This document summarizes and compares different coastal defense methods:
1. Groynes trap sand to widen beaches but starve other areas, costing £1200 per meter with an appearance of 5/10.
2. Sea walls absorb wave energy to protect cliffs, costing £5000 per meter with an appearance of 6/10.
3. Managed retreat allows natural erosion and flooding of low value areas with high environmental quality of 9/10.
4. Beach replenishment replaces washed away sand but needs regular replenishment, costing £3-10 per meter with an appearance of 9/10.
This document summarizes and compares different coastal defense methods:
1. Groynes trap sand to widen beaches but starve other areas, costing £1200 per meter with an appearance of 5/10.
2. Sea walls absorb wave energy to protect cliffs, costing £5000 per meter with an appearance of 6/10.
3. Managed retreat allows natural erosion and flooding of low value areas with high environmental quality of 9/10.
4. Beach replenishment replaces washed away sand but needs regular replenishment, costing £3-10 per meter with an appearance of 9/10.
This document summarizes and compares different coastal defense methods:
1. Groynes trap sand to widen beaches but starve other areas, costing £1200 per meter with an appearance of 5/10.
2. Sea walls absorb wave energy to protect cliffs, costing £5000 per meter with an appearance of 6/10.
3. Managed retreat allows natural erosion and flooding of low value areas with high environmental quality of 9/10.
4. Beach replenishment replaces washed away sand but needs regular replenishment, costing £3-10 per meter with an appearance of 9/10.
This document summarizes and compares different coastal defense methods:
1. Groynes trap sand to widen beaches but starve other areas, costing £1200 per meter with an appearance of 5/10.
2. Sea walls absorb wave energy to protect cliffs, costing £5000 per meter with an appearance of 6/10.
3. Managed retreat allows natural erosion and flooding of low value areas with high environmental quality of 9/10.
4. Beach replenishment replaces washed away sand but needs regular replenishment, costing £3-10 per meter with an appearance of 9/10.
How do they work? How do they work? How does it work?
These fences are placed at right angles to the Concrete walls built to protect towns. They absorb Large boulders piled on the beach absorb the wave beach to trap sand being moved by longshore drift. the wave energy and protect the cliffs behind. They energy so reducing erosion of the beach or cliff. This creates a wider beach to absorb the waves often have a curved top to reflect the waves back They can be moved if needed. energy. out to sea. Cost per m Cost per m Cost per m £1000 £1200 £5000 (+ any repair work) Environmental Quality 8/10 Environmental Quality 4/10 Environmental Quality 5/10 Rock armour has minimal effect on wildlife; in some They cause erosion down the coast to increase by They create an artificial environment and cases it creates new habitats. trapping all of the sand. encourage tourism which can lead to litter. Usually Appearance 8/10 leads to a strong backwash. Appearance 5/10 They make beaches look messy These are one of the most natural looking defences Appearance 6/10 Very artificial structure, but can Lifetime Lifetime be designed as a promenade. 25 years 100-500 years Lifetime Issues Issues 100 years They starve other They do lose beaches making Issues marks for the them narrower so The walls environmental they offer less can create damage due to protection against a strong transportation. erosion. backwash which erodes under the wall. Managed Retreat Gabions Revetments How does it work? How do they work? How do they work? This doesn’t stop erosion; it allows some coastal Steel mesh cages filled with boulders to absorb These are sloping ramps which absorb the waves areas to erode and flood naturally. Usually these wave energy. They are placed at the bottom of energy but also allow sand and sediment to filter will be areas of low value like nature reserves or cliffs like a sea wall. through small holes to build up the beach behind. farmland. Cost per m Cost per m Cost per m £400 £2000 Varies. There are initial compensation payments to Environmental Quality 6/10 Environmental Quality 5/10 make Eventually, grasses and plants start to grow on top Affects/blocks Environmental Quality 9/10 of them to create new habitats. The wires can be a species that These retain the natural coastal environment. They hazard for large animals, however. require both create wetlands habitats for wildlife. It can also, land and water. Appearance 6/10 however, destroy the environment naturally. Eg: crabs. They don’t look natural for years until vegetation Appearance 10/10 covers them. Appearance This creates a beautiful natural environment. Life Span 4/10 Life span 10 years Artificial Forever structure, but beach access. Issues Issues The cages can be This is often Life Span sharp so tourists unpopular as much Wooden – 25-30 years who walk on of the land flooded Concrete – 40 years them can hurt themselves. is rural and attractive so Issues popular for walking, Like a sea wall, these create a strong backwash bird watching etc. which erodes under the revetment. Beach Replenishment Dune Stabilisation Offshore breakwater How does it work? How do they work? How do they work? Sand is added to the beach to replace sand washed Dunes are a natural defence against wave energy. These are large piles of concrete or cement just off away. The beach then absorbs the wave energy The roots of the coast. They lie parallel to the beach. protecting the cliffs. The sand needs to be plants like Breakwaters force the waves to break before they replaced regularly. couch grass reach the beach so absorb most of the energy. bind the sand. Cost per m Cost per m By planting From £3-10 £300 these and Environmental Quality 8/10 keeping tourists Environmental Quality 6/10 Collecting sand from the sea bed can kill organisms and grazing They can damage the seafloor habitat like sponges and corals. animals away, the dunes can develop. Appearance 7/10 Appearance 9/10 Cost per m They don’t look entirely natural (some beaches Other than when the sand is being collected or £200 have natural rock further out similar to this method) replaced this look natural and creates a wide open but they do preserve a wide beach. Environmental Quality 10/10 beach These defend the natural environment Lifespan Lifespan Varies dependent on storms and building material Appearance 9/10 Up to 5 years These don’t look like a defence method other than Issues Issues fencing and signage Breakwaters only reduce erosion and they don’t This needs protect the cliffs Lifespan constant upkeep directly. Forever (if maintained). Can be destroyed by and as a result is trampling by humans and fires. only really suitable for tourist areas. Issues The fencing and planting can be time consuming and the dunes will never be as strong as a man-made defence