Turning Ideas Into Gold: A Practical Guide For Innovators
Turning Ideas Into Gold: A Practical Guide For Innovators
Turning Ideas Into Gold: A Practical Guide For Innovators
John Seah
Published By
Copyright 2009 by John Seah Yam Sung All Rights Reserved. No part of this book may be used or reproduced, or transmitted in any form, by any means whatsoever (electronic, photocopying, recording, or otherwise) without prior written permission, except for brief quotations in critical articles or reviews. For information, suggestions, queries, sales of books, training and consulting engagements, please contact: Johnseah@everesti.com Everest Innovation Pte Ltd 36 Simon Place, Singapore 545981 Website: www.everesti.com Cover Design: Rank Publishing Illustrator: John Seah Published by: ISBN: 978-981-08-3199-8 Disclaimer:
Much as we have taken steps to ensure the accuracy of the information shared in this book, the publisher and author do not warrant that the information contained in this publication is complete and correct and shall not be liable for any damages incurred as a result of its use. Note that some of the stories quoted have been simplified or modified to suit the learning lessons without boring the readers with technical or corporate details.
v
Everything is possible Until proven impossible And even then It is still possible.
- John Seah
v
Facts are double-edge weapons. The great strength of knowing facts is that, once established, we no longer need to question facts; The greatest weakness is we no longer question facts.
- John Seah
v
PREFACE
The idea of writing this book was mooted by the 2008 Global Economy Recession. Inspired yet humbled by my experience and success of leading the Hewlett Packard team out of the 1997/98 Asian Economic Crisis, I felt ready for what I saw as necessary to consolidate our methodology and framework into a book to share with the greater audience. I am deeply saddened by the deep retrenchment and job losses around me. Retrenchment during recession is a lousy management practice to remedy poor business performance. I hope that, through this book, managers and leaders can find new ways to do old business, new ways to revitalize existing products and new ways to reinvent the entire industry. I write this book for CEOs, directors, and managers who believe that their years of experience have taught them everything. Many think innovation is expensive, without realizing that not innovating is even more expensive. Through this book, I hope they will see the new light and embrace innovation into their businesses. I had the honor of being the chief judge for numerous innovation competitions. While I was delighted and amazed by some of the great innovations presented in these competitions, I shared the pains of those innovators whose projects did not make the grade. Many of these innovations either had fundamental flaws in them (which meant that their projects were doomed to fail from Day 1) or the innovators were poor in articulating the value of their innovations (which meant that they could not convince the judges that their stone was a gem). I write this book to encourage and to guide these innovators along the correct path, and hopefully, to help them avoid the common pitfalls and dangers. Finally, I write this book as a companion guide for my workshop participants. Many of my workshop participants who embarked on the innovation journey ended up gracing the headlines of their local newspapers. Those
v
who made it happen emerged as heroes for their companies cost-saving or revenue-generating projects. Innovation is a journey. The incredible journey had changed their lives. Do you want to change yours? Using the innovation methodology taught in this book, I hope that it can help you solve your toughest problems, innovate your way out of recession and fulfilling your wildest dreams. With innovation, you do not worry about the competition. In your new arena, you face no competitor. With innovation, you do not worry about market share. In your new market, you monopolize the market. With innovation, you do not worry about the future. You create the future. Have fun! John Seah
x
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I am grateful to so many friends, colleagues, and clients who contributed in various ways to make this book possible. This book narrates a journey. Along the journey, I met many friends and strangers who walked the rugged terrain with me. Strangers became good friends as we cheered each other on through good times and shared each others burdens through the difficult times. An innovators journey is never smooth, as conquering a new mountain is never easy. Id like to thank the following friends and business partners who spent precious hours reviewing the various drafts of this book. Their comments, suggestions, and ideas were valuable! They helped to shape and polish both the flow and the contents of this book: Foo Phang Khim, Sharene Leong Siew Sim, Cheryl Lim Hock Thye, Ronald Loh, Kiun Chze, Lawrence Tan Heng Meng Wong Po Ki, Joseph Yap Lee Yee
In this book, I mentioned a team of superheroes in Hewlett Packard who had labored very hard to conquer the Asian Economic Crisis. I deeply appreciate your dedication to innovation and your commitment to our Everest Challenge. You are the heroes behind the legacy. South East Asia Strategic Planning and Quality Team Ooi Tay Peng Ng Peng Teck South East Asia Product Support Team Lim H C, Angelina (Business Development)
Ngiam K K, Eddy (Logistics) Kok Wai Bun (Parts Supply) Yap Siaou Hung (Cost Saving Project) Kelli Yao (Finance) Joyce Lin (Admin) Hazel Lim (Admin)
Singapore Loh Kiun Chze, Lawrence Goh Mia Heng, Teo Ee Tiong, David Chee Indonesia Yap Siaou Hung Malaysia Moh Siew Kee, Goh Lee Chin Thailand Khun Mayuree Chatmethakul, Suwat, Suleeporn, Smith Philippines Jopet Vietnam Tran, Thuan T M Dau Thuy Ha Id also like to acknowledge Goh Kheng Chuan (Rank Publishing) for guiding me through the publication of this book.
x
CONTENTS
Foreword Acknowledgements Preface Sneak Prevew Real Life Story 1: The day the world nearly came to an end Real Life Story 2: The Crazy Million Dollar Idea Real Life Story 3: Voices from beyond Chapter 1: Introducton It was a dark and stormy day Retrenchment by dusk Management versus Leadership Dawn of a New World The Vision The Everest Challenge Chapter 2: The Innovators Journey What is Innovation? Wheel of Innovation Chapter 3: The Innovatve Mndset The power of the Mind The power of a Dream Walt Disney and his dream Michael Dell and his dream The two cycle mechanics and their dreams How to Dream I Wish The monster called Fear Overcoming Fear The Invention of Electronic Vaulting System ix vii
3 6 8
13 15 16 17 18 21
27 28
36 38 39 42 44 45 47 49 51
x
The power of Belief Defining your Everest Why Everest? Chapter 4: Teamng for Innovaton Resources Capabilities Innovation Owner Facilitator Innovation Project Team Sponsor Innovation Administrator Chapter 5: Innovaton Statement Inefficiency (Problem Area) Inspiration (Dreams) Inadequacy (Not enough) Crafting an Innovation Statement An Awesome Innovation Statement Innovation Statement Self Check How high is your Everest? Formulating an Awesome Innovation Statement Reframing the Innovation Statement Chapter 6: Ideas Generaton Climbing Everest the easier way Your Best Ideas Brainstorming Ideas the traditional way Spawning Ideas Principles of Generating Ideas Concurrent thinking Ideas Generation Techniques Silent Brainstorming SCAMPER Case Study: Reverse Logic for Killing Mosquitoes Humans Infecting Mosquitoes - the Reverse Logic
53 54 56
62 64 64 66 66 69 69
73 74 77 78 83 85 86 89 91
97 101 102 103 104 105 106 106 109 140 143
x
Beyond Scamper Brainstorming using Related and Unrelated Words What-If? Technique Fireworks A Spark of Innovation Chapter 7: Ideas Selecton Voting Perspective-Criteria Matrix Sort (PCM) Variation of PCM PCM Alignment Chapter 8: Incubaton Ideas Development and Enhancement PENS Technique A Day in the Life of the Customer Knowing your Data Incubation Period Chapter 9: Investment Decson What to look out for in an Investment Decision? Selling your ideas Understanding the audience Understand the environment Know your timing Content and Structure Differentiating Winners from Losers Chapter 10: Implementaton Implementing Innovation as a project Traditional Project Management versus Innovation Project Management Phases of a project Project Planning Project Execution Critical Success Factors
xv
Prototyping Risk Management Opportunity Management Change Management and Control Project Related Changes People Behavioral Change The Rocket Science of Low-cost Airlines Chapter 11: Iteraton Chapter 12: Concluson Sunshine after the Storm: The HP Story The Battle of Julu Forming the S.W.A.T. Team Cost Saving ideas Free Spare Parts Idea Revenue Generating Ideas The Everest Summit Bibliography Index
xv
SIGN POSTING
To help you navigate your way around, I have planted the following sign posts for you, which are self-explanatory:
xv
SNEAK PREVIEW
SNEAK PREVIEW
SNEAK PREVIEW
Now I see!
SNEAK PREVIEW
SNEAK PREVIEW
REAL LIFE STORY 1: THE DAY THE WORLD NEARLY CAME TO AN END
The world would have ended in 2003. Millions of us would have died. Not because of a nuclear war. Not because of a doomsday asteroid. But because of a near pandemic caused by an invisible killer the Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) virus. The super deadly SARS virus was hyper infectious and it spread across the world at the speed of a Jumbo 747. Within weeks, the virus spread across the globe, infecting 8096 people in 37 countries. Okay, I might have exaggerated about the part regarding the end of the world. As the virus was airborne, it spread through cough, sneezes, touch, and even breath. Carried by wind, SARS spread through the masses across the streets and playground. Carried by air-conditioners, it spread to colleagues in the office, children in schools, travelers in airports, and patients in the hospitals. All around, people were dying. Wherever there was a crowd, there would be a danger of being infected with SARS. Doctors and nurses attending to the infected became infected themselves. As the medical professionals searched frantically for a cure, there was a desperate need to isolate the infected from the uninfected. On 3rd April, 2003, Singapores Ministry of Health approached the Defence Science & Technology Agency of Singapore (DSTA) and Singapore Technologies (ST) for a solution. Within a week, a prototype was up.
World Health Organization. (2006). SARS: How a global epidemic was stopped. WHO Press.
On April th, Singapore rolled out the worlds first SARS Thermal Scanner, more formally known as the Infrared Fever Screening System (IFSS2 ). And the world was saved. You and I can now live happily ever after. Prior to this incident, nobody had heard of SARS before. How could Singapore suddenly invent the SARS Thermal Scanner within eight days? What happened? Read on
SNEAK PREVIEW
To adapt is to make use of an existing system and adapt it to a different industry for a different usage. In this case, the DSTA/ST team adapted the IFSS3 from a military thermal imager. Adaptation involves only minor modification, fine-tuning, and testing. Thats why the innovation heroes took only a week. More about the SARS story inside
DSTA. (2005). Development & Deployment of Infrared Fever Screening Systems by Tan Yang How and Team. https://www. dsta.gov.sg/index.php/DSTA-2005-Chapter-/
SNEAK PREVIEW
SNEAK PREVIEW
WHAT HAPPENED?
Jane and Mei were both serving their time as inmates in the Singapore Prison. They were working in a call center and speaking to the public from behind the prison bars4 5 . What is normal then is that inmates are forbidden to talk to the public (and around the world still). How can we expect the inmates to integrate easily into the society and be a productive workforce in the society when they have been isolated for a long time from society?
Straits Time. (2005, Aug 24). 24-hour call center - behind bars. Straits Time. (2005, July 29). Sweet Female Voice on hotline.
0
Problem Statement : Our inmates could not get jobs because their tattoos would FRIGHTEN OFF their prospective employers and clients. After Reframing, the Innovation Statement became: How can our inmates get jobs where CLIENTS WOULD NOT SEE their tattoos?
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
11
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
12
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
13
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
It was the best of times; it was the worst of times. It was the age of wisdom; it was the age of foolishness. It was the epoch of belief; it was the epoch of incredulity. It was the season of Light; it was the season of Darkness. It was the spring of hope; it was the winter of despair. We had everything before us, we had nothing before us. We were all going direct to Heaven; we were all going direct the other wayin short, the period was so far like the present period, that some of its noisiest authorities insisted on its being received. For good or for evil, in the superlative degree of comparison only. Charles Dickens in A Tale of Two Cities
14
Thailand was the first country to show signs of cracks in its economic infrastructure. The banks lent too much money to finance businesses, which were not viable, and the economy over-stretched itself. The collapse in the Thailand stock exchange triggered a series of shock waves that shook the financial pillars of neighboring countries. Indonesia was next to buckle under the weight of drastic devaluation of the rupiah. Like the proverbial dominoes, the economies of Malaysia, Philippines, Hong Kong, Singapore, and South Korea tumbled and fell one after another to the synchronized rhythm of bursting hot air bubbles. The Thai Baht was devalued, which triggered widespread panic. At its worst, the Thai currency plunged from 25 Baht to 97 Baht to the US Dollar. Likewise, the Indonesian Rupiah plunged from 2300 Rupiah to 17,000 Rupiah to the US Dollar. Millionaires became thousandaires overnight. As devastating as a massive earthquake, all the other Asian countries crashed one after another like a pack of cards. If you had a USD$1,000,000 worth of Thai Baht in Thailand, your assets would have dropped to $258,000 overnight. If you were a millionaire in Indonesia, your assets would be worth only $135,000! As most businesses borrowed money to fuel the over-heating economy, businesses collapsed as no one could repay their loan in US Dollars (or in any foreign currencies). There were massive retrenchments and unemployment, and these triggered riots and social unrest, especially in Indonesia. Thousands were made homeless as they could not repay their property loan, and money deposited in the bank could not be withdrawn, as banks became insolvent. It was the worst recession since World War II. Until 1997, Asia was a region paved with gold and abound with opportunities. Every direction a trader turned, every journey a ship sailed, and every cent an investor placed, all landed up in Asia. Those were the good times where businesses bloomed and the prices of cars and
Jomo, K. et. al. (1997). Southeast Asias Msunderstood Miracle: Industrial Policy and Economic Development in Thailand, Malaysia, and Indonesia. Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Jomo, K. et.al. (1998). Tigers in Trouble: Financial Governance, Liberalisation and Crises in East Asia. London, UK: Zed Books. Karunatilleka, E. (1999, 11 Feb). Asian Economic Crisis. House of Commons. UK: House of Commons Library.
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
15
houses skyrocketed. The bears were hibernating while the bulls ran wild. Things were so rosy that many people took up huge loans to finance the ever-increasing business opportunities and purchase of properties. Asia was experiencing stellar economic growth rates of about 8 to 12% GDP. Capital flowed in from all over the world. News of mega investments graced the headlines on a daily basis. It was clear blue skies as the bubble grew and grew. Some economists called this phenomenon the Asian Economic Miracle. I named it after the movie The Day Before Tomorrow.
RETRENCHMENT BY DUSK
Our story began on a one dark and stormy day that July 1997 week. I was working with Hewlett Packard (HP) as the Director of Product Support Center, South East Asia. In my close circle of friends, we joked that HP stood for Happy People as long as you could meet the revenue and profitability targets. However, if your business unit could not meet the revenue or profitability targets, then HP stood for High Pressure. Within a few days of the economic tsunamis, it became apparent that my department was not going to meet or touch the financial targets for our business. Our financial targets were set during the sunny skies days, and as good managers, we certainly needed an alternate rainy dayin this case, a stormy day plan. My business plans and budgets were drenched in the mud. I needed an alternative plan, a life buoy, or even an umbrella fast! As if my boss had read my thoughts, the phone rang. My Asia Pacific boss was located in sunny Australia while I was located in stormy Singapore. Do you know that South East Asia is in the midst of an economic crisis? he asked. A rhetorical question, I thought. Yes, certainly, I replied.
16
I have been monitoring the situation and have done some analysis. From my calculations, you will not be able to meet your financial targets Oh-no, here comes the bad news! From my calculations, you need to retrench 20% of your head counts to meet your profitability target, my boss said unemotionally. Retrench 20% of my head counts! My mind went blank. I had 350 professionals with me across South East Asia. 20% worked out to be 72. To me, 72 staff was not a mere figure in our business plan. They were my friends, and I loved my staff members dearly And ... I could not bear to break the news to them. My mind raced to find something to say to my boss. Boss, we planned and we executed our plans, I began. Situations changed. We can react John, what are you talking about? This is an economic crisis! Just give me the names.
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
17
as a good leader, when we lead our men into the jungle, we are accountable to lead our men out of the jungle.
How do you intend to lead your men out of the jungle? my boss asked, dumbfounded by my unexpected reaction. One word, boss INNOVATION. There was 20 or 30 seconds of long silence. I thought my boss had died of a heart attack, or at least fallen off his chair. I do not know what you are talking about, John. But based on your track record, I trust you. Trust in your people is one of the great virtues embedded into our brain, our life, and our work by the founders of Hewlett Packard. Collectively, these virtues of HP are known as The HP Way7. Whew! I was lucky that my boss did not ask me to elaborate on what I intended to do about innovation. I knew very little about innovation, apart from its spelling!
Packard, D. (1995). The HP Way: How Bill Hewlett and I Build Our Company. New York: HarperCollins.
18
These were excellent books, but none answered my needs on how to innovate my way out of the recession.
THE VISION
It did not matter that I did not know HOW TO GET THERE, but I was crystal clear WHERE my destination was. I reckoned that I could figure out the HOW along the way. In the army, we were taught that if we got lost, we were to take our bearings of where we were and where our destination was. Using those two points as the general direction, we should point our compass and head towards that direction. The Innovation Journey should start with a Vision. What is a Vision? A Vision is a picture of a better tomorrow. I called my team of country managers together for a meeting to decide on a vision and action plans that would tide us over the difficult times. Because a vision is about a better tomorrow, we agreed not to mention anything about the words Recession or Retrenchment to our staff. We chose to focus our energy on the upside opportunities instead of the negativity of the situation. After an hour of pondering, one of my managers came out with the idea of BEST Service Center in South East Asia. It was a typical statement, no big deal. What about BEST in Asia Pacific? Sounded good. Oh, lets aim for the sky! Let us be the BEST Service Center in the WORLD! Suddenly, the team burst with excitement. The vision was inspirational. It was captivating!
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
19
Could we be the BEST Service Center in the World? What were the benchmarks or award for the BEST Service Center in the World? Truly, there was no such award. How could you set a destination when there was no such place? It was like aiming to land a man on the moon, when there was no such thing as the moon. Again, we were dumbfounded. A fruitless hour went by. Finally, we decided that if there was no such thing as the Best Service Center in the World, we would create one. If there was no such planet called the moon, we should find a planet and call it the moon. If there was no such thing as a light bulb, then we should create something and name it a light bulb. That is what innovation is all about. To be the Best Service Center in the World, we must define and attain a target where no one had been before or attain an undisputed height that would wow the world.
If there is no such planet called the moon, we shall find a planet and call it the moon. If there is no such thing as a light bulb, then we shall create something and name it a light bulb. That is what innovation is all about.
I had five Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for my service center (Revenue, Profitability, Customer Satisfaction, Reseller Satisfaction, and Operational Efficiency). My boss measured me by these five KPIs on a regional basis and I measured my country managers by these same five KPIs in their respective countries. This is called the metrics tree, where nutrients (like information, results, reports, etc) flowed up, and apples (salary, bonuses, incentives, etc) fell down.
20
I was accountable for the performance of six product lines across six countries (Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia, Philippines, and Vietnam). We used a traffic light system to measure our performance. Green light meant we were okay, amber meant we were in danger of failing, and red meant we were dead meat. Most of the time my boss embarrassed me by calling my monthly report card a set of blinking Christmas lights. When and if I got all my Christmas lights to blink green, I called it a miracle. To save our skin, we needed to meet 100% of our revenue and profitability targets. To do so at the expense of customer satisfaction and reseller satisfaction would be unthinkable. To do the bare minimum would not be inspirational, let alone anywhere close to achieving our BEST Service Center Vision. Another hour went by. We decided that a 500% growth in revenue in the midst of a recession would be world class. It sounded inspirational. In fact, it would be legendary if we could achieve a 500% growth in revenue. Surely nobody in the world could do that. Nobody would be so dumb as to choose such a target anyway. But we were not dumb; we were desperate to save 72 families. In reality, a 500% growth in revenue in depreciated Thai baht, Indonesian rupiah, Philippine pesos, Malaysian ringgit, and Singapore dollars would translate to a modest 150% revenue and 30% profit in US dollars. Excitedly, every single one of my regional managers and country managers signed off on our vision statement and our five KPIs.
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
21
I set up an incentive scheme to encourage innovation and trained everyone on it. We formed teams both at the regional level and at the country level. Everybodys KPIs were aligned to the Best Service Centers vision. We nicknamed the innovation journey The Everest Challenge. Everest, the highest mountain on Earth, was chosen as it is a place where dreams are chased above the clouds. It is a place where only a few daring people can beat all odds to stand on her summit. If our teams could beat all odds to achieve our 500% profitability growth target, then we would have conquered the Everest in our hearts and in our dreams.
22
i. How could we innovate to bring ourselves out of the recession? ii. How could we prosper and grow despite the worst recession in living memory? iii. In what ways could we apply innovation to grow our business and to save millions of dollars across the organization? iv. Could we really become the BEST Service Center in the World? Continue on Chapter 12. The worlds economy had been through an ever-twisting never-ending rollercoaster ride. We met the 1998 Asian Economic Crisis, followed immediately by the 2001 dot-com burst. Before the year was up, terrorists crashed jumbo jets into the World Trade Center. Just as we surfaced for a gasp of oxygen, we caught the Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) in 2003. The world was ripped apart again and again by Katrina, the Christmas eve tsunami, the Szechuan earthquake, the US home subprime crisis, Mumbai bombing, and recently the collapse of big giants like the Lehman Brothers, triggering the 2008 global financial crisis. In the darkness of the night, there was a ray of hope. The world groped aimlessly in darkness because they chose to see darkness. One could choose to follow the world in despair, or one could choose to cling to the straw of hope. If you chose to survive the gloom and doom, you chose to persevere and to let the human mind and spirits carry you through. How could anyone see sunshine in the midst of an economic storm? How could we stand tall while the sky tumbles and falls? This is what this book is about. Real life stories with real life applications of innovation. Innovation is a fascinating journey, filled with its little potholes and life-threatening crevasses. Embarking on an innovation journey is like exploring dark caves of unknown, filled with exciting artifacts and treasures. Through this book, I would like to help you and your team navigate
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
23
the trodden path instead of treading on virgin snow. At least, this book shares with you whats ahead in your journey so that you can be better prepared not only for the joys of conquest, but also for the heartbreaks and despair. To find out how to bring the magic of innovation to life, read on and enjoy the journey.
24
SUMMARY
1. Innovation is about both management and leadership. a. Leadership sets the directions. It takes courage to lead your team into the jungle. It takes commitment to lead them out. (Do the right thing). b. Management drives efficiency (Do it right). 2. Trust in your people (The HP Way). 3. A vision is a picture of a better tomorrow. 4. The vision itself does not move mountains. It needs to be translated into action. 5. To be great, we need to set inspirational targets. The results of our achievements shall be legendary. . Innovation is like a journey. We know the general direction, but not the specific path. Point your compass straight and figure out the details along the way. There will be some points when we get lost, some backtracking, and some pitfalls. Strive on and we shall emerge as heroes.