Unit 3b WLB 2
Unit 3b WLB 2
Work-life balance has always been a concern of those interested in the quality of working life
and its relation to broader quality of life.
In the early days of the industrial revolution in Europe (and today in some parts of the
developing world) a primary concern was with the impact of child labour.
Yet work-life balance has come to the fore in contemporary debates largely because in
affluent societies the excessive demands of work are perceived to present a distinctive issue
that needs to be addressed.
If we use the scales, then balance occurs when there is “an equal distribution of weight or
amount” but this presents problems for work-life balance since both sides may be very heavy
or very light.
Work-family conflict and time pressure had a stronger effect than other stressors such as
leader relations and job insecurity.
However this affected each partner independently and did not spill over into the marital
satisfaction of the other partner.
In the community, there is growing concern that the quality of home and community life is
deteriorating. There are various explanations for this associated with affluence, the growth of
single parent families, the privatization of family life and the lack of local resources and
facilities. In addition, the pressures and demands of work reflected both in longer hours, more
exhaustion and the growth of evening and weekend work leave less scope for “quality”
family time.
The consequences include increases in juvenile crime, more drug abuse, a reduction in care of
the community and in community participation and less willingness to take responsibility for
care of elderly relatives and for the disadvantaged. While steps to redress these concerns
transcend work and employment, it is nevertheless argued that the demands of work
contribute to a reduced participation in non-work activities resulting in an imbalance.
Much of the general analysis about the causes and consequences of work-life imbalance is
speculative and based on limited convincing evidence. We need to learn more in particular
about the consequences of imbalance on family and community and on changing values
among younger workers. It is also notable that debates about work-life balance often occur
without any clear and consistent definition of what we mean by work-life balance.
Work-Life Balance – Among Men and Women, Gender Differences and The Work
Home Interface
For many employees today both male and female their lives are becoming more consumed
with a host of family and other personal responsibilities and interests. Therefore, in an effort
to retain employees, it is increasingly important for organizations to recognize this balance.
According to Sylvia Hewlett, president of the Center for Work-Life Policy, if a woman takes
time off to care for children or an older parent, employers tend to “see these people as less
than fully committed. It’s as though their identity is transformed.”
Research conducted by the Kenexa Research Institute (KRI), a division of Kenexa, evaluated
how male and female workers perceive work-life balance and found that women are more
positive than men in how they perceive their company’s efforts to help them balance work
and life responsibilities. The report is based on the analysis of data drawn from a
representative sample of 10,000 U.S. workers who were surveyed through Work Trends,
KRI’s annual survey of worker opinions.
The results indicated a shift in women’s perceptions about work-life balance. In the past,
women often found it more difficult to maintain balance due to the competing pressures at
work and demands at home.
Women spend more time feeling tense and worried at work than their male colleagues, a new
in- depth study into workplace relations shows. The research by experts from Kingston
University’s School of Human Resource Management found women were less likely than
men to be relaxed and calm in the workplace, but still tended to be more satisfied with their
job.
One possible explanation for the anxiety women reported could be down to the fact that 29
per cent of those surveyed said they had encountered some form of bullying or harassment at
work. Dr. Soane said. Men on the other hand had experienced less bullying with just 19 per
cent saying it was a problem. Despite women feeling less relaxed in the office, overall the
study showed there were no significant differences between men and women’s experiences of
stress at work.
The study also showed women tended to fare better in their appraisals and were more
passionate about their work. They also felt more positive about their senior management team
than men, with 41 per cent of women questioned saying they had confidence in their senior
managers, compared to 34 per cent of men.
Female workers also reported a number of other positive aspects about their jobs. Women
worked shorter hours, with 44 per cent of women contracted to work fewer than 35 hours per
week compared with 18 per cent of men. Female workers were also happier with their work-
life balance and felt they got more support to work flexible hours than their male
counterparts.
A total of 58 per cent of women surveyed said they were happy with their work-life balance,
compared to 52 per cent of men. This is probably a reflection of the fact that employers have
made some changes to make it easier for women to work shorter or more flexible hours, but
this has not yet filtered through to men.
Work life balance is the boundary that you create between your profession, career, or
business and every other segment that makes up your life. It is the separation between your
work life and your personal life. Aside from your career, these segments include your family,
personal growth, spirituality, fitness and health, and community and friendships.
Once you begin to establish healthy boundaries between your work life and your personal
life, you begin to feel more fulfillment and personal satisfaction. This happens as a result of
your own state of wellness. Your mental state becomes much more confident, clear, and
decisive because you are well-rounded and balanced.
By having a clear and consistent separation between your job and the other segments of your
life, you enable yourself to truly be present in each realm of your life. You no longer worry
about work projects while at home and do not worry about things you need to do at home
while at the office.
This allows you to be sharper, more efficient, and better-focused. It also enables you to use
your time more efficiently, be more effective with your communication, task completion, and
decision making, and to enjoy your time at work much more than ever before.
Work life balance plays a huge role in determining whether a person will reach career
advancement. This has been proven by studies and statistics. The studies on work life balance
are truly impressive and have been eye-opening to many employers.
Gender Differences and the Work Home Interface:
Another important research perspective within the work-family literature has focused on
gender differences. Gender has been found to affect career advancement, perhaps through
differential access to valuable work networks, work and family time investment, work-family
conflict and roles stress, and strategies for managing the work-family interface. These gender
differences may due to gender role socialization and different opportunity structure for men
and women, which can lead men and women to have different psychological experiences of
work and family roles.
Men and women have different perceptions of their work roles. Women’s perceptions of their
work role often shaped by barriers to career advancement, compensation and networking
opportunities. Such barriers start with sex typing of jobs and persist with differential access to
development opportunities such as international assignments.
Gender differences also exist in the ways that participation in work and family roles affects
one another. For example- Tenbrunsel et al. (1995) found that, unexpectedly, men’s work
involvement increased their family involvement, but that women’s work involvement had no
effect on their family involvement. Rothboard and Edwards (2003) found that family time
investment decreased work time investment for women but did not affect work time
investment for men.
Men and women also differ in the ways they manage the boundary between work and family
roles, whereas women tend to integrate these roles. This gender difference in management of
the boundary between work and family is thought to stem from differences in mental models
men and women have about work and family roles, as well as from different societal
expectations regarding how men and women ought to handle work and family roles.
Although much research has found gender differences in work-family relationships, it is
important to note that some researchers have not found these differences. For example- Frone
et al. (1992) did not find significant gender differences in the antecedents and outcomes of
work-family conflict. Likewise, Frone et al. (1992) did not find gender differences in the
permeability of the work-home boundary. Further, Anderson et al. (2002) did not find
differences between men and women in the experience of work-family conflict.
Balancing is harder for men also than it was once. The men in the study came to realize that
the tide toward their privileged status has turned both at work and home.
Job demands have gone up, especially for assistant professors. The quantity of publications
and presentations required for tenure has risen dramatically. Men report working harder than
before. Some wonder if they have grown less efficient as they have grown older.
Male faculty at every stage of career agrees that senior professors are better positioned for
work/ life balance than their junior colleagues. Assistant professors see themselves as
carrying undue burdens as a result of changing rules, rewards and definitions of academic
success.
Meanwhile on the home front, men are doing more housework as their partners take full-time
jobs. The old clear-cut division of labor has yielded to a more participatory model. Some
divide tasks by who enjoys what instead of traditional gender roles. Accurately or not, many
of the early- career men see themselves as equal partners at home.
Husband and father are important parts of their identities. In addition to helping meet
practical needs, they value their role in the family. They want to be there for their children in
a way some of their fathers were not for them.
Work-Life Balance –
Techniques of Work-Life Balance Adopted by Subordinates and Boss
In order to help employees to maintain a fair balance between work and personal life
commitments, the company may resort to the given techniques:
1. Bring children to the office if and when one can, and let them see their photos or their
creative work on your desk. This lets them know that they are in your mind and heart. It helps
them understand that you think of them often – and they will also feel a part of what you do.
Make their special day an adventure.
2. Know the boss’s schedule – Maximize meeting time with your boss; be strategic and work
closely with his administrative staff to achieve this.
3. Know when to make calls and when to do administrative work to optimize your time at
work.
4. Schedule family vacations when people aren’t going to be around. Offer a countdown to
vacation time so there are no surprises for your boss or team.
5. Draw a clear line between your personal and work time. Set clear expectations with your
boss.
6. In case of an overachiever, consider cutting back to realistic goals in order to succeed.
i. Societal Drivers:
Agricultural society is giving way to the industrial and knowledge societies. Consequently,
we can observe major shifts in societal forms and structures. This shift is leading to conflicts
between work and life activities. In the past, husbands used to earn livelihood while wives
were responsible only to manage the domestic issues. In other words, men were responsible
for working outside the family while women were the homemakers. The centuries-old
traditional gender roles have changed now.
Women are pursuing higher levels of education. Added to this, double income has emerged
as a prime necessity. Societal perceptions have changed and it is now appropriate for both
men and women to pursue paid employment outside home and also share responsibilities
within the home.
The Indian society is male dominated and has traditionally granted a favoured status to men
as the chief breadwinners. The employment rate of women has also increased worldwide.
Women’s increased wish for autonomy and social recognition is quite justified. Work-life
balance is critically important for working women to ensure sound physical and mental
health.
ii. Organizational Drivers:
Employee-oriented organizations believe that if employees’ work-life balance is well
achieved then organizational effectiveness will be high. It is evident from literature survey
that most multinationals from Scandinavian and western countries take initiatives to promote
work-life balance. On the other hand, the inclination towards the same in Korean and Indian
organizations are low.
HR initiatives play a vital role in promoting work-life balance practices in an organization.
Work load, working hours, stress at work, and organizational reasons are the grounds behind
experiencing difficulty in balancing work life. Organizations should formulate HR practices
such as job description, and role clarity to reduce role stress due to overload, role ambiguity,
and role conflict.
Effective organizational design and systems and processes further facilitate achieving work-
life balance. Progressive organizations develop a variety of work-life balance practices, such
as flexi time, no meetings after core working hours, forced annual leave, maternity and
paternity leave, shopping at work, creche, disincentives to overtime, gym and good food
facility, no late sitting culture, and so on.
iii. Individual Drivers:
Individuals hold differing views about life. The philosophy of life is a major determinant of
work-life balance. All of us have a life philosophy that affects of work-life balance. However,
philosophy is generally implicit and people cannot articulate it concisely in a few words.
One’s philosophy of life can focus either on ‘being’ or ‘becoming’ or strive to attain a
balance between the two.
The state of being is concerned with human endeavour for self-actualization, contentment,
harmony, and enjoying what one is. However, the state of becoming is related to material
achievement, money, power, and social status, etc. ‘The greater the conflict between being &
becoming within an individual, the lower is the WLB.’ Individuals must learn to prioritize
between and professional and personal goals while companies cannot afford to neglect the
need for work-life balance.
Consequences of Imbalance:
Work life, if not properly balanced, leads to a range of physical and psychological strains,
such as irritability, depression, anxiety, diminished self-confidence, inability to relax, lack of
sleep, increased susceptibly to a number of illnesses, a number of psycho-somatic disorders,
burnout, low productivity, high employee turnover, safety hazards, increase in divorce cases,
high blood pressure, ulcer, migraine and many psychosomatic disorders.
Karatepe and Tekinkus (2006) found that the work-family conflict has increased emotional
exhaustion and decreased job satisfaction.
The consequences of work-life imbalance are also categorized as societal, organizational, and
individual consequences.
i. Societal Consequences:
Societal consequences include family dynamics, social pathology, and harmony. People with
poor work-life balance cannot do justice with family members. In such conditions, the family
is likely to be unhealthy characterized by exchange of hot words, misunderstanding between
husband and wife, and so forth. This unhealthy family environment gets reflected onto the
society.
A family lives in a society and hence, it is a subset of the society. To improve the societal life
and make it healthier, it is of utmost importance to put all-round efforts to balance the work
life.
ii. Organizational Consequences:
The direct consequences are poor productivity, high employee turnover, accidents, etc. The
indirect consequences are low involvement, serious interpersonal conflicts at work, apathetic
attitude towards work and so on.
iii. Individual Consequences:
Lack of work-life balance affects family dynamics indirectly and negatively. The child may
not get proper guidance. In many cases, it results in marital discord, divorce, child abuse, and
neglect of old parents. All these affect societal functioning and harmony.