TB Chapter03 Analysis of Financial Statements
TB Chapter03 Analysis of Financial Statements
Easy:
Current ratio Answer: a Diff: E
1
. All else being equal, which of the following will increase a company’s
current ratio?
Chapter 3 - Page 1
Leverage and financial ratios Answer: d Diff: E
4
. Stennett Corp.’s CFO has proposed that the company issue new debt and
use the proceeds to buy back common stock. Which of the following are
likely to occur if this proposal is adopted? (Assume that the proposal
would have no effect on the company’s operating income.)
a. A company that has positive net income must also have positive EVA.
b. If a company’s ROE is greater than its cost of equity, its EVA is
positive.
c. If a company increases its EVA, its ROE must also increase.
d. Statements a and b are correct.
e. All of the above statements are correct.
Chapter 3 - Page 2
ROE and EVA Answer: b Diff: E
8
. Devon Inc. has a higher ROE than Berwyn Inc. (17 percent compared to 14
percent), but it has a lower EVA than Berwyn. Which of the following
factors could explain the relative performance of these two companies?
a. The two companies have the same basic earning power (BEP).
b. Bedford has a higher return on equity (ROE).
c. Bedford has a lower level of operating income (EBIT).
d. Statements a and b are correct.
e. All of the statements above are correct.
Chapter 3 - Page 3
Financial statement analysis Answer: e Diff: E
12
. Company A and Company B have the same total assets, return on assets
(ROA), and profit margin. However, Company A has a higher debt ratio and
interest expense than Company B. Which of the following statements is
most correct?
Chapter 3 - Page 4
Chapter 3 - Page 5
Medium:
Current ratio Answer: d Diff: M
16
. Van Buren Company has a current ratio = 1.9. Which of the following
actions will increase the company’s current ratio?
a. Issue short-term debt and use the proceeds to buy back long-term debt
with a maturity of more than one year.
b. Reduce the company’s days sales outstanding to the industry average
and use the resulting cash savings to purchase plant and equipment.
c. Use cash to purchase additional inventory.
d. Statements a and b are correct.
e. None of the statements above is correct.
Current Debt
ratio TIE ratio
a. 0.5 0.5 0.33
b. 1.0 1.0 0.50
c. 1.5 1.5 0.50
d. 2.0 1.0 0.67
e. 2.5 0.5 0.71
a. Drysdale has a higher profit margin and a higher debt ratio than
Commerce.
b. Drysdale has a lower profit margin and a lower debt ratio than
Commerce.
c. Drysdale has a higher profit margin and a lower debt ratio than
Commerce.
d. Drysdale has lower net income but more common equity than Commerce.
Chapter 3 - Page 6
e. Drysdale has a lower price earnings ratio than Commerce.
Ratio analysis Answer: a Diff: M
20
. You are an analyst following two companies, Company X and Company Y. You
have collected the following information:
Chapter 3 - Page 7
Financial statement analysis Answer: d Diff: M N
23
. Harte Motors and Mills Automotive each have the same total assets, the
same level of sales, and the same return on equity (ROE). Harte Motors,
however, has less equity and a higher debt ratio than does Mills
Automotive. Which of the following statements is most correct?
Chapter 3 - Page 8
ROE and EVA Answer: d Diff: M
27
. Huxtable Medical’s CFO recently estimated that the company’s EVA for the
past year was zero. The company’s cost of equity capital is 14 percent,
its cost of debt is 8 percent, and its debt ratio is 40 percent. Which
of the following statements is most correct?
a. If two firms have the same ROE and the same level of risk, they must
also have the same EVA.
b. If a firm has positive EVA, this implies that its ROE exceeds its cost
of equity.
c. If a firm has positive ROE, this implies that its EVA is also
positive.
d. Statements b and c are correct.
e. All of the statements above are correct.
a. If Firms A and B have the same earnings per share and market to book
ratio, they must have the same price earnings ratio.
b. Firms A and B have the same net income, taxes paid, and total assets.
If Firm A has a higher interest expense, its basic earnings power
ratio (BEP) must be greater than that of Firm B.
c. Firms A and B have the same net income. If Firm A has a higher
interest expense, its return on equity (ROE) must be greater than
that of Firm B.
d. All of the statements above are correct.
e. None of the statements above is correct.
Chapter 3 - Page 9
Miscellaneous ratios Answer: e Diff: M
30
. Reeves Corporation forecasts that its operating income (EBIT) and total
assets will remain the same as last year, but that the company’s debt
ratio will increase this year. What can you conclude about the
company’s financial ratios? (Assume that there will be no change in the
company’s tax rate.)
Tough:
ROE and EVA Answer: a Diff: T
32
. Division A has a higher ROE than Division B, yet Division B creates more
value for shareholders and has a higher EVA than Division A. Both
divisions, however, have positive ROEs and EVAs. What could explain
these performance measures?
Chapter 3 - Page 10
Ratio analysis Answer: d Diff: T
33
. You have collected the following information regarding Companies C and
D:
Chapter 3 - Page 11
Chapter 3 - Page 12
Leverage and financial ratios Answer: d Diff: T
36
. Blair Company has $5 million in total assets. The company’s assets are
financed with $1 million of debt and $4 million of common equity. The
company’s income statement is summarized below:
Chapter 3 - Page 13
Multiple Choice: Problems
Easy:
Financial statement analysis Answer: a Diff: E
38
. Russell Securities has $100 million in total assets and its corporate
tax rate is 40 percent. The company recently reported that its basic
earning power (BEP) ratio was 15 percent and its return on assets (ROA)
was 9 percent. What was the company’s interest expense?
a. $ 0
b. $ 2,000,000
c. $ 6,000,000
d. $15,000,000
e. $18,000,000
a. $ 33.33
b. $ 75.00
c. $ 10.00
d. $166.67
e. $133.32
a. $20.00
b. $ 8.00
c. $ 4.00
d. $ 2.00
e. $ 1.00
a. 500,000
b. 125,000
c. 2,000,000
Chapter 3 - Page 14
d. 800,000,000
e. Insufficient information.
Market/book ratio Answer: e Diff: E N
42
. Strack Houseware Supplies Inc. has $2 billion in total assets. The other
side of its balance sheet consists of $0.2 billion in current
liabilities, $0.6 billion in long-term debt, and $1.2 billion in common
equity. The company has 300 million shares of common stock outstanding,
and its stock price is $20 per share. What is Strack’s market/book
ratio?
a. 1.25
b. 2.65
c. 3.15
d. 4.40
e. 5.00
a. 8.4%
b. 10.9%
c. 12.0%
d. 13.3%
e. 15.1%
a. $42.86
b. $50.00
c. $40.00
d. $60.00
e. $57.93
Chapter 3 - Page 15
ROE Answer: c Diff: E
45
. Tapley Dental Supply Company has the following data:
If Tapley could streamline operations, cut operating costs, and raise net
income to $300 without affecting sales or the balance sheet (the
additional profits will be paid out as dividends), by how much would its
ROE increase?
a. 3.00%
b. 3.50%
c. 4.00%
d. 4.25%
e. 5.50%
Balance Sheet:
Cash $ 20
A/R 1,000
Inventories 5,000
Total current assets $6,020 Debt $4,000
Net fixed assets 2,980 Equity 5,000
Total assets $9,000 Total claims $9,000
Income Statement:
Sales $10,000
Cost of goods sold 9,200
EBIT $ 800
Interest (10%) 400
EBT $ 400
Taxes (40%) 160
Net income $ 240
The industry average inventory turnover is 5. You think you can change
your inventory control system so as to cause your turnover to equal the
industry average, and this change is expected to have no effect on either
sales or cost of goods sold. The cash generated from reducing
inventories will be used to buy tax-exempt securities that have a 7
percent rate of return. What will your profit margin be after the change
in inventories is reflected in the income statement?
a. 2.1%
b. 2.4%
c. 4.5%
Chapter 3 - Page 16
d. 5.3%
e. 6.7%
Du Pont equation Answer: a Diff: E
47
. The Wilson Corporation has the following relationships:
a. 2%; 0.33
b. 4%; 0.33
c. 4%; 0.67
d. 2%; 0.67
e. 4%; 0.50
a. $10.00
b. $ 7.50
c. $ 5.00
d. $ 2.50
e. $ 1.50
a. $20.00
b. $30.00
c. $40.00
d. $50.00
e. $60.00
Chapter 3 - Page 17
Current ratio and inventory Answer: b Diff: E N
50
. Iken Berry Farms has $5 million in current assets, $3 million in current
liabilities, and its initial inventory level is $1 million. The company
plans to increase its inventory, and it will raise additional short-term
debt (that will show up as notes payable on the balance sheet) to
purchase the inventory. Assume that the value of the remaining current
assets will not change. The company’s bond covenants require it to
maintain a current ratio that is greater than or equal to 1.5. What is
the maximum amount that the company can increase its inventory before it
is restricted by these covenants?
a. $0.50 million
b. $1.00 million
c. $1.33 million
d. $1.66 million
e. $2.33 million
Medium:
Accounts receivable increase Answer: b Diff: M R
51
. Cannon Company has enjoyed a rapid increase in sales in recent years,
following a decision to sell on credit. However, the firm has noticed a
recent increase in its collection period. Last year, total sales were $1
million, and $250,000 of these sales were on credit. During the year, the
accounts receivable account averaged $41,096. It is expected that sales
will increase in the forthcoming year by 50 percent, and, while credit
sales should continue to be the same proportion of total sales, it is
expected that the days sales outstanding will also increase by 50 percent.
If the resulting increase in accounts receivable must be financed
externally, how much external funding will Cannon need? Assume a 365-day
year.
a. $ 41,096
b. $ 51,370
c. $ 47,359
d. $106,471
e. $ 92,466
a. $576,000
b. $633,333
c. $750,000
Chapter 3 - Page 18
d. $900,000
e. $966,667
ROA Answer: a Diff: M
53
. A fire has destroyed a large percentage of the financial records of the
Carter Company. You have the task of piecing together information in
order to release a financial report. You have found the return on equity
to be 18 percent. If sales were $4 million, the debt ratio was 0.40,
and total liabilities were $2 million, what would be the return on
assets (ROA)?
a. 10.80%
b. 0.80%
c. 1.25%
d. 12.60%
e. Insufficient information.
a. 6.45%
b. 5.97%
c. 4.33%
d. 8.56%
e. 5.25%
a. 3.2%
b. 4.0%
c. 4.8%
d. 6.0%
e. 7.2%
a. 7.1%
b. 33.4%
c. 3.4%
d. 71.0%
Chapter 3 - Page 19
e. 8.1%
Chapter 3 - Page 20
ROE Answer: b Diff: M
57
. A firm has a debt/equity ratio of 50 percent. Currently, it has
interest expense of $500,000 on $5,000,000 of total debt outstanding.
Its tax rate is 40 percent. If the firm’s ROA is 6 percent, by how many
percentage points is the firm’s ROE greater than its ROA?
a. 0.0%
b. 3.0%
c. 5.2%
d. 7.4%
e. 9.0%
ROE Answer: d Diff: M
58
. Assume Meyer Corporation is 100 percent equity financed. Calculate the
return on equity, given the following information:
a. 25%
b. 30%
c. 35%
d. 42%
e. 50%
Sales $1,000
Total assets $1,000
Total debt/Total assets 35.00%
Basic earning power (BEP) ratio 20.00%
Tax rate 40.00%
Interest rate on total debt 4.57%
a. 11.04%
b. 12.31%
c. 16.99%
d. 28.31%
e. 30.77%
Chapter 3 - Page 21
Equity multiplier Answer: d Diff: M
60
. A firm that has an equity multiplier of 4.0 will have a debt ratio of
a. 4.00
b. 3.00
c. 1.00
d. 0.75
e. 0.25
a. 2.4
b. 3.4
c. 3.6
d. 4.0
e. 5.0
a. 2.25
b. 1.71
c. 1.00
d. 1.33
e. 2.50
a. 2.5
b. 3.0
c. 1.5
d. 1.2
e. 0.6
Chapter 3 - Page 22
TIE ratio Answer: d Diff: M N
64
. Roll’s Boutique currently has total assets of $3 million in operation.
Over this year, its performance yielded a basic earning power (BEP) of
25 percent and a return on assets (ROA) of 12 percent. The firm’s
earnings are subject to a 35 percent tax rate. On the basis of this
information, what is the firm’s times interest earned (TIE) ratio?
a. 1.84
b. 1.92
c. 2.83
d. 3.82
e. 4.17
a. 2.06
b. 1.52
c. 2.25
d. 1.10
e. 2.77
a. 0.20
b. 0.30
c. 0.33
d. 0.60
e. 0.66
a. 3.48%
b. 5.42%
c. 6.96%
d. 2.45%
Chapter 3 - Page 23
e. 12.82%
Financial statement analysis Answer: e Diff: M R
68
. Collins Company had the following partial balance sheet and complete
income statement information for 2002:
Income Statement:
Sales $10,000
Cost of goods sold 9,200
EBIT $ 800
Interest (10%) 400
EBT $ 400
Taxes (40%) 160
Net income $ 240
a. 33.33%
b. 45.28%
c. 52.75%
d. 60.00%
e. 65.65%
a. -$ 8,333
b. $ 68,493
c. $125,000
d. $200,000
Chapter 3 - Page 24
e. $316,667
Chapter 3 - Page 25
c. 2.33
d. 1.25
e. 1.67
Current ratio Answer: c Diff: M N
73
. Cartwright Brothers has the following balance sheet (all numbers are
expressed in millions of dollars):
a. 1.00
b. 0.63
c. 1.30
d. 1.25
e. 1.50
a. 1.43
b. 1.50
c. 2.50
Chapter 3 - Page 26
d. 2.00
e. 1.20
Chapter 3 - Page 27
Credit policy and ROE Answer: c Diff: M R
75
. Daggy Corporation has the following simplified balance sheet:
The company has been advised that their credit policy is too generous
and that they should reduce their days sales outstanding to 36 days
(assume a 365-day year). The increase in cash resulting from the
decrease in accounts receivable will be used to reduce the company’s
long-term debt. The interest rate on long-term debt is 10 percent and
the company’s tax rate is 30 percent. The tighter credit policy is
expected to reduce the company’s sales to $730,000 and result in EBIT of
$70,000. What is the company’s expected ROE after the change in credit
policy?
a. 14.88%
b. 16.63%
c. 15.86%
d. 18.38%
e. 16.25%
a. 55%
b. 60%
c. 65%
d. 70%
e. 75%
a. $1,440,000,000
b. $2,400,000,000
c. $ 120,000,000
d. $ 360,000,000
Chapter 3 - Page 28
e. $ 960,000,000
a. $1,500,000
b. $2,857,143
c. $ 428,571
d. $2,333,333
e. $ 52,500
Tough:
ROE Answer: c Diff: T
79
. Roland & Company has a new management team that has developed an
operating plan to improve upon last year’s ROE. The new plan would
place the debt ratio at 55 percent, which will result in interest
charges of $7,000 per year. EBIT is projected to be $25,000 on sales of
$270,000, it expects to have a total assets turnover ratio of 3.0, and
the average tax rate will be 40 percent. What does Roland & Company
expect its return on equity to be following the changes?
a. 17.65%
b. 21.82%
c. 26.67%
d. 44.44%
e. 51.25%
Chapter 3 - Page 29
ROE Answer: d Diff: T
80
. Georgia Electric reported the following income statement and balance
sheet for the previous year:
Balance Sheet:
Cash $ 100,000
Inventories 1,000,000
Accounts receivable 500,000
Current assets $1,600,000
Total debt $4,000,000
Net fixed assets 4,400,000 Total equity 2,000,000
Total assets $6,000,000 Total claims $6,000,000
Income Statement:
Sales $3,000,000
Operating costs 1,600,000
Operating income (EBIT) $1,400,000
Interest 400,000
Taxable income (EBT) $1,000,000
Taxes (40%) 400,000
Net income $ 600,000
• The company maintained the same sales, but was able to reduce
inventories enough to achieve the industry average inventory
turnover ratio.
• The cash that was generated from the reduction in inventories was
used to reduce part of the company’s outstanding debt. So, the
company’s total debt would have been $4 million less the freed-up
cash from the improvement in inventory policy. The company’s
interest expense would have been 10 percent of new total debt.
• Assume equity does not change. (The company pays all net income as
dividends.)
Under this scenario, what would have been the company’s ROE last year?
a. 27.0%
b. 29.5%
c. 30.3%
d. 31.5%
e. 33.0%
Chapter 3 - Page 30
ROE and financing Answer: a Diff: T
81
. Savelots Stores’ current financial statements are shown below:
Balance Sheet:
Inventories $ 500 Accounts payable $ 100
Other current assets 400 Short-term notes payable 370
Fixed assets 370 Common equity 800
Total assets $1,270 Total liab. and equity $1,270
Income Statement:
Sales $2,000
Operating costs 1,843
EBIT $ 157
Interest 37
EBT $ 120
Taxes (40%) 48
Net income $ 72
a. 10.5%
b. 7.8%
c. 9.0%
d. 13.2%
e. 12.0%
Chapter 3 - Page 31
ROE and refinancing Answer: d Diff: T
82
. Aurillo Equipment Company (AEC) projected that its ROE for next year
would be just 6 percent. However, the financial staff has determined
that the firm can increase its ROE by refinancing some high interest
bonds currently outstanding. The firm’s total debt will remain at
$200,000 and the debt ratio will hold constant at 80 percent, but the
interest rate on the refinanced debt will be 10 percent. The rate on
the old debt is 14 percent. Refinancing will not affect sales, which
are projected to be $300,000. EBIT will be 11 percent of sales and the
firm’s tax rate is 40 percent. If AEC refinances its high interest
bonds, what will be its projected new ROE?
a. 3.0%
b. 8.2%
c. 10.0%
d. 15.6%
e. 18.7%
Assets $10,000
Profit margin 3.0%
Tax rate 40%
Debt ratio 60.0%
Interest rate 10.0%
Total assets turnover 2.0
a. 0.95
b. 1.75
c. 2.10
d. 2.67
e. 3.45
a. 1.50
b. 1.97
c. 1.26
d. 0.72
Chapter 3 - Page 32
e. 1.66
P/E ratio and stock price Answer: b Diff: T
85
. XYZ’s balance sheet and income statement are given below:
Balance Sheet:
Cash $ 50 Accounts payable $ 100
A/R 150 Notes payable 0
Inventories 300 Long-term debt (10%) 700
Fixed assets 500 Common equity (20 shares) 200
Total assets $1,000 Total liabilities and equity $1,000
Income Statement:
Sales $1,000
Cost of goods sold 855
EBIT $ 145
Interest 70
EBT $ 75
Taxes (33.333%) 25
Net income $ 50
a. $ 3.33
b. $ 6.67
c. $ 8.75
d. $10.00
e. $12.50
a. 25.0%
b. 35.0%
c. 50.0%
d. 52.5%
e. 65.0%
Chapter 3 - Page 33
Financial statement analysis Answer: a Diff: T
87
. A company has just been taken over by new management that believes it
can raise earnings before taxes (EBT) from $600 to $1,000, merely by
cutting overtime pay and reducing cost of goods sold. Prior to the
change, the following data applied:
These data have been constant for several years, and all income is paid
out as dividends. Sales, the tax rate, and the balance sheet will
remain constant. What is the company’s cost of debt? (Hint: Work only
with old data.)
a. 12.92%
b. 13.23%
c. 13.51%
d. 13.75%
e. 14.00%
Assets $100,000
Profit margin 6.0%
Tax rate 40%
Debt ratio 40.0%
Interest rate 8.0%
Total assets turnover 3.0
a. $ 3,200
b. $12,000
c. $18,000
d. $30,000
e. $33,200
Chapter 3 - Page 34
Sales increase needed Answer: b Diff: T N
89
. Ricardo Entertainment recently reported the following income statement:
Sales $12,000,000
Cost of goods sold 7,500,000
EBIT $ 4,500,000
Interest 1,500,000
EBT $ 3,000,000
Taxes (40%) 1,200,000
Net income $ 1,800,000
The company’s CFO, Fred Mertz, wants to see a 25 percent increase in net
income over the next year. In other words, his target for next year’s
net income is $2,250,000. Mertz has made the following observations:
a. 72.92%
b. 9.38%
c. 2.50%
d. 48.44%
e. 25.00%
Multiple Part:
(The following information applies to the next two problems.)
Fama’s French Bakery has a return on assets (ROA) of 10 percent and a return
on equity (ROE) of 14 percent. Fama’s total assets equal total debt plus
common equity (that is, there is no preferred stock). Furthermore, we know
that the firm’s total assets turnover is 5.
a. 14.29%
b. 28.00%
c. 28.57%
d. 55.56%
e. 71.43%
Chapter 3 - Page 35
Profit margin and Du Pont analysis Answer: a Diff: E N
91
. What is Fama’s profit margin?
a. 2.00%
b. 4.00%
c. 4.33%
d. 5.33%
e. 6.00%
Miller also reported sales revenues of $4.5 billion and a 20 percent ROE for
this same year.
a. 2.500%
b. 3.125%
c. 4.625%
d. 5.625%
e. 7.826%
a. 0.455
b. 0.818
c. 1.091
d. 1.125
e. 1.800
Chapter 3 - Page 36
(The following information applies to the next three problems.)
Dokic, Inc. reported the following balance sheets for year-end 2001 and 2002
(dollars in millions):
2002 2001
Cash $ 650 $ 500
Accounts receivable 450 700
Inventories 850 600
Total current assets $1,950 $1,800
Net fixed assets 2,450 2,200
Total assets $4,400 $4,000
a. The company’s current ratio was higher in 2002 than it was in 2001.
b. The company’s debt ratio was higher in 2002 than it was in 2001.
c. The company issued new common stock during 2002.
d. Statements a and b are correct.
e. Statements a and c are correct.
a. $ 50 million
b. $150 million
c. $250 million
d. $350 million
e. $450 million
Chapter 3 - Page 37
Sales, DSO, and inventory turnover Answer: b Diff: M N
96
. When reviewing the company’s performance for 2002, its CFO observed that
the company’s inventory turnover ratio was below the industry average
inventory turnover ratio of 6.0. In addition, the company’s DSO (days
sales outstanding, calculated on a 365-day basis) was less than the
industry average of 50 (that is, DSO < 50). On the basis of this
information, what is the most likely estimate of the company’s sales (in
millions of dollars) for 2002?
a. $ 2,940
b. $ 5,038
c. $ 7,250
d. $10,863
e. $30,765
Below are the 2001 and 2002 year-end balance sheets for Kewell Boomerangs:
2002 2001
Cash $ 100,000 $ 85,000
Accounts receivable 432,000 350,000
Inventories 1,000,000 700,000
Total current assets $1,532,000 $1,135,000
Net fixed assets 3,000,000 2,800,000
Total assets $4,532,000 $3,935,000
Kewell Boomerangs has never paid a dividend on its common stock. Kewell
issued $1,200,000 of long-term debt in 1997. This debt was non-callable and
is scheduled to mature in 2027. As of the end of 2002, none of the principal
on this debt has been repaid. Assume that 2001 and 2002 sales were the same
in both years.
Chapter 3 - Page 38
Financial statement analysis Answer: a Diff: E N
97
. Which of the following statements is most correct?
a. 1.018
b. 1.021
c. 1.023
d. 1.027
e. 1.033
Chapter 3 - Page 39
CHAPTER 3
ANSWERS AND SOLUTIONS
Chapter 3 - Page 40
1. Current ratio Answer: a Diff: E
Pepsi Corporation:
Before: Current ratio = $50/$100 = 0.50.
After: Current ratio = $150/$200 = 0.75.
Coke Company:
Before: Current ratio = $150/$100 = 1.50.
After: Current ratio = $250/$200 = 1.25.
Statements a and c are correct. The increase in debt payments will reduce
net income and hence reduce ROA. Also, higher debt payments will result
in lower taxable income and less tax. Therefore, statement d is the best
choice.
Statement a is true; higher debt will increase interest expense and net
income will decline, resulting in a lower ROA than before. Statement b is
true; both net income and equity are going to decline, but net income will
decline less because the basic earning power exceeds the cost of debt, so
ROE will actually rise. Statement c is true; both EBIT and total assets
remain the same. Therefore, statement e is the best choice.
If the cost of equity times the amount of equity is greater than NI, EVA
could be negative. Just because a company has a positive NI does not mean
that it is earning enough to adequately compensate its shareholders.
Therefore, statement a is not correct.
From the formula above, you can see that a company can increase its EVA by
increasing its ROE, decreasing its cost of equity, or by increasing its
equity investment. Any of these three changes would increase EVA, not
just the increase in ROE. Therefore, statement c is incorrect.
EVA is the value added after both shareholders and debtholders have been
paid. Net income only takes payments to debtholders into account, not
shareholders. Therefore, statement a is false. EVA = (ROE - k) × Total
equity. So, if k is larger than ROE, EVA would be negative even if ROE is
positive. The shareholders are getting a return but not as much as they
require. Therefore, statement b is false. Statement c is exactly the
opposite of what is true, so it is false. EVA will be negative whenever
the cost of equity exceeds the ROE. Since statements a, b, and c are
false, the correct choice is statement e.
Since Devon has a higher ROE, but its EVA is lower, the only things that
could explain this is if (1) its k s were higher or (2) its equity (or size)
were lower.
Answer: b Diff: E
Bedford = D; Breezewood = Z.
TAD = TAZ; ROAD = ROAZ; TD = TZ; D/AD > D/AZ; INTD > INTZ; ROA = NI/TA.
If both companies have the same ROA and total assets, then they must both
have the same net incomes. Therefore, NID = NIZ.
Bedford has a higher D/A ratio than Breezewood; therefore, it has a higher
EM than Breezewood. If its EM is higher and its ROA is the same, then
Bedford’s ROE must be higher than Breezewood’s.
From the first sentence, both firms have the same net income, sales, and
assets. Since A has more debt, it must have less equity. Thus, its ROE
(calculated as Net income/Equity) is higher than B’s. So statement a is
correct. Since the two firms have the same total assets and sales, their
total assets turnover ratios must be the same. So statement b is false. If
A has higher interest expense than B but the same net income, this means
that A must have higher operating income (EBIT) than B. Therefore
statement c is correct. Since statements a and c are correct, the correct
choice is statement e.
The firms have the same profit margin and equity multiplier. The equity
multiplier is the same because both companies have the same debt ratio. If
Company A has a higher ROE than B, then from the Du Pont equation Company
A also has a higher total assets turnover ratio than B. The current ratio
does not explain the ratios discussed. Therefore, only statement a
explains the observed ratios.
TAD = TAC.
TATOD = TATOC so, S/TAD = S/TAC.
ROED = ROEC.
ROAD > ROAC.
Since TATO is the same for both, and since TA is the same for both, sales
must be the same for both (since TATO = Sales/TA). Remember the Du Pont
equation: ROE = PM × TATO × EM. Drysdale and Commerce have the same TATO.
So, if Drysdale has a higher PM and a higher EM (if the debt ratio is
higher, the EM is higher), then its ROE must be higher. However, the problem
states that the companies have the same ROE. Therefore, statement a is
incorrect. If Drysdale’s PM and debt ratio are lower than Commerce’s and
both have the same TATO, Drysdale would have a lower ROE. The problem states
that the companies have the same ROE, so statement b is incorrect. Looking
again at the Du Pont equation: ROE = PM × TATO × EM. If the ROEs are the
same and the TATOs are the same, then (PM × EM) must be the same for the two
companies. If Drysdale has a higher PM and a lower EM, then (PM × EM)
could be the same for both. Therefore, statement c could explain the
ratios in the problem. If Drysdale has lower NI and more common equity
(higher TE), then its ROE would be lower. Therefore, statement d is
incorrect. The P/E ratio is irrelevant. The stock price cannot explain
what is going on with the two companies’ ratios.
Statement a is correct. The other statements are false. The use of debt
provides tax benefits to the corporations that issue debt, not to the
investors who purchase debt (in the form of bonds). The basic earning
power ratio would be the same if the only thing that differed between the
firms were their debt ratios.
Answer: d Diff: M N
TATO = Sales/TA. Both companies have the same total assets. However,
since A has a lower profit margin than B and its net income is the same as
B’s, it must have higher sales; thus, A has a higher total assets turnover
ratio than B. Therefore, statement a is true. ROE = NI/Equity. Both
companies have the same total assets and net income, but A has more debt
and thus less equity than B. Therefore, A has a higher ROE than B.
Therefore, statement b is true. BEP = EBIT/TA. We know that A has higher
interest payments than B but the same net income as B. Therefore, A must
have a higher EBIT than B to cover this extra interest. Thus, A must have
a higher basic earning power ratio than B. Therefore, statement c is
true. Since statements a, b, and c are true, the correct choice is
statement e.
If BEP and total assets are equal, we know that EBIT is equal. Company A
has a higher debt ratio and higher interest expense than Company B.
Since Company A has lower net income, it must have a lower ROA (since
total assets are the same). If EBIT is the same for both A and B and
Company A has higher interest expense, Company A must have a lower TIE
ratio than Company B. Company A has a lower EBT and lower net income than
Company B. If A has lower EBT, then Company A pays less in taxes than
Company B. There is a positive relationship between the debt ratio and
the equity multiplier, which means that Company A has a higher equity
multiplier than B because A’s debt ratio is higher than B’s. Therefore,
the correct choice is statement d.
Statements b and c are correct. ROA = NI/TA. An increase in the debt ratio
will result in an increase in interest expense, and a reduction in NI. Thus
ROA will fall. EM = Assets/Equity. As debt increases, the amount of equity
in the denominator decreases, thus causing the equity multiplier (EM) to
increase. Therefore, statement e is the correct choice.
Since X has a lower ROA (NI/TA) than Y and both firms have the same
assets, X must have a lower net income than Y. So statement c is correct.
X has a higher ROE (NI/EQ) than Y, even though its net income is lower.
Consequently, X must have less equity than Y, and therefore, more debt
than Y. So statement a is false. Since X has a higher total assets
turnover ratio (Sales/TA) than Y and both firms have the same assets, X’s
sales must be higher than Y’s. This fact, combined with X’s lower net
income, means that X must have a lower profit margin (NI/Sales) than Y, so
statement b is correct. Thus, statements b and c are both correct. So,
the correct choice is statement d.
32. ROE and EVA Answer: a Diff: T
The following formula will make this question much easier: EVA = (ROE - k s)
× Total equity. If Division A is riskier than Division B, then A’s cost of
equity capital will be higher than B’s. If k s is higher, EVA will be lower.
So, statement a is true. If A is larger than B in terms of equity, then the
term (ROE - k s) will be multiplied by a much larger number for Division A.
Since A’s ROE is also higher than B’s, then its EVA would be higher than
B’s. Therefore, statement b is false. If A has less debt, then its
interest payments will be lower than B’s, so its EBIT will be higher.
Another way to write the EVA formula is EVA = EBIT (1 – T) – [Cost of
capital × Investor-supplied capital employed]. So, a higher EBIT will lead
to a higher EVA. In addition, a lower level of debt will make A less risky
than B, so A’s cost of equity will be lower than B’s. From the other EVA
formula, we can see that this would cause a higher EVA, not a lower one.
So, statement c is false.
Statement d is correct; the others are false. ROA = NI/TA. Company C has
higher interest expense than Company D; therefore, it must have lower net
income. Since the two firms have the same total assets, ROA C < ROAD.
Statement a is false; we cannot tell what sales are. From the facts as
stated above, they could be the same or different. Statement b is false;
Company C must have lower equity than Company D, which could lead it to
have a higher ROE because its equity multiplier would be greater than
company D's. Statement c is false as TIE = EBIT/Interest, and C has
higher interest than D but the same EBIT; therefore, TIE C < TIED. Statement
e is false; they have the same BEP = EBIT/TA from the facts as given in
this problem.
We can conclude that X has a lower NI, because it has a lower EBIT and
higher interest than Y, but the same tax rate as Y. Sales for each
company are the same because they have the same total assets and the same
total assets turnover ratio (TATO = Sales/TA). Therefore, since X has a
lower NI and same sales as Y, it must follow that it has a lower profit
margin (NI/Sales).
Answer: d Diff: T
ROAL = ROAY; S/TAL > S/TAY; EML > EMY, or A/EL > A/EY.
From the Du Pont equation we know that ROA = Profit margin × Total assets
turnover. If the 2 firms’ ROAs are equal, but Lancaster’s total assets
turnover is greater than York’s then Lancaster’s profit margin must be lower
than York’s. Therefore, statement a is true. The debt ratio is calculated
as 1 - 1/Equity multiplier. So, if Lancaster has a higher equity multiplier
than York, its debt ratio must be higher too. So, statement b is false.
From the extended Du Pont equation we know that ROE = Profit margin × Total
assets turnover × Equity multiplier. We also know that ROA = Profit margin
× Total assets turnover. Since we know the
2 firms’ ROAs are equal and Lancaster has a higher equity multiplier it must
have a higher ROE too. Therefore, statement c is true. Since statements a
and c are true, the correct choice is statement d.
NI $540,000 $600,000
ROAOld = = = 10.8% ; ROENew = = 10%.
Assets $5,000,000 $6,000,000
Therefore, ROA falls.
NI $540,000 $600,000
ROEOld = = = 13.5% ; ROENew = = 15.0%.
Equity $4,000,000 $4,000,000
Since net income increases, ROA falls and ROE increases, statement d is
the correct choice.
TATO = Sales/TA
= NI/TA × S/NI
= ROA × 1/PM.
D/A = TD/TA
= (TA - EQ)/TA
= (TA/TA) - (EQ/TA)
= 1 - (EQ/NI) × (NI/TA)
= 1 - (ROA/ROE).
ROA = NI/TA
NI = TA × ROA.
Hemmingway Fitzgerald
TATO = ROA/PM = 0.09/0.04 = 0.08/0.03
= 2.25×. = 2.67×.
D/A = 1 - (ROA/ROE) = 1 - (0.09/0.18) = 1 - (0.08/0.24)
= 0.5. = 0.667.
NI = TA × ROA = 2 × 0.09 = 1.5 × 0.08
= $0.18 billion. = $0.12 billion.
BEP = EBIT/TA
0.15 = EBIT/$100,000,000
EBIT = $15,000,000.
ROA = NI/TA
0.09 = NI/$100,000,000
NI = $9,000,000.
EBT = NI/(1 - T)
EBT = $9,000,000/0.6
EBT = $15,000,000.
Alternative solution:
Book value per share = $1,250/25 = $50.
Market value per share = $50(1.5) = $75.
41
. Market/book ratio Answer: c Diff: E
M Price per share × shares
=
B BV
$80 × shares
4.0 =
$40,000,000
$160,000,000 = $80 × shares
2,000,000 = shares.
$1,200,000,000
Book value = = $4.00.
300,000,000
$20.00
M/B = = 5.0.
$4.00
TIE = EBIT/INT
7 = ($300 + INT)/INT
7INT = $300 + INT
6INT = $300
INT = $50.
With the numbers provided, we can see that Iken Berry Farms has a current
ratio of 1.67 (CA/CL = $5/$3 = 1.67). If notes payable are going to be
raised to buy inventories, both the numerator and the denominator of the
ratio will increase. We can increase current liabilities $1 million
before the current ratio reaches 1.5.
CA + X
≥ 1.5
CL + X
$5,000,000 + X
≥ 1.5
$3,000,000 + X
$5,000,000 + X ≥ $4,500,000 + 1.5X
$500,000 ≥ 0.5X
$1,000,000 ≥ X
X ≤ $1,000,000.
First solve for current annual sales using the DSO equation as follows: 50
= $1,000,000/(Sales/365) to find annual sales equal to $7,300,000.
If sales fall by 10%, the new sales level will be $7,300,000(0.9) =
$6,570,000. Again, using the DSO equation, solve for the new accounts
receivable figure as follows: 32 = AR/($6,570,000/365) or AR = $576,000.
Step 2: NI/TA = ROA, so now we need to find net income. Net income is
found by working through the income statement (in millions):
EBIT $40
Interest 5 (from TIE ratio: 8 = EBIT/Int)
EBT $35
Taxes (40%) 14
NI $21
55 . ROA
Answer: c Diff: M N
EBIT $50,000
Int -10,000
EBT $40,000
Taxes (40%) -16,000
NI $24,000
EBIT
= 0.12
$8,000,000,000
EBIT = $960,000,000.
NI
= 0.03
$8,000,000,000
NI = $240,000,000.
Now use the income statement format to determine interest so you can
calculate the firm’s TIE ratio.
TIE = EBIT/INT
= $960,000,000/$560,000,000
= 1.7143 ≈ 1.71.
BEP = EBIT/TA
25% = EBIT/$20,000,000
$5,000,000 = EBIT.
ROA = NI/TA
10% = NI/$20,000,000
$2,000,000 = NI.
NI = (EBIT - I)(1 - T)
$2,000,000 = ($5,000,000 - I)(1 - 0.4)
$2,000,000 = ($5,000,000 - I)(0.6)
$3,333,333 = $5,000,000 - I
$1,666,667 = I.
The times interest earned (TIE) ratio is calculated as the ratio of EBIT
and interest expense. We can find EBIT from the BEP ratio and total
assets given in the problem.
EBIT
BEP =
TA
EBIT
25% =
$3,000,000
EBIT = $750,000.
NI
ROA =
TA
NI
12% =
$3,000,000
NI = $360,000.
NI
EBT =
(1 - T)
$360,000
EBT =
(1 − 0.35)
EBT = $553,846.
EBIT
TIE =
INT
$750,000
TIE =
$196,154
TIE = 3.82×.
EBIT/$9,000,000,000 = 0.09
EBIT = $810,000,000.
3 = EBIT/INT
3 = $810,000,000/INT
INT = $270,000,000.
EBITDA = EBIT + DA
= $810,000,000 + $1,000,000,000
= $1,810,000,000.
Sales/Total assets = 6
Total assets = $24,000,000/6 = $4,000,000.
ROE = NI/Equity
Equity = NI/ROE = $400,000/0.15 = $2,666,667.
$1,000
Current DSO = = 36.5 days. Industry average DSO = 30 days.
$10,000/365
$10,000
Reduce receivables by (36.5 – 30) = $178.08.
365
Debt = $400/0.10 = $4,000.
TD $4,000 - $178.08
= = 65.65%.
TA $6,000 - $178.08
Given ROA = 10% and net income of $500,000, total assets must be $5,000,000.
NI
ROA =
A
$500,000
10% =
TA
TA = $5,000,000.
EBIT
BEP =
TA
$1,033,333
=
$5,000,000
= 0.2067 = 20.67%.
The current EPS is $1,500,000/300,000 shares or $5. The current P/E ratio
is then $60/$5 = 12. The new number of shares outstanding will be 400,000.
Thus, the new EPS = $2,500,000/400,000 = $6.25. If the shares are selling
for 12 times EPS, then they must be selling for $6.25(12) = $75.
Answer: a Diff: M
If DSO changes while sales remain the same, then receivables must
change.
$400
40 =
Average Daily Sales
$10 = Average Daily Sales.
Currently:
DSO = AR/Average Daily Sales
= $250/$10
= 25 days.
Now, Cartwright wants to reduce DSO to 15. The firm needs to reduce
accounts receivable because it doesn’t want to reduce average daily sales.
So, we can calculate the new AR balance as follows:
DSO = AR/Average Daily Sales
15 = AR/$10
$150 million = AR.
If the firm reduces its DSO to the industry average, its AR will be $150
million, reduced by $100 million. Therefore, there must be an equal
reduction on the right side of the balance sheet. Half of this $100
million of freed-up cash will be used to reduce notes payable, and the
other half will be used to reduce accounts payable. Therefore, notes
payable will fall by $50 million to $250 million, and accounts payable
will fall by $50 million to $250 million.
Step 2: Calculate what the firm’s inventory balance should be if the firm
maintains the industry average inventory turnover.
Inv. turnover = Sales/Inv.
10× = $3 million/Inv.
$300,000 = Inv.
Half of the $200,000 that is freed up will be used to reduce notes payable,
and the other half will be used to reduce common equity. Therefore, notes
payable will be reduced by $100,000 to a new level of $100,000.
Step 5: Calculate the firm’s new current ratio with the improved
inventory management.
CR = CA/CL
= $600,000/$400,000
= 1.5×.
Use the DSO formula to calculate accounts receivable under the new policy
as 36 = AR/($730,000/365) or AR = $72,000. Thus, $125,000 - $72,000 =
$53,000 is the cash freed up by reducing DSO to 36 days. Retiring $53,000
of long-term debt leaves $247,000 in long-term debt. Given a 10% interest
rate, interest expense is now $247,000(0.1) = $24,700. Thus, EBT = EBIT -
Interest = $70,000 - $24,700 = $45,300. Net income is $45,300(1 - 0.3) =
$31,710. Thus, ROE = $31,710/$200,000 = 15.86%.
NI/E = 15%; D/A = 40%; E/A = 60%; A/E = 1/0.6 = 1.6667; NI/S = 5%.
3.5× = Sales/TA
$10,000,000
3.5× =
Assets
Assets = $2,857,142.8571.
The firm is not using its “free” trade credit (that is, accounts payable
(A/P)) to the same extent as other companies. Since it is financing part
of its assets with 10% notes payable, its interest expense is higher than
necessary.
Calculate the increase in payables:
Current (A/P)/Inventories ratio = $100/$500 = 0.20.
Target A/P = 0.60(Inventories) = 0.60($500) = $300.
Increase in A/P = $300 - $100 = $200.
Since the current ratio and total assets remain constant, total
liabilities and equity must be unchanged. The increase in accounts
payable must be matched by an equal decrease in interest-bearing notes
payable. Notes payable decline by $200. Interest expense decreases by
$200 × 0.10 = $20.
Construct comparative Income Statements:
Old New
Sales $2,000 $2,000
Operating costs 1,843 1,843
EBIT $ 157 $ 157
Interest 37 17
EBT $ 120 $ 140
Taxes (40%) 48 56
Net income (NI) $ 72 $ 84
Construct comparative Income Statements from EBIT, and calculate new ROE:
Old New
EBIT $33,000 $33,000
Interest 28,000 20,000
EBT $ 5,000 $13,000
Taxes (40%) 2,000 5,200
Net income $ 3,000 $ 7,800
EBIT
TIE = = ?
I
TA Turnover = S/A = 2
S/$10,000 = 2
S = $20,000.
TD
= 0.6;
TA
TD = 0.6($10,000)
Debt = $6,000.
I = $6,000(0.1) = $600.
NI
PM = = 3%
S
NI
PM = = 0.03
$20,000
NI = $600.
$600
EBT = = $1,000.
(1 - 0.4)
EBIT $1,600
Interest 600
EBT $1,000
Taxes (40%) 400
NI $ 600
Step 2: Calculate the new level of accounts receivable when DSO = 30:
30 = AR/$40,000
$1,200,000 = AR.
So, the change in receivables will be $1,600,000 – $1,200,000 =
$400,000.
NI S A
× × = ROE.
S A EQ
Data for A:
NI $1,000 $500
× × = 0.15
$1,000 $500 0.7($500)
NI
= 0.15 = NI = $52.50.
0.7($500)
NI $52.50
∴ROE = = = 0.0525 = 5.25%.
S $1,000
Data for B:
NI S A
× × = 0.30
S A EQ
$500
0.0525 × 2 × = 0.30
EQ
$500
0.1050 × = 0.30
EQ
$500
= 2.8571
EQ
Equity = $175.
EBIT EBIT
BEP = = = 0.133125; EBIT = $1,065.
TA $8,000
You need to work backwards through the income statement to solve this
problem.
ROE = ROA × EM
14% = 10% × EM
1.4 = EM.
From the equity multiplier (A/E), we can calculate the debt ratio:
1.4 = A/E
E/A = 1/1.4
E/A = 0.7143.
D/A = 1 – E/A
D/A = 1 – 0.7143
D/A = 0.2857 = 28.57%.
Using the Du Pont analysis again, we can calculate the profit margin.
ROE = PM × TATO × EM
14% = PM × 5 × 1.4
14% = PM × 7
2% = PM.
We, know ROE = NI/Common equity = 0.20, with Common equity = $900,000,000
(from the balance sheet).
0.20 = NI/$900,000,000
NI = $180,000,000.
The correct answer is statement e. The current ratio in 2002 was 1.77, while
the current ratio in 2001 was 1.64. Hence, the current ratio was higher in
2002. The debt ratio was 0.4773 in 2002 and 0.5250 in 2001, so the debt
ratio decreased from 2001 to 2002. The firm issued $300 million in new
common stock in 2002.
Step 2: Our second initial condition is that DSO < 50, hence:
AR/(Sales/365) < 50.0
$450,000,000/(Sales/365) < 50.0
[($450,000,000)(365)]/Sales < 50.0
($450,000,000)365 < 50(Sales)
[($450,000,000)(365)]/50 < Sales
Sales > $3,285,000,000.
So, the most likely estimate of the firm’s 2002 sales would fall between
$3,285,000,000 and $5,100,000,000. Only statement b meets this requirement.
Answer: a Diff: E N
Answer: c Diff: M N
Step 3: Determine the amount of freed-up cash and the new level of
accounts payable.
Freed-up cash = $432,000 - $324,000 = $108,000.
New AP = $700,000 - $108,000 = $592,000.
Step 4: Determine the new current ratio:
CR = ($100,000 + $324,000 + $1,000,000)/($592,000 + $800,000)
= $1,424,000/$1,392,000
= 1.023.