Compendum of Fracture Toughness Part 2
Compendum of Fracture Toughness Part 2
Compendum of Fracture Toughness Part 2
Table I lists the journals reviewed and the periods covered during
this review. Table II lists the abbreviations used for the various
references. Table III lists the materials for which data were located
and the corresponding references.
The authors stated in [la] that all data sources for materials
such as Ti-6AI-4V titanium alloy and 7075-T6 aluminum alloy were not
listed because the sources shown were judged to typify the full range
of data. Further review of the literature indicates this judgement
m~y have been slightly optimistic. Consequently additional references
for these materials are cited herein.
[Axx-xxxxx] AIAA
Technical Information Service
750 Third Avenue
New York, NY 10017 USA
[Nxx-xxxxx] NASA
Scientific and Technical Information
or Facility
P.O. Box 8757
[Xxx-xxxxx] B.W.I. Airport, MD 21240 USA
5Ni-Cr-Mo-V 58,214,291,557
9Ni 434,529
10Ni 82,149,153,214,226,227,230,241,$71,558
10Ni weld 149
10Ni-Cr-Mo-Co 210,482,526
12Ni 58,153,226,394
12Ni-5Cr-3Mo 291,396,482
13Cr 529 18Ni(200) 394,396
18Ni(250) 223,371 18Ni(300) 278,355
18Ni 226,227 49Ni 463
Fe-.035C-3.4Ni-I.8Cr-0.6Mo-0.5Mn-0olV 471
Fe-0.23C 555 Fe-0.45C 555
Fe-0.64C 555 18G2VA 559
300M 53,61,200,203,253,474,476,477,480
835M30 560
Cl. Stainless Steel; Fracture Toughness
AISI 301 6,7,28,35,46,456,561-563
AISI 301 HAZ 35,563
AISI 301 weld 28,35,46,563
AISI 304 7,118,564,565
AISI 304 HAZ 563 AISI 308 weld 563,564
AISI 310 6,7,38,118,566,567
AISI 310 weld 567
AISI 316 38,118,565,568-570
AISI 316 weld 568,570 AISI 347 365,571,572
AISI 403 mod 12Cr 67,129,286 AISI 431 37
AISI 3105 129
PH 13-8Mo 3,37,43,61,130,255,399
PH 13-8Mo weld 61 PH 14-8Mo 1,123,375
PH 15-5Mo 37,55,573 PH 15-7Mo 37,48,336,388
PH 17-4Mo 1,67,336,401,574,575
PH 17-7Mo 37,336,388,576,577
A-286 31,38,129,365,563,566,567,571,572,578
A-286 weld 567
AFC 77 1,55,338,423,579,580
AFC 260 1 AM 350 64,388,563
AM 355 37,62,64,130,336
Custom 450 1 Custom 455 1,123,581
Kromarc 58 129,566,567 Kromarc 58 weld 567
Pyromet 538 567 Pyromet 538 weld 567
Fe-13Cr-19Mn 582 Fe-13Cr-19Mn HAZ 582
Fe-18Cr-2Mo 583
Fe-21Cr-6Ni-9Mn 38,73,384,584-586
Fe-21Cr-6Ni-gMn weld 129
Fe-22Cr-13Ni-5Mn 31,365,587
C2. Stainless Steel; Fatigue Crack Growth
AISI 301 28,31,46,201,588
AISI 301 weld 28,46
AISI 304 31,118,128,153,192,193,211,230,240,485,529,530,564,
588-601
AISI 308 weld 128,564,589,591,599,602
AISI 310 31,118~485,566~567,594
AISI 310 weld 567
AISI 316 31.!18,i28,153,192.210,$85,569,588-594~598-601,603-608
AISI 3i6 weld 56~,588,589,591
AISI 321 575~590 AISI 347 365
AISI 348 575,590 AISI 403 609
PHI3-8Mo 61,128,226,257,526
PHI3-8Mo HAZ 61 PHI3-8Mo 6]
PHI5-5Mo 610
PHi7-4Mo 247,268,575,610
~286 31,365,566,567,611,611A
A.286 weld 567
AFNOR Z0 CD 26-1 612
AFNOR Z~ CNDU 21-7 612
AFNOR Z5 CNDT 17-12 612
AFNOR Z6 CND 17-12 612
ASTM A453 485,594 Custom 450 1
Kromarc 58 31,566,567 Kromarc 58 weld 567
Pyromet 538 567 Pyromet 538 weld 567
Trip 613 Uranus 50 5!2
VK-A271 612,614 12Cr-Mo-V-W 615
Fe-13Cr 6!6 Fe-13.Cr-19Mn 58~
[195] R. J. Bucci, Flaw Growth and Fracture, STP 631, American Society
for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia (1977) 388-401 [A78-26654].
[196] K. Walker, Effects of Environment and Complex Load History on
Fatigue Life, STP 462, American Society for Testing and Materials,
Philadelphia (1970) 1-14 [A70-26089].
[197] D. Brock, 2nd International Conference on Fracture, Brighton,
England (1969) 754-764 [A69-23065].
[198] W. G. Fleck and R. B. Anderson, 2nd International Conference on
Fracture, Brighton, England (1969) 790-802 [A69-23072].
[199] N. E. Ashbaugh and A. F. Grandt, AFML-TR-77-233 (1978) [N79-
12477].
[200] P. E. Ruff and W. S. Hyler, AFML-TR-74-67 (1974) [N75-I0506].
[201] E. K. Walker, AFFDL-TR-70-144 (1970) 225-233 [N71-25092].
[202] W. G. Fleck and R. B. Anderson, AFFDL-TR-70-144 (1970) 417-424
[N71-25092].
[203] C. E. Jaske, C. E. Feddersen, K. B. Davies, and R. C. Rice, NASA
CR-132332 (1973) [N74-I1714].
[204] R. G. Dubensky, NASA CR-1732 (1971) [N71-18002].
[205] T. L. MacKay, EFM ii (1979) 753-761 [A79-28885].
[206] J. A. Vazquez, A. Morrone, and H. Ernst, EFM 12 (1979) 231-240
[A80-12161].
[207] F. Erdogan, NASA CR-901 (1967) [N67-39068].
[208] D. A. Virkler, B. M. Hillberry and P. K. Goel, JEMT i01 (1979)
148-153 [A79-39789].
[209] H. Okamura and S. Sakai, FEMS 1 (1979) 409-419 [A79-52412].
[210] A. J. McEvily, MS ii (1977) 274-284 [A77-47502].
[211] M. Kikukawa, M. Jono, and K. Tanaka, Special Volume, 2nd Inter-
national Conference on Mechanical Behavior of Materials (1976)
254-277.
[212] G. R. Chanani, Corrosion-Fatigue Technology, STP 642, American
Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia (1978) 51-73
[A78-38185].
[213] W. G. Truckner, J. T. Staley, R. J. Bucci, and A. B. Thakker,
AFML-TR-76-169 (1976) [N77-26300].
[214] A. M. Sullivan and T. W. Crooker, NRL Report 7912 (1975) [N76-
17242].
[215] H. W. Liu and A. S. Kuo, Fracture Mechanics and Technology,
Sijthoff and Noordhoff International Publishers (1977) 893-906
[A78-42584].
[216] H. W. Liu and N. lino, 2nd International Conference on Fracture,
Brighton, England (1969) 812-823 [A69-23082].
[217] D. N. Lal and V. Weiss, 2nd International Conference on Mechanical
Behavior of Materials (1976) 617-621.
213-234 [A79-24283].
[264] B. R. Kirby and C. J. Beevers, FEMS i (1979) 203-215 [A79-47774].
[265] D. R. Holloway, Air Force Institute of Technology Report AFIT/
GAE/MC/775-1 (1977) [N78-32233].
[266] R. R. Cervay, AFML-TR-72-173 (1972) [N73-18560].
[267] D. E. Pettit and J. M. Van Orden, Fracture Mechanics, STP 677,
American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia (1979)
106-124 [A80-23861].
[268] F. D. Bogar and T. W. Crooker, NRL Report 8265 (1978) [N79-16951].
[269] W. D. Dover and J. Boutle, Journal of Strain Analysis 13 (1978)
129-139 [A79-52410].
[270] D. Rhodes and J. C. Radon, FEMS 1 (1979) 383-393.
[271] J. C. Radon, MS 13 (1979) 411-419.
[272] H. Abdel-Raouf, T. H. Topper, and A. Plumtree, MT 10A (1979)
449-456.
[273] S. J. Maddox and D. Webber, Fatigue Testing of Weldments, STP
648, American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia
(1978) 159-184.
[274] J. F. Knott and A. C. Pickard, MS ii (1977) 399-404 [A77-47513].
[275] B. M. Kapadia and E. J. Imhof, Jr., Flaw Growth and Fracture,
STP 631, American Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia
(1977) 159-173.
[276] J. L. Shannon and W. Rzasnicki, NASA TM-73847 (1977) [N78-13182].
[277] H. Conrad, M. K. Keshavan, and G. A. Sargent, Special Volume, 2nd
International Conference on Mechanical Behavior of Materials
(1976) 538-568.
[278] R. L. Tobler, R. P. Reed, and R. E. Schramm, JEMT i00 (1978) 189-
194 [A78-35387].
[279] G. R. Irwin, J. M. Kraft, P. C. Paris, and A. A. Wells, NRL
Report 6598 (1967) [N68-17840].
[280] F. J. Loss, NRL Memo Report 3289 (1976) [N77-12461].
[281] F. J. Loss, J. R. Hawthorne, and C. A. Griffis, NRL Memo Report
3036 (1975) [N76-20556].
[282] A. M. Sullivan, ist International Conference on Fracture, Sendai,
Japan 3 (1966) 1949-1969.
[283] J. D. Landes and J. A. Begley, Developments in Fracture Mechanics
Test Methods Standardization, STP 632, American Society for Test-
ing and Materials, Philadelphia (1977) 57-81 [A77-51580].
[284] J. D. Landes and J. A. Begley, Fracture Analysis, STP 560, Ameri-
can Society for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia (1974) 170-
186.
[285] E. T. Wessel, W. G. Clark, Jr., and W. H. Pryle, 2nd Internation-
al Conference on Fracture, Brighton, England (1969)825-850.
[349] W. E. Wood, Oregon Graduate Center Final Report, Naval Air Sys-
ems Command Contract N00019-76-C-0149 (1977) [N77-31289].
[350] P. E. Irving, M. P. Seah, and A. Kurzfeld, 2nd International CQn-
ference on Mechanical Behavior of Materials (1976) 563-567.
[351] Deleted.
[352] M. H. Jones and W. F. Brown, Jr., NASA TM X-1860 (1969) [N69-
34916].
[353] A. A. Anctil and E. B. Kula, AMM C TR 69-15 (1969) [N69-39318].
[354] B. Mravic and J. H. Smith, AFML-TR-71-213 (1971) [N80-70447].
[355] C. S. Carter, AFML-TR-70-139 (1970) [X70-17953].
[356] M. Azrin, M. L. Ebner, D. R. Poirier, W. A. Backofen, and M. C.
Flemings, AFML-TR-64-376 (1965) [N65-20923].
[357] Deleted.
[358] Go T. Hahn~ R. G. Hoagland, M. F. Kanninen, A. R. Rosenfield,
and R. Sejnoha, Battelle Columbus Laboratories Report No. SSC-
242 (1973) [N74-26045].
[359] J. Lereim and J. D. Embury, EFM ii (1979) 161-164.
[360] T. B. Cox and J. R. Low, Jr., NASA CR-131102 (1972) [N73-19523].
[361] J. H. Underwood, EM 18 (1978) 350-355.
[362] R. O. Ritchie and R. M. Horn, MI 9A (1978) 331-341 [A78-30113],
[363] M. ~ Bhat, Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory Report LBL-6046 (1977)
[N78-I0276].
[364] Y. E. Smith and D. E. Diesburg, MP 115 (May 1979) 68-73.
[365] W. D. Bixler, NASA CR-157366 (1972) [N78-79364].
[366] K. Nakazawa and G. Krauss, MT 9A (1978) 681-689.
[367] R. J. Kar, R. M. Horn, and V. F. Zackay, MT 10A (1979) 1711-1717.
[368] Deleted.
[369] Deleted.
[370] F. H. Froes, J. C. Chesnutt, R. G. Berryman, G. R. Keller, and
W. T. Highberger, 10th National SAMPE Technical Conference, i0
(1978) 522-533 [A79-24118].
[371] S. R. Novak, A. W. Loginow, H. M. Reichhold~ J. G. Bassett, and
G. C. McKelvey, AFML-TR-78-89 (1978) [N79-14200].
[372] C. D. Little and P. M. Machmeier, AFML-TR-75-148 (1975) [N76-
26336]~
[373] P. M. Machmeier, J. C. Collins, and R. L. Jones, AFML-TR-77-61
(1977) [N77-32294].
[374] W. E. Routh, AFFDL-TR-77-73 (1977) [N78-15239].
[375] J. P. Hickerson, Jr., Sandia Laboratories Report SLA 73-0498
(1974) [N75-I1376].
[376] M. G. Dawes, Elastic-Plastic Fracture, STP 668, American Society
Int Journ of Fracture 20 (1982)
RIQO
for Testing and Materials, Philadelphia (1979) 307-333 [A79-
51164].
[377] N. E. Ryan, Aircraft Structural Fatigue, Australian Research
Laboratory (ARL)/Struc-Report-363, ARL/Mat-Report-104, Melbourne
(1977) 393-418 [N78-30287].
[378] V. F. Zackay, W. W. Gerberich, R. Busch, and E. R. Parker, ist
International Conference on Fracture, Sendai, Japan, 2 (1966)
813-834.
[379] P. N. Randall, AFML-TR-66-204 (1966) [X67-II037].
[380] M. F. Amateau and E. G. Kendall, Space and Missile Systems Organi-
zation Report SAMSO-71-186 (1971) [N72-14570].
[381] C. E. Feddersen, AFML-TR-72-20 (1972) [N73-II033].
[382] P. A. Parrish, AFML-TR-74-149 (1975) [N77-72885].
[383] R. T. Ault, K. D. McDowell, and P. L. Hendricks, AFML-TR-66-276
(1966) [X68-80652].
[384] G. K. Bhat, NASA CR-135044 (1976) [N77-16150].
[385] J. C. Radon and A. A. Pollock, Fracture Toughness and Slow-Stable
Cracking, STP 559, American Society for Testing and Materials,
Philadelphia (1974) 15-30.
[386] D. A. Curry and J. F. Knott, MS 13 (1979) 341-345.
[387] R. J. Weimer and H. C. Rogers, 2nd International Conference on
Mechanical Behavior of Materials (1976) 1473.-1477.
[388] S. O. Davis, D. C. Lagrone, R. M. Niemi, and N. G. Tupper, AFML-
TR-65-214 (1965) [X66-23714].
[389] J. H. Mulherin, W. B. Steward, and J. D. Corrie, Frankford Arsenal
Report FA-TR-76015 (1976) [AD-A027025].
[390] D. Kalish and S. A. Kulin, AFML-TR-68-69 (1968) [X68-17822].
[391] F. R. Stonesifer and H. L. Smith, NRL Memo Report 1933 (1968)
[N69-24749].
[392] J. A. Van Den Aryle, Sandia Laboratories Report SAND-78-0462
(1978) [N79-II197].
[393] F. R. Stonesifer and H. L. Smith, NRL Memo Report 2466 (1972)
[N72-28506].
[394] T. W. Crooker and E. A. Lange, NRL Report 6761 (1968) [N69-16260].
[395] T. W. Crooker and E. A. Lange, NRL Report 6805 (1968) [N69-20403].
[396] T. W. Crooker and E. A. Lange, Effects of Environment and Com-
plex Load History on Fatigue Life, STP 462, American Society for
Testing and Materials, Philadelphia (1970) 258-271 [A70-26100].
[397] T. W. Crooker, L. A. Cooley, E. A. Lange, and C. N. Freed, NRL
Report 6698 (1968) [N69-77689].
[398] R. E. Jones, AFML-TR-71-250 (1971) [N74-72911].
[399] R. T. Bubsey and W. F. Brown, Jr., NASA TN D-4998 (1969) [N69-
17275].
Int Journ of Fracture 20 (1982)
RI01
(1971) [N71-29812].
[515] W. T. Matthews, F. I. Baratta, and G. W. Driscoll, AMMRC TR 71-38
(1971) [N72-30492].
[516] P. E. Irving and A. Kurzfeld, MS 12 (1978) 495-502.
[517] R. P. Jewett, R. J. Walter, and W. T. Chandler, Corrosion-Fatigue
Technology, STP 642, American Society for Testing and Materials,
Philadelphia (1978) 243-263 [A78-38191].
[518] J. C. Radon, C. M. Branco, and L. E. Culver, IJF 13 (1977) 595-
610.
[519] I. M. Austen and P. Mclntyre, MS 13 (1979) 420-428 [A79-43874].
[520] J. T. Barnby and R. Holder, MS ii (1977) 5-10.
[521] J. K. Musuva and J. C. Radon, FEMS i (1979) 457-470 [A79-52417].
[522] B. Mukherjee, JEMT i01 (1979) 47-52.
[523] M. H. E1 Haddad, T. H. Topper, and K. N. Smith, EFM ii (1979)
573-584 [A79-23899].
[524] P. E. Irving and L. N. McCartney, MS ii (1977) 351-361 [A77-47508].
[525] T. W. Crooker, NRL Report 7220 (1971) [N79-74847].
[526] T. W. Crooker and E. A. Lange, NRL Report 6870 (1969) [N69-33111].
[527] R. O. Ritchie, V. A. 6~ang, and N. E. Paton, FEMS I (1979) 107-121
[A79-33206].
[528] H. Kitagawa and S. Takahashi, 2nd International Conference on
Mechanical Behavior of Materials (1976) 627-631.
[529] K. Nishioka, K. Hirakawa, and I. Kitaura, International Committee
on Aeronautical Fatigue, Document Number 993. Reprinted from The
Sumitomo Search~ 17 (1977) 39-55 [N79-70116].
3 September 1981