Structural Adhesives 5 Myths White Paper Final
Structural Adhesives 5 Myths White Paper Final
Figure 1. Stress distribution of rivets or spot welds (left) and structural adhesive bonds
(right). The red dotted line is the midline of the overlap joint. The blue arrows represent
how the stress is being distributed within the bondline. Stress concentrations are
created by rivets or spot welds as seen by the ascending blue arrows.
Structural adhesives are similar in strength when compared to welds, and more than twice as
strong as spot welds, bolts and rivets (Figure 2). As a result, structural adhesives are an ideal
choice for even the most demanding applications. For example, structural adhesives have
been used to bond high performance aerospace components and carbon fiber drive shafts. In
one 3M test, a structural adhesive was strong enough to hold 14,550 lbs. suspended in the air
over 18 hours (watch video) through a winter night in Minnesota.
Manufacturers often have the additional option of combining structural adhesives with
traditional joining methods. For example, in the transportation industry structural adhesives
are often combined with spot welds or rivets.
Figure 2. Overlap shear strength of different attachment methods.
Data was collected by 3M, https://multimedia.3m.com/mws/media/646994O/3ms-tough-stuff-white-paper.pdf,
https://multimedia.3m.com/mws/media/1054052O/acrylic-adhesives-recent-advancements-white-paper.pdf
Materials that cannot be effectively joined by traditional methods can be bonded with
structural adhesives. Structural adhesives have had a large role in lightweighting because they
enable the bonding of thin gauge metals and composite materials. Structural adhesive bonding
does not require drilling holes and they do not cause thermal distortions that damage thin
gauge metals. Composite materials cannot be welded or effectively drilled into but can be
joined by structural adhesives.
Structural adhesives are polymers and have different properties when compared to traditional
joining methods. For example, structural adhesives can make flexible bonds, reducing stresses
due to part movement and thermal expansion. This makes structural adhesives ideal for joining
dissimilar materials including metals, plastics, composites and wood. Structural adhesives can
also help to dissipate energy, making them ideal for vibration and impact resistance.
Evaluating your entire production process can help identify process steps where changes
could help an adhesive work and perform better. This can also lead to areas where you might
reduce time or labor, like the time spent inserting mechanical fasteners or refinishing weld
distortions. 3M adhesive specialists can help reduce scrap by testing adhesive alternatives to
your substrates and suggesting products or modifying process steps. Rework can also be
reduced by selecting adhesives with longer open times that enable repositionability.
Production cycles can be shortened, while also reducing WIP, by utilizing fast-cure or heat-
cure adhesives that reach handling strength more quickly and enable parts to be moved within
the process faster. As engineers look to automate the dispense process, our specialists can
offer ideas that could help reduce and reallocate labor by mapping out different automation
options.
Labor Challenges:
• High turnover creates demand for standard operating procedures (SOPs) and
optimizing processes for consistency
• Process training
• Worker fatigue and injuries
Labor is an important part of the production process and should also be evaluated. Replacing
mechanical fasteners with structural adhesives may help reduce worker fatigue related to
applying mechanical fasteners (screws, bolts, rivets). Reducing the number of welds in an
assembly process can help reduce not only the specialized and expensive labor of welding
itself, but also the grinding and refinishing required to make the weld aesthetically pleasing.
3M adhesive experts can help in this evaluation and recommend easy-to-use adhesives and
tapes.
Design Challenges:
• Pressure to reduce cost or weight
• Need to create more streamlined designs by removing metal attachments
• Using new difficult-to-bond materials such as LSE plastics
• Assemblies that need to reduce noise and vibration or withstand harsh conditions
• Issues with bond line read-through that occur while using your current adhesive
• Changing or challenging conditions of final end-use of the assembly
Finally, reviewing an assembly and its expected environment helps engineers evaluate the
process used to make it. Can a joint be redesigned for greater strength by changing the stress
modes, or do you need to bond new materials such as composite substrates or low surface
energy (LSE) plastics? 3M adhesive experts can help your design engineering teams evaluate
these and other possibilities, including adhesive options that don’t run or drip. There are also
available product options that help eliminate bond line read-through or reduce noise and
vibration. Challenging end-use conditions such as heat, cold, humidity or chemical
environments can also be solved with the correct adhesive selection. A review of testing
protocols and the ability to perform tests on specific substrates to determine whether a
solution may be “over-engineered” is an important step in the overall selection process. 3M
can provide on-site testing that will simulate the temperature, humidity and stress levels that a
specific assembly will experience.
3M adhesives specialists have worked with and advised customers in nearly every industry,
application and location – we can help evaluate and help you improve your unique assembly
and application.
• Watch how 3M structural adhesives helped one customer reduce labor hours by 50%*
• Watch how 3M adhesives products helped one customer see 5x* faster assembly than
competitors
• Watch how 3M structural adhesives helped one customer increase output from 35% to
98%*
* Results are specific to each unique customer process and adhesive application. Individual results may
vary.
Flexible Epoxies SL SS
RoSB PS
SL SS
MSPR ER
6 RoSB PS
MSPR ER
LSE Acrylics SL SS
SL SS Low Odor
Semi-Rigid RoSB PS
RoSB PS SL SS Acrylics
Polyurethanes MSPR ER
MSPR ER Rigid Epoxies RoSB PS
4 MSPR ER
SL SS
SL SS RoSB PS
Flexible PUR Hot Melts Instants &
RoSB PS MSPR ER
Polyurethanes Anaerobics
MSPR ER SL SS
2 RoSB PS SS
SL
MSPR ER RoSB PS
MSPR ER
0
0 2 4 6 8 10
Process Characteristics - Convenience of Use
(shelf life (SL), rate of strength build (RoSB), minimal surface prep required (MSPR))
Figure 3. A schematic of the main types of structural adhesives and how they
directionally compare to each other when considering both process characteristics and
physical characteristics. This chart can help determine which adhesive family to lead
with when the application requirements are known and prioritized. Within each sub-
category (e.g., toughened epoxy, MMA Acrylic, PUR, etc.) there are different open
times not listed here.
The 3M structural adhesives portfolio offers an extensive assortment of options that can span
low-to-high modulus, short-to-long open times, self-leveling to non-sag dispensability and
much more. Understanding the prioritized requirements of an application is an important first
step. This prioritized list should be based on the criticality of the bonded assembly coupled
with the production requirements. Systematically thinking through the entire bonding process
can help ensure the correct adhesive solution is chosen and the resultant bonding application
is a confidence-building success.
Acrylic Adhesives
Key Strengths: Robustness and fast curing
Acrylic adhesives bond exceptionally well to most plastics including low surface
energy (LSE) plastics, difficult-to-bond paints and coatings, and to metals that may be
somewhat oily. This versatility enables engineers and manufacturers more design
flexibility when it comes to assembly of parts consisting of different materials.
• Exceptional in bonding plastics, including LSE plastics
• Least sensitive to surface preparation
• Least sensitive to off-ratio mixing
• Faster cure rate than epoxy or urethane adhesives
• Toughened formulations with good impact resistance
• May contain spacer beads to maintain consistent bond line
• User-friendly, low odor options available
• Example Uses:
o Panel-to-frame – bond to a wide range of plastics and metals for
processes that don’t allow rigorous cleaning
o Enclosures – potential for process improvement due to speed of cure
with a durable bond; also bonding of parts that will go through a powder
coat process
o LSE plastics – the best chemistry to bond to LSE plastics with little to no
surface prep
• Popular products:
o 3M™ Scotch-Weld TM Low Odor Acrylic Adhesive DP8805NS – Low
odor, fast curing, strong and tough, bonds many materials
o 3M™ Scotch-Weld TM Structural Plastic Adhesive DP8010 – Excellent
bonder to many engineering plastics plus LSE plastics
o 3M™ Scotch-Weld TM Metal Bonder Acrylic Adhesive DP8407NS –
Metal bonder, resists powder coating temperatures, strong and tough
o Plus 14 other products with a range of open times to fit your applications
Urethane Adhesives
Key Strengths: Flexible and strong
Urethane chemistries are ideal for creating strong, flexible bonds between dissimilar materials.
Urethanes excel at bonding to composites, wood and concrete as well as a variety of
engineering plastics and some metals.
• Better aesthetics without a visible bond line due to low shrinkage
• Bonds provide the strength or flexibility to resist shock, vibration and impact loads
• Variety of open times available to suit process needs
• Example Uses:
o Composite panel bonding with a class A surface – no read-through of adhesive
o Glass bonding – adhesive’s low modulus allows for fluctuations in temperature
o Potting applications requiring flexible adhesive
• Popular products:
o 3M™ Scotch-Weld TM Multi-Material Composite Urethane Adhesive
DP6310NS General purpose, bonds especially well to composite materials,
good impact strength at high and low temperatures, relatively fast setting
o 3M™ Scotch-Weld TM Urethane Adhesive DP604NS – Flexible and fast
setting, best for bonding plastics
o Plus 11 other products to fit your applications
PUR Adhesives
Key Strengths: Fast holding power with flexibility
PolyUrethane Reactive (PUR) adhesives are one-part formulations that combine the initial
speed of a hot melt adhesive with the strength of a structural adhesive. They bond
exceptionally well to wood, glass, ceramics and many plastics including nylon.
• Rapidly reaches handling strength
• Eliminates clamping of parts
• One-part adhesive requires no mixing
• Variety of open times to suit process requirements
• Example Uses:
o Panel and stiffener bonding for appliances – due to fast cure and ability to gap
fill
o Woodworking – offers improvements over traditional wood glue
o Electronics – due to fast curing and viscoelasticity
o Glass and plastics bonding – flexible and elongating, fast cure
• Popular products:
o 3M™ Scotch-Weld TM PUR Adhesive TS230 – General purpose, bonds well
to plastic, wood and glass, longer open time
o 3M™ Scotch-Weld TM PUR Adhesive EZ250060 – Wood bonder, plasticizer
resistant, medium set speed
o Plus 17 other products with a range of open times to fit your applications
Instant Adhesives
Key Strength: Speed
Instant adhesives, also known as cyanoacrylates, are one-part products that attain handling
strength in a matter of seconds. They are excellent for bonding rubber, including LSE
elastomers such as EPDM and silicone. They also bond well to common engineering plastics,
LSE plastics, metals and wood. They are best suited for small parts assembly.
• One-part formulations requires no mixing
• Reaches handling strength in seconds
• Eliminates clamping of parts
• Excellent bonder of elastomers
• Can bond to LSE plastics and elastomers when used with a primer
• Clear and colorless
• Example Uses:
o Small plastic and metal parts assembly
o Rubbers and elastomers such as door seal or rubber soles for orthopedic
devices
o Decorative wood trims
• Popular products:
o 3M™ Scotch-Weld TM Plastic & Rubber Instant Adhesive PR100 – General
purpose, especially for plastics and rubbers
o Plus 25 other special purpose products with a range of viscosities to fit your
applications
Anaerobic Adhesives
Key Strength: Keep nuts and bolts from loosening
Commonly known as threadlockers, Anaerobic adhesives are one-part adhesives that cure in
the absence of oxygen; this group also includes gasket makers, pipe sealants and
hydrauylic/pleumatic sealants. They augment the strength of a threaded metallic joint,
preventing loosening due to excessive vibration. Specialized formulations can also be used as
retainer adhesives for bonding non-threaded shafts, or as a temporary gasket for flanges.
• Lock and in some cases seal
• One-part adhesive that requires no mixing
• Threadlockers are color coded to easily identify strength rating
• Resist vibration and galvanic corrosion
• Example Uses:
o Thread locking and in some cases thread sealing
o Tube-in-tube retaining compound to replace keys, splines or set screws
o Gaskets
• Popular product:
o 3M™ Scotch-Weld TM Threadlocker TL42 – medium strength thread locker
resists pressure and vibration for long term durability
o Plus 18 other specialized products with varying strengths to fit your applications
Figure 4. 3M Structural Adhesives grouped by family.
Product Selection and Use: Many factors beyond 3M’s control and uniquely within user’s knowledge and control
can affect the use and performance of a 3M product in a particular application. As a result, customer is solely
responsible for evaluating the product and determining whether it is appropriate and suitable for customer’s
application, including conducting a workplace hazard assessment and reviewing all applicable regulations and
standards (e.g., OSHA, ANSI, etc.). Failure to properly evaluate, select, and use a 3M product and appropriate
safety products, or to meet all applicable safety regulations, may result in injury, sickness, death, and/or harm to
property.
Warranty, Limited Remedy, and Disclaimer: Unless a different warranty is specifically stated on the applicable 3M
product packaging or product literature (in which case such warranty governs), 3M warrants that each 3M product
meets the applicable 3M product specification at the time 3M ships the product. 3M MAKES NO OTHER
WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ANY IMPLIED
WARRANTY OR CONDITION OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, OR ARISING
OUT OF A COURSE OF DEALING, CUSTOM, OR USAGE OF TRADE. If a 3M product does not conform to this
warranty, then the sole and exclusive remedy is, at 3M’s option, replacement of the 3M product or refund of the
purchase price.
Limitation of Liability: Except for the limited remedy stated above, and except to the extent prohibited by law, 3M
will not be liable for any loss or damage arising from or related to the 3M product, whether direct, indirect, special,
incidental, or consequential (including, but not limited to, lost profits or business opportunity), regardless of the
legal or equitable theory asserted, including, but not limited to, warranty, contract, negligence, or strict liability.