Chap 1 Introduction
Chap 1 Introduction
Chap 1 Introduction
J.P. PONTHOT
Aerospace & Mechanical Laboratory/LTAS-MN2L
1
University of Liège, Belgium
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Juan C. SIMO
2
An introduction to Finite Element Method
2
An introduction to Finite Element Method
CHAPTER 1:
2
An introduction to Finite Element Method
64
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Theoretical
Mechanics Applied
Computational
Computational Mechanics
Continuum Mechanics:
Computational Solids and Structures
Mechanics Fluids
Multiphysics
Systems
7
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Statics
Computational
Solid and Structural
Mechanics (CSM)
Dynamics
(“Theory of Vibrations”)
8
An introduction to Finite Element Method
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
CONTINUUM MECHANICS
•KINEMATICS
•CONSERVATION LAWS PDE.
•MATERIAL BEHAVIOR
•LOADS
•SUPPORTS BC
11
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Algebraic equations
Virtual analysis
FEM (Finite Element Method) is a toolkit
for such a numerical approach 12
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Traditional definition
Scaled fabricated version of a physical system
(think of a car or a train model)
Virtual analysis
13
An introduction to Finite Element Method
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
Based on classical Mechanics of Materials (MoM)
IDEALIZATION
Limited to simple concepts, bar, trusses, beam, plate,
shell…
Limited combinations of structural concepts
COMPUTATION
“exact” solutions (but very simplified models…)
LIMITATIONS ADVANTAGES
Quasi-static cases Generality
Small displacements “formulas”
Elasticity (isotropic) Feeling for a designer
Mechanics of materials
(MoM)
14
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
PRE-COMPUTER AGE
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
COMPLEXITY ARISES FROM:
•Complex geometrical shapes
•Complex material behavior
•Complex loading
•Boundary conditions (contact,…)
•Coupling with other phenomena (multiphysics)
•Design criteria
IDEALIZATION
16
*CAD = Computer Aided design
An introduction to Finite Element Method
IDEALIZING
=
SIMPLIFYING!
MODEL PROBLEM
The basic idea is to divide the body (structure) into “finite elements”
(often called elements) of simple shapes -Think of a LEGO game –
connected by ”nodes” and try to obtain an approximate solution.
First step is to generate a Mesh or Grid that approximates the geometry
The vertices of the elements are called the nodes (this is not an
absolute rule).
The loads (heat fluxes) are applied at the nodes and we will try
to determine displacements (temperatures) at the nodes.
22
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Values of the field at the nodes are called nodal values. They
become the basic unknowns or DOF (Degree of Freedom) of
the problem. Thus, there is now a finite number of DOF.
23
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Mesh of Romain Boman generated from a picture thanks to our mesher GEN4.
22
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Kq=g
where
1. q is an unknown vector containing all nodal temperatures
(dimension = number of DOF = NDOF)
1. K is the heat conductivity matrix (material and geometry dependent!)
2. g is the “action” vector resulting from imposed heat sources and fluxes
28 .)
Temperature field in a pump (Courtesy of Samtech S.A
THE KIND OF RESULTS YOU CAN OBTAIN
Front view Back view
FUNDAMENTAL CONCEPTS
The system of simultaneous NDOF algebraic equations
K q = g q = K -1g
will play a central role all along this course. In general
STRUCTURAL MECHANICS
Kq=g q = K -1g
CONCEPTS-SUMMARY
FEM is a systematic way to approximate the solution of an infinite number of
PDE by transforming them into a finite number of algebraic equations
K q = g simplest example
K = spring stiffness
g = applied load
q = end displacement 32
An introduction to Finite Element Method
MODELING = SIMPLIFYING
Geometry, Material & Loads
Idealization
MODELING = SIMPLIFYING
Geometry, Material & Loads
Discretization
DOF=DEGREE OF FREEDOM
NB. Prototypes are still necessary, but they appear in the last stages of design
35
An introduction to Finite Element Method
FEM TRIANGLE
P.D.E.
FUNCTIONAL ANALYSIS
APPROXIMATION THEORY
VARIATIONAL METHODS
……..
SOFTWARE
MODELING
PHYSICAL PROBLEMS
COMPUTER
ENGINEERING “ART”
NUMERICAL ANALYSIS
MATERIAL DESCRIPTION
ALGORITHMS
C.A.D. MATERIAL SCIENCE
…….. 36
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Fancy, colorful
contours can
be produced by
any model,
good or bad!!
ENGINEERING JUDGEMENT
STILL ESSENTIAL 40
An introduction to Finite Element Method
•DATA HANDLING
•Use of inconsistent units (e.g. E=200 GPa, Force=100 lbs)
•Bad idealization / wrong assumptions (element type, BC’s…)
•Distorted, skewed or bad aspect ratio elements in the mesh
•Coarse mesh
•no solution verification
Figure!!!
Results obtained from ten reputable FEM Displacement (mm) versus time (ms)
codes and by users regarded as experts.*
*P. Symonds & T. Yu Counterintuitive behavior in problem of Elastic-Plastic beam Dynamics.
45
ASME Journal of Applied Mechanics, Vol 52, No 3, 1985, page 517-522
An introduction to Finite Element Method
•Use the coarsest mesh that will capture the dominant behavior of the
physical model, particularly in design situations
46
An introduction to Finite Element Method
•Most of the academic community first view FEM very skeptically, some
prestigious journals refused to publish papers on FEM.
47
An introduction to Finite Element Method
•Ray Clough was a Prof. at the Berkeley and worked at Boeing for summer job. In
1960, he wrote a paper** where he coined the term ‘Finite Element’
•In 1960, Argyris and Kelsey published a book*** which was a collection of their
papers published in 1954 and 1955.
*Stiffness and deflection analysis of complex structures, J. Aeronaut. Sci., 23, 805-823, 1956.
** The Finite Element Method in Plane Stress Analysis, Proceedings of 2 nd ASCE Conference on Electronic
Computation, Pittsburgh, PA, September 8-9, 1960. 44
***Energy Theorems and Structural Analysis, Butterworths, London
An introduction to Finite Element Method
45
A BRIEF HISTORY OF FEM
•Subsequently (late 60’s), mathematicians (re)discovered a paper by COURANT
(1943)*, he used triangular elements to solve vibration problems. In this paper, he
wrote « We imagine a mesh of triangles covering the domain… »
many mathematicians have claimed that this was the original discovery of the
method.
•In 1973, FEM was provided a rigorous foundation (Strang & Fix, An Analysis of the
Finite Element Method, Prentice Hall)
Strang on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WwgrAH-IMOk
•Mathematicians showed that (provided some conditions) for linear problems, finite
elements solutions converge to the exact solution of the PDE as the number of
elements is increased ( we also say that the mesh is refined)
Nowadays millions of engineers worldwide use the FEM to predict the behavior of
the structural, mechanical, thermal, material, electro-magnetical, biomechanical
and chemical systems! 50
*Variational methods for the solution of problems of equilibrium and vibrations. Bull. Am. Math. Soc., 42, 2165-86, 1943
An introduction to Finite Element Method
51
An introduction to Finite Element Method
•Now, FEM had led to tremendous reductions in design cycle time in many
industries
WHY?
52
An introduction to Finite Element Method
49
An introduction to Finite Element Method
52
An introduction to Finite Element Method
53
An introduction to Finite Element Method
SAMCEF Software
(Système d’Analyse des Milieux Continus par Eléments Finis) 58
An introduction to Finite Element Method
SAMCEF Software
(Système d’Analyse des Milieux Continus par Eléments Finis)
56
An introduction to Finite Element Method
57
An introduction to Finite Element Method
58
An introduction to Finite Element Method
59
An introduction to Finite Element Method
60
An introduction to Finite Element Method
61
An introduction to Finite Element Method
62
An introduction to Finite Element Method
63
An introduction to Finite Element Method
64
An introduction to Finite Element Method
64
Walloon Share in Civil Aircraft Parts
Fuselage parts
77
An introduction to Finite Element Method
78
An introduction to Finite Element Method
73
An introduction to Finite Element Method
74
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Courtesy of CENAERO
Courtesy of CENAERO
Courtesy of CENAERO
Courtesy of CENAERO
79
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Courtesy of CENAERO
Volume Mesh (12M nodes)
16mm
8mm
12 BL
(∆=0.5 mm)
(12 layers,
80
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Courtesy of CENAERO
81
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Courtesy of CENAERO
Instantaneous Vorticity Structures (12M)
82
Finite element mesh generation for biomedical applications
Surface meshes
V. d’Otreppe, LTAS-MN2L
An introduction to Finite Element Method
FIRST CONCLUSIONS
&
WARNINGS
90
An introduction to Finite Element Method
ESSENTIAL REMARKS
FE Modeling techniques are mostly deterministic: all correct geometrically,
physical, material, parameters must be given (INPUT of the problem). They
are generally not known.
Optimization and Sensitivity analysis can (should) be performed to cover
variations (uncertainties) on input data.
CAD should be connected easily to FEM. It is still a bottleneck!
Always adapt model to the details to want to capture. Keep your model as
simple as possible…. But not too simple!
Be aware of the limitations of the methodology.
91
An introduction to Finite Element Method
As proposed by the project As understood by the project As designed by the senior analysts As produced by the programmers As corrected by the Business
sponsor managers Consultants
As documented in the paperwork As installed at the user’s site What has been charged on the As technical support has been What the user actually needed.
invoice contracted
92
An introduction to Finite Element Method
93
An introduction to Finite Element Method
88
An introduction to Finite Element Method
•BECKER A.A.
An introductory guide to Finite Element analysis
Professional Engineering Publishing, 2004
•COOK R.D.
Concepts and Applications of Finite Element Analysis – Second Edition
John Wiley and Sons, 1981
•COOK R.D.
Finite Element Modeling for Stress Analysis 89
John Wiley and Sons, 1995
An introduction to Finite Element Method
•THOMSON E.G.
Introduction to the Finite Element Method
John Wiley and Sons, 2005
•AKIN J.E.
Finite Element Analysis for Undergraduates
Academic Press, 1986
•FELIPPA C.A.
Introduction to Finite Element Method
Ebook !!!
90
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Intermediate level:
•HUGHES T.J.R.
The Finite Element Method
Prentice-Hall, 1987
Recently reprinted by Dover.
It requires substantial mathematical expertise on the part of the reader.
•BATHE K.J.
Finite Element Procedures
Prentice Hall, 1996
•MACNEAL R.H.
Finite Elements: their design and performance
Marcel Dekker, 1994 91
An introduction to Finite Element Method
Mathematically oriented:
93