2022 - Chapter01 - Why Value ValueValue

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 13

Business Valuation

Chapter 1
Why value value?

Economics and Business School/Finance & Accounting Specialization


Instructors:
Please do not post raw
PowerPoint files on public

Chapter 1
websites. Thank you!

Why Value Value ?


The shareholder value framework

• Academics and even some business leaders have called for companies
to change their focus from increasing shareholder value to a broader
focus on all stakeholders, including customers, employees, suppliers
and local communities

• Many of theses impulses are naïve. A system focused on creating


shareholder value is not the problem; short-termism is.

• The objective should be reformulated: “Maximizing a company’s


collective value to current and future shareholders, not just today’s”.

• Creating value for investors shows a clear link with creating value and
improving the society at large.

3
The shareholder value framework

• Since investors do not have complete information, it’s easy for


companies to pump up their share price in the short term. This does not
mean that the stock market is not “efficient” in the academic sense that
it incorporates all public information. Markets do a great job with public
information, but markets are not omniscent. Markets cannot price
information they don’t have.

• Despite such challenges, the evidence makes it clear that companies


with a long strategic horizon create more value.

• We’ve found, empirically, that long-term revenue growth –particularly


organic revenue growth- is the most important driver of shareholder
returns for companies with high returns on capital.

4
The shareholder value framework
The shareholder value framework
The shareholder value framework

• It is management’s and the board’s task to demonstrate that courage,


despite the short-term consequences, in the name of value creation for
the collective benefit of all present and future shareholders.

• It is also true that for most companies anywhere in the world, pursuing
the creation of long-term shareholder value requires satisfying other
stakeholders as well. You cannot create long-term value without happy
customers, suppliers, and employees.

• However, the stakeholder approach (defined as running the company in


away that treats all stakeholder interests equally), does not provide an
answer to the question of how to prioritize the demand of each group
and what concrete decision management and boards should take. The
shareholder model, however, does provide an answer.

7
The shareholder value framework

• This focus on long-term shareholder value can affect negatively some


stakeholders, but, on the long run, consumers, employees and the
economy as a whole benefit when unproductive plants and closed and
employees move to new jobs with more competitive companies.

• However, it is true that Shareholder capitalism cannot solve all social


issues: These so-called externalities -for example, carbon emissions-
are often beyond the ken of corporate decision making because there
is no objective basis for making trade-offs among parties. Here
governments should develop incentives to take care of such
externalities.

8
The shareholder value framework

• Forgetting the principles of value creation brought us to the Internet


bubble (when managers and investors lost sight of what drives Return
On Invested Capital) and the financial crisis (when some banks lent on
the assumption that house prices would only increase).

• Too many managers continue to plan and execute strategy –and then
report their performance- against shorter-term measures, particularly
earnings per share (EPS).

• Why? Some executives argue that investors will not let them focus on
the long term (because some short-term-oriented investors will always
clamor for short-term results); other fault the rise of shareholder
activists in particular, although the evidence shows that, on average,
activist investors strengthen the long-term health of the companies they
pursue.
9
The shareholder value framework

• Changes in corporate governance might help. Board members might


be required to spend more time on their board activities. Executives’
remuneration should be linked to long-term

10
Main messages during this course on
corporate valuation
• The combination of growth and return on invested capital (ROIC),
relative to its cost, is what drives value.

• Anything that does not increase cash flows (for example: accounting
changes, modification in the timing of profits, changes in the ownership
of claims to cash flows) does not create value.

• Only if companies have a well-defined competitive advantage can they


sustain strong growth and high returns on invested capital (ROIC).

• Empirical observation shows that creating sustainable value is a long-


term endeavor, that needs to take into account wider social,
environmental, technological, and regulatory trends.

11
Main messages during this course on
corporate valuation
• Competition tends to erode competitive advantages and with them,
returns on invested capital. Therefore, companies must continually
seek and exploit new sources of competitive advantage if they are to
create long-term value.

• To that end, managers must resist short-term pressure to take actions


that create illusory value quickly at the expense of the real thing in the
long term. Creating value for shareholders is not the same as meeting
the analysts’ consensus earnings forecast for the next quarter.

• That means balancing near-term financial performance against what it


takes to develop a healthy company tat can crate value for decades
ahead – a demanding

12
Main messages during this course on
corporate valuation
• Applying the principles of value creation…

– sometimes means going against the crowd

– means accepting that there are no free lunches

– means relying on data, thoughtful analysis, and a deep understanding of the


competitive dynamics of your industry.

13

You might also like

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy