Managing Interest Rate Risk by Managing Duration
Managing Interest Rate Risk by Managing Duration
In a perfect world, interest rates would not fluctuate and the value of the bonds in your portfolio
would not change over time.
One of the ways we help to insulate your portfolio from negative interest rate moves and to take
advantage of those that are positive, is to carefully monitor its duration. In what follows, we will
examine the concept of duration and its applicability as an interest rate risk management tool.
There is an inverse relationship between the price of a bond and its yield. The yield on a bond is
the discount rate that makes the present value of the bond’s cash flows equal to its price. Thus,
as the bond’s price declines, its yield increases, a direct reflection of the discount between the
bond’s par value and the price investors are willing to pay for it.
In a rising interest rate environment investors demand greater yields, which can only be provided
by lowering the asking price for the bond. Conversely, in a decreasing interest rate environment,
the bond’s fixed rate of return may make it very attractive to investors, causing its price to rise (a
reflection of increased demand) and its yield to decline.
Obviously, this kind of price variability can play havoc on the value of a fixed income portfolio
at any given point in time, unless the portfolio is carefully monitored and positioned to defend
against or take advantage of changes in the interest rate environment.
Duration, which measures the price sensitivity of bonds to a variable yield environment, enables
us to do just that.
There are three primary duration calculations: Macaulay Duration, Modified Duration and
Effective Duration.
Macaulay Duration:
In 1938, Frederick Macaulay introduced the concept now known as “Duration”. Named after its
founder, Macaulay Duration is a calculation of the approximate sensitivity of a bond’s price to
changes in interest rates.
VANDERBILT AVENUE ASSET MANAGEMENT
Macaulay Duration
= Σ (Number of Years x Present Value of Cash Flows)
In general, Macaulay Duration is used to determine the point in time, measured in years, at
which half of a bond’s total cash flows will be received. However, to make it more usable as a
mathematical calculation of risk, Macaulay Duration has been modified slightly, giving rise to a
more modern interpretation known as “Modified Duration”.
Modified Duration:
Modified Duration equals Macaulay Duration divided by one plus the yield to maturity. Since
Modified Duration and Macaulay Duration essentially measure the same thing (i.e., sensitivity of
a bond’s price to changes in yields or interest rates), one measure is not strictly preferable to the
other. However, for estimating price changes, Modified Duration is easier to use, as can be seen
in the following equation.
As determined by the Modified Duration method, duration is the approximate percentage change
in a given bond’s price for each 100 basis point (bp) shift in the yield curve. For example, if a
bond’s duration is 4.0, this means a 1.0% (100 basis point) decrease in interest rates will result in
a price increase of approximately 4.0%. By the same token, a 50 basis point increase in yields
will result in a price decline of approximately 2.0%.
Effective Duration:
Modified Duration is a good way to measure bonds that have fixed cash flows and maturity
dates, but it can’t accurately measure the price/interest rate sensitivity of bonds that have
embedded options, such as mortgage backed securities and callable corporate bonds.
Mortgages backed securities are complicated by the fact that homeowners have the option of
refinancing their mortgages when interest rates drop. When this option is exercised, investors in
mortgage backed securities get their principal back much earlier than expected and are faced
with having to reinvest the proceeds in lower yielding instruments.
Similarly, with callable corporate bonds, issuers have the right to call, or redeem, the bond prior
to maturity. As with the homeowner, corporations tend to call these bonds when interest rates
fall, in order to reduce the borrowing cost of the loan. Again, the investor must reinvest in lower
yielding instruments.
VANDERBILT AVENUE ASSET MANAGEMENT
We have to quantify and adjust for redemption-related risk when analyzing the characteristics of
a bond with embedded options. Modified Duration does not take into account this risk of
optionality, if you will, because it assumes the yield to maturity is not affected by changes in
interest rates.
The only duration formula that can measure the risk of bonds that have embedded options is
called “Effective Duration,” or “Option Adjusted Duration”. Effective Duration adjusts the
riskiness of bonds by taking into account the relative sensitivity of bonds with different coupon
rates and terms to prevailing interest rates. It can gauge the likelihood of the call being
exercised, or a mortgage being refinanced, and thereby help to measure the risk represented by
these securities in various yield, or interest rate, environments. We would note that Effective
Duration should be equal to or close to Modified Duration for bulleted bonds, (i.e. those without
option risk)
Now, let’s review how these duration formulas can be applied to different types of bonds.
Example:
Here, we will calculate Macaulay Duration, Modified Duration and Effective Duration for a
bond with the following characteristics:
Discount
Years YTM = 0.071 Factor Coupon Cash Flow
Macaulay Duration
= Σ (Number of Years Χ Present Value of Cash Flows)
Price of the bond
Where Σ = Sum of
VANDERBILT AVENUE ASSET MANAGEMENT
With this bond, Macaulay Duration is equal to
= 274.92 ÷ 97.11
= 2.83 years
The Modified Duration for this bond would be calculated by using the following formula:
(1 + y)
Where y = yield to maturity or YTM
= 2.83 ÷ 1.071
= 2.64
For the sake of simplicity, we will calculate the Effective Duration for the above bond with a
few assumptions. We will calculate the Effective Duration from a hypothetical change in bond
prices, as interest rates move up or down by 2%. If interest rates move down, the issuer will
exercise the call option, which is the additional risk we will quantify. The call price is assumed
to be 100.
For a 2.0% (or .02) increase in interest rates, the percentage change, or decrease, in the bond’s
price would be as follows:
Approximate Percentage
change in price = -2.64 × (+0.02)
= -0.0528
= -5.28% decrease in price
For a 2% (or –0.02) decrease in interest rates, the percentage change, or increase, in the bond’s
price would be as follows:
Approximate Percentage
change in price = -2.64 × (-0.02)
= 0.0528
= 5.28% Increase in price
Therefore, if interest rates increase by 2.0% (or 0.02), the bond’s price would decline by
approximately 5.28%, to $91.98. Similarly, it would at first appear that when interest rates
decrease by 2.0%, the bond’s price would increase by 5.28%, to $102.24. However, that would
not be the case.
With a reduction in interest rates, the call option would kick in and the bond would most likely
be called at $100. Subsequently, as interest rates decrease, the bond would trade very close to or
equal to its call price. As such, the bond price would be close to or equal to $100 and not
$102.24.
Taking this into account, the Effective Duration of this bond in a declining rate environment
would be calculated as follows:
Effective Duration
V_ V+
=
2 x Vο x (Δy)
Where:
Effective Duration
100.00 − 91.98
=
2 × ( 97.11 ) × ( 0.02 )
= 2.06
If we used the price of $102.24, instead of $100, in calculating this bond’s Effective Duration in
a declining interest rate environment, the Effective Duration would be equal to Modified
Duration. Let’s find out why…
Effective Duration
102.24 − 91.98
=
2 × ( 97.11 ) × ( 0.02 )
= 2.64
Under this circumstance, the $2.24 premium fully compensates the investor for the option risk
and is a good representation of the cost of the option. And, as we mentioned earlier, Effective
Duration will equal or be very close to Modified Duration for bulleted bonds (i.e. those without
option risk). Now that the optionality is fully priced into the value of the bond, the Effective
Duration and Modified Duration calculations are the same.
In conclusion, duration can be interpreted as the approximate percentage change in price for each
1.0% shift in the yield curve, and as such is an important measure of a bond’s sensitivity to
changing interest rates. By actively managing this risk factor, we can control your portfolio’s
exposure to external market forces. By lengthening the duration of your portfolio, for example,
we can enhance your overall returns when interest rates fall. And, by shortening your portfolio’s
duration, we can mitigate potential underperformance when interest rates rise.
Please let us know if you have any questions concerning the duration of your portfolio, or if you
would like a more detailed examination of the concept of duration and its applicability in the
process of managing fixed income interest rate risk.