Putnam 2021 Session A Solutions

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

A1 A grasshopper starts at the origin in the coordinate plane and makes a sequence of hops.

Each
hop has length 5, and after each hop the grasshopper is at a point whose coordinates are both
integers; thus, there are 12 possible locations for the grasshopper after the first hop. What is
the smallest number of hops needed for the grasshopper to reach the point (2021, 2021)?
Answer: 578.
Solution: Each hop can be described by a displacement vector hp, qi with p2 + q 2 = 25 ; the
twelve possible vectors are

h3, 4i; h−3, 4i; h3, −4i; h−3, −4i; h4, 3i; h−4, 3i; h4, −3i; h−4, −3i; h5, 0i; h−5, 0i; h0, 5i; h0, −5i.

One way to write the total displacement as a sum of 578 of these vectors is

h2021, 2021i = 288 · h3, 4i + 288 · h4, 3i + h0, 5i + h5, 0i.

To show that it cannot be done with fewer, note that each hop can increase the sum of the
grasshopper’s coordinates by at most 3 + 4 = 7. Because this sum has to reach

2021 + 2021 = 4042 = 7 · (577) + 3 ,

at least 578 hops are needed.

1
A2 For every positive real number x, let
 r1
g(x) = lim (x + 1)r+1 − xr+1 .
r→0

g(x)
Find lim .
x→∞ x
Answer: e.
Solution: Note that for r > −1 and any positive x, we have (x + 1)r+1 − xr+1 > 0. Thus, by
the continuity of the logarithm,

 1

log g(x) = lim log ((x + 1)r+1 − xr+1 ) r
r→0
1
log (x + 1)r+1 − xr+1 .

= lim
r→0 r
Applying L’Hôpital’s rule, we get

(x + 1)r+1 log(x + 1) − xr+1 log x


log g(x) = lim
r→0 (x + 1)r+1 − xr+1
(x + 1) log(x + 1) − x log x
= log (x + 1)x+1 x−x ,

= so
(x + 1) − x
 x
1
g(x) = (x + 1)x+1 x−x = (x + 1) 1 + .
x

Finally,  x
g(x) x+1 1
lim = lim 1+ = 1 · e = e.
x→∞ x x→∞ x x

2
A3 Determine all positive integers N for which the sphere

x2 + y 2 + z 2 = N

has an inscribed regular tetrahedron whose vertices have integer coordinates.


Answer: A necessary and sufficient condition is that N be of the form N = 3m2 , where m is
a positive integer.
Solution 1: To see that the condition is sufficient, note that the four points

(−m, −m, −m), (m, m, −m), (m, −m, m), (−m, m, m)

are the vertices of a regular tetrahedron inscribed in the sphere x2 + y 2 + z 2 = 3m2 .


To show that the condition is necessary, we will use two lemmas:

Lemma 1. If T is a tetrahedron whose vertices have integer coordinates, then its volume is
of the form V (T ) = D/6 for some integer D.

Lemma 2. The √ volume of a regular tetrahedron T inscribed in a sphere of radius R is given


8 3R3
by V (T ) = .
27

Assuming that the sphere x2 + y 2 + z 2 = N has an inscribed regular tetrahedron T whose √


vertices have integer coordinates, we can combine the results of these lemmas (for R = N )
to get √
16 3 N 3/2 16N √
D = 6 V (T ) = = 3N .
9 9

Because D is an integer, it follows that 3N is a rational number. Thus the prime factorization
of N must contain an odd number of factors 3 and an even number of factors p for any other
prime p ; therefore, N = 3m2 for some positive integer m.

Proof of Lemma 1: Let P , Q, R, and S be the vertices of the tetrahedron. As these are all
lattice points, the three vectors

P~Q = hq1 , q2 , q3 i, P~R = hr1 , r2 , r3 i, P~S = hs1 , s2 , s3 i

have integer components. We can use a triple product to express the volume as
 
q1 q2 q3
1 ~ ~ ~ 1
V = |P Q · (P R × P S)| = det r1
 r2 r3  ,
6 6
s1 s2 s3

and as the determinant is an integer, we are done.


Proof of Lemma 2: If a regular tetrahedron T is inscribed in a sphere of radius R, we can
choose a coordinate system in which the vertices of T are given by

P = (−d, −d, −d), Q = (d, d, −d), R = (d, −d, d), S = (−d, d, d)

with 3d2 = R2 . We then have

P~Q = h0, 2d, 2di, P~R = h2d, 0, 2di, P~S = h2d, 2d, 0i,

3
and the volume is

 
0 2d 2d
1 ~ ~ ~ 1 8 3 8 3R3
V = |P Q · (P R × P S)| = det  2d 0 2d  = d = .
6 6 3 27
2d 2d 0

Solution 2: As in Solution 1, the condition on N is sufficient. To show that it is necessary,


note that if
vi = (xi , yi , zi ), i = 1, 2, 3, 4
are the vertices of a regular tetrahedron inscribed in the sphere x2 + y 2 + z 2 = N , we can add
the four antipodal points

wi = (−xi , −yi , −zi ), i = 1, 2, 3, 4

to get the eight vertices of a cube. (This is easily seen by choosing an alternate coordinate
system as in the proof of Lemma
√ 2 above.) Because this cube is inscribed in thep sphere, its
space diagonals have length 2 N ; therefore, each edge of the cube has length 2 N/3 and its
p 3
volume is 8 N/3 . But the volume of the cube is the determinant of three vectors with
integer coordinates, so it is an integer, and as in Solution 1 it follows that N = 3m2 for some
positive integer m.

4
A4 Let
1 + 2x2 1 + y2
ZZ  
I(R) = 4 2 2 4
− dx dy .
1 + x + 6x y + y 2 + x4 + y 4
x2 +y 2 ≤R2

Find
lim I(R) ,
R→∞

or show that this limit does not exist.



π 2 log 2
Answer: The limit exists and equals .
2
Solution: First we symmetrize the integrand. Let

1 + 2x2 1 + y2
f (x, y) = − , so that
1+ x4 2 2
+ 6x y + y 4 2 + x4 + y 4

2 + 2(x2 + y 2 ) 2 + x2 + y 2
f (x, y) + f (y, x) = − and thus
1 + x4 + 6x2 y 2 + y 4 2 + x4 + y 4

2 + 2(x2 + y 2 ) 2 + x2 + y 2
ZZ
2 I(R) = − dx dy.
1 + x4 + 6x2 y 2 + y 4 2 + x4 + y 4
x2 +y 2 ≤R2

Now consider the “first part” of this double integral, say

2 + 2(x2 + y 2 )
ZZ
J(R) = dx dy.
1 + x4 + 6x2 y 2 + y 4
x2 +y 2 ≤R2

Let u = x − y and v = x + y. Then

u2 +v 2 = (x+y)2 +(x−y)2 = 2(x2 +y 2 ), u4 +v 4 = (x+y)4 +(x−y)4 = 2x4 +2y 4 +12x2 y 2

∂(u, v) 1 −1
and = = 2 , so
∂(x, y) 1 1

2 + 2(x2 + y 2 )
ZZ
J(R) = 2 dx dy
2 + 2x4 + 12x2 y 2 + 2y 4
x2 +y 2 ≤R2

2 + u2 + v 2
ZZ
= du dv.
2 + u4 + v 4
u2 +v 2 ≤2R2

Note that if we rename the variables in this last integral x, y instead of u, v, the integrand
will be the same as the integrand of the “second part” of the double integral for 2 I(R) above.
Thus we can recombine the parts to get

2 + x2 + y 2
ZZ
2 I(R) = dx dy.
2 + x4 + y 4
R2 <x2 +y 2 ≤2R2

Converting to polar coordinates, we get



2π R 2
2 + r2
Z Z
2 I(R) = r dr dt.
t=0 r=R 2 + r4 (cos4 t + sin4 t)

5
As R → ∞, throughout the range of integration r also goes to infinity and

2r + r3 1
4 = + O(1/r3 ) ,
2+ r4 (cos4 t + sin t) r(cos t + sin4 t)
4

where the error term makes a vanishing contribution to the integral. So


"Z √ # Z
R 2 2π 
dr dt
2 I(R) ∼ 4 4 .
r=R r t=0 cos t + sin t

Now √
Z R 2
dr √ √ 1
= log(R 2) − log(R) = log( 2) = 2 log 2
r=R r
and
Z 2π Z 2π Z 2π
dt dt 2 dt
= =
t=0 cos4 t + sin4 t t=0 1 − 2 sin2 t cos2 t t=0 2 − sin2 (2t)
Z2π
2 dt
= .
t=0 2 cos (2t) + sin2 (2t)
2

π
The integrand is periodic with period and is also even, so we can proceed as follows:
2
Z 2π Z π/4 Z π/4
dt 2 dt 2 dt
= 4 = 8
t=0 cos4 t + sin4 t t=−π/4 2 cos2 (2t) + sin2 (2t) t=0 2 cos2 (2t) + sin2 (2t)
Z π/4
16 sec2 (2t) dt
=
t=0 2 + tan2 (2t)
Z ∞ Z ∞
8 dw 4 dw
= 2
= 2
w=0 2 + w w=0 1 + w /2
√ √ ∞ √
= 4 2 tan−1 (w/ 2) = 2π 2 .
w=0

So √
1 √ √ π 2 log 2
lim 2 I(R) = ( log 2)(2π 2) = π 2 log 2 , and lim I(R) = .
R→∞ 2 R→∞ 2

6
A5 Let A be the set of all integers n such that 1 ≤ n ≤ 2021 and gcd(n, 2021) = 1. For every
nonnegative integer j, let X
S(j) = nj .
n∈A

Determine all values of j such that S(j) is a multiple of 2021.

Answer: All j that are not multiples of 42 or 46.


Solution: Note that modulo 2021, the set A consists precisely of the elements of the mul-
tiplicative group. Multiplying by an element of that group permutes the elements, so if x is
relatively prime to 2021, then
X X
xj · S(j) = (xn)j ≡ mj ≡ S(j) (mod 2021).
n∈A m∈A

Therefore,
(xj − 1) S(j) ≡ 0 (mod 2021).

Also note that 2021 = 2025 − 4 = 452 − 22 = 43 · 47 gives the prime factorization of 2021. Let
x be a primitive root modulo 43 (that is, an integer between 1 and 42 that is a generator of
the cyclic group (Z/43 Z)∗ , which is the multiplicative group of the field with 43 elements).
Then xj − 1 ≡ 0 (mod 43) if and only if j is a multiple of 42 ; also, x is relatively prime to
2021. In particular, if j is not a multiple of 42 we have

(xj − 1) S(j) ≡ 0 (mod 2021) ⇒ (xj − 1) S(j) ≡ 0 (mod 43) ⇒ S(j) ≡ 0 (mod 43) .

Similarly, if y is a primitive root modulo 47 and y 6= 43, we have

(y j − 1) S(j) ≡ 0 (mod 2021) ⇒ (y j − 1) S(j) ≡ 0 (mod 47) ⇒ S(j) ≡ 0 (mod 47)

whenever j is not a multiple of 46. So if j is not a multiple of 42 or 46, then S(j) is a multiple
of both 43 and 47, hence of 2021.

Conversely, suppose that j is a multiple of 42. Then nj ≡ 1 (mod 43) for all n in the sum,
and S(j) is therefore not a multiple of 43 (or of 2021), as
X
S(j) ≡ 1 = 42 · 46 · 1 ≡ −3 ≡ 40 (mod 43).
n∈A

Similarly, if j is a multiple of 46, then S(j) ≡ 5 (mod 47).

7
A6 Let P (x) be a polynomial whose coefficients are all either 0 or 1. Suppose that P (x) can be
written as the product of two nonconstant polynomials with integer coefficients. Does it follow
that P (2) is a composite integer?
Solution: Yes, we will show that P (2) must be composite. Let P (x) = F (x)G(x) have
degree N , where F (x) and G(x) are nonconstant polynomials with integer coefficients, and
suppose that P (2) = p were prime. Then either F (2) or G(2) would be a unit, so without
loss of generality we may assume that G(2) = 1. We have N ≥ 2 because F (x) and G(x) are
nonconstant, and we can write
N
X
P (x) = σn xn ,
n=0
where each σn is either 0 or 1 and σN = 1.
Because the coefficients of P (x) are nonnegative integers, P (x) cannot have a positive real
root, so G(x) cannot have a positive real root either. Thus, as G(2) is positive, G(x) must be
positive for all x > 0. In particular, because σN = 1 is the product of the leading coefficients
of F (x) and G(x), the polynomial G(x) must be monic. Let r1 , . . . , rk be the (complex, not
necessarily distinct) roots of G(x), so that
k
Y
G(x) = (x − rj ) .
j=1

Consider the integer G(1). Because G(x) > 0 for x > 0, we have G(1) ≥ 1 = G(2). In
particular, |G(1)| ≥ |G(2)|, and using the factorization of G(x) we get
k
Y k
Y
|1 − rj | ≥ |2 − rj | .
j=1 j=1

It follows that G(x) must have at least one root ρ with |ρ − 1| ≥ |ρ − 2|, which is equivalent
to Re(ρ) ≥ 23 . This implies that |ρ| ≥ 32 ; note that ρ is also a root of P (x).
First consider the case N = 2. Dividing P (ρ) = 0 by ρ yields
σ0
ρ + σ1 + = 0.
ρ
3
We have Re(ρ) ≥ 2 > 0 and hence
   
1 ρ̄ 1
Re = Re 2
= 2 Re (ρ) > 0.
ρ |ρ| |ρ|
But then  
σ0
Re(ρ) ≤ Re ρ + σ1 + = 0,
ρ
which is a contradiction. (Alternatively, one can check the four possible polynomials P (x) of
degree 2 with coefficients from {0, 1}.)
For N > 2, we again divide P (ρ) = 0 by ρN −1 , which now yields
σN −2 σN −3 σ0
ρ + σN −1 + = − 2 − · · · − N −1 .
ρ ρ ρ

Once again, the terms on the left have nonnegative real parts. The triangle inequality gives
 
σN −2 σN −2 σN −3 σ0
Re(ρ) ≤ Re ρ + σN −1 + ≤ ρ + σN −1 + ≤ + · · · + N −1 ,
ρ ρ |ρ|2 |ρ|

8
and we can estimate the sum on the right using an infinite geometric series:
σN −3 σ0 1 1
+ · · · + N −1 ≤ 2 + · · · + N −1
|ρ|2 |ρ| |ρ| |ρ|
 
1 1 1
≤ 2 1+ + + ···
|ρ| |ρ| |ρ|2
1 1 1
= 2· = .
|ρ| 1 − 1/|ρ| |ρ|(|ρ| − 1)

1 3
But is a decreasing function of x for x > 1, and |ρ| ≥ Re(ρ) ≥ , so we get
x(x − 1) 2
3 1 1 4
≤ Re(ρ) ≤ ≤ 3 3 = ,
2 |ρ|(|ρ| − 1) 2(2 − 1) 3

a contradiction.

Remark. There are polynomials like x7 + x2 + x + 1 = (x + 1)(x2 + 1)(x4 − x3 + 1) or


x7 + x3 + x2 + x + 1 (which is irreducible) which have roots with real part greater than 1. The
polynomial x11 + x3 + x2 + x + 1 has a root r with |r − 2| < 1. Hence one needs to take some
care with this argument.

You might also like

pFad - Phonifier reborn

Pfad - The Proxy pFad of © 2024 Garber Painting. All rights reserved.

Note: This service is not intended for secure transactions such as banking, social media, email, or purchasing. Use at your own risk. We assume no liability whatsoever for broken pages.


Alternative Proxies:

Alternative Proxy

pFad Proxy

pFad v3 Proxy

pFad v4 Proxy