Intellectual Property Laws
Intellectual Property Laws
Assignment of copyright
Owner of existing work or prospecting owner of future work may assigns
either fully or partly or generally with limitations. However in case of
future work assignment will not be effective unless the work comes into
existence.
Assignee includes legal representatives of the assignee in case of death.
Assignment should be in writing and clearly mentioned the terms of the
assignment including territorial limits and duration, royalty payable etc.
If no terms are mentioned it will be taken as 5 years. If no territorial
limits mentioned it will work within India.
3/1/22
Compulsory License (in works withheld from public)
During the term of copy right in Indian work which has been published
or performed in India any person can complained to the Copyright Board that:
(a)Refusal to republish or allowing it to republish or refusal to allow
communication to public by broadcast is withholding from the public,
the copyright board may after hearing the other party grant compulsory
license for publication of such work with appropriate compensation to
the author.
Where two or more persons make similar applications, Copyright Board
may grant license to one of them who can better serve the purpose in
the interest of general public.
Compulsory license in unpublished Indian work
When the author is dead/ unknown/ untraceable any person may apply
to Copyright Board to publish the work or a translation of the work in
any language.
The applicant shall publish his proposal in a newspaper in English and
also in a language in which it intends to translate.
Any royalty received as determined by copyright board shall be
deposited in a public Account of India which can be given to the
author/his legal representative if found or identified.
If the original author is dead, and the publication of work is national
interest, Central Government may require the successor/legal
representative to publish the same.
Translations (License)
1. Any person may apply to copyright board after a period 7 years from
first publication.
2. Any applications for translation can be made after 3 years form the first
publication for the purpose of teaching and research. However, if such
translation is not in the language of developed country the application
can be made after one year.
International copyright
Patentable invention
As per the Indian Patents Act, 1970 invention means any new or
useful -
Art, process, method or manner of manufacture
ii) Machine, apparatus or other article.
iii) Substance produced by manufacture and includes any new and
useful improvement of any of them and alleged invention.
What cannot be patented....
Invention which is frivolous and obviously contrary to natural
laws.
Invention intended for or use for commercial exploitation is
contrary to public order.
Mere discovery of scientific principle.
The mere discovery of new article or new use of a known
substance.
Substance obtained by mere admixture or aggregation.
Combination of components resulting in new result or old result in
better, more or expeditors or economical manner.
A method or agriculture or horticulture.
Re-arrangement or duplication
Process of medical treatment of humans or animals or plants.
Computer program.(IBM and Borough’s Corporation case)
Literary or artistic work.
Invention based on traditional knowledge.
Invention relating to atomic energy.
Eligibility for application for a patent
o Any person being the true and first inventor of an invention or his
assignee/ on death by legal representative can apply alone or
jointly with any other person
o Applicant of an application in a basic convention country can apply
by himself or through his assignee.(PCT)
Stages of obtaining a patent
o i) Submission of application accompanied by either a provisional
or complete specification.
o ii) Examination of application and acceptance.
o iii) Advertisement in the Patent Gazette.
o except;
o secrecy direction
o abandoned
o Withdrawn before 3 months.
o (iv) Examination of application
o v) Opposition to the grant of patent, if any.
o vi) Grant and sealing of the patent.
Specification and when the it is to be filed
A patent specification is a technical document describing the
invention. A specification may be either provisional or complete.
Provisional specification gives the initial description of an
invention when the application is filed. It is to fix the priority date
since Indian patent law is based on ‘first to apply’ principle, the
inventor who first secures his invention against a similar claim.
The provisional application closely describes the invention and
does not set out the claims that the applicant desires.
A patent specification can be prepared by the applicant himself or his
registered and authorized agent. It comprises of the title of the
invention indicating its technical field, prior art, draw backs in the prior
art, the solution provided by the inventor to obviate the drawbacks of
the prior art, a concise but sufficient description of the invention and its
usefulness, drawings (if any) and details of best method of its working.
at least one claim defining the scope of the invention for which
protection is sought for.
All the patent applications are kept secret up to 18 months from the
date of filing or priority date whichever is earlier and thereafter they are
published in the Official Journal of the Patent Office available on the IPO
website. Early publication is possible within a period of one month
provided the invention contained thereon does not relate to atomic
energy or defense purpose.
The complete specification shall be filed within 12 months of the filling
of the provisional specification and if such complete specification is not
filed within the aforesaid 12 months the application shall be deemed to
be abandoned.
After filing the application for the grant of patent, a request for examination
is required to be made by the applicant or usually, the First Examination
Report is issued and the applicant is given an opportunity to correct the
deficiencies in order to meet the objections raised in the said report.
When all the requirements are met, the patent is granted and notified in
the Patent office Journal. However before the grant of patent and after the
publication of application, any person can make a representation for pre-
grant opposition.
Patent right comes to thw applicant opn granting and not before.
Complete specification
o A complete specification gives full and sufficient description of an
invention i.e.
o a full and particular description of the invention and its operation
or use
o method of his invention
o scope of invention
o Designs and drawings.
o The complete specification shall be filed within 12 months of the
filling of the provisional specification and if such complete
specification is not filed within the aforesaid 12 months the
application shall be deemed to be abandoned. andoned.
Conditions for patent
All patents are subject to certain conditions. These conditions are
as follows: (it will not be construed as infringement)
1. Government can make, or import any machine, apparatus etc. for
which patent is granted/ application pending, for its own use.
2. If sufficient record show that the Govt. has done research on any
application pending before patent office before filing of complete
specification, Govt. can also use the same invention without
payment of royalty.
3. Any machine, apparatus, process etc. can be made or used by any
person merely for research or experiment.
4. Government can import any medicine or drug for its own use or
for distribution in any dispensary, hospital etc. as specified by
Central Government, with regard to public service carried out by
such hospital, dispensary, or medical institution.
International patent
o Territorial right-within India; no worldwide patent is available.
o Application in other countries can be made within 12 months of
application in India and get the same in that country. However,
some of the offices in India can receive application for other
countries under the Patent Cooperation Treaty(PCT)
Legal action for 'infringement of patent' during the pendency of a patent
application
It is not possible to initiate legal action against the infringers during the
pendency of patent application.
It will take minimum of 4 to 5 years for examination of patent application
and then only it will be decided whether to grant a patent or not. Till then it
will be called as 'invention' only. Until the statutory right is conferred upon
the applicant for his invention, the question of infringement will not arise.
There are no common law rights like that of 'passing off' in trademark
matters for the patent applicants.
Working of patent and compulsory licensing:
o Patent is for use and not for hoarding or exploitation. Patents are
granted to encourage inventions and to secure that the inventions
are worked within India on a commercial scale and to fullest
extent that is reasonably practical without undue delay.
o If the patented invention is not available to public at reasonable
price or that reasonable requirements of public are not fulfilled or
if patented inventions is not worked within the territorial limits of
India, then the Controller can order the patent holder to grant a
license to other person upon such terms and conditions as may be
fixed by the Controller.
o Application for such compulsory licensing can be made only after
three years from the date of sealing.
Term of patent
o The term of the patent is meant for duration of the validity of the
patent.
o The term of patent in respect of all inventions will be TWENTY
years from the date of patent (i.e. date of filing complete
specification).
o In case of international application, from the date it is filed in the
home country
Rights of patentee and transfer of rights
o Right to exploit
o Right to license: performing on behalf of the owner- no transfer of
interest.
o Assign: transfer of interest full or in part
o surrender
o sue for infringement/ specific performance of contract/recovery
of royalty
Infringement of patent
Duration of the trade mark registration. Its renewal, lapse and restoration.
Duration of registered trade mark is 10 years, and can be renewed on
payment of prescribed fees.
Application for renewal to be made before six months of expiry of the
registration, on expiry of the registration, Registrar to send notice of
expiry. Registrar shall not remove the mark from the register if the fee
and surcharge is paid within six months of grace period.
Restoration possible even after expiry one year, subject to conditions
and limitations by the Registrar. The marks shall be deemed to be
registered mark for the purpose acceptance any application otherwise.
In order to get registration, application has to be made after searching,
advertisement for opposition has to be given.
Any person within 3 months from the advertisement, Re-advertisement
shall give a notice of opposition with a prescribe fees, which shall be
served to the applicant and the applicant shall within two months of
receipts of such notice make a counter statement, failing which is
deemed that he has abandoned the application.
The Registrar shall register the trademark when there is no opposition
within the prescribed time and even after opposition, the decision has
gone in favour of the applicant, unless there is any contrary direction
from the Central Government.
Validity of trademark registration outside India
Certain countries, do recognize a trademark registration in India as a
basis for registering the mark in those countries. The laws of each
country regarding registration must be consulted.
Falsifying : deviating a popular mark
falsely applying: applying a mark which do not belong to the trader/
manufacturer
Absolute grounds for refusal…
When the trade mark is not capable of distinction.
When the trade mark consists of any work or, indication which may
serve in trade to designate any kind/ quality/ quantity/ intended
purpose, geographical origin or time of production etc.
Geographical names disallowed:
India(electrical fan) , simla(tobacco) Himalayan(tea/coffee),
Geographical names allowed:
Italia(motor car)magnolia(metal)
When the trade mark has become customary in the current language
other than well-known trade mark.
When the trade mark proposed to be registered is of such nature so as
to deceive public or cause confusion.
If the trade mark contains any matter which will hurt religious
sentiment.
If the trade mark contains scandalous or obscene matters.
If the trade mark is prohibited under Emblems and Name (Prevention of
Improper use) Act, 1950
Protection available for trademarks
There are two forms of legal protection that are available for
trademarks. Under the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958, once
the trademark is registered, infringement can be easily established.
In case of unregistered marks and marks which are not registerable, the
only form of protection is the common law remedy of passing off.
Trademark law protects the right of the owner of a mark to use marks
that distinguish his goods from others and to prevent others from using
marks that are likely to cause confusion
Accordingly, in order to establish infringement with regard to a
registered trademark, it is necessary only to establish that the infringing
mark is identical or deceptively similar to the registered mark and no
further proof is required.
Infringement
The following acts amount to infringement of a trade mark:
Use of any mark, in course of trade which is identical or deceptive to any
other registered Trademark.
Deception as to goods
Deception as to trader
Deception as to trade connection
Lakme: like-me
Mitaso: metashow
Fevicol :fxacol
Colgate:collegiate
If any person uses a registered trademark of any other person as his
trade name or part of his trade name.
Use of trade mark means
Affixing of the concerned trade mark into goods or packages.
Exhibiting any goods with such trademark.
Importing or exporting any goods with such trademarks.
Using of the mark in office stationary, merchandising items or
advertisement in case there is any damage to the reputation.
Acts not constituting to infringement
The use of a sign is in good faith and for the purpose of indicating
quality, quantity, purpose, value or geographic region of goods and
services
The use is in respect of part of trademark that is disclaimed
Where a court believes that the infringer would have obtained
registration of the mark that it uses had the infringer applied for it and
assuming that the infringer’s mark is the same as the registered.
Persons eligible for sueing for infringement of a registered trade mark
◦ The proprietor of a registered trade mark
◦ The legal heirs or predecessor of the proprietor of a registered
trade mark
◦ The registered user can bring a suit for infringement.
◦ A foreign proprietor can sue in India provided the mark is
registered in India.
◦ An assignee of a registered trade mark can bring a suit for
infringement before the registration of the assignment is effected
because registration of assignment is not a condition precedent to
suing.
Persons who can be sued for infringement of a registered trade mark
The person who infringes the trade mark can be sued.
If the infringement is committed by the servant then the master can be
sued irrespective of the fact whether the servant acted with / without
the knowledge of the master. Even if the servant acted against the
orders of the master then also the master will be sued.
An agent of the principal who infringes can also be sued. Therefore a
person who prints the infringing label can be sued.
Reliefs granted by Court in case of infringement
In case of suit for infringement the Court can grant the following
reliefs:
◦ Injunction restraining the use of the trade mark
◦ Damages or an account of profit
◦ Order for destruction of the infringed marks
The reliefs granted by the Court are discretionary
The Trade Marks Registry