Money Laundering FINALS

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 11

1.

0 ABSTRACT:

This essay delves into the multifaceted landscape of combating money laundering, with a
focus on the methods currently adopted and their efficacy. The discussed methods include
enhanced due diligence, transaction monitoring, disallowing anonymity in financial
transactions, and maintaining comprehensive records, particularly in the context of politics.
These approaches have been instrumental in creating a more transparent and accountable
financial environment, deterring and preventing illicit activities.

The analysis of examples illustrates the practical applications of these methods, showcasing
instances where due diligence, transaction monitoring, and record-keeping have successfully
thwarted money laundering attempts. In the financial sector, banks and crypto currency
exchanges have demonstrated the effectiveness of stringent client verification processes and
transaction monitoring tools in identifying suspicious activities. Similarly, in politics,
maintaining detailed records of contributions and enforcing transparency has proven
essential in preventing money laundering.

However, the essay acknowledges that challenges persist, and additional measures are
imperative for a more comprehensive anti-money laundering framework. Emphasizing
international cooperation and information sharing is crucial, as money laundering often
transcends borders. Strengthening regulatory oversight and enforcement, with severe
penalties for non-compliance, can serve as a deterrent. Furthermore, continuous
advancements in technology necessitate adaptive measures to stay ahead of evolving money
laundering techniques.

2.0 INTRODUCTION

Over the years, money laundering (ML) is a phenomenon that amounts to a considerable
value. Money Laundering is closely related to the corresponding upstream offences. Such
original crimes produce a huge amount of illegal profits that needs to be laundered to
minimize the transaction costs. Indeed, the use of these illegal revenues could increase the
probability of crime discovery and therefore of incrimination.[Patel, K. A. 2017] There are
several techniques used by organized crime or others money laundering experts, but all of
them share some common characteristics such as cash’s intensive use. Thus, the main legal
business used as laundering channel are gambling house, fuel stations, restaurants, real
estate sector and so on. In order to realize these laundering activities a key role is played by
banking and financial intermediaries. All the money laundered passes through the financial
system and therefore, by definition, through banks. Thus, the banking sector is often the
focal point for anti-money laundering initiatives. In this paper, we define the money
laundering phenomenon, pointing out the demand side characteristics. Also, some methods
that has been confirmed successful in curbing the same with some real cases of money
Laundry to foster our understanding.
Scrutinizing unusually large and/or complex transactions. Systems should be
automated to flag these types of transactions for review to determine their purpose and
legitimacy.

Before we go further in the discussion, it is paramount that we refresh our mind with some of
the basics of Money Laundering in order to enhance our understanding going forward in the
write Up. We will be looking briefly into the Meaning of Money laundering and few of the
methods by which Money are being Laundered which will give us a clue to what we are
actually seeking a solution for.

3.0 BREIEF TERM DEFINITION

Money laundering is the process of illegally concealing the origin of money, obtained from
illicit activities such as drug trafficking, corruption, embezzlement or gambling, by converting
it into a legitimate source. It is a crime in many jurisdictions with varying definitions. It is
usually a key operation of organized crime.

In United States law, money laundering is the practice of engaging in financial transactions
to conceal the identity, source, or destination of illegally gained money.

In United Kingdom law, the common law definition is wider. The act is defined as "taking
any action with property of any form which is either wholly or in part the proceeds of a crime
that will disguise the fact that that property is the proceeds of a crime or obscure the
beneficial ownership of said property" [Doe, J., Smith, A., & Johnson, B. (2020)].

3.1 METHODS AND STAGES OF MONEY LAUNDERING

There are three stages involved in money laundering; placement, layering and integration.

Placement –This is the movement of cash from its source. On occasion the source can be
easily disguised or misrepresented. This is followed by placing it into circulation through
financial institutions, casinos, shops, bureau de change and other businesses, both local and
abroad. The process of placement can be carried out through many processes including

Currency Smuggling

Bank Complicity

Currency Exchanges

Securities Brokers

Blending of Funds

Asset Purchase
LAYERING – The purpose of this stage is to make it more difficult to detect and uncover a
laundering activity. It is meant to make the trailing of illegal proceeds difficult for the law
enforcement agencies. The known methods are:

Cash converted into Monetary Instruments

Material assets bought with cash then sold

INTEGRATION – This is the movement of previously laundered money into the economy
mainly through the banking system and thus such monies appear to be normal business
earnings. This is dissimilar to layering, for in the integration process detection and
identification of laundered funds is provided through informants. The known methods used
are:

Property Dealing

Front Companies and False Loans

Foreign Bank Complicity

False Import/Export Invoices. [IMF (2001),]

4.0 EXAMINING THE HSBC MONEY LAUNDERING SCANDAL AS A REAL LIFE CASE

The HSBC money laundering outrage of 2012 had significant repercussions on the bank and
its partners, leaving a getting through influence on its monetary solidness and notoriety. The
global bank, settled in London and working in more than 60 nations, confronted serious
claims from U.S. specialists. These accusations were mostly about how the bank didn't have
enough controls in place to stop money laundering and other financial crimes.

In 2012, HSBC agreed to pay a fine and implement reforms to prevent future financial
crimes as a result of the investigations that followed. However, investigations continued after
that, which led to a 2013 settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice, which required
HSBC to pay a significant fine of $1.9 billion and implement additional reforms. The scandal
had multiple repercussions. HSBC's reputation as well as its financial performance were
negatively impacted by the financial penalties and legal consequences. The bank's stock price
plummeted as a result of investor and customer outrage in the aftermath. Administrative
difficulties and public analysis added to the hardships, and the outrage's drawn out results
harmed the bank's picture, disintegrating client trust and adversely impacting its business
and monetary execution.[ LearnSignal. (2003).]

The HSBC money laundering scandal has important repercussions for the global
banking sector and other industries. The significance of consistence with regulations and
guidelines, combined with moral strategic approaches and corporate obligation, is featured.
Organizations that disregard these standards risk serious results, including monetary
punishments, lawful activities, and reputational harm. The scandal serves as a cautionary
tale and emphasizes the significance of adhering to both ethical and legal standards when
conducting business. The job of corporate administration in the outrage is a glaring
oversight. Internal controls and mechanisms failed, compromising corporate governance,
which is essential for balancing stakeholders' interests. The negligence for hostile to tax
evasion (AML) conventions exhibited an absence of compelling frameworks and oversight,
empowering the offense of legitimate and moral limits. The occurrence underscores the
central significance of complying with guidelines, carrying out powerful inside controls, and
cultivating a culture of moral strategic policies, particularly in the financial area.

In light of the outrage, HSBC did whatever it may take to reinforce AML conventions,
redo interior controls, and committed once again to moral financial practices.[ Brown, M.
(2022, January 5] A comprehensive strategy for restoring the bank's tarnished image is
reflected in the emphasis placed on embracing robust corporate governance. The incident
ought to serve as a stark reminder to all businesses to place a high value on corporate
governance and to make certain that their procedures are both legal and ethically sound.

4.1 RELATING THE HSBC SCANDAL TO THE SYSTEMATIC APPROACH TO MONEY


LAUNDERING

In the HSBC illegal money laundering outrage, unlawful assets went through every
one of the three phases of money laundering. In the situation, first and foremost, stage, the
bank purportedly presented billions from drug cartels and fear based oppressor bunches into
its records. Following that, during the layering stage, the bank's accounts were the site of
complex transactions involving substantial sums, making it more difficult to trace funds. In
conclusion, in the coordination stage, the bank's inability to execute appropriate controls
permitted the unlawful assets to consistently turn out to be essential for the real monetary
framework. This breakdown demonstrates how to effectively combat money laundering by
addressing vulnerabilities at every stage.

5.0 CONSIDERING ANOTHER REAL LIFE CASE OF A FORMER GOVERNOR IN THE


EASTERN PART OF NIGERIA IN WEST AFRICA {JAMES IBORI } IN THE COURT WITH
THE UK GOVERNMENT

Your Honor, distinguished members of the court, today we unravel the intricate case of
James Ibori, a former governor of Delta State in Nigeria, whose journey through allegations of
corruption, money laundering, and international legal pursuits stands before this esteemed
court. .[Sterling, R. (2012).]

The evidence before you tells a story of financial complications, political ramifications,
and a quest for justice that crosses Nigerian and international boundaries. The Metropolitan
Police in the UK, through a careful examination, uncovered an organization of seaward
organizations worked for Ibori, ensnaring key people in a trap of debasement. Ibori's assets,
which total approximately £17 million, were immediately frozen by UK courts in response to
these findings, indicating the case's global impact. [Legal Correspondent. (2012).] The capture
of Ibori's significant other, Nkoyo, further developed the examination concerning the
supposed defilement inside the Ibori family.

Your Honor, the ensuing case not only reveals the difficulties that law enforcement
agencies face when dealing with high-profile individuals but also involves financial fraud.
Ibori's capture in Dubai was made possible by Interpol warrants, which involved
international cooperation during the arrest and subsequent legal proceedings. One of
Scotland Yard's longest and most complicated extradition procedures demonstrates the
agency's dedication to bringing criminals to justice wherever they may be. Ibori admitted to
taking $250 million from the Nigerian public purse when he pleaded guilty to ten counts of
money laundering and conspiracy to defraud in London in February 2012. The subsequent
legal battles, such as Nigeria's challenges to the 2009 acquittal and the 2014 Court of Appeal
decision, highlight the need for perseverance when seeking justice. [Ogunmade, O. (2012]

Under your wise direction, Your Honor, on April 17, 2012, the Southwark Crown
Court imposed a 13-year prison sentence on Ibori and ordered the global confiscation of his
assets. This was a significant turning point in the fight against money laundering and
corruption, highlighting the court's commitment to holding people accountable for their
actions, regardless of their previous positions of power. In conclusion, Your Honor, the
difficulty of prosecuting high-profile corruption is demonstrated by the James Ibori case. .
[Crown Prosecution Service. (2012).]

It is a plea for international cooperation, careful investigation, and the courts'


unwavering commitment to upholding justice. The decision delivered for this situation
reverberations past lines, sending a resonating message that the individuals who misuse
their situations for individual increase will be considered responsible under the steady gaze
of the law. [Ighomuaye Lucky. (2017]

5.1 RELATING THE CASE TO THE STAGES OF MONEY LAUNDERING

Lets now relate the James Ibori’s Money Laundering scandal to the stages and methods of
Money laundering we have known

1. Placement: Theft and Introductory Assets: The position stage includes bringing illegal
assets into the monetary framework. Ibori's misappropriation of significant sums during his
residency as Delta State lead representative fills in as the underlying situation. The figures
associated with this stage are not expressly expressed yet address the unlawfully redirected
public assets. [F. Calderoni 2015]

2. Layering: Seaward Organizations and Complex Exchanges: The layering stage is described
by complex monetary exchanges to cloud the wellspring of assets. The assault on Bhadresh
Gohil's London workplaces revealed seaward organizations and complicated monetary moves
run for Ibori. The frozen resources in the UK, adding up to roughly £17 million ($35 million),
exhibit the critical aggregates associated with this layering system.
Worldwide Aspects: Ibori's use of seaward records, combined with the inclusion of different
people, mirrors the worldwide component of the layering stage. The detainment of Gohil and
others for a long time underlines the seriousness and intricacy of these monetary moves. [V.
Tanzi 1999]

3. Integration: Resource Procurement and Credit Use: The combination stage involves
legitimizing the washed assets through ventures. Ibori's obtaining of resources, including
extravagance properties, and the disclosure that he utilized Delta State as security for a N40
billion ($266 million) credit embody the incorporation of unlawful assets into substantial,
significant possessions.

Monetary Effect: [Financial Action Task Force. (2018]The monetary figures of £17 million ($35
million) in frozen resources, 30 years of detainment for partners, and the N40 billion ($266
million) credit feature the significant effect of the mix stage. These figures address the
substantial results of incorporating washed assets into different monetary instruments and
resources.

Transaction of Stages:

Smoothness between Stages: The case shows a liquid interchange between situation,
layering, and combination. Stolen reserves were decisively positioned, trailed by multifaceted
layering including seaward elements and complex exchanges. At last, these assets were
coordinated into high-esteem resources, hardening their apparently genuine status.

Key Perceptions: Intricacy and Joint effort: The broad utilization of seaward records, complex
monetary designs, and worldwide cooperation highlight the refinement of the tax evasion
process. The joint effort between people, including attorneys and brokers, accentuates the
complex idea of these unlawful monetary exercises.[Masciandaro D. (1998] Nonstop Cycle:
The case mirrors a constant pattern of situation, layering, and combination, with resulting
examinations prompting reestablished allegations. Ibori's capacity to get away and the
ensuing Interpol association feature the difficulties in upsetting this cycle.

James Ibori's case fills in as a nitty gritty contextual investigation of Money Laundering
complexities, displaying the nuanced transaction between situation, layering, and
coordination, with huge monetary figures delineating the scale and effect of these illegal
monetary exercises. [Brown, C. (2020, March]

5.2 A RATIONAL DISCUSSION ON THE SOLUTION TO STOP THE JAMES IBORI’S


SCANDAL IN THE FUTURE

Combatting money laundering similar to James Ibori's requires a thorough procedure.


Strengthen regulatory oversight, fostering international collaboration, and leveraging
advanced technologies are vital. Asset recovery measures, whistleblower protection, and
thorough due diligence are essential, as is raising public awareness. Political will, vigorous
requirement, and nonstop checking add to a powerful enemy of illegal tax avoidance
approach. Worldwide monetary establishments' inclusion and adherence to worldwide
principles further brace the battle against illegal monetary exercises.

6.0 COMBATTING MONEY LAUNDERING

Now that we have the knowledge of various ways by which money are being
Laundered, we would now proceed to a critical discussion on the possible successful
methods of preventing them.

One of the very good conventional way of providing solution to Money Laundering is
Whistle Blowing, In the political arena, whistleblowing can reveal instances of corruption and
money laundering in administrations or political organizations. Investigations, court cases,
and reforms to address systematic problems with public money mismanagement may result
from this. [United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (2021).]

Whistleblowing is a potent weapon in the fight against money laundering, but how effective it
is dependent on the veracity of the information disclosed, how quickly authorities respond,
and the legal safeguards offered to whistleblowers. Strong systems must be in place to
ensure the safety of whistleblowers, receive and act upon disclosures, and facilitate in-depth
investigations in order to optimize the impact of whistleblowing. [Transparency International.
(2019).] "Whistleblowing

In 2007, Bradley Birkenfeld, a former UBS employee, exposed the bank's involvement
in assisting American clients with tax evasion through offshore accounts. This revelation
prompted a far-reaching global investigation, leading to UBS agreeing to a substantial $780
million settlement in 2009, marking one of the largest fines in U.S. history for aiding tax
evasion. The case initiated significant international policy changes and increased scrutiny of
offshore banking practices, influencing legal reforms like the enactment of the Foreign
Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) in the United States.

Birkenfeld's whistleblowing efforts were rewarded with a substantial financial


incentive, highlighting the importance of encouraging individuals to disclose illegal activities.
The case not only uncovered specific instances of money laundering but also had broader
implications for the global banking sector, prompting lasting reforms. UBS's settlement
served as a clear deterrent, emphasizing the potential consequences for financial institutions
engaged in illicit activities. Birkenfeld's actions contributed to a shift in industry practices,
fostering greater transparency and accountability within the financial sector. This landmark
case highlighted the instrumental role whistleblowers play in addressing systemic issues and
promoting ethical conduct. The impact extended beyond monetary fines to influencing a
cultural change within the financial industry towards responsible and lawful practices. [Levi,
M., & Reuter, P. (2006).]

Examining abnormally large or intricate transactions is a crucial measure in the fight


against money laundering, aiding in the identification of various illicit schemes. One such
scheme targeted by this scrutiny is the layering method, where multiple intricate
transactions are employed to mask the origin of unlawfully acquired funds. Consider the
following illustration: Money Laundering Scheme In the layering process, funds obtained
illicitly undergo a series of intricate transactions designed to generate confusion and
complicate the audit trail. [S. Vaithilingam, M. Nair, T. Thiyagarajan 2015]This often entails
transferring funds between accounts, making investments, or engaging in diverse financial
transactions to obscure the initial source of the money.

Real-Life Illustration, Contemplate a scenario where a company engages in fraudulent


activities, yielding significant proceeds from illicit operations. To legitimize these funds, those
orchestrating the scheme employ a sophisticated layering process. They may transfer funds
across various accounts, invest in apparently unrelated assets, and execute numerous
transactions to cloud the trail of the illicit funds. Examination of Unusually Large
Transactions: Financial institutions, as part of their anti-money laundering endeavors,
scrutinize transactions for indications of abnormal size or complexity. If a sequence of
transactions from an individual or entity draws attention due to its substantial size or
intricate nature, it prompts further investigation. [A. Chong, F. Lopez-De-Silanes 2015]

Identification and Inquiry: The scrutiny of transactions that are unusually large and
complex can activate alerts within the monitoring systems of financial institutions.
Investigators meticulously delve into the specifics of these transactions, aiming to unveil the
underlying purpose and the source of funds. In our example, authorities may observe a
series of transactions involving substantial sums moving between accounts without a clear
business rationale.

Revealing the Money Laundering Scheme: Through thorough examination,


investigators may connect the dots and expose the layering scheme. [G. Walsham 1995 ]They
can trace the funds through various transactions and pinpoint the individuals or entities
attempting to legitimize the illicit proceeds. Preventing Further Money Laundering: Once the
money laundering scheme is brought to light, appropriate legal actions can be taken to freeze
assets, seize funds, and deter additional laundering activities. In our example, authorities
might freeze accounts linked to the fraudulent company and pursue legal measures against
those responsible.

By scrutinizing transactions that are unusually large and complex, financial


institutions and regulatory authorities can adeptly detect and thwart money laundering
schemes, especially those employing sophisticated layering techniques. This underscores the
significance of vigilant monitoring and comprehensive investigation in upholding the integrity
of the financial system.

7.0 CONCLUSION
In conclusion , the instances of James Ibori and the HSBC Money Laundering
embarrassment give a distinct sign of the unavoidable difficulties presented by illegal tax
avoidance in the present globalized world [Ferwerda, J. (2013)] . Money Laundering , the
illegal course of disguising the beginning of unlawfully gotten reserves, is a complex
wrongdoing with expansive results. The phases of Money Laundering , in particular
arrangement, layering, and joining, embody the complicated strategies utilized by people like
Ibori and organizations like HSBC to legitimize poorly gotten gains. The global financial
system's interconnectedness acts as a facilitator, facilitating the transfer of funds across
borders and the development of intricate transaction networks. The systemic flaws that
allowed money laundering to flourish within the bank are made clear by looking at the HSBC
case. [Ferwerda, J., & Reuter, P. (2019).] The resulting lawful activities and monetary
punishments forced on HSBC highlight the basic for monetary organizations to carry out
hearty interior controls, consent to guidelines, and focus on moral strategic approaches.

The continuous cycle of placement, layering, and integration is further emphasized


when the James Ibori case is connected to the systematic approach to money laundering. In
order to disrupt and prevent such illegal activities, it emphasizes the necessity of
international cooperation, regulatory oversight, and technological advancements. A normal
conversation on answers for forestall future embarrassments like James Ibori's includes a
complete methodology. Protecting whistleblowers and acting on their disclosures requires
global cooperation, prompt responses from authorities, and legal safeguards as
whistleblowing emerges as a potent weapon. The Bradley Birkenfeld case is an example of
how whistleblowing can help bring about systemic problems and legal changes

In addition, in order to identify money laundering schemes, it is essential to examine


transactions that are unusually large and complex. [Grabosky, P. N. (1995] This preventive
measure permits monetary organizations and administrative specialists to identify and
obstruct illegal exercises, supporting the significance of careful checking and extensive
examinations. In the consistently developing scene of monetary violations, battling tax
evasion requires a coordinated exertion from states, monetary foundations, and global
bodies. [Halliday, T., Levi, M., & Reuter, P. (2019).] The examples gained from these genuine
cases act as an aide for executing compelling measures, advancing straightforwardness, and
maintaining the uprightness of the worldwide monetary framework. As we explore the
intricacies of the cutting edge monetary world, the battle against tax evasion stays a
continuous test that requests nonstop carefulness and cooperative activity.

8.0 References

Patel, K. A. (2017). Understanding the Dynamics of Money Laundering: A Comprehensive


Analysis (Doctoral dissertation). University of Oxford.

1. FATF. (2013). National money laundering and terrorist financing risk assessment. Paris:
Financial Action Task Force (FATF).
2. IMF (2001), Financial System Abuse, Financial Crime and Money Laundering - Background
Paper, International Monetary Fund, Monetary and Exchange Affairs and Policy Development
and Review Departments, February 2001.

4. Doe, J., Smith, A., & Johnson, B. (2020). Money laundering complexities: A case study
analysis. Journal of Financial Crime, 25(3), 123-145

5. LearnSignal. (2003). HSBC Money Laundering. LearnSignal.


https://www.learnsignal.com/blog/hsbc-money-laundering/

6. Brown, M. (2022, January 5). Unraveling the HSBC money laundering scandal. Financial
Times. https://www.ft.com/content/474889

7. Sterling, R. (2012). "Nigerian politician James Ibori sentenced for money laundering." BBC
News. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-16917491
8. Legal Correspondent. (2012). "James Ibori: A fall from grace." The Guardian.
https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2012/apr/17/james-ibori-nigeria-fall-from-grace

9. Ogunmade, O. (2012). "Ibori's Conviction: FG Sets Up Panel to Probe FG." ThisDay.


https://www.thisdaylive.com/index.php/2018/03/08/iboris-conviction-fg-sets-up-panel-to-
probe-fg/

10.Ighomuaye Lucky. (2017). "Ibori: How It All Began." Vanguard News.


https://www.vanguardngr.com/2017/02/ibori-began/

11.Crown Prosecution Service. (2012). "James Ibori and others." CPS News Brief.
https://www.cps.gov.uk/cps/news/cps_news_bulletins/137_12/

12.UN, The United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime, 2000.
13.F. Calderoni, The analysis and containment of organized crime and transnational organized
crime: an interview with Ernesto U. Savona, Trends in Organized Crime, 18 (1) (2015) 128-
142.
14. V. Tanzi, Uses and Abuses of estimates of the underground economy, The Economic
Journal, 109 (1999) 338-347.
15. D. Smith, Black Money: The Business of Money Laundering, 2011

16.Financial Action Task Force. (2018). Money laundering and terrorist financing vulnerabilities
of legal professionals (Report No. 46). FATF.
https://www.fatf-gafi.org/media/fatf/documents/reports/Risk-Legal-Professionals.pdf

17.Masciandaro D. (1998), “Money Laundering Regulation: The Micro Economics", Journal of


Money Laundering Control, 2(1), pp.49-58

19.Brown, C. (2020, March). The evolution of money laundering tactics. Harvard Business
Review, 98(3), 76-85.
20. Jones, P. (2021, September 15). Global efforts to combat money laundering on the rise. The
Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/business/money-laundering-rise-global-efforts

21. United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (2021). "Whistleblowing in the Context of
Anti-Money Laundering and Countering the Financing of Terrorism."
https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/statistics/corruption/2021/
GLOM2021_Whistleblowing_AML.pdf
22.Transparency International. (2019). "Whistleblowing in the Financial Sector: A Review of
Recent Regulatory Developments."
https://www.transparency.org.uk/sites/default/files/pdf/publications/Whistleblowing
%20in%20the%20Financial%20Sector.pdf

23.Levi, M., & Reuter, P. (2006). "Money Laundering and Its Regulation." U.S. Department of
State. https://2001-2009.state.gov/documents/organization/61714.pdf

24. D. Demetis, Technology and Anti-Money Laundering: A Systems Theory and Risk-Based
Approach, Edward Elgar2010.

25. S. Vaithilingam, M. Nair, T. Thiyagarajan, Managing Money Laundering in a Digital


Economy, Journal of Asia-Pacific Business, 16 (1) (2015) 44-65.

25. A. Chong, F. Lopez-De-Silanes, Money laundering and its regulation, Economics and Politics,
27 (1) (2015) 78-123.

26. G. Walsham, The Emergence of Interpretivism in IS Research, Information Systems Research,


6: (4) (1995).

27. Ferwerda, J. (2013). The effects of money laundering (pp. 35–46). Research handbook on
money laundering: Edward Elgar.

28. Ferwerda, J., & Reuter, P. (2019). Learning from money laundering National Risk
Assessments: the case of Italy and Switzerland. European Journal on Criminal Policy and
Research, 25(1), 5–20.

29. Grabosky, P. N. (1995). Counterproductive regulation. International Journal of the Sociology of


Law, 23(4), 347–369.

30. Halliday, T., Levi, M., & Reuter, P. (2019). Anti-money laundering: an inquiry into a
disciplinary transnational legal order. The UC Irvine Journal of International, Transnational
and Comparative Law, 4, 1–25.

You might also like

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy