The document provides analysis of the short stories "Lamb to the Slaughter" and "The Way Up to Heaven". It discusses themes of revenge and irony in the stories. In both stories, the wife ends up killing her husband, though Mrs. Maloney directly kills Mr. Maloney with a frozen leg of lamb, while Mrs. Foster leaves Mr. Foster to die stuck in an elevator. Neither wife is ultimately proven to be the murderer. The document also analyzes the relationships and characterizations of the couples in each story.
The document provides analysis of the short stories "Lamb to the Slaughter" and "The Way Up to Heaven". It discusses themes of revenge and irony in the stories. In both stories, the wife ends up killing her husband, though Mrs. Maloney directly kills Mr. Maloney with a frozen leg of lamb, while Mrs. Foster leaves Mr. Foster to die stuck in an elevator. Neither wife is ultimately proven to be the murderer. The document also analyzes the relationships and characterizations of the couples in each story.
The document provides analysis of the short stories "Lamb to the Slaughter" and "The Way Up to Heaven". It discusses themes of revenge and irony in the stories. In both stories, the wife ends up killing her husband, though Mrs. Maloney directly kills Mr. Maloney with a frozen leg of lamb, while Mrs. Foster leaves Mr. Foster to die stuck in an elevator. Neither wife is ultimately proven to be the murderer. The document also analyzes the relationships and characterizations of the couples in each story.
The document provides analysis of the short stories "Lamb to the Slaughter" and "The Way Up to Heaven". It discusses themes of revenge and irony in the stories. In both stories, the wife ends up killing her husband, though Mrs. Maloney directly kills Mr. Maloney with a frozen leg of lamb, while Mrs. Foster leaves Mr. Foster to die stuck in an elevator. Neither wife is ultimately proven to be the murderer. The document also analyzes the relationships and characterizations of the couples in each story.
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 4
1.
The title "Lamb to the slaughter" refers to the story since
it means ignorance and innocence. It conveys the idea that a lamb is innocent and doesn't ask questions and doesn't think about the implications that can come out of naive actions, just like Mary Maloney has thrown the leg of the lamb at her husband. She had been very calm, and she was even happy afterward and was unaware of the fact that she and her incoming baby will probably be killed when the police will discover that Mrs. Maloney was the one who killed her husband. It's ironic since the literal meaning of it is that a lamb is leading to slaughter (slaughter of Patrick Maloney). The title "The way up to heaven" refers to the story since Mrs. Foster is sending Mr. foster up to heaven as she had left him stuck between the second and third floor when he went up in the elevator to their apartment. The story is called "The way up to heaven" because Mr. foster had been on his way up to heaven (he died), just as he had been on his way up to their apartment. It's ironic since Mr. Foster was the one who sealed his fate while he wanted to annoy his wife by taking his time so she will be anxious, and about those kinds of things, you go to heaven, just like Mr. Foster went up to heaven after his actions. 2. The relationship between Mrs. and Mr. Maloney isn't very healthy. Mrs. Maloney cares a lot about her husband, she attempts to make him feel comfortable, as opposed to Mr. Maloney, who doesn't care about his wife but cares more about his work as a detective. As Mr. Maloney comes back from work, Mary cares about how was his day and if he is tired, and if he wants her to cook him dinner instead of going out like they usually do every Thursday. Instead of being kind to Mary, Patrick replies with dry answers, so Mary understood something happened and as he told her what happened, she got angry at him, and it leaded to the fact that she had thrown a lamb at him and killed him. We can learn about Mary from this situation that she has a short fuse and about Patrick that he was sorry for his actions (this can be understood from the fact that he behaved differently than usual. He didn't want to go out to eat outside and he drunk all the wine in a single sip instead of drinking slowly as usual). It is a story of revenge since that as an act of revenge on what Patrick has told his wife (probably he told her that they're divorcing), she killed him with a frozen leg of lamb. The relationship between Mrs. and Mr. Foster is very unhealthy. Both are acting like babies by disturbing and annoying each other on purpose. As Mrs. Foster is worrying about being on time for her flight, Mr. Foster does his best to make her late so she will miss her flight and get angry. Because they are behaving like babies, she was looking for a way to pay him back and when she heard that he is stuck in the elevator she didn't hurry to help him, but she escaped to the airport in order to be on time for her flight. We can learn from those actions that Mr. Foster likes to annoy his wife and Mrs. Foster is very hasty and revengeful and she decided to leave her husband to die in the elevator instead of trying to help him. It is a story of revenge since that as an act of revenge to that Mr. Foster made Mrs. Foster late for her flight, she didn't help him to get out of the stuck elevator and left him there to die. 3. The first impression about Mrs. Maloney is that she is just a normal pregnant woman who loves her husband and cares about him. This impression changes quite fast in the story, as she decides to throw on her husband a leg of a lamb and kill him in that way. As she does that, we learn that maybe she doesn't love her husband as much as we thought on our first impression of her. The first impression about Mrs. Foster is that she is an ordinary, organized, kind woman who likes to be on time for places. Our impression of her changes when she leaves her husband to die, stuck in the elevator. At this moment we can learn about her that she is revengeful and isn't as kind as we thought she is. 4. I think that Mrs. Maloney is the villain in the story and Mr. Maloney is the victim. The fact that her husband told her something that made her angry isn't a good reason for murdering him. Also, she acted like a villain as she tried to hide the evidence (the leg of the lamb) and ended up hiding it by giving it as supper for the detectives who came to search for evidence. If she was the victim, she wasn't running to the grocery to buy some vegetables for dinner to get an alibi because victims don't need to prove themselves as innocent, only villains need. I think Mr. Maloney is the victim in the story because he wasn't doing anything to his wife, couples are divorcing quite a lot and divorce isn't a reason to kill someone. I think that Mr. Foster is the villain in the story and Mrs. Foster is the victim. Mr. Foster is annoying all the time and although he knows about Mrs. Foster's problem of being late to places, he does everything to make her late for her flight. Mrs. Foster is acting from a place of a woman in an anxiety attack, which is very hard to control, and she doesn't think about her actions at this moment. But Mrs. Foster is still the victim because the villain, her husband, made her be in an anxiety attack, and in doing so he sealed his fate. 5. One thing that is similar in the stories "Lamb to the slaughter" and "The way up to heaven" is that in both stories the wife is killing her husband. Another thing that is similar in those stories is that in the end, both wives are not proven as murderers. One thing that is different between the stories is that in the story "Lamb to the slaughter" Mrs. Maloney is directly killing her husband by throwing on him a leg of lamb, but in the story "The way up to heaven" Mrs. Foster isn't directly killing her husband, she just does not help him to get out of the stuck elevator. Another thing that is different between the stories is that in the story "Lamb to the slaughter" the husband didn't deserve to die, but in the story "The way up to heaven" the husband deserved to die because he was so annoying to his wife, and he didn't care about her. The irony in the story "Lamb to the slaughter" is that Mr. Maloney said "Don't make supper for me because I am going out" but at this moment he did not know that she is going to kill him, and he will not escape the house ever again. Another irony in this story is that a policeman said, "the evidence is right under our nose" and it was, they were eating the evidence. The irony in the story "The way up to heaven" is that Mrs. Foster is writing letters to her husband from Paris, although she already knew he is dead because she left him to die instead of helping him escape the elevator. Another irony in the story is that Mr. Foster was the one who sealed his fate while he wanted to annoy his wife and take his time so she will be anxious, and about those kinds of things you go to heaven, just like Mr. Foster went up in the elevator to heaven.