Basic EPR Spectroscopy - Theory
Basic EPR Spectroscopy - Theory
Basic EPR Spectroscopy - Theory
By splitting the electron spin ground state in a strong external magnetic field, we get Zeeman
resonances in the gigahertz (GHz = 109 Hz) range of the electromagnetic spectrum. The observation
of these spectral features is the basis of electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy, which
is also known as electron spin resonance (ESR).
Otto Stern and Werner Gerlach had already demonstrated it in their famous experiment of 1921: a
collimated beam of silver (Ag) atoms, which are in the ground state 2S½ at room temperature (one
5s electron, the other shells are full or empty), passes parallel to the edge of the wedge-shaped pole
shoe of an electromagnet, so that the magnetic field and its gradient are aligned parallel (z-axis).
The atomic beam travels perpendicular to this direction. A homogenous magnetic field only affects
the orientation of microscopic magnetic moments µ. The inhomogeneous magnetic field, however,
applies a force in the z direction
which diverts the atomic beam in this direction. From the above equation, we get maximal
deflection with opposite sign for microscopic magnetic moments in the z and –z-directions.
z
y
Fig. 5.1 Stern-Gerlach Experiment. The cross section of the
x z
magnet, and the beam of silver atoms coming from the gas
reservoir. The beam is collimated by masks and split in the
inhomogeneous magnetic field. The detector was a cooled
glass plate to which the silver atoms stuck. The spots were
seen after chemical development.
Ag Source
According to classical laws, we should observe deflection in the direction of the gradient of the
magnetic field for random orientations of μ (except for perpendicular orientation of the dipole to
the external field). In applying the inhomogeneous magnetic field, the cross section of the atomic
beam was not even approximately continuous. Two spots instead of one were seen along the z
axis. Two conclusions could be drawn from the experiment:
1) the existence of the magnetic moment of the electrons (whose connection to the spin of the
electrons was first made in 1925 by Samuel Abraham Goudsmit and George Eugene Uhlenbeck),
and
2) the proof of two preferred directions of the magnetic moment, which were later shown in quantum
mechanics to be the magnetic quantization of the electron spins in an external field.
The Stern-Gerlach experiment was a major influence in the development of modern physics.
It created a basis for the high frequency spectroscopic methods used in the study of paramagnetic
substances. In 1938, Isodor Isaak Rabi developed molecular beam resonance. EPR and NMR
followed. NMR, is based on nuclear paramagnetism (gross selection rule), and EPR is based on
electron paramagnetism (gross selection rule).
Basics of EPR Spectroscopy
Much of our knowledge of the structure of molecules has been gained from the analysis of
molecular absorption spectra. Such spectral data are obtained by measuring the intensity
(transmission or absorption) versus frequency (or wavelength) of a beam of electromagnetic
radiation as it passes through a sample (matter). Spectral lines or bands in a spectrum represent
transitions between energy levels of the absorbing molecular species. The frequency (or
wavelength) of each line or band measures the energy separation of two levels. Based on enough
spectral data and some rudimentary guidance from the theory (quantum theory), one may
construct an energy-level diagram from a spectrum. Comparison of an energy-level diagram and
an observed spectrum clearly indicates that, of the many transitions that may occur between the
various levels, relatively few specifically ‘allowed’ transitions are observed. Hence the prediction
of transition intensities requires detailed knowledge of selection rules.
The origin of the signal is therefore the electron. In fact, since many students of chemistry
are much more familiar with NMR, one way of describing EPR is as if it were NMR with the
electron as the observant nucleus. To extend this analogy a little further:
Page 3
Basics of EPR Spectroscopy
NMR property EPR equivalent
observe nucleus (e.g. 1H, 77Se) one or more unpaired electrons
magnetic dipole vs. magnetic quadrupole ms = ½ (i.e. resembles spin-½ nuclei)
chemical shift (i.e. field/frequency ratio) g-value (i.e. field/frequency ratio)
homo-nuclear coupling normally not seen - all electrons equivalent
hetero-nuclear coupling (always first-order) hyperfine splitting (always first-order)
References: Shriver, Atkins, Langford, Inorganic Chemistry, 2nd edition (Freeman, 1994) p. 606 - 608 Buttler and
Harrod, Inorganic Chemistry, (Benjamin/Cummings, 1989) p. 221-225.
J.A. Weil, J.R. Bolton and J.E. Wertz, Electron Paramagnetic Resonance, (Wiley, 1994).
1. Electron spin.
Electron spin energy levels become distinct only when the atom is inside the magnetic field.
The size of this energy gap is larger than for nuclear spin, and the spectroscopy takes place
in the microwave frequency range. The size of the energy gap is given by the equation:
E = h0 = gµBB0
Here g is the Landé splitting energy, usually called the "g value." This is 2.002319 for the free
electron (after incorporating the quantum eletrodynamics corrections), and the applied
magnetic field strength is in Gauss or Tesla or mT units. (1 Tesla = 10,000 Gauss.), while µB
is the Bohr magneton, µB = eћ/2me (9.27400949 10 27 JT 1).
B0 is the applied magnetic field (B and H are almost, but not quite interchangeable measures
of magnetic field strength (There is a fundamental difference in the definitions of magnetism
laws using cgs and SI units!).
The size of E corresponds to photon energies in the microwave region of the electromagnetic
spectrum. Thus EPR spectrometers combine microwave sources and detectors with powerful
electromagnets, in a similar manner NMR spectrometers integrate radio frequency technology
with superconducting magnets.
Page 4
Basics of EPR Spectroscopy
mS = +1/2
E
n
e
r E
g
y
ms= 1/2
Magnetic Field
The center of an EPR spectrum is calculated as the corresponding "g-value". This is more akin
to the chemical shift of the signals in an NMR spectrum. In virtually all cases, one species
only gives one EPR signal, hence there is normally only one g-value! The g-value of molecules
and atoms measures how far the magnetic environment of the unpaired electrons differs from
that of a free, gas-phase electron. Reference compounds such as "Fremy's salt" or DPPH are
used as the g-value reference compounds. If we compare the left-hand EPR spectrum (figure
above) with a typical 1H-nmr spectrum, we may see another important aspect of EPR: the
bands are broad w.r.t. the difference in g-value, and although the possible range of g-values is
huge, most free-radicals, in fact, exhibit very little variation in their g-value. For such
compounds, it is the rule rather than the exception to have overlapping spectra if there is
more than one compound present in a solution.
2. Hyperfine splitting
What closely relates EPR to NMR is that the electron spin energy levels are split by the interaction of
nuclear spins of attached nuclei. This results in a multi-line pattern (Multiplets), which for each set of N
equivalent nuclei gives: No. of lines = 2nI + 1 ;
Page 5
Basics of EPR Spectroscopy
where n = the number of equivalent nuclei the electron couples to, and I = nuclear spin.
We first consider a very simple example: a deuterium atom, which of course has a single electron.
The spin of deuterium is I = 1. Looking back at the splitting induced by the magnetic field (figure below),
In a free radical, the unpaired electron occupies a molecular orbital and interacts with spins
from other closely surrounded electrons and nuclei. In the Following example, in an EPR
spectrum where the unpaired electron interacting with two sets of equivalent protons: 2 and
4arising from the molecules Butadiene ion in liquid NH3 is depicted below:
Page 6
Basics of EPR Spectroscopy
Furthermore, the intensity ratio can also be predicted without developing detailed
energy-level diagrams because they follow simple polynomial expansions (Pascal‟s
triangle), as shown in the following table:
Page 7
Basics of EPR Spectroscopy
Page 8
Basics of EPR Spectroscopy
1/2
1/2
B0 +1/2
a
h/g
Page 9
Basics of EPR Spectroscopy
Some basic aspects of EPR spectroscopy methods are pertinent for the understanding of the
underlying principles. These aspects will be discussed in the next session.
Page 10
Basics of EPR Spectroscopy
In EPR, the most important parameter for the description of the spin system is the g factor. Before
we define it, we will first briefly turn to orbital and spin magnetism, in which we will go from a
classical to a quantum mechanical description.
An electron orbiting at radius r with the angular frequency creates a current I = e/2 where the
magnitude of the elementary charge e = 1.602 10 C. In general, the magnetic moment of a
current I, which encloses the surface A, is µ = IA. With A = r2, µ = ½ er2. With the angular
momentum L = me.r2. (electron mass me = 9.109 1031 kg), we get an orbital magnetism which
depends on the angular momentum L:
For spin magnetism, we assume a rotating sphere of mass me and charge e (the axis of rotation
goes through the center of mass). We divide this sphere into infinitesimal volume elements, in
which the ratio of segment charge through segment mass is independent of segment size. We then
perform for each segment the same procedure that we used for an electron in a circular orbit and
add all their contributions to the dipole moment. We get a magnetic moment dependent on the
electron spin S, analogous to the above equation for orbital momentum:
Due to the quantization of the angular momentum, we need the orbital angular momentum
quantum number l and the spin quantum number s for the magnitude.
| | √ ( ) | | √ ( )
The components in the direction of the external magnetic field in the z-direction are
There are 2l+1 magnetic quantum numbers for the orbital magnetism
and only two magnetic quantum numbers for electron spin magnetism
The magnetic moment and angular momentum are proportional to each other, in
both classical and quantum mechanics. An analog of an orbital magnetic dipole is a
classical particle of mass m and charge e, rotating with velocity V (speed v ) in a
Page 11
Basics of EPR Spectroscopy
circle of radius r, taken to lie in the xy plane. Associated with the circulating electric
current i is a magnetic field equivalent to that produced by a point magnetic dipole.
Such a dipole has a moment i and is normal to the plane, where  = r2 is the area
of the circle. The effective electrical current i (charge flow per unit time) is ev/2r.
The magnetic moment points along the direction z perpendicular to the plane of the
circle and is given by
The sign choice depends on the direction of rotation of the particle. Here l z is the
orbital angular momentum of the particle about the axis z. The proportionality
constant, γ = e/2m is called the gyromagnetic ratio (or sometimes the magnetogyric
ratio) and has units C.kg1 = s1.T1. The proportionality constant, γ, converts the
angular momentum l to magnetic moment, μ. More generally, γ = ge/2m, where g is
the Zeeman correction term (g-value). Thus, quantum mechanically, each integral
multiple ħ of orbital angular momentum has an associated orbital magnetic moment
of magnitude β = |e|ħ/2m = γħ/g.
We now return specifically to the free electron. The component μz of electron spin
magnetic moment along the direction of the magnetic field B applied along the direction
z is
where ge is the free-electron g-factor. The negative sign arises because of the negative
charge on the electron and the choices of μe and ge as positive quantities.
A very important quantity for the molecular spectroscopy course is the magnetic-
dipole moment μe, which has units of J T1. Each magnetic species (magnetic dipole
moment) can change its energy, i.e., its orientation in an external field B, by interacting
with external magnetic excitation. The macroscopic collection of N such magnetic dipoles
in a given volume V has the resultant macroscopic moment per unit volume, called
the magnetization, M,
which has units of J.T1.m3 (the same unit as for H). M is thus the net magnetic
moment per unit volume. Since the magnetic moments of nuclei, atoms and
molecules are proportional to the angular momenta of these species, it is convenient
to write each such proportionality factor as a product of a dimensionless g factor and
a dimensioned factor (a conglomeration of physical constants) called the magneton.
Page 12
Basics of EPR Spectroscopy
e =J
where has the same units as vector m; g is the magnitude of the electron Zeeman
factor for the species considered, and J is the general angular-momentum vector.
This is taken to be dimensionless (in units of h— , h/2), as its units (J.s) have been
incorporated into ; the factor a (=1) is defined below. The circumflex (^) is
placed above symbols such as J and μ when it is desirable that these be interpreted
as quantum-mechanical operators. Such operators can simultaneously be vectors.
For free electrons, e = 1, J is the electron spin operator S, so that β becomes
where βe is called the Bohr magneton; e is the electronic charge, h— is the Planck‟s
constant and me is the mass of the electron. The Zeeman splitting constant for the
free-electron Zeeman factor
ge = 2.0023193043617(15)
is one of the most accurately known of the physical constants.
While for the magnetic nucleus, J is the nuclear spin angular momentum operator, I,
and e = +1, and therefore,
We can consider next the magnetic moment m in a magnetic field B, where m may
describe either a nuclear or an electron magnetic dipole. Its component mz along B
(taken along z-direction) is generally defined as
U=μ•B
Page 13
Basics of EPR Spectroscopy
U = |μB|cos(μ B)
where (μ B) represents the angle between μ and B. For a given value of B, there is a
minimum energy |μB|, which occurs when the angle (μ B) is equal to 0, that is, the
magnetic moment is parallel to the direction of B; the maximum energy +|μB| occurs
when (μ B) = ; at intermediate angles, the potential energy U falls between these two
extremes.
Spectroscopic transitions between the two electron spin Zeeman levels may be induced by
an electromagnetic Field B1 (EMR) of the appropriate frequency provided the photon
energy h matches the energy separation, ΔE, between the spins energy-levels. Thus ΔE
= h ge.βe.B0 where B0, the applied magnetic field that satisfies the resonance
condition. The conservation of angular momentum imposes a selection rule of Δms = 1
to such spectroscopic transitions because the photon has one unit (ħ) of angular
momentum. Thus there is a second requirement, other than energy requirement, that
must be met for a magnetic transition to take place.
Let us briefly think in terms of absorption and emission of individual photons by the
unpaired-electron system. The photon has its spin component (+ħ) along or opposed to its
direction of motion. This corresponds to right and left circular polarization of the linearly
polarized light. The photon has no magnetic moment. For absorption, depending on its
direction of approach relative to the axis of the electron spin, it can deliver either energy
h and angular momentum (photon type ) or merely energy (photon type ). To meet
the energy requirement (ΔE), several photons can cooperate, but only photon of type
can be involved, in order to match the condition of total (photon + electron) angular-
momentum conservation.
The transitions between the Zeeman levels require a change in the orientation of the
electron magnetic moment. Hence transitions can occur only if the electromagnetic
radiation can cause such a reorientation. To make transitions possible, the
Page 14
Basics of EPR Spectroscopy
electromagnetic radiation must be polarized such that the oscillating magnetic field has
a component perpendicular to the static magnetic field. The requirement of a suitable
oscillating perpendicular magnetic field (i.e., photons) is easily met at microwave
frequencies. If we apply the electromagnetic radiation polarized such that its oscillating
magnetic field B1 (EMR) is oriented parallel to the static magnetic field B, then the effect
of the radiation would merely cause an oscillation at frequency in the energies of the
Zeeman levels. Generally no reorientation of the electron magnetic moment would occur.
In this case no spectroscopic transitions are possible.
g-factor calculation for Co2+ impurity in MgO (with the magnetic field value of 162.906
mT 1629.06 G) using the resonance condition equation,
Due to hyperfine splitting, hyperfine splittings associated with real absorptions occur in
multiples. EPR is a high resolution technique based on being able to resolve these
peaks. The peaks are broadened by relaxation processes. These are known as T1 and
T2 processes. T1 processes are observable along the axis of the applied static magnetic
field (longitudinal). T2 processes are observable transverse to this field (transverse). T2
broadening is always observed whereas T1 broadening is usually only significant during
saturation (very high radiation intensity).
n exp(-gβHlkT)
Absorption
kN = 1/T1
n 1
No net change in n/ n, but still decreases.
Page 15
Usually whatever causes T1 relaxation also causes T2 relaxation, so
1/T2 > 1/T1, so T2 < T1, so the linewidth is determined by T2: /2 = 1/T2
Classical theory:
Electron spin moment interacts with B0 E
h
1
ms = —
2
Quantum theory:
Separation of the degenerate spin energy
levels are due to the interaction of the
magnetic moments with the applied
Energy