Prose 2 Year (Intermediate) : 1. How To Avoid Foolish Opinions (Bertrand Russell)
Prose 2 Year (Intermediate) : 1. How To Avoid Foolish Opinions (Bertrand Russell)
Prose 2 Year (Intermediate) : 1. How To Avoid Foolish Opinions (Bertrand Russell)
3. Answer Any Two of the following questions in about 100 words each.
[2×4=8Marks]
a) How can we prevent developing a dogmatic attitude as per Russell’s suggestion?
b) Travel is an excellent educator. Explain with reference to Russell’s essay How to Avoid
Foolish Opinions.
c) According to Russel, what is the only way to tackle self-pride?
d) What does Bertrand Russell say about a person getting angry about a difference of opinion?
Introduction: These lines are taken from the lesson “How to Avoid Foolish Opinions” written
by “Bertrand Russell”
About the author: Bertrand Arthur William Russell was born in the United Kingdom. He was a
Philosopher, logician, mathematician, historian, writer, Social critic, Political activist, and Nobel
laureate. His writing is characterized by an extended knowledge of Science and Philosophy. He
is the author of Principia Mathematica, The Problem of Philosophy, and many other influential
works.
Context – The article “How to Avoid foolish Opinions” deals with various ways to avoid many
mistakes man makes. If someone says two and two are five, we don’t feel angry, But if we lack
in arithmetic knowledge, we become angry. Anger cautions us to be careful. Where there is
not much evidence about a particular issue, there is scope for differences in opinions.
Theology leads to arguments whereas arithmetic doesn’t give any chance for disputes. Travel
is an excellent educator. It teaches one, through many live examples, what cultures customs,
crops climates, etc are!
Awareness of multiple types of beliefs through world journeys avoids foolish opinions. Russel
found out that participating in an imaginary argument with a person holding opposite to yours
is an effective technique.
Russell explains self-esteem is one major reason for differences in opinions. We have many
instances where ideas flatter over Self-esteem. Both men and women strongly believe that
they are better than the other sex.
Russell analyses that keep on expanding your knowledge on various issues that help you stay
away from anger. A great thinker as Russell is, he suggests here a simple way to tackle self-
pride. The method is to remember how short our life span is on a Small Planet.
Conclusion: Thus Russell gives us tips on how to avoid foolish opinions. The first is observation
then, being ready to reconsider our opinions, the third is becoming aware of the fact, the
fourth is ample use of psychological imagination and the fifth is keeping self-esteem within
limits.
OR
Introduction: These lines are taken from the lesson “How to Avoid Foolish
Opinions” written by “Bertrand Russell“.
About the author: Bertrand Arthur William Russell was born in the United Kingdom. He was a
Philosopher, mathematician, historian, writer, political activist, and Nobel laureate.
Context: The article How to Avoid foolish Opinions deals with various ways to avoid many
mistakes a man makes.
Explanation: Russell, in his essay, How To Avoid Foolish Opinion says that there are many way
to avoid being foolish. Making a keen observation where it can settle the bias is the first way.
Next, to know what other people think
one has to be aware of what they think. This can be done by going on vacation and talking to
peope with different ideas. The third is arguing with an imaginary character who has a
different point of view. The fourth one is to deal with one’s sense of selfworth which is the
hardest, to overcome we must remember that we live for a short while on a small planet.
Conclusion: Thus Russell gives us tips on how to avoid foolish opinions
2. The Awakening of Women( K. M. Panikkar )
1. Annotate the following into about 100 words each [2×4=8Marks]
a) Undoubtedly women in ancient India enjoyed a much higher status than their descendants
in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.
b) From the first days of his movement Gandhiji realized that there was a source of immense
untapped power in the womanhood of India …
c) It was a matter of surprise to the outside world that independent India should have
appointed women to the highest posts so freely, as members of the Cabinet…
d) The contribution of women to modern India may therefore be said to have led to
reintegration of social relationships.
3. Answer Any Two of the following questions in about 100 words each.
[2×4=8Marks]
a) To make the spirit of the religion of the forest clear to readers, Tagore presents some sets of
contrasts. Explain them.
b) This aspect of truth cannot be ignored; it has to be known and mastered. What is that
aspect of truth, according to Tagore?
c)The hermitage shines out in all our ancient literature, as the place where the chasm between
man and the rest of creation has been bridged. Explain this statement of Tagore.
d) Explain how the old simplicity of Hindu life had broken up in Kalidasa’s time.
Introduction: These lines are taken from the thought-provoking essay “The Religion Of The Forest” written by
Rabindranath Tagore.
About the author: Rabindranath Tagore a polymath is fondly remembered as Gurudev and VishwaKavi. He
was awarded the Nobel Prize for his Gitanjali. As a poet, dramatist, novelist, story writer, artist, educationist,
social, dramatist, novelist, story writer, artist, educationist, social, political, and religious thinker, and
philosopher, Tagore remains immoral.
Content: The essay “The Religion Of The Forest” is an extract from his original English composition “Creative
Unity”. The essay looks like a research paper.
Explanation: Ancient India provided serene surroundings to her wife sages in her lush green forest. They
preached the idol of perfection to the world the essence of that teaching is so Universal and long-lasting that it
dominates our mind even today.
Indians were mostly forest dwellers. They picked up from nature the principle of peaceful coexistence. North
men and on the other hand, were mainly sea forces and their motto was confrontation and subjugation.
Tagore explains, objectively, both the merits and demerits of each side, still, he guides the readers to choose
well. When the world seen as alien to us, then its mechanical aspect becomes prominent in our minds. The
machine also has its place in the world. Europe has done so and has reaped a rich harvest.
The view of ancient Indians about our life and universe is well summed up in the term ‘Sacchi Danada’ it tells
that reality has three phases. The first phase is ‘Sat’ which states the fact that things exist and the fact that
relates us to all things through the relationship of common existence.
The second phase is ‘chit’ which states that we know and this relates to all things through knowledge.
In Kalidas’s Shakuntala, the hermitage overshadowed the magnificence of the king’s Palace. While describing
the Hermitage in “Kadambari” Bana tells us one could hear the groves, the verses, repeated by the parrots and
the wildfowl enjoying their food. One could also see the Ducks coming up from the lake, the dear caressing the
young hermit boys. All these things tell us that the hermitage was the place where the wide differences of the
feeling of man and the rest of the creation has been bridged.
For Tagore, our relationship with the forest and nature is a relationship that allows us to experience our
humanity. Realism is the value of this concept and living as per that ideal promotes peace and prosperity.
In Kalidas’s time, the kings became self-seeking epicureans. It is evident from Kalidas’s poem one should find
enjoyment through renunciation, not through the greed of possession, future would be glorious when there
would be the calm of self-control, purity, and renunciation in the atmosphere.
Conclusion: The essay serves as an example of both an expository and argumentative essay for learners to
emulate.
(OR)
Introduction: These lines are taken from the thought-provoking essay The Religion of the Forest written by
Rabindranath Tagore
About the author: Rabindranath Tagore is fondly remembered as Gurudev and VishwaKavi. He was awarded
the Nobel Prize for his Gitanjali.
Context: The essay The Religion Of the Forest is an extract from his original English composition Creative
Unity. The essay looks like a research paper.
Explanation: Tagore seeks to present the ideal of perfection as explained by the ancient Indian forest-
dwellers. Ancient India provided calm surroundings to her wise sages in her green forests. They preached the
ideal of perfection to the world. The view of ancient Indian about a life and universe is well summed up in the
term. “Sacdhidanada”.The first phase is “Sat” which states the things that exist. The second phase is “Chit”
which states that we know and this relates to all, things through knowledge. The third phase is “Ananda”
which is the fact that we enjoy and this unites as with all things through love.All through the Kalidas’s poem
there, runs the idea that the future would be glorious when there would be calm of self-control.
Conclusion: Thus living in harmony with nature is the religion of the forest.
5. Guilty (Horace J Gardiner and Bonneriere)
1. Annotate ANY TWO of the following in about 100 words each. [2×4=8Marks]
a) Maybe the world needs good Watchmen as much as it does engineers
b) He is a fine, good boy and a hard worker
c) Ma, you’re talking like someone in a fog, without any sense.
d) You have put what you think is two and two together and made four out of it, haven’t you?
3. Answer any two of the following questions in about 100 words each.
[2×4=8Marks]
a) Describe the importance of Mrs. Moore’s role in Guilty
b) Ma Ryan puts what she thinks is two and two together and makes four out of it. Discuss the
developments that lead ( or, rather mislead ) Ma Ryan into making this mistake.
c) Sketch the character of Jim in the light of Ma Ryan’s comments like it is the same! but how
did it get into Jim’s pocket?
d) “Ma, you’re talking like someone in a fog, without any sense.” Are these words from Jim an
order or exception? Explain.
Introduction: These lines are taken from the delightful and humorous one-act
play Guilty written by Horace J. Gardiner and Bonneriere
About the Author: Horace J.Gardiner was born in the U.S.A not much is known to the world
about him. People consider Horace J. Gardiner and Bonnevier Arnaud a single author, for the
apparent reason of the Non-availability of any work by them individually.
Context: Guilty is a delightful one and play the play succeeds in delivering a clear social
message.
Explanation: Jim Ryan is the central character of this one-act play. He is an engineering
graduate. But he has been compelled to work as a night watchman, for want of a better job.
Jim’s mother Ma Ryan knows about her son well she has unflinching love towards her son, but
what pleases her most is that Jim still keeps some of the bad company.
They highlight the dignity of labor. She says that she is very much afraid that the boy remains
unemployed forever. She worries a lot that he would get discouraged, and depressed. One
could do anything when it becomes difficult to survive. The neighboring woman Mrs. Moore
says that the boy is not that sort and he won’t do anything wrong. Ma Ryan, too, agrees Mrs.
Moore always
One night, the neighbor Mrs. Moore calls on Ma Ryan and shows her in a news item in the
newspaper. It is about a stolen Diamond robbery is committed at the Van Kings warehouse,
the previous night where Jim is working. The thieves have stolen the famous Van King’s
diamond pendant, coincidentally Ma Ryan has found a jewel wrapped in a kerchief in Jim’s
sweater. Mother doubts if it is the stolen diamond of Van King. She grows anxious, she fears
that her son would be sent to Jail.
The next movement a police officer calls at their house, then Jim and a stranger turn up. Ma
Ryan asked Jim to run away from home, then the stranger says that she guessed it wrongly it is
indeed Mr. Jim, who somehow got the Diamond. Later, Jim clarifies that all her fears and
untrue, and she is totally confused.
Conclusion: The play is full of gripping narrations and it delivers a clear social message.
(OR)
Introduction: These lines are taken from the delightful and humorous one-act play
Guilty written by Horace J. Gardiner and Bonneriere
About the Author: Horace J.Gardiner was born in the U.S.A not much is known to
the world about him. People consider Horace J. Gardiner and Bonnevier Arnaud a
single author, for the apparent reason of the Non-availability of any work by them
individually.
Context: Guilty is a delightful one and play the play succeeds in delivering a clear
social message.
Explanation: Jim Ryan is a young engineering graduate. He works as a
Nightwatchman at Van King Warehouse. Mrs More the neighbour, shows Jim’s
mother, Ma Ryan a newspaper report about a robbery at the Van King Warehouse.
As Ma Ryan straightens up Jims room, she finds the robbed diamond pendant in
the pocket of Jim’s sweater. She starts worrying that her son is mixed up in the
robbery. She puts two and two together. But very soon, she discovers her mistake.
And all is well that ends well.
Conclusion: The play is full of gripping narrations and it delivers a clear social
message.