Yooonii
Yooonii
(1) Vertisols
Vertisols are heavy clayey soils enriched with montmorillonite clay minerals that
shrink when dry and swell when wet. Through alternation of dry and wet, deep and
wide vertical cracks are developed on their profiles. Pelli-Calcic Vertisols (Hidi
series) are the most predominant in the hilly area (valcano-lacustrine terrace)
extending to the northern study area. They are very deep, black and fine textured,
partly sodic (sodium-rich) phase.
(2) Andosols
(3) Fluvisols
Fluvisols are derived from alluvium on the lakeshore and along the Meki river.
Gleyic-Mollic Fluvisols (Abay series) are derived from lacustrine deposits and cover
the lakeshore of Ziway. They are deep, black, fine loamy and partly sodic. Due to
poor drainage conditions and higher groundwater table, they sometimes show gley
layers with hydromorphic properties. They are seasonally flooded for
approximately four (4) months in a year. Calcaric Fluvisols and Mollic Fluvisol are
also observed along the Meki river. They are well-drained loamy soils.
III - 1
(4) Solonetz
Solonetz is one of problem soils with high sodium content accumulated through
alternation of dry and wet conditions. They sporadically observed in the study area
particularly in the bottomlands and slight depression within the flood plains. In
both Meki and Alem Tena towns, Mollic Solonetz derived from lacustrine widely
covers the flat land. Solonetz with high clay content is very hard when dry.
Within the framework of the study on the Meki Irrigation and Rural Development
Project (the Study), the reconnaissance soil study was carried out in order to confirm
the previous soil information mentioned above and to assess their suitability for crop
production.
The Study firstly conducted the soil profile observation at three (3) representative
sites, which were selected along the transect line from upper Meki river basin to
lower basin taking the geomorphological conditions into consideration. The
location of the soil pits is indicated in Figure III.1.1. The soil profile was observed
up to 250 cm in depth. Their descriptions are presented in Figure III.1.2.
The soil samples were collected from three (3) soil layers at 20 cm, 50 cm and 150
cm in depth of each test pit. The total of nine (9) samples, i.e. 3 samples x 3
profiles, were collected and sent to the soil laboratory in Addis Ababa. The
laboratory test was carried out to verify the physical and chemical properties
including soil color, bulk density, pH (H2O), pH (KCl), electric conductivity (EC),
exchangeable cations (Na+, K+, Ca2+, Mg2+), Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC),
organic carbon, available phosphorous and total nitrogen (N). The results of
laboratory tests are presented in Table III.1.1.
The soils in the root zone are generally very compact. Their bulk density is as high
as 1.75 gm/ml, which may hinder healthy root extension. The hydraulic
conductivity is in very low ranges. Contents of organic carbon, total nitrogen and
available phosphorous are also very low.
CEC ranges from medium to very high. CEC of the Soil Profile No.1 of Vertisols is
as high as over 45 meq/100gm soil. Exchangeable cations are represented by Ca2+.
Cation saturation percentages (total ex-cations / CEC) often exceed 100%, which is
an evidence of crystalline salt accumulation in the profile.
III - 2
1.1.3 Land Suitability
Soil salinity and alkalinity are focused on as major soil hazard in the study area. In
order to grasp their occurrence and spatial distribution patterns, the field observation
was made at 275 sites with the survey density of one sample per 600 ha.
Throughout the survey, 245 soil samples were collected as listed in Table III.1.2.
Immediately after sampling, they were transported to the OIDA office at Addis
Ababa and the analyses were made for soil pH, soil EC2.5 (electric conductivity) and
soil texture. The result of soil analyses is presented in Table III.1.3.
Although soil texture changes from place to place, sand to sandy loam are dominant
in the study area.
120
100
80
Frequency (No.)
60
40
20
0
S:Sand SL:Sandy SC:Sandy L:Loam LS:Loamy SiL:Silty SiCL:Silty CL:Clay C:Clay
Loam Clay Sand Loam Clay Loam Loam
Soil pH of topsoils is in a range between 5.5 and 7.3, which are categorized into
medium acid to slightly alkaline. Only two (2) samples collected on the Ziway
lakeshore, high pH over 8.8. Soil EC2.5 are also in a wide range between 2.0µs/cm
(micro siemens) and 1,550µs/cm. The highest EC value was 5,600µs/cm on the
lakeshore of Tepo Choroke PA.
III - 3
Soil pH (1:2.5)
140
120
100
Frequency (No.)
80
60
40
20
0
5.5-5.9 6.0-6.4 6.5-6.9 7.0-7.4 7.5-7.9 8.0-8.4 8.5-8.9
pH
EC (1:2.5)
200
180
160
140
Frequency (No.)
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
0-100 101-200 201-300 301-400 401-500 501-1000 1001- 2001<
2000
EC (mS/cm)
The soils in the study area are generally suitable for crop production. It is noted that
proper soil husbandry is required to improve their crop productivity and to avoid soil
degradation process. The following soil measures are recommendable.
III - 4
residues and farmyard manure into soils.
Soils are highly susceptible to salt accumulation, which may be easily initiated when
intensive irrigation farming is practiced. Since the lake water of Ziway is slightly
saline, special attention is required when the irrigation farming is introduced to the
lakeshore. One of the advantages in the soil characteristics is their coarse to
medium texture with favorable drainage conditions for salt leaching.
Senbelet (Hyparrhenia ruffa) is a grass species particularly suitable for grazing and
preserved in the Meki area. Otherwise, palatable and digestible grass species have
been rapidly replaced with other grass species of low nutritional value in most of
rangeland.
The present land use patterns are classified broadly into four (4) categories, namely
farmland, forest/shrub/bush, grazing land and others (residence, road, water body
etc). The present land use conditions of each of Dugda Bora Wareda is presented by
PA in Table III.1.5 and summarized below.
III - 5
Summary of Present Land Use Conditions of Dugda Bora
Land Use Category Area (ha) Extent (%)
Farmland 67,828 46.2
Forest/Bush/Shrub 19,971 13.6
Grazing Land 36,326 24.7
Others /1 22,757 15.5
Total 146,882 100.0
Remark: /1 including residence, road, swamp, etc
Farmland occupies 68,000 ha of 46% of the Dugda Bora Wareda. Out of 68,000 ha
of farmland, 55,000 ha or 81% are currently cropped, while the remaining 12,000 ha
or 19% are fallow land as presented in Table III.1.6. The agricultural land use
intensity is changed as illustrated in Figure III.1.3.
The study area is characterized by rapidly growing population pressure and animal
population. As a result of uncontrolled firewood cutting and overgrazing,
vegetation coverage of the study area is generally very sparse. Consequently, soil
erosion is accelerated particularly in terrace edges and hilly slopes.
Lease agreement is mainly on annual basis and land rent varies from place to place.
The annual rental charge of rain-fed farmland ranges between Birr 100 and Birr 200
per ha, while irrigated land from Birr 300 to Birr 800 Birr per ha. Needless to say,
III - 6
such lease agreement is not forwarded through the official channels. Therefore, it is
difficult for the Dugda Bora district administration to grasp actual land tenure
situation in detail.
The majority (75%) of the local farmers are small farmers with land less than 2.0 ha.
Land holding size per farm household in the study area is presented below.
Below 1 ha 1 – 2 ha 2 – 4 ha 4 – 6 ha 6 – 8 ha 8 – 10 ha
25 % 50 % 10 % 7% 5% 3%
The Meki Nursery Center (MNC) has been established since 1989 assisted by the
NGO, Self Help Development International (SHDI), aiming at establishment of state
forest and soil conservation under jurisdiction of the District Agriculture Bureau
Office. The activities of MNC is summarized in Table III.1.7.
The area of MNC is 0.75 ha with the management office and produced annually
around 24 tree species of 800,000 seedlings in a maximum capacity under irrigation
from Meki River. The tree species produced by the MNC is based on an annual
PA’s demand compiled through the Development Agent (extension worker) stationed
to each PA. The routine nursing activity will be started from October to gather seeds
over different places via local farmers by giving an incentive to buy seeds with 15 to
20 Birr/kg, depending on tree species. The routine annual activity and tree species
nursed in the 1999-2000 season are shown in below tables. However, the project
term supported by the SHDI has been phased out since January 1999 and the World
Food Program (WFP) has taken over a position of assisting the MNC with change of
project scope of work that confines to only specified project area approved by the
WFP.
III - 7
CHAPTER II CROP PRODUCTION
The study area situates from El. 1,600 m to El. 2,000 m on the bottom of the
Ethiopian Rift Valley system. The area is classified into SA2 (semi-arid 2) zone
according to the agro-climatic zoning system of Ministry of Agriculture (1998).
The climate in the Meki town is characterized by erratic, unreliable and low rainfall
with averaging between 600 mm to 1,100 mm per annum over past 30 years. The
rainfall is bimodal with the long rain season (Meher) from July to September and the
short rain season (Belg) from February to early May.
180 22
160
21
140
Rainfall/ETO (mm
120 20
Degree C
100
19
80
60 18
40
17
20
0 16
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
The soils are also broadly grouped into two (2) zones. In the hilly land with
relatively higher rainfalls, heavy clays with vertic properties are predominant. In
contrast sandy soils cover the central flat plain of Meki area. The Ziway and Koka
III - 8
lakeshores are affected by seasonal inundation and suffer from saline soils.
Farmers have carefully selected suitable crops taking rainfall patterns and indigenous
soil conditions of their farmlands into consideration. Therefore the leading crops
show specific distribution patterns, which are highly coincident with agro-ecological
zones. The leading crop zoning map is prepared as presented in Figure III.2.1.
Crop residues provide vital supplemental fodder source left on farm after harvesting.
Farmlands after harvested are used as communal grazing purposes among the rural
community. Crop production also relies on animal husbandry. Oxen provide draft
power source for land preparation, transportation and threshing.
Off-farm activities are not common in the study area because of not much available
for the working opportunities in and out of the study area like Nazareth and Addis
Ababa.
III - 9
pepper, carrot, beet root (Beta vugaris), watermelon,
cucumber, eggplant, sugarcane, garlic, etc.
Maize is usually planted on fertile soils with priority. Wheat and teff is usually
alternative to maize. Maize is sown immediately before onset of long rainy season
in April. Other grains such as wheat, haricot beans and teff follow maize. In case
of poor crop establishment of maize under delay of rains, maize is incorporated into
soils and other crops are sown.
Teff and wheat are leading crops followed by maize and barley. Other crops such as
haricot beans, sorghum, horse bean, field peas and chickpea are planted to the
limited extent. All crops are cultivated under rain-fed conditions in a single
cropping season. Chickpea is planted in early September and harvested around the
end of December with utilization of residue moisture retained in soils.
In the central study area, most of the grains are planted from May to June and
harvesting crop is done through October to November.
The northern lakeshore of Ziway is seasonally flooded. Heavy clay soils, which are
locally called “Kotticha”, cover this area. By knowing an inundation cycle farmers
utilize receding water for second crops. Figure III.2.3 shows a double cropping
pattern in the Ziway inundation area, and single cropping of local cabbage and
chickpea in the Cheleleka inundation area.
In the Ziway lakeshore area, seasonal flood cycle depends on rainfalls and yearly
III - 10
changed. Therefore, farmers sow maize in early April and harvest green maize at
the end of June when they prospect floods in early July. If not, grain maize is
harvested in August. Either chickpea or haricot beans are then sown in the middle
of October by using soil residue moisture.
On the other hand, dry season cropping is also observed on seasonally flooded flat
land surrounding the Cheleleka lake. The major crops include Ethiopian cabbage
and chickpea by utilizing soil residue moisture after flood water ebbs away and land
becomes a workable condition from mid-August.
25,000
20,000
15,000
Planted Area (ha)
10,000
5,000
0
94/95 95/96 96/97 97/98 98/99 99/00*
Year
Teff Wheat Maize Haricot Bean
III - 11
3.50
3.00
2.50
Unit Yield (ton/ha)
2.00
1.50
1.00
0.50
0.00
94/95 95/96 96/97 97/98 98/99 99/00*
As discussed in Section 1.2.2 on Present Land Use, 67,800 ha or 46% of the district
area of Dugda Bora are categorized into farmland, of which 54,900 ha or 81% were
cropped with diversity of rain-fed crops in the crop year 2000/01. Planted area,
yield and production of the 2000/01 crops in the study area are presented for each PA
in Tables III.2.2 to III.2.11. They are summarized below.
It is noted that only four (4) major crops consisting of teff, maize, wheat and haricot
beans cover 91% of the total planted area in 2000/01.
In addition, horticulture crops were also planted only 1,804 ha as presented in Table
III.2.12. Horticultural crops are represented by tomatoes with 581 ha or 32% of the
1,804 ha. Hot pepper and onion are also prevailing. These three crops cover over
III - 12
70% of the total planted area of horticulture crops. Vegetables and papaya are
generally produced under irrigated conditions along to the Meki river as well as
lakeshores. The location of horticultural production areas is indicated in Figure
III.2.4. The present crop intensity (CI) of the study area results in around of 83 %
but the irrigable land is mostly cultivated with two crops per year and beyond 100 %.
III - 13
CHAPTER III FARM INPUTS AND PRACTICES
3.1.1 General
In the study area, there are several sources and channels for procurement of farm
inputs. They are (i) Extension Package Program (EPP), (ii) input supply shop by
NGOs, (iii) middlemen’s shop, (iv) cooperatives and (v) retailers in large urban
centers.
III - 14
3.1.3 Other Sources
(1) Input supply shop by cooperative union supported by NGO
The cooperative shop deals with only vegetable seeds (tomato, onion, cabbage, chili
pepper, potato and garlic). Cereal seeds are not available. It sells chemical
fertilizer (DAP, Urea), some agro-chemicals (herbicide and 3 types of pesticide) and
farming implement (portable sprayer). Further, imported vegetable seeds by this
shop vary the quality, i.e.germination rate, according to the interview to the shop
manager.
A part from this shop, Adami Tulu chemical Co., Ltd adjacent to Dguda Bora
District supplies most of agro-chemicals except for the Kocide and Menkozep
chemicals which are quite high demand for tomato cultivation.
This access is not stable to get proper items on time and a quality of some items such
as agro-chemicals are not reliable. Most of farmers procure grain seeds through this
channel.
(3) Cooperatives
This channel is confined to the cooperative member only and cooperative purchases
agro-inputs in collective way for the members.
Most of state farm and private farmer who are strong financial status purchase
agro-inputs directly from Addis Ababa by themselves.
3.2.1 General
The farming practice of major food grain and leguminous crops among the subsistent
landholder prevailing in the study area is summarized in Table III.3.1. The farming
practices prevailing in the study area are highly relied on animal draught power from
land preparation to harvesting, namely plowing, inter-tillage locally called
“Shilshalo”, transportation of farm produce and threshing.
III - 15
2-3 times for maize, barley and wheat, and 1-2 times for the rests including sorghum
and pulses. Although the area is limited, private tractor hire service is also available
in the study area. The service charge is Birr 260 per ha in 1999/2000.
3.2.3 Sowing
Sowing is manually done. Seed rates are generally higher than recommended
seed rate to make up lower germination percentage and seedling damages by
drought. The standard seed rates of major crops are presented below.
Standard Seed Rate
Urea (46-0-0) and DAP (18-46-0) are common in Ethiopia. Most of subsistent
small farmers do not use chemical fertilizers for sorghum and leguminous crops but
cow dung. Chemical fertilizers are applied to cash crops including wheat and teff.
The standard application rates under EPP are presented below.
Moisture stressed area is not recommended to practice split application in order to avoid leaf
burn caused by fertilizer-itself and waste use of fertilizer generated by moisture stress under
erratic rain.
III - 16
Herbicide such as 2,4 D and U-46 are sprayed for cash crops including teff and
wheat at a rate of one liter per ha after emergence. Weeding is done by hand for
maize and sorghum at knee-high stage and inter-tilling by ox-plow (Maresha) in
order to thin plant population and control weeds. Weeding is not done for pulse
crops after sowing till harvesting.
3.2.7 Harvesting
Except for maize and sorghum, most of cereal crops are cut as whole plant and
bundled and sun dried either in the harvested field or surroundings of homestead,
and followed by threshing operation which is down by driving oxen trampling on the
spread grain bundles and cleaned by hand winnowing in the same place.
Meanwhile, leguminous crop are pulled out by hand and stacked in the filed until
dried or brought to the threshing ground and stacked there for drying. Threshing is
done by oxen, followed by hand winnowing same as grain crops. Maize is harvested
by hand and brought to homestead by donkey cart for shelling by beating cob with
stick or near motor- driven corn sheller place.
3.2.8 Storing
Majority of farmers has equipped with traditional storage bin called “Gotera”, made
of woven wood and bamboo splits in homestead and with 15 to 20 quintals capacity.
Harvested grains are stored in this Gotera or sacs either in-house or open place.
However, cash crops like teff, wheat, haricot beans and surplus of farm produce
except for self-consumption are immediately sold to middle men followed by
processing grains due to very limited
margin for money among the subsistent landholders. Cereal grains are milled at the
nearest flour mill and used as food diet of Injera, locally brewed beer such as Tella,
and sprit like “Arake”. Pulse grains are also used as ingredient of Injera, soup or
roasting.
III - 17
3.2.9 Utilization of crop residue and cow dang
Field crop residue after crop harvest is utilized as open grazing land. Maize and
sorghum stalk are used as fuel source or construction materials for hut after feeding
tender part to animals. Straws of teff, wheat, and barley are also used as important
supplemental feeding materials followed by threshing process and leguminous crops
as well.
Thus, incorporating the crop residue into the soil is quite limited extent. Cow dung
in the study area is used for plastering materials of traditional storage bin, hive, and
circular plot of threshing place, and fuel source after drying, however most of
interviewed farmer reported about 90 % of cow dung is returned to field.
On the basis of the above conditions, the farm labor balance study was made as
presented in Table III.3.2. Labor shortage appears twice a year in May to June and
October. The former is caused by intensive farm works from land preparation to
sowing for wheat, teff and haricot bean, and harvesting of four (4) crops, the later is
during harvesting of those crops. However, labor shortage is mitigated through a
traditional labor exchange custom, so called ”Debo”. It is a sort of reciprocal help
system with provision of a tiny compensation with beverage and food provided by
host farmer. “Debo” is not common among irrigation farmers. Large farmers with
nearly 10 ha of farmland usually employ a few permanent workers by boarding them
as part of family member.
III - 18
CHAPTER IV CROP BUDGET
4.1 Introduction
The major grain and horticulture crops prevailing in the Study Area were analyzed in
terms of crop budget by dividing them into 3 farming technology levels, i.e. 1)
traditional farming level under rain-fed condition, 2) improved packaged technology
level (EPP), and 3) irrigation farming on horticulture crops. The detail result of crop
budget analyses is shown in Table IV.4.1.
4.1.1 Market Price of Major Grain Crops
Below Table shows minimum and maximum producer-based marketing price of the
major grain crops over the past 5 years from 1995 to 2000 in Meki area. Generally,
sale price in the open market shows a tendency of augmentation except for the '95 to
'97 years. The monthly price curve shows a upward flow toward the off-season,
while drops just after harvesting crops. Farm gate price fluctuation of the major
horticulture crops is mentioned in Chap V.
Marketing Price of Major Food Grains in the Meki Area
Haricot bean Maiz Wheat Teff
Year Mean Min Max Mean Min Max Mean Min Max Mean Min Max
99-00 183 174 190 132 103 153 173 137 202 233 204 295
98-99 162 162 162 100 74 150 159 128 200 221 176 275
97-98 146 140 150 93 81 110 159 150 170 212 196 240
96-97 110 83 147 63 46 89 101 77 141 186 150 231
95-96 157 150 161 82 70 120 117 101 150 210 194 238
Souce: Ethiopia Grain Trade Enterprise(EGTE) Unit: Birr/qt
III – 19
In this table, the unit sale price is applied to a mean value of the 1999-2000 year, and
resulted in 1.34 - 1.63 B/C ratio among the crops. However, the net revenue might be
varied toward more profit if farm operation including labor is managed through a
traditional labor exchange custom called "Debo" mentioned in Chap., III.
III – 20
Summary Table for the Irrigated Horticulture Crops
Crop Unit Papaya* Tomato Onion Cabbage Chili
Unit of Area Ha 1 1 1 1 1
Expected yield qt 500 100 170 120 62
Marketable rate (%) 70 80 90 90 80
Unit sale price Birr/qt 15 45 31 30 65
Gross revenue Birr 5,250 3,600 4,743 3,240 3,224
Hired Oxen plowing Birr 0 0 0 0 0
Hired tractor Birr 0 0 0 0 0
Seed Bir 0 113 400 154 18
Fertilizer Birr 0 455 455 0 0
Agro-chemicals Birr 0 626 1,280 930 965
Labor Birr 0 165 602 189 160
Fuel Birr 1,314 500 500 500 500
Lubrication Birr 83 79 99 28 55
Depreciation cost(pump: 8 years) Birr 875 438 438 438 438
Depreciation cost(Hand sprayer: 6 years) Birr 0 43 43 43 43
Depreciation cost (poles: 6 cropping) Birr 0 250 0 0 0
Production cost 2,272 2,669 3,816 2,282 2,179
Net revenue Birr 2,978 931 927 959 1,045
B/C ratio 2.3 1.3 1.2 1.4 1.5
Source: JICA Study T eam Unit: Birr/ha
Note: Expected yield of papaya is estimated based on a mean yield over 5 economic
production year and marketable rate of 70 % to the produce..
III – 21
CHAPTER V POST HARVEST AND MARKETING
No agro-industries exist in or around the study area except for small-scale flour mills
operated by private individuals registered by the District Financial Office as below .
Some non-registered flour mills also operated in the study area. Apart from flour mill,
there are two large agro-storages operated by the Ethiopia Grain Trade Enterprise
(ETGE) and the District Agriculture Bureau Office with capacity of 5000 and 500
tons, respectively. The former was temporarily rented to the Disaster Prevention
Preparedness Bureau (DPPB) for food relief but restored to EGTE now. In
household level, most of farm household has few traditional storage bins (capacity:
10-15 qts locally called Gotera) in their homestead to keep farm produce such as
food grains.
There are four primary markets in the study area. The primary markets are held in
town level and first two are held on every Monday and Thursday in Meki town, and
2nd two are daily held in Meki and Alan Tena towns with small scale. The Monday
market and daily markets are dealt with farm produce and some daily commodities
mainly for local consumers, while the Thursday Market is extensively operated for
trading livestock, all kind of food grains, vegetables, daily commodities with outside
collector as well as local consumers. And the registered middlemen trading in the
Thursday Market is charged 6 Birr/month by the Meki Municipal Office. In this
III - 22
Thursday market, most of the farmers in the study area will come out to the market
with their farm produce such as grains, livestock, firewood, folk craft and etc, and
trade with necessary daily goods.
The schematic food grain channel in the study area is shown in Figure III.5.1.
There are four food grain channels from the producers to consumers in the study area.
About 70 % of marketing grains are traded through the registered middlemen
channel, followed by 20 % of retailers and 10 % of direct trade with individual
consumers, respectively. Ethiopian Grain Trade Enterprise (EGTE), a
profit-oriented state enterprise playing a role to export surplus grain and to control
floor market price of the food grain has irregularly participated to purchase food
grains, especially haricot bean from Meki Area. However, food grain such as teff,
wheat, maize including haricot bean has almost not been merchandised during the
past 5 – 6 years because of no surplus grains available in the market due to drought
prone area.
The quantities of major grains annually traded in the study area can be estimated
only based on taxation system controlled by the Meki Municipal Office that tax the
registered middlemen based on their capitals scale. Farm produce such as vegetables
and fruit is directly traded with local consumer as well as middlemen from outside,
thus no official census is available.
5.3 Prices
1) Middlemen
Below table shows the prevailing market price of farm produce in the study area.
Buying price by middlemen is seasonally changed but not much difference among
the buyer (middlemen) because of a tacit agreement among the middlemen made.
The commission charge per quintal of grain usually ranges 10 to 20 Birr. But this
farm gate price jumps to 125 % -130 % in the Addis Ababa Market, thus it reveals
III - 23
that middlemen channels squeeze unreasonable profit from the producer.
Buying Price of Major Crop purchased by Middlemen in Meki area
Below table shows the Thursday market price on farm produce as of October 2000.
Price of farm produce in the Thursday Market Price
Unit : Birr
No Crop Buying price Selling price to Other
middlemen
1 Haricot bean (white & red) 165/qt 175
2 Maize 70/qt 80
3 Wheat 140/qt 150
4 Dry hot chili 8 -10 /kg
5 Ethiopian cabbage 0.5 /bunch
6 Green chili pepper 0.25/heap
7 Sugarcane 0.50/stem
8 Orange 2.0/kg
9 Pumpkin 2.0/pc (big size)
0.75/pc (medium)
10. Tomato 1.5 /kg
11 Beet root 1.0/kg
12 Fresh Ginger 10/heap (4 ~ 5 kg)
13 Potato 1.0 /kg
14 Carrot 2.0 / kg
15 Red onion 2.5/kg
16 Garlic 2.0 /kg
III - 24
by EGTE seasonally varied and grain quality is subject to the normal stipulated by
the Ethiopian Standard Authority but EGTE at least supports a minimum marketing
price. Table III.5.1 shows the monthly marketing price of food grains among the
producer, wholesaler and retailer over the past 5 years from 1995 to 2000 in Meki
area. The commission from producer to retailer ranges from 8 to 16 Birr/qt
depending on kind of grain crop. The price fluctuation over monthly and yearly
movement tends to show a very arbitrary change, but general trend of market price
indicate a higher price during the off-season of crop harvest and lower price during
November to March of harvesting season.
Price fluctuation on the major horticultural crops in Meki area is shown below table
with some case study of farm gate price curve for onion and tomato along to the
Meki River bank. The seasonal and annual fluctuation of farm gate price show
arbitrarily movement without regular tendency under free market condition. But,
farm gate price generally appears to indicate higher price in the rainy season and
lower price during the dry season. Also, the result of interviewed survey on farm
gate price among the farmers varies from place to place. For instance, the onion and
tomato 2000 year price curve (Below Figure) were made by the newly formed WUA
member at PRA meeting, while the 2001 price curve and figures in below table were
compiled based on the horticulture crop farmer's interview survey in the surrounding
area. Namely, the highest price of onion is differed among the informants.
M onthly O nion Farm gate Price in Som bo M onthly Tom ato Farm gate Price in ShubiG am e
5.0 2000 year 2.0
4.5 1.8
4.0 1.6 2001 year
2001 year 2000 year
3.5 1.4
3.0 1.2
2.5 1.0
2.0 0.8
1.5 0.6
1.0 Nursery Transplanting Harvesting 0.4 Transplanting
0.5 0.2
Nursery
0.0 Harvesting
Birr/kg 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Birr/kg 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
M onth M onth
III - 25
CHAPTER VI CONSTRAINTS AND PROSPECTS
6.1 Constraints
Erratic rainfall pattern is the most crucial constraints, particularly recurrent dry spell
during the reproductive stage of grain crop causes severe bad crops. In the western
to northern lakeshore of Ziway is chronic drought prone area and has resulted in
continuous bad crop since 5 - 6 years ago.
III - 26
farmers. Through the interview survey, some farmer reported to fear getting credits
because of unable to refund under recurrent drought.
Apart from herbicide for grain crop production, most of agro-chemicals are
consumed by horticultural crop growers including private farmers. Availability of
agro-chemicals is also limited to cooperative union shops, EPP, middlemen or
retailers in Addis Ababa. Improved seeds, mostly cereal crops are only available via
EPP or on-farm research purpose and local market by middlemen handles only local
varieties. Even though EPP suffer from shortage of improved seeds such as teff and
haricot beans.
Land tenant usufructuary right is given equally to every farming family without
distinction of sex, up to 10 ha in max per family. However, there are many lease
agreements of farmland among the subsistent landholders in the study area due to
insufficient of the farmland based on economic size per family. One farmer
reported that he has no land after his father passed away because his mother
inherited land use right, thus he has farmed by renting farmland but unable to be a
member of the PA and legally no access to EPA.
About 70 % of cereal grains are traded through the middlemen channels at farm gate
level, and vegetables and fruits are as well. Most of producers are individual basis
to trade with middlemen who make tacit agreement of purchase price from producer
before hand, while the producer has no financial margin to build up bargaining
power, thus the producer is forced to sell farm produce by asking price
III - 27
(8) Insufficient extension service to the farmers
The farmer’s interview survey by the JICA Study Team verified that beneficiaries
accessed by DAs are varied from place to place ranging from one to four times per
month or 5 times per year. Most of interviewees want more frequent access by DAs
to meet for their technical information demand. Also, the insufficient of practical
information of plant protection is reported by horticulture growers.
2) Research-Extension-Farmer’s Linkage
In the study area, most of on-farm based demonstration plot occasionally carried out
by the research sector for extension purpose is confined to a popularization of new
variety on haricot bean and maize coupled with extension package program so far.
Thus, the farming practices to conserve soil moisture and sustain soil fertility to
improve land productivity are not demonstrated even though the research sector has
already verified certain useful technology for improving rain-fed farming in the East
Showa.
6.2 Opportunities
(1) Erratic rain
(2) Soil characteristic of low water holding capacity and low fertility
III - 28
Traditionally, indigenous way to alleviate poor crop growth caused by salt
accumulation is empirically verified by applying cow dang into the affected soil
among the subsistent farmers, and should be massively practiced where faces salinity
problem.
The cooperative union comprising of WUAs has already launched an union shop to
deal with farming inputs under support by NGO, thus it is possible to apply this
way to the existing Cooperative Association which has already operated some credit
sale for fertilizer.
Animal keeping plays a role to insure against emergency case to cope with drought
problem. However, it is inferred that vicious circle of overgrazing and
over-cultivation coupled to drought coping strategy can be alleviated with proper
livestock density via dialog with inhabitants if crop production is improved by
applying several countermeasure on rain fed farming.
Present marketing system which middlemen purchase farm produce directly from the
producer should be shifted to a marketing system from the producer to consumer
channel by minimizing middlemen channels. This advanced marketing system has
already launched by the cooperative union in the study area, thus it is highly possible
to apply it to the existing-cooperative association, and the margin profit squeezed by
middlemen can be returned to the producer.
III - 29
The agriculture research stations in the East Shewa have already verified some
useful technologies in terms of soil water conservation and keep soil fertility under
rain-fed condition but not been disseminated in on-farm level yet. Thus it is
essential to extend their useful expertise by verifying in accordance with
agro-ecological system in the study area
One of indigenous strategies to cope with drought problem is to adjust a sowing time
of cereal crops along to rainfall pattern. Maize is generally sown from late April to
early May in the central Meki area but immediately shift to barely, wheat or haricot
bean if poor rain is anticipated during this short rain period (Belg). But if the rain in
the Belg season is good and dry spell occurs later in the Meher season (long rainy
season), severe moisture stress causes a mass mortality and no option to avoid
drought at the silking/tasseling growth stage. This supported that the poor rain
drastically increased an acreage of haricot bean up to 14,730 ha in the 1999-2000
season, but decreased to 6,350 ha in this good rain year (2000-2001 season).
Most of interviewed farmers by the JICA Study Team employ a higher seed rate as
shown below:
III - 30
Recommended and Farmers’ Seed Rates
From this table, higher seed rate to the recommended rate ranges from 133 % to
500%, varying from crop to crop. One interviewed farmer reported that the reason of
applying this high seed rate is accounted for their drought coping strategy to ensure a
number of good stand and secure the biomass of plant for feeding live stock if dry
spell occur later and forced to shift to other grain crop.
In the sloped field where is cultivated with teff, wheat, and barley even in flat field,
regular ditches with 2 – 3 m interval along to control line is observed. The ditch play
a role to cut drain and infiltrate rainwater into the soil in stead of run-off and protect
soil erosion as well. In the flat field, it serves as drainage to avoid suffocation of
emerged seed due to stagnant water in the field.
In the surrounding of the Ziway lake area, soil salinity problem suppressing crop
growth is observed in the farmlands. Farmer cope with this problem by applying cow
dung manure, which appears to have some effect to alleviate soil salinity and results
in some harvest according to the interviewed farmer.
Apart from the improved seeds on food grains, there are few indigenous varieties of
major food grain crops like maize, wheat, teff and haricot bean, which have been
traditionally multiplied and kept by farmers themselves. Characteristics of these
cultivars are summarized as below:
III - 31
Indigenous Varieties of Major Crops
Crop Local Varietal Potential Yield Growth
Name Characteristics (kg/ha) Period (day)
Maize Milisha Mixed variety of white & brown 4,000 90
grains
Wheat Lakech Formally released as improved 2,400 120
seeds but no more distribution
Teff White 1,600 105
Brown 2,000 105
Mixed 2,000 105
Haricot B. Round & Fat 2,000 105
The lift valley area is often hit by drought and exposed to progressive soil erosion
over hilly area and sloping land generated by deforestation, over-grazing and
over-cultivation under increase of pressure to land due to growing of human and
livestock population. Under recurrent drought, keeping livestock plays a role of
security at emergency case and accelerates land-degradation coupled with growing
rural population, which pressurizes progressively land use.
Development of this area is only possible when the mixed farming system engaged
by the subsistent landholder, who is accounted for majority of inhabitants in the
study area is managed in a sustainable way under fragile agro-ecosystem of the rift
valley.
The study area where is classified as semi arid area with annual rainfall of 700 – 800
mm and is often hit by recurrent drought at reproductive stage of grain crop under
rain-fed condition. Seeking for sustainable farming is most prioritized by
alleviating drought damage on crop growth caused by erratic rainfall pattern, and by
stabilizing and improving crop production, with prevention of on-going
desertification under the fragile natural ecosystem. The program is based on the
following concept and direction.
III - 32
(2) Basic Concept
iii. Most vital issue in the rain-fed farming area is how to alleviate water stress
on grain crop growth at emergence and flowering stage during the recurrent
dry spell, thus some of useful technologies which have already been verified
by the local agriculture research station under the similar agro-climatic
condition in the study area should be verified in on-farm level.
iv. Kind of crop and cropping period in the present rain-fed farming system is
basically continued and is focused on improvement of land productivity.
The cultivated crops currently are followed as status quo and are focused on
improving agricultural productivity based on the three components illustrated below
III - 33
conceptual figure.
There are two vital factors to be considered for improving rain-fed farming. The
first is how to conserve soil moisture and the second, how to keep soil fertility.
Approach to improved rain-fed farming is essential for an integration of three
components comprising of a) utilization of indigenous drought coping practice, b)
utilization of locally available resources and c) utilization of useful technology
verified by the local agriculture research station.
Further the integrated approach should be examined in its effect through the
agriculture verification study scheme in collaboration with local agriculture research
station based on agro-ecological on-farm trial base. The trial subject to be verified in
the study area should consider the followings:
g. Watershed management
III - 34
APPENDIX III
AGRICULTURE
Tables
Table III.1.1 The Result of Soil Physio-chemical Analyses in the Study Area
No. Soil Physical and Chemical Properties Gusa Elementary School (About 11 Km. far from
Ela - Gebre Dalacha (23 Km far from Meki town) Bekele Girsa Area(1 Km. far from Meki town)
T.P1)
Soil Depth (cm)
20 50 150 20 50 150 20 50 150
Light brown silty Light gray clayey, Light brown silty Whitish gray silty
White sandy
Black silty clay Black silty clay Brown sand sandy sand Light brown sand
1 Visial Description gravel with
with few sand with few sand silty clay with clay and few silt with few with few gravel sandy silt with few gravel
silt and few clay
gravel gravel and clay and clay
2 Bulk Density (gm/cm3) 1.95 1.69 1.78 1.76 2.05 1.67 1.76 1.58 1.76
3 Gravel (%) 0.4 0.4 0.5 7.2 5.4 39.2 8.8 0 7.8
4 Particle size distributionSand (%) 9.8 7.2 7.8 44.9 30.4 58.6 56.4 63.7 54.3
Silt (%) 38.1 30.8 28.1 36.4 33.2 31.7 34.2 20.9 37.2
Clay (%) 52.1 61.9 64.0 18.6 36.4 9.7 9.4 15.4 8.5
5 pH(H2O) 6.2 6.4 6.5 5.2 6.4 7.2 6.6 7.2 8
6 pH(KCl) 5.0 4.5 4.3 4.8 4.6 6.8 6.0 6.4 7.2
7 Electrical Conductivity (EC), mmho/cm 0.28 0.15 0.11 0.03 0.09 0.12 0.06 0.07 0.49
8 Cation Exchange Capacity(CEC) (meq/100gm soil) 45.51 55.15 45.63 16.92 26.33 35.1 25.87 16.95 34.93
Very High Very High Very High Medium High High Medium Medium High
9 Exchangable Sodium (meq/100gm soil) 1.76 2.71 2.7 1.69 1.69 2.61 2.59 2.59 7.97
10 Exchangable Potassium (meq/100gm soil) 0.96 1.08 1.35 0.71 0.78 1.78 1.92 1.87 4.5
11 Exchangable Calcium (meq/100gm soil) 32.95 39.28 33.48 7.07 19.92 39.08 14.58 14.16 40.98
12 Exchangable Magnesium(meq/100gm soil) 9.54 10.48 10.87 4.16 5.51 5.04 3.75 3.34 7.53
Total Exchangeable Cations (meq/100gm soil) 45.21 53.55 48.4 13.63 27.9 48.51 22.84 21.96 60.98
Saturation Percentages (%, Total Ex-Cations / CEC) 99.3 97.1 106.1 80.6 106.0 138.2 88.3 129.6 174.6
13 Organic Carbon (%) 1.12 1.2 0.25 0.93 0.45 0.28 1.00 0.77 0.37
Organic Matter Content (%) (= Org.C % x 1.724) 1.93 2.07 0.43 1.60 0.78 0.48 1.72 1.33 0.64
Low Low Very Low Low Very Low Very Low Low Low Very Low
14 Available Phosphorous(mg/Kg P2O5) 4.778 4.81 3.74 2.011 1.025 2.485 3.023 3.023 3.597
Low Low Low Low Low Low Low Low Low
15 Total Nitrogen(%) 0.087 0.064 0.032 0.084 0.039 0.035 0.063 0.098 0.049
Low Low Very Low Low Very Low Very Low Low Low Very Low
Remarks : 1) Measurement of pH(H20) and EC are made using suspension as soil and water ratio of 1:2.5 and pH (KCl) using suspension as soil and 1M-Kcl ratio of 1:2.5.
2) Soil Organic Matter content (%) is calculated by multiplying conversion factor of 1.724 to orgarnic carbon (%).
Table III.1.2 Soil Samples Collected by PA
No of
No. Peasant Association Soil Sample Number per Peasant Association
Samples
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
1. Kersa Gambala 0
2. Abene Kumuro 0
3. Adie Mirt 246 247 2
4. Biliti Balewoid 218 220 223 224 238 5
5. Koto Biliti 222 221 240 239 241 242 243 244 245 248 249 11
6. Argo Gadilala 271 233 232 270 273 5
7. Tuchi Denbel 228 229 230 231 4
8. Weyo Gebriel 227 225 28 29 4
9. Aboro Gebriel 268 27 2
10. Dodoti Dembel 26 31 30 236 235 234 226 215 8
11. Mukiye 1 216 209 208 212 210 205 204 41 40 39 38 11
12. Birbirsa Guda Sabole 60 62 67 70 4
13. Birbirsa Gale 0
14. Eela Gebre Daiech 65 64 63 66 4
15. Menjegso Weji 0
16. Joro Reka 71 1
17. Korke Adama 68 69 74 75 4
18. Goro Korke 72 73 79 3
19. Kiltu Ombole 78 80 102 203 4
20. Doyo Laman 138 140 201 200 199 198 6
21. Tute Koremtu 137 202 139 3
22. Koye Jejeba 108 110 112 76 111 77 135 136 8
23. Hafe Kemale 101 107 113 115 109 5
24. Weldia Hafa 121 114 123 128 130 5
25. Beyimogusa 55 103 57 104 105 106 6
26. Dongorota 59 56 58 61 4
27. Mukiya 2 42 44 46 43 45 5
28. Hate Leman 206 37 47 48 4
29. Tepho Choroke 25 207 155 32 4
30. Giraba Korke Adi 33 34 35 36 49 50 6
31. Bekele Girisa 264 24 23 259 260 5
32. Weldiyo Mekidela 265 266 2
33. Weldiyo Kelina 261 262 263 86 267 5
34. Saubi Gamo 82 83 84 2 4
35. Tuchi Sumeyo 3 156 157 158 161 5
36. Jawe Bofa 20 21 118 3
37. Oda Bokota 1 51 52 116 117 5
38. Sera Wekele 53 54 119 120 122 5
39. Derara Daiecha 5 7 4 85 88 159 274 275 8
40. Burka Debrebeg 87 89 90 6 98 5
41. Jirme Bora 8 9 10 11 160 162 6
42. Berta Sami 16 17 18 19 124 125 126 154 8
43. Sori Dolesa 127 129 131 132 134 5
44. Tuka Largamo 15 151 152 153 4
45. Gose Korke 133 141 142 143 144 145 6
46. Tuchi Deko 146 147 148 149 189 5
47. Elen 186 187 188 3
48. Kushe Huluko 194 195 196 197 4
49. Lafesa Germeji 190 191 192 193 4
50. Gora Leman 0
51. Dodo Wedera 179 181 182 183 184 185 6
52. Malema Jere Bera 176 177 178 180 4
53. Tube Suti 171 173 174 175 4
54. Dalota Mati 12 13 14 150 163 164 167 169 170 9
Meki City 22 81 2
Source : JICA Study Team/December, 2000. 245