See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/320702019

Investigating Thermal Effect on a Cross Linked Polyethylene Power Cable

Article  in  TELKOMNIKA Indonesian Journal of Electrical Engineering · February 2017

DOI: 10.11591/ijeecs.v2.i2.pages

CITATION READS

1 353

3 authors, including:

Emna Khouildi Rabah Attia

Ecole Polytechnique de Tunisie Ecole Polytechnique de Tunisie
8 PUBLICATIONS   15 CITATIONS    192 PUBLICATIONS   1,107 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

MPSoC architecture for real time vision View project

Radio Over Fiber (4G/5G) View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Emna Khouildi on 22 February 2019.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.

Indonesian Journal of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science
Vol. 2, No. 3, June 2016, pp. 401 ~ 408
DOI: 10.11591/ijeecs.v2.i2.pages  401

Investigating Thermal Effect on a Cross Linked

Polyethylene Power Cable

Emna Khouildi1,2, Rabah Attia1, Rafik Cherni2

1PolytechnicSchool of Tunisia, University of Carthage, 1054 Cartage, Tunisia
2Tunisian Company of Electricity and Gas, Direction of Management of Technology, 1005 Omrane, Tunisia
*Corresponding author, e-mail: emna_khouildi@hotmail.fr

Abstract
One of the agents responsible of the degradation of power cables in electrical distribution network
is the temperature. In this paper, numerical modelling of temperature effect on the cross linked polyethylene
(XLPE) insulation of a medium voltage cable containing internal defects, which are air void cavity and water
tree cavities, is developed by using the finite element method and simulated by COMSOL Multiphysics
Software. The experimental investigation is conducted through studying parial discharge inception voltages
in XLPE insulation before and after 23 heating cycles of a 7 meters sample of a medium voltage cable at
100°C and 120°C temperatures. Partial discharge inception voltages detection were performed using the
IEC60270 test method. The simulation results and experimental measurements assessed the thermal effect
on the degradation of XLPE insulation.

Keywords: XLPE cable, Temperature, Finite element method (FEM), Partial discharge, IEC60270 test
method.

Copyright © 2016 Institute of Advanced Engineering and Science. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction
Underground XLPE insulated cables are widely used for transmission and distribution
networks. Several problems in these cables are caused by external activities, but more than half
of the damage is due to internal defects in the XLPE insulation system [1]. Although XLPE has
good dielectric properties for high voltage applications, ageing of this insulation material cannot
avoidable after long time in operation under various stress conditions, such as electrical stresses
(due to voltage), thermal stresses (due to loss), mechanical stresses (due to vibration) and
environmental stresses (due to pollution, humidity) [2]. In fact, several studies have shown
that ageing of XLPE cables is related to the temperature of the insulation [3] and the insulation
breakdown is closely related to partial discharge activities [4].
All XLPE cables contain antioxidants which protect the XLPE from oxidation during
the extrusion and cross-linkng process, and also during the service life of the cable. The rate
at which the antioxidant is used up is dependant on temperature. The normal maximum operating
temperature of XLPE cables is (90±10)°C. Tests have shown that XLPE cables can operate
at a temperature of 105°C for a limited time without significantly reducing the service life of cables.
At temperatures in excess of 105°C deformation of XLPE readilly occurs, particularly at positions
where the insulation is under mechanical stress. The maximum overload temperature of XLPE
is limted to (105±10)°C [5,6].
In the present work, a 2-dimensional model of a single phase medium voltage cable with
XLPE insulation is developed based on the FEM. This cable model comprises internal defects in
the insulation material which are air void cavity, vented water tree cavity and bow tie water tree
cavity. The thermal effect is described by simulating the distributions of ambient temperature
(30°C), the normal operating temperature (100°C), and the overload temperature (120°C)
throughout the cable structure based on 3-dimensional modeling. An experimental study is
subsequently carried out. A medium voltage cable sample of 7 meters is subjected to 23 cycles
of heating at 100°C and 120°C. After that, an artificial defect is created by a needle in the
insulation, heating cycles are repeated with the same conditions. Partial discharge inception
voltages are measured continuously before and after heating periods by the IEC60270 test
method. Finally, the simulation and experimental results are used to demonstrate the effect
of temperature on the insulation degradation and the cable breakdown.

Received January 1, 2016; Revised April 24, 2016; Accepted May 10, 2016
402  ISSN: 2502-
4752
2. Numerical Modelling of thermal effect on XLPE Cable
This section focuses on the numerical modelling of the temperature distribution in a
medium voltage cable that contains internal defects wich are air void cavity and water trees.
The model is implemented in the finite element method based on the software package COMSOL
Multiphysics.

2.1. XLPE Medium Voltage Cable Description

The cable employed in this study is a medium voltage single phase cable of 18 kV.
Its structure is shown in Figure 1. The cable is composed from a copper conductor (1),
a semi-conducting layer (2), an XLPE insulation (3), a semi-conducting shield (4), a copper tape
screen serves as the earth conductor (5), a bedding (6), an aluminum wire armor (7) and a PVC
ground sheath (8).

Figure 1. Physical Model of single-core 240 mm² XLPE cable

2.2. Thermal Model of XLPE Cable

In Comsol Multiphysics software a 2D cable model is implemented. It is based on the
Finite Element Method that transforms the designed model into a mesh of many elements. It is
used to compute the values at every point in the model to get fine results. The software package
is composed from many modules. In the present work, the Heat Transfer module is used by
adding heat transfer in solids subdivision in it to determine the temperature distribution in the
cable containing internal cavities. COMSOL’s electrostatic application modes with sub domain
settings solve Heat transfer equation:

T
ρC  .  kT   Q  h.  Text  T   (1)
t
Where ρ is the mass specific (kg/m), C is the heat specific (J/m 3.K), k is the heat conductivity
(W/m.K), T is the conductor temperature (K), Q is the heat source (W/m), h is the heat transfer
conduction and Text is the external temperature (K).

2.3. Internal cavities model

The internal cavities used in this study are air void cavity and water tree cavities which
are two types, vented water tree cavity and bow tie water tree cavity. Along the axis of the electric
stress, the vented water tree is growing from the insulating material boundaries to the other side
of the insulation as shown in Figure 2a. The possibility of vented tree initiation is due to irregularity
in the semiconducting screen. It has a bad contact with the insulation [7].

Figure 2a. Vented water tree Figure 2b. Model used in Comsol

IJEECS Vol. 2, No. 3, June 2016 : xxx – xxx

IJEECS ISSN: 2502-4752  403

A vented water tree is modeled as is depicted in Figure 2b to simulate the temperature

distribution in this type of defect [8].
Bow tie water trees are the permanent structures that grow within the body of polymer
insulation, they initiate from impurties and voids within the bulk insultaion and tend to grow in two
directions [9]. The term ‘bow tie’ is derived from the shape of the tree as shown in Figure 3a. A
bow tie water tree is modeled as is depicted in Figure 3b [8].

Figure 3a. Bow-tie water tree [10] Figure 3b. Model used in Comsol

2.4. Temperature distributions in XLPE cable

The distributions of ambient temperature, normal operating temperature and maximum
overload temperature are shown in Figure 4a, Figure 4b and Figure 4c respectively.

Figure 4a. Temperature distributions in XLPE cable at ambient temperature: T= 30°C

Figure 4b. Temperature distributions in XLPE cable at normal operating temperature: T= 100°C

Title of manuscript is short and clear, implies research results (First Author)
404  ISSN: 2502-
4752

Figure 4c. Temperature distributions in XLPE cable at maximum overload temperature: T= 120°C

The cable is heated for 23 days and thermal cycles are performed as follows [11]:
- A test of 20 cycles of heating, 8 hours of heating at the temperature of 100 °C and 16 hours
cooling in air at ambient temperature.
- A test of three heating cycles, 8 hours of heating at the temperature of 120 °C and 16 hours
cooling in air.
A load current transformer is used to heat the cable by applying a current of 1500 A as
shown in Figure 5. Heating temperatures are chosen in accordance with IEC 60811-1-2 standard,
which requires temperature (10±2) °C above the maximum conductor temperature of the cable in
normal operation [12].

Figure 5. Load Current Transformer

A control cable is used to raise the temperature and allow the regulation of the current
transformer, in order to ensure the good performance of heating cycle’s tests.
Throughout the different heating cycles, a voltage Uo of 18kV at an industrial frequency
of 50 Hz is applied between the conductor and the metallic screen (earth conductor).

IJEECS Vol. 2, No. 3, June 2016 : xxx – xxx

IJEECS ISSN: 2502-4752  405

The activity of PD is continuously measured by the test circuit shown in Figure 6, [13].

Figure 6a. Partial discharge measurement circuit Figure6b. Parial discharge detector

Partial discharge measuring system consists of a test object which is the MV XLPE cable,
a coupling capacitor, a measuring system or a PD detector, a high voltage supply, with sufficiently
low level of background noise to allow the specified partial discharge magnitude to be measured
at the specified test voltage, high voltage connections, and a filter was introduced at high voltage
to reduce background noise from the power supply.
In a second phase and in order to produce an artificial cavity inside the insulation, a steel
needle-plane geometry is opted. This approach is widely used in research for simulaing the
electrical stress enhancements and initiating the electrical treeing inside the polymeric insulation.
The insertion of the sharp needle inside the polymer creates a micro-void at the tip of the needle
resulting in the inception of partial discharge activity at relatively low voltages [14].
Heating cycles are repeated with the same conditions and partial discharge activities are
measured continuously.

3. Results and Discussion

The partial discharge voltage is measured over a period of 20 ms each test day during
23 days of heating. Measurement data are recorded in the form of Excel tables, and partial
discharge voltage changes over time have been represented on Matlab software. In Figure 7 is
shown an example of partial discharge activities evolutions before and after the heating cycles at
120 °C for the twentieth day.

Figure 7a. . Partial discharge activity before Figure 7b. Partial discharge activity after heating
heating cycle at 120°C cycle at 120°C

PD signals have increased after heating cycles of 100°C and 120°C. Figures 4 and 5 show that
PD voltage peaks passed from the range between 300mVand 400 mV to the range between 4V
and 5 V by increasing the heating temperature.

Title of manuscript is short and clear, implies research results (First Author)
 406  ISSN: 2502-
4752
PD activity evolution during 23 heating cycles is shown in Figure 8 and Figure 9.

Figure 8a. PD voltage evolution during the heating Figure 8b. Partial discharge activity after heating
cycles of 100°C: during the first ten days cycle at 120°C : during the last ten days

Figure 9. PD voltage evolution during the heating cycles of 120°C

As it can be seen, the partial discharge voltage tends to increase after heating cycles.
Figure 9 shows that between days 22 and 23, the discharge pulses are characterized by very
high- intensity discharge activity, and the partial discharge voltage reaches 14V whereas it did
not exceed a few volts at the beginning of the heating cycle at 100 ° C like is shown at Figure 8.a.
This indicates the increase in surface conductivity of the cavity wall due to the erosion
and chemical reactions creating dissociation products of air. This results in roughness of the
surface and formation of more localized solid by-products, for example, the formation of hydrated
oxalic acid crystals [15, 16].
We can notice that the shape of partial discharge pulse changes significantly over the
prolonged insulation ageing. Discharge pulses with extremely short rise time and pulse width are
observed at the beginning of heating cycles, it is the initial phase of electrical tree inside the
insulation [17].

IJEECS Vol. 2, No. 3, June 2016 : xxx – xxx

IJEECS ISSN: 2502-4752  407

Figure 10. PD voltage evolution in the sample with artificial cavity

Partial discharge activity continued with the artificial cavity for only six days as is shown
in Figure 10 and then the cable was destroyed. PD voltage drops to almost zero for few days
before the cable breakdown. According to research [18], this may take place as a result of
carbonization of the partial discharges inside the void.
This phenomenon prevents the voltage build up across the void and creating a very low
resistive path for very high currents flows. These high current pulses are known as ‘tiny arcs’. It
results in increased heating and severe insulation deterioration.
The intense heat can cause molecular and chemical breakdown of the insulation which
further accelerates the deterioration process as depicted at Figure 11.

Figure 11. Damage of XLPE insulation due to accelerated ageing

4. Conclusion
In this paper, the effect of temperature on XLPE insultaion of a medium voltage cable has
been studied. This study is based on a finite element model of temperature distribution in the
cable containing internal defects, and on an experimental measurements of the evolution of the
inception voltage of partial discharge activity in a cable undergoing heating cycles.
According to the simulation results, we can see that internal defects in the insulation are
accentuated with the temperature increase, these structural changes in the cross linked
polyethylene morphologie due to thermal ageing generate changes in dielectric properties of the
XLPE cable which are confirmed by experimental measurements.
This work is still in development and research field is oriented on the analysis and the
exploitation of partial discharge signals in order to build up a fundamental basis for the
development of an accurate remaining lifetime diagnostics of power cables.

Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the Polytechnic School of Tunisia and Tunisian Company
of Electricity and Gas for supporting this work.

Title of manuscript is short and clear, implies research results (First Author)
 408  ISSN: 2502-
4752
References
[1] Gulski E, Wester FJ, Boone W, Van Schaik N, Steennis EF, Groot ERS, Pellis J, Grothenhuis BJ.
Knowledge rules support for CBM of power cable circuits. CIGRE. The Netherlands. 2002:1-12.
[2] Rawangpai A, Maraungsri B, Chomnawang N. Artificial accelerated ageing test of 22 kV XLPE cable for
distribution system applications in Thailand. International Journal of Electrical, Computer, Energetic,
Electronic and Communication Engineering. 2010; 4(5): 797-802.
[3] Nikolajevic SV. Accelerated aging of XLPE and EPR cable insulations in wet conditions and its influence
on electrical characteristics. IEEE International Conference on Conduction and Breakdown in Solid
Dielectrics. Vasteras. 1998; 1: 337-340.
[4] Gulski E, Smit JJ, Wester FJ, Van Doeland JW. Condition assessment of high voltage power cables.
International Conference on Power System Technology. Singapore. 2004; 2: 1661-1666.
[5] Metwally IA. The evolution of medium voltage power cables. IEEE Potentials. 2012; 31(3): 20-25.
[6] Yonemoto N, Kuramochi T, Kato K, Eshima H, Imai T, Sasaki K, Endoh T. Automatic PD monitoring for
after-laying test of long-distance 500 kV XLPE cable line. Hitachi Cable Review. 2001; 7(20): 63-68.
[7] Ihsan M. Degradation of Polymeric Power Cable Due To Water Tree under DC Voltage. PhD Thesis.
Malaysia: Universiti Teknologi; 2010.
[8] Emna K, Rabah A, Nejib C. Numerical Modeling of the Electric Field and the Potential Distributions in
Heterogeneous Cavities inside XLPE Power Cable Insulation. Journal of Electrical and Electronics
Engineering. 2016; 9(2): 37-42.
[9] Hvidsten S, FaremoH, Eriksson R, Wei M. Water treeing and condition assessment of high voltage
XLPE cables. IEEE International Symposium on Electrical Insulation. USA. 2002; 14: 112-115.
[10] IEC Standards Commission. 60502-2. Power cables with extruded insulation and their accessories for
rated voltages from 1 kV (Um = 1,2 kV) up to 30 kV (Um = 36 kV) - Part 2: Cables for rated voltages
from 6 kV (Um = 7,2 kV) up to 30 kV (Um = 36 kV). Switzerland: IEC Publisher; 2005.
[11] IEC Standards Commission. 60811-1-2. Common test methods for insulating and sheathing materials
of electric cables-Part 1: Methods for general application-Section 2: Thermal ageing methods.
Switzerland: IEC Publisher; 1985
[12] NF EN. 60885-3. Electrical test methods for electric cables - Part 3: Test methods for partial discharge
measurements on lengths of extruded power cables. France: European Committee for Electrotechnical
Standardization; 2004.
[13] Bamji SS, Bulinski AT, Densley RJ. Degradation of polymeric insulation due to photoemission caused
by high electric fields. IEEE Transactions on Electrical Insulation. 1989; 24(6): 91-98.
[14] Morshuis PHF. Degradation of solid dielectrics due to internal partial discharge: some thoughts on
progress made and where to go now. IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation. 2005;
12(6): 905-913.
[15] Hudon C, Bartnikas R, Wertheimer MR. Analysis of degradation products on epoxy surfaces subjected
to pulse and glow type discharges. Annual Report Conference on Electrical Insulation and Dielectric
Phenomena. Tennessee. 1991: 237-243.
[16] Blackburn TR, Liu Z, Morrow R, Phung BT. Partial discharges development in a void and its effect on
the material surface. Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Properties and Applications
of Dielectric Materials. China. 2000; 2: 280-285.
[17] Morshuis PHF. Time-resolved discharge measurements. International Conference on Partial
Discharge. Canterbury. 1993: 43-46.
[18] Jianying L, Xuetong Z, Guilai Y , Shengtao L, Jiankang Z, Benhong O. The effect of accelerated water
tree ageing on the properties of XLPE cable insulation. IEEE Transaction on Dielectrics and Electric
Insulation. 2011; 18(5): 562-569.

IJEECS Vol. 2, No. 3, June 2016 : xxx – xxx

View publication stats