Why Had International Peace Collapsed by 1939
Why Had International Peace Collapsed by 1939
Why Had International Peace Collapsed by 1939
Department: Humanities
Syllabus Code 0470: Option B
TOPIC: Why had international peace collapsed by 1939?
Focus Points
• What were the long-term consequences of the peace treaties of 1919–23?
• What were the consequences of the failures of the League in the 1930s?
– The collapse of international order in the 1930s
-The increasing militarism of Germany, Italy and Japan
• How far was Hitler’s foreign policy to blame for the outbreak of war in 1939?
– the Saar
– remilitarisation of the Rhineland
– involvement in the Spanish Civil War
– Anschluss with Austria – appeasement
– crises over Czechoslovakia and Poland
– the outbreak of war
• Was the policy of appeasement justified?
• How important was the Nazi–Soviet Pact?
• Why did Britain and France declare war on Germany in September 1939?
Question: What actions had Hitler taken by the end of 1935 to break the Treaty of
Versailles?
Hitler refused to pay any more reparations.
He left the League of Nations.
In 1933, Hitler began re-arming in secret.
Hitler attempted the Anschluss with Austria.
Hitler re-introduced conscription.
He announced that his army would be 500000.
He announced his intention of creating a military air force.
Hitler signed the Anglo-German Naval Agreement, which allowed him a
fleet that was 35% the size of Britain’s fleet.
This Agreement allowed Germany 45% of Britain’s submarines.
What were the consequences of the failures of the League in the 1930s?
Manchuria and Abyssinia, along with disarmament failure, led to League of Nation
losing all credibility. ‘Nail in the coffin’ for its authority.
Exposed League’s weaknesses
Britain & France unprepared for war and wanted to avoid it as much as possible.
Needed to buy time to prepare. Led to appeasement, which made Hitler more
confident
Led to the second world war
How far was Hitler’s foreign policy to blame for the outbreak of war in
1939?
Role of Hitler’s foreign policy: expansionism intent clearly outlined in Mein Kampf,
Nazi Party gained support in Germany and he gambled his way to rearmament,
Rhineland, Sudetenland, Czechoslovakia, Poland. Willingness to fight for his interest
would ultimately lead to war.
Role of other factors: his foreign policy was more gambling than planned;
encouraged by appeasement (e.g. Rhineland 29 Czechoslovakia). Failure of the
League meant there was no condemnation or collective security to impede him.
Treaty of Versailles weaknesses exploited and this discontent largely shaped his
foreign policy. Expansionist intent not new to Germany- ‘greater Germany’ vision
resonated by Kaiser also- German foreign policy’ and aggressive nationalism in
general to blame for war, not just Hitler’s nationalism.
German Rearmament
When Hitler became Chancellor of Germany in 1933, he was determined to make Germany
the leading military power in Europe and conquer territory in Eastern Europe for his master
race. In order to do this, he needed to rearm Germany with modern weapons and increase
the size of her armed forces. However, the main obstacle to his plan was the Treaty of
Versailles, which was enforced by the League of Nations. Luckily for Germany, the
international determination to make the League of Nations work had been weakened in the
1920s and had been further undermined by the Great Depression, which made it difficult for
the League to enforce its economic sanctions. As a result, countries were focusing on fixing
their own problems, rather than those in other countries. Aware of this, Hitler was careful to
avoid provoking Britain and France until he was ready.
• German rearmament began immediately in 1933. At first, this was done secretly with the
help of industrialists who supported Hitler and helped to fund the Nazi party. Production of
new tanks, aircraft and other weapons began.
• In 1934, Hitler went to the Geneva Disarmament Conference. He asked for equality with
the French army. The British agreed but the French refused. Hitler walked out left the
League of Nations claiming that Germany was being treated unfairly. Britain and France
blamed each other for the failure to reach agreement.
• In 1935, the Anglo-German Naval agreement allowed Germany to increase her Navy
beyond the limits set at Versailles. The French were furious and believed the British were
too soft with Germany. This further divided Britain and France to Hitler’s advantage.
• Later in 1935 Hitler declared that he was increasing the German Army to 500,000. He also
announced the existence of a German Air Force. These things had been forbidden at
Versailles.
• Rearmament was very popular in Germany and it boosted support for the Nazi party.
Hitler also knew that the British public had some sympathy with Germany on the issue.
• At each stage Britain and France were divided over what to do. Many people in Britain felt
that the terms of the Treaty of Versailles were too harsh and were prepared to support
politicians who were prepared to follow policies which avoid confrontation with Germany.
Question: In what ways had Hitler built up Germany’s military strength by March 1936?
• 1919 – The Saar was removed from Germany on a temporary / permanent basis for 15
years and put under the control of the League of Nations. All the profits from this rich coal
mining area are given to France as part of her reparation payments. This is bitterly resent by
most Germans as the people in the Saar were no longer part of Germany.
• 1933 – When Hitler comes to power, some of his opponents took refuge in the Saar,
where they campaigned for the area to remain under the League, but the great majority of
the people living there were Germans and there was rooted hostility to France.
• 1935 – The League of Nations holds a plebiscite or vote on whether the Saar should
reunite with Germany. They voted 477,000 or 90% to 48,000 or 10% in favour of a return to
Germany. This was an important victory for the Nazis who were able to portray themselves
as representing the popular will of the German people in the fight against the unfair treaty
of Versailles.
• Germans who lived outside Germany had shown the world that they hated the Treaty of
Versailles democratically and loved Germany more than they feared Hitler's regime. It
made it very hard for Hitler’s opponents to argue that the German people were not wholly
behind him and his aims for ‘One People, One Leader, One Empire.’
Remilitarisation of the Rhineland
The Terms of the Treaty of Versailles, forbade Germany from having any armed forces in
the Rhineland. This was done to stop future German aggression and give both France and
Belgium security. However, both countries had exploited this weakness by invading
Germany in 1923 in order to force her into paying reparations. This left a lasting sense of
bitterness in Germany and helped to increase hatred towards the treaty of Versailles, which
helped the Nazis to get elected in 1933.
Aware of the fact that the world was focusing on the international crisis in Abyssinia, Hitler
marched his troops back into the Rhineland in March 1936. Shocked by this turn of events
Britain and France did nothing.
Austria, (Anschluss), 1938
Hitler had been born in Austria. He believed that as the Austrians were German speaking,
they should be joined or united with into a greater Germany. This was strictly forbidden
under the terms of the Treaty of Versailles. However, a strong Nazi Party already existed in
Austria and Hitler used them to stir up trouble and make it appear that the Austrians
wanted to join with Germany. They staged demonstrations calling for political union with
Germany (Anschluss) and some of these turned into riots. However, Hitler’s dream was put
on hold in 1934, when Mussolini had stopped him. Four years later the situation was very
different. Germany was stronger and Hitler and Mussolini were now allies.
Countdown to Anschluss
• In February 1938, Hitler called a meeting with the Austrian Chancellor Herr Schuschnigg
and told him that they only way to solve Austria’s problems was through Anschluss. The
meeting ended with Hitler threatening Schuschnigg into making concessions. See Source 5.
• On his return to Austria, Herr Schuschnigg decided to try and fight Hitler by trying to
arrange a plebiscite or referendum (vote) on whether his country should remain
independent of Germany.
• On 11 March, Hitler demanded that the vote should be stopped. Schuschnigg resigned and
Germany invaded, supposedly at the invitation of the Austrian Nazis.
• Britain and France did nothing to stop the invasion. Hitler later held a plebiscite or vote in
April 1938 and 99.75% of Austrian’s supposedly approved the uniting of Austria with
Germany.
• Chamberlain, the British Prime Minister, felt that the Austrians and Germans had a right to
be united and felt that the Treaty of Versailles had been wrong to separate them.
• Britain’s Lord Halifax had even suggested to Hitler before the Anschluss that Britain would
not resist Germany uniting with Austria.
• The lack of opposition from Britain and France made Hitler even more confident. He was
aware that many people Britain felt that the Treaty of Versailles had been too harsh on
Germany and that people did not want their country dragged into another war.
Spanish Civil War
Hitler & Mussolini supported General Franco’s right-wing extremist rebels against
communist supporter of the Republican government. LON helpless. Condor legion bombed
Guernica. (Nationalist victory). Dress rehearsal/testing ground for WW2.
Question: Why was involvement in the Spanish Civil War of benefit to Hitler?
Hitler was able to test the capability of his Luftwaffe in strategic bombing of
Spanish towns such as Guernica.
It was testing carpet bombing which made civilians a direct target.
The attacks were designed in waives to maximise the damage and casualties.
He was able to support a fellow fascist.
Hitler was able to try out his military equipment.
He was able to try out his tactics.
Hitler was able to combat communism.
It provided a distraction while he took action over Austria.
Mussolini and Hitler worked closely together in Spain leading to the ‘Rome-Berlin
Axis’.
Munich Pact (1938)
Czechoslovakia Triumph? Averted war, gain time, people learnt to not trust Hitler (Opinion
poll Oct 1938- 93% did not believe his claim of have no more territorial ambition in Europe)
or Sell out? Public relief overstated-not really peace just preparation period, appeasement
failed, Allies lost important ally. Trigger: claim that Czech government mistreating Germans
in Sudetenland, wanted to ’rescue’ them by 1st Oct. Britain sees demands as unreasonable
and mobilizes army, war imminent. Resolved with Munich pact & joint declaration (peace
for our time) on 29th September 1938. Czechs and USSR not consulted about conceding
Sudetenland to Germany.
Question: ‘Chamberlain’s attempts to reach agreement at Munich were worthwhile.’ How
far do you agree with this statement? Explain your answer.
During the 1st World War, Chamberlain was Director General of National Service
and had seen the horrors of war.
Chamberlain was trying to keep the peace.
Nearly every family had lost a member in the war.
He wanted to avoid going to war again at all costs.
Chamberlain did not think Britain was prepared for war.
Britain’s air defences were incomplete.
The British Empire would not support another war
However,
If war had broken out in October 1938, Britain and France would have had the
support of the 36 divisions of the Czech army fighting behind their well-defences.
The Soviet Union would probably have remained neutral. Britain had abandoned
Czechoslovakia. Britain, France and Czechoslovakia together could have defeated
Hitler. There was little point given Hitler’s plans.
Czechoslovakia, 1938
After the Anschluss, it was clear that Czechoslovakia, with its land thrusting deep into
German territory, would be a direct threat to Germany. Edward Benes, the leader of
Czechoslovakia was horrified at the Anschluss. He realised that his country would be next
on Hitler’s takeover list as it had three million ethnic Germans living in an area called the
Sudetenland.
Although not a large country, Czechoslovakia was well defended and had a modern well-
equipped army which was similar in size to the German Army. The country had a lot of
natural resources including coal, iron and steel as well as a thriving arms industry. With
support from Britain and France the Czechoslovakian’s could have successfully resisted a
German invasion. There was a real threat of war!
• By 1938, Germany was in a very strong position and when Hitler moved against
Czechoslovakia, he was ready for war. Britain was not and had only just begun to rearm.
• Within a few weeks of the Anschluss, Nazis living in the Sudetenland started claiming that
they were being treated badly by the Czechoslovakian government.
• Hitler ordered his generals to start planning for an invasion on 1st October 1938 and told
them: ‘It is my unalterable decision to smash Czechoslovakia. At a meeting with the Czech
President Benes, he demanded the Sudetenland be given to Germany.
• The Soviet Union (USSR) offered to help the Czechs provided the French were willing to
fight. The Czechs and the French began to mobilize their armies. German troops were
moved to the Czech border.
• In a last-ditch attempt to prevent the invasion and keep the peace, Chamberlain, the
British Prime Minister flew to Germany to meet with Hitler on 15th September 1938.
• The meeting appeared to go well. Hitler was prepared to negotiate saying that he was
only interested in the Sudetenland and then only if a plebiscite or election showed that the
Sudeten Germans wanted to join Germany. This seemed reasonable to Chamberlain or
thought that he could do a deal with Hitler.
• On 19th September, the British and French put to the deal that Chamberlain had
negotiated to the Czech government. However, they refused to surrender the Sudetenland
as it would make them defenceless against Germany.
• On 22nd September, Hitler went back on his word and said that he wanted the whole of
the Sudetenland. Chamberlain refused saying that Hitler’s demands were unreasonable.
The British army and navy were mobilized for war.
• Chamberlain was desperate for a solution that would avoid war. Britain was not ready
and had only just begun to rearm. When Mussolini, proposed a four-power conference,
both Hitler and Chamberlain, who both saw a solution to their problems agreed to attend.
• On 29th September 1938, the leaders of Britain, France, Germany and France met at
Munich and signed an agreement that gave Hitler the terms he had demanded.
Czechoslovakia was broken up and Hitler had got what he wanted. However, as part of the
agreement, Chamberlain also got Hitler to agree that he would not take any more land in
Europe.
• Throughout these negotiations, neither the Czech nor the USSR governments were
consulted over the Munich Agreement.
• On his return to Britain, Chamberlain claimed that the Munich agreement would bring
‘peace in our time.’ However, this new policy of appeasement relied very heavily on Hitler
keeping his promises. Meanwhile, Britain began to rearm in earnest and prepare for war.
Why did Britain and France declare war on Germany in September 1939?
Hitler’s actions and policies- Hitler was determined to undo Treaty of Versailles from
very beginning, would happen sooner or later
League of the Nations failed after Manchuria, Abyssinia and unsuccessful
disarmament attempts.
Appeasement intensified Hitler’s aggression. Britain and France unprepared for war
and had little other choice
Nazi Soviet Pact paved way for the invasion of Poland gave USSR time in rearm
Violation of the Munich Pact & Polish guarantee led to war
However other important factors also played a role in starting the war:
Appeasement also very important in causing war by encouraging Hitler’s aggression
Failure of League caused by Great Depression meant appeasement inevitable &
Hitler aggression unchecked
Polish guaranteed invasion would certainly result in war
Treaty of Versailles inspired Hitler’s revenge therefore very large role to play