Fiber Gaskets – are used on flat faced metallic flanges. A compressed fiber gasket
O.D. is full-faced extending past the flange bolt holes and generally has a 1/16” (2mm) thickness.
A common manufacturer is The Klinger Group.
Rubber Gaskets – are typically used on low pressure larger diameter flanges (usually flat-faced)
and various non-metallic flanges as dictated by the application. Rubber gaskets are full-faced
extending past the flange bolt holes and are constructed of cloth inserted sheet rubber with a
thickness ranging from 1/16” (3mm) to 1/8” (6mm).
Flange Insulating Kits – are typically used on below grade to above grade metallic flange
interfaces that need to be cathodically insulated to prevent stray ground currents from passing
through the below grade pipe material to the above grade material, causing undo corrosion or
eventual breakdown of the metal. They may also be required for dissimilar metal flange
interfaces. The kit contains a full-faced insulating and sealing flange 1/8” (6mm) thick gasket, full
length insulating sleeve for each bolt, and flat insulating washers for each bolt. A common
manufacturer is Advance Products & Systems. Flange insulating kits are not meant to be used on
flanged valves or expansion joints.
Valve classes are based on the ANSI pressure temperature ratings for valve class and
body/bonnet material. The standard classes are 150, 300, 600, 900, 1500, and 2500.
Some valves come in class 125, 800, or other designated classes based on material
and/or application of the valve.
Most valves come in butt-weld or flanged end connections and selection may be based
on:
o The system application
o Valve body material
o Construction preference – flanged valves over butt-weld valves due to installation
cost-savings.
o Most high pressure valves (class 600 and above) are likely to be butt-welded
ends, but there are exceptions
Accessibility to valves shall be taken into consideration when routing a system. Control
valves, motor and air operated valves and all other valves defined as “normally operated”
shall be accessible from floor or platform elevations. Identify the parts of a valve and
operator that require access for operation and maintenance, and then provide a sketch to
the structural engineer defining the elevation and size of required platform. Do not wait
until the project is complete to address access needs as it is likely adequate access
space will blocked by other components. Vents, drains, bypass and root valves may or
may not require normal access and should be considered on a case by case basis.
There are several approaches to laying out a valve station taking into consideration the
pipe/valve size, type of valves, and the space availability. Figure 3.6A Option A reflects
the typical layout for pipe/valve sizes 8” (200mm) and above due to the height and size of
the valve operators. Figure 3.6A Option B reflects an optional layout when space is
limited and a compact valve station is required. Generally this layout will accommodate
pipe/valve size 6” (150mm) and below. Always take into account the maintenance pull
space for the valves and required space to operate the valve.
FIGURE 3.6A
Valve Stations with Bypasses
Valve stations are usually located 12-18” (300-450mm) above the supporting floor to
provide adequate space for locating a support under the station and to allow operating
personnel to access the valve operator without the aid of a ladder. Refer to Figure 3.6B.
Use the vendor shop drawing or catalog cut to determine the height of the valve operator
from an operations and maintenance point of view. Generally handwheels over 4’-0”
(1.25m) above the floor are difficult for operators to open and close.
FIGURE 3.6B FIGURE 3.6C
Valves should be installed in the upright position (stem up) wherever possible.
When valves are located in the vertical give consideration to the height and rotation of the
operator for the following reasons:
o Place the valve height where the operator is accessible from the floor.
o Do not rotate the operator where it extends out into access or maintenance aisle
ways.
o Do not place valve at a height that is consider a head-knocker, which may be
from 5-7’-0” (1.5-2.1m) off the accessing floor. Refer to Figure 3.6C.
o Try to rotate the larger valve operators over adjacent piping to shield it from aisle
ways.
The elevation of a valve station on a hot system may require additional space from the
floor to the bottom of the pipe to allow for a pipe support spring can or the HP drain
support bracket detail (refer to DM-125 drawing). Be aware that if the valve is raised in
elevation that the valve operator must still be accessible either off the floor or a platform.
Use the maximum dimensions provided by the vendor for height (include removal space)
and diameter (include limit switches) when modeling for interference checking.
Some pump manufacturer’s have specific requirement for location of the first valve off the
pump discharge – always consult the manufacturer for layout specifics.
Consider access to drip pot drain valves during the routing process as they are often
either elevated off the main floors or located away from platform access. Always consult
the project contract for valve access requirements to determine if permanent platform, or
ladder access is required, or if access via a manlift is adequate to meet contract
requirements.
Isolation and root valves should be located as close to the main header as possible in
case of line breakage.
Consult the valve manufacturer in the case of unique locations and orientations of valves.
FIGURE 3.6.2A
3.6.3 Control Valves
The location of control valves in a piping system must take into consideration several design
parameters such as whether the system is a high or low pressure system, a high or low energy
application. Use the following suggestions to properly locate a control valve along with the layout
mistakes to avoid:
Incorporate minimum upstream / downstream requirements provided by the control valve
manufacturer.
On high pressure and high energy systems never place a control valve directly adjacent
to a horizontal elbow. The flow rate may cause severe vibration to the valves operating or
control parts leading to damage to the actuator, pilot valve, valve trim, and valve plug due
to actuator failure. A minimum of 10 pipe diameters is required upstream of the valve inlet
and 5 pipe diameters is required downstream of the valve outlet to the inlet of the elbow.
Always follow the manufacturer’s recommendations. Refer to Figure 3.6.3A.
On low pressure systems avoid locating a control valve directly adjacent to a horizontal
elbow. The flow rate may cause severe vibration to the valves operating or control parts
leading to damage to the actuator, pilot valve, valve trim, and valve plug due to actuator
failure. A minimum of 3-5 pipe diameters is suggested upstream of the valve inlet and 2-3
pipe diameters is suggested downstream of the valve outlet to the inlet of the elbow.
Always follow the manufacturer’s recommendations. Refer to Figure 3.6.3A.
FIGURE 3.6.3A
Reducers are commonly located on each side of a control valve and should be placed as
close to the valve as possible with no or minimal straight pipe-run. See Figure 3.6B.
One issue associated with pipe reduction around valves is the related to the strength of
the valve in relation to the strength of the adjacent piping. Too much of a reduction
creates sort of a “fuse” connection in the pipe line. Restrict pipe reduction upstream of
control valves to the following common rules of thumb:
o Valve size not less than ½ half pipe size
o Valve size not less than 2 nominal sizes below the line size
Isolation (block) valves for the control valve should be the same size as the main pipe
line prior to the valve reduction. Refer to Figure 3.6B.
If the isolation valves are placed in the vertical always leave several pipe diameters up
and downstream of the control valve to allow the flow stream to straighten, reducing flow
turbulence prior to entering the valve inlet.
Incorporate minimum upstream / downstream requirements from butterfly or ball valves to
control valve.
Place drain/tell tale connection on upstream side of control valve.
Verify adequate pull space for operator from the vendor drawing.
Provide adequate space for the control valve and up and downstream reducers (valve will
probably be one size smaller than line size). The required minimum space should be the
length of the valve at line size and the length of two reducers. It is a good practice to
leave additional space between the valve and the reducers.
Orientate operator in the vertical position unless authorized in writing from system design
engineer and/or valve manufacturer.
Avoid crossing over the top of the valve with an overhead pipe run. In plant areas with
low head room the lower pipe run may interfere with the valve and/or operator removal
space, especially on valves for the higher pressure systems.
Request catalog cuts from the system design engineer during released for routing
meeting and store with the RFR package.
Require shop drawings for the valve, including the operator, before releasing the pipe for
fabrication. If no shop drawing is available at release for fabrication stage then a “Hold”
must be placed on the valve and associated dimensions.
Ia
Pa
Pb
Ic
The orientation of this type of valve requires careful consideration due to the typically 90°
inlet/outlet configuration. The operator is generally very large in size and requires
adequate space to access the operator and maintenance space to pull the operator and
valve stem.
Upstream and downstream straight pipe-run recommendations vary per the system
application and the manufacturer. Refer to Figure 3.6.5B. The upstream straight run is
required to reduce non-uniform flow pattern as it enters the valve. Downstream straight
run is required to allow the desuperheating injection water droplets, usually condensate
or feedwater, to evaporate prior to hitting the pipe wall and fittings causing erosion. A
general guideline to use is:
o 5 pipe diameters upstream are required based on 1 pipe bend upstream of the
pipe-run prior to the valve. Additional pipe bends require additional straight pipe-
run.
o Downstream straight run requirements varies considerably depending on several
design conditions – velocity and temperature of the superheat steam,
temperature of the desuperheating water, and in some cases water to steam
ratio. In short, each application requires input from the manufacturer which may
range from 10-30 pipe diameters of straight pipe-run.
When alloy pipe is required upstream of the steam conditioning valve, it is as a general
rule required downstream of the valve outlet. This straight run of alloy pipe is required to
allow the superheating steam drops in temperature as the injection water mixes with the
steam. In short, each application requires input from the manufacturer, which may range
from 5-10 or more pipe diameters of straight pipe-run.
The temperature element (TE) located downstream of the steam conditioning valve outlet
will vary for the downstream straight pipe-run requirements based on the time it takes the
desuperheating water and steam to mix to provide an accurate temperature reading, The
straight pipe-run distance may vary from 39-100 (11.75-30.5m) feet depending on the
system design conditions. Always consult the engineer and valve manufacturer for
requirements.
The location of the pressure transmitter (PT) downstream of the valve discharge will vary
per manufacturer and system application, but a general rule of thumb is 5 pipe diameters
of straight pipe-run downstream of the valve discharge.
3.6.6 Butterfly Valves
Many butterfly valves are rubber-lined and/or faced so either a flat-faced or raised-faced
flange (preferred by B&V) may be used. Neither flange requires a gasket when the valve
is rubber-faced.
As a general rule locate butterfly valves a minimum of 6 pipe diameters from fittings,
valves and pumps to avoid turbulent flow that may lead to undue wear of the valve.
Consult the Engineer and/or manufacturer when 6 pipe diameters is not practical.
Be aware of the clearance requirements of the internal disc on a butterfly valve with up
and downstream components when the valve is in the open position. Two good examples
are the pipe schedule has a wall thickness that impedes the disc from opening and
closing and locating a thermowell too close to the valve, resulting in an interference
between the valve disc and the thermowell that extends inside the pipe.
It is recommended to orientate the valve stem in the vertical position.
In certain applications, for example slurries, horizontal positioning is preferred or required
– provide manufacturer this information as required so that they provide the proper valve.
Butterfly valves should not be installed with the operator in the down position which does
not allow the disc to seat properly.
Refer to the Standard EEC-Std-3-03113-01208, Standard for Large Diameter Butterfly
Valves for installation and design requirements of large butterfly valves.
Always consult the vendor for specific installation/orientation procedures that may conflict
with the B&V Standard. Provide layout data to the vendor for recommendations when
questions arise.
3.6.6.2 Location
The location of a butterfly valve in relation to a pump or fitting, such as a tee or elbow,
can affect the performance of the valve and/or pump. Manufacturers normally
recommended a distance of 6 to 10 pipe diameters, which is not always practical on large
diameter piping due to building and/or pump structure space limitations. The distance
from the valve to the nearest pump or fitting may be decreased to 2 to 3 pipe diameters
downstream and 1 to 2 pipe diameters upstream for pipeline velocities with values of 10
fps (3 m/s) or less. This is to be discussed with the System Engineer who may need to
obtain approval from the vendor.
The orientation of the shaft with respect to pumps and fittings affects the pressure drop
across the valve, torque required of the operator, and stability of the disk in the open
position.
Butterfly valves located on the outlet of an elbow or immediately after a reducer on the
discharge of a pump will be subjected to an uneven flow pattern. An eccentric type disc
on the valve assists in reducing chattering in the valve.
Locating a butterfly valve on the inlet of the elbow generally requires an eccentric type
disc on the valve to assist in reducing chattering in the valve.
Butterfly valves located near suction connections of double suction horizontal pumps
should be oriented with the shaft parallel to the pump shaft to provide hydraulic symmetry
to both sides of the impeller.
Butterfly valves should be installed with the shaft in the horizontal position on surface
water systems that contain silt and sand that can settle in the bottom of the pipe and
valve. This position keeps the shaft bearing away from the sediment area minimizing
wear.
Some manufacturers recommend orienting the shaft vertical on the discharge of large
vertical circulating water pumps to reduce disk flutter and opening torque caused from the
position and location in relation to the pump discharge. Always provide the manufacturer
with a layout of the piping arrangement for their recommendations.
All of the above factors must be taken into consideration when determining the shaft
orientation of each valve. Generally, the valve shafts should be installed horizontally for
all applications since the bearing wear factor will normally outweigh all other
considerations. The valve shafts should not be oriented vertically unless there are
specific overriding reasons to do so.
The valve shaft orientation must be reflected in the line list to ensure proper
communication of orientation to the manufacturer. Tight piping configurations should be
provided to the manufacturer for design considerations.
The actuators for butterfly valves installed in horizontal runs of pipe should be designed to rotate
the bottom half of the disk in the direction of flow when opening. The bottom half of the disk
should rotate toward the pump if located in the pump suction and away from the pump if located
in the pump discharge.
Closed Vent Stack – mainly used to protect pressure vessels (FW Heaters, deaerator
heaters, boiler drums as a few examples).
o Equipment vents may be vented to a common open vent stack in certain cases
such as with vents off of FW heaters.
o Closed stacks should be used in extremely long runs and where the failure of an
open stack would be hazardous to operating personnel.
o Closed vent stacks should use a vent connector (Drawings 81113-DM-0116 (dwg
or pdf) and 81113-DM-0117 (dwg or pdf)) between the safety valve and the vent
stack.
o In the case that the equipment vent is close in proximity to the common vent
stack, it may be necessary to use a vent seal that can accommodate the thermal
movements or provide a routing that accounts for the thermal movements.
Relief valves that discharge water 250° F and below may be piped to discharge in a drain
funnel. The pipe routing should be direct and as short as possible. A baffle at the drain
funnel may be required to keep hot water from splashing out of the drain funnel.
3.7 Instruments
Use care in selecting locations for flow elements and pressure instrument taps to assure
that adequate headroom is available to route the instrument piping properly.
Careful consideration is required when locating instrument connections so that shutoff
valves can be operated and maintenance can be performed including removal of
instrument.
Avoid locating connections on column rows where pipe supports are likely to be placed.
Locate sample connections on the top or side of horizontal piping.
Locate connections as close as possible to its destination or sources as possible.
Locating instruments in vertical piping for any of three following types of connections
listed below allows total circumference usage, which supports accurate instrumentation
readings.
Pressure taps shall be located upstream of temperature taps.
Space shall be provided adjacent to all taps for instrument installation and removal
(typically a 6” (150mm) diameter cylinder ½ the pipe diameter plus 8” (200mm) in length).
FIGURE 3.7.1A
PRESSURE CONNECTIONS – PREFERRED LOCATIONS
Temperature connections shall follow the orientation guidelines as shown below in Figure 3.7.2A.
FIGURE 3.7.2A
TEMPERATURE CONNECTIONS – PREFERRED LOCATIONS
As an alternate, the parallel mounting method does not require a larger section of pipe, and
allows freedom to select sufficient insertion length and still place the sensitive area in the center
of the pipe. However, it typically requires more specialized fittings and careful attention by the
Pipe Designer, and coordination since the proper installation requirements cannot be easily
identified on P&ID drawings. The design also must be reviewed to ensure the thermowell
penetration does not cause unnecessary flow restriction in the pipe. The parallel mounting
arrangement can consist of an elbow with an "Elbolet" (or similar fitting) or the use of a tee. Refer
to Standard Energy-Std-3-03114-03331 Standard for Piping Temperature Element Wells for
additional guidance.
3.7.3 Flow Measurement Connections
Socket Weld connections (sockolets) shall be used for flow measuring devices.
All flow elements shall be located in straight sections of piping with adequate straight run,
generally 20 pipe diameters upstream and 5 pipe diameters downstream. Consult with
the responsible Control Engineer and the manufacturer requirements.
There must not be any valves, pressure connections, or thermowells in these straight
pipe sections, either upstream or downstream.
Placement of flow elements in horizontal pipe runs is preferred.
Taps for horizontal steam, water, or liquid filled piping shall be located on the side or 45
degrees below horizontal as a second choice.
Taps for horizontal gas and air piping shall be located on the top or within 45 degrees
either side.
Flow device connections for instrumentation taps shall follow the orientation guidelines as shown
below in Figure 3.7.3A.
FIGURE 3.7.3A
FLOW PRESSURE CONNECTIONS - PREFERRED LOCATIONS
Level instruments must be arranged and located for easy access during maintenance.
3.8.1 Pumps
Pumps present several unique piping, fitting, and valve layout requirements depending on the
type of pump and the system application. This section will provide good engineering practices in
laying out piping around pumps that will avoid pump problems during operation.
The following are some basic definitions of terminology associated with pumps for the Pipe
Designer’s reference.
o Centrifugal Pump – Is the typical type of pump used in power plants, and within
this group there are several variations of design that are described below. A
centrifugal pump has two main parts – the rotating element, that includes an
impeller and a shaft, and the stationary element consisting of the casing, stuffing
box, and bearings.
o NPSH (Net Positive Suction Head) – The Hydraulic Institute defines NPSH as the
total suction head in feet absolute, determined at the suction nozzle and
corrected to datum, less the vapor pressure of the liquid in feet absolute. In
simpler terms, it is an analysis of energy conditions on the suction side of a pump
to determine if the liquid will vaporize at the lowest pressure point in the pump.
All pumps require a positive NPSH to operate correctly or cavitation may occur in
the pump.
o Cavitation – a term used to describe the phenomenon which occurs in a pump
when there is insufficient NPSH available. The pressure of the liquid is reduced
to a value equal to or below its vapor pressure, and small vapor bubbles or
pockets begin to form. As these vapor bubbles move along the impeller vanes to
a higher pressure area, they rapidly collapse. The collapse or implosion is so
rapid that it may be heard as a rumbling noise, as if you were pumping gravel.
Cavitation may result in damage to the impeller, leading to vibration and
mechanical failure such as bearing failure.
o Suction lift - when the pump is physically located above the water source supply
level.
o Hydraulic Institute (HI) - has a leading role in the development of pump standards
in North America and worldwide. HI standards are developed within guidelines
established by the American National Standards Institute (ANSI).
Foremost it is very important to be aware that vendor recommendations vary on the
subject of piping and valve arrangements around the pump. Always consult the vendor
for layout specifics and request written documentation to be submitted with the shop
drawings. If these requirements are not reasonable to be met then we must submit B&V’s
layout for the pump manufacturer’s written approval.
Suction piping should be short in length, straight as possible, and not smaller in diameter
than the pump suction opening. Most pump manufacturers have a minimum of 5 pipe
diameters between the inlet elbow and the pump connection. Always consult the
manufacturer’s recommendations for specific straight pipe-run requirements.
Avoid locating elbows and tees adjacent to the pump suction nozzle where uneven flow
patterns or vapor separation may occur. The uneven flow distribution across the impellers
may lead to pump cavitation, vibration, and excessive shaft deflection.
Always use a long radius elbow upstream of pump suction.
On pump locations that involve suction lift the suction pipe at the pump must be exactly
horizontal or have a uniform slope upward (1% or more) toward the pump suction nozzle.
Always use an eccentric reducer (flat on top) in this arrangement to avoid high spots in
the piping that can form air pockets.
Avoid several bends (elbows) in pumps that involve suction lift. If the arrangement
dictates several offsets a flow straightener may be required between the last offset and
the pump suction nozzle.
The depth of the suction pipe for pumps that involve suction lift is critical to the operation
of the pump. A suction line inlet that is too close to the surface may draw the vortex core,
which is filled with air, into the pump suction leading to cavitation of the pump. This vortex
core is similar to the water action you see in a bathtub drain. Refer to the HI
recommendations for submergence level of the suction pipe inlet.
A reducer or increaser (as required) should separate the valve and the pump connection
in addition to required straight pipe-run.
As a general rule the reducer reduction size upstream of the pump suction nozzle should
be only one-size, or at the most two sizes, larger than the pump nozzle. If the diameter
difference is larger a straight pipe-run may be required to avoid the flow pattern being
deflected toward one side of the impeller eye due to the drastic angle of the reducer.
Eccentric reducers installed with the straight side on top should be used as pump suction
reducers except for horizontal circulating water pumps that take suction from a basin.
Increasers located at the pump discharge should be of the concentric type with an angle
not exceeding 10 degrees.
A good engineering design is to use an eccentric reducer, flat on top, on the suction side
of centrifugal pumps. The use of an eccentric reducer in this position prevents air pockets
from forming upstream of the pump suction. Concentric reducers located at the pump
suction could result in an air pocket forming and then being swept into the pump suction
cavity causing possible pump cavitation as the air pocket hits the pump impellers.
Always install the suction side isolation valve where no air pockets can be formed.
Install gate valves with stems horizontal, if at all possible, to avoid air pockets forming at
the upstream side of the valve wedge.
3.8.1.1 End Suction/Top Discharge Pumps
This is a centrifugal pump with the suction located on the front-end of the pump and the
discharge on the top of the pump.
When several pumps are in parallel in a system sharing a common supply header a
separate isolation valve will be required for each pump suction line.
The suction side requires straight pipe-run upstream of the suction nozzle and usually an
eccentric reducer (flat on top). Follow manufacturer’s recommendations for downstream
pipe diameters.
In cases where an expansion joint is required it is to be located directly on the nozzle.
The discharge pipe usually requires a concentric reducer located as close to the nozzle
following only the flange and expansion joint (if required).
Maintain a straight pipe run downstream of the discharge nozzle as required by the pipe
manufacturer.
Refer to the Valve Section 3.6.2 and Figure 3.6.2A for the location of check valves on the
discharge side of this type of pump.
Refer to Figure 3.8.1.1A.
Discharge Nozzle
FIGURE 3.8.1.4A
Centrifugal Vertical Pump
For layout purposes the following list provides typical power plant pump applications for various systems:
Abbreviations: HSCP = horizontal split-cased pump, FMESP = frame-mounted end suction pump
CCMP = close-coupled motor pump, CMVSP = centerline mounted vertically split pump, TT = turbine type
3.8.2 Tanks
Use flanged valve at tank nozzle with Expansion / BARCO joints outside of isolation
valve. Verify welded attachments required on tank for supports before coating or painting
the tank.
Use care in placing expansion joints adjacent to a flanged valve because the control rod
lugs extend beyond the flanges and may interfere with the valve body.
3.8.3 General
LATER
LATER
3.12 Constructibility
The following are some general and specific considerations in plant design that designers
need to be aware of.
During the review of vendor drawings for pipe connections consider how the piece of
equipment will be assembled and set in place during construction. An example of this
would be the pipe connections that are welded onto the sidewalls of the condenser.
These connections may need to be identified as field weld after the condenser is set in
place to miss the turbine pedestals, as the condenser is usually erected outside then
slide in between the pedestal legs. The clearance between the condenser sidewalls and
the pedestal legs may be as little as 1.5” (40mm), which would not allow the pipe
connections that extend 3”-12” (80-300mm) beyond the face of the condenser wall to
clear the pedestal legs.
Consider shipping flanges loose on systems as the circ water system, which usually are
large diameter lines that are interfacing with large equipment components (cooling tower,
condenser, tanks, and pumps) that have a tendency to have erection accuracy problems.
Shipping the flanges loose allows the field to manually do a fit-up of the flanged
connections before welding the loose flange in place. Always get your constructors input
on this before designating whether a flange is shipped loose. In the case of circ water
piping the field will normally have to repair the pipe interior coating that is damaged
during the welding of the loose flange.
4.0 Responsibilities and Authorities
Responsibilities for the piping process in accordance with this handbook are as follows:
Project Lead Designer is responsible for assigning routing assignments, developing pipe
routing/deliverables schedule, coordinating the engineering support for Released for Routing
Packages, and employing QA requirements to pipe routing deliverables.
System Engineer is responsible for performing the engineering design of the systems including
providing complete line lists, valve lists, equipment data, and P&IDs – all are to be included in the
“Released for Routing” package that is assembled by the system engineer.
Pipe Designer is responsible for performing the pipe routing and associated activities as defined
in this guideline.
Checker is responsible for performing an independent detailed check of all piping systems as
defined in this guideline.
5.0 References
Hydraulic Institute (HI) website accessible via Knowledge Central on B&V Intranet - IHS Search
NAVCO Book