4) Think Again
4) Think Again
4) Think Again
Superforecasters change their mind twice as much as other forecasters before making a final prediction.
College students who reconsider their answers before handing in an exam and have more eraser marks on their exam score
higher than students who do not rethink their first answer.
The highest‐ranked U.S. presidents in history (according to historians) displayed more intellectual curiosity and revised more of
their original policies.
Many of us fail to “rethink” our beliefs and opinions because we get stuck in overconfidence cycles: 1. Form an opinion that feels right. 2.
Seek information to support that opinion. 3. Feel validated. 4. Proudly express our opinions.
Overconfidence cycles strengthen every time we preach, prosecute, and politick. When stuck in any of these three modes, feeling right
becomes more important than being right, and we stop learning.
Adam Grant says (paraphrased), "When we become so wrapped up in preaching that we're right, prosecuting others
who are wrong, and politicking for support, we don't bother to rethink our own views and get trapped in an overconfidence cycle.” To
get ourselves out of an overconfidence cycle, we need to think like scientists.
“In preacher mode, changing our minds is a mark of moral weakness; in scientist mode, it’s a sign of intellectual integrity. In prosecutor
mode, allowing ourselves to be persuaded is admitting defeat; in scientist mode, it’s a step toward the truth. In politician mode, we flip‐
flop in response to carrots and sticks; in scientist mode, we shift in the face of sharper logic and stronger data.” – Adam Grant
Start thinking like a scientist by actively seeking out disconfirming information and getting curious when you experience doubt. When
doubt turns to curiosity, you have an opportunity to discover new ideas and experience the joy of learning. By learning and improving upon
your ideas, you gain confidence in your capacity to learn while remaining humble about what you didn't know and what you still don't
know ‐ this is called confident humility.
One way to keep the rethinking cycle going is to update a note on your phone with two lists: “Things I don't know” and “Things I've
learned recently.” Another way to stay in the rethinking cycle is to listen to podcasts by people who make you think even if you disagree
with what they think.
“Learn something new from each person you meet. Everyone knows more than you about something. Ask
people what they’ve been rethinking lately, or start a conversation about times you’ve changed your mind in
the past year.” – Adam Grant
www.ProductivityGame.com