Doctrine of Pious Obligation - Family Law Assignment

12/12/22, 7:12 PM Doctrine of Pious Obligation - Family Law Notes
FAMILY LAW
Doctrine of Pious Obligation – Family Law

Notes
By Akash | June 22, 2021
doctrine of pious obligation, pious obligation,

what is pious, what is pious obligation, pious
obligation meaning, pious obligation notes,
pious obligation notes, family law notes,
Doctrine of pious obligation can be found under Hindu Law. In this

article, we will see the meaning of pious obligation, its history and
relevant case laws.
Meaning of Pious Obligation

The Pious Obligation, here pious means religious, devout or Godly. And
the obligation means duty or Karma of the Hindu person.
https://legalkatta.in/doctrine-of-pious-obligation-family-law-notes/ 1/8
So, the pious obligation means a duty of a Hindu person due to deep
deviation from the Hindu religion.
There are two principles in Hindu Law, one is independent and standard
of autonomous coparcenary rights in the son which is an incident of birth,
giving to the son vested rights in the coparcenary property and the other
one is the pious duty of a son to furnish all the debts of his deceased
father which are not tainted with illegality or immorality.
Under Hindu Law, the son is under pious obligation to furnish his father’s
debts. Let’s discuss it in detail.
What is Son’s Pious Obligation?

Under Hindu Law, the son of a deceased father has an obligation to
discharge his father’s debts out of his ancestral property regardless of any
possibilities that he had not been profited by the debts, having debts is
not avyavaharik.
It is stated under Hindu Law as ‘Who has received a sum lent and does
not repay it to the moneylender will be born hereafter in the creditor’s
house as a slave, servant, women or quadruped. As per the Hindu
Cultures, it is the duty of the son to repay his father’s debts.
This obligation is not only limited to the son but also the son’s son
(grandson) or the son’s son’s son (great-grandson). Thus, this religious
obligation is attached to the three generations.
In the case of Sidheswar vs Bhubaneshwar Prasad, the Supreme Court

of India delivered the judgment as “The Doctrine of Pious Obligation has
origin in the conception of Smriti writers who considered non-payment of
debts as sin, this is considered as evil practice and is the purpose of
rescuing the father from such evil practice and his torments in the next
world that an obligation is imposed on son to pay their father’s debts.”
Historical Background of Pious Obligation

In ancient India, legal writing is itself a novel approach as to the specialist
of morals which was perceived by the Legal Aid British India. The pious
obligation of a son is a moral obligation that was given over legal rights.
The views of P.V. Kane’s is similar to the philosophy of ancient Indian law
codes, which are famously known as Dharmashastra.
The significance of ancient Indian legal writing given to furnishing the

liability to repay the debts from ancient times. As per the ancient legal
thought, one has no liability to pay the debts whereas the other is under
obligation to furnish his duty by paying the debts of his father.
Exceptions to This Doctrine

If the person has obtained such debts illegally or immorally, then the son
has no liability to repay the debts and here the pious obligation is
applicable.
A son doesn’t need to prove the criminal liability of his father in respect of
debts. Here, the son may be exempted from the pious obligation and
there is no liability on the son to pay the debts of his father which are
occurred by illegal means.
Here we will discuss some debts which are outside of the scope of this
doctrine
1. Avyavaharik Debts
The avyavaharik debts can be found in Mitakshara. It is indicated that the

avyavaharik debts are outside of this doctrine. So, what is meant by
avyavaharik debts? Colebrooke has defined avyavaharik debts as a liability
incurred for a cause repugnant to good morals. If it is wholly or partly
improper then they cannot be called vyavaharik debts.
Avyavaharik debts are debts that occurred by way of illegal means. And,
the son is not liable for such illegal debts that occurred by his father.
2. Commercial Debts
In old laws, the commercial debts were kept outside the regulation and
the doctrine was not applicable. But, at present law, commercial debts are
subject to this doctrine i.e. the son is subject to repay the debts of his
father.
3. Gambling Debts
The debts which are taken from gambling or gaming are outside of the
regulation and this doctrine.
For example, debts caused by drinking.
4. Suretyship Debts
When the debts are caused under the suretyship or partnership then the
liability arising out of suretyship by the father is not official on the son.
The Effect of Doctrine of Pious Obligation After

Amendment of 2005
After the enforcement of the Hindu Succession Amendment Act of
2005, no court shall recognize any right to proceed against son, son’s son
(grandson) or son’s son’s son (great-grandson) for any recovery of money

due from his father, grandfather, or great grandfather, on the ground of
pious obligation.
Hence, pious obligation after 2005 under Hindu law, the son, grandson or
great-grandson is discharged from the liability arising out of the pious
obligation and they can discharge such debt.
Conclusion
Here, it is concluded that under the doctrine of pious obligation under
which sons are liable to furnish the father’s debts is completely religious
consideration. The doctrine considered that the father’s debt is vyavaharik
and the debt of the father should be paid by his son.
About Author
Hello there. I am Akash, a YouTuber by Hobbie, and Blogger by Passion.
I Love to spread information that helps others to live in this legal world.
Learn More ➜
PREVIOUS NEXT

Doctrine of Pious Obligation - Family Law Assignment

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Doctrine of Pious Obligation - Family Law Assignment

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Doctrine of Pious Obligation - Family Law Assignment

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

12/12/22, 7:12 PM Doctrine of Pious Obligation - Family Law Notes

Doctrine of Pious Obligation – Family Law

doctrine of pious obligation, pious obligation,

Doctrine of pious obligation can be found under Hindu Law. In this

Meaning of Pious Obligation

What is Son’s Pious Obligation?

In the case of Sidheswar vs Bhubaneshwar Prasad, the Supreme Court

Historical Background of Pious Obligation

The significance of ancient Indian legal writing given to furnishing the

Exceptions to This Doctrine

The avyavaharik debts can be found in Mitakshara. It is indicated that the

For example, debts caused by drinking.

The Effect of Doctrine of Pious Obligation After

(grandson) or son’s son’s son (great-grandson) for any recovery of money

You might also like

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.