art

in
mediation
Recollections and Reflections
from a Colloquium

artasfoundation

1
«I have come to the personal conclusion
that while all artists are not chess players,
all chess players are artists.»
Marcel Duchamp

5
artasfoundation, the Swiss foundation artasfoundation, die Schweizer Stiftung In June 2015, just after the colloquium «Art in Mediation», I came
for art in conflict regions, is an indepen- für Kunst in Konfliktregionen, ist
across a work by the American artist Brigham Baker, an installation
dent, politically unaffiliated, operating eine unabhängige und unparteiliche,
foundation. Established in 2011, it is operative Stiftung. Finanziert aus
with which he graduated from the Zurich University of the Arts:
financed by private contributions. It Spendengeldern zahlreicher Menschen three closed glass boxes set up in a room, each divided into an
initiates its own art projects, accompa- aus der Zivilgesellschaft, wurde sie upper and lower half, the two halves being connected by a blue,
nies their realisation, and investigates 2011 gegründet. Sie initiiert eigene
partly-worn sheet of paper. Fixed within each of the two halves was
how spaces for art can promote conflict Kunstprojekte und begleitet diese in der
meditation and peace building. Umsetzung und sie untersucht, wie a special loudspeaker, sending most of its sound to the spaces
Freiräume für Kunst zu Konfliktver- inside the glass. From the outside I could hear only a hum. On a
Current information can be found on mittlung und Friedensförderung bei-
card I read: «Hive, 2015. Dyed newspapers, glass, exciters.» So the
the website www.artasfoundation.ch. tragen können.
For further questions, please contact us! hum seemed to be the busy noise of insects. What struck me was
Aktuelle Nachrichten finden Sie auf the blue paper that lay between the spaces at the top and bottom.
der Webseite www.artasfoundation.ch. Why was it there? Why was it so frayed? What had been the pro-
Bitte kontaktieren Sie uns, falls
cess that had marked it with these traces and holes? Maybe it was
Sie weitere Informationen wünschen!
because my mind was still busy with our colloquium, I immediately
interpreted this work as having to do with peace-mediation.

Later I found what the artist had written about his work: «When
beekeepers need to merge two separate beehives into one, a
common technique is to place the two bee boxes on top of each
artasfoundation Swiss Foundation for Art other with only one single sheet of newspaper in between them.
in Regions of Conflict This barrier allows the two beehives to become familiar to each
other’s sound and smell, and over time, the bees will chew their
Schweizer Stiftung für Kunst
in Konfliktregionen way through the newspaper. The result is one single, combined
hive. Without the newspaper, the two hives would likely attack
Lindenbachstr. 21, CH - 8006 Zürich
each other.
Web: www.artasfoundation.ch
Mail: info@artasfoundation.ch For my work, international newspapers were dyed with blue food
Tel.: +41-(0)44-3502437 colouring diluted in ‹Bee Tea›, a mixture of herbs ... They were given
Contact /Ansprechpartnerin:
to various beekeepers in Switzerland  … and were later collected
Dagmar Reichert
again. Along with the holes are traces of nectar, pollen, and wax
Bank account /Bankkonto: on the surface. They are placed in glass boxes, made to scale with
Artas foundation, Raiffeisen Bank,
8001 Zürich, IBAN: CH56 8148
7000 0412 5940 4
7
the bee boxes ... The sounds are recordings from the separate Art in Mediation
beehives that were combined in the project».
Peace-mediation is a professional field in which mediators and
Was the blue paper in the position of a mediator, trying to unite two their team assist in negotiations between conflicting parties in
parties that otherwise would fight? Or if not a person, being so order to transform the conflict and find peaceful solutions. Their
worn, was the blue paper like the trace of a process of negotiation work may consist of facilitating the communication between the
and convergence, a document of coming to an agreement? conflicting parties in order to enhance mutual understanding, but
Or, rather than the mediation between two conflicting parties that it may also include the role of structuring the dialogue process,
we had talked about in our colloquium, was the blue paper our bringing in special know-how, or providing substantive proposals
colloquium itself, the meeting not of opponents, but of two colonies, or suggestions.
artists and peace-mediators, that were foreign to each other, artasfoundation raises the question whether artistic ways of rela-
even though both were of the same species? And the traces on the ting to the world – through art or artists – could contribute to such a
blue paper: were they a kind of recollection and reflection of search for peaceful conflict resolution and support the work of
their meeting? peace-mediators. A meeting between a group of artists and of
And was the humming in the closed boxes like the secret exchanges mediators constituted a step in the exploration of this question.
of a diplomatic process, or like past conversations of a colloquium
on art in mediation …? On the 29th of May 2015, fourteen persons met in the beautiful

A colloquium
premises and warm hospitality of Villa Frontenex-Saladin
in Geneva. Ambassador Alexandre Fasel, Permanent Repre-
sentative of Switzerland to the Office of the United Nations
at Geneva, had invited them for an exchange on possible contri-
butions of art to processes of peace-mediation, and on possible
impulses for art from this field. With Dagmar Reichert from the
Swiss foundation artasfoundation, who had organised the
meeting, he shared the assumption that both these seemingly
very separate fields had much in common and could strengthen
each other through cooperation. The invitation was a trial run,
a first attempt of this kind.
Several people were willing to join the experiment and found the
time to participate: Jean-Daniel Biéler, Cynthia Cohen, Enrico

8 9
 Formica, Antje Herrberg, Michelle LeBaron, Eran Schaerf, Dorothea
Schürch, Marcel Schwald, Matthias Siegfried, and Alain Sigg.
Sébastien Brack and Nicole Fasel-Rossier joined the group in the
evening, Andrea Aeby and Andrea Saemann took the role of
special rapporteurs (See page 20 for institutional backgrounds).

It was important for the organisers to avoid role stereotypes and

the trap of false representation (being seen as a representative
of a collective or category while speaking as a person). Therefore
the colloquium did not start with «the artists» vs. «the mediators»,
but with two freely mixed working groups for telling each other
about one‘s current activities and the difficulties one meets therein.
As the groups began their engaged and stimulating exchanges,
the participants also tried to formulate implicit principles and
guide-lines of their respective practices. When excerpts of these
conversations were reported later to the other group, there was
quick agreement on the fact that «artists and mediators should
really work together«. Then a second round of small-group work
focused on the question of how to practically begin and struc-
ture such a collaboration. Collecting these thoughts and ideas in
a final plenum, the participants of the colloquium formulated
some proposals for concrete artist-mediator collaborations.

Even though many participants had not known each other before,
the atmosphere of the meeting was very amicable and stimula-
ting. Alexandre Fasel captured it when he formulated his thanks to
the participants: «I would like to express my warm thanks for your
valuable contributions to the colloquium. It is my feeling that the
quality and fluidity of contacts between the participants, as
well as the interest you expressed towards one another and

10 11
towards each other’s experience, went beyond the usual sharing. Recollections of the exchange between of artists and mediators
The discussions were nourished by your human qualities and Dagmar Reichert
high-level of expertise. As a person coming from the mediation
side, what particularly struck me was the level of curiosity Explaining practices and challenges of one‘s work to interes-

Meeting in blind spots?

and the quality of listening on behalf of the artists, their sharp ted outsiders – in this case, people active in the field of peace-
insights and the degree of precision with which they described mediation explaining their work to artists – old questions and
what they were doing. It is my impression that, as a result of the new options may emerge within established routines.
discussions, we are beginning to depict what the ground for What, for example, is the role of language in a mediation
collaboration between art and mediation might look like – that process? Is it language itself that is mediating between
it grasped ‹something› that could grow.» conflicting parties? And if so, is language mediating in a
different way than mediators do? Language certainly has its
In order to support such growth and the next steps in a collabo- built-in biases and values. And – as someone in the colloquium
ration of artists and peace-mediators, this booklet recollects remarked – the language that is used in negotiation processes
some of the thoughts and ideas of this initial encounter. It was usually has the conflict built into it (for example, the familiar
produced with significant help from Andrea Aeby and Andrea dilemma of how to challenge discrimination by racial or religious
Saemann, but the responsibility for selecting and ordering all the distinction without using and reinforcing these very categories).
notes and quotations remains with the author. Do mediators have to be less biased than language? But, as one
mediator described one of the difficulties of this work: «In reality
it is often pretty clear from the outset what can count as a result
of the talks, and what the result should be».
So back to language: What is the language of mediation? Com-
municating in English, French or Spanish seems to be common,
whereas the information contained in glances, body movements
and facial expressions, in the rhythm and tone of voice, while
still considered significant, seems to be difficult to capture (These
are communication channels some artists are familiar with.).
Still in the realm of mediation in the language of words and sen-
tences: what happens in the transition between spoken and
written words, the written words of a treaty? Is this transition the
crucial move in a mediator‘s craft? Is it a move of pinning down

12 13
14 15
or one of a series of tangential contacts? Interesting here is, not space in which negotiating parties can say and try things out
how to conceal unresolved issues in vague formulas, but how before they become «real» in the eyes and ears of their constitu-
to find words that capture the agreement in a precise and correct encies or opponents? True enough, it seems, and this framing
way, while leaving a breathing space for the valuable potential is also not foreign to artists, given the edge of the stage or border
of an unforeseeable future. And how to convey in the paragraphs of the image that is required for their art. In the discussion with
of a legal contract the spirit of trust and good will (however them, some mediators questioned their own convention of secre-
minimal) that the parties were able to build up in their meetings? cy: they said that if a public could hear and watch their talks it
Here, someone in the colloquium pointed to the stylistic differences would be more difficult to hide a political agenda, the agenda of a
between a contract‘s preamble and its operational paragraphs; negotiating party or of other parties who might be involved.
a joint effort, perhaps, of poets and lawyers. The experimental space of art and combines both qualities, being
What is the significance of the table in mediated negotiations? distanced from everyday life liabilities through a frame, and
Most of them seem to take place, if not at the beginning, then being public. Could artists lend this space to others?
as soon as possible, around a table. For practical reasons, but
also as a common level of height, a table may function as an Some blind spots in the routines of the guild of peace-media-

Reasons to cooperate
important symbol. No wonder it is often so difficult to «bring them tors may become visible in the conversation with artists and –
to the table», to convince conflicting parties to meet on an this was not elaborated here – one would equally hope that
equal basis, on one level of humanity in spite of all the differences such exchanges could enable people from the art world to see
in power, deeds or intentions. But if the table can be seen as an limiting conventions and alternatives in their own practices.
embodiment of the idea of mediation, would the carpet not be But did the colloquium bring up other reasons for a possible
even more appropriate for this idea – and actually for the praxis? integration of artists in mediation processes?
Even when coming from other cultures, many representatives of «We might be victims of our own success», one of the mediators
opposing parties will be familiar with western lifestyles, and so said; «with increasing professionalization certain methods have
sitting around a table may not be unusual for them. But why fix become established, expectations have been formed, and our
positions, viewpoints and distances when their transformation is ways of proceeding feel often quite narrow». Here, art-based
what it is all about? One of the participants in the colloquium was approaches can create new openings, but, as someone else said,
very familiar with the potential of dance and asked: what does they need not necessarily come from artists. There are mediators
the convention of sitting around a table really allow, and what who just practice learned skills, but there are others who can rely
does it hinder or exclude? on experience to follow their inspiration and who work in a way
Another theme is secrecy: it seems to be a basic element of the that could be called artistic. So if a license to creativity would be
practice of mediators. Does it delineate a special, experimental all that artists could bring in, it would not be so special. What

16 17
 rather could be needed are special art-related competences to
extend the existing methodological repertoire.
One of the colloquium’s participants named situations in which
such a broadening of the repertoire for peace making is asked for:
often a crucial challenge in a mediation process is whether one
manages to «unlock the egos». Bringing people from a mode of
fighting and distrust to an openness in which they can see others
as potential partners, and unlocking fixed views and positions
towards possible transformation. Such turning points often become
possible through occurrences outside of the negotiation room.
The case of adversaries who, at the dinner table and after some
drinking, ended up singing songs they both remembered from
their Communist youth camps, is just one of many anecdotes about
successful confidence building that mediators can recollect.
Leaving a sphere in which the pressure is high, and meeting in
another realm, a realm in which right or wrong is not at issue,
in which one may differ in taste or not … this is the sphere that art
could offer – even within a negotiation room. One mediator gave
the example of inviting the participants around the table to descri-
be a present stalemate by choosing a photograph from a series
that was offered, and to comment on this choice. Here, for examp-
le, the visual artist’s competence in working with pictures, their
way of providing images that counter (media-) stereotypes, but
invite reactions and leave space for a variety of interpretations,
might support such an innovative method.
Moments of art

Some of the challenges for peace-mediation in armed con-

flicts may stem from the difficulty of resolving deep conflicts
using the repertoire of established methodological tools,
which, as one participant of the colloquium explained, would

18 19
involve legal argumentation and a very specific rationality. This one perceives: noticing – while trying to grasp what it is about – all
person pointed to the challenge that there is a lot at stake in such the irritations and contradictions that make it difficult to capture
negotiations and that the pressure is often very high. Mediation what is meant; treating these irritations and contradictions not as
would be a political process that would follow political demands something to be quickly gotten rid of, but as motors for change,
and might be of another nature than activities in which personal and using one‘s authority to welcome them; upholding with one’s
or momentary needs matter instead. In this, the speaker saw a personality a safe space for uncertainty, and trying to «put this
significant difference with the practice of artists, who could freely indefiniteness, correctly and unfalsified, into words». Maybe this
define new rules and change these rules as part of their work way of proceeding through an aesthetic rationality can explain
process. Another participant of the colloquium shared this view, what is meant by «moments of art».
but added: «Even under the conditions of high pressure that we
face when mediating in an armed conflict, and even when certain Even if an opportunity for moments of art may already appear

Cultivating moments of art

rules have to be clearly set and accepted from the outset, there in processes of peace-mediation, and even if such moments
are many rules that have to change and many fixed ideas that have can be created by mediators themselves, artists could support
to be transformed. For such transformations we may need their cultivation. Thus one of the colloquium’s working groups
moments of art». came up with a list of hypotheses as to where and how artists,
The notion of «moments of art» might be a useful one. It describes or their art, might usefully be introduced. Some of these points
situations in which new experiences or impressions can dissolve were later taken up in the discussion of the entire group and
given concepts and re-form them. Even if artists may be more further explained:
used to letting such situations occur, the notion of «moments of Art for atmosphere: The presence of artworks or a live art perfor-
art» might overcome a strict distinction between artists and non- mance could create an atmosphere in a meeting room. Forms of
artists. It could describe moments of another type of rationality, art that are particularly respected in the cultures of the negotiating
which can be found in the work of artists and mediators alike. parties (e.g. poetry, calligraphy) would be especially relevant.
In the colloquium, the author of the present text made a short Artists as muses of mediators: artists could be invited as conversati-
presentation in which she described some characteristics of this on-partners for mediators when they are preparing or reflecting the
other type of rationality, a so-called aesthetic one. process. They would not be present at the actual negotiations, but
The notion of aesthetic rationality comes from the philosophy of might add questions or observations from their own professional
art and describes a special way of relating to the world, to one‘s perspective. They might encourage and consult mediators who want
surroundings. As in the practice of mediators, who want to serve to try new methods and work with wider forms of expression.
their parties by being «good listeners», it is a way of stepping back Artists mirroring the process: artists could be part of the mediation
from intending something specific, and rather focusing on what support team and be present in the conference room. In the team

20 21
meeting at the end of the day, they could mirror the negotiation could be. An actual art intervention would not be necessary, but
process from the perspective of an engaged outsider. An example not excluded either.
for the potential of distancing things through their mirroring was It was particularly the last option that the participants of the
given by a conference participant: a political conversation had colloquium, and especially the artists, saw as a useful and
been recorded and transcribed for a theatre production, and when concrete first step. They expressed a strong interest in learning
it was read by some actors, it was heard in a very different way. more about the practice of mediation, perhaps first as observers
Just art: artists of trust could be invited to present a work or to of a training workshop for mediators, before having to meet
perform at certain moments during negotiations. The timing specific expectations. What was also important to them – be it in
would be important, but mediators would not connect a specific, a mirroring function, as witness or conversation partner – to
a-priori intention with the art intervention. They would treat it come up with a meaningful contribution, the collaboration should
instead as a punctuation that could permit shifts for a new start. be planned as a continuous process, not just as a one-time visit.
Artists as witnesses: with the explicit agreement of the nego- Now the next step is to start planning this concretely.
tiating parties, artists could be invited to witness the talks. They
could be free to just be present and remain silent (possibly having
an effect as a source of projections), or they could later offer,
through art, their impression of the conversation. Such a response Participants in the colloquium: Dorothea Schürch Artist (music,
could be spontaneous and improvised (music, dance), or created Jean-Daniel Biéler Swiss diplomat, performance art), professor at the Bern
ambassador and mediator, Geneva University of the Arts
outside and brought back in later (if so, it must not be made
Cynthia Cohen Program-director Marcel Schwald Theatre director,
public without the mediator‘s consent). «Peacebuilding and the Arts», Brandeis performer, dramatic advisor, Basel,
Artists as a bridge: based on the assumption that artists may have University, USA Switzerland
Alexandre Fasel Ambassador, Matthias Siegfried Mediation advisor,
a different, possibly closer relationship to «the people», they
Permanent Representative of Head of the swisspeace Mediation
could serve as a bridge between them and their official represen- Switzerland to the UNOG, Geneva Program
tatives in the negotiation room. In this, they could strengthen Enrico Formica Senior Political Affairs Alain Sigg Consultant, mediator,
other members of civil society who may take part, and support Officer for Mediation, UNOG, Geneva member of the Swiss Expert Pool for
Antje Herrberg Mediator, CEO of Peace Building
their arguments through presentations in other media or formats mediatEUr, Brussels, Belgium
(storytelling, video ... ). Michelle LeBaron Professor at Allard The rapporteurs:
The artist is present: this is the possibility of a trial run, the invitation School of Law, Vancouver, Canada Andrea Aeby Counselor at the
Dagmar Reichert Executive director Permanent Mission of Switzerland
of an artist into a mediation-support team or a negotiation pro-
of artasfoundation, Switzerland to the UNOG, Geneva
cess with the principal aim of finding out – for both sides, artists Eran Schaerf Artist (visual arts), profes- Andrea Saemann Artist (performance
as well as mediators – what a meaningful contribution of an artist sor at the Zurich University of the Arts art) and artistic director, Basel

22 23
artasfoundation needs your support!
artasfoundation braucht Ihre Unterstützung!
The projects of artasfoundation should be supported by
a broad social base and we invite you to participate!

Die Projekte der Stiftung brauchen ein breites Fundament

interessierter Menschen. Wir laden Sie ein, dazu beizutragen!

Friend Freund_innen
With a yearly contribution of CHF 100 Mit einem jährlichen Unterstützungs-
you will be kept informed of the beitrag von CHF 100 werden Sie laufend
foundation‘s activities and receive an über die Aktivitäten der Stiftung
invitation and free admission to an infor-miert und erhalten eine Einladung
annual cultural event. und kostenlosen Eintritt zu einer
jährlichen Kulturveranstaltung.
Donor
With a yearly contribution of CHF 2‘000 Gönner_innen
or more, you will receive a multiple from Mit einem Unterstützungsbeitrag von
each project and all the publications CHF 2‘000 oder mehr erhalten Sie neben
of the foundation in addition to current laufenden Informationen, Veranstaltung-
information, invitations and free seinladungen und Eintritten auch alle
admission to the foundation‘s events. Publikationen der Stiftung, sowie ein
Multiple von jedem Projekt.
Patron for a project
Support a particular art project and Patenschaft für ein Projekt
accompany us in the realisation on site. Übernehmen Sie eine Patenschaft für
If you wish, we will help you with ein spezifisches Projekt und wir laden
planning your travel to the project Sie ein, seiner Durchführung vor Ort
region. beizuwohnen. Falls Sie dies wünschen,
können wir Ihnen dafür ein Reisepro-
gramm erstellen.

artasfoundation is recognized as a Swiss charitable artasfoundation ist als gemeinnützige Schweizer

trust and is controlled by the Federal Authority Stiftung anerkannt und untersteht der Eidgenössi-
for Foundations. Donations are tax-deductible. schen Stiftungsaufsicht. Spenden sind steuerlich
abzugsberechtigt.
artasfoundation

26