Outcome of Surgical Treatment of Intestinal Perforation in Typhoid Fever
Outcome of Surgical Treatment of Intestinal Perforation in Typhoid Fever
Outcome of Surgical Treatment of Intestinal Perforation in Typhoid Fever
BRIEF ARTICLE
Aziz Sümer, Özgür Kemik, Ahmet Cumhur Dülger, Aydemir Olmez, Ismail Hasirci, Erol Kişli, Vedat Bayrak,
Gulay Bulut, Çetin Kotan
Aziz Sümer, Özgür Kemik, Aydemir Olmez, Ismail Hasirci, segmental resection and end ileostomy with mucous
Erol Kişli, Vedat Bayrak, Çetin Kotan, Department of Gen- fistula operation. Postoperative morbidity was seen in
eral Surgery, Medical Faculty, University of Yüzüncü Yıl, Van, 5 cases and mortality was found in one case.
6500, Turkey
Ahmet Cumhur Dülger, Department of Gastroenterology, Medi- CONCLUSION: Intestinal perforation resulting from
cal Faculty, University of Yüzüncü Yıl, Van, 6500, Turkey
Salmonella typhi is an important health problem in East-
Gulay Bulut, Department of Pathology, Medical Faculty, Uni-
versity of Yüzüncü Yıl, Van, 6500, Turkey ern and Southeastern Turkey. In management of this ill-
Author contributions: Sümer A collected and analyzed the data ness, early and appropriate surgical intervention is vital.
and wrote the paper; Kemik Ö, Kişli E, Dülger AC, Bayrak V
and Kotan Ç contributed to the discussion; Kişli E, Bayrak V and © 2010 Baishideng. All rights reserved.
Kotan Ç performed the surgical operations; Bulut G performed
the pathological evaluation; Olmez A and Hasirci I collected the Key words: Intestinal perforation; Typhoid fever; Treat-
data. ment
Correspondence to: Aziz Sümer, MD, Assistant Professor,
Department of General Surgery, Medical Faculty, University of Peer reviewer: Radha K Dhiman, Associate Professor, Depart-
Yüzüncü Yıl, Van, 6500, Turkey. azizsumer2002@yahoo.com ment of Hepatology, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Educa-
Telephone: +90-432-2251024 Fax: +90-432-2164705 tion and Research, Chandigarh 160012, India
Received: May 10, 2010 Revised: June 6, 2010
Accepted: June 13, 2010 Sümer A, Kemik Ö, Dülger AC, Olmez A, Hasirci I, Kişli E,
Published online: September 7, 2010 Bayrak V, Bulut G, Kotan Ç. Outcome of surgical treatment of
intestinal perforation in typhoid fever. World J Gastroenterol
2010; 16(33): 4164-4168 Available from: URL: http://www.
wjgnet.com/1007-9327/full/v16/i33/4164.htm DOI: http://
Abstract dx.doi.org/10.3748/wjg.v16.i33.4164
AIM: To represent our clinical experience in the treat-
ment of intestinal perforation arising from typhoid fever.
perforation occur in the terminal ileum secondary to ne- Table 1 Preferred surgical methods
crosis of Peyer’s patches at 2-3 wk after the onset of the
disease[4,5]. Frequency of perforation varies between 0.8% Preferred surgical methods Patients
and 18%[3,6,7]. Mortality rates of typhoid intestinal perfora- (n = 22)
tion (TIP) cases are reported to be between 5% and 62%. Segmental resection + anastomosis 16
Perioperative mortality rates are noted to rise up to 80% in Jejunum 3
Ileum 12
patients who received surgery due to late perforations[2,6-9].
Cecum (right hemicholectomy) 1
Studies focusing on TIP in large series, are generally Debridement + 2-layered primary repair 3
reported from endemic regions[3]. In a study including 2-layered primary repair + end ileostomy 1
229 cases, Asefa[10] notes TIPs as one of the most im- Segmental resection + anastomosis followed by an end 1
portant causes underlying the acute abdomen. ileostomy
Segmental resection + end ileostomy with mucous fistula 1
While early surgical procedures are regarded as defin-
itive treatments along with preoperative resuscitation and
postoperative intensive care, the methods that should be
used in surgery are still contentious. intestinal perforation cases, whereas the remaining pa-
The aim of the present study is to retrospectively re- tients were operated on with the prediagnoses of peptic
view TIP cases and evaluate the outcomes of this compli- ulcer perforation, perforated appendicitis, and generalized
cation among patients treated in the Department of Gen- peritonitis. In all cases, laparotomy was performed by
eral Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Yuzuncu Yil University midline incision. Six cases demonstrated multiple perfora-
of Van, which has provided healthcare services since 1994 tions, while 16 cases showed perforation on the antimes-
enteric side, appearing similar to a staple hole. One of the
to a wide region of Turkey encompassing many provinces
cases with multiple perforations had 7 perforation foci.
and districts.
The location of the perforations was the jejunum in 3
cases (located at an average distance of 63 cm from the
MATERIALS AND METHODS Treitz ligament), the ileum in 18 cases (located at an aver-
age distance of 50 cm from the ileocaecal valve), and the
The study included 22 cases admitted with an acute abdo-
cecum in one case. Based on the preference of operating
men profile who were diagnosed with TIP and treated in
surgeons and the extent of peritoneal contamination, 15
the Department of General Surgery between 1994 and
cases (68.2%) were subjected to segmental resection and
2010. By retrospectively reviewing the patient records, the
end-to-end anastomosis, while 3 cases (13.6%) received
cases were analyzed in terms of demographic, medical, 2-layered primary repair following debridement, one case
and surgical personal data. The cases were evaluated with (4.55%) with multiple perforations received 2-layered pri-
regard to age, gender, number of perforations, localization mary repair and end ileostomy, one case (4.55%) received
of the perforation, type of operation, and morbidity and segmental resection and end-to-end anastomosis, followed
mortality rates. With the exception of 3 patients who were by an end ileostomy, one case (4.55%) received right hemi-
admitted to the Department of Internal Diseases and cholectomy and end-to-end anastomosis, and one case
Department of Infectious Diseases and diagnosed with (4.55%) received segmental resection and end ileostomy
typhoid fever before being transferred to the Department with mucous fistula operation.
of Surgery upon development of acute abdomen, all cases Pezzer drains were inserted into both subhepatic and
initially presented to the Emergency Department because retrovesical spaces of 4 cases, while placing 2 Pezzer
of abdominal pain. The cases who were considered to be drains in the retrovesical space in one case, and one Pez-
prediagnosed with acute abdomen secondary to medical zer drain in the retrovesical spaces of 17 cases. The pre-
history and physical examination results, were subjected to ferred surgical methods are outlined in Table 1. In all the
erect abdominal plain film, posterior to anterior lung film, 19 patients who had no serological or bacteriological diag-
complete blood count, complete urinalysis, and biochemi- nosis, typhoid fever diagnosis was verified by isolation of
cal analysis including amylase. None of our patients, even Salmonella typhi serologically and/or from stool. The case
those who were reported to have intraabdominal free fluid who presented with a sepsis profile and was subjected to
by ultrasonography, received paracentesis. ileum resection and anastomosis treatment, died postop-
eratively at 10 h. Five cases, including a patient who re-
ceived debridement and primary repair before formation
RESULTS of an ileal fistula that closed spontaneously during the
There were 18 males (81.8%) and 4 females (18.2%), with postoperative period, and 4 patients who exhibited wound
an age range of 8-64 years (mean, 37 years). Common infection, developed morbidity.
symptoms were fever, abdominal pain, and vomiting.
Physical examination revealed generalized peritonitis in all Histopathologic results
cases. Each patient received urinary and nasogastric cath- Macroscopic view: In patients who received resection,
eters prior to the operation. Fluid/electrolyte imbalance there were ulcers in the jejunum, ileum, and cecum, which
was corrected and antibiotherapy was started. Three cases had a perforated appearance, extending parallel to the axis
transferred from the Departments of Internal Diseases of the intestines and displaying a length varying between 0.2
and Infectious Diseases were diagnosed and recorded as and 2 cm. Mesenteric lymphadenomegaly was determined.
TIPs started to be treated surgically towards the end differences in reported mortality rates have revealed the
of the 1800s. As a result of understanding the pathogen- need to investigate the underlying reasons. Young age,
esis of typhoid fever and using more effective antibio- inadequate medical treatment, late presentation, number
therapies, early surgery has become the optimal treatment of perforations and sepsis are mentioned among the fac-
option for perforations[1]. However, the method to be tors influencing mortality[1]. Some authors claim that the
applied in surgical treatment of TIP cases, is still conten- number of perforations might affect prognosis[20,22]. On
tious. From a practical point of view, the perforation site the other hand, Rahman et al[17] and Atamanalp et al[7] de-
should be closed and the peritoneal cavity should be ir- termined no significant correlation between the number
rigated in the surgical treatment. In multiple perforations, of perforations, and prognosis and mortality. We found
segmental resection and anastomosis can be performed no study reporting a relationship between the localiza-
safely[2]. Rahman et al[17], found no correlation between the tion of perforation and prognosis in the literature. In
applied surgical procedure and the reduction in mortal- the present study, among our 22 cases, only one 62-year-
ity. In a majority of the cases, TIP affects the ileum and old patient with sepsis died in the postoperative period.
primary repair is appropriate. Shah et al[18] found the rates The low mortality rate in our study might be secondary
of complications and mortality in resection-anastomosis to factors such as early and appropriate surgical interven-
patients were lower than in other intervention groups. tion, effective perioperative resuscitation, postoperative
Therefore, they advocated resection-anastomosis as the intensive care procedures, safe anesthesia, and delivery of
ideal surgical method for typhoid enteric perforations. wide-spectrum antibiotics with low resistance.
Similarly, Athié et al[19] performed surgery on 352 The most common complication of TIP cases is
cases with typhoid ileal perforation, and found the rates wound infection, while the most serious is formation of
of mortality and morbidity in the resection-anastomosis a fecal fistula. Wound dehiscence, intestinal obstruction,
group were lower than in the primary closure group. intraabdominal abscess, empyema, bleeding diathesis, and
They recommended a 10 cm resection from the upper psychosis may occur[7]. In the present study, one case de-
and lower ends of the perforation and anastomosis (even veloped an ileal fistula which closed spontaneously in the
if there is only one perforation) in cases with a perfo- postoperative period and 4 cases developed wound infec-
rated ileum. However, Beniwal et al[20] suggested primary tion (5 complications in total).
closure as the first choice of treatment. Similarly, Shukla In conclusion, the treatment of TIP consists of ap-
et al[21], reported a reduction in mortality rate from 35% propriate early surgical intervention, effective resuscitation
to 10.8%, secondary to using a single-layer primary clo- in the preoperative period, postoperative care, and use of
sure method. Adesunkanmi et al[22], advocated the 2-layer proper antibiotics. Although primary closure is the most
closure technique as the most successful surgical method frequently recommended procedure, segmentary resection
regardless of the application of an omental patch. In the and end-to-end anastomosis may be reserved for patients
study of Saxe et al[2], which included 112 typhoid enteric with multiple perforations. Segmentary resection and end-
perforation cases, 77% of the cases received primary re- to-end anastomosis has low mortality and morbidity rates.
pair for single perforation, while 19% of the cases were Thus resection-anastomosis should be used as a surgical
subjected to segmental resection because of multiple treatment method for TIP. Ileostomy is associated with
perforations. Atamanalp et al[7] performed surgery on 82 high mortality and morbidity. However, it may be life-
patients with typhoid ileal perforation: primary repair af- saving in patients with severe abdominal contamination.
ter debridement in 32 cases, wedge resection and primary
closure in 9 cases, resection and anastomosis in 9 cases,
COMMENTS
COMMENTS
end ileostomy after resection in 28 cases, and exterioriza-
tion in 4 cases. In multiple perforation cases where short Background
bowel syndrome development is likely, primary repair is Typhoid fever is a febrile disease caused by Salmonella typhi and is an im-
recommended instead of resection[3,23]. Several authors portant problem in tropical regions. Progression of disease is associated most
commonly with hemorrhage and intestinal perforation.
suggest ileostomy in cases with delayed multiple perfora-
tion and diffuse peritoneal contamination[22,24,25]. Research frontiers
Typhoid perforation is an important complication of typhoid fever. It is seen
Recently, laparoscopic treatment methods have also rarely, but shows a high mortality and morbidity. The mainstay of treatment of
been employed in TIP cases. Ramachandran et al[26] re- typhoid intestinal perforation is surgery.
ported 6 successful laparoscopic primary closure cases. Innovations and breakthroughs
Sinha et al[27] treated 25 cases laparoscopically with a port- Recent reports have highlighted the importance of surgical treatment. Patho-
site infection rate of 8%. genesis of typhoid perforation indicates the need for more effective antibiotic
therapies and early surgery.
The mortality rate in TIP cases is reported to vary
between 5% and 60%[7,9,28]. Saxe[2] found a postoperative Applications
Although primary closure is the most frequently recommended procedure, this
mortality rate of 16%. In the studies of Ameh[13] and research opens the way for new surgical options such as segmentary resection
Meier et al[24], the mortality rates were 20% and 39%, re- and end-to-end anastomosis.
spectively. Atamanalp et al[7] determined a mortality rate Peer review
of 11%. Although, mortality rates have shown a decrease After reviewing the literature on surgical aspects, authors should recommend
lately, they are still at important levels. The significant the surgery of choice and should be included in conclusions.