Chapter5 - Working Capital FInance
Chapter5 - Working Capital FInance
4
Cash management and
4
Learning objectives
Oncompletion
ofthischapter
youshould
beableto:
Syllabus
reference
Managementofinventories,
receivables,
payables andcash(continued)
• Explain
thevarious
reasons forholding
cash,anddiscussandapplythe C2(f)
useofrelevant
techniquesinmanaging cash,including:
- preparingcashflowforecaststodeterminefuture
cashflowsandcash
balances
- assessingthebenefits
ofcentralised
treasurymanagementandcash
control
- cashmanagement models, suchastheBaumol andtheMiller-Orr
G H
models
- investing
short-term.
Determining
working capitalneedsandfunding strategies
• Describe
anddiscuss thekeyfactors indeterminingworkingcapital C3(b)
funding
strategies,
including:
- thedistinction
between permanent andfluctuatingcurrentassets
- therelative
costandriskofshort-term andlong-term finance
- thematching principle
- therelative
costsandbenefits ofaggressive,conservative
and
matchingfunding policies
- management attitudestorisk,previous
fundingdecisions
&
organisation
size.
4
Exam context
Thischaptercoversissuesrelatingtoliquidity
andthefinance ofworkingcapital,whicharepart
ofSectionC ofthesyllabus (Working capitalmanagement)andcompletes thissyllabussection.
Likethepreviouschapter,thissyllabusareaisexaminableinallsections
oftheexamandexam
questionswon’tjustinvolve
calculations(eginsectionC partofanexamquestion mayaskyouto
discusstypesofworking capitalfunding strategies
ortoexplainthemeaning ofa numericalcash
flowanalysis
thatyouhaveperformed).
Page 93 of 641
q
4
Chapter overview
Workingcapital finance
Cashmanagement Mathematical
models
Motives
forholding
cash Baumol
Cash
flow
forecasting Miller-Orr
Easing
cash
shortages
Managing
cashsurpluses
Working
capitalfinance Treasury
management
G
Asset
types Functions H
Aggressive
financing
strategy Centralised
Conservative
financing
strategy Decentralised
72 Financial
Management
(FM)
Page 94 of 641
q
1 Cash management
PER alert
Performance objective
10requires
youto‘prepare
andmonitoranorganisation’s
cashflow,
creditfacilities
andadvise
onappropriate
actions’.
Thischapter
covers
themanagement of
cashandcashflowforecasts.
easilybeconverted intocash
(discussedinsection 1.4).
However,
holding
cash(ornearequivalents
tocash)hasa cost:thelossofprofitswhichwould
otherwise
havebeenobtained
byusingthefundsinanother way.So,asever,thefinancial
manager
musttrytobalance
liquidity
withprofitability.
1.2 Cash flow forecasting
Cashflowforecast:
Adetailed
forecast
ofcashinflows
andoutflows
incorporating
both
KEY revenue
andcapitalitems.
TERM
Cashflowforecasts
willbeprepared
continuously
during
theyearandwillallowa business
to
planhowtodealwithexpectedcashflowsurpluses
orshortages.
1.2.1 Formatofcashflowforecast
Acashflowforecastwilltabulateestimatedfuture cashreceiptsandpayments insucha wayas
toshowtheforecastcashbalance ofa businessatdefined intervals.
Thereisno‘set’format
that
youarerequiredtousebutitissensible tofollowtheseguidelines:
(a) Havetwoseparate sections,oneforcashinflows andoneforcashoutflows
(b) Don’treproduce
theforecast separatelyforeachtimeperiod (instead
adda newcolumn for
eachtimeperiodbeinganalysed)
(c) Finish
eachcolumn bynetting offthecashflowfortheperiod andaddingittocashbrought
forwardtocreatea finalcashflowcarriedforward figure.
Thiscanbedoneeasilyintheexam
usingthespreadsheet functionality
availableintheconstructiveresponseworkspace.
4:Cashmanagement
andworking
capital
finance 73
Page 95 of 641
q
Hereisanexample
ofa cashforecast,
illustrating
a sensible
format.
CASHFORECASTFORTHETHREEMONTHS
ENDED31MARCH20X1
January February March
Cashreceipts
Salesreceipts
(W1) X X X
Issueofshares X
Cashpayments
Purchase
payments
(W2) (X) (X) (X)
Dividends/Taxes (X)
Purchase
ofnon-current
assets (X)
Wages (X) (X) (X)
Cashsurplus/deficit
formonth X (X) X
Cashbalance,
beginning X X (X)
Interest
onopening
cash
balance X X (X)
Cashbalance,
ending X (X) X
Working
January February March
G
1. Timing
ofsalesreceipts H
Revenue
fromsales1monthago(assuming
1- FromDec FromJan FromFeb
monthcreditperiod) sales sales sales
2. Timing
ofsupplier
payments
Supplier
invoices
from2 months
ago(assuming FromNov FromDec FromJan
2-monthcreditperiod) purchases purchases purchases
Examfocus point
Intheexamyouwillneedtothinkcarefully
abouttheexpectedtimingofreceipts
and
paymentsofcashduringtheperiodandwhether
a costisa cashitemegdepreciation.
Activity1:Cash forecast
Benisa wholesalerofmotorcycle
helmets.
Itis1January20X2.
Creditsalesinthelastquarter
of20X1wereasfollows:
Helmets
October 2,000
November 2,000
December 2,500
74 Financial
Management
(FM)
Page 96 of 641
q
Hiscreditsalesinthefirstquarter
willbeasfollows:
Helmets
January 3,000
February 5,000
March 4,500
Customers aregiven60days’creditandtheaverage sellingpriceis$10,a priceriseof$1is
planned inFebruary. Hisbiggestcustomer,Mickster,
isgivena 2%discount forpayingcashwhen
thesaleismade.Mickster isplanning
tobuy150helmets inJanuaryand250Helmets inMarch.
ThesalestoMickster areinadditiontothosecreditsalesstatedabove.
Purchases (anaverage of30days’credit) are$4perhelmet. Benplanstobuyinthehelmets a
month inadvance ofsellingthem.Totaloverheadsare$2,000permonth; thisincludes$400
depreciationandwagesof$1,000.Allotheroverheads arepaidforaftera creditperiod of30
days.
Benplanstoinjecta further $5,000ofhisownmoney intothebusiness inMarchtohelptobuy
non-current assetsfor$29,000.Theseassetswillbedepreciatedoverfiveyears.
Opening cashflowisnegative $4,550whichisclosetoBen’soverdraft limitof$5,500.
Required
Prepare
a monthly
cashflowforecast
forthefirstquarter
of20X2andcomment
onyourresults.
Solution
G H
4:Cashmanagement
andworking
capital
finance 75
Page 97 of 641
q
1.2.2 Workingcapitalmovements
Ifa questionprovides
youwithoperating cashflowsandworking capitalmovements,youmay
berequired toadjust
theoperating cashflowsforthecashflow impactofworkingcapital
movements tocalculate
monthly cashflows.
Takingthepreviousactivity,
ifyouhadbeengiventheoperating cashflowsinJanuaryasbeing
$17,270andhadbeentoldthat,during Januaryreceivablesareforecasttoincrease
by$10,000
(meaning that$10,000ofrevenue isdeferredtothenextperiod),
tradepayablesareforecast
to
increaseby$7,400(meaning that$7,400ofcostisdeferred tothenextperiod)andinventory
is
forecasttoriseby$7,400(incurring $7,400ofcostinthisperiod);
thenthenetcashflowin
G
Januarycouldbecalculated as: H
$
Original
operating
cashflows 17,270
Lessincrease
inreceivables (10,000)
Plusincrease
inpayables 7,400
Lessincrease
ininventory (7,400)
NetcashflowforJanuary 7,270
Essentialreading
SeeChapter 4 Section
1oftheEssential
Reading,
available
inthedigitaledition
oftheWorkbook,
forfurther
practice
onthisarea.
TheEssential
readingisavailable
asanAppendix
ofthedigitaledition
oftheWorkbook.
76 Financial
Management
(FM)
Page 98 of 641
q
Forexample, ifa company’s policyistoreplace company carseverytwoyears,butthecompany
isfacinga cashshortage, itmightdecidetoreplace carseverythreeyears.
(b) Accelerating cashinflows whichwouldotherwise beexpected ina laterperiod.
Itmightbepossible toencourage creditcustomers topaymorequickly byofferingdiscounts
for
earlier
payment. Thiswascovered inChapter 3.
(c) Reversing pastinvestment decisions bysellingassetspreviously acquired
Someassetsarelesscrucialtoa business thanothers.Ifcashflowproblems aresevere,
theoption
ofselling
investments orpropertymighthavetobeconsidered. Saleandleaseback ofproperty
couldalsobeconsidered.
(d) Negotiating a reductionincashoutflows topostpone orreduce payments
Thereareseveral waysinwhichthiscouldbedone:
• Longer creditmightbetakenfromsuppliers. Suchanextension ofcreditwouldhavetobe
negotiatedcarefully:therewould bea riskofhaving furthersuppliesrefused.
• Loanrepayments couldberescheduled byagreement witha bank.
• Dividend payments couldbereduced. Dividendpayments arediscretionary
cashoutflows,
however cutting thedividendislikelytobeinterpreted assignofweakness bythefinancial
markets sothiscouldbeconsidered asa lastresort.
1.4 Managing cash surpluses
Ifcashsurpluses
areonlyforecastfortheshort-term
(egduetoseasonal factors)
andwillbe
required
tooffsetcashdeficits
inthenear-future,
thenitwillbeimportant
toinvest
thesecash
surpluses
ina waythatminimises risk(because
thefundswillbeneeded soon).
Desirable
investments
wouldgenerally belowriskandliquid(ieeasytoturnintocash).These
couldinclude:
Definition
G H
Treasury
bills Short-term
government
IOUs,canbesoldwhenneeded
Termdeposits Fixedperiod
deposits
Certificates
ofdeposit Issued
bybanks,
entitle
theholder
tointerest
plusprincipal,
canbe
soldwhenneeded
Commercial
paper Short-term
IOUsissued
bycompanies,
unsecured
Ifcashsurplusesareforecast
forthelong-term(egduetoseasonal
factors)
thena different
perspective
canbetaken. Long-term cashsurpluses
maybeusedtofund:
(a) Investments– newprojectsoracquisitions
(b) Financing– repaydebt,buybackshares
(c) Dividends– returning
fundstoshareholders
These areasarecoveredinlaterchapters.
Essentialreading
SeeChapter 4 Section
2 oftheEssential
reading,
available
inthedigitaledition
oftheWorkbook,
forfurther
discussion
ofthisarea.
TheEssential
readingisavailable
asanAppendix
ofthedigitaledition
oftheWorkbook.
2 Mathematical models
Anumber
ofdifferent
cashmanagement
models
indicate
theoptimum
amount
ofcashthata
company
shouldhold.
4:Cashmanagement
andworking
capital
finance 77
Page 99 of 641
q
2.1 Baumol model
TheBaumol model isbasedontheideathatdecidingonoptimum cashbalancesislikedeciding
onoptimum inventorylevels.
Itassumesthatcashissteadily
consumedovertimeanda business
holdsa stockofmarketable
securities
thatcanbesoldwhencashisneeded. TheBaumol modelis
anadaptation oftheEOQmodel tomanage cash.
Formulaprovided
Thecostofholdingcash(Ch)isthecostofobtaining
thefundsnetofanyinterest
earned
by
investing
thefunds.
Thecostofplacinganorder(Co)istheadministration
costincurred
whenselling
thesecurities.
Thedemand (D)istheannualcashrequired.
Illustration1:Baumolapproachto cash management
Finder
Cofacesa fixedcostof$400toobtain
newfunds.Itrequires
$240,000ofcasheachyear.
Theinterest
costonnewfinance is12%peryearandtheinterest
earnedonshort-term
securities
is
9%peryear.
Required
Howmuchfinance
should
Finder
raiseata time?
G
Solution H
Thecostofholdingcashis12%– 9%=3%
Thecostofplacinganorderis$400
Theannualdemand is$240,000
Applying
theEOQformula, theoptimum
levelofQ(the‘reorder
quantity’)
is:
2 × 400× 240,000= $80,000
0.03
Theoptimumamount ofnewfundstoraiseis$80,000.Thisamount
israised
threetimes
every
year(240,000÷80,000).
Activity2: Baumolmodel
Adivision
requires
$1.5m
peryear;cashuseisconstant
throughout
theyear.Transaction
costsare
$150pertransaction
anddeposit
interest
isgenerated
at7.5%andinterest
onshort-term
financial
securities
is12%.
Required
Whatistheoptimaleconomicquantity
ofcashtransfer
intothisdivision’s
sub-account
andhow
frequently?
$1,500,000oncea year
$77,500,
19times a year
$61,200,25timesa year
$100,000,15timesa year
78 Financial
Management
(FM)
balance Upper
limit
Thefirm
buyssecurities
Return
point
Thefirm
sells
securities
Lower
limit
B
0 Time
Formulaprovided
Thereturn
pointiscalculated
as:Lower
limit+ (1/3×spread)
Thisformula
isalsogiven.
Illustration2: Miller-Orr
Thefollowing
dataapplies
toa company.
(1) Theminimum
cashbalance is$8,000.
4:Cashmanagement
andworking
capital
finance 79
Solution
(1) Thespread between
theupperandlowercashbalance
limits
iscalculated
asfollows.
( )1
Spread = 3 3 × Transactioncost× Varianceofcashflows
3
4 Interest
rate
( )1
Spread = 3 3 × 50× 4,000,000
3
4 0.00025 =
3 × (6 × 10 11) 1 = 3 × 8,434.33 = $25,303 say $25,300
3
(2) Theupperlimitandreturn pointarenowcalculated.
Upperlimit= lower
limit+ $25,300=$8,000+$25,300=$33,300
Returnpoint= lowerlimit+ 1/3×spread= $8,000+1/3×$25,300
=$16,433,
say$16,400
(3) Thedecisionrulesareasfollows.
• Ifthecashbalance reaches $33,300,buy$16,900(=33,300- 16,400)
inmarketable
securities.
• Ifthecashbalance fallsto$8,000,sell$8,400ofmarketable
securities
forcash.
G H
Examfocus point
Variance=standarddeviation
2soifyouaregiventhestandarddeviation,
youwillneedto
squareittocalculate
thevariance.
Ifyouaregiventheannualinterest
rate,youwillneedtodivide
itby365toobtainthedaily
interest
rate.
2.2.1 DrawbacksoftheMiller-Orrmodel
Theusefulness
oftheMiller-Orrmodel islimited
bytheassumptions onwhichitisbased:
• Theestimatesused(forexample ofvariability)
arelikelytobebasedonhistoric information
whichmayunreliable asa predictoroffuture
variability
(forexample
iftheeconomic or
competitive
environmentchanges).
• Themodeldoesnotincorporate theimpact ofseasonality:forexample,
fora retailer,
seasonal
factors
arelikelytoaffectcashinflows.
Workingcapitalfinance:
Theapproach
takentofinancing
thelevel,andfluctuations
inthe
KEY
TERM level,
ofnetworking capital.
80 Financial
Management
(FM)
Similar
terminology
exists
whenwediscuss working
capitalfinancing
strategies.
Aggressive
financingstrategy Conservative
financingstrategy
Minimallong-term
finance
forworking Highleveloflong-term
finance
forworking
capital capital
Mainlyusescheaper short-termsourcesof Mainlyusesmoresecure long-termsources
finance
– short-termfundsareusedto offinance– long-termfundsareusedto
finance
fluctuating
currentassetsanda financepermanent currentassetsanda
proportionofpermanentcurrent assets. proportion
offluctuating current
assets.
Leadstoproblemsifshort-termfinanceisnot Thisstrategyissaferbutcanbeexpensive
available
whenrequired.Thisstrategy
is
therefore
risky
Thefollowingdiagramrelates
thesetypesofstrategytotheinvestmentinnon-current
assetsand
currentassetsofa business.
Thecurved linerepresents
thefinancerequiredatanypointintime.
Thedotted linesA,BandC aredifferentpossible
levelsoflong-term
finance,
dependingonthe
workingcapitalfinance
strategybeingfollowed.
Assets
abovetherelevant dottedlinearefinancedbyshort-term funding
whileassetsbelowthe
dottedlinearefinancedbylong-term funding.
4:Cashmanagement
andworking
capital
finance 81
Non-current
assets
0 Time
Aisa conservative
(a) Policy working capitalfinance strategy.
Allnoncurrent assetsandpermanent current assets,aswellasa significant
partofthe
fluctuatingcurrentassets,arefinanced bylong-term funding.
Attimes whenfluctuatingcurrent assetsarelowandtotalassetsfallbelow lineA,therewillbe
surpluscashwhichthecompany willbeabletoinvest inmarketable securities.
(b) PolicyBisanaggressive working capitalfinancestrategy.
Allfluctuatingcurrentassetsallfinanced outofshort-term sources,andalsosomeofthe
permanent current
assets.Minimal long-term finance isused.
(c) PolicyC isa matching (ormoderate) approach.
Abalance between riskandreturn isachieved bypolicyC, a policyofmaturitymatching in
whichlong-term fundsfinance permanent assetswhileshort-term fundsfinancenon-permanent
assets.Thismeans thatthematurity ofthefundsmatches thematurity
oftheassets.
G H
Examfocus point
Becareful
nottoconfuseworkingcapitalinvestmentandworking capitalfinancing
strategies.
Theamountofworkingcapitalthata company choosestohaveisaninvestment
decision
whereasthetypeoffinancing
itusesforitsworking capitalisa financing
decision.
Inexamquestions,
manystudentsdonotdemonstrate knowledge oftheconservative,
aggressive
andmatchingapproachestoworking capitalfinancing.
4 Treasury management
Theresponsibility
forarranging
short-andlong-term
finance
ispartoftheresponsibility
ofthe
Treasury
department.
82 Financial
Management
(FM)
Treasury
management
Funding Corporate
finance
4.1.1 Liquiditymanagement
Thisistheshort-term
management ofcashthatwehavereferredtoatthestartofthischapter.
Theaimistoensure thata companyhasaccesstothecashthatitneedsbutdoesnothold
unnecessarily
highlevels
ofcashanddoesnotincurhighcostsfromneedingtoorganise
unforeseenshort-term
borrowing.
4.1.2 Funding
Thisinvolves
deciding
onsuitable
formsoffinance
andorganising
suitable
bankandcapital
marketdebt.
Sourcesoffinancewillbecovered
inChapter9.
4.1.3 Corporatefinance
Thisistheexaminationofa company’s financial
strategies.
Forexample,
isthecapitalstructure
appropriate,
howareinvestments appraised,andhowarepotential
acquisitions
valued?
These areasareallcoveredinlaterchapters.
G H
4.1.4 Riskmanagement
Thisinvolves
understanding
andquantifying
therisksfacedbya company.
Inthisexamthemainfocusisoncurrency
riskandinterest
raterisk(covered
inChapters
14and
15).
4.2 Centralisation of treasury management
Withina centralised
treasury
department,
thetreasurydepartmentisnormally
basedatHead
Officeandactsasanin-house bankserving
theinterests
ofthegroup.
Thishasa number ofadvantagescomparedtothealternative
ofallowing
eachdivision
to
organisetheirown(decentralised)
treasury
operations:
Advantagesof centralisation
Economies
ofscale Borrowingrequired
fora number ofsubsidiaries
canbe
arranged
inbulk(meaning lower administration
costsand
possibly
a betterloanrate),alsocombined
cashsurpluses
canbeinvestedinbulk.
Improved
riskmanagement Foreign exchange riskmanagement islikelytobeimproved
because a central
treasury
department canmatchforeign
currency income earnedbyonesubsidiary withexpenditure
inthesamecurrency byanothersubsidiary.Inthisway,the
riskoflosses onadverseexchangeratemovements canbe
avoided withoutincurring
thetimeandexpense inmanaging
foreignexchange risk.
4:Cashmanagement
andworking
capital
finance 83
However,somecompanies prefer
todecentralise
treasurymanagementbecause:
(a) Sourcesoffinancecanbediversified
andcanmatchlocalassets.
(b) Greaterautonomy canbegiventosubsidiaries
anddivisions
becauseofthecloser
relationships
theywillhavewiththedecentralised
cashmanagementfunction.
(c) Adecentralised
treasuryfunction
maybemoreresponsivetotheneedsofindividual
operating
units.
G H
84 Financial
Management
(FM)
Workingcapital finance
Cashmanagement Mathematical
models
Motives
forholding
cash Baumol
Transaction,
precautionary
andspeculation • Uses
EOQmodel
motives • Assumes
constant
useofcash
which
isunlikely
Cashflowforecasting Miller-Orr
• Neat
layout • Recognises
cash
variability
• Carewith
timings
andnon-cash
items • Establishes
upper
andlower
cashlimits
Easing
cashshortages
• Practical
steps
designed
nottodamagethe
business
long-term
• Where
possible
avoiddividend
cuts
orcuts
to
important
capital
expenditure
Managing cashsurpluses
• Short-term
investments
inlowrisk,
highly
liquid
assets
• Long-term
surplus
needstobeusedtocreate
G
shareholder
value
orreturned
toshareholders H
Working
capitalfinance Treasury
management
Assettypes Functions
• Non-current
assets • Liquidity
management
• Permanent
current
assets • Funding
• Fluctuating
current
assets • Risk
management
• Corporate
finance
advice
Aggressive
financing
strategy
• Mainly
usesshort-term
finance
forcurrent Centralised
assets
andeven forsomepermanent
current • Economies
ofscale
assets • Improved
risk
management
• Cheaper
butrisky • Reduced
borrowing
• Lower
cashbalances
• Expertise
Conservative
financing
strategy
• Mainly
useslong-term
finance
fornon-current
assets,
permanent
current
assets
andalso Decentralised
somefluctuating
current
assets • Local
finance
used
• Safer,
butmoreexpensive • Autonomy
forsubsidiaries
• More
responsive
4:Cashmanagement
andworking
capital
finance 85
1.Cashflowforecasting
Thisisthekeytoolforcashmanagement.
Becareful
withcashflowtimings
andnon-cash
items.
2. Cashsurpluses
andshortages
Cashshortages
canbeeasedbypostponingcapitalexpenditure,
sellingassets,takinglonger
to
payaccounts
payableandpressingaccounts
receivable
forearlier
payment.
Temporary
cashsurpluses
canbeinvested
ina variety
oflowriskandhighlyliquidfinancial
instruments.
Longer-term
surpluses
should
bereturnedtoshareholders ifthereisa lackof
investment
opportunities.
3. Mathematical
models
Optimalcashholding
levels
canbecalculated
fromformal
models,
suchastheBaumol
model
and
theMiller-Orr
model.
4. Workingcapitalfinancestrategies
Aggressive
strategyrelies
mainly
onshort-termfinance
tofinanceworking
capital,a conservative
strategy
relies
moreonlong-term finance
tofinanceworkingcapital.
5. Treasury
management
Alargeorganisation
willhavea treasury
department tomanage liquidity,
funding,
risk
managementandcorporate financeadvice.
Thisisoftencentralised.
G H
86 Financial
Management
(FM)
Question practice
Nowtrythefollowing
fromtheFurther
question
practice
bank(available
inthedigitaledition
of
theWorkbook):
Section
A questions
Q14
Section
C questions
Q42Velm
G H
4:Cashmanagement
andworking
capital
finance 87
Activity1:Cashforecast
Cashflowforecast
Jan Feb Mar
Inflows $ $ $
Sales
– Mickster
(Cash)
(98%×$10×150; 2,695
98%×$11×250) 1,470
Salesreceipts
(W1) 25,000
20,000 30,000
Capital
– – 5,000
Totalinflows 21,470 25,000 37,695
Outflows $ $ $
Purchases
(W2) 12,600 20,000 19,000
Overheads
(2,000– 400– 1,000) 600 600 600
G Wages 1,000 1,000 1,000 H
Non-current
assets – – 29,000
Totaloutflows 14,200 21,600 49,600
Working
Jan Feb Mar
Salesreceipts
from
2 monthsago
November
credit
sales 2,000×$10=20,000
December
credit
sales 2,500×$10=25,000
Januarycredit
sales 3,000×$10=30,000
88 Financial
Management
(FM)
Activity2: Baumolmodel
Thecorrect answeris:$100,000,
15times
a year
Thecalculationisasfollows:
EOQ = 2 × 150× 1,500,000 = $100,000
0.045
ie15transfers
of$100,000
areneeded.
G H
4:Cashmanagement
andworking
capital
finance 89
G H
90 Financial
Management
(FM)