Teachernotes U04
Teachernotes U04
4
Success
at a glance
AT A GLANCE
For a fast route through the unit focusing mainly on speaking skills, just use the underlined sections.
For one-to-one situations, most parts of the unit lend themselves, with minimal adaptation, to use with individual
students. Where this is not the case, alternative procedures are given.
36
business brief
People are fascinated by success. Business commentators try to understand the success factors that
make for successful individuals, products and companies, and for economically successful countries.
People
Different types of organisation require different types of leaders. Think of start-ups with their
dynamic entrepreneurs, mature companies with their solid but hopefully inspirational CEOs,
BUSINESS BRIEF
companies in difficulty with their turnaround specialists. Each also requires managers and
employees with different personality make-ups. Think of the combination of personality types
needed in banks compared to those in advertising agencies.
Products
Successful products are notoriously hard to predict. There are subtle combinations of social,
cultural and technological circumstances that mean that something will succeed at one time but
not another. People talk rightly about a product ‘whose time has come’. The technology to meet
a particular need may exist for a long time before the product on which it is based takes off. For
example, photocopying technology was around for years before photocopiers were commercialised
on a large scale. In the beginning, cost may be a factor, but after a time a critical mass of users
develops, costs come down, and no one ‘can understand how they could have done without one’.
Companies
Success factors here include energy, vision and efficiency, but many of the companies that were
thought to possess these attributes 30 or even five years ago are not those we would think of
as having these qualities today. Management fashions are a big factor: gurus and management
books have a lot to answer for. Once something becomes a mantra, everyone starts doing it, but
objective measures of the relative efficiency of each type of company are hard to find. Different
types of activities require different approaches to deliver strong financial results, the one
measure of success that people usually agree on.
Countries
Economic success stories such as Japan, Germany and Sweden became models that everyone
wanted to imitate. In the 1970s, government experts and academics went to these places by the
planeload looking for the magic ingredients. In the 1980s and early 90s they went to the emerging
economies of the so-called ‘Asian tigers’. Now China is seen as the country to watch. At various
times, commitment to self-improvement, entrepreneurial flair, efficient access to capital, vibrant
institutions, a good education system and good infrastructure are held to be important factors
for success, but the countries mentioned above possess these to very varying degrees.
In any case, how can companies and countries imitate others? Companies have a particular
culture that is the result of their history, short or long. If managers and their consultants change
them radically, for example by downsizing them, they may be ripping out the very things that
make them tick. On the other hand, change may really be necessary, and companies with cultures
and structures that were successful under earlier conditions are very hard to change in a genuine
way, even if they go through the motions of adopting the latest management fashion.
With countries, how do you imitate social structures and habits that have evolved over centuries
elsewhere, often with an entirely different starting point? The old joke about not wanting to start
from here if you’re going there is applicable. Also, by the time the model has been identified as
one worth imitating, the world economy has moved on, and your chosen model may no longer be
the one to follow.
Ability to adapt is key. Here, the US is world leader in adapting old organisations to new conditions
– McDonald’s and IBM, for example, have had amazing turnrounds from earlier difficulties. But
radical innovation is equally important. The US is also good at generating entirely new companies
that become world leaders. Though not as dominant as it once was, the US economy seems to be
particularly good at producing these companies – witness Microsoft, Intel and Google. China, for all
its new-found economic power, has yet to produce a company in this league.
Read on
James C. Collins, Jerry I. Porras: Built to Last: Successful Habits of Visionary Companies, Random
House, 2005
Michael Hoyle, Peter Newman: Simply a Great Manager: The 15 fundamentals of being a
successful manager, Marshall Cavendish, 2008
37
lesson notes
Warmer C
• Ask the students to name the most successful
business person/people in their own country/ • Get the students to work on the success indicators
in pairs. Ask them also to name the particular cars,
countries. (In a multi-nationality group, this is a
jewellery, holiday destinations, leisure activities,
good chance for students to learn about each other’s
etc. that successful people choose at the moment.
business heroes.)
LESSON NOTES
A Vocabulary: Prefixes
Students look at some common prefixes.
• Get the students to discuss the words in pairs. Tell
them that they can add vocabulary that came up
A – B
during the warmer session to their lists if they want to.
Circulate, monitor and assist, for example, by explaining • Ask the students to find prefixes in the article.
charisma, nepotism and ruthlessness, helping with
pronunciation and suggesting words where necessary
• Get the students to complete Exercise A in pairs.
Circulate, monitor and assist.
to describe particular character traits.
• Check the answers with the whole class.
• Ask individual pairs to give their five most
important characteristics and ask them why • Ask the students what other words they know that
they have chosen them. use these prefixes or get them to use dictionaries
to find some (e.g. reapply, overreaction, outdo,
• Invite comments and encourage discussion. The co-author, underdeveloped, ultra-efficient,
students may say, for example, that the characteristics misaddressed, ex-teacher, decommissioned).
depend on the type of person. The characteristics of a
successful novelist overlap with, but are not identical • Then do Exercise B as a quick-fire whole-class activity.
to, those for a successful chief executive. (Drive and
discipline might be common to both.) Exercise A
renamed, overconfidence, outperform, co-founder,
B underestimated, ultramodern, misinformed,
ex-business, devalued
• Ask the students, in pairs, to talk about individuals
they know, perhaps in relation to the five words Exercise B
they chose in Exercise A, and report their findings 1 over- 2 out- 3 mis- 4 ultra- 5 ex- 6 de-
to the whole class. Say that they can relate the 7 co- 8 under- 9 re-
characteristics to the people that they mentioned in
the Warmer activity if they want to.
38
C Suggested answer
Do the first one as an example with the whole class and Natural Motion was set up in 2002 and its workforce
demonstrate that the odd one out in each group is the has passion, vision and clarity. It has gone on to be a
word that cannot take the prefix in bold at the beginning very successful software animation company, whose
of the line. Ask the students to complete the exercise in software tools are used in the film industry and in
pairs. Circulate, monitor and assist. the computer game industry, to help make software
characters look more realistic in those formats.
2 boss 3 decide 4 lose 5 look 6 win Those involved have worked together from their early
LESSON NOTES
7 big 8 staff 9 grow vision for what this company might be and have seen
that being delivered with passion and enthusiasm.
D There have been some challenges along the way,
• Get the students to work either individually or in but the team have taken forward their vision with
pairs to complete the sentences. impressive clarity.
• Check answers with the whole class. • Get two or three students to quickly read out what
they have written and compare the different versions.
2 co-authors 3 relaunch 4 overestimated
5 mismanaged 6 outbid 7 ultramodern C CD1.28
8 ex-boss 9 deregulated
• Play the recording and elicit answers from the whole
class, explaining any difficulties.
E
• Get students to discuss the statements in pairs. 1 e
nvironmental technologies, low-carbon
Circulate and monitor the language being used, technologies and alternative-energy technologies
especially prefixes. 2 a
smart-metering technology company, a project
for tidal energy, a project for wind energy, a
• Bring the class to order. Get representatives of
each pair to report their conclusions. Encourage project for lightweight electric motors
discussion with the whole class.
• sk students if they have heard about these
A
• Praise good language points and work on three or four technologies and applications in other contexts,
points that need it, especially in relation to prefixes. and if so, where.
i-Glossary tudents can watch the interview with Tom
S
Hockaday on the DVD-ROM.
Resource bank: Listening (page 191)
Listening: Successful businesses
The managing director of a technology development
company talks about what makes for a successful business.
Reading: Carlos Slim
A CD1.26
Students read about one of the world’s richest men,
• Get students to read the text to anticipate the words Carlos Slim.
that might go in the gaps.
A
• Play the recording once or twice and ask the students
for the missing words. • Explain the task and get students to look through the
summary before they read the article.
• Then play the recording again, stopping after any
words that have caused difficulty. • Students read the article individually or in pairs.
1 successful 2 manufacture 3 sell • Go round the class and assist where necessary.
4 product 5 service 6 sell 7 cost • When most students have finished, bring the class to
8 produce 9 technology 10 increasing value order and get students to say what the errors are.
11 venture capital
Carlos Slim is probably the richest man you have
B CD1.27 never heard of. The major influences on his life
were his father, Julián, who was born in Lebanon,
• Explain the task. Play the recording, stopping at
and Jean Paul Getty. He studied civil engineering at
convenient points, and get students to write a
university in Mexico City and on graduating set up as
summary of what Tom Hockaday says.
a stockbroker. He made a lot of money in the Mexican
recession of 1982, buying his assets in the middle
of the crisis. In 1990 Slim gained control of Telmex,
which owns 90% of Mexican telephone lines and is
one of the largest parts of Slim’s empire. Slim is also
involved in charity through his Carso Foundation.
39
B
article again.
• Get students to do this task in pairs in class to
1 b 2 g 3 e 4 f 5 d 6 a 7 c practise the grammar before doing Exercise C for
homework. Circulate and assist where necessary.
• Get students to read the article again and find where
and how the pairs are used. C
C
• Students do this exercise for homework. Make sure
that they hand it in in the next lesson or e-mail it to
• Get students to work on this individually or in pairs. you to correct.
1 present simple 2 past simple • Get students to look at the sentences with gaps in C
3 present continuous 4 present perfect and anticipate what might go in them.
5 past perfect • Play the recording again, stopping at convenient
points and get students to say what is in the gaps,
• Point out the grammar reference section at the back
working on any difficulties.
of the Course Book if the students have not already
seen it. They can look at the material on these verb
1 discount 2 standard; in mind
tenses for homework.
3 double; willing; reasonable 4 asking a lot
5 proposal; prepared 6 a deal; the list price
A
• Do as a whole-class activity, re-explaining rules D
where necessary.
• Get students to look at the script on page 157 of the
Course Book in pairs, identifying the expressions in
each category.
40
E
• Explain the situation.
LESSON NOTES
• Put the students into pairs and appoint the Sales
Managers and Chief Buyers. Make sure that everyone
knows who they are.
One-to-one
This role play can be done between teacher and
student. Don’t forget to note language points for
praise and correction afterwards. Discuss with the
student their negotiating plan and the tactics they
were using.
41
case study
Kensington United Current situation
Students study information about Kensington United Current sponsorship Insurance company (about
football club and take part in the negotiations between deal with to end)
the club and a big media company about a new
Possible new Universal Communications
sponsorship deal.
broadcasting/ (UC)
CASE STUDY
• When students are ready, put them into pairs, with • Check that the situation is clear to all the students by
one A and one B in each. Students summarise their asking a few quick questions.
information for their partners.
• Once you are satisfied that the situation is clear,
• While students are doing this, put the points in the move on to Stage 2.
left hand columns of the two tables below on the
Task
board. Students work in their pairs to complete as
much information as they can. • Divide the class into groups of four to six. Within each
group, half the students will represent KU and the
• Elicit answers and add them to the board. There will other half, UC (two to three students on each side).
be some information missing.
• Ask the whole class to look at the agenda for the
CD1.30 negotiations and elaborate briefly on each point.
• Play the recording once or twice and get students to • Before the students read their role cards, make it clear
make notes of the missing information. that each side will have to work out its objectives,
priorities, strategy and tactics, and think carefully
• Round up the answers on the board with the whole class.
about what concessions they are willing to make.
Kensington United (KU)
• KU negotiators turn to page 133 and read their role cards.
Recent Very successful in UK and mainland • UC negotiators turn to page 141 and read their role cards.
performance Europe
• Get each team to work together to develop an
Recent Commercially very successful effective strategy for the negotiations. Circulate,
business monitor and assist.
performance
• Make sure that each side has a chief negotiator who
Footballing Marco Conti, its Italian manager will be the first to speak. The chief UC negotiator will
success due to outline the purpose of the negotiations and the chief
KU negotiator will reply. The chief negotiators should
Commercial Ingrid Tauber, Commercial Director, and make sure that the discussions move on smartly, so
success due to her work on diversifying into: that participants do not spend too long on each point.
• club travel agency
• The negotiations can begin, in parallel where there is
• hospitality facilities more than one group.
• joint venture with insurance company • Circulate and monitor, noting strong points and
those that need correction. Do not intervene in
• training courses on leadership
the negotiations themselves unless the teams are
• football boot manufacturing completely stuck.
company.
CD1.31
Problems Spectator (teach this word if necessary)
behaviour • Just before the negotiations seem to be coming to a
conclusion, stop the class and tell them that a news
report has just come on the radio. Play recording
1.31. Then ask the students to continue their
negotiation.
42
CASE STUDY
rephrase what they said earlier, incorporating the
corrections.
One-to-one
This negotiation can be done one-to-one. Ask the
student which side they would prefer to represent.
You represent the other side. Don’t forget to note
language points for praise and correction later.
Afterwards, discuss with the student their negotiating
plan and the tactics they were using. Praise and
correct your student’s use of language as appropriate,
and highlight some of the language you chose to use
as well.
43